_08042026-1255
Town of Summerville · Berkeley County · meeting of Aug 4, 2026 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Summerville
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Board of Architectural Review Minutes
July 7, 2026
Members Present:
David Price (Chair)
Beth Huggins (Vice Chair)
Jane Knight
Ken Battle
Don Baus
Staff Present:
Jim Langenstein, Planner II, Lenny Larkin, IT Director
Minutes
Meeting was called to order at 6:00 PM by Chairman Price.
I. Oath of Office - Ms. Beth Messervy (Town Clerk) administered the Oath of Office to
Ms. Huggins and Mr. Baus.
II. Approval of Minutes – Mr. Battle motioned to approve the June 2, 2026 minutes
amended to add Mr. Price as the dissenting vote on 214 E South 4
th St. Ms. Knight
seconded the motion. Motion carried 5-0.
Public Hearing – None
Old Business
1. 210 S Gum St – Mr. Mark Tirico presented the revised plans to convert the existing
garage into an ADU, remove the existing asphalt shingle roof, raise the roof pitch, and
replace with a standing seam metal roof to match the existing roof on the primary
structure. Wood siding to match the primary structure was proposed to cover the existing
CMU block exterior walls. The proposed windows and doors are to match the existing
windows and doors of the home. A new bathroom along the back wall of the proposed
ADU was also proposed.
Ms. Huggins motioned to approve the plans as presented. Mr. Battle seconded the
motion. Motion carried 5-0.
New Business
2. 125 E Richardson Ave – Ms. Rachel Burton from Swallowtail Architecture presented for
the owner, Ms. Michelle Sauter from One Coast Design. The applicant proposed a two-
story, 1,216 SF ADU in the rear of their property with a one bay garage on the first floor
and a studio apartment on the second. An administrative adjustment of the proposed
height was granted to allow the building to be 22’ tall rather than the 20’ allowed in the
D-MX Zoning District. The applicant presented two window options to the Board. The
first option matched the 6 over 6 windows of the primary structure. The second option
proposed using 2 over 2 windows. Both options were simulated divided light windows.
The applicant felt that the 6 over 6 grid pattern was too busy on the smaller ADU
windows and preferred the 2 over 2 option. Mr. Price said that the 2 over 2 were still
proportionate and were a common window configuration throughout the Historic District.
Mr. Baus suggested that the garage door grid pattern be changed to reflect the 2 over 2
window configuration. The applicant agreed that they would make that change.
Ms. Knight motioned to approve the application with 2 over 2 windows with the garage
doors to be amended to reflect this window configuration. Mr. Battle seconded the
motion. Motion carried 5-0.
3. 208 Sumter Ave – The Elizabeth Arden House - The applicant was originally requesting
to remove the existing gray standing seam metal roof with a standing seam metal roof
with a Drexlume Mill finish. The requested finish of the proposed roof is why this
application was deferred to the BAR since it was a very different roof color than what
was originally on this structure. The applicant has since changed their color selection to a
Musket Gray. The applicant stated that historically the roof was black but faded to a slate
gray. Mr. Price said that historically the roof has been Charleston Green but has been
coated over the years to its current gray color. He has lived next to the property for over
50 years. The BAR asked to see larger samples of the darkest green color available, Slate
Gray, Matte Black, and Musket Gray. It was felt that the Hartford Green may not be dark
enough.
Ms. Huggins motioned to table this application until the panels can be reviewed. Mr.
Baus seconded the motion. Motion passed 5-0.
Added Note : The purview of the BAR is to provide guidance on exterior applications in
the Historic District. It is not to specifically select colors. The BAR has provided this
guidance to the applicant. They have suggested four (4) colors that should be considered
– Charleston Green, Slate Gray, Matte Black, and Musket Gray. This application was
brought to the BAR only because the original proposed roofing color was not typical of
the Historic District. The applicant has since changed their preferred color to one of the
BAR’s suggested colors. The approval of roofing is typically under the staff’s purview.
Consequently, the applicant shall provide the color samples to staff for further review.
Miscellaneous:
The Summerville Historic District Design Guidelines Section 2.5 Demolition and
Appendix E. Section 13.8.2.C still have the old notification guidelines in them and do not
adhere to the UDO guidelines. This issue was brought before the Board as a courtesy to
notify them that the guidelines are going to be changed. The differences between the
current notification standards and the old standards were discussed. The Board preferred
the broader notification standards for demolition, standalone construction, and the
moving of structures that were previously followed.
Mr. Battle motioned to request Town Council to make changes to the current standards to
reflect the previous notification standards. Mr. Baus seconded the motion. Motion
passed 5-0.
Added Note : The BAR does not have the authority to change the standard established in
the UDO. This change was presented to them at their July 2025 meeting as a courtesy to
let them know that the notification standards were being changed. Staff cited excessive
time commitment, cost, and ineffective methods as determining factors. As such, the
Historic District Design Guidelines will be changed to reflect the notification standards
outlined in the UDO.
As there was no more business in front of the Board, Mr. Baus motioned to adjourn. Mr.
Battle seconded the motion. Motion carried 5-0. Meeting was adjourned at 7:16.
Respectfully submitted,
Jim Langenstein, RLA
Planner II
Source: Town of Summerville website. First collected Oct 15, 2026.