RecordWell Data

_07202026-1251

Town of Summerville · Berkeley County · meeting of Jul 20, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from Town of Summerville

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

1 Jessi Shuler From: Megan Dungan <megdungan@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, July 20, 2026 10:49 AM To: Jessi Shuler; Scott Slatton; Johnson, Tiffany; Touchberry, Russ Subject: Letter for Planning Commission Members Dear Planning Commission Members, Thank you for taking the time to read this letter. Unfortunately, I am unable to attend Monday night's meeting, but I wanted to share my thoughts regarding my rezoning request. Earlier this year, I applied to rezone my property at 115 S. Magnolia Street to DMX so I could continue operating Magnolia Inn. Just two years ago, the Town of Summerville had at least five operating inns. Today, there are none because the current regulations have made it nearly impossible for them to continue operating. After my request was denied, I met with Town staff, members of Town Council, and the Mayor to discuss what options were available if I decided to take the property off the market. I was told my options under the current zoning were to operate the property as a state-licensed group home or convert it into a long- term residential rental. Over the past several months, I have spent hours researching both options and meeting with potential tenants. Then, last month, 103 S. Magnolia Street, owned by David and Kimberly Garber, with David Garber serving as a Dorchester County employee, and currently under contract to Charpia & Hammes Law, was approved for NMX zoning. After that approval, I was encouraged to submit an application for NMX as well. I am simply asking to be treated consistently with the surrounding properties and with the Town's recent zoning decisions. My property is surrounded by properties that are already zoned NMX: • Across S. Magnolia Street are Shelbourne Law, Amanda Leviner Law, and Magnolia Management Company. • Two properties down will soon be the office of Charpia & Hammes Law Firm. • Behind my property, at 301 E. Richardson Avenue, is the Pink Dolphin Inn (currently for sale), and at 303 E. Richardson Avenue is the Dorchester Children's Advocacy Center. With the recent rezoning of 103 S. Magnolia Street, three of the four sides of my property are now adjacent to NMX zoning. Because of this, I do not believe this request could reasonably be considered spot zoning. Instead, it simply extends the zoning pattern that already exists in this area. The businesses surrounding my property generate very little traffic, and rezoning my property to NMX would be consistent with the existing character and use of Magnolia Street. Caution: This email originated from outside of the organization. Please take care when clicking links or opening attachments. 2 I appreciate your time and respectfully ask for your support of my rezoning request. Thank you for your thoughtful consideration. Sincerely, Megan Dungan 1 Jessi Shuler To: imac Subject: RE: Hi July 13, 3026 Thank you for accepting my letter in protest of rezoning of 115 S. Magnolia St. from GR2 zoning to NMX zoning. I live next door to 115. Thank you also, all planning commission members, for consistently making thoughtful and wise decisions when rezoning issues come before you. Regarding 115 S. Magnolia, the Municipal Association of SC and State law require zoning ordinances to follow the comprehensive plan. Under the South Carolina Comprehensive Planning Act (SC Code Title 6, Chapter 29), all land-use regulations—including zoning codes and the official map—must be adopted and maintained in accordance with the municipality’s comprehensive plan. If a rezoning or development decision is inconsistent with the Future Land Use Map, SC courts have repeatedly held that the decision is legally vulnerable and can be invalidated. Local governments use these long range plans to ensure that development aligns with established goals for housing, economic development, infrastructure, and natural resources. Rezoning of 115 S. Magnolia violates the Comprehensive Plan and Future Land Use map, as did the rezoning of 103 S. Magnolia, located two doors down. While the application of the petitioner states, “Closed bed and breakfast and looking to rezone to N-MX,” under the present zoning, GR2, Magnolia B&B can legally operate with a conditional use permit. On April 8, 2026, the Town’s Attorney, Mr. G. W. Parker conceded to my attorney, Mr. Andy Gowder, that the amendment (to rezone 115) was not in concert with the Comprehensive Plan. Nothing has changed in 3 1/2 months. For the 3rd time since 2024, I oppose rezoning of 115 S. Magnolia. Thank you, Laura S. Crosby 207 E. Richardson Ave. Summerville, SC 29483 8435325443 1 Jessi Shuler To: Ray Crosby Subject: RE: letter to planning commission To Planning Commission Members: Thank you for the work you do. The property at 115 S. Magnolia has come before you several times in the past two years. On each occasion you have denied the owners’ request. I ask that you again deny the request before you for rezoning from GR-2 to N-MX. The property shares borders with 5 other residential properties. Changes to 115’s zoning will impact these other properties, perhaps leading to rezoning requests from them as well. Granting this request would not follow the Summerville’s Comprehensive Plan and the Future Land Use map and the underlying state codes prohibiting such an action. While town council members have viewed previous req uests through the lens of the property continuing as a short-term rental or bed and breakfast, you know that this change in zoning would allow a myriad of other uses, s ome more egregious that others. Those uses, even service industry uses are not in accordance with the character of this block which is designated for single family dwellings, or at least was until council disregarded your recommendation and approved rezoning of 103 S. Magnolia. In closing, I ask that you deny this rezoning request. Birdie Crosby 207 E Richardson Ave Summerville SC 29483

Source: Town of Summerville website. First collected Oct 15, 2026.