_03162026-1206
Town of Summerville · Berkeley County · meeting of Mar 16, 2026 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Summerville
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1
Jessi Shuler
From: Randy Sadler <rsadler17@gmail.com>
Sent: Monday, March 16, 2026 2:21 PM
To: Jessi Shuler
Subject: Zoning Parcel as MFR in Newington Plantation
SUMMERVILLE PLANNING DEPARTMENT,
I am surprised and concerned that the Town’s Planning department is already considering
another request to zone the parcel of land across from the elementary schools at King Charles Circle as
Multi-Family Residential.
Recently the neighborhood as well as the Planning Commission and the Town Council all agreed
that this parcel is not suitable for MFR zoning. Many reasons were given and the Town voted
overwhelmingly that MFR was inappropriate. It would be hypocritical to change positions now.
Apparently, for financial reasons, the church’s developer wants to artificially inflate the value of
this property as an MFR-suitable parcel, and it is not. It is suitable only for residential zoning.
Thank you,
RANDY SADLER, Long-time Newington Resident
14 Plantation Circle
Summerville, SC 29485
Email:
rsadler17@gmail.com
Could you please provide my comment to the Town’s Planning Commission.
You don't often get email from rsadler17@gmail.com. Learn why this is important
Caution: This email originated from outside of the organization. Please take care when clicking links
or opening attachments.
1
Jessi Shuler
From: erynn estep <erynnestep@gmail.com>
Sent: Monday, March 16, 2026 2:37 PM
To: Jessi Shuler
Subject: Today's meeting
Greetings Director of Planning Shuler,
I appreciate you taking the time to read this email and at this point in the process you may have heard so
much about this situation that it may sound like static. I value your time and my ability to be part of it.
I am writing to encourage you to NOT change the zoning for the Summerville Methodist church at
Newington to Multi-family (MFR), by refusing the zoning change altogether or enforcing deed restrictions
in the event of a sale of the property from the church. I would appreciate you taking a moment to
encourage others, town council, Mayor Touchberry and zoning administrators to consider the following.
1. Why does the church need MFR zoning?
They can already do anything they need/want to do without that zoning change-Jessi Schuler
has told them that. This is a greedy move, FOR A CHURCH, to try and change this, even if their
reason is a business one to help them navigate forward, they don’t need MFR to navigate. You
as a council member, know this. It is strictly being done as a shady, back door move, everyone
can see that and it is really disgraceful for a church to do such devious things. The church
does not need multi-family zoning to do church things. Period.
2. Zoning change will pull a fast one on us all.
We all know how Newington feels about a potential pile of apartments going into that
space, you’ll recall this past fall when this all started, the massive turnout that took place.
We as a neighborhood were so grateful for all of you, that saw through the greedy
developers plans, saw that they were not willing to work with us. We were truly
appreciative that you sided with us, the community members that voted for you to have
your space in the council. We are asking you to please keep the zoning as it is now, so that
if the church changes their mind, something shifts course, they cannot collect a huge sum
of money by a developer swooping in and do what you and I both know isn’t wanted or what
is right for this parcel of land.
3. Business moves: Why would it matter if both pieces of property have the same zoning if both
pieces are now owned by the same church who can do whatever they want without
restrictions
because they are a church? They want it changed so they can sell it.
The church can build whatever they want right now, by changing the zoning the church can
sell, take the money and run, and apartments go up.
You don't often get email from erynnestep@gmail.com. Learn why this is important
Caution: This email originated from outside of the organization. Please take care when clicking links
or opening attachments.
2
4. Why is MFR zoning bad for this space ? We do not need more apartments- I don’t think that is the
point to make for this argument but nonetheless, if rezoned to MFR, that could happen.
The church folk are simply telling us to rely on faith and have a little faith in them, but what
happens when the zoning changes, and the church sells and this nightmare becomes true?
Shame on the church for using faith and God in such a manner to guilt us into trusting them
but potentially to line their own pockets and collect on their deceit and greed.
IF zoned MFR, the domino effect will begin, little by little more trees and wetlands
disappear, the character of Summerville is already fading with the unhinged growth and
out of control developments.
As a resident and teacher in Newington, the changes that have occurred in the last year are
already overwhelming. The traffic through the neighborhood is getting scary- constant cut
throughs, speeding and increased noise this just from the opening of the BGM parkway
(also affiliated with the church – boy, does that raise some eyebrows). By changing the
zoning and allowing the MFR, the increase of students in our already OVERVCROWDED,
maxed out schools will be almost unbearable. The attendance lines being redrawn from
Sand Hill and Beech Hill have put Newington Elementary OVER capacity, crowded our
classrooms, made chaos across the board for our school, additional families are moving in
everyday and our numbers are increasing at an alarming rate with no slowi ng down in sight.
Multi-family housing going in across from the TWO elementary schools will have dire
consequences in our school setting. Please do not make this property zoned for Multi-
family.
5. The church is unwilling to cooperate and work with Newington. Just like the developers last fall,
we as a neighborhood, were proactive in reaching out to them. We have tried the
same with Summerville Methodist church, the church will not bend or compromise (deed
restrictions is another option) to meet us about our concerns, which is the biggest red flag
about all of this. As a neighborhood, we love the idea of church going in that space. We do not
understand why the church is insistent on changing the zoning when they do not need to
change it to do what they want to do as a church.
6. Deny the change, less work for everyone. If the zoning changes to MFR, that means more work for
everyone, more meetings, more input, more explanations, more complications and convolutions
for everyone and every project moving forward. By leaving the zoning as is, the church still gets
what they want, Newington plantation gets what they want, and the town of Summerville and city
council doesn’t have to hear from any of us anymore about this property. Why say yes to a zoning
change when it’s so easy to say no?
Please, please see this situation for what it is…a sneaky opportunity to disguise deception and greed with
good will and faith.
Please do not change the zoning for the church to Multi-Family at Newington Plantation.
I thank you kindly for your time and efforts in this matter. I am confident that you will make the right
choice and do the right thing for the voting citizens of Newington plantation, for the families attending
Newington and Flowertown schools and for all members of the Summerville community, please do not
allow the multi-family zoning for Summerville Methodist church.
~Erynn Estep
Source: Town of Summerville website. First collected Oct 15, 2026.