RecordWell Data

_07072026-1245

Town of Summerville · Berkeley County · meeting of Jul 7, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from Town of Summerville

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Board of Architectural Review Minutes June 2, 2026 Members Present: David Price (Chair) Jane Knight Tim Pye Ken Battle Kinsey Hollifield Staff Present: Jim Langenstein, Planner II Draft Minutes Meeting was called to order at 6:00 PM by Chairman Price. I. Oath of Office - Ms. Beth Messervy (Town Clerk) administered the Oath of Office to the attending Board members. Ms. Huggins and Mr. Baus were not present and will need to take the Oath at the next meeting. II. Approval of Minutes – Ms. Knight motioned to approve the May 5, 2026 minutes without amendment. Mr. Battle seconded the motion. Motion carried 5-0. Public Hearing – Mr. Peter Gorman, 313 S Magnolia St, came forth to speak. He was happy to see that work was beginning on 401 S. Magnolia St. However, he was not in favor of the demolition of 214 E. 4 th South St, which he considered to be a structurally sound, viable residence in the Historic District even if it did not have any historic significance. He felt that demolition should be the last resort and not the first resort. He urged the Board to delay approval until drawings for the proposed structure are submitted. Old Business – None New Business 1. 210 S Gum St – Mr. Vladimir Silveira presented the project for the owner, Sarita Kauffman. Mr. Price brought up the issue of the accuracy of the elevations and the lack of detail that they contained. He emphasized the importance of showing what they are proposing to build in the elevations to scale so that they have an accurate depiction of what is going to be built. He mentioned that the windows on the elevations were square and not appropriate for the Historic District. Mr. Silveira stated their size, but Mr. Price countered that they needed to be shown correctly on the elevations and not just told what the size of the windows were going to be. He was reluctant to approve given the lack of detail on the elevations. The issue of the roof materials to be used was brought up by Mr. Price. He recommended a metal roof to match the existing red metal roof of the primary structure and the proposed pavilion. Ms. Kauffman brought up the cost difference between the two materials and she was trying to stay within budget. Mr. Price and Mr. Pye stated that the cost difference may be less than expected since they are removing the roof anyway. The applicant was asked to come back to the next meeting with the cost difference between using an asphalt shingle roof and a standing seam metal roof. Mr. Hollifield motioned to approve the outdoor kitchen and pavilion and conditionally approve the ADU with the condition that the applicant revise their elevations to show a greater level of detail, especially regarding the windows. Mr. Pye seconded the motion. Motion approved 5-0. 2. 127 W Richardson Ave – Ms. Maggie Williams from Surculus, presented for the owner. The applicant presented their conceptual plans to renovate the rear patio and access lane for the Montreux Bar and Grill. The concrete access lane near W Richardson Ave is envisioned to be removed and replaced with a bluestone and brick patio. A wrought iron gate with brick columns will separate the front patio from a rear one that would utilize additional brick or concrete pavers. The existing chain-link fence along the southern property will be replaced with a perforated brick wall that incorporates a fountain in the rear patio area. The existing brick patio will be re-utilized and include a shade structure for all-weather use. Lastly, the trash enclosure will be replaced with a stage for live concerts. Mr. Price inquired about how the restaurant was planning to dispose of their waste and Ms. Williams replied that the owner is trying to work out an arrangement with the neighboring property to share a dumpster and that a gate has been proposed in the brick wall to allow access. She also mentioned that they have had discussions with the Fire Marshall regarding accessibility and they have received conditional approval based on the revised gate location. They anticipate final approval at the next TRC meeting. Mr. Pye motioned to approve the concept as presented. Mr. Battle seconded the motion. Motion carried 5-0. 3. 214 E 4 th South St – John Steele presented the application to demolish the existing block house to build another residence. Initially, it was thought that they would demolish both the house and the garage, but they are currently thinking of possibly reusing the garage and incorporate it into the new house design. They will not be able to verify this option until the site plan/engineering is complete. Mr. Pye inquired about the amount of time it would take to demolish the residence and Mr. Steele thought that it would take about a week. Mr. Pye was OK with approving the demolition considering the amount of time it takes to complete the process. Mr. Price was reluctant to approve without the full set of drawings. Mr. Pye motioned to approve the application to demolish the existing house with the condition that they would need to come back before the Board for final design approval of the proposed house. Mr. Mr. Hollifield seconded the motion. Motion carried 4-1with Mr. Price dissenting. 4. 401 S Magnolia Ave – Ms. Rachael Reed (owner) presented the application. Mr. Pye recused himself from this application due to his involvement with it. The applicant is asking permission to build a set of wood front steps to replace the previous concrete steps. In addition, they are proposing to add a railing to the front porch to bring it up to code. The proposed railing is a classic design with 2x2 spindles, 2x4 stringers, and a 2x6 top rail. This detail is commonly found in the Historic District. All wood will be painted white. The porch’s brick skirting, step treads, and the porch floor will be painted gray. The applicant also proposed to remove the existing vinyl siding to expose the wood siding beneath it. The wood siding would then be painted white as it had been prior to the vinyl siding. Lastly, the applicant proposed to remove the existing concrete sidewalk and replace it with brick lined “plantation mix” gravel paving. Ms. Knight motioned to approve the application as presented. Mr. Battle seconded the motion. Motion carried 4-0. 5. 100 Marion Ave – Mr. Taylor Charpia (owner) presented the application. The applicant is proposing to remove the roof from his existing accessory structure as well as its side door and roof. They then want to replace the accessory structure roof and extend it to create a 22’ x 20’ pavilion. This pavilion will share a common roof with the accessory structure. A brick outdoor fireplace is being proposed to be centrally located against their shared exterior wall. Its chimney will project through the structure’s roof. All materials will be the same as the primary structure. The roofing will be the same red standing seam metal roof as the primary structure, the brick for the fireplace will be the same brick that is on the foundation of the house and that lines the driveway, and the chimney will be the same design as the ones on the primary structure. The columns for the pavilion will be the same as the turned columns found on the back porch. All wood will be painted white. The removed side door will be re-utilized as the entrance door to the accessory structure from the pool patio. Ms. Knight made the motion to approve as presented. Mr. Hollifield seconded the motion. Motion carried 5-0. 6. 200 Salisbury Dr – Brett from Southern Industries presented the application for the owner Stephen and Andrea Barlow. The contractor is asking for after-the-fact approval for the window replacement at this residence. They were in the process of applying for the required permits but installed the windows before the permits were approved. Most of the windows were in kind replacements. The one exception was the true divided light bow window. This window was replaced with 4 single panes of glass with the grid between the glass panes arranged in the shape of a bow window. The applicant stated that the cost to replace the original bow window with a true bow window would have been almost 4 times the cost of the product that was used. The windows were replaced to try to improve the energy efficiency of the home. Mr. Pye did not have issue with the style used since this residence was not a historic home. Mr. Price would have preferred to have simulated divided light windows to maintain the appearance of the true divided light window. Ms. Knight mentioned that they did not want to set precedence for future approvals by allowing the between the glass grids to be approved. The use of an exterior mounted grid to match the grid used between the glass was discussed as an alternative option to create the look of the simulated divided light windows. The Board said that the applicant would not have to appear again and that the grid system could be approved by staff. Ms. Barlow mentioned that the salesperson offered external grids, so it was thought that this was a viable option. Mr. Pye made the motion to approve the windows that were replaced in kind as presented and conditional approval of the bow window with the condition that the applicant comes back to staff with the external grids. Ms. Knight seconded the motion. Motion carried 5- 0. As there was no more business in front of the Board, it was adjourned at 7:05. Respectfully submitted, Jim Langenstein, RLA Planner II

Source: Town of Summerville website. First collected Oct 15, 2026.