Minutes
City of Sumter · Sumter County · meeting of Jan 28, 2021 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Sumter
This document is no longer listed on City of Sumter's website. We kept the copy we read.
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
HISTORIC PRESERVATION
DESIGN REVIEW
Minutes of the Meeting
January 28, 2021
ATTENDANCE
A regular meeting of the Historic Preservation Design
Review Committee was held on Thursday, January 28 ,
2021, in the Sumter Opera House Theater located on the
First Floor of the Sum ter Opera House. Five board
members –Ms. Julie Her long; M s. Heidi Burkett ; Mr.
Jerome Robinson; Mr. Bill Buxton ; and Ms. Lucy Wilson
were present and two board member s – Ms. Jean
Whitaker and Ms. Vivian Sharp were absent.
Staff members present were Mr. Kyle Kell y, Mr. Jeff
Derwort; Mr. Preston McClun; and Ms. Kellie Chapman.
The meeting was called to order at 4:30 p.m. by Ms. Julie
Herlong.
MINUTES
Mr. Bill Buxton made a motion to approve the minutes of
the November 19 , 20 20 meeting as written. The m otion
was seconded by Ms. Lucy Wilson and c arried by a
unanimous vote.
APPROVAL OF 2021
MEETING DATES
Mr. Bill Buxton made a motion to approval the meeting
dates for 2021. The motion was seconded by Mr. Jerome
Robinson and carried by a unanimous vote.
ELECTION OF
OFFICER FOR 2021
Ms. Julie Herlong opened the floor for nominations for Co-
Chair for 2021.
Ms. Julie Herlong nominated Mr. Bill Buxton for the
position of Co-Chair for 2021. T he nomination was
seconded by Ms. Heidi Burkett and carr ied by a
unanimous vote.
Ms. Julie Herlong then opened the floor for nominations for
Chair for 2021.
Ms. Heidi Burkett nominated Ms. Julie Herlong for the
2
position of Chair for 2021. The nomination was seconded
by Mr. Bill Buxton and carried by a unanimous vote.
NEW BUSINESS
HP-20-28, 100 Broad St. (City) was presented by Mr.
Kyle Kelly . The Committee reviewed thi s request for
Historic Preservation Design Review appr oval for exterior
renovations to the existing commercial building and
associated sit e improvements, including addition of two
new doors and aw nings, a p layground, and a new
dumpster enclosure.
Mr. Kelly stated that according to the Sumter County
Assessor’s Office, the 2,029 sq. ft. building was
constructed in 1963 and is in the mid -century modern
style of architecture, primarily characterized by, among
other things, flat storefronts, concrete finishes, vene ers
with little to no mo lding of ornamen tation. Whil e several
commercial entities occupy buildings in the Hampton Park
Historic Distr ict, 100 Broad St. is one of only three
buildings in the District bot h zoned for and developed
specifically for a commercial use.
Mr. Kelly added that based on the current age of the
structure, location wi thin the district, and architectural
features, 100 Broad St. is not considered on e of the
contributing properties to the Historic District.
Mr. Jay Stu tz was present to speak o n behalf of the
request.
After some discussion, Mr. Bill Buxton made a motion to
approve this re quest in accor dance with the mat erials,
photographs, and construction details submitted and
based on compliance with Design Review G uidelines.
The motion was seconded by Mr. Jerome Robinson and
carried by a unanimous vote.
HP-20-30, 111 Church St. (City) was presented by Mr.
Preston Mc Clun. The Committee review ed this request
for Historic Preservation Desi gn Review appr oval for the
construction of a 576 s q. ft. accessory structure , new
fencing and gate construction, and demolition of a rear
handicap ramp and portion of existing fencing.
Mr. McClun mentioned the property contains a si ngle-
family residential dwelling. T he modification to the site
will meet the needs of the applicant while complying with
the Historic Preservation Design Review G uidelines and
3
using building materials simi lar to the construc tion of the
principal structure and neighboring residences.
Mr. McClun added the scope of work to be compl eted by
the applicant:
1. Construct new 576 sq. f t (24X24 ft) garage
immediately adjacent to the residence.
2. Construct brick and iron fence and gate along the
front property line.
3. Construct 6’ tall wooden privacy fence along the
southern property line.
4. Install a Brick Driveway
5. Demolish handicap r amp located behind the
residence.
6. Demolish 6’ wood priv acy gate a djacent to the
structure to allow for construction of the garage.
Ms. Terri Smith was present to speak on behalf of the
request.
After some discussion, Mr. Bill Buxton made a motion to
approve this re quest in accor dance with the materials,
photographs, and construction details submitted based on
compliance with Design Review Guidelines. The motion
was seconded by Ms. Heidi Burkett and carried a
unanimous vote.
HP-21-01, 146 & 150 S. Main St. (City) was presented by
Mr. Kyle Kelly. The Committee review ed this request for
Historic P reservation Design Revi ew appr oval for
demolition of the commercial buildings on the property.
Mr. Kelly briefed that the buildings are currently vac ant
and were formerly part of the Hill Furniture Company.
Based on the 2010 City of Sumter Historic Resources
Survey, the buildings at 146 & 150 S. Main St. are part of
a multip le storef
ront development in which the first
portions were built circa 1910. The two bui ldings, along
with the adjacent building at 154 S. Main St., were at one
time occupied by the H ill Furniture Company, which
created openings between the fi rewalls of the buildings in
order to operate them as a single business.
Mr. Kelly stated that the building at 150 S. Main St. has a
rectangular floor plan, with a brick two-story configuration.
The ground floor level is c omprised of a glass storef ront
with wooden bulkhead and alumin um awning . The
second floor has fou r (4) window openings with arched
4
detailing at the top. The or iginal exterior entrance to 150
S. Main St. was converted to serve as an additi onal
storefront window space at an unknown date . The
building at 146 S. Main St. has a rectan gular floor plan,
with a brick one -story con figuration. The ground floor
level is comprised of a glass storef ront with an aluminum
awning and glass windows behind the awning.
Based on the current bound ary of the Su mter National
Register Historic District, while 150 S. Main St. is fro m the
period of signifi cance for Do wntown Sumter, it is not
located within the Downtown Sumter Na tional Re gister
District Boundary and is thus not a contributing structure
of the Dist rict, though it is a hist oric structure in its own
right and does contribute to the C ity-designated
Downtown Design Review Dist rict. 146 S. Main St. is not
from the period of significance for Downtown Sumter.
Mr. Kelly mentioned the scope of work proposed by the
applicant for this request is complete demolition and
removal of all st ructures at both 146 S. Main St. and 150
S. Main St.
However, staff has analyzed the structures proposed for
removal and has determined that they represent three
distinct functional parts. Part A is 146 S. Main St., Part B
is the rear addition on 150 S. Main St., and Part C is the
original storefront for 150 S. Main St.
Mr. Kelly added the Design Review Guidelines for
demolition are intended to ensure t hat the full cultural,
historic, and architectural character of a structure is
considered and evaluat ed before it is irrevocabl y
removed. When the C ity acquired the property at both
146 and 150 S. Main St., the buil dings were in varying
stages of deterioration.
In the case of 146 S. Main St., the building h as been
evaluated by the Sumter Codes Enforcement Department
and the Sumter City-County Building Offic ial. The
Building Official has determined it to be in such a state of
decay that demolition is the only f easible path forward in
removing a hazard to public safety. The building does not
represent a struct ure of Dow nton Sumter ’s pe riod of
historical significance, and ther e are no architectural
characteristics cited for this building that merit restoration.
In the case of 150 S. Main St., the st ructure has been
5
evaluated by the City of Sumter Code Enfor cement
Department and the Sumter City -County Building Official.
It has been determined that the rear of the buil ding is in
an advanced state of decay that makes demoli tion the
only viable option to remove a ha zard to public safety.
However, the original storef ront, oc cupying +/- 1,500 sq.
ft. (represented as “Part C”), is from Downtown Sumter ’s
period of historical significance. There are architectural
characteristics that merit preservation/restoration. It is
unclear whether investment in the building to stabilize the
most hist oric section of the structure , where the
contributing architectural characteristics exi st, makes
sense from a financial standpoint. At this time, it is the
applicant’s intent to remove the structures in their entirety.
Mr. Howie Owens and Mr. Tr ipper Lee were present to
speak on behalf of the City of Sumter for the request.
Ms. Tracey Fle ming, an adjacent property owner, was
present to present concerns about this request.
After some discussion, Mr. Bill B uxton made a motion to
approve demolition of the building at 146 S. Main St. and
the rear ad dition of the building at 150 S. Main St. i n
accordance with the material s, photographs, and details
submitted and referenced in the Staff Rep ort based on
compliance with Design Review Guidelines . Mr. Buxton
also included in his motion to conditionally approve
demolition of the storefront building at 150 S. Main St.,
subject to submission of a structur al condition
assessment report prepared by a licensed architect or
structural engineer that fully documents the bu ilding’s
current physical c onditions, provides a reasonable cost
estimate for necessary repairs , and justi fies why such
repairs are not feasible. The mot ion was seconded by
Ms. Heidi Burkett and carried by a unanimous vote.
OLD BUSINESS
NONE
OTHER BUSINESS
Mr. Kyle Kelly briefed the Committee on Certificates of
Appropriateness issued by staff under delegated authority
from November 19, 2020 – January 28, 2021.
ADJOURNMENT
With no further business, Mr. Bill Buxton made a motion to
adjourn the meeting at 5:16 p.m. The motion was
6
seconded by Ms. Lucy Wilson and carried by a unanimous
vote.
Respectfully submitted,
Kellie K. Chapman
Kellie K. Chapman, Board Secretary
Source: City of Sumter website. First collected Oct 15, 2026.