May 15, 2026 Minutes (PDF)
Town of Sullivan's Island · Charleston County · meeting of May 15, 2026 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Sullivan's Island
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
MAY 15, 2026 PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE MEETING 1
TOWN OF SULLIVAN’S ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA
PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE
Friday, May 15, 2026
Committee met at 3:00 p.m. on Friday, May 15, 2026 at Town Hall (2056 Middle St.), all
requirements of the Freedom of Information Act having been met.
Present were:
Chairman Pat O’Neil, Committee members Carl Hubbard and Laura Schroeder
Staff: Police Officer Gary Erickson, Rebecca Fanning, Assistant Fire Chief Amanda Hawver,
Town Administrator Joe Henderson, Fire Chief Anthony Stith, and Becky Williams.
A. Call to Order
B. Confirmation of FOIA Notice
Chair O’Neil called the meeting to order at 3:00 p.m., stating the press and public were duly
notified pursuant to state law, and all Committee members were present.
Media: One (1)
Public: Twenty-Seven (27)
C. Approval of the April 20, 2026, Public Safety Committee Meeting Minutes
Motion was made by Laura Schroeder, seconded by Carl Hubbard to approve the April 20,
2026 Public Safety Committee Meeting Minutes, passed unanimously.
D. Public Comment (Usual Council Rules)
Laurie Arthur, Town resident – supports having an external review of the Fire
Department despite the source. Feels the anonymous source needs to refuted and
should include the past two fires.
Jacky Gypin, Town resident – supports the Fire Department and does not feel a third-
party review is necessary. Questioned why a Police Department audit has not been
suggested for safety and improvement purposes as well.
Barbara Spell, Town resident – supports a third-party review and thinks the scope of
the RFP should be discussed in a public session.
MAY 15, 2026 PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE MEETING 2
Email Correspondence:
Mike Burkhold, Town resident – opposed to the RFP being discussed in Executive
Session
E. New Business (Discussion and Action Items)
1. Chief’s Reports
Fire Chief Anthony Stith stated Garret Blakely graduated from the Fire Academy, making all the
firefighters certified. SC250 banners have been installed and the Floppin Flounder 5K will be on
Saturday, May 30, 2026.
Sergeant Gary Erickson stated a coyote trap was set up between Stations 26 and 26 ½ after an
animal attack. One female coyote was caught and transported off the Island. There will be
County Officers helping with traffic on Memorial Day weekend from 2:00-7:00 p.m. There will
also be overlapping police shifts for extra coverage.
2. Review of Draft Ordinance 2026-04, An Ordinance to amend Section 132.32 regarding
the regulation of gas-powered handheld outdoor maintenance equipment (approve First
Reading at April meeting of Town Council): Consideration of potential revisions to the
ordinance as approved.
Director of Resilience and Natural Resource Management Rebecca Fanning reviewed the
revisions that were suggested by Councilmember Burkhold after First Reading of the ordinance.
Each edit was discussed by the Committee. It was suggested to not include gas-powered
mosquito foggers or multi-use powerhead tools because they are not used as often. Also it was
suggested that we do not apply the new ordinance rules to residents, as well as simplifying the
hours rather than including breaks. There were some edits regarding language prohibiting
blowing leaves into storm drains and enforcement. These recommendations will be sent out prior
to Second Reading at the May 19, 2026 Regular Council Meeting.
Motion was made by Laura Schroeder, seconded by Carl Hubbard, to take those
recommendations to Council, passed unanimously.
3. Executive Session – Contractual Matters: Consideration of issuing RFP/RFQ for external
review of Fire Department operations, assets, and staffing, and the scope of services
sought.
MAY 15, 2026 PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE MEETING 3
Motion was made by Carl Hubbard, seconded by Pat O’Neil, to go into Executive Session
with this limited purpose, perhaps limited to 10 minutes at 3:46 p.m., passed 2-1, with
Laura Schroeder opposing.
Laura Schroeder stated she wants the contractual matters to be discussed in open session. Chair
O’Neil, Town Administrator Joe Henderson, and Carl Hubbard confirmed this was to discuss
legal matters regarding the contract and the scope of the RFP would be discussed in open
session.
Motion was made by Carl Hubbard, seconded by Laura Schroeder, to come out of
Executive Session at 3:58 p.m., passed unanimously.
There were no votes taken or motions made during Executive Session.
4. Open Session: Consideration of recommendation to Council re. obtaining external review
of Fire Department operations, assets, and staffing, and the scope of services sought.
Mr. Henderson stated they are discussing two drafts, one presented by Laura Schroeder and the
other recommended by Chief Greg Grayson, of NC Fire Chief Consulting. He then reviewed the
RFP (Request for Proposals) process and stated they are planning to release it on May 20, 2026
to seek bidders. They typically include an executive statement, goals and objectives, the scope of
work, contact information, a timeline, scoring criteria, and legal requirements. He stated this RFP
is expedited compared to the Town’s typical process, but the Committee feels four weeks is
enough time to procure bids. He reviewed each bullet point and task, then took questions from
the Committee. The results will be presented to Town Council and the public at a Town Council
meeting.
Laura Schroeder shared her detailed proposal that she drafted with Gordon Routley compared to
that of the two Chiefs and outlined each of the proposed eight sections. Mr. Routley led the
review of the Charleston Sofa Super Store Fire of 2007. Mr. Henderson stated a detailed outline
of goals and objectives should be included. Laura Schroeder also reviewed the criteria for how
the results will be presented publicly. She would like the Committee to use only her draft rather
than merge it with Mr. Henderson’s. The final draft will be a combination of the two and will be
presented to Council on May 19, 2026 for approval.
Motion was made by Carl Hubbard, seconded by Laura Schroeder, for Ms. Schroeder’s
scope of work to be brought over to Joe’s draft that was put together for an RFP to include
everything she has put forth and any additional that Joe has will be included as well and
merge those two documents together so we can have them to review in advance of our
Tuesday meeting, passed unanimously.
F. Old Business (Staff update available)
MAY 15, 2026 PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE MEETING 4
G. Pending Items (Discussion / Action not required)
Public Comment:
Barbara Spell, Town resident – asked why the Fire Department reports to Joe
Henderson and stated doing so is a conflict of interest.
Anthony Stith, Sullivan’s Island Fire Chief – stated he would like to see the review
done so it can be put behind us. He feels the rumors could potentially lead to ruining
the mutual aid agreements with Mt. Pleasant and Isle of Palms. He has not joined the
“big five” agreement with City of Charleston as that would leave the Island
unattended. Neither homeowner from the two fires have come to discuss them with
him.
H. Adjourn. There being no further public discussion or new business, the meeting adjourned at
approximately 4:49 p.m.
Motion was made by Laura Schroeder, seconded by Carl Hubbard to adjourn the meeting
at 4:49 p.m., passed unanimously.
Respectfully Submitted,
Pamela Otto
Approved at the May 19, 2026 regular Town Council Meeting.
1
Pam Otto
From: Michael Burkhold <mburkhold@gmail.com>
Sent: Thursday, May 14, 2026 1:03 PM
To: Carl Hubbard; Laura Schroeder; Joe Henderson; Bridget Welch; Pam Otto
Cc: asharpe@postandcourier.com
Subject: Formal Objection: Public Safety Committee Agenda Item E.3 Must Be Conducted in
Open Session – May 15, 2026
CAUTION: > This email originated from outside the Town of Sullivans Island. Do not click links or open
attachments unless you have verified the sender and know the content is safe.
Dear Mayor O’Neil and Members of the Public Safety Committee:
I write to formally object to Agenda Item E.3 for tomorrow’s Public Safety Committee meeting. The
proposed Executive Session labeled “Contractual Matters” - for the purpose of “Consideration of issuing
RFP/RFQ for external review of Fire Department operations, assets, and staffing, and the scope of
services sought” - violates the South Carolina Freedom of Information Act, S.C. Code Ann. § 30-4-70.
Section 30-4-70(a)(2) permits a closed session only for “Discussion of negotiations incident to proposed
contractual arrangements” or “the receipt of legal advice where the legal advice relates to a pending,
threatened, or potential claim or other matters covered by the attorney-client privilege.” Neither
exception applies.
No RFP or RFQ has been issued, no proposals have been received, and no counterparty exists. The
Committee is conducting preliminary policy deliberation about whether to issue a solicitation and what
its scope should be. This is not a negotiation and does not qualify as “negotiations incident to proposed
contractual arrangements.”
The “legal advice / potential claim” prong is likewise inapplicable. The agenda announces no legal advice
and references no pending, threatened, or potential claim. It announces only the consideration of issuing
an RFP/RFQ and defining its scope — an administrative and public-policy decision. A public body cannot
announce one statutory purpose and then discuss another in executive session; doing so would itself be
a separate FOIA violation.
Even if the topic arguably fit an exception, the announced purpose “Contractual Matters” is insufficiently
specific. The South Carolina Supreme Court held in Donohue v. City of North Augusta, 412 S.C. 526, 773
S.E.2d 140 (2015) that a generic label such as “contractual matter” does not satisfy the “specific
purpose” requirement of § 30-4-70(b).
The Town Council already reached public consensus in open session on April 21, 2026 that an external
third-party review of the Fire Department is needed. What remains is pure implementation detail, which
the FOIA requires to be conducted in open session.
Agenda Item E.3 should be moved to open session immediately or the executive-session portion be
canceled entirely. The public must be allowed to observe the Committee’s deliberations on this matter.
2
Please confirm by return email today that this item will be handled in open session.
Respectfully,
Mike Burkhold
--
Michael Burkhold
1660 Atlantic Avenue
843.478.5696
mburkhold@gmail.com
Source: Town of Sullivan's Island website. First collected Oct 15, 2026.