RecordWell Data

_08042026-618

Town of Summerville · Berkeley County · meeting of Aug 4, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from Town of Summerville

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Board of Architectural Review Minutes August 4, 2026 Members Present: David Price (Chair) Tim Pye Jane Knight Ken Battle Don Baus Staff Present: Jim Langenstein, Planner II Minutes Meeting was called to order at 6:00 PM by Chairman Price. I. Approval of Minutes – Ms. Knight motioned to approve the July 7, 2026 minutes. Mr. Baus seconded the motion. Motion carried 5-0. Public Hearing a. Mr. James Bigelow – Discussed issues regarding parking and lighting. He quoted the St Paul’s representatives as saying that they wouldn’t turn Waring St into a parking lot. They now have 20 parking spaces along Waring St. The lighting for the Campus has intruded on the neighborhood even when the parking lot is empty. He felt that the best solution for St Paul’s would be to buy a large parcel in the country where they could create the expansive campus that they want. b. Diane Frankenberger – regarding 321 S. Laurel Ave application. Central Ave is very different from the other streets in the Historic District. There is a significant amount of traffic on this street which creates a tremendous amount of noise. She understands why the homeowner constructed the screen that they did and felt that a reasonable solution would be to paint it black and allow it to stay until SCDOT resolved the truck traffic issue on Central Ave. c. Alex McIntosh – St Paul’s parishioner – They have not caused the growth; growth is coming to them. They already have satellite parishes in other areas. They host many outreach missions in the community. They are trying to prepare for the future given the growth of their congregation. d. Elise Richardson – Lights and increase traffic are her main concern. e. Karyn Healy – Stormwater management is a concern for the St. Paul’s project. They are already over the allowed impervious coverage and they want to add a large structure that will only increase their stormwater issue. What is the effect that this will have on the surrounding properties? f. Jim Healy – The concern regarding St Paul’s is the impervious coverage and what is happening during construction. How is the proposed basin going to control the release of this detained water? What is the effect on the surrounding area? g. Peter Gorman – Re:401 S. Magnolia St – Commended the workmanship that has been done so far. The garage and addition design are very appropriate. Of the two proposed garage locations, he preferred the rear yard location and felt that location was more appropriate than the side yard location. Old Business 1. 321 S Laurel St – Mary Jo Swanson presented the application. The applicant installed a wooden screen to reduce the amount of noise from the traffic at the intersection of Central Ave and S Laurel Ave. She proposed three (3) options. 1. Leave the existing screen in place and paint it black. 2. Re-install the railing and install Bahama Shutters that would be attached to it. 3. Install a shutter that is attached to the existing screen for the full length of the screen without installing the railing. Of these three options the applicant preferred options 1 and 3. The Board was receptive of the 2 nd and 3rd options. Board deferred the decision with the anticipation that the applicant was to submit plans for the full length Bahama Shutter with no railing to staff for review and approval. New Business 2. 311 Sumter Ave - Mike Taylor presented the application. Applicant requested to construct a dormer off the back of their client’s house. The proposed dormer addition is to be 8” fiber cement siding. All trim and siding are to be white. Windows will be simulated divided light windows with 6 over 6 grids to match the existing windows. Roofing will match the existing raised seam metal roofing in color and material. Mr. Baus thought the design was appropriate and motioned to approve the application. Ms. Knight seconded the motion. Motion carried 5-0. 3. 108 Rutherford St – This application requested to enclose the rear portion of the wraparound porch to create an addition in the back of the house. Materials used are to match the existing materials – wood siding, brick piers, and simulated divided light 6 over 6 windows. The existing rear door and window will be re-used. All siding and trim are to be the same color as the existing siding and trim. Mr. Price recommended saving the original windows. It was agreed to use new simulated divided light windows on the new construction and keep the 10 existing windows for the remainder of the house and possibly renovate them over time. Mr. Pye motioned to approve this application. Mr. Baus seconded the motion. Motion passed 5-0. 4. 401 S. Magnolia St – Mr. Pye recused himself from this application. Ms. Rachel Reed presented this application to build an addition in the rear corner of the house and to build a detached two-car garage. The addition requires the demolition of an existing porch addition that was previously enclosed. There are two proposed locations for the proposed garage. The first location was in the side yard between 401 and 405 S. Magnolia St. The setbacks were sufficient for this location. The driveway entrance was off of S. Magnolia St and offset from the garage to get around a large (30”+)Live Oak. The applicant felt that it allowed them to provide access from the driveway to the front door. This location will require review by the Tree Protection Board and approval from SCDOT for the new curb cut on Magnolia. The applicant has been in touch with the Township Arborist and is scheduled next month to appear before the TPB. They have also been in touch with SCDOT and they did not seem to have an issue with the location of the driveway entrance. The second location was in the rear yard with the driveway access off E 3 rd South St. This location was located between two Live Oaks but was at the edge of both of their drip lines. It was not as intrusive on the trees as the side yard location. The downside was that it broke up the back yard. Ms. Knight motioned to approve the demolition of the existing rear addition, the design and construction of the proposed addition, and the design and construction of the proposed garage in the side yard. Mr. Baus seconded the motion. Motion passed 4-0. 5. 111 Waring St. – St Paul’s Episcopal Church – Rector Tripp Jeffords and Eric Epstein, Epstein Architecture presented the current plans. Rector Jeffords presented the current need for the Church’s expansion. During the early 2000’s, the Church experienced rapid growth that resulted in the construction of Doar Hall, the Youth and Learning Center, and the Nursery and Fellowship Center. Part of this original master plan was the demolition of Skardon Hall to create room for an adult education building, and a future church. The latter phases did not happen. The Church is again rapidly growing with many outreach programs that service community needs. These programs often meet during the day during school hours and consequently require separate facilities. In addition, Trinity Academy was added to the St. Paul’s community and is also in need for additional facilities. Mr. Epstein presented the proposed design. The site (about 1 acre) is off Waring St between the current Youth and Learning Center and the cemetery. Skardon Hall currently occupies the site and was built in 1974 using light wood frame construction on a cinder block foundation. This construction limits its ability to be expanded. The current plan follows the L shaped design of the original masterplan but has one building instead of two. There is still a courtyard, but it is greatly reduced in size. The building is divided into two wings. The left wing is the classroom wing for adult classrooms on the first floor and classrooms for Trinity Academy on the second floor. The right wing is for the gynatorium. A central hallway connects the two wings and leads from the Waring St entrance to the courtyard area on the other side. There are a variety of siding options on the proposed structure – lap siding, board and batten, and louvers/shutters - all of which are on other campus structures. Natural wood will be used to highlight prominent areas such as entrances. Brick will be used predominantly as a paving element. The proposed roof is a red standing seam metal roof that is indicative of the other roofs found on the campus. Mr. Price asked about what grades the classrooms on the second floor served. Mr. Epstein responded 5-8. There was no intention to go beyond the 8 th grade at this time. If the need for high school level classrooms arose, then they would consider building off campus as a separate facility. Mr. Pye asked about the size difference between what was conceptually approved vs what is being proposed today. The proposed building is larger than what was previously proposed, partly because of increased growth of the St. Paul’s community. Mr. Pye and Mr. Price mentioned that their purview did not address lighting, parking, and stormwater management. These issues will be resolved by others as they go through the approvals process. Mr. Price mentioned that the lighting issues brought up by the residents could be addressed regardless of what happens with this application. Mr. Baus commented that the Waring St side was more abrupt and sheer than the campus side of the building. It did not have the same scale as the other elements. The link between the two wings was proposed to be wood looking Hardie Plank siding or wood siding. Mr. Epstein said that they will continue to study this elevation, but it is stacked classrooms so they may be limited in breaking it down more. Mr. Baus was thinking about the residents across the street and thought that it was a bit “boxy’. Mr. Price questioned about breaking down the other side of the Waring St entrance where the gymnatorium is located and that they were hesitant to approve board and batten for residential projects. Mr. Epstein responded that the treatment at the roofline and that the proposed board and batten is more pronounced than typical board and batten to allow for greater shadow play and create more interest. Mr. Pye and Mr. Battle also commented on the Waring St elevation and that they thought that they should look at trying to break it up more on the right side of the entrance. Mr. Epstein said that they will look at it. Mr. Pye made a motion to conceptually approve the demolition of Skardon Hall and the conceptual building design pending final building design approval. Mr. Baus seconded the motion. Motion passed 5-0. As there was no more business in front of the Board, Ms. Knight motioned to adjourn. Mr. Baus seconded the motion. Motion carried 5-0. Meeting was adjourned at 7:52. Respectfully submitted, Jim Langenstein, RLA Planner II

Source: Town of Summerville website. First collected Oct 15, 2026.