RecordWell Data

Minutes

Town of Awendaw · Charleston County · Minutes

Open the original document More from Town of Awendaw

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

TOWN OF AWENDAW 6971 Doar Road I P.O. Box 520 I Awendaw, SC 29429 B43.928.3100 I townadministrator@townofawendawsc.org Katharine Watkins I Town Administrator Takeya White | Clerk Town of Awendaw South Carolina SETTLED 1696 Town Council Special Called Meeting Agenda Monday, May 18, 20261:30 P.M. 1. Call to Order Mayor Crolley called the meeting to order at 1 :32pm. 2. Roll Call Chris Crolley I Mayor Town Council Paul Brown I Grace Gasper Wendy Helms I Rodney Porcher Kent Prause I John Timmons All members were present to include, Councilman Paul Brown, Councilwoman Wendy Helms who attended via Zoom, Councilwoman Grace Gasper, Mayor Chris Crolley, Councilman John Timmons, Councilman Kent Prause and Staff Town Administrator Mrs. Katharine Watkins, Town Clerk/Planning Clerk Mrs. Takeya White, Town Attorneys Mr. Mac McQuillin & Mr. James Ward IV (HSB), and Planning Manager Mr. Daniel O'Hara Councilman Rodney Porcher was absent 3. Invocation Mayor Crolley led the invocation. 4. Pledge of Allegiance The Pledge of Allegiance was recited by all. 5. Civility Pledge Councilman Paul Brown read the Civility Pledge. Prior to consideration of the agenda, Council approved an amendment to add a Public Comment section to the meeting agenda. Motion: To amend the May Special Called Meeting Agenda to include Public Comments as item #7. Posed By: Councilman Kent Prause Second: Councilwoman Grace Gasper Discussion: None Vote: Unanimous Approval Mayor Crolley then went on to agenda item 6 by entertaining a motion. 6. Approval of the May Special Called Meeting Agenda Page 1 of 14 APPROVED Motion: To approve the May Special Called Meeting Agenda. Posed By: Councilman Paul Brown Second: Councilman John Timmons Discussion: None Vote: Unanimous Approval 7. P ublic Comments – [Time Stamp: 2:56/2:54:34] Council received and reviewed written comments submitted by members of the public regarding the proposed Wetlands Ordinance, Tree Preservation Ordinance, and Lighting Ordinance. Written comments were incorporated into the meeting record and addressed topics including administrative review authority, significant tree protections, mitigation requirements, tree preservation standards, and dark sky lighting practices. Four residents addressed Council regarding the proposed ordinances: • Ms. Susan Cox – 6209 Rudder Lane - Mayor Crolley read Susan Cox’s submitted writte n co mments • Ms. Erin Stevens – Surculus – Submitted written comments pertaining to the Tree O rdinance • Mr. John Brubaker - 600 Flatfield Farm Road spoke in support of adopting stronger e nvironmental protections and recommended utilizing language from the original ordinance drafts. He also offered suggested revisions to the Significant Tree Protection provisions and discussed the long-term value of preserving mature trees. • Ms. Susan Cox - 6209 Rudder Lane – (in person commentary) thanked Council, staff, and the Planning Commission for their work on the ordinances and encouraged Council to adopt language that would best preserve the Town's rural character and natural resources. • Dr. Demetrios Popodopulos, representing the Lowcountry Stargazers organization, provided commentary around dark sky lighting standards. He discussed best practice s p romoted by DarkSky International, including shielding requirements, light trespass standards, color temperature limitations, and outdoor lighting design principles. Dr. P opodopulos also encouraged the Town to pursue designation as a Dark Sky Community and discussed the benefits of preserving Awendaw's nighttime environment. Council members asked questions regarding dark sky initiatives, existing lighting conditions within the Town, potential impacts of future development, and opportunities for community education regarding responsible outdoor lighting practices. Hearing no other public comments, Mayor Crolley went on to agenda item 8, Executive Session. 8. Executive Session in accordance with S.C. Code Section 30-4-70(a)(2) to receiv e l egal advice concerning Town of Awendaw v Elliott Summey and Jackson Development Group, LLC arbitration covered by the attorney-client privilege. Council may take action following the executive session. [Time Stamp: 40:15/2:54:34] C ouncil entered Executive Session pursuant to the South Carolina Freedom of Information Act to receive legal advice regarding a pending matter covered by attorney- Page 2 of 14 APPROVED client privilege at 2:14 pm. Motion: To go into Executive Session. Posed By: Councilwoman Gasper Second: Councilman Kent Prause Discussion: NONE Vote: Unanimous Approval Executive Session lasted for 18 minutes, and open session was reconvened at 2:53 pm. Motion: To come out of Executive Session. [Time Stamp: 1:18:04/2:54:34] Posed By: Councilwoman Gasper Second: Councilman Kent Prause Discussion: NONE Vote: Unanimous Approval Following Executive Session, Town Administrator Mrs. Katharine Watkins announced for the record that no motions, votes, or decisions were made during Executive Session. Mayor Crolley then moved on to agenda item 9. 9. Ordinances for Second Reading a. Ordinance 2026-04: An ordinance to amend Chapter 153, Zoning Code, Tree Preservation Requirements Division, Subsection 153.195 and 153.196, to restructure the review, mitigation, and site restoration process for the removal of protected trees. Council considered Ordinance 2026-04 regarding amendments to the Tree Preservation Ordinance. Mayor Crolley entertained a motion to accept Ordinance 2026-04. Motion: To accept Ordinance 2026-04 Posed By: Councilman Paul Brown Second: Councilwoman Grace Gasper Discussion: [Time Stamp: 1:20:32/2:54:34] Discussion focused on the multiple versions of the ordinance currently under consideration, including the First Reading version, Planning Commission recommendations, and staff revisions developed following Council workshop discussions. Council discussed: • Tree protection zones; • Drip line versus diameter-at-breast-height (DBH) measurement standards; • Tree mitigation and replacement requirements; • Enforcement mechanisms and penalties; • Recommendations received from residents and subject matter experts; • The need for a clearer, consolidated ordinance draft. Page 3 of 14 APPROVED The Town Attorney provided procedural guidance regarding amendments and second reading requirements. Councilman Prause noted that he didn’t want to vote on Ordinance 2026-04 because he just got the information. Following discussion, Council determined that additional review was necessary before proceeding with Second Reading. Councilman Paul Brown withdrew his pending motion and Council voted to establish a Tree Ordinance Subcommittee to work with staff and subject matter experts to finalize recommended revisions. The subcommittee will review comments received, work through outstanding policy questions, and return a recommendation to Council for future consideration. Motion: Motion to appoint a special subcommittee composing of Grace Gasper, John Brubaker and Planning Manager Dan O’Hara to review and revise Ordinance 2026-04 and return with recommendations to Town Council. Posed By: Councilman Kent Prause Second: Councilman Paul Brown Discussion: None Vote: Unanimous Approval Motion: To defer Ordinance 2026-04. Posed By: Mayor Chris Crolley Second: Councilwoman Grace Gasper Discussion: None Vote: Unanimous approval Mayor Crolley then moved on to agenda item 9, b. b. Ordinance 2026-06: An Ordinance of the Town of Awendaw, South Carolina, to Amend Title XV: Land Usage, Chapter 153: Zoning Code, General Provisions of the Code of the Town of Awendaw, South Carolina, by Amending Section 153.009 Definitions, adopting a new Section 153.065 Lighting Regulations, along with new Sections 153.066 through 153.070 thereto, providing for New Lighting Regulations. (Deferred Second Reading Item) Council considered Ordinance 2026-06, Outdoor Lighting Regulations. Mr. O'Hara provided an overview of the ordinance, noting that the proposed regulations were developed using examples from other municipalities and model dark sky ordinances and had been reviewed by the Planning Commission. Dr. Demetrios Popodopolus of Lowcountry Stargazers delivered a presentation regarding opportunities for the Town to pursue recognition through the International Dark Sky program. He shared recent dark sky measurements taken within the Town and explained that Awendaw is close to meeting the criteria for designation as a Dark Sky Park. Dr. Popodopolus also outlined the various designations available through Dark Sky International, including Dark Sky Page 4 of 14 APPROVED Parks, Dark Sky Communities, and Urban Night Sky Places. Dr. Popodopolus recommended that the Town: • Adopt dark sky lighting standards; • Conduct a lighting inventory of Town facilities and surrounding areas; • Collaborate with neighboring communities and stakeholders to support dark sky initiatives; and • Consider pursuing designation as either a Dark Sky Park or an Urban Night Sky Place. Council discussed residential and commercial lighting standards, enforcement mechanisms, public education and outreach, light trespass and shielding requirements, color temperature and lumen limitations, future commercial development considerations, and the Town's long- term goal of preserving its natural night environment. Council members expressed support for protecting Awendaw's dark skies while ensuring that any regulations adopted remain practical and understandable for residents and businesses. Mr. O'Hara recommended that educational efforts accompany implementation of the ordinance and suggested periodic review of the regulations following adoption to determine whether amendments may be warranted. Motion: To accept Ordinance 2026-06-02 Posed By: Councilman Paul Brown Second: Councilwoman Grace Gasper Discussion: [Time Stamp: 2:16:46/2:54:34] During Discussion, Councilman Prause suggested amending Section 153.073 by removing Planning Commission and replacing with Planning Manager and posed a motion. Motion: To amend Section 153.073 by removing Planning Commission and replacing with Planning Manager in subsection a,2 and in b, strike second sentence “Planning Manager shall …” Posed By: Councilman Kent Prause Second: Councilwoman Grace Gasper Discussion: None Vote: Unanimous Approval After this vote, Town Attorney, Mr. Mac McQuillin suggested that council vote on the underlying ordinance. Motion: Motion to approve the underlying motion as amended. [Time Stamp: 2:32:19/2:54:34] Posed By: Mayor Chris Crolley Seconded: Councilman Kent Prause Discussion: None Page 5 of 14 APPROVED Vote: Unanimous Approval c . Ordinance 2026-07: An Ordinance of the Town of Awendaw, South Carolina, to Amend Title XV: Land Usage, Chapter 153: Zoning Code, Wetlands and Waterways Setbacks Division of the Code of the Town of Awendaw, South Carolina, by renaming the Division thereof to Wetlands Protection and repealing the Existing Section 153.225 thereto and adding a New Section 153.225, along with New Sections 153.226 through 153.238 thereto, Providing for the Protection of Tidal and Freshwater Wetlands, and all Effected Sections for Clarity; Section 153.009 Definitions to Include Proposed Definitions, Section 153.025 through 153.032 “Description of Zoning Districts” to reference the Wetlands Standards. Council considered Ordinance 2026-07 regarding Wetlands Protection and discussed the need for additional review before final adoption. Concerns were raised regarding the ordinance's regulatory authority, exemptions, prohibited activities, nonconforming uses, and whether the proposed language adequately reflected Council's policy objectives for wetlands preservation. Staff emphasized the importance of ensuring the ordinance clearly protects wetlands while also identifying what activities are permitted, prohibited, or exempt. Council breached this topic by discussing several practical applications of the ordinance, including impacts on docks, nonconforming structures, and private property rights. Mr. O’Hara noted that as currently drafted, certain activities could still occur if applicants met the ordinance requirements and recommended further review to ensure the ordinance's intent was clearly reflected in the regulatory standards. Discussion also included the role of appeals, variances, and the authority of the Board of Zoning Appeals in reviewing decisions. Councilman Prause then posed a motion. Motion: Motion to defer final reading of Ordinance 2026-07 and appoint a special subcommittee composing of Kent Prause, Susan Cox and Planning Manager Dan O’Hara to review and revise the ordinance to return with recommendations to Town Council. Posed By: Councilman Kent Prause Second: Councilman Paul Brown Discussion: D uring discussion, Councilwoman Grace Gasper expressed concern that the ordinance had become overly complex through the review process and suggested revisiting language contained in earlier draft versions. Staff noted that while the wording had evolved, the overall regulatory authority and permitted activities remained largely consistent between versions. Following discussion, Council voted to defer final reading of Ordinance 2026-07. Vote: Unanimous Approval Following the vote, Mayor Crolley went on to agenda item #10, “Other Business Items.” 1 0. Other Business Items – Page 6 of 14 APPROVED a . Resolution 2026-02: A Resolution of the Town of Awendaw, South Carolina, Authorizing the Town of Awendaw to Participate in the South Carolina Rural Infrastructure Authority Viability Improvement Program. During Other Business, Mayor Crolley raised concerns regarding the Town's water system, specifically referencing resident complaints about the taste and odor of municipal water. He also stated for the record that residents who pay for municipal water services should be assured that the water is safe, potable, and meets all applicable standards. Motion: Motion to approve Resolution 2026-02. Posed By: Councilman Paul Brown Second: Councilman Kent Prause Discussion: Additional discussion on the matter was anticipated at a future meeting. Councilman Prause stated that he was not prepared to vote on Resolution 2026-02, noting that he had only recently received the information. Staff clarified that the information had originally been distributed on May 13, 2026. Following further discussion, Councilman Paul Brown withdrew his original motion, and Mayor Crolley entertained a new motion for Council's consideration. [Time Stamp 2:54:09/2:54:34] Motion: Motion to defer Resolution 2026-02 to a later meeting. Posed By: Mayor Chris Crolley Second: Councilwoman Grace Gasper Discussion: None Vote: Unanimous Approval 11. Adjournment – Motion to Adjourn Posed By: Councilman Paul Brown Second: Councilman Kent Prause Discussion: None Vote: Unanimous Approval Town Council Meeting Ended at 4:28 pm DRAFT Minutes Respectfully submitted on Wednesday, June 3rd, 2026, by Takeya White Final Approval Date: 06.04.2026 Electronic Signature: Takeya White, CMC Note: These meeting minutes are not verbatim. To watch the full meeting video, please visit the town’s YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/@TownOfAwendaw. Notice of Meeting: In accordance with the SC Code of Laws, 1976, Section 30-4-80(d), as amended, the following have been notified of the time, date, place, and agenda of this meeting. The agenda was posted on the bulletin board at Town Hall prior to the meeting. Page 7 of 14 APPROVED ADDENDUM - May 18th, 2026 – TOWN COUNCIL MEETING EXHIBIT A – WRITTEN COMMENTS SUBMITTED BY SUSAN COX – 6209 RUDDER LANE, AWENDAW, SC 29429 EXHIBIT B – WRITTEN COMMENTS SUBMITTED BY ERIN STEVENS – SURCULUS EXHIBIT C – WRITTEN COMMENTS SUBMITTED BY JOHN BRUBAKER – 600 FLATFIELD FARM RD, AWENDAW, SC 29429 Page 8 of 14 APPROVED APPROVED From: Susan Cox <s > Sent: Sunday, May 17, 2026 11:01 AM To: Town Administrator <townadministrator@townofawendawsc.org>; Planning Manager <planningmanager@townofawendawsc.org> Subject: Comments on Wetlands and Tree Protection Ordinances   Dan and Katharine, Please find below my comments on the referenced ordinances. I request that these comments be read into the record of the Council meeting on May 18, 2026. WETLANDS ORDINANCE The agenda for the meeting has 2 wetlands ordinances attached. 2026-07-01 had 1st reading in January and I believe largely reflects Council’s goals. It is essentially SCELP’s, language with very few changes. However, there are several items that I believe Council should address. They are as follows: -The TITLE at the beginning is incorrect and needs to be amended - SCELP’s original language called for Planning/Zoning administrator to make the decisions. regarding wetland protection. The PC changed this to have the Planning Commission make the decision. It is my thought that council would want to have these very important, and often very technical, decisions to be made by a professional town official instead of a volunteer board. Should you agree, you would need to direct staff to change all references to the Planning Commission back to the Planning Manager (or whatever Dan’s title is). In addition, with this change I believe that any appeal would then go to the BZA as opposed to circuit court, which would be less difficult for the local population.   - I have corresponded with Kenzie at SCELP about the red-lined language added to Section 153.009 DEFINITIONS (I) Wetlands (3) CRITICAL AREA WETLANDS. I did not know if this language would enhance wetlands protection or reduce wetland protections. She said she did not have a problem with this language, but Mr Brubaker does not like it and prefers the original language in the SCELP document, which does not include this red language. He thinks the document should revert to SCELP’s original language. -The Ordaining Clause at the end of the document is incorrect and needs to be amended. TREE PROTECTION ORDINANCE Proposed Staff Edits version in Appendix Page 11 of 16 -Section 153.195 SIGNIFICANT TREE PROTECTION (A) (a.) (i) pg. 11 of 16 The draft that received 1st reading last year stated that “If trees are clear cut for farming or timbering, the land may not be used for development for eight (8) years following removal of trees.” The section referenced here has changed that number from 8 to 6. If the goal is to deter clear cutting for development , I would recommend changing back to 8 years, as that is truly a deterrent for developers.  -Section 153.195 SIGNIFICANT TREE PROTECTION (D) pg 12 of 16 6/3/26, 6:43 AM Inbox - Takeya White - Outlook https://outlook.cloud.microsoft/mail/id/AAQkAGQyN2E4MmUxLTYwMTItNDk0Mi1iYzNiLTFhNjNhNzM3NmM2MAAQAMFn8BQDqjhDuwd8IMovJRk%3D 2/3 Page 10 of 14 APPROVED I would retain the language “before any Significant Tree removal can take place.” This is not stated elsewhere and it should be crystal clear. -Section 153.195 SIGNIFICANT TREE PROTECTION (E) Tree Fund (b) (i) replace “stoppage of work” with "revocation of permit for 3 years." Developers have no problem paying fines, they would just cut the tree(s) and pay the fine. Adding this language would give this section real teeth. -Section 153.196 GRAND TREE PROTECTION (B) Grand Tree Protection Zone (a) Applicability pg 13 of 16 After “the DBH of the tree” add the language "or the drip line, which ever is greater.” Then make the e.g. explanation a separate sentence. I suggest adding language that requires fencing 4 feet high with a solid top rail, per Charleston County, "must be constructed of wood, metal, plastic fencing, or other approved material, and include a top rail AND must be installed around required trees before development activity begins."  Section 153.196 GRAND TREE PROTECTION (C)(b) (iii) add at end of sentence “ after all reasonable alternative plans have been discussed." Section 153.198 MITIGATION REQUIREMENTS (b) Perhaps I do not understand the chart, but if a 1 to 1 mitigation is required for the removal of 5 trees or less, then why does the removal of MORE THAN  5  trees only require a maximum 50% mitigation, even less depending on the type of tree. This does not make logical sense to me and I think Council should reconsider, if the goal is to preserve the Town’s tree canopy and maintain rural character. I hope Council will make these changes to the proposed drafts. I met the local Dark Sky guy at the BBNF Saturday and I understand he is planning to come to the meeting on Monday to speak on the topic. Please don’t hesitate to call me if you have any questions. Susan Susan Cox  Susan Cox  Susan Cox  Susan Cox 6/3/26, 6:43 AM Inbox - Takeya White - Outlook https://outlook.cloud.microsoft/mail/id/AAQkAGQyN2E4MmUxLTYwMTItNDk0Mi1iYzNiLTFhNjNhNzM3NmM2MAAQAMFn8BQDqjhDuwd8IMovJRk%3D 3/3 Page 11 of 14 APPROVED APPROVED are trying to encroach into a certain area of the DBH-established protection zone. You may also consider requiring dripline surveys in the case of grand tree removals / encroachments if they are trees that you really want to see preserved. Often the dripline (depending on species) will extend significantly beyond the DBH-based zone (depending on what calculation you are using… foot of TPZ for inch of DBH, etc) and be a further hindrance to site development. In cases where the tree should be the priority, it can provide a more stringent protection for its health. I know these codes are always trying to strike the balance between saving tree canopy and specimen/grand trees in particular, while also allowing people to use their properties. The biggest issues are often not with large scale development, but with individual homeowners who want to improve upon their properties , and being too protective of the tree zone can have real consequences for those individuals, sometimes leading to unnecessary tree removals in the end (“I’d rather pay to mitigate it than not be able to use my property”). Allowing some encroachment into these zones is typically fine for the tree’s health, so long as they are properly cared for during construction. Happy to talk through my notes, because describing these nuances via email is tricky. Joseph, feel free to add anything you think I’ve missed. Have a great weekend! Erin Erin F. Stevens, PLA, LEED AP PRESIDENT / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT SURCULUS 62A Cannon Street Charleston, SC 29403 . Page 13 of 14 APPROVED EXHIBIT C Page 14 of 14 APPROVED

Source: Town of Awendaw website. First collected Oct 16, 2026.