RecordWell Data

_04092026-1216

Town of Summerville · Berkeley County · meeting of Apr 9, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from Town of Summerville

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Mayor Russ Touchberry Town Administrator Scott Slatton Council Members: Dexcter Mack Tiffany Johnson Richard G. Waring, IV Kima Garten Bob Jackson Matt Halter Town Clerk Beth Messervy Town Attorney G.W. Parker Town of Summerville, SC COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES April 9, 2026 ATTENDANCE Present: Mayor Russ Touchberry, Councilmembers Tiffany Johnson, Kima Garten, Dexcter Mack, Matt Halter and Richard G. Waring, IV. Councilmember Bob Jackson participated via Zoom. Also in attendance were Town Administrator Scott Slatton, Town Attorney GW Parker, and Town Clerk Beth Messervy. A quorum was met. Public and press were duly notified. The meeting took place in Council Chambers at 200 South Main Street and was livestreamed from the Town’s website. CALL TO ORDER Mayor Touchberry called the meeting to order at 6:00pm on Thursday, April 9, 2026. Councilmember Dexcter Mack gave the invocation and pledge of allegiance. **Ms. Garten made a motion, seconded by Mr. Waring, to move item 9c to be considered immediately following the approval of minutes. The motion carried unanimously. EMPLOYEE RECOGNITION Mayor Touchberry recognized Lenny Beall, the security guard in Town Hall, for his joyful attitude, gracious demeanor, helpful heart, and overall dedication to the Town of Summerville. PROCLAMATION Mayor Touchberry presented a proclamation for Child Abuse Prevention Month to staff and volunteers from the Kay Phillips Children’s Advocacy Center, as well as members of the law enforcement community. SPECIAL RECOGNITION The Ukrainian Chaplain Patrol presented Police Chief Doug Wright with a plaque honoring him and the Police Department for their continued relationship with the Ukrainian Police Department. APPROVAL OF MINUTES Town Council Meeting Minutes – April 9, 2026 Page 2 Mr. Waring made a motion, seconded by Ms. Garten, to accept the minutes from the February 12, 2026 Council meeting, the February 23, 2026 Special Joint Meeting with the Planning Commission, the February 26, 2026 Special Council Meeting Budget Workshop, the March 24th Special Council Meeting Budget Workshop, and the committee meetings from April 6, 2026. The motion carried unanimously, and the minutes were accepted into record. **Mr. Waring made a motion, seconded by Mr. Halter, to approve a resolution to support the Greater Summerville / Dorchester County implementation of the 15-year community Vision Plan. The motion carried unanimously. (Item 9C) PUBLIC COMMENT – FEBRUARY 12, 2026 AGENDA ITEMS The Mayor opened the Public Comment portion of the meeting. Larry Collett spoke against the request to annex the property on Luden Drive and King Charles Circle as MF-R, multi-family residential. He stated that while the Newington subdivision residents would welcome a church there, as is proposed by the annexation petitioner, the residents do not want the property to be zoned MF-R because of what could happen in the future if the church decides to sell the property. Mr. Collett asked Council to uphold their denial of zoning the property MF-R, as they had done last summer when a developer wanted to build townhomes there. Fran Harbeson spoke in opposition of the proposed rezoning of 115 South Magnolia Street from GR-2 to DM-X. She stated that it was spot-zoning that should not even be considered. William Harbeson spoke in opposition of the proposed rezoning of 115 South Magnolia Street because of the number of cottages that would be allowed in the DM-X zoning. Kevin Carroll, a resident of Newington, stated that the property on Luden and King Charles is identified as SF-R in the Town’s Comprehensive Plan. He told Council that the adjoining property is zoned MF-R and that the annexation applicant wants to build a church on the proposed annexed property. Mr. Carroll stated that churches aren’t allowed in PL (Public Lands) zoning, but that it’s not necessary to choose MF-R for the church to be allowed there. Rebecca Jackson spoke on behalf of the Summerville Methodist Church, the petitioner for annexation. She explained to Council that her roots run deep in this part of the community. She lived in Newington and raised her two boys there. Ms. Jackson stated that MF-R was the zoning path that the church was advised to take since the adjacent property is already zoned MF-R. She explained to Council that the church will build a church on the property, but that they need Council to give them the ability to move forward with their plans by approving the annexation and rezoning. Mary Maxwell Whitehead, a senior student at Summerville High School, spoke to the Summerville Methodist Church’s background and intention to build on the Newington property. Ms. Whitehead stated that Pastor Ross and his wife, Ginny, meet with the youth of the church every Wednesday at locations around Summerville, and that the youth congregation is excited for the new building. She asked Council to help make the new building a reality. Town Council Meeting Minutes – April 9, 2026 Page 3 Wanda Farinelli stated that the Dungans, the applicants for rezoning at 115 South Magnolia Street, have brought many properties up to code and into existence for the better in downtown Summerville. She said that 115 South Magnolia Street is no exception, and she spoke in favor of rezoning to DM-X. Debbie Tomczyck spoke against the rezoning at 115 South Magnolia Street, stating that DM-X is inconsistent with the Town’s Comprehensive Plan and that the applicants only want relief from their current zoning restrictions. She stated that the request is about marketability of the property. Zachary Hamilton spoke in opposition of the annexation/zoning request for Luden Drive and King Charles Circle, stating that while a church being at that location is more desirable than an apartment complex, things can change if the church decides not to build there and sells to an apartment developer. Mr. Hamilton stated that church leadership can change plans and asked that Council understand that zoning restrictions are the Town’s only tool to help prevent overdevelopment. Peter Gorman spoke in opposition of the rezoning request for 115 South Magnolia, thanking Councilmembers Waring and Jackson for voting against first reading at last month’s Council meeting. Mr. Gorman stated that a title covenant in this case is a meaningless gesture and that zoning DM-X at this location would be against the Town’s Comprehensive Plan and Future Land Use map. Mike Streckert spoke in opposition of the rezoning request for 115 South Magnolia Street, citing that the Planning Commission already made a recommendation for denial and some on Council opposed first reading. He stated that this would be a case of spot zoning and that it is against the Town’s Comprehensive Plan. Mr. Streckert said that a vote in favor of this rezoning is acknowledgement that this is illegal. Diane Frankenberger stated that “survival depends on adaptability.” She stated that the downtown district is vibrant, and she is “by nature, a non-conforming enthusiast.” However, she stated that the 115 South Magnolia rezoning issue isn’t about a bed or breakfast or a specific family. She stated that she is in opposition because it is spot zoning. Frank Tomczyk spoke in opposition of the rezoning request for 115 South Magnolia Street, stated that the Planning Commission already voted against the request after looking on the map of surrounding properties. He also stated that granting a rezoning to help property owners gain financially creates a dangerous precedent. Shannon Sutton stated that she is not against bed and breakfasts, but that she is against changing zones for certain people to get their way. She wants to maintain the full block of the side of South Magnolia as residential. Thomas Stanford stated that the Town is at an impasse because of short term rental rules and what the owners of 115 South Magnolia have already done to their property without permission. He explained that rezoning is not the answer to this problem. Town Council Meeting Minutes – April 9, 2026 Page 4 Mark Greenslit explained to Council that traffic on West Richardson Avenue is increasing since the opening of the Maple Street Extension, especially at the intersection of West Carolina and West Richardson. He said that a four way stop at this intersection isn’t the best solution, because it will cause traffic congestion there. Instead, he urged the Town to get a traffic study done by the SCDOT for speeding and the excessive number of accidents at that location. Megan Dungan, owner at 115 South Magnolia Street, stated that when she and her husband bought the property, they got a permit for 5 units for a bed and breakfast. However, she stated that staff then told them they were capped at 3 units and would have to have a live-on-site house manager to operate. Ms. Dungan stated that the neighbors have spoken untruths about her family and that she and her husband have always been open to compromise. Justin Dunga, owner at 115 South Magnolia Street, stated that this is a “boy who cried wolf” situation, where sensationalism makes one lose credibility. He stated that the opponents to this rezoning request think that visitors to Summerville should stay at the Hamilton Motel or at one of the hotels by the interstate. He stated that bed and breakfasts are important to downtown Summerville, citing that his guests spend a lot of money at downtown businesses nearby to his establishment. Mr. Dungan said that he would rather see this request downzoned to NM-X than see it be denied entirely. Christina Sineath, the selling agent of record for 115 South Magnolia Street, stated that rezoning to DM-X would correct the error that passing the UDO made for bed and breakfasts. She stated that this property is not in a traditional residential area anymore. Mark Bacher, a resident of Newington, said that while he does not have any opposition to a church being built at Luden and King Charles, he is opposed to the MF-R zoning request. He stated that the current church leaders aren’t willing to put deed restrictions on the property, which upsets him. Birdie Crosby spoke in opposition of the rezoning request at 115 South Magnolia Street. He stated that SC Code requires that zoning be made in alliance with the Town’s Comprehensive Plan. He explained that approval of the DM-X rezoning would bring litigation. Laura Crosby spoke in opposition of the rezoning request at 115 South Magnolia Street. She stated that there’s more there than just a house; there is a cottage in the backyard that is 5 feet away from her property line. She stated that if the rezoning to DM-X was allowed, a restaurant could buy the property and she would have the loud noise of such an establishment five feet from her back window. Seth Deitch spoke in opposition of the rezoning request at 115 South Magnolia Street. He stated that the DM-X zoning involves a lot of layers and intricacies that don’t need to be so close to a residential area. Mr. Deitch said that he is asking for the law to be applied as written in this case. Sherrie Parks spoke against the request for MF-R zoning for the Newington annexation by the Summerville Methodist Church. She stated that zoning decisions should be based on what is best for the neighborhood, not for financial reasons. Town Council Meeting Minutes – April 9, 2026 Page 5 Yeadon Smith spoke against the request for MF-R zoning for the Newington annexation by the Summerville Methodist Church. He stated that even though he believes a church will be built there, there is always a possibility that church leadership could change and sell to an apartment developer. He asked Council to work with the church for a different zoning request. Micah Pridgen stated that he is not anti-church, but he is against the MF-R zoning request for the property in Newington on Luden and King Charles Circle. He is concerned about the future land use of the church property is new leadership takes over and sells the property. Dave Comer, a resident on West Richardson Avenue, stated that the traffic on West Richardson has definitely increased since the completion of Maple Street Extension. He asked the Town to pay attention to the speed (lower to 30 mph), enforce the noise ordinance, and to better enforce the “No Thru Trucks” signage for the street. Gene Brislin, a resident of Newington, spoke in opposition of the Summerville Methodist Church’s request for MF-R zoning on the proposed annexation of property on Luden Drive and King Charles Circle. Mr. Brislin said that the piece being annexed and the adjacent already- annexed property, could both be zoned GR-5 instead. Austin Abel asked Council to vote no on first reading of the ordinance to annex and zone MF-R by the Summerville Methodist Church in case the church needs a chance to pivot its direction. Mark Wimberly spoke on behalf of the Finance Committee of the Summerville Methodist Church, stating that the church is already over 400 members strong and that the membership has already undertaken viable actions to build a church on the piece of property being proposed for annexation. He respectfully asked for Council’s support to move forward. John DuBose stated that he was relieved to hear that it is now a church, and not a an apartment complex, that wants to annex the property on Luden and King Charles in Newington. However, he stated that all of those that were opposed to the MF-R rezoning request of last summer are still opposed to the MF-R rezoning request by the church. Adriann Kwist stated that the rezoning request on 115 South Magnolia Street is commercialism versus preservation. He reminded Council that the Planning Commission voted down the request to rezone as DM-X, and he stated that the citizen shouldn’t have to keep showing up to meetings to convince Council to do what the Planning Commission already found right to do. John Eppes, a resident on West Richardson Avenue, reiterated Dr. Greenslit’s request for a traffic study on that road. He stated that there is too much speeding and too many accidents there, and that a stop sign should be considered at the intersection of West Carolina and West Richardson. David Chinnis, a Newington resident who has ties to Newington and the Methodist church, stated that the issue at hand is about zoning and not about the church wanting to build there. He stated that MF-R is not the proper zoning for that location. He asked Council to consider GR-5 for the property instead. Town Council Meeting Minutes – April 9, 2026 Page 6 There being no further comments, the Mayor then closed this section of the meeting. PETITIONS Ms. Garten made a motion to deny the petition by Ambassadors of 1857 to annex TMS# 144-00- 00-082, located at Luden Drive and King Charles Circle, and totaling approximately 4.26 acres. Currently zoned TRM, Transitional Residential District, in Dorchester County and requested to be zoned MF-R, Multi-family Residential, following annexation into the Town of Summerville’s municipal limits. (Council District 5). There being no second, the motion failed. Mr. Waring made a motion, seconded by Mr. Mack, to approve first reading of the ordinance to annex TMS# 144-00-00-082, located at Luden Drive and King Charles Circle, to be zoned MF-R following annexation into the Town of Summerville’s municipal limits. **Councilmember Halter recused himself from the discussion and vote.** Ms. Garten stated that she would not vote for the annexation. Ms. Johnson stated that she would vote in support of the church. Mr. Waring stated that the zoning map allows this zoning on this property. Mr. Jackson stated that he supports the church going there, but has a problem with the MF-R zoning; he then stated that he would vote for first reading. The motion passed 5-1, with Ms. Garten voting in opposition. PENDING BILLS AND RESOLUTIONS Ms. Johnson made a motion, seconded by Mr. Halter, to give second and final reading to an ordinance to annex TMS# 138-00-00-013 located at 507 E. 5th North Street, and totaling approximately one (1) acre. Currently zoned TRM, Transitional Residential District, in Dorchester County and requested to be zoned G-B, General Business, following annexation into the Town of Summerville’s municipal limits. (Council District 2). The motion carried unanimously. Ms. Johnson made a motion, seconded by Mr. Halter, to amend from DM-X to NM-X the second reading of an ordinance to rezone TMS#137-07-16-009, located at 115 S. Magnolia Street, totaling approximately 0.67 acres, and owned by Magnolia Bed & Breakfast LLC, from GR-2, General Residential (2 units/acre), to D-MX, Downtown Mixed-Use (Council District 2). Town Administrator Scott Slatton called a point of order on Ms. Johnson’s motion, recommending to stay within Robert’s Rules of Order, for someone to first make a motion to accept second reading as written and then have a motion to amend to NM-X. With that, Ms. Johnson withdrew her motion. Mr. Halter then made a motion, seconded by Ms. Johnson, to give second and final reading to an ordinance to rezone 115 South Magnolia Street from GR-2 to DM-X. Mr. Halter explained that DM-X is too aggressive for this area and believes that it is spot zoning. He stated that he has no interest in the personal conflicts amongst neighbors or in making a decision based on the threat of a lawsuit. Mr. Halter then made a motion, seconded by Ms. Johnson, to amend the original motion to change the DM-X zoning to NM-X. Ms. Johnson stated that she did a lot of research on bed and breakfasts and zonings when she got elected, and she feels that the UDO Town Council Meeting Minutes – April 9, 2026 Page 7 is keeping the Dungans (owners) from operating a bed and breakfast that is vital to downtown Summerville. Mr .Waring stated that he still intends to vote against DM-X or even NM-X because “once we say yes to commercializing South Magnolia, where do we stop?” Mr. Jackson asked rhetorically if Council is willing to approve everyone’s rezoning request in the downtown area. Mayor Touchberry stated that while he supports bed and breakfasts in the historic downtown, the current zoning already allows them to operate under certain restrictions. He stated that he is willing to change the UDO to help bed and breakfasts thrive in the historic districts. On the vote to amend the motion to give second and final reading, Mr. Halter and Ms. Johnson voted in favor; the motion to amend failed 2-5. With the amendment to the original motion failing, the Mayor called for the vote on the original motion to approve second and final reading of the ordinance to rezone 115 South Magnolia Street as DM-X. The motion failed 0-7. The rezoning was denied. Mr. Jackson made a motion, seconded by Ms. Garten, to give second and final reading to and ordinance to convey by Quit Claim Deed a portion of TMS: 130-10-00-066 containing 0.04 acre (1,762 SF) to Dorchester County for the sum of $12,335. The motion carried unanimously. INTRODUCTION OF BILLS AND RESOLUTIONS Ms. Johnson made a motion, seconded by Mr. Jackson, to give first reading to an ordinance to amend the Summerville Unified Development Ordinance (UDO), Chapter 3, Section 3.3 – Table of Permitted Uses and Section 3.4.5(E)(1)(a) - Tobacco/Tobacco Alternative/CBD/CBD Alternatives Sales Store. The motion carried unanimously. Mr. Jackson made a motion, seconded by Ms. Johnson, to give first reading to an ordinance to amend the Summerville Unified Development Ordinance (UDO), Chapter 10, Section 10.7.2 – Temporary Freestanding Signs Erected During An Election Season and Section 10.8.3 – Temporary Yard Signs. The motion carried unanimously. (Item 9c was taken up earlier in the evening.) Mr. Jackson made a motion, seconded by Mr. Halter, to approve a resolution to annex Charleston County Tract 49C, formerly known as a portion of TMS# 379-00-00-022, owned by the Town of Summerville, SC, in accordance with the South Carolina Code of Laws § 5-3-100. The motion carried unanimously. MISCELLANEOUS Mr. Waring made a motion, seconded by Ms. Johnson, to approve an amendment to the Employee Handbook to include a Town Cybersecurity Training Awareness Policy. The motion carried unanimously. On item 10b (West Richardson four way stops and possible takeover from SCDOT), Ms. Johnson stated that there have been a lot of traffic accidents on West Richardson with the opening of the Maple Street Extension. She stated that she does not want to take over the road Town Council Meeting Minutes – April 9, 2026 Page 8 from SCDOT, but that something must be done to calm traffic. Mr. Halter stated that West Richardson is the west end entrance to our Town from the Nexton Parkway, and that the Town needs to take over the road for maintenance since we are doing it anyway. Ms. Garten made a motion, seconded by Ms. Johnson, to put up four way stops at the intersections of West Richardson and West Carolina, as well as West Richardson and South Hickory Street. Mayor Touchberry asked for clarification that Ms. Garten intended to put up stop signs on a SCDOT- owned road with no permission or traffic study from the SCDOT. Ms. Garten confirmed her motion. The Mayor then stated that he would advocate for the Town reaching out to SCDOT for a traffic study now that the Maple Street Extension is complete and causing more traffic and accidents. Mr. Waring agreed with the Mayor, asking that the Town give the process time to work. The motion failed 3-4, with Ms. Johnson, Ms. Garten, and Mr. Jackson voting in favor. Mayor Touchberry then asked staff to initiate the conversation with SCDOT about speeding, thru traffic, and accidents on West Richardson Avenue. Mr. Jackson made a motion, seconded by Mr. Halter, to authorize Town Staff to enter into a Memorandum of Understanding with Dorchester School District 2 for acquisition of additional property for skatepark. The motion carried unanimously. Mr. Waring made a motion, seconded by Ms. Johnson, to authorize Town Staff to enter into a Memorandum of Understanding and Agreement of Mutual Aid with City of North Myrtle Beach for assistance during Bike Week in May 2026. The motion carried unanimously. PUBLIC COMMENTS (open) The Mayor opened up the floor to public comments from citizens for items not on the agenda. Cornelius Smith expressed his concerns about the traffic patterns on Maple Street with the extension in its final phases of completion. He stated that cars and motorcycles are taking off at high rates of speed at the light on Maple Street, coming from Richardson. He is also concerned about the lack of turning lane on Maple Street going onto Wassamassaw or Shamrock, or even into his driveway. Mayor Touchberry pointed Mr. Smith to the correct staff member for his concerns. Fran Harbeson stated that the owners of the Elizabeth Arden house on Sumter Avenue have replaced the sidewalks in front of the property with flowerbeds, making it unwalkable on that section of Sumter Avenue. EXECUTIVE SESSION Mr. Waring made a motion, seconded by Mr. Halter, to enter into Executive Session for the following items: Discussion of personnel matter related to the hiring of a new Human Resources Manager; Discussion of personnel matter regarding an appointment to fill a vacancy on the State Accommodations Tax Advisory Committee; Discussion of a contractual matter regarding a proposed engagement agreement with Parker Poe Adams and Bernstein LLP and Dorchester County related to the redevelopment of the Interfor property at 1400 West 5th North Street; Discussion of matters related to the proposed location, expansion, or the provision of services encouraging location or expansion of industries or other businesses at the property owned by Interfor. The motion carried unanimously, and Council entered into Executive Session at 8:31pm. Town Council Meeting Minutes – April 9, 2026 Page 9 Mr. Waring made a motion, seconded by Ms. Garten, to return from Executive Session. The motion carried unanimously, and Council returned to open session from Executive Session at 9:26pm. Town Attorney GW Parker stated that Council met in Executive Session for Discussion of personnel matter related to the hiring of a new Human Resources Manager; Discussion of personnel matter regarding an appointment to fill a vacancy on the State Accommodations Tax Advisory Committee; Discussion of a contractual matter regarding a proposed engagement agreement with Parker Poe Adams and Bernstein LLP and Dorchester County related to the redevelopment of the Interfor property at 1400 West 5th North Street; Discussion of matters related to the proposed location, expansion, or the provision of services encouraging location or expansion of industries or other businesses at the property owned by Interfor. He stated that no action was taken in Executive Session. Mayor Touchberry noted that Katie DePoppe was invited into Executive Session for Discussion of personnel matter related to the hiring of a new HR Manager; that Beth Messervy was invited to Executive Session for Discussion of personnel matter regarding an appointment to fill a vacancy on the State Accommodations Tax Advisory Committee; and that Steve Doniger and Rebecca Vance were invited into Executive Session for Discussion of matters related to the proposed location, expansion, or the provision of services encouraging location or expansion of industries or other businesses at the property owned by Interfor. OTHER BUSINESS Mr. Waring made a motion, seconded by Ms. Johnson, to appoint Katie DePoppe as the new Human Resources Manager for the Town of Summerville. The motion carried unanimously. Ms. Johnson made a motion, seconded by Mr. Waring, to appoint David Holaday to fill the vacancy on the State Accommodations Tax Advisory Committee. The motion carried unanimously. Ms. Johnson made a motion, seconded by Mr. Waring, to approve an engagement agreement with Parker Poe Adams and Bernstein LLP and Dorchester County related to the redevelopment of the Interfor property at 1400 West 5th North Street. The motion carried unanimously. ADJOURN Ms. Johnson made a motion, seconded by Mr. Waring, to adjourn the meeting. There being no further business, and with a unanimous vote, Mayor Touchberry adjourned the meeting at 9:29pm. Respectfully Submitted, APPROVED: Beth Messervy, Town Clerk Russ Touchberry, Mayor

Source: Town of Summerville website. First collected Oct 15, 2026.