RecordWell Data

Minutes

Town of Awendaw · Charleston County · Minutes

Open the original document More from Town of Awendaw

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Town of Awendaw Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting APPROVED MINUTES Monday, January 6, 2025 6:30 PM, Town Hall 6971 Doar Road, Awendaw, SC 29429 A. Prayer, Pledge of Allegiance & Civility Pledge Interim Town Director, Mr. Riccardo Giani began the meeting at 6:30 pm, and opened up with some minor rules of procedure (to include silencing cell phones and that there were times allotted for general public comments and for comments pertaining to the public hearing, to please direct public comments to the Board of Zoning Appeals and not the applicant.) Town Planning Clerk, Takeya White led prayer, Mr. Allen Rioux led pledge of allegiance and also recited the Civility Pledge. B. Call to Order and Roll Call Because this was the 1 st meeting in over a year, Interim Town Planner, Mr. Riccardo Giani, called the meeting to order and did the roll. All members were present (to include Mr. Ken Killough, Ms. Karen Claussen, Mr. Allen Rioux, Mrs. Willette Alston- Hockaday, and Mr. Samuel McNeal) C. A pprove Minutes – There were no minutes to Approve. M r. Giani let the BZA Board members know that there were no minutes to approve, but he thanked the board members for continuing to serve on the BZA and their dedication to public service. M r. Giani began to preface the need to discuss and appoint a board chairman, vice chairman and secretary. M r. Allen Rioux called a “point of order,” and reminded Mr. Giani that public comments were next on the agenda. M r. Giani apologized and then went back to Agenda item D, “Public comments,” and let the public know that the floor was open for general public comments. D. P ublic Comments – There were none. E. New Business 1. Discuss and Appoint Chairman, Vice Chairman, and Secretary Page 1 of 68 Town Staff prefaced the need to appoint a Chairman & Vice Chairman for the BZA Board. H aving no public comments, Mr. Giani then moved on to agenda item E, “New Business,” and prefaced item #1, the need to discuss and nominate a Chairman and a Vice Chairman, and that staff will serve as Secretary of the board. Mr. Giani then asked for a motion to nominate a chairman. M otion: Motion to nominate Allen Rioux as Board of Zoning Appeals Chairman. Posed By: Ms. Karen Claussen Second: Mr. Ken Killough Roll Call Vote: Unanimous McNeal – yes Rioux – yes Claussen – yes Killough – yes Alston-Hockaday – yes M r. Giani then passed the meeting on to newly appointed chairman, Mr. Allen Rioux. C hairman Rioux moved on to item #2. Mr. Giani then reminded Chairman Rioux that they still needed to nominate a Vice-Chairman. Chairman Rioux then asked for nominations for Vice-Chairman. He then asked for volunteers, and Mrs. Alston-Hockaday raised her hand. Chairman Rioux then asked the board members for a motion. M otion: Motion to nominate Ms. Willette Alston-Hockaday as BZA Vice-Chairman. Posed By: Ms. Karen Claussen Second: Mr. Allen Rioux Roll Call Vote: Unanimous McNeal – yes Rioux – yes Claussen – yes Killough – yes Alston-Hockaday – yes C hairman Rioux then moved on to item #2. 2. D iscuss Board of Zoning Appeals Training M r. Giani made the board aware of the state law requirement for continuing education. He let them know that the Municipal Association of South Carolina offers training courses that could help them meet this requirement. After some discussion, Chairman Rioux asked Planning Clerk, Mrs. Takeya White, if she still intends on creating a seminar day for board members. Mrs. White responded that she was still waiting on the new Town Administrator before moving forward. C hairman Rioux then went on to item #3, public hearing for BZA Application 2501-01. He debriefed the public on the meeting procedures . He stated , f irst, staff will give their presentation explaining in detail the application up for decision. Staff would then hold their recommendations for approval or denial of the application until it’s concluded that the Page 2 of 68 board has heard all information and discussed the application. Mr. Rioux then stated that the board would circle back for staff reco mmendation. He also stated that after the initial application presentation by staff, t he applicant will have 10 minutes to present further comments to explain their applicatio n, and then he will open the floor for public hearing comments, leading with those FOR the applicant, and followed by those OPPOSED . The public was told that they would have 3 minutes to speak unless otherwise directed by the chair, and all comments are to be directed to the chair and not the applicant. Chairman Rioux lastly stated that after public hearing , the public portion of the meeting would be closed, and the board will discuss and deliberate. C hairman Rioux then passed the meeting on to Interim Planning Director, Mr. Ricca rdo Giani. Mr. Giani then gave his staff presentation. Mr. Giani stated that the applicant is requesting an 8’ variance to the side setback for the purposes of building an accessory structure. He went on to say that the parcel is in a subdivision that is best known as “Seewee Run.” Mr. Giani went on to explain the staff findings below: “ Staff Findings When reviewing applications for Variances, South Carolina State Law Section 6-29-800- A-2-A through D states the following, “A variance may be granted in an individual case of unnecessary hardship if the board makes and explains in writing the following findings”: ( a) there are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property; (b) these conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity; ( c) because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property; and ( d) the authorization of a variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent property or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by the granting of the variance. The applicant has submitted documents that respond to each of the stated criteria for a variance and detailed the approximate encroachment into the required interior setback of 15’ within the residential district. Additionally, he has submitted letters of support from neighboring property owners for his variance application. A pplicant, Mr. Bob Fuller, then gave his presentation to the board. [ Verbatim Speech ; Audio Time Stamp – 0:15:59.13] “M r. Bob Fuller: We moved here a year ago in November. Our journey here started on, ah, my son's birthday, March 7th 2023, when we found out our youngest grandson had a genetic issue. We were living in Massachusetts and the obvious answer is we're coming to help. We came Page 3 of 68 down a couple of times and looked for property , looked through Mount Pleasant there in Carolina Park, looked at property and couldn't find anything we liked. We looked in this area that we're in Seewee Run and there was a floor plan perfect for us as we are getting older and wanted everything on the 1st floor but there were none available. We were looking a little further up on Doar Road, and got a call from our realtor, who said a house had fallen through. It was this lot, ahh we knew the floor plan; we had never seen the lot. We took 24/ 48 hours and bought it. Our kids watched the house go up. I came down a couple of times and you know, just didn’t, the land was not cleared as it was. Finally it was just there and you know, they were building the house. When we moved in …oh, another thing, our son signed the documents as we were still in Massachusetts. When we got here, everything was awesome. We like living here … we’re 10 minutes from the uh, uh …. One of the things that I have always wanted and never had the opportunity to have is a place to cook outdoors. It’s helpful. I don't have hobbies such as fishing, hunting, … I used to play, uh, golf a lot, but I tore up my wrist and I can’t swing as well. So, cooking is kind of my life. I have a small seasoning company that I'm trying to get relocated here in town and so this pavilion area is going to be our family gathering spot for us our neighbors our friends and uh, stupidly, I guess, I had four people that came out and worked around the property, the area that we're dealing with, I had a fence guy, a concrete guy, a tree guy and a landscaper and none of them mentioned anything about a 15 foot setback. It's my bad. I know that. I was not expecting 15 feet, uhm and this is where I’m at. The areas, you can see by the pictures, is in the back corner of the lot and is as far away from my neighbor behind me as it can be and as far away from my neighbor on the other side as it can be and I doubt the dump truck drivers going up and down Seewee Road will notice much of anything. It's a very nice building. It’s a timber frame building and it’s got a dark metal roof that I don’t think, will, like, I mean it will blend in around the areas, circled around completely by trees. I made a mistake and I'm asking you for some help to keep me from losing quite a bit of money in the process. I think it will add to the character of the house and the landscape character of, uh, the area. If you drive up and down Seewee Road and around and there's a lot of buildings that look very close to the property. I'm sure some are grandfathered. I don't know… that's pretty much where we're at. If you look at the drawings and anybody have any questions or anything about how it works or wanted my drawing - can I ask that? Chairman Rioux: Sure, I think we'll come back to the question. At this point we just wanted to your thoughts. Mr. Bob Fuller: … but If you look at the drawing it’s a really not a very … it’s an odd shaped lot … the front of the lot is 72 inch, ah, feet wide versus the 100, so and then the septic system the way it’s laid out, there’s no place to put any kind of, even a shed , let alone a place where we can have a little outdoor kitchen and a place to put a table and have a covered pavilion. Chairman Rioux: Ahh, okay, Thank you. Mr. B ob Fuller: Thank you. “ Page 4 of 68 After Mr. Fuller’s presentation, Chairman Rioux then asked the public if there were any in favor of Mr. Fuller’s application. 3. Public Hearing – Application 2501-01, Request for an 8’ Variance to the Interior Setback Requirement within a Residential District. Two (2) residents were in support of the applicant, and the president of the Seewee Run HOA sent in their letter of support also. Chairman Rioux then opened the floor to those in opposition to the application. Seven (7) members of the public spoke in opposition to the application. Chairman Allen Rioux noted that the board received many applications requesting denial of the application. The BZA Board then asked questions of the staff and the applicant concerning his case. Chairman Rioux then asked Mr. Giani for his recommendation. Recommendation by the Town Planner: Staff recommended that the BZA approve the requested variance (potential motion #1), based on the following written findings of the required criteria per State Law (or as amended by the BZA): a. The lot size, lot orientation, and placement of septic system of the lot was not due to the actions of the applicant and is a unique feature to this lot within the subdivision. b. There is an existing house to the rear of the development that has several storage buildings on or near the property line. Additionally, the unique location of this lot within the subdivision makes improvements difficult for this particular lot. c. The septic systems installed by the developer limit the utilization of the lot, as this was the only option as there is no sewer service for this subdivision. d. The applicant’s proposed location of the unenclosed structure was determined after thorough consideration from his neighbors. The applicant has provided letters of support from those most affected by the variance. Chairman Rioux asked the board of they wanted to entertain a mo tion to approve BZA application 2501-01. Hearing none, he then asked the board for a motion to deny BZA application 2501-01. Motion: Motion to deny BZA application 2501-01 because it would set a precedent for others later down the line. Posed By: Ms. Karen Claussen Page 5 of 68 Second: Mr. Ken Killough The floor was then opened for discussion among the board. Chairman Rioux gave directional comments to the board, letting them know that before the board discussed the proposed motion, that the board needs to make a finding that all 4 of the proposed criteria by Town Staff have not been met, and it needed to be clearly stated so the applicant had something to react to. [ Verbatim speech noted below ; Audio Time Stamp 0:52:26.35] “ Right, I think that it's just my comments before we open it up to the commissioners to discuss, we need to make a finding that all four of these criteria are not met and that needs to be clearly stated so the applicant has something to react to potentially in the future, so “ Chairman Rioux then led the board in a discussion around each of the below individual staff findings: (a) there are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property; (b) these conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity; (c) because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property; (d) the authorization of a variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent property or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by the granting of the variance. At the end of the discussion, Chairman Rioux stated that from what he was hearing, he concluded that the board felt that criteria (a) was not met, criteria (b) was not met, criteria (c) could be met, and criteria (d) was probably met. Mr. Giani then asked commissioner C laussen to amend her original motion, and commissioner Claussen would have to second that motion. Motion: To accept the revised rationale of the B ZA's review of the criteria as a friendly amendment, where criteria (a) and (b) were not met and criteria (c) and (d ) were met, as stated. Posed by: Ken Killough Second: Karen Claussen Roll Call Vote: 4 – Aye, 1 – Nay McNeal – Aye Rioux – Aye Killough – Aye Claussen – Nay Alston – Aye [Audio Stamp: 1:00:32.81] Mr. Giani then called for a motion. Page 6 of 68 Cha irman Allen Rioux then stated a point of order, that if you wanted to deny the applicant, you would vote,” Yes.” Mot ion: Deny the variance as per staff rationale. Posed by: Karen Claussen Second: Ken Killough Vote: Motion failed – 2 – Aye, 3 – Nay McNeal – Nay Rioux – Nay Killough – Aye Claussen – Aye Alston – Nay Mr . Giani then asked for a new motion. Cha irman Allen Rioux then asked the board for a motion for approval. Mot ion – Motion for approval as per staff rationale. Posed by: Chairman Allen Rioux Second: Mr. Samuel McNeal Cha irman Rioux then led the board in a discussion around the below staff findings: a. The lot size, lot orientation, and placement of septic system of the lot was not due to the actions of the applicant and is a unique feature to this lot within the subdivision. b. There is an existing house to the rear of the development that has several storage buildings on or near the property line. Additionally, the unique location of this lot within the subdivision makes improvements difficult for this particular lot. c. The septic systems installed by the developer limit the utilization of the lot, as this was the only option as there is no sewer service for this subdivision. d. The applicant’s proposed location of the unenclosed structure was determined after thorough consideration from his neighbors. The applicant has provided letters of support from those most affected by the variance. Chairman Rioux then asked Mr. Giani to call the roll for a vote. Vot e: Motion passed – 3 – Aye, 2 – Nay McNeal – Aye Rioux – Aye Killough – Nay Claussen – Nay Alston – Aye Mr . Giani concluded the meeting by letting the public know that there is an appeal period for this decision, and they would have 10 days to file an appeal. F. Old Business. – There was none. G. Closing Remarks – There were none. Page 7 of 68 H. Adjournment Motion: Motion to adjourn. Posed by: Mr. Ken Killough Second by: Willette Alston-Hockaday Vote: Unanimous Meeting ended at 7:37pm. I. Next Meeting – February 3, 2025 (if needed) IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT, THE PRINT MEDIA WERE DULY NOTIFIED, ALONG WITH A HARD COPY POSTED AT CITY HALL. ● SHOULD YOU HAVE QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS, PLEASE CONTACT PLANNING AT (843) 931-8125. MINUTES APPROVED DURING APR 2025 BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS MEETING Respectfully submitted o n Wednesday, March 26th, 2025. Page 8 of 68 Town of Awendaw Town of Awendaw Planning Department 6971 Doar Road Board of Zoning Appeals Application Awendaw, SC 29429 Phone (843) 928-3100 Application ;N111Dber 2. 5,0J ."': 0 I- " Di VARIANCE □ SPECIAL EXCEPTION □ APPEAL - From Zoning Administrator's Decision (must be filed within 15 days of Administrator's decision) Property Address 1 DD 2-- a u-rf)OS'T LC<-4-J b ltwt9IJ '[}IJ/,,), � t- z, r 4-k 5 / I TaxMapNumber(s) 0'2-9 - 00 -t?D-,7 �Z- Present Zoning District __________ _ Lot Dimensions FRo).J'"T"'1-15' 1'1lr� � US I CL'F,- 11-p_!- _ fllt.JI1·-f4:R r Acre'I. 0-'3� \ Deed Recorded: Book 12 ( .3 Page 7 3 , Date� _Q]_j ..n_ Plat Recorded: Book L 7- 7- Page OZ. i fo Date _!!_J__j 2. q · /'2.o �2. Approved No. ___ _ Site Plan Submitted?: I yes ____ no Applicant RoB e: R.'f D, Fi,, L t.,.fi 12-. -#.. L,4 U ktr .:::S- L V l> ll) J G Address I o Q Z Dt.rr Pos-r "1lcA I(.. 1 1\i/6p/:JP(/,() � Z<ffifoJe # (Home) f • _______________________ Phone# (Work) _______ _ Owner(s) (if other than applicant) ________________________ _ Address Phone# (Home) -------------------- ------- Phone# (Work) ----------------------- -------,--- Designation of Agent ( complete only if owner is not applicant): T (u,r-) 1',-.n:ahy !:IIJ',XV'.;n-,. f''b.a JMl"T'l:'nfl '"'q�od cu, .A.pplioo.n.t- o.o an. y (ous-) o gon.� to- s-op.na-0'9Ut. an� (-) iu ti.Lill • ""tu-....,l fu1. a. LUJJlu g pic.111111. Owner Signature (s) Date I (we) hereby certify that the infonnation in this application and all attached documents is correct and I authorize the subject property to be inspected ·ed with a notice of the hearing before the Board_ Date Information required with application (check information submitted}: i Tax map indicating Sllbjed property Approved, recorded plat Scaled site plan indicating variance request (3 copies) Check or cash (made payable to Town of Aweadaw) Incomplete applications wiU be returned to the applicant. Application continued on the reverse side I ir ..... 3,... Page 9 of 68 Page 10 of 68 Page 11 of 68 Page 12 of 68 Page 13 of 68 Page 14 of 68 Page 15 of 68 Page 16 of 68 Page 17 of 68 Page 18 of 68 Page 19 of 68 Page 20 of 68 Page 21 of 68 Page 22 of 68 Page 23 of 68 Page 24 of 68 Page 25 of 68 Page 26 of 68 Page 27 of 68 Page 28 of 68 Page 29 of 68 Page 30 of 68 October 1, 2024 Town of Awendaw Board of Zoning Appeals 6971 Doar Road PO Box520 Awendaw, SC 29429 Dear Members of the Zoning Board, Elizabeth & Matthew Johnson 1006 Outpost Trail Awendaw, SC 29429 We are writing to express our support for our neighbors, Bob Fuller and Laura Ludwig, in connection with their request to obtain a zoning variance. We have thoroughly reviewed the design plans and are fully aware of the proposed location of the new structure. Having considered the plans, we want to emphasize that we have no objections to them. Please let us know if you have any questions or need any further information from us to move forward with granting the variance. Thank you for considering our support for this variance request. Sincerely, Matthew Johnson Elizabeth and Matt Johnsor Page 31 of 68 Subject: 1002 Outpost Trail Permission to build Dare: Oct 2, 2024 at 6:14:16AM To Whom It May Concern: -------- -· -- - I, Susan Peeler Wood of 5270 Seewee Road in Awendaw, SC Charleston County and property owner of said location do allow Robert D Fuller & Laura J Ludwig of 1002 Outpost Trail in Awendaw , SC Charleston County to build an outdoor structure on a provided slab that is located 15. 03 feet from the property line between the two stated residential properties. Most sincerely, Susan Peeler Wood Sent from my iPad fe7«Jan !.¥� 6)/lood Page 32 of 68 Page 33 of 68 planning.awendaw@tds.net From: Sent: To: Cc: Subject: Bet Rhodes Monday, January 6, 2025 10:46 AM Giani, Riccardo ; Takeya White-Town Planner Re: Variance request 2502 - 01 Our address is 6769 Limehouse Road, Awendaw, SC 29429 On Mon, Jan 6, 2025 at 10:45 AM Giani, Riccardo wrote: Received. Please respond with your address of your primary residence so we may record this in the official record. Thank, RICCARDO GIANI, AICP / MRB Group/ From: Bet Rhodes > Sent: Monday, January 6, 2025 10:44 AM To: Giani, Riccardo < > Subject: Variance request 2502 - 01 I am asking you to vote no to the request for variance, application 2502- 01, 1002 Outpost Trail, Awendaw. This is a small lot that is fully built out with a new home and there is no hardship for this owner that would justify a variance. Granting this variance would set a very dangerous precedent for the Town and consequently it should be denied. Please vote no and work to maintain Awendaw's niral character that we all enjoy. 1 Page 34 of 68 Page 35 of 68 Page 36 of 68 Page 37 of 68 Page 38 of 68 Page 39 of 68 Page 40 of 68 Page 41 of 68 Page 42 of 68 Page 43 of 68 Page 44 of 68 Page 45 of 68 Page 46 of 68 Page 47 of 68 Page 48 of 68 Page 49 of 68 Page 50 of 68 Page 51 of 68 Page 52 of 68 Page 53 of 68 Page 54 of 68 Page 55 of 68 Page 56 of 68 Page 57 of 68 Page 58 of 68 Page 59 of 68 Page 60 of 68 Page 61 of 68 Page 62 of 68 Page 63 of 68 Page 64 of 68 Page 65 of 68 Page 66 of 68 Page 67 of 68 Page 68 of 68

Source: Town of Awendaw website. First collected Oct 16, 2026.