RecordWell Data

Minutes

Town of Seabrook Island · Charleston County · Minutes

Open the original document More from Town of Seabrook Island

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Town Council Special Called Meeting March 31, 2026 – 2:30 PM View Meeting on YouTube Seabrook Island Town Hall, Council Chambers 2001 Seabrook Island Road Seabrook Island, SC 29455 MINUTES CALL TO ORDER Mayor Kleinman called the meeting to order at 2:31 pm. ROLL CALL Councilmembers Present: Bruce Kleinman, Mayor; Darryl May, Thomas Hund, Raymond Hamilton, Patrick Faulkner Town Staff Present: Joe Cronin (Town Administrator), Tyler Newman (Planning & Zoning Director), Amber Howard (Finance Director), Abby Grooms (Community Affairs Director), and Peter Wiggins (Town Clerk). FOIA STATEMENT The Town Clerk confirmed that the meeting was advertised in compliance with the requirements of the South Carolina Freedom of Information Act. Agendas were posted and furnished to news media and all others requesting notification. AGENDA REORDER Mayor Kleinman sought unanimous consent to reorder “Other Action Items”. He asked Town Council to take up Resolution 2026-31 as the first item. Mayor Kleinman’s request was granted without objection. ORDINANCES FOR FIRST READING 2026-01: An ordinance amending the Town of Seabrook Island Development Standards Ordinance (DSO) to establish a Planned Development (PD) District and to update various development regulations, Mayor Kleinman reminded the council that they were sent the proposed changes to the DSO over a month ago. He stated that because of this, he has asked the Town’s Planning & Zoning Director to not enumerate all of the changes, but rather a give brief overview of what is being proposed. Mr. Newman gave a brief overview of the proposed changes to the Town’s DSO found in ordinance 2026-01. administrative procedures, and definitions Net Acreage Pending Ordinance Doctrine Mr. Hamilton asked a clarifying question related to a public comment received by the Town. He asked if bees were classified as livestock and if so, should the ordinance allow bees in specific zoning districts. Mayor Kleinman asked Mr. Hamilton to hold the question. Mr. Faulkner asked Mr. Newman to clarify the change proposed by the Planning Commission that strikes “High Ground Acreage” and replaces it with “Net Acreage”. Mr. Newman stated that Net Acreage is defined as the total area of high ground on a given lot or group of lots, including areas for proposed public and private roads. He stated that the two terms mean, effectively, the same thing. He stated it was an amendment that came from the Planning Commission with no objections from staff. Mr. Hamilton motioned to approve Ordinance 2026-01 at first reading, seconded by Mr. May. The town attorney advised Town Council to consider changes to Section 19.2 (D). He stated the section currently states that the Planning Commission shall review and provide a recommendation on all proposed amendments to this ordinance and the official zoning map prior to consideration by Town Council. He stated he would advise striking the word “consideration” and replacing it with “adoption”. He stated that South Carolina statutes currently allow local governments to deny a permit application such as a zoning or building permit if the proposed use is in conflict with a new ordinance being considered. He stated this would prevent a property owner from rushing to secure a permit that would soon be in violation of a pending regulatory change. He stated that an ordinance is deemed considered as soon as it is given first reading by the Town Council. He stated an ordinance is not deemed considered if the only action that has taken place was the consideration of it by the Planning Commission. He stated that the draft ordinance as currently worded, would prohibit the council from taking up a proposed zoning change before the Planning Commission has given its recommendation. He stated that a more precise way of wording this section would be to replace “consideration” with “second reading”. Mayor Kleinman asked if this proposal was discussed by the Planning Commission. The town attorney stated this proposal was discussed but not acted upon. He stated because it was discussed, should the Town Council want to make this change, the ordinance would not need to go back to the Planning Commission for a recommendation. Chain Link Fences Mary Jo Manning, Chairwoman of the Planning Commission, stated there was considerable discussion of this proposal. She stated there were reservations due to this proposal being brand new to the commissioners. She stated that because of this, the decision was made to let this go without a recommendation. The town attorney reminded councilmembers that, assuming this ordinance is adopted at first reading, any zoning or permit applications that are received after the current meeting that are inconsistent with the proposed changes in Ordinance 2026-01, could be denied based on the “Pending Ordinance Doctrine” previously discussed. Mr. May motioned to amend Ordinance 2026-01, per the town attorney’s recommendation, seconded by Mr. Hund. Mr. May agreed to amend his motion allowing the incorporation of changes to language in Ordinance 2026-01 that may still be in conflict with the town attorney’s prior recommendation. Mr. May’s motion was APPROVED unanimously. Mr. Hamilton asked if there was a discussion requiring chain link fences be coated with a black or green coating, as is common among other municipalities. Mr. New man stated that had not been discussed. He stated the reason for the language concerning chain link fences was related to the Racquet Club. He stated he was unsure if the ordinance were amended to require a coating, if that would adversely affect the Racquet Club. He stated he had no opposition to this requirement. Mayor Kleinman reminded the council that the proposed changes in Ordinance 2026-01 are being thought of as “low-hanging fruit”. He stated there will be another round of DSO amendments later in 2026. He continued by stating he was unsure if this requirement proposed by Mr . Hamilton is low-hanging fruit. He stated that, provided Mr. Hamilton’s proposal is not agreed upon today, he would direct staff to include this in the next round of DSO amendments. Mr. May stated that the ARC does not address the coating of chain link fences, simply because the ARC does not allow this type of fence. He stated the proposed changes would only apply to areas outside the jurisdiction of the ARC. He stated if the council determines this is appropriate, he would be in support. Mr. Hund asked why government agencies do not have to follow the height requirement for walls and fences found in Section 2.5 (B)(1)(g). Pools Apiculture Exotic Animals Mr. Cronin stated this exemption from the height limitation is primarily for the Utility Commission. He stated this exemption ensures that sewer facilities are properly secured. Mr. Hamilton, in Section 2.5 (E)(3), stated that the section did not reference elevated pools. He stated he was sure that building codes require an enclosure around elevated pools. He stated he proposes that this section allow for fencing or an enclosure. Mr. Newman stated that the changes in this section recognize that a fence is not the lone requirement for securing a pool for the purposes of safety. He stated that the Town has received complaints from pool contractors who stated that fences are not the only means of securing pools. He stated that as the DSO is currently drafted, the only allowable means for securing a pool is a fence or automatic cover. Mr. Hamilton stated that his interpretation of the proposed changes would only apply to in-ground pools considering this section is silent on elevated pools. Mr. Cronin stated this section is worded in such a way to give deference to the Charleston County Building Inspections Department. Mr. Hamilton stated that if bees are considered livestock, the DSO should allow for bees in certain zoning districts considering bees are critical for Seabrook Island. Mr. Cronin stated that if the council would like to allow bees in certain zoning districts, the definition of livestock would need to be amended at the end of the DSO and also amended to allow for the keeping of livestock in whatever districts council feels is appropriate. He said that currently, livestock are not allowed in the Conservation District due to that zoning district being commonly found adjacent to the marsh. Mr. Cronin closed by stating that if the definition of livestock is amended, this would be an amendment that would need to be sent o the Planning Commission for their recommendation. He stated in light of this, he would propose including this in the next round of DSO amendments coming later this year. Mr. Newman recommended recognizing the existing keeping of bees on a parcel as is being discussed could be treated as an existing, non- conforming use subject to the provisions of Section 21.2 of the DSO. He stated this would allow the operation to remain, subject to the operation not being enlarged or moved. Mr. Hamilton asked why exotic animals would be allowed in certain zoning districts, per the current DSO. Temporary Certificates of Occupancy Mr. Hamilton motioned to amend Section 2.6 (C)(2), so as to exclude the keeping of exotic animals in the AGR, RC, and CSC Zoning Districts, seconded by Mr. May. Mr. Hamilton’s motion was APPROVED unanimously. Mr. Hamilton, in Section 18.2 (G)(4), asked when the Town would allow persons to occupy a structure under a temporary certificate of occupancy. He asked what was meant by term “safely”. Mr. Newman stated his practice would be to define safely as the occupants being in possession of a certificate of completion from Charleston County Building Inspections. He stated he faced a past situation where a new home was completed, but due to the builder constructing an HVAC stand into a required side yard setback, a certificate of occupancy could not be given by the Town. He stated the residents already had movers in route to place furniture inside the home. He stated that he allowed the furniture to be installed in the home, but told the homeowners they could not occupy the unit until the HVAC stand was moved out of the setback. Mr. Cronin stated that the Town has been in the habit of issuing temporary certificates of occupancy based on language found in the building code and per Mr. Newman’s previous example. He stated if it is the wish of council for the Town to stop issuing temporary certificates off occupancy, homeowners will just need to wait for these minor fixes to be remedied. Mr. Hamilton stated he is viewing this issue as both the Planning & Zoning Director and as a property owner. He stated that as drafted, the Planning & Zoning Director is given 100% authority to determine whether or not to issue a temporary certificate of occupancy. He stated there are no guidelines drafted to determine what might be required to issue a temporary certificate of occupancy. Mr. Hamilton stated that he would be more comfortable with a better definition of “safely”. He stated if that were the case, this wouldn’t be such an arbitrary decision. Mr. Hamilton continued by stating he was uncomfortable that there was no time limit on how long a temporary certificate of occupancy would be valid, as well as no requirement on when the issues must be remedied. Mr. Cronin stated that what is usually the issue, is the County Building Inspection s Department being backlogged where construction is complete and the county has performed a final inspection, and because of the backlog, it takes time to issue a certificate of completion. Mr. Newman reminded the council that he would never issue a temporary certificate of occupancy that would allow individuals to occupy the home, and additionally, this section of the DSO is written in such a way to give deference to the Planning and Zoning Director. Mr. Hamilton asked if the intention is to never allow a homeowner to dwell in the property under a temporary certificate of occupancy, why isn’t it stated in this section of the DSO. Mr. Hund reminded the council that in the commercial property arena, temporary certificates of occupancy are common. Mr. May stated that it seemed to him there neede d to be minor wording tweaks to address Mr. Hamilton’s concerns. Mr. Hamilton stated he would have no issues with amending this section to state that this practice would only apply to residential properties. He stated that this would mean that the Town would not issue temporary certificates of occupancy for non-residential properties. Mr. May motioned to amend Section 18.2 (G)(4) to read, “…. the Zoning Administrator is authorized to issue a temporary certificate of occupancy prior to completion of the entire work covered by the permit, provided such portion or portions of the structure shall be occupied safely, as evidenced by passage of a final inspection by Charleston County Building Inspections, and provided no persons occupy the structure as a dwelling”, seconded by Mr. Hamilton. Mr. Faulkner stated that hospitals are occupied under a temporary certificate of occupancy quite regularly. He stated these temporary certificates are good for thirty days. He stated it is up to the building inspecto r whether the building is safe to occupy, to Mr. Cronin’s point. He further stated that the council would not come to an agreement on this today, but that it might bear some further clarification if the council were to take up another set of DSO amendments later in the year. Mr. May stated that it was his understanding from Mr. Newman that as long as he is employed by the Town, he will not be issuing a temporary certificate of occupancy to a commercial building. He further stated that the Town does n’t have any commercial buildings under construction at the moment, but might in the future. He added that the council could consider what to do about issuing a temporary certificate to a commercial building if and when another round of DSO amendments is taken up later in the year. Mr. May’s motion was APPROVED unanimously. Covered Porches Setbacks Fines Enforcement Chain Link Fences Mr. Hamilton stated he would like future versions of the DSO to place time limits on temporary certificates of occupancy. Mr. Hamilton, referring to Section 21.3 (B)(1), asked why a property owner would be permitted to enclose and/or cover a porch that is encroaching up to 50% into a required setback. Mr. Newman stated that the section of the DSO assumes the porch is already covered. He stated this only applies to porches that are being enclosed. He stated this is a very common issue that is taken up by the Board of Zoning Appeals. He stated this is an attempt to reduce the number of cases heard by the Board of Zoning Appeals. Mr. Hamilton, referring to Section 21.3 (B)(3), proposed a scenario where setbacks have changed over the years to make portions of the home non-conforming. He posed a scenario where the property burns down, and asked why the DSO would not allow the home to be rebuilt on the existing foundation. Mr. Cronin stated that this type of scenario, and any potential fixes for this scenario, would be a major amendment to the DSO, and advised Mr. Hamilton to hold this policy discussion for the next round of DSO amendments coming later in the year. Mr. Hamilton, referring to Section 22.2 (F), asked if the scenario posed in the section would be legally permissible. He stated viewing this scenario from the point of view of a property owner, this language would be challenged in a court of law. Mr. Cronin stated a change to this section would also be a major amendment to the DSO. He continued by stating that every place he has been employed has had language similar to this, although the type of enforcement described in the section is very seldomly used. Mr. May motioned to amend the DSO to allow temporary, chain link fencing for the purposes of securing construction sites, seconded by Mr. Hamilton. Mr. Cronin asked Mr. May if he wanted to also propose a maximum time period the fencing would be permitted. Mr. May agreed to amend his motion to allow the fencing only when the construction permit is valid. Mr. Cronin asked Mr. May if he would allow chain link fences in all zoning districts provided the fence is used to secure a construction site. Design Standards Mr. May stated that it was his belief that SIPOA would not permit chain link fences at residential construction sites. Mayor Kleinman stated he sees chain link fences securing many construction sites on Seabrook Island. He also stated that the time constraint for removing chain link fences from construction sites would probably be similar to the requirement for silt fences. Mr. Faulkner questioned why the DSO needed additional language establishing time constraints for temporary fences. He proposed that the Town not issue a certificate of occupancy until any temporary fencing is removed. Mr. Newman stated that a certificate of occupancy is only issued for single family, new construction. He stated a certificate would not be issued for anything other than new construction. He stated tying the requirement that a fence be removed to a certificate of occupancy might be problematic. Mr. Newman continued by stating that the Town would not be scrutinizing every temporary fence that is constructed, but stated it would be beneficial, for those odd situations, for the DSO to specify a time constraint on removing temporary fencing. Mr. May’s motion was APPROVED unanimously. Mr. Hund asked how the Town would conduct a design review of projects that might fall under a Planned Development ordinance. He stated he was specifically thinking about height requirements, roads, and building design. In discussing Section 7.1 (E)(7), Mr. Hund asked if each phase should require a mix of residential and non-residential types and/or uses. Mr. Hund stated that construction phases may not have a mixture of each type of use, he asked if this warrants more discussion. Mr. Cronin stated that, considering this was not taken up by the Planning Commission, should council want to amend this section, this would need to go back to the Planning Commission for a recommendation. Mr. Hund asked that, as larger projects are proposed, should the town play a larger role along the way to avoid the case where the Town is not pleased with the final design. He further stated that the Planning Commission has the opportunity to provide input on design standards in the DSO and Comprehensive Plan. He stated that he didn’t think the town needs a Design Review Board, but stated the Town should have a way to provide feedback on design standards. Definition of Planned Development Formal Recommendation Mr. Newman stated the Planning Commission will be taking up proposed amendments to the Town’s Comprehensive Plan. He stated one of the proposed amendments is the addition of a goal/strategy that would eliminate the Mixed-Use District and the Agricultural District subject to the successful rezoning of remaining properties away from these districts. He reminded Mr. Hund that the previous points made on design standards would be included in any Planned Development text. Mr. Hamilton asked if the town can require, as part of a Planned Development, a project have a public benefit such as a park. Mr. Cronin stated that a Planned Development is tool authorized under state statutes. He stated there is a requirement in state statute that a Planned Development contain a mixture of uses, as well as the establishment of procedural requirements for the adoption of a Planned Development. He stated a planned development is treated as project specific zoning. He continued by stating that using a Planned Development allows the Town to tailor zoning requirements to specific projects. He stated the policy could be to allow publicly accessible facilities or amenities in certain locations per the Comprehensive Plan. The town attorney stated that in its simplest form, a Planned Development is its own zoning ordinance. He stated the council would be creating its own, customized zoning district. He stated it is treated as its own zoning ordinance along with a recommendation from the Planning Commission, two readings of an ordinance, as well as a public hearing. Mr. Hamilton thanked the Planning Commission for their hard work and stated they did a wonderful job. Mayor Kleinman motioned to amend, in Section 19.2 (D), so as to read “… After receiving the application materials from the Zoning Administrator, the Planning Commission shall have 30 days within which to submit its formal recommendation to Town Council”, seconded by Mr. May. Mayor Kleinman’s motion was APPROVED unanimously. Mr. May stated he enthusiastically supports passage of this ordinance. Mr. Hamilton’s original motion to pass Ordinance 2026-01 at First Reading was APPROVED unanimously. OTHER ACTION ITEMS Resolution 2026-31: A resolution adopting a credit card policy for the Town of Seabrook Island Resolution 2026-02: A resolution to adopt the Town of Seabrook Island’s Strategic Priorities for 2026- 2027 Lowcountry Marine Mammal Network Agreement Mr. Cronin gave a summary of Resolution 2026-31. Mr. Hamilton proposed that upon the leave of employment, the Finance Director immediately cancel that employee’s credit card. He stated he also would like staff to create a lost receipt form in the case of an employee misplacing a receipt. He suggested that if the purchase is under a certain amount, a receipt is not required. Mayor Kleinman stated he would rather not formalize the process of documenting lost receipts. Mr. Hamilton stated that in the case that a receipt is lost, the employee should be reprimanded, but that the town should still pay that charge. Mr. Cronin stated the policy states that the Finance Director must pay each credit card bill in full on or before the due date. Mr. Hamilton motioned to approve Resolution 2026-31, provided there is language added requiring the Finance Director cancel an employee’s card upon leave of employment, seconded by Mr. May. Mr. Hamilton’s motion was APPROVED unanimously. Mr. Cronin gave an update on the drafting of the language of Resolution 2026-02. Mr. Hamilton stated he viewed some items that are moderate priorities as priorities that must be accomplished, such as beach signage. The council applauded Mr. Cronin on his work in drafting the resolution. Mr. Hund motioned to approve Resolution 2026-02, seconded by Mr. Hamilton. Mr. Hund’s motion was APPROVED unanimously. Mayor Kleinman gave an update on the status of the agreement with the Lowcountry Marine Mammal Network. He stated there was a need for the council to authorize him to enter into an agreement with the Lowcountry Marine Mammal Network for the purposes of the Dolphin Education Program. Mr. Hund asked if this is a similar contract to those agreed to in the past. Mr. Cronin stated the services are unchanged. He stated the Lowcountry Marine Mammal Network asked for a nominal price increase. Mayor Kleinman stated there are non-financial aspects of the program that can be done better, such as better communication with the Town through its Environment & Wildlife Committee. Mr. Hund motioned to authorize Mayor Kleinman to enter into an agreement with the Lowcountry Marine Mammal Network for the Dolphin Education Program, seconded by Mr. Hamilton. Mr. Hund’s motion was APPROVED unanimously. ADJOURNMENT There being no further business before the council, Mayor Kleinman declared the meeting adjourned at 4:49 pm. Peter D. Wiggins II, MPA Town Clerk

Source: Town of Seabrook Island website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.