RecordWell Data

Packet

City of Hardeeville · Jasper County · meeting of Jan 7, 2021 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Hardeeville

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

City of Hardeeville Regular City Council Meeting and Public Hearings Council Chambers 205 Main Street Hardeeville, SC 29927 AGENDA JANUARY 7, 2021 5:00 PM I. INVOCATION & PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE II. CALL TO ORDER III. OATH OF OFFICE MAYOR - HARRY WILLIAMS ITEM III - OATH OF OFFICE MAYOR (ELECTED) (PDF).PDF IV. OATH OF OFFICE COUNCIL MEMBER - JOHN CARROLL ITEM IV AND V - OATH OF OFFICE COUNCIL MEMBER (ELECTED) (PDF).PDF V. OATH OF OFFICE COUNCIL MEMBER - BO WHITE ITEM IV AND V - OATH OF OFFICE COUNCIL MEMBER (ELECTED) (PDF).PDF VI. SELECTION OF MAYOR PRO TEMPORE PURSUANT TO ARTICLE IV SECTION 2-96 OF THE HARDEEVILLE CODE OF ORDINANCES VII. ELECTION OF MUNICIPAL OFFICERS AND EMPLOYEES PURSUANT TO ARTICLE IV SECTION 2-81 OF THE HARDEEVILLE CODE OF ORDINANCES VIIA. APPOINTMENT OF THE CITY ATTORNEY PURSUANT TO ARTICLE IV SECTION 2- 136 OF THE HARDEEVILLE CODE OF ORDINANCES ITEM VIIA - OATH FOR CITY ATTORNEY (PDF).PDF VIII. APPROVAL OF AGENDA IX. [RESERVED] X. PUBLIC COMMENTS (3 MINUTE TIME LIMIT) XI. PUBLIC PRESENTATIONS XIA. A PROCLAMATION COMMEMORATING THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE SCHOOL CHOICE WEEK – JANUARY 24 – JANUARY 30, 2021 ITEM XIA - PROCLAMATION SCHOOL CHOICE WEEK (PDF).PDF XIB. INTRODUCTION OF FIRE DEPARTMENT DEPUTY CHIEF – BRIAN MAYO AND ENGINEERS – NICHOLAS KELLERMEYER AND CHRISTIAN HANTHORN XIC. INTRODUCTION OF PARKS, RECREATION & TOURISM RECREATION CENTER MANAGER – HUGO MONTENEGRO XII. XIIA. PRESENTATION & APPROVAL OF MINUTES FROM THE DECEMBER 10, 2020 REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING ITEM XIIA - DECEMBER 10, 2020 COUNCIL MINUTES (PDF).PDF XIIB. PRESENTATION & APPROVAL OF MINUTES FROM THE DECEMBER 22, 2020 SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING ITEM XIIB - DECEMBER 22, 2020 SPECIAL COUNCIL MINUTES (PDF).PDF XIII. OLD BUSINESS XIIIA. SECOND READING OF AN ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE EAST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT; PROVIDING FOR THE FINANCING OF IMPROVEMENTS WITHIN THE IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT BY ASSESSMENTS, THE ISSUANCE OF BONDS, OR OTHER REVENUES AS HEREIN DESCRIBED; AND OTHER MATTERS RELATINGTHERETO. (2020-12-10C) PUBLIC HEARING ITEM XIIIA - MID CREATION ORDINANCE - EAST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIIA- EAST ARGENT MID (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIIA SUMMARY FOR ORDINANCE ON EAST ARGENT MID IMPROVEMENT PLAN AND FINANCING (PDF).PDF XIIIB. SECOND READING OF AN ORDINANCE APPROVING THE ASSESSMENT ROLL AND MASTER ASSESSMENT METHODOLOGY FOR THE EAST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT AND OTHER MATTERS RELATING THERETO. (2020-12- 10D) PUBLIC HEARING ITEM XIIIB - ASSESSMENT ROLL ORDINANCE - EAST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIIB - EAST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT MASTER METHODOLOGY REPORT (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIIB SUMMARY FOR ORDINANCE FOR THE MASTER ASSESSMENT METHODOLOGY AND ROLL FOR THE EAST ARGENT MID IMPROVEMENTS (PDF).PDF XIIIC. SECOND READING OF AN ORDINANCE TO ADOPT A MASTER PLAN SUBMITTAL FOR A TRACT OF LAND CONSISTING OF APPROXIMATELY +/-197 ACRES, KNOWN GENERALLY AS THE HUNT CLUB AT EAST ARGENT LOCATED OFF OF EAST ARGENT LOOP ROAD AND JASPER STATION ROAD AND TO AMEND THE OFFICIAL MAP OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE TO INDICATE THAT PORTION SUBJECT TO THE MASTER PLAN. (2020-12-10E) PUBLIC HEARING ITEM XIIIC - SUMMARY FOR HUNT CLUB MASTER PLAN (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIICD - EAST ARGENT IMPS - LOCATION MAP (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIIC - COVER ORD FOR HUNT CLUB MASTER PLAN (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIIC - HUNT CLUB MASTER PLAN (PDF).PDF XIIID. SECOND READING OF AN ORDINANCE TO ADOPT A MASTER PLAN SUBMITTAL FOR A TRACT OF LAND CONSISTING OF APPROXIMATELY +/-50.55 ACRES, KNOWN GENERALLY AS POINTE GRAND AT EAST ARGENT LOCATED OFF OF EAST ARGENT LOOP ROAD AND TO AMEND THE OFFICIAL ZONING MAP OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE TO INDICATE THAT PORTION SUBJECT TO THE MASTER PLAN. (2020-12-10F) PUBLIC HEARING ITEM XIIICD - EAST ARGENT IMPS - LOCATION MAP (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIID - COVER ORD FOR POINTE GRAND MASTER PLAN (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIID - SUMMARY FOR POINTE GRAND MASTER PLAN (PDF).PDF XIV. New Business XIVA. FIRST READING OF AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA ESTABLISHING THE EXIT 3 REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA; MAKING CERTAIN FINDINGS OF AN “AGRICULTURAL AREA” AND A “BLIGHTED AREA” WITHIN THE EXIT 3 REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA; DESIGNATING AND DEFINING REDEVELOPMENT PROJECTS CONSISTING OF PUBLIC IMPROVEMENTS WITHIN THE EXIT 3 REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA; DESIGNATING APPROPRIATE REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT COSTS; APPROVING AN OVERALL REDEVELOPMENT PLAN; AND OTHER MATTERS RELATED THERETO. (2020-11- 5A) PUBLIC HEARING ITEM XIVA - ORDINANCE-EXIT 3 REDEVELOPMENT PLANTIF (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVA - SUMMARY ORDINANCE ON EXIT 3 TIF REDEVELOPMENT PLAN (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVAB - CCL COMMENT HARDEEVILLE AGENDA IXA B EXIT 3 (PDF).PDF XIVB. FIRST READING OF AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA, AUTHORIZING AND APPROVING THE EXIT 3 IMPROVEMENT PLAN AND THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE EXIT 3 MUNICIPAL IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT; PROVIDING FOR THE FINANCING OF IMPROVEMENTS WITHIN THE EXIT 3 MUNICIPAL IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT BY ASSESSMENTS, ASSESSMENT DEBT AND OTHER FUNDS AS HEREIN DESCRIBED; AND OTHER MATTERS RELATING THERETO. (2020-11-5B) PUBLIC HEARING ITEM XIVAB - CCL COMMENT HARDEEVILLE AGENDA IXA B EXIT 3 (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVB - ORDINANCE - EXIT 3 MID (2020) (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVB - SUMMARY FOR ORDINANCE ON EXIT 3 MID IMPROVEMENT PLAN (PDF).PDF XIVC. A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA CITY COUNCIL AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO EXECUTE AN AMENDMENT TO THE MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING WITH SLF III HARDEEVILLE, LLC DATED OCTOBER 31, 2018 TO COMPLETE CONCEPT PHASE SERVICES NECESSARY FOR A NEW EXIT INTERCHANGE ON I- 95, TO BE KNOWN AS EXIT 3, AND THE RIVERPORT PROPERTY (2021-1- 7C) PUBLIC COMMENT ITEM XIVC - RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING CM TO ENTER AMENDMENT 3 (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVC - SLF COH MOU (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVC - THIRD AMENDMENT TO IGA (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVC - AGENDA SUMMARY THIRD AMENDMENT (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVC - EXIT 3 CONCEPT PROPOSAL.PDF XV. MANAGERS REPORT XVI. COUNCIL ISSUES AND CONCERNS XVII. EXECUTIVE SESSION XVIIA. DISCUSSION OF NEGOTIATIONS INCIDENT TO PROPOSED CONTRACTUAL ARRANGEMENTS AND PROPOSED SALE OR PURCHASE OF PROPERTY, THE RECEIPT OF LEGAL ADVICE WHERE LEGAL ADVICE RELATES TO A PENDING, THREATENED, OR POTENTIAL CLAIM OR OTHER MATTERS COVERED BY THE ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGE, SETTLEMENT OF LEGAL CLAIMS, OR THE POSITION OF THE PUBLIC AGENCY IN OTHER ADVERSARY SITUATIONS INVOLVING THE ASSERTION AGAINST THE AGENCY OF A CLAIM IN ACCORDANCE WITH S.C. CODE OF LAW 30-4-70(A)(2). • PROPERTY ACQUISTION COUNCIL MAY TAKE ACTION IN OPEN SESSION ON MATTERS DISCUSSED IN EXECUTIVE SESSION XVIII ADJOURNMENT Upcoming Events January 12 Annual Strategic Retreat – Latitude Margaritaville 8 A.M. January 12 Accommodations Tax Comm. Mtg – Council Chambers 10 A.M. January 13 Planning Commission Meeting – Council Chambers 10 A.M. January 21 Hardeeville City Council Meeting – Council Chambers 5 P.M. January 21 Ridgeland Town Council Meeting – Ridgeland Town Hall 6 P.M. 1. 2. 3. Documents: 4. Documents: 5. Documents: 6. 7. 7.I. Documents: 8. 9. 10. 11. 11.I. Documents: 11.II. 11.III. 12. 12.I. Documents: 12.II. Documents: 13. 13.I. Documents: 13.II. Documents: 13.III. Documents: 13.IV. Documents: 14. 14.I. Documents: 14.I.i. Documents: 14.I.i.1. Documents: 15. 16. 17. 17.I. 18. 19. City of Hardeeville Regular City Council Meeting and Public Hearings Council Chambers 205 Main Street Hardeeville, SC 29927 AGENDA JANUARY 7, 2021 5:00 PM I. INVOCATION & PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE II. CALL TO ORDER III. OATH OF OFFICE MAYOR - HARRY WILLIAMS ITEM III - OATH OF OFFICE MAYOR (ELECTED) (PDF).PDF IV. OATH OF OFFICE COUNCIL MEMBER - JOHN CARROLL ITEM IV AND V - OATH OF OFFICE COUNCIL MEMBER (ELECTED) (PDF).PDF V. OATH OF OFFICE COUNCIL MEMBER - BO WHITE ITEM IV AND V - OATH OF OFFICE COUNCIL MEMBER (ELECTED) (PDF).PDF VI. SELECTION OF MAYOR PRO TEMPORE PURSUANT TO ARTICLE IV SECTION 2-96 OF THE HARDEEVILLE CODE OF ORDINANCES VII. ELECTION OF MUNICIPAL OFFICERS AND EMPLOYEES PURSUANT TO ARTICLE IV SECTION 2-81 OF THE HARDEEVILLE CODE OF ORDINANCES VIIA. APPOINTMENT OF THE CITY ATTORNEY PURSUANT TO ARTICLE IV SECTION 2- 136 OF THE HARDEEVILLE CODE OF ORDINANCES ITEM VIIA - OATH FOR CITY ATTORNEY (PDF).PDF VIII. APPROVAL OF AGENDA IX. [RESERVED] X. PUBLIC COMMENTS (3 MINUTE TIME LIMIT) XI. PUBLIC PRESENTATIONS XIA. A PROCLAMATION COMMEMORATING THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE SCHOOL CHOICE WEEK – JANUARY 24 – JANUARY 30, 2021 ITEM XIA - PROCLAMATION SCHOOL CHOICE WEEK (PDF).PDF XIB. INTRODUCTION OF FIRE DEPARTMENT DEPUTY CHIEF – BRIAN MAYO AND ENGINEERS – NICHOLAS KELLERMEYER AND CHRISTIAN HANTHORN XIC. INTRODUCTION OF PARKS, RECREATION & TOURISM RECREATION CENTER MANAGER – HUGO MONTENEGRO XII. XIIA. PRESENTATION & APPROVAL OF MINUTES FROM THE DECEMBER 10, 2020 REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING ITEM XIIA - DECEMBER 10, 2020 COUNCIL MINUTES (PDF).PDF XIIB. PRESENTATION & APPROVAL OF MINUTES FROM THE DECEMBER 22, 2020 SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING ITEM XIIB - DECEMBER 22, 2020 SPECIAL COUNCIL MINUTES (PDF).PDF XIII. OLD BUSINESS XIIIA. SECOND READING OF AN ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE EAST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT; PROVIDING FOR THE FINANCING OF IMPROVEMENTS WITHIN THE IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT BY ASSESSMENTS, THE ISSUANCE OF BONDS, OR OTHER REVENUES AS HEREIN DESCRIBED; AND OTHER MATTERS RELATINGTHERETO. (2020-12-10C) PUBLIC HEARING ITEM XIIIA - MID CREATION ORDINANCE - EAST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIIA- EAST ARGENT MID (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIIA SUMMARY FOR ORDINANCE ON EAST ARGENT MID IMPROVEMENT PLAN AND FINANCING (PDF).PDF XIIIB. SECOND READING OF AN ORDINANCE APPROVING THE ASSESSMENT ROLL AND MASTER ASSESSMENT METHODOLOGY FOR THE EAST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT AND OTHER MATTERS RELATING THERETO. (2020-12- 10D) PUBLIC HEARING ITEM XIIIB - ASSESSMENT ROLL ORDINANCE - EAST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIIB - EAST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT MASTER METHODOLOGY REPORT (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIIB SUMMARY FOR ORDINANCE FOR THE MASTER ASSESSMENT METHODOLOGY AND ROLL FOR THE EAST ARGENT MID IMPROVEMENTS (PDF).PDF XIIIC. SECOND READING OF AN ORDINANCE TO ADOPT A MASTER PLAN SUBMITTAL FOR A TRACT OF LAND CONSISTING OF APPROXIMATELY +/-197 ACRES, KNOWN GENERALLY AS THE HUNT CLUB AT EAST ARGENT LOCATED OFF OF EAST ARGENT LOOP ROAD AND JASPER STATION ROAD AND TO AMEND THE OFFICIAL MAP OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE TO INDICATE THAT PORTION SUBJECT TO THE MASTER PLAN. (2020-12-10E) PUBLIC HEARING ITEM XIIIC - SUMMARY FOR HUNT CLUB MASTER PLAN (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIICD - EAST ARGENT IMPS - LOCATION MAP (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIIC - COVER ORD FOR HUNT CLUB MASTER PLAN (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIIC - HUNT CLUB MASTER PLAN (PDF).PDF XIIID. SECOND READING OF AN ORDINANCE TO ADOPT A MASTER PLAN SUBMITTAL FOR A TRACT OF LAND CONSISTING OF APPROXIMATELY +/-50.55 ACRES, KNOWN GENERALLY AS POINTE GRAND AT EAST ARGENT LOCATED OFF OF EAST ARGENT LOOP ROAD AND TO AMEND THE OFFICIAL ZONING MAP OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE TO INDICATE THAT PORTION SUBJECT TO THE MASTER PLAN. (2020-12-10F) PUBLIC HEARING ITEM XIIICD - EAST ARGENT IMPS - LOCATION MAP (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIID - COVER ORD FOR POINTE GRAND MASTER PLAN (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIID - SUMMARY FOR POINTE GRAND MASTER PLAN (PDF).PDF XIV. New Business XIVA. FIRST READING OF AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA ESTABLISHING THE EXIT 3 REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA; MAKING CERTAIN FINDINGS OF AN “AGRICULTURAL AREA” AND A “BLIGHTED AREA” WITHIN THE EXIT 3 REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA; DESIGNATING AND DEFINING REDEVELOPMENT PROJECTS CONSISTING OF PUBLIC IMPROVEMENTS WITHIN THE EXIT 3 REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA; DESIGNATING APPROPRIATE REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT COSTS; APPROVING AN OVERALL REDEVELOPMENT PLAN; AND OTHER MATTERS RELATED THERETO. (2020-11- 5A) PUBLIC HEARING ITEM XIVA - ORDINANCE-EXIT 3 REDEVELOPMENT PLANTIF (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVA - SUMMARY ORDINANCE ON EXIT 3 TIF REDEVELOPMENT PLAN (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVAB - CCL COMMENT HARDEEVILLE AGENDA IXA B EXIT 3 (PDF).PDF XIVB. FIRST READING OF AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA, AUTHORIZING AND APPROVING THE EXIT 3 IMPROVEMENT PLAN AND THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE EXIT 3 MUNICIPAL IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT; PROVIDING FOR THE FINANCING OF IMPROVEMENTS WITHIN THE EXIT 3 MUNICIPAL IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT BY ASSESSMENTS, ASSESSMENT DEBT AND OTHER FUNDS AS HEREIN DESCRIBED; AND OTHER MATTERS RELATING THERETO. (2020-11-5B) PUBLIC HEARING ITEM XIVAB - CCL COMMENT HARDEEVILLE AGENDA IXA B EXIT 3 (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVB - ORDINANCE - EXIT 3 MID (2020) (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVB - SUMMARY FOR ORDINANCE ON EXIT 3 MID IMPROVEMENT PLAN (PDF).PDF XIVC. A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA CITY COUNCIL AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO EXECUTE AN AMENDMENT TO THE MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING WITH SLF III HARDEEVILLE, LLC DATED OCTOBER 31, 2018 TO COMPLETE CONCEPT PHASE SERVICES NECESSARY FOR A NEW EXIT INTERCHANGE ON I- 95, TO BE KNOWN AS EXIT 3, AND THE RIVERPORT PROPERTY (2021-1- 7C) PUBLIC COMMENT ITEM XIVC - RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING CM TO ENTER AMENDMENT 3 (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVC - SLF COH MOU (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVC - THIRD AMENDMENT TO IGA (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVC - AGENDA SUMMARY THIRD AMENDMENT (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVC - EXIT 3 CONCEPT PROPOSAL.PDF XV. MANAGERS REPORT XVI. COUNCIL ISSUES AND CONCERNS XVII. EXECUTIVE SESSION XVIIA. DISCUSSION OF NEGOTIATIONS INCIDENT TO PROPOSED CONTRACTUAL ARRANGEMENTS AND PROPOSED SALE OR PURCHASE OF PROPERTY, THE RECEIPT OF LEGAL ADVICE WHERE LEGAL ADVICE RELATES TO A PENDING, THREATENED, OR POTENTIAL CLAIM OR OTHER MATTERS COVERED BY THE ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGE, SETTLEMENT OF LEGAL CLAIMS, OR THE POSITION OF THE PUBLIC AGENCY IN OTHER ADVERSARY SITUATIONS INVOLVING THE ASSERTION AGAINST THE AGENCY OF A CLAIM IN ACCORDANCE WITH S.C. CODE OF LAW 30-4-70(A)(2). • PROPERTY ACQUISTION COUNCIL MAY TAKE ACTION IN OPEN SESSION ON MATTERS DISCUSSED IN EXECUTIVE SESSION XVIII ADJOURNMENT Upcoming Events January 12 Annual Strategic Retreat – Latitude Margaritaville 8 A.M. January 12 Accommodations Tax Comm. Mtg – Council Chambers 10 A.M. January 13 Planning Commission Meeting – Council Chambers 10 A.M. January 21 Hardeeville City Council Meeting – Council Chambers 5 P.M. January 21 Ridgeland Town Council Meeting – Ridgeland Town Hall 6 P.M. 1. 2. 3. Documents: 4. Documents: 5. Documents: 6. 7. 7.I. Documents: 8. 9. 10. 11. 11.I. Documents: 11.II. 11.III. 12. 12.I. Documents: 12.II. Documents: 13. 13.I. Documents: 13.II. Documents: 13.III. Documents: 13.IV. Documents: 14. 14.I. Documents: 14.I.i. Documents: 14.I.i.1. Documents: 15. 16. 17. 17.I. 18. 19. City of Hardeeville Regular City Council Meeting and Public Hearings Council Chambers 205 Main Street Hardeeville, SC 29927 AGENDA JANUARY 7, 2021 5:00 PM I. INVOCATION & PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE II. CALL TO ORDER III. OATH OF OFFICE MAYOR - HARRY WILLIAMS ITEM III - OATH OF OFFICE MAYOR (ELECTED) (PDF).PDF IV. OATH OF OFFICE COUNCIL MEMBER - JOHN CARROLL ITEM IV AND V - OATH OF OFFICE COUNCIL MEMBER (ELECTED) (PDF).PDF V. OATH OF OFFICE COUNCIL MEMBER - BO WHITE ITEM IV AND V - OATH OF OFFICE COUNCIL MEMBER (ELECTED) (PDF).PDF VI. SELECTION OF MAYOR PRO TEMPORE PURSUANT TO ARTICLE IV SECTION 2-96 OF THE HARDEEVILLE CODE OF ORDINANCES VII. ELECTION OF MUNICIPAL OFFICERS AND EMPLOYEES PURSUANT TO ARTICLE IV SECTION 2-81 OF THE HARDEEVILLE CODE OF ORDINANCES VIIA. APPOINTMENT OF THE CITY ATTORNEY PURSUANT TO ARTICLE IV SECTION 2- 136 OF THE HARDEEVILLE CODE OF ORDINANCES ITEM VIIA - OATH FOR CITY ATTORNEY (PDF).PDF VIII. APPROVAL OF AGENDA IX. [RESERVED] X. PUBLIC COMMENTS (3 MINUTE TIME LIMIT) XI. PUBLIC PRESENTATIONS XIA. A PROCLAMATION COMMEMORATING THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE SCHOOL CHOICE WEEK – JANUARY 24 – JANUARY 30, 2021 ITEM XIA - PROCLAMATION SCHOOL CHOICE WEEK (PDF).PDF XIB. INTRODUCTION OF FIRE DEPARTMENT DEPUTY CHIEF – BRIAN MAYO AND ENGINEERS – NICHOLAS KELLERMEYER AND CHRISTIAN HANTHORN XIC. INTRODUCTION OF PARKS, RECREATION & TOURISM RECREATION CENTER MANAGER – HUGO MONTENEGRO XII. XIIA. PRESENTATION & APPROVAL OF MINUTES FROM THE DECEMBER 10, 2020 REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING ITEM XIIA - DECEMBER 10, 2020 COUNCIL MINUTES (PDF).PDF XIIB. PRESENTATION & APPROVAL OF MINUTES FROM THE DECEMBER 22, 2020 SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING ITEM XIIB - DECEMBER 22, 2020 SPECIAL COUNCIL MINUTES (PDF).PDF XIII. OLD BUSINESS XIIIA. SECOND READING OF AN ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE EAST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT; PROVIDING FOR THE FINANCING OF IMPROVEMENTS WITHIN THE IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT BY ASSESSMENTS, THE ISSUANCE OF BONDS, OR OTHER REVENUES AS HEREIN DESCRIBED; AND OTHER MATTERS RELATINGTHERETO. (2020-12-10C) PUBLIC HEARING ITEM XIIIA - MID CREATION ORDINANCE - EAST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIIA- EAST ARGENT MID (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIIA SUMMARY FOR ORDINANCE ON EAST ARGENT MID IMPROVEMENT PLAN AND FINANCING (PDF).PDF XIIIB. SECOND READING OF AN ORDINANCE APPROVING THE ASSESSMENT ROLL AND MASTER ASSESSMENT METHODOLOGY FOR THE EAST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT AND OTHER MATTERS RELATING THERETO. (2020-12- 10D) PUBLIC HEARING ITEM XIIIB - ASSESSMENT ROLL ORDINANCE - EAST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIIB - EAST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT MASTER METHODOLOGY REPORT (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIIB SUMMARY FOR ORDINANCE FOR THE MASTER ASSESSMENT METHODOLOGY AND ROLL FOR THE EAST ARGENT MID IMPROVEMENTS (PDF).PDF XIIIC. SECOND READING OF AN ORDINANCE TO ADOPT A MASTER PLAN SUBMITTAL FOR A TRACT OF LAND CONSISTING OF APPROXIMATELY +/-197 ACRES, KNOWN GENERALLY AS THE HUNT CLUB AT EAST ARGENT LOCATED OFF OF EAST ARGENT LOOP ROAD AND JASPER STATION ROAD AND TO AMEND THE OFFICIAL MAP OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE TO INDICATE THAT PORTION SUBJECT TO THE MASTER PLAN. (2020-12-10E) PUBLIC HEARING ITEM XIIIC - SUMMARY FOR HUNT CLUB MASTER PLAN (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIICD - EAST ARGENT IMPS - LOCATION MAP (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIIC - COVER ORD FOR HUNT CLUB MASTER PLAN (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIIC - HUNT CLUB MASTER PLAN (PDF).PDF XIIID. SECOND READING OF AN ORDINANCE TO ADOPT A MASTER PLAN SUBMITTAL FOR A TRACT OF LAND CONSISTING OF APPROXIMATELY +/-50.55 ACRES, KNOWN GENERALLY AS POINTE GRAND AT EAST ARGENT LOCATED OFF OF EAST ARGENT LOOP ROAD AND TO AMEND THE OFFICIAL ZONING MAP OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE TO INDICATE THAT PORTION SUBJECT TO THE MASTER PLAN. (2020-12-10F) PUBLIC HEARING ITEM XIIICD - EAST ARGENT IMPS - LOCATION MAP (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIID - COVER ORD FOR POINTE GRAND MASTER PLAN (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIID - SUMMARY FOR POINTE GRAND MASTER PLAN (PDF).PDF XIV. New Business XIVA. FIRST READING OF AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA ESTABLISHING THE EXIT 3 REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA; MAKING CERTAIN FINDINGS OF AN “AGRICULTURAL AREA” AND A “BLIGHTED AREA” WITHIN THE EXIT 3 REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA; DESIGNATING AND DEFINING REDEVELOPMENT PROJECTS CONSISTING OF PUBLIC IMPROVEMENTS WITHIN THE EXIT 3 REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA; DESIGNATING APPROPRIATE REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT COSTS; APPROVING AN OVERALL REDEVELOPMENT PLAN; AND OTHER MATTERS RELATED THERETO. (2020-11- 5A) PUBLIC HEARING ITEM XIVA - ORDINANCE-EXIT 3 REDEVELOPMENT PLANTIF (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVA - SUMMARY ORDINANCE ON EXIT 3 TIF REDEVELOPMENT PLAN (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVAB - CCL COMMENT HARDEEVILLE AGENDA IXA B EXIT 3 (PDF).PDF XIVB. FIRST READING OF AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA, AUTHORIZING AND APPROVING THE EXIT 3 IMPROVEMENT PLAN AND THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE EXIT 3 MUNICIPAL IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT; PROVIDING FOR THE FINANCING OF IMPROVEMENTS WITHIN THE EXIT 3 MUNICIPAL IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT BY ASSESSMENTS, ASSESSMENT DEBT AND OTHER FUNDS AS HEREIN DESCRIBED; AND OTHER MATTERS RELATING THERETO. (2020-11-5B) PUBLIC HEARING ITEM XIVAB - CCL COMMENT HARDEEVILLE AGENDA IXA B EXIT 3 (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVB - ORDINANCE - EXIT 3 MID (2020) (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVB - SUMMARY FOR ORDINANCE ON EXIT 3 MID IMPROVEMENT PLAN (PDF).PDF XIVC. A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA CITY COUNCIL AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO EXECUTE AN AMENDMENT TO THE MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING WITH SLF III HARDEEVILLE, LLC DATED OCTOBER 31, 2018 TO COMPLETE CONCEPT PHASE SERVICES NECESSARY FOR A NEW EXIT INTERCHANGE ON I- 95, TO BE KNOWN AS EXIT 3, AND THE RIVERPORT PROPERTY (2021-1- 7C) PUBLIC COMMENT ITEM XIVC - RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING CM TO ENTER AMENDMENT 3 (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVC - SLF COH MOU (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVC - THIRD AMENDMENT TO IGA (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVC - AGENDA SUMMARY THIRD AMENDMENT (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVC - EXIT 3 CONCEPT PROPOSAL.PDF XV. MANAGERS REPORT XVI. COUNCIL ISSUES AND CONCERNS XVII. EXECUTIVE SESSION XVIIA. DISCUSSION OF NEGOTIATIONS INCIDENT TO PROPOSED CONTRACTUAL ARRANGEMENTS AND PROPOSED SALE OR PURCHASE OF PROPERTY, THE RECEIPT OF LEGAL ADVICE WHERE LEGAL ADVICE RELATES TO A PENDING, THREATENED, OR POTENTIAL CLAIM OR OTHER MATTERS COVERED BY THE ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGE, SETTLEMENT OF LEGAL CLAIMS, OR THE POSITION OF THE PUBLIC AGENCY IN OTHER ADVERSARY SITUATIONS INVOLVING THE ASSERTION AGAINST THE AGENCY OF A CLAIM IN ACCORDANCE WITH S.C. CODE OF LAW 30-4-70(A)(2). • PROPERTY ACQUISTION COUNCIL MAY TAKE ACTION IN OPEN SESSION ON MATTERS DISCUSSED IN EXECUTIVE SESSION XVIII ADJOURNMENT Upcoming Events January 12 Annual Strategic Retreat – Latitude Margaritaville 8 A.M. January 12 Accommodations Tax Comm. Mtg – Council Chambers 10 A.M. January 13 Planning Commission Meeting – Council Chambers 10 A.M. January 21 Hardeeville City Council Meeting – Council Chambers 5 P.M. January 21 Ridgeland Town Council Meeting – Ridgeland Town Hall 6 P.M. 1. 2. 3. Documents: 4. Documents: 5. Documents: 6. 7. 7.I. Documents: 8. 9. 10. 11. 11.I. Documents: 11.II. 11.III. 12. 12.I. Documents: 12.II. Documents: 13. 13.I. Documents: 13.II. Documents: 13.III. Documents: 13.IV. Documents: 14. 14.I. Documents: 14.I.i. Documents: 14.I.i.1. Documents: 15. 16. 17. 17.I. 18. 19. City of Hardeeville Regular City Council Meeting and Public Hearings Council Chambers 205 Main Street Hardeeville, SC 29927 AGENDA JANUARY 7, 2021 5:00 PM I. INVOCATION & PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE II. CALL TO ORDER III. OATH OF OFFICE MAYOR - HARRY WILLIAMS ITEM III - OATH OF OFFICE MAYOR (ELECTED) (PDF).PDF IV. OATH OF OFFICE COUNCIL MEMBER - JOHN CARROLL ITEM IV AND V - OATH OF OFFICE COUNCIL MEMBER (ELECTED) (PDF).PDF V. OATH OF OFFICE COUNCIL MEMBER - BO WHITE ITEM IV AND V - OATH OF OFFICE COUNCIL MEMBER (ELECTED) (PDF).PDF VI. SELECTION OF MAYOR PRO TEMPORE PURSUANT TO ARTICLE IV SECTION 2-96 OF THE HARDEEVILLE CODE OF ORDINANCES VII. ELECTION OF MUNICIPAL OFFICERS AND EMPLOYEES PURSUANT TO ARTICLE IV SECTION 2-81 OF THE HARDEEVILLE CODE OF ORDINANCES VIIA. APPOINTMENT OF THE CITY ATTORNEY PURSUANT TO ARTICLE IV SECTION 2- 136 OF THE HARDEEVILLE CODE OF ORDINANCES ITEM VIIA - OATH FOR CITY ATTORNEY (PDF).PDF VIII. APPROVAL OF AGENDA IX. [RESERVED] X. PUBLIC COMMENTS (3 MINUTE TIME LIMIT) XI. PUBLIC PRESENTATIONS XIA. A PROCLAMATION COMMEMORATING THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE SCHOOL CHOICE WEEK – JANUARY 24 – JANUARY 30, 2021 ITEM XIA - PROCLAMATION SCHOOL CHOICE WEEK (PDF).PDF XIB. INTRODUCTION OF FIRE DEPARTMENT DEPUTY CHIEF – BRIAN MAYO AND ENGINEERS – NICHOLAS KELLERMEYER AND CHRISTIAN HANTHORN XIC. INTRODUCTION OF PARKS, RECREATION & TOURISM RECREATION CENTER MANAGER – HUGO MONTENEGRO XII. XIIA. PRESENTATION & APPROVAL OF MINUTES FROM THE DECEMBER 10, 2020 REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING ITEM XIIA - DECEMBER 10, 2020 COUNCIL MINUTES (PDF).PDF XIIB. PRESENTATION & APPROVAL OF MINUTES FROM THE DECEMBER 22, 2020 SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING ITEM XIIB - DECEMBER 22, 2020 SPECIAL COUNCIL MINUTES (PDF).PDF XIII. OLD BUSINESS XIIIA. SECOND READING OF AN ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE EAST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT; PROVIDING FOR THE FINANCING OF IMPROVEMENTS WITHIN THE IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT BY ASSESSMENTS, THE ISSUANCE OF BONDS, OR OTHER REVENUES AS HEREIN DESCRIBED; AND OTHER MATTERS RELATINGTHERETO. (2020-12-10C) PUBLIC HEARING ITEM XIIIA - MID CREATION ORDINANCE - EAST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIIA- EAST ARGENT MID (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIIA SUMMARY FOR ORDINANCE ON EAST ARGENT MID IMPROVEMENT PLAN AND FINANCING (PDF).PDF XIIIB. SECOND READING OF AN ORDINANCE APPROVING THE ASSESSMENT ROLL AND MASTER ASSESSMENT METHODOLOGY FOR THE EAST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT AND OTHER MATTERS RELATING THERETO. (2020-12- 10D) PUBLIC HEARING ITEM XIIIB - ASSESSMENT ROLL ORDINANCE - EAST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIIB - EAST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT MASTER METHODOLOGY REPORT (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIIB SUMMARY FOR ORDINANCE FOR THE MASTER ASSESSMENT METHODOLOGY AND ROLL FOR THE EAST ARGENT MID IMPROVEMENTS (PDF).PDF XIIIC. SECOND READING OF AN ORDINANCE TO ADOPT A MASTER PLAN SUBMITTAL FOR A TRACT OF LAND CONSISTING OF APPROXIMATELY +/-197 ACRES, KNOWN GENERALLY AS THE HUNT CLUB AT EAST ARGENT LOCATED OFF OF EAST ARGENT LOOP ROAD AND JASPER STATION ROAD AND TO AMEND THE OFFICIAL MAP OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE TO INDICATE THAT PORTION SUBJECT TO THE MASTER PLAN. (2020-12-10E) PUBLIC HEARING ITEM XIIIC - SUMMARY FOR HUNT CLUB MASTER PLAN (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIICD - EAST ARGENT IMPS - LOCATION MAP (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIIC - COVER ORD FOR HUNT CLUB MASTER PLAN (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIIC - HUNT CLUB MASTER PLAN (PDF).PDF XIIID. SECOND READING OF AN ORDINANCE TO ADOPT A MASTER PLAN SUBMITTAL FOR A TRACT OF LAND CONSISTING OF APPROXIMATELY +/-50.55 ACRES, KNOWN GENERALLY AS POINTE GRAND AT EAST ARGENT LOCATED OFF OF EAST ARGENT LOOP ROAD AND TO AMEND THE OFFICIAL ZONING MAP OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE TO INDICATE THAT PORTION SUBJECT TO THE MASTER PLAN. (2020-12-10F) PUBLIC HEARING ITEM XIIICD - EAST ARGENT IMPS - LOCATION MAP (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIID - COVER ORD FOR POINTE GRAND MASTER PLAN (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIID - SUMMARY FOR POINTE GRAND MASTER PLAN (PDF).PDF XIV. New Business XIVA. FIRST READING OF AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA ESTABLISHING THE EXIT 3 REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA; MAKING CERTAIN FINDINGS OF AN “AGRICULTURAL AREA” AND A “BLIGHTED AREA” WITHIN THE EXIT 3 REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA; DESIGNATING AND DEFINING REDEVELOPMENT PROJECTS CONSISTING OF PUBLIC IMPROVEMENTS WITHIN THE EXIT 3 REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA; DESIGNATING APPROPRIATE REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT COSTS; APPROVING AN OVERALL REDEVELOPMENT PLAN; AND OTHER MATTERS RELATED THERETO. (2020-11- 5A) PUBLIC HEARING ITEM XIVA - ORDINANCE-EXIT 3 REDEVELOPMENT PLANTIF (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVA - SUMMARY ORDINANCE ON EXIT 3 TIF REDEVELOPMENT PLAN (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVAB - CCL COMMENT HARDEEVILLE AGENDA IXA B EXIT 3 (PDF).PDF XIVB. FIRST READING OF AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA, AUTHORIZING AND APPROVING THE EXIT 3 IMPROVEMENT PLAN AND THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE EXIT 3 MUNICIPAL IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT; PROVIDING FOR THE FINANCING OF IMPROVEMENTS WITHIN THE EXIT 3 MUNICIPAL IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT BY ASSESSMENTS, ASSESSMENT DEBT AND OTHER FUNDS AS HEREIN DESCRIBED; AND OTHER MATTERS RELATING THERETO. (2020-11-5B) PUBLIC HEARING ITEM XIVAB - CCL COMMENT HARDEEVILLE AGENDA IXA B EXIT 3 (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVB - ORDINANCE - EXIT 3 MID (2020) (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVB - SUMMARY FOR ORDINANCE ON EXIT 3 MID IMPROVEMENT PLAN (PDF).PDF XIVC. A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA CITY COUNCIL AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO EXECUTE AN AMENDMENT TO THE MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING WITH SLF III HARDEEVILLE, LLC DATED OCTOBER 31, 2018 TO COMPLETE CONCEPT PHASE SERVICES NECESSARY FOR A NEW EXIT INTERCHANGE ON I- 95, TO BE KNOWN AS EXIT 3, AND THE RIVERPORT PROPERTY (2021-1- 7C) PUBLIC COMMENT ITEM XIVC - RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING CM TO ENTER AMENDMENT 3 (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVC - SLF COH MOU (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVC - THIRD AMENDMENT TO IGA (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVC - AGENDA SUMMARY THIRD AMENDMENT (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVC - EXIT 3 CONCEPT PROPOSAL.PDF XV. MANAGERS REPORT XVI. COUNCIL ISSUES AND CONCERNS XVII. EXECUTIVE SESSION XVIIA. DISCUSSION OF NEGOTIATIONS INCIDENT TO PROPOSED CONTRACTUAL ARRANGEMENTS AND PROPOSED SALE OR PURCHASE OF PROPERTY, THE RECEIPT OF LEGAL ADVICE WHERE LEGAL ADVICE RELATES TO A PENDING, THREATENED, OR POTENTIAL CLAIM OR OTHER MATTERS COVERED BY THE ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGE, SETTLEMENT OF LEGAL CLAIMS, OR THE POSITION OF THE PUBLIC AGENCY IN OTHER ADVERSARY SITUATIONS INVOLVING THE ASSERTION AGAINST THE AGENCY OF A CLAIM IN ACCORDANCE WITH S.C. CODE OF LAW 30-4-70(A)(2). • PROPERTY ACQUISTION COUNCIL MAY TAKE ACTION IN OPEN SESSION ON MATTERS DISCUSSED IN EXECUTIVE SESSION XVIII ADJOURNMENT Upcoming Events January 12 Annual Strategic Retreat – Latitude Margaritaville 8 A.M. January 12 Accommodations Tax Comm. Mtg – Council Chambers 10 A.M. January 13 Planning Commission Meeting – Council Chambers 10 A.M. January 21 Hardeeville City Council Meeting – Council Chambers 5 P.M. January 21 Ridgeland Town Council Meeting – Ridgeland Town Hall 6 P.M. 1. 2. 3. Documents: 4. Documents: 5. Documents: 6. 7. 7.I. Documents: 8. 9. 10. 11. 11.I. Documents: 11.II. 11.III. 12. 12.I. Documents: 12.II. Documents: 13. 13.I. Documents: 13.II. Documents: 13.III. Documents: 13.IV. Documents: 14. 14.I. Documents: 14.I.i. Documents: 14.I.i.1. Documents: 15. 16. 17. 17.I. 18. 19. City of Hardeeville Regular City Council Meeting and Public Hearings Council Chambers 205 Main Street Hardeeville, SC 29927 AGENDA JANUARY 7, 2021 5:00 PM I. INVOCATION & PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE II. CALL TO ORDER III. OATH OF OFFICE MAYOR - HARRY WILLIAMS ITEM III - OATH OF OFFICE MAYOR (ELECTED) (PDF).PDF IV. OATH OF OFFICE COUNCIL MEMBER - JOHN CARROLL ITEM IV AND V - OATH OF OFFICE COUNCIL MEMBER (ELECTED) (PDF).PDF V. OATH OF OFFICE COUNCIL MEMBER - BO WHITE ITEM IV AND V - OATH OF OFFICE COUNCIL MEMBER (ELECTED) (PDF).PDF VI. SELECTION OF MAYOR PRO TEMPORE PURSUANT TO ARTICLE IV SECTION 2-96 OF THE HARDEEVILLE CODE OF ORDINANCES VII. ELECTION OF MUNICIPAL OFFICERS AND EMPLOYEES PURSUANT TO ARTICLE IV SECTION 2-81 OF THE HARDEEVILLE CODE OF ORDINANCES VIIA. APPOINTMENT OF THE CITY ATTORNEY PURSUANT TO ARTICLE IV SECTION 2- 136 OF THE HARDEEVILLE CODE OF ORDINANCES ITEM VIIA - OATH FOR CITY ATTORNEY (PDF).PDF VIII. APPROVAL OF AGENDA IX. [RESERVED] X. PUBLIC COMMENTS (3 MINUTE TIME LIMIT) XI. PUBLIC PRESENTATIONS XIA. A PROCLAMATION COMMEMORATING THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE SCHOOL CHOICE WEEK – JANUARY 24 – JANUARY 30, 2021 ITEM XIA - PROCLAMATION SCHOOL CHOICE WEEK (PDF).PDF XIB. INTRODUCTION OF FIRE DEPARTMENT DEPUTY CHIEF – BRIAN MAYO AND ENGINEERS – NICHOLAS KELLERMEYER AND CHRISTIAN HANTHORN XIC. INTRODUCTION OF PARKS, RECREATION & TOURISM RECREATION CENTER MANAGER – HUGO MONTENEGRO XII. XIIA. PRESENTATION & APPROVAL OF MINUTES FROM THE DECEMBER 10, 2020 REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING ITEM XIIA - DECEMBER 10, 2020 COUNCIL MINUTES (PDF).PDF XIIB. PRESENTATION & APPROVAL OF MINUTES FROM THE DECEMBER 22, 2020 SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING ITEM XIIB - DECEMBER 22, 2020 SPECIAL COUNCIL MINUTES (PDF).PDF XIII. OLD BUSINESS XIIIA. SECOND READING OF AN ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE EAST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT; PROVIDING FOR THE FINANCING OF IMPROVEMENTS WITHIN THE IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT BY ASSESSMENTS, THE ISSUANCE OF BONDS, OR OTHER REVENUES AS HEREIN DESCRIBED; AND OTHER MATTERS RELATINGTHERETO. (2020-12-10C) PUBLIC HEARING ITEM XIIIA - MID CREATION ORDINANCE - EAST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIIA- EAST ARGENT MID (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIIA SUMMARY FOR ORDINANCE ON EAST ARGENT MID IMPROVEMENT PLAN AND FINANCING (PDF).PDF XIIIB. SECOND READING OF AN ORDINANCE APPROVING THE ASSESSMENT ROLL AND MASTER ASSESSMENT METHODOLOGY FOR THE EAST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT AND OTHER MATTERS RELATING THERETO. (2020-12- 10D) PUBLIC HEARING ITEM XIIIB - ASSESSMENT ROLL ORDINANCE - EAST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIIB - EAST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT MASTER METHODOLOGY REPORT (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIIB SUMMARY FOR ORDINANCE FOR THE MASTER ASSESSMENT METHODOLOGY AND ROLL FOR THE EAST ARGENT MID IMPROVEMENTS (PDF).PDF XIIIC. SECOND READING OF AN ORDINANCE TO ADOPT A MASTER PLAN SUBMITTAL FOR A TRACT OF LAND CONSISTING OF APPROXIMATELY +/-197 ACRES, KNOWN GENERALLY AS THE HUNT CLUB AT EAST ARGENT LOCATED OFF OF EAST ARGENT LOOP ROAD AND JASPER STATION ROAD AND TO AMEND THE OFFICIAL MAP OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE TO INDICATE THAT PORTION SUBJECT TO THE MASTER PLAN. (2020-12-10E) PUBLIC HEARING ITEM XIIIC - SUMMARY FOR HUNT CLUB MASTER PLAN (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIICD - EAST ARGENT IMPS - LOCATION MAP (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIIC - COVER ORD FOR HUNT CLUB MASTER PLAN (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIIC - HUNT CLUB MASTER PLAN (PDF).PDF XIIID. SECOND READING OF AN ORDINANCE TO ADOPT A MASTER PLAN SUBMITTAL FOR A TRACT OF LAND CONSISTING OF APPROXIMATELY +/-50.55 ACRES, KNOWN GENERALLY AS POINTE GRAND AT EAST ARGENT LOCATED OFF OF EAST ARGENT LOOP ROAD AND TO AMEND THE OFFICIAL ZONING MAP OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE TO INDICATE THAT PORTION SUBJECT TO THE MASTER PLAN. (2020-12-10F) PUBLIC HEARING ITEM XIIICD - EAST ARGENT IMPS - LOCATION MAP (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIID - COVER ORD FOR POINTE GRAND MASTER PLAN (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIID - SUMMARY FOR POINTE GRAND MASTER PLAN (PDF).PDF XIV. New Business XIVA. FIRST READING OF AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA ESTABLISHING THE EXIT 3 REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA; MAKING CERTAIN FINDINGS OF AN “AGRICULTURAL AREA” AND A “BLIGHTED AREA” WITHIN THE EXIT 3 REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA; DESIGNATING AND DEFINING REDEVELOPMENT PROJECTS CONSISTING OF PUBLIC IMPROVEMENTS WITHIN THE EXIT 3 REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA; DESIGNATING APPROPRIATE REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT COSTS; APPROVING AN OVERALL REDEVELOPMENT PLAN; AND OTHER MATTERS RELATED THERETO. (2020-11- 5A) PUBLIC HEARING ITEM XIVA - ORDINANCE-EXIT 3 REDEVELOPMENT PLANTIF (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVA - SUMMARY ORDINANCE ON EXIT 3 TIF REDEVELOPMENT PLAN (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVAB - CCL COMMENT HARDEEVILLE AGENDA IXA B EXIT 3 (PDF).PDF XIVB. FIRST READING OF AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA, AUTHORIZING AND APPROVING THE EXIT 3 IMPROVEMENT PLAN AND THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE EXIT 3 MUNICIPAL IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT; PROVIDING FOR THE FINANCING OF IMPROVEMENTS WITHIN THE EXIT 3 MUNICIPAL IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT BY ASSESSMENTS, ASSESSMENT DEBT AND OTHER FUNDS AS HEREIN DESCRIBED; AND OTHER MATTERS RELATING THERETO. (2020-11-5B) PUBLIC HEARING ITEM XIVAB - CCL COMMENT HARDEEVILLE AGENDA IXA B EXIT 3 (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVB - ORDINANCE - EXIT 3 MID (2020) (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVB - SUMMARY FOR ORDINANCE ON EXIT 3 MID IMPROVEMENT PLAN (PDF).PDF XIVC. A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA CITY COUNCIL AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO EXECUTE AN AMENDMENT TO THE MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING WITH SLF III HARDEEVILLE, LLC DATED OCTOBER 31, 2018 TO COMPLETE CONCEPT PHASE SERVICES NECESSARY FOR A NEW EXIT INTERCHANGE ON I- 95, TO BE KNOWN AS EXIT 3, AND THE RIVERPORT PROPERTY (2021-1- 7C) PUBLIC COMMENT ITEM XIVC - RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING CM TO ENTER AMENDMENT 3 (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVC - SLF COH MOU (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVC - THIRD AMENDMENT TO IGA (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVC - AGENDA SUMMARY THIRD AMENDMENT (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVC - EXIT 3 CONCEPT PROPOSAL.PDF XV. MANAGERS REPORT XVI. COUNCIL ISSUES AND CONCERNS XVII. EXECUTIVE SESSION XVIIA. DISCUSSION OF NEGOTIATIONS INCIDENT TO PROPOSED CONTRACTUAL ARRANGEMENTS AND PROPOSED SALE OR PURCHASE OF PROPERTY, THE RECEIPT OF LEGAL ADVICE WHERE LEGAL ADVICE RELATES TO A PENDING, THREATENED, OR POTENTIAL CLAIM OR OTHER MATTERS COVERED BY THE ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGE, SETTLEMENT OF LEGAL CLAIMS, OR THE POSITION OF THE PUBLIC AGENCY IN OTHER ADVERSARY SITUATIONS INVOLVING THE ASSERTION AGAINST THE AGENCY OF A CLAIM IN ACCORDANCE WITH S.C. CODE OF LAW 30-4-70(A)(2). • PROPERTY ACQUISTION COUNCIL MAY TAKE ACTION IN OPEN SESSION ON MATTERS DISCUSSED IN EXECUTIVE SESSION XVIII ADJOURNMENT Upcoming Events January 12 Annual Strategic Retreat – Latitude Margaritaville 8 A.M. January 12 Accommodations Tax Comm. Mtg – Council Chambers 10 A.M. January 13 Planning Commission Meeting – Council Chambers 10 A.M. January 21 Hardeeville City Council Meeting – Council Chambers 5 P.M. January 21 Ridgeland Town Council Meeting – Ridgeland Town Hall 6 P.M. 1. 2. 3. Documents: 4. Documents: 5. Documents: 6. 7. 7.I. Documents: 8. 9. 10. 11. 11.I. Documents: 11.II. 11.III. 12. 12.I. Documents: 12.II. Documents: 13. 13.I. Documents: 13.II. Documents: 13.III. Documents: 13.IV. Documents: 14. 14.I. Documents: 14.I.i. Documents: 14.I.i.1. Documents: 15. 16. 17. 17.I. 18. 19. City of Hardeeville Regular City Council Meeting and Public Hearings Council Chambers 205 Main Street Hardeeville, SC 29927 AGENDA JANUARY 7, 2021 5:00 PM I. INVOCATION & PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE II. CALL TO ORDER III. OATH OF OFFICE MAYOR - HARRY WILLIAMS ITEM III - OATH OF OFFICE MAYOR (ELECTED) (PDF).PDF IV. OATH OF OFFICE COUNCIL MEMBER - JOHN CARROLL ITEM IV AND V - OATH OF OFFICE COUNCIL MEMBER (ELECTED) (PDF).PDF V. OATH OF OFFICE COUNCIL MEMBER - BO WHITE ITEM IV AND V - OATH OF OFFICE COUNCIL MEMBER (ELECTED) (PDF).PDF VI. SELECTION OF MAYOR PRO TEMPORE PURSUANT TO ARTICLE IV SECTION 2-96 OF THE HARDEEVILLE CODE OF ORDINANCES VII. ELECTION OF MUNICIPAL OFFICERS AND EMPLOYEES PURSUANT TO ARTICLE IV SECTION 2-81 OF THE HARDEEVILLE CODE OF ORDINANCES VIIA. APPOINTMENT OF THE CITY ATTORNEY PURSUANT TO ARTICLE IV SECTION 2- 136 OF THE HARDEEVILLE CODE OF ORDINANCES ITEM VIIA - OATH FOR CITY ATTORNEY (PDF).PDF VIII. APPROVAL OF AGENDA IX. [RESERVED] X. PUBLIC COMMENTS (3 MINUTE TIME LIMIT) XI. PUBLIC PRESENTATIONS XIA. A PROCLAMATION COMMEMORATING THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE SCHOOL CHOICE WEEK – JANUARY 24 – JANUARY 30, 2021 ITEM XIA - PROCLAMATION SCHOOL CHOICE WEEK (PDF).PDF XIB. INTRODUCTION OF FIRE DEPARTMENT DEPUTY CHIEF – BRIAN MAYO AND ENGINEERS – NICHOLAS KELLERMEYER AND CHRISTIAN HANTHORN XIC. INTRODUCTION OF PARKS, RECREATION & TOURISM RECREATION CENTER MANAGER – HUGO MONTENEGRO XII. XIIA. PRESENTATION & APPROVAL OF MINUTES FROM THE DECEMBER 10, 2020 REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING ITEM XIIA - DECEMBER 10, 2020 COUNCIL MINUTES (PDF).PDF XIIB. PRESENTATION & APPROVAL OF MINUTES FROM THE DECEMBER 22, 2020 SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING ITEM XIIB - DECEMBER 22, 2020 SPECIAL COUNCIL MINUTES (PDF).PDF XIII. OLD BUSINESS XIIIA. SECOND READING OF AN ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE EAST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT; PROVIDING FOR THE FINANCING OF IMPROVEMENTS WITHIN THE IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT BY ASSESSMENTS, THE ISSUANCE OF BONDS, OR OTHER REVENUES AS HEREIN DESCRIBED; AND OTHER MATTERS RELATINGTHERETO. (2020-12-10C) PUBLIC HEARING ITEM XIIIA - MID CREATION ORDINANCE - EAST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIIA- EAST ARGENT MID (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIIA SUMMARY FOR ORDINANCE ON EAST ARGENT MID IMPROVEMENT PLAN AND FINANCING (PDF).PDF XIIIB. SECOND READING OF AN ORDINANCE APPROVING THE ASSESSMENT ROLL AND MASTER ASSESSMENT METHODOLOGY FOR THE EAST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT AND OTHER MATTERS RELATING THERETO. (2020-12- 10D) PUBLIC HEARING ITEM XIIIB - ASSESSMENT ROLL ORDINANCE - EAST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIIB - EAST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT MASTER METHODOLOGY REPORT (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIIB SUMMARY FOR ORDINANCE FOR THE MASTER ASSESSMENT METHODOLOGY AND ROLL FOR THE EAST ARGENT MID IMPROVEMENTS (PDF).PDF XIIIC. SECOND READING OF AN ORDINANCE TO ADOPT A MASTER PLAN SUBMITTAL FOR A TRACT OF LAND CONSISTING OF APPROXIMATELY +/-197 ACRES, KNOWN GENERALLY AS THE HUNT CLUB AT EAST ARGENT LOCATED OFF OF EAST ARGENT LOOP ROAD AND JASPER STATION ROAD AND TO AMEND THE OFFICIAL MAP OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE TO INDICATE THAT PORTION SUBJECT TO THE MASTER PLAN. (2020-12-10E) PUBLIC HEARING ITEM XIIIC - SUMMARY FOR HUNT CLUB MASTER PLAN (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIICD - EAST ARGENT IMPS - LOCATION MAP (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIIC - COVER ORD FOR HUNT CLUB MASTER PLAN (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIIC - HUNT CLUB MASTER PLAN (PDF).PDF XIIID. SECOND READING OF AN ORDINANCE TO ADOPT A MASTER PLAN SUBMITTAL FOR A TRACT OF LAND CONSISTING OF APPROXIMATELY +/-50.55 ACRES, KNOWN GENERALLY AS POINTE GRAND AT EAST ARGENT LOCATED OFF OF EAST ARGENT LOOP ROAD AND TO AMEND THE OFFICIAL ZONING MAP OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE TO INDICATE THAT PORTION SUBJECT TO THE MASTER PLAN. (2020-12-10F) PUBLIC HEARING ITEM XIIICD - EAST ARGENT IMPS - LOCATION MAP (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIID - COVER ORD FOR POINTE GRAND MASTER PLAN (PDF).PDF ITEM XIIID - SUMMARY FOR POINTE GRAND MASTER PLAN (PDF).PDF XIV. New Business XIVA. FIRST READING OF AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA ESTABLISHING THE EXIT 3 REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA; MAKING CERTAIN FINDINGS OF AN “AGRICULTURAL AREA” AND A “BLIGHTED AREA” WITHIN THE EXIT 3 REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA; DESIGNATING AND DEFINING REDEVELOPMENT PROJECTS CONSISTING OF PUBLIC IMPROVEMENTS WITHIN THE EXIT 3 REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA; DESIGNATING APPROPRIATE REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT COSTS; APPROVING AN OVERALL REDEVELOPMENT PLAN; AND OTHER MATTERS RELATED THERETO. (2020-11- 5A) PUBLIC HEARING ITEM XIVA - ORDINANCE-EXIT 3 REDEVELOPMENT PLANTIF (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVA - SUMMARY ORDINANCE ON EXIT 3 TIF REDEVELOPMENT PLAN (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVAB - CCL COMMENT HARDEEVILLE AGENDA IXA B EXIT 3 (PDF).PDF XIVB. FIRST READING OF AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA, AUTHORIZING AND APPROVING THE EXIT 3 IMPROVEMENT PLAN AND THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE EXIT 3 MUNICIPAL IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT; PROVIDING FOR THE FINANCING OF IMPROVEMENTS WITHIN THE EXIT 3 MUNICIPAL IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT BY ASSESSMENTS, ASSESSMENT DEBT AND OTHER FUNDS AS HEREIN DESCRIBED; AND OTHER MATTERS RELATING THERETO. (2020-11-5B) PUBLIC HEARING ITEM XIVAB - CCL COMMENT HARDEEVILLE AGENDA IXA B EXIT 3 (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVB - ORDINANCE - EXIT 3 MID (2020) (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVB - SUMMARY FOR ORDINANCE ON EXIT 3 MID IMPROVEMENT PLAN (PDF).PDF XIVC. A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA CITY COUNCIL AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO EXECUTE AN AMENDMENT TO THE MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING WITH SLF III HARDEEVILLE, LLC DATED OCTOBER 31, 2018 TO COMPLETE CONCEPT PHASE SERVICES NECESSARY FOR A NEW EXIT INTERCHANGE ON I- 95, TO BE KNOWN AS EXIT 3, AND THE RIVERPORT PROPERTY (2021-1- 7C) PUBLIC COMMENT ITEM XIVC - RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING CM TO ENTER AMENDMENT 3 (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVC - SLF COH MOU (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVC - THIRD AMENDMENT TO IGA (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVC - AGENDA SUMMARY THIRD AMENDMENT (PDF).PDF ITEM XIVC - EXIT 3 CONCEPT PROPOSAL.PDF XV. MANAGERS REPORT XVI. COUNCIL ISSUES AND CONCERNS XVII. EXECUTIVE SESSION XVIIA. DISCUSSION OF NEGOTIATIONS INCIDENT TO PROPOSED CONTRACTUAL ARRANGEMENTS AND PROPOSED SALE OR PURCHASE OF PROPERTY, THE RECEIPT OF LEGAL ADVICE WHERE LEGAL ADVICE RELATES TO A PENDING, THREATENED, OR POTENTIAL CLAIM OR OTHER MATTERS COVERED BY THE ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGE, SETTLEMENT OF LEGAL CLAIMS, OR THE POSITION OF THE PUBLIC AGENCY IN OTHER ADVERSARY SITUATIONS INVOLVING THE ASSERTION AGAINST THE AGENCY OF A CLAIM IN ACCORDANCE WITH S.C. CODE OF LAW 30-4-70(A)(2). • PROPERTY ACQUISTION COUNCIL MAY TAKE ACTION IN OPEN SESSION ON MATTERS DISCUSSED IN EXECUTIVE SESSION XVIII ADJOURNMENT Upcoming Events January 12 Annual Strategic Retreat – Latitude Margaritaville 8 A.M. January 12 Accommodations Tax Comm. Mtg – Council Chambers 10 A.M. January 13 Planning Commission Meeting – Council Chambers 10 A.M. January 21 Hardeeville City Council Meeting – Council Chambers 5 P.M. January 21 Ridgeland Town Council Meeting – Ridgeland Town Hall 6 P.M. 1. 2. 3. Documents: 4. Documents: 5. Documents: 6. 7. 7.I. Documents: 8. 9. 10. 11. 11.I. Documents: 11.II. 11.III. 12. 12.I. Documents: 12.II. Documents: 13. 13.I. Documents: 13.II. Documents: 13.III. Documents: 13.IV. Documents: 14. 14.I. Documents: 14.I.i. Documents: 14.I.i.1. Documents: 15. 16. 17. 17.I. 18. 19. Oath of Office For Elected Officials City of Hardeeville South Carolina “I do solemnly swear that I am duly qualified, according to the Constitution of this State, to exercise the duties of the office to which I have been elected and that I will, to th e best of my ability, discharge the duties thereof, and preserve, protect, and defend the Constitution of this State and of the United States. So help me God.” As Mayor of the City of Hardeeville, I will equally, fairly, and impartially, to the best of my ability, and skill, exercise the trust reposed in me, and will use my best endeavor to preserve the peace and carry into effect according to law the purposes for which I have been elected, so help me God. Signature: ______________________________ Date: ________________ Printed Name: ___Harry Williams_______ Attest:_________________________________ Date: _________________ City Manager Michael Czymbor Attest__________________________________ Date:_________________ City Clerk Dolores Pomarico (Seal) Oath of Office For Elected Officials City of Hardeeville South Carolina “I do solemnly swear that I am duly qualified, according to the Constitution of this State, to exercise the duties of the office to which I have been elected and that I will, to the best of my ability, discharge the duties thereof, and preserve, protect, and defend the Constitution of this State and of the United States. So help me God.” As Councilman of the City of Hardeeville, I will equally, fairly, and impartially, to the bes t of my ability, and skill, exercise the trust reposed in me, and will use my best endeavor to preserve the peace and carry into effect according to law the purposes for which I have been elected, so help me God. Signature: ______________________ Date:_________________ Printed Name: Bo White Attest:___________________________ Date:_________________ City Manager Michael Czymbor Attest:_________________________ Date:_________________ City Clerk Dolores Pomarico (Seal) Oath of Office For Elected Officials City of Hardeeville South Carolina “I do solemnly swear that I am duly qualified, according to the Constitution of this State, to exercise the duties of the office to which I have been elected and that I will, to the best of my ability, discharge the duties thereof, and preserve, protect, and defend the Constitution of this State and of the United States. So help me God.” As Councilman of the City of Hardeeville, I will equally, fairly, and impartially, to the bes t of my ability, and skill, exercise the trust reposed in me, and will use my best endeavor to preserve the peace and carry into effect according to law the purposes for which I have been elected, so help me God. Signature: ______________________ Date:_________________ Printed Name: Bo White Attest:___________________________ Date:_________________ City Manager Michael Czymbor Attest:_________________________ Date:_________________ City Clerk Dolores Pomarico (Seal) Oath for City Attorney City of Hardeeville South Carolina I, Prina Maines, do solemnly swear that I will fulfill the duties of the City Attorney of the City of Hardeeville to the best of my abilities and uphold the Constitution of the United States so help me God. Signature: __________________________ Date: __________________________ Printed Name: ____Prina Maines________ Attest: _____________________________ Date: __________________________ City Manager Michael J. Czymbor Attest: _____________________________ Date: __________________________ City Clerk Dolores Pomarico (Seal) A Proclamation Commemorating City of Hardeeville School Choice Week WHEREAS, all children in Hardeeville should have access to the highest-quality education possible; and, WHEREAS, Hardeeville recognizes the important role that an effective education plays in preparing all students in Hardeeville to be successful adults; and, WHEREAS, quality education is critically important to the economic vitality of Hardeeville; and, WHEREAS, Hardeeville is home to a multitude of high quality public and nonpublic schools from which parents can choose for their children, in addition to families who educate their children in the home; and WHEREAS, educational variety not only helps to diversify our economy, but also enhances the vibrancy of our community; and, WHEREAS, Hardeeville has many high-quality teaching professionals in all types of school settings who are committed to educating our children; and, WHEREAS, School Choice Week is celebrated across the country by millions of students, parents, educators, schools and organizations to raise awareness of the need for effective educational options; NOW, THEREFORE, I, Harry Williams do hereby recognize January 24 – 30, 2021 as Hardeeville School Choice Week, and I call this observance to the attention of all of our citizens. In witness thereof, I have hereunto set my hand this 7th day of January 2021 _________________________________________ Harry Williams Mayor, City of Hardeeville City of Hardeeville Regular City Council Minutes December 10, 2020 Page 1 of 12 CITY OF HARDEEVILLE REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARINGS MINUTES DECEMBER 10, 2020 5:00 PM VIRTUAL Present: Mayor Harry Williams, Mayor Pro Tem Carolyn Kassel, Council Members John Carroll, David Spisso, and Bo White, City Manager Michael Czymbor, Deputy City Manager Matt Davis, City Attorney Prina Maines, Police Chief Sam Woodward, Fire Chief Steve Cam p, Manager of Information Systems TJ Hubbard, Parks, Recreation, & Tourism Director Jennifer Combs, Media Specialist Imelda Golden, Media Technician Shantez Herrington I. INVOCATION & PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE Council Member White gave the invocation. II. CALL TO ORDER Mayor Williams called the meeting to order at 5:00 p.m. III. APPROVAL OF AGENDA A motion was made by Council Member Carroll to approve the agenda. The motion received a proper second by Council Member Spisso and carried unanimously. IV. [RESERVED] V. PUBLIC COMMENTS (3 MINUTE TIME LIMIT) Mayor Williams read a letter submitted by Tedd Moyd. “To the Mayor and Council, I reviewed your agenda for tonight’s meeting, and I am a little disturbed by all of the agenda items for public input. With this being a virtual meeting, it does not give the residents a fair shot at asking questions on all the items that need to be voted on. I am appalled that the mayor and agenda setting committee would have such an extensive agenda of this magnit ude and it looks like the citizens input does not matter. There are a lot of important decisions that are going to be voted on tonight and you all have truly dismissed us altogether. These issues involve our tax dollars and there will be no voice from the public but if you all feel good about your decisions tonight to have all of these items being voted on then I know where we as citizens of the City of Hardeeville stands. Nowhere and that is not a very good thing for residents.” City of Hardeeville Regular City Council Minutes December 10, 2020 Page 2 of 12 Mayor Williams thanked Mr. Moyd for his comments. VI. PUBLIC PRESENTATIONS A. ACCEPTANCE OF CITY OF HARDEEVILLE AUDIT REPORT OF FISCAL YEAR 2020 FINANCIAL STATEMENTS/AUDIT – TREY SCOTT PUBLIC COMMENT Mauldin & Jenkin representative Trey Scott stated the City’s financial statements present fairly as of June 30, 2020. Within the general fund, the City reported almost thirteen million dollars ($13M) in revenues and almost seventeen million dollars ($17M) in expenditures with a fund balance of approximately ten million dollars ($10M). Mayor Pro Tem Kassel asked Mr. Scott to explain the material deficiency referenced in the audit. Mr. Scott responded anytime an auditor finds something it is brought to management’s attention. Dependent upon the significance of the adjustment, auditing sta ndards determine whether or not the finding can be reported as a significant deficiency, a management point, or a material weakness. Some of the adjustments that are required to be posted were significant enough to be considered material weakness. Mr. Scott stated he believes this finding was a culmination of three (3) things and he does not anticipate this being an issue going forward. Council Member White asked City Manager Czymbor and Finance Director Boyle if Council could be updated on an action plan within the next ninety (90) days. A motion was made by Council Member Carroll to adopt the audit. The motion received a proper second by Mayor Pro Tem Kassel and carried unanimously. VII. A. PRESENTATION & APPROVAL OF MINUTES FROM THE NOVEMBER 19, 2020 REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Kassel to approve the November 19, 2020 Regular City Council Meeting Minutes . The motion received a proper second by Council Member Carroll and carried unanimously. VIII. OLD BUSINESS A. SECOND READING OF AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND SECTION 2 -51(a), MEETINGS, OF THE HARDEEVILLE CODE OF ORDINANCES, FOR THE PURPOSE OF CHANGING THE TIME OF THE REGULAR MEETING (2020-11-19C) PUBLIC HEARING City Manager Michael Czymbor stated staff is recommending adoption. City of Hardeeville Regular City Council Minutes December 10, 2020 Page 3 of 12 Mayor Williams asked for public comment. There was no public comment. A motion was made by Council Member Spisso to approve Ordinance 2020-11-19C at second reading. The motion received a proper second by Mayor Pro Tem Kassel and carried unanimously. B. SECOND READING OF AN ORDINANCE TO ADOPT THE WHYTE HARDEE BLVD MASTER PLAN INCLUDING IMPLEMENTATION MATRIX (2020-11-19D) PUBLIC HEARING Mayor Williams asked for public comment. There was no public comment. A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Kassel to approve Ordinance 2020-11-19D at second reading. The motion received a proper second by Council Member Carrol l and carried unanimously. IX. NEW BUSINESS A. FIRST READING OF AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA ESTABLISHING THE EXIT 3 REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA; MAKING CERTAIN FINDINGS OF AN “AGRICULTURAL AREA” AND A “BLIGHTED AR EA” WITHIN THE EXIT 3 REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA; DESIGNATING AND DEFINING REDEVELOPMENT PROJECTS CONSISTING OF PUBLIC IMPROVEMENTS WITHIN THE EXIT 3 REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA; DESIGNATING APPROPRIATE REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT COSTS; APPROVING AN OVERALL REDE VELOPMENT PLAN; AND OTHER MATTERS RELATED THERETO (2020-11-5A) PUBLIC HEARING Mayor Williams stated the City does not have all of the necessary information to proceed with this item. Mayor Williams asked for public comment. There was no public comment. City of Hardeeville Regular City Council Minutes December 10, 2020 Page 4 of 12 A motion was made by Council Member Carroll to table Ordinance 2020- 11-5A until January 7, 2021. The motion received a proper second by Mayor Pro Tem Kassel and carried unanimously. B. FIRST READING OF AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA, AUTHORIZING AND APPROVING THE EXIT 3 IMPROVEMENT PLAN AND THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE EXIT 3 MUNICIPAL IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT; PROVIDING FOR THE FINANCING OF IMPROVEMENTS WITHIN THE EXIT 3 MUNICIPAL IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT BY ASSESSMENTS, ASSESSMENT DEBT AND OTHER FUNDS AS HEREIN DESCRIBED; AND OTHER MATTERS RELATING THERETO (2020-11-5B) PUBLIC HEARING Mayor Williams stated the City does not have all of the necessary information to proceed with this item. Mayor Williams asked for public comment. There was no public comment. A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Kassel to table Ordinance 2020-11-5B until January 7, 2021. The motion received a proper second by Council Member Carroll and carried unanimously. C. FIRST READING OF AN ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE EAST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT; PROVIDING FOR THE FINANCING OF IMPROVEMENTS WITHIN THE IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT BY ASSESSMENTS, THE ISSUANCE OF BONDS, OR OTHER REVENUES AS HEREIN DESCRIBED; AND OTHER MATTERS REL ATING THERETO. (2020-12-10C) PUBLIC HEARING City Manager Czymbor stated this is a request by the developer to special assess their property for proposed municipal improvements per South Carolina law. Phillip Hunt gave a brief PowerPoint presentation. There are nine (9) properties to be assessed for improvements. In total, t here are one thousand two hundred seven (1,207) proposed residential units and three hundred twelve thousand nine hundred (312,900) proposed commercial square feet. The proposed infrastructure improvements include roads, water, sewer, and stormwater totaling fourteen million seven hundred thirty- eight thousand seven hundred twenty- five dollars ($14,738,725). City of Hardeeville Regular City Council Minutes December 10, 2020 Page 5 of 12 Mayor Pro Tem Kassel commented that this Municipal Improvement District (MID) has no impact on the borrowing power of the City. Mayor Williams stated he is concerned that the City does not have a n established limit on the amount of MID loans the City is taking. Mayor Williams com mented that he has heard many numbers regarding this MID and asked what the true amount is. Mr. Hunt responded they will be borrowing eleven or twelve million ($11-12M) and netting approximately eight point five or nine million ($8.5-9M) in the construction fund. The landowner, not the City, is the obligor on the debt. City Manager Czymbor stated he will work with City Attorney Maines to develop a proposed policy regarding issuance of debt using MIDs. Mayor Williams stated he is concerned about the density of homes in the two hundred sixty (260) acres. City Manager Czymbor responded that is a calculation for the MID, it does not represent the land use or density. Mayor Williams asked for public comment. There was no public comment. A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Kassel to approve Ordinance 2020- 12-10C at first reading. The motion received a proper second by Council Member Spisso and carried unanimously. D. FIRST READING OF AN ORDINANCE APPROVING THE ASSESSMENT ROLL AND MASTER ASSESSMENT METHODOLOGY FOR THE EAST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT AND OTHER MATTERS RELATING THERETO. (2020-12-10D) PUBLIC HEARING City Manager Michael Czymbor stated this is the methodology to describe the proposed improvement and how each property is apportioned the cost for their benefit. Mayor Williams asked for public comment. There was no public comment. A motion was made by Council Member Spisso to approve Ordinance 2020-12-10D at first reading. The motion received a proper second by Mayor Pro Tem Kassel and carried unanimously. E. FIRST READING OF AN ORDINANCE TO ADOPT A MASTER PLAN SUBMITTAL FOR A TRACT OF LAND CONSISTING OF APPROXIMATELY +/- 197 ACRES, KNOWN GENERALLY AS THE HUNT CLUB AT EAST ARGENT City of Hardeeville Regular City Council Minutes December 10, 2020 Page 6 of 12 LOCATED OFF OF EAST ARGENT LOOP ROAD AND JASPER STATION ROAD AND TO AMEND THE OFFIC IAL MAP OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE TO INDICATE THAT PORTION SUBJECT TO THE MASTER PLAN. (2020-12-10E) PUBLIC HEARING Planning Manager Katie Woodruff gave a brief PowerPoint presentation. This project is proposed to be a single-family residential development; the site is currently vacant and undeveloped. It is a five hundred (500) unit and the project site is a total of one hundred ninety- seven (197) acre s located in the East Argent Planned Development District (PDD). There are access points off both East Argent Parkway and Jasper Station Rd. There is a self -imposed fifty-foot (50’) buffer from East Argent Parkway that is not required in the PDD, but the developer has offered that as part of their application. The overa ll open space provided is thirty- six percent (36%) ; the PDD only requires ten percent (10%) . A community trail as well as sidewalks will be provided throughout the property and the amenities site will consist of a clubhouse, pool, fitness facility and othe r potential amenities. Planning Commission and staff are recommending approval. Rusty Windsor, Thomas and Hutton representative, stated this is a M aster Plan within an overall PDD. As part of that, the declarant put some of this property in a conservation easement. A portion of that was dedicated to the City for various uses. Overall, this community will have other forms of recreation. Mayor Pro Tem Kassel asked how the residents will get their mail. Mr. Windsor responded twenty- unit mail kiosks will be placed within the community. Mayor Williams asked if this will be a gated community; Mr. Windsor responded no. Mayor Williams asked if this property will ha ve full access to Jasper Station Road; Mr. Windsor responded yes. Mayor Williams stated the roads are not very wide and he is concerned about the traffic. Planning Manager Woodruff responded during Staff Review Committee (SRC) the applicant will be require d to work with staff and SC DOT on improvements for roads. The City collects developer fees which will go towards any improvements that need to be made. Mayor Williams asked for public comment. John Kemp commented via the Facebook live stream, “Is ther e any accommodation for a voting precinct.” City Manager Czymbor stated the City can communicate with the County and the supervisor of elections to work out a deal to use a facility in the East Argent area to utilize as a poll place. A motion was made by Council Member Carroll to approve Ordinance 2020-12-10E at first reading. The motion received a proper second by Mayor Pro Tem Kassel and carried unanimously. City of Hardeeville Regular City Council Minutes December 10, 2020 Page 7 of 12 F. FIRST READING OF AN ORDINANCE TO ADOPT A MASTER PLAN SUBMITTAL FOR A TRACT OF LAND CONSISTING OF APPROXIMATELY +/- 50.55 ACRES, KNOWN GENERALLY AS POINTE GRAND AT EAST ARGENT LOCATED OFF OF EAST ARGENT LOOP ROAD AND TO AMEND THE OFFICIAL ZONING MAP OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE TO INDICATE THAT PORTION SUBJECT TO THE MASTER PLAN. (2020-12-10F) PUBLIC HEARING Planning Manager Woodruff gave a brief PowerPoint presentation. In summary, the project site is located off East Argent Parkway and is proposed to be a multi-family residential development; the site is currently vacant and undeveloped. T his is a three hundred twelve (312) unit, multi -family development and is part of the East Argent PDD. The property is surrounded by freshwater wetlands and there is a wetlands buffer. The overall open space is fifty -three percent (53%) and the active open space is six-point three percent (6.3%). The applicant is proposing a minimum of fifty-foot (50’) buffer from East Argent Parkway. A community trail as well as sidewalks will be provided throughout the site; the plan also provides a park site and a separate amenities site. Planning Commission and staff are recommending adoption. Mayor Pro Tem Kassel asked if the apartments are income based , how large the apartments are, and what they cost per month for rent. Marcus Wiedower, Highpoint LLC representative, responded the apartments are two-bedroom two-bathroom units. They are not low income, but they are affordable. Mayor Pro Tem Kassel asked if the utilities will be included in the rent. Mr. Wiedower responded yes. Mayor Williams asked what the plans are for getting a traffic light approved in the area where the project is going. Planning Director Brana Snowden responded a traffic study has already been done and staff will continue to work with SC DOT to ensure the appropriate light is put in as needed. Mayor Williams asked for public comment. There was no public comment. A motion was made by Council Member Spisso to approve Ordinance 2020-12-10F at first reading. The motion received a proper second by Council Member Carroll and carried unanimously. G. A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA, CITY COUNCIL AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR TO EXECUTE AN AMENDMENT TO THE EMPLOYMENT CONTRACT WITH MICHAEL CZYMBOR. ( 2020-12-10G) PUBLIC COMMENT City Manager Czymbor thanked Council for their suppor t; he is looking forward to a prosperous 2021. City of Hardeeville Regular City Council Minutes December 10, 2020 Page 8 of 12 Council Member White commented he would like to see critical milestone updates. Mayor Williams asked for public comment. Greg Padgett commented via the Facebook livestream video, “no more than a ten (10) year extension.” A motion was made by Council Member Carroll to approve Resolution 2020- 12-10G. The motion received a proper second by Council Member White and carried unanimously. H. A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA, CITY COUNCIL, AUTHORIZING THE ACQUISITION OF CERTAIN PROPERTY BY THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE IN THE AMOUNT OF NOT EXCEEDING $120,000.00; THE EXECUTION AND DELIVERY OF CERTAIN INSTRUMENTS; AND OTHER MATTERS RELATING THERETO. (2020-12-10H) PUBLIC COMMENT City Manager Czymbor stated as part of the annual budget process we have a Capital Improvement Plan that includes vehicle purchases. This R esolution would authorize the purchasing of two (2) vehicles for the Police Department. Police Chief Woodward stated bids were obtained from three (3) vendors; O.C. Welch submitted the best bid. Mayor Williams asked for public comment. There was no public comment. A motion was made by Mayor Williams to approve Resolution 2020- 12-10H. The motion received a proper second by Council Member Carroll and carried unanimously. I. A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA, CITY COUNCIL AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO ENTER AGREEMENTS AS NECESSARY TO INVEST AVAILABLE FUNDS. (2020-12-10I) PUBLIC COMMENT Finance Director Boyle stated South Carolina law dictates what the City can invest in and by law, they can only invest in certain things. For returns, the City has invested a substantial portion of its funds with the Local Government Investment Pool (LGIP), which is run by the State Treasurer’s Office. Director Boyle stated he did some research and found that LGIP does not have the best returns. This R esolution would allow City Manager Czymbor to enter into agreements to invest funds and improve the returns that the City does have. Council Member Spisso asked what the difference is in the interest rates. Director Boyle responded approximately twenty-eight (28) basis points. City of Hardeeville Regular City Council Minutes December 10, 2020 Page 9 of 12 Council Member White asked if there is any increased risk that has to be balanced against the returns. Director Boyle responded these are secure investments and anything the City invests in is collateralized at one hundred two percent (102%). Mayor Williams asked for public comment. There was no public comment. A motion was made by Council Member Spisso to approve Resolution 2020- 12-10I. The motion received a proper second by Council Member Carroll and carried unanimously. J. A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE APPROVING THE EXTENSION OF AN INTERGOVERNMENTAL AGREEMENT WITH JASPER COUNTY FOR THE PROVISOS OF AUTOMATIC AID AND MUTUAL AID TO THE HARDEEVILLE RURAL DISTRICT AREA AND A PORTION OF THE CURRENT CITY OF HARDEEVILLE LIMITS. (2020-12-10J) PUBLIC COMMENT City Manager Czymbor stated the City entered into a six (6) month agreement with Jasper County earlier this year , that agreement expires December 2020. Staff is recommending entering into a one (1) year agreement with Jasper County for the Hardeeville rural area. City Manager Czymbor spoke with County Administrator Andy Fulghum and Mr. Fulghum concurs with the one (1) year agreement. Fire Chief Camp stated in this calendar year, the Fire Department has received five hundred thirty- two automatic aid requests. Hardeeville Fire Department (HFD) has given automatic aid to Jasper County seven (7) times and Jasper County has given HFD automatic aid twelve (12) times. HFD helped Jasper County with mutual aid thirteen (13) times and Jasper County helped HFD seven (7) times. Mayor Williams commented that he hopes there is an objective analysis as to what the benefit is to have two (2) fire stations point eight (.8) miles apart from each other. Mayor Williams asked for public comment. There was no public comment. A motion was made by Council Member Carroll to approve Resolution 2020- 12-10J. The motion received a proper second by Council Member White and carried unanimously. K. A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA, CITY COUNCIL EXECUTING A SUPPLEMENTAL INTERGOVERNMENTAL AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE COUNTY OF JASPER AND THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE REGARDING CONTRACTING FOR IMPROVEMENTS TO BE City of Hardeeville Regular City Council Minutes December 10, 2020 Page 10 of 12 PAID OUT OF THE LOCAL OPTION SALES TAX REFERENDUM OF 2016 FOR INFRASTRUCTURE IMPROVEMENTS FOR THE HARDEEVILLE COMMERCE PARK AND AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR TO EXECUTE THE AGREEMENT ON BEHALF OF THE CITY. (2020-12-10K) PUBLIC COMMENT City Manager Czymbor stated the City initially had approval of one million dollars ($1M) for limited scope of improvements to the Commerce Park. This new request takes into account the completion of the four point five million dollar ($4.5M) project. The City is asking the County to increase the I ntergovernmental Agreement (IGA) from one million ($1M) to one million , six hundred fifty thousand ($1,650,000); we also have many other funding partners as well as a significant contribution from the City. Jasper County prepared and approved the proposed amendment. Mayor Williams asked what the additional six hundred fifty thousand dollars ($650,000) is for. City Manager Czymbor responded the initial project scope was only a portion of the proposed project; after grant funds this is the remaining amount. Mayor Williams asked for public comment. There was no public comment. A motion was made by Council Member Carroll to approve Resolution 2020- 12-10K. The motion received a proper second by Council Member White and carried unanimously. L. A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE TO ENTER INTO AN INTERGOVERNMENTAL AGREEMENT WITH JASPER COUNTY TO PROVIDE FOR FIRE SERVICES WITHIN AN AREA THAT WAS ANNEXED, SPECIFICALLY A TEN-ACRE PARCEL (TMS NO.067 -00-02-003), WHICH WAS PREVIOUSLY PART OF THE CHERRY POINT FIRE DISTRICT. (2020-12-10L) PUBLIC COMMENT City Manager Czymbor stated Pulte Corporation purchased ten (10) acres as part of their last phase and they applied for annexation which was approved by Council. Jasper County notified the City that those ten (10) acres was serviced by the Cherry Point Fire District . State law requires once property is annexed from a special district to a municipal corporation the County and the City must negotiate terms of who is providing service. This Resolution would allow the City to enter into an IGA with Jasper County in which the City would pay Jasper County and the Cherry Point Fire District for three (3) years their Cherry Point millage as consideration for the removal of that parcel. Mayor Pro Tem Kassel stated Council does not understand why this is being done , but this is the best place we can be at this point. City of Hardeeville Regular City Council Minutes December 10, 2020 Page 11 of 12 Mayor Williams asked for public comment. There was no public comment. A motion was made by Council Member Carroll to approve Resolution 2020- 12-10L. The motion received a proper second by Spisso and carried unanimously. M. APPROVAL OF 2021 REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATES PUBLIC COMMENT Mayor Williams asked for public comment. There was no public comment. A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Kassel to approve the 2021 Regular City Council meeting dates. The motion received a proper second by Council Member Carroll and carried unanimously. X. MANAGERS REPORT City Manager Michael Czymbor thanked t he Council and the public as this was a long meeting; he also thanked MIS Manager T.J. Hubbard, Media Specialist Mel Golden, and Media Technician Shantez Herrington; the Annual Report has been distributed, he thanked Director of Administrative Services Neil Parsons and Media Specialist Golden for their hard work; and he wished everyone Happy Holidays. Fire Chief Camp informed Council of the Fi re Department’s new hire, Mr. Brian Mayo, Deputy Chief of Operations. Mr. Mayo will start January 4, 2021. PRT Director Combs announced that she also has a new hire. Mr. Hugo Montenegro will start January 4, 2021 as the Recreation Center Manager. XI. COUNCIL ISSUES AND CONCERNS Council Member Spisso thanked all that participated in Fill the Sleigh; he stated the Annual Report is great; he wished everyone Happy Holidays, Merry Christmas, and Happy New Year; and he welcomed the new hires within the Fire Department and PRT. Mayor Pro Tem Kassel attended the Patel Foundation of the Lowcountry COVID -19 supply and food giveaway, she thanked The Patels for everything they do for our community; she and her husband helped pick up toys in Sun City for Fill the Sleigh; she, along with others, helped wrap all of the gifts that were donated; she reminded everyone about Screen on the Green; she also reminded everyone about Wreaths Across America, which will take place on December 19; and she wished everyone Happy Holidays, Merry Christmas, and Happy New Year. City of Hardeeville Regular City Council Minutes December 10, 2020 Page 12 of 12 Council Member Carroll wished everyone Merry Christmas and Happy New Year. Mayor Williams proposed to Council that they create an award for Rick Patel honoring him for being such a boost within the community; he reminded everyone that he, Council Member Carroll, and Council Member White will be sworn in at the first meeting in January; he also reminded everyone that a new Mayor Pro Tem will be voted on at the first meeting in January; he thanked Mr. Dale Thompson and Ms. Elaine Thompson for donating food for Mercy Mis sion; he thanked Rick Patel for a great event last Saturday and he thanked the Police Department for their help with traffic control; he gave his compliments to City Staff for the Tree Lighting; he had the honor of blowing the horn at a half marathon sponsored by The Network Mortgage Company, it was a high quality event and they are planning on doing more events like this in Hardeeville ; he thanked everyone in the Sun City community who donated toys for Fill the Sleigh, over 600 toys were wrapped for elementary children and gift cards will be given to middle school children; he wished everyone a Happy Hanukah, Merry Christmas, Happy Kwanzaa, and Happy New Year. XII. ADJOURNMENT A motion was made by Council Member Carroll to adjourn the meeting. The motion received a proper second by Mayor Pro Tem Kassel carried unanimously. The meeting adjourned at 7:49 p.m. _____________________ _____________________ Lori Pomarico, City Clerk Date (Seal) City of Hardeeville Special City Council Minutes December 22, 2020 Page 1 of 2 CITY OF HARDEEVILLE SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARINGS MINUTES DECEMBER 22, 2020 10:30 AM VIRTUAL Present: Mayor Harry Williams, Mayor Pro Tem Carolyn Kassel, Council Members John Carroll, David Spisso, and Bo White, City Manager Michael Czymbor, City Attorney Prina Maines, Deputy City Manager Matthew Davis I. INVOCATION & PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE Council Member Kassel gave the invocation. II. CALL TO ORDER Mayor Williams called the meeting to order at 10:30 a.m. III. APPROVAL OF AGENDA A motion was made by Council Member Carroll to approve the agenda. The motion received a proper second by Mayor Pro Tem Kassel and carried unanimously. IV. EXECUTIVE SESSION A. DISCUSSION OF NEGOTIATIONS INCIDENT TO PROPOSED CONTRACTUAL ARRANGEMENTS AND PROPOSED SALE OR PURCHASE OF PROPERTY, THE RECEIPT OF LEGAL ADVICE WHERE LEGAL ADVICE RELATES TO A PENDING, THREATENED, OR POTENTIAL CLAIM OR OTHER MATTERS COVERED BY THE ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGE, SETTLEMENT OF LEGAL CLAIMS, OR THE POSITION OF THE PUBLIC AGENCY IN OTHER ADVERSARY SITUATIONS INVOLVING THE ASSERTION AGAINST THE AGENCY OF A CLAIM IN ACCORDANCE WITH S.C. CODE OF LAW 30-4-70(A)(2). • NICKLE PLATE - MCIP COUNCIL MAY TAKE ACTION IN OPEN SESSION ON MATTERS DISCUSSED IN EXECUTIVE SESSION A motion was made by Council Member Carroll to enter into Executive Session and adjourn directly from Executive Session . The motion received a proper second b y Mayor Pro Tem Kassel and carried unanimously. City of Hardeeville Special City Council Minutes December 22, 2020 Page 2 of 2 V. ADJOURNMENT A motion was made by Council Member Carroll to adjourn the meeting. The motion received a proper second by Mayor Pro Tem Kassel and carried unanimously. The meeting adjourned at 11:03 a.m. _____________________ ______________________ Lori Pomarico, City Clerk Date (Seal) ORDINANCE NO. 2020-12-10C AN ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE EAST A RGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT; PROVIDING FOR THE FINANCING OF IMPROVEMENTS WITHIN THE IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT BY ASSESSMENTS, THE ISSUANCE OF BO NDS, OR OTHER REVENUES AS HEREIN DESCRIBED; AND OTHER MATTERS RELATING THERETO. EAST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT January 7, 2021 2 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA, AS FOLLOWS: Section 1 Findings. The City Council of the City of Hardeeville (the (“City Council”) the governing body of the City of Har deeville, South Carolina (the “ City”), hereby makes the f ollowing findings of fact in connection with the enactment of this ordinance (this “Ordinance”): (a) Pursuant to Title 5, Chapter 37 of the Code of Laws of South Carolina 1976, as amended (the “Act”), governing bodies of the municipalities of the State of South Carolina (the “ State”) are authorized to establish improvement districts and thereafter to acquire, own, construct, establish, instal l, enlarge, improve, expand, operate, m aintain, and repair, and sell, lease, and otherwise dispose of any improvements therein and to finance such acquisition, construction, establishment, installation, enlargement, improv ement, expansion, operation, maint enance, and repair, in whole or in part , by the imposition of assessments in accordance with the Act , by special district bonds, by general obligation bonds of the municipality , by revenue bonds of the municipality, or fro m general revenues from any source not restricted from such use by law, or by any combination of such funding sources. (b) As set forth in a resolution adopted by the City Council on October 15, 2020 (the “Resolution”), the City has received a petition of Argent Land Holdings, LLC, Argent TH B, LLC, RF Development, LLC , and RF Deve lopment II, LLC (collectively, the “Petitioner”) petitioning the City for, and consenting to, the creation of an “improvement district” (within the meaning of Section 5-37- 20(3) of the Act) pursuant to the provisions of the Act, to be referred to as the East Argent Improvement District (the “ Improvement District ”), which shall con sist of approximately 291 upland acres ( 400.21 total acres) of real property, which is described more specifically at E xhibit A to this Ordinance. The Petitioner i s the “ owner” (within the meaning of Section 5- 37-20(6) of the Act) of the parcels of real property that are the subject of the Petition and included within the Improvement District. (c) Pursuant to t he R esolution, the C ity approved an “improvement plan ” (within the meaning of Section 5- 37-20(4) of the Act ), entitled “Improvement Plan – East Argent Improvement District”, and attached to the Resolution as its Exhibit B (as the same may be amended from time to time, the “Improvement Plan”), which Improvement Plan c ontemplates the establishment of the Improvement District. The Improvement Plan contemplates the construction of certain public improvements within or benefiting t he Improvem ent District as more particularly described therein (collectively, the “Improvements”) which constitute “improvements” within the meaning of Section 5-37-20(2) of the Act. The Improvements are to be located within the corporate limit s of the City and are described with greater specificity in the Engin eer’s R eport f or East Ar gent Improvement District, Hardeeville, SC (the “Engineer’s Report”) which is attached to this Ordinance at Exhibit B. Certain of the Improvements are located outside of the boundaries o f the Improvement District and are necessary t o make Improvements within the District effective for the benefit of property inside the Improvement District. (d) Pursuant to the Act, the cost of the Improvements may be paid by the imp osition of an “assessment” (within the m eaning of Section 5- 37-20(1) of the Act) upon real property in the Improvement District (“Assessments”), by special district bonds, by general oblig ation bonds of the municipality, or by revenue bonds of the City. (e) Pursuant to Section 5- 37-45(A)(1) and (B) of the Act, the City may include within the Improvement District an area in which Improvements have been constructed or are under construction at the time of the establishment of the Improvement District, provided the area proposed for inclusion within 3 the Improvement District is subject to a development agreement pursuant to the South Carolina Local Government Development Agreement Act within three years prior to the date of the Resolution. (f) The entirety of real property proposed to be included within the Improvement District is subject to the East Argent Tract Development Agreement and PDD, dated October 21, 2005 (as amended, the “Development Agreement”). The real property within the Im provement District has remained subject to the Development Agreement since the effective dat e thereof, includi ng during the three -year period prior to the date of the Resolution. The Cit y may, there fore, include a n area within the Impro vement District in which Improvements have been constructed or are under constructi on a nd reimburse the Petitioner for the cost of constructing such Improvements. (g) In a ccordance with Section 5 -37-40(A) of the Act, th e City Council hereby finds and determines that (i) the I mprovements would be beneficial w ithin the I mprovement District; (ii) the Improvements would preserve or increase pr operty values within the I mprovement D istrict; (iii) the Improvements are likely to encourage development in the I mprovement District; (iv) the general wel fare and tax base of the City would be maintained or likely improved by creation of the Improvement District in the City; and (v) it would be fair and equitable to finance all or part of the cost of the Improvements by the Assessment upon the real property within the Improvement District. (h) Pursuant to the Resolution, the City C ouncil did order that a public hearing be held on November 19, 2020, on the question of the estab lishment of the Improvement District (the “Public Hearing”). Pursuant to Section 5-37-60 of the Act, the entire tex t of the Resolution was published once a week for two successive weeks in the Jasper County Sun Times, a newspaper of general circulation in the City, on October 28, 2020, and November 4, 2020. The last date of publication was not less than ten days prior to the date of the Public Hearing. (i) Pursuant to Section 5-37-50 of the Act and the provisions of the Resolution, the Public Hearing was held on November 19, 2020, which date was neither sooner than 20 days nor more than 40 days following the adoption of the Resoluti on, and neither less than ten days nor more than 120 days before the second reading and passage of this Ordinance. (j) The City Council hereby finds that the Improvements may be financed by the City through the issuance of assessment revenue bonds (the “Bonds”), secured by and to be s erviced from the Assessments (together with any other sources pledged to secure and service such Bonds), so as to provide funds, inter alia, to pay th e costs of acquiring, equippi ng, and constructing the Improvements, interest coming due on the Bonds during the construction period of the Improvements , funding debt service reserves for the Bonds, and paying the costs incurred in connection with the authorization, issuance , and sale of the Bonds. (l) The City Council determines that no funds from any sources other than the Bonds and the Assessment are reserved, allocated, or otherw ise set aside by the C ity pursuant to the budget or financial policies of the C ity for the financing of any portion of the costs of acqui sition, constr uction, and equipping of the Improvements proposed to be funded from the Bonds and the Assessment. (m) The City Council finds that the cost of the acquisition, construction, and equipping of the Improvements, including interest on the Bonds during the construction period of the Improvements, debt service reserves required to be established in connection with the issuance of the Bonds , and costs 4 incurred in connection with the authorization, issuance, and sale of the Bonds, to be funded from proceeds of the Bonds, is expected to be not in excess of $18,200,000. Section 2 Establishment of Improvement District. The I mprovement District as described above and more ful ly set forth in the Improvement Plan is hereby established and the adoption of the Improvement Plan is hereby authorized. Section 3 Financing of Improvements. The estimated cost of the Improvements is approximately $14,738,725, and the total costs of the I mprovements to be de rived from Assessmen ts is not expected to exceed such amount. In order to finance the portion of the cost s of the Improvements to be derived from Ass essments, including interest on the Bonds during the construction period of the Improvements, debt service reserves required to be established in connection w ith the issuance of the Bonds, and costs incurred in connection with the authorization, issuance, and sale of the Bonds, the City intends to issue not exceeding $18,200,000 of Bonds, in one or more series, secured by and to be serviced from the imposition of the Assessments (together with any other sources pledged to se cure and service such Bonds) on all parcels of real property located within the Improvement District. The Bonds described in this Sec tion 3 may be combined with or constitute a portion of a l arger debt issue includi ng bonds issued for other purposes. Section 4 Imposition of Assessments; Ba sis for and Rates of Assessment s. The total of Assessments imposed within the Improvement District shall be based on actual costs of the Improvements or re asonable estimates of th e co st of t he Improvements, to include, but not be limited to, interest expense, principal repayment, debt service reserves, bond issuance costs, design and engineering c osts and costs associated with the establishment and administr ation of the Improvement District. Assessments shall be imposed upon parcels of real property in the Improvement District based upon the parcel’s expected development use and the estimated benefit of the Improvements to the parcel, according to the procedures set forth in the Eas t Argent Improvement District - Master Special Assessment Methodology Report, date d Decem ber 10, 2020, which shall establish an assessment allocation methodolo gy which fairly reflects the benefits de rived from the Improvements. It is presently anticipated that the total of the Assessments i mposed upon the parcel s located within the I mprovement Districts shall not exceed $47,893,788. Assessments withi n the Imp rovement District shall be billed annually at a rate or rates which shall be sufficient t o produce revenue equal to the principal of and accrued interest on the Bonds described herein, as well as administrative expenses with respect to the Improvement District. Upon the subdivision of any parcel, the total Assessment allocated to that parcel prior to t he subdivision shall be alloca ted to the parcels r esulting from the subdivision in accordance w ith the established assessment allocation methodology. The Ass essments on the parent parcel prior to the subdivision shall equal the sum of the Assessments on the r esulting parcels after the subdivision of the parent parcel. An Assessment shall not be imp osed upon property within the boundaries of the Impro vement District that does not receive a benefit from the Improvements. An Assessment shall not be imposed upon property outside the bounda ries of the Improvement District. Assessments shall also not be imposed on any property purchased or otherwise acquired by a public entity. 5 Section 5 General Repealer; Severability. All rules, regulations, resolutions , and part s thereof, procedural or ot herwise, in conflict herewith, to the extent of such conflict, ar e hereby repealed. The provisions of this Ordinance are hereby declared to be separate and if any section, phrase or provision shall for any reason be declared by a court of competent jurisdiction to be invalid or unenforceable, such declaration shall not affect the validity of the remainder of the sections, phrases and provisions hereunder. Section 6 Effective Date. This Ordinance shall be effective on the sevent h d ay after this ordinance has been published in accordance with section 5-37-100 of the act. DONE AND ENACTED IN MEETING DULY ASSEMBLED this 7th day of January, 2021. CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA (SEAL) By: Harry Williams, Mayor Attest: Lori Pomarico, City Clerk A-1 EXHIBIT A LEGAL DESCRIPTIONS OF THE PROPERTY TO BE INCLUDED IN THE EAST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT PARCEL 4A – EAST ARGENT ALL THOSE CERTAIN PIECES, PARCELS OR LOTS OF LAND, SITUATED, LYING AND BEING IN THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, JASPER COUNTY, SOUTH CAROLINA, SHOWN AS: BEGINNING AT A POINT ON THE SOUTHERN RIGHT OF WAY OF EAST ARGENT PARKWAY; THENCE LEAVING SAID RIGHT OF WAY S 04°27'13" W A DISTANCE OF 623.40 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE S 37°07'31" E A DISTANCE OF 72.29 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE S 20°08'57" W A DISTANCE OF 628.48 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE S 67°45'32" W A DISTANCE OF 1093.77 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE N 07°28'17" E A DISTANCE OF 2128.12 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE S 62°18'32" E A DISTANCE OF 535.78 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE W ITH THE ARC OF A CURVE TURNING TO THE LEFT, HAVING AN ARC LENGTH OF 188.78 FEET, A RADIUS OF 1050.00 FEET, A CHORD LENGTH OF 188.52 FEET, AND A CHORD BEARING S 67°27'34" E TO A POINT; THENCE S 72°36'36" E A DISTANCE OF 206.88 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE WITH THE ARC OF A CURVE TURNING TO THE RIGHT, HAVING AN ARC LEN GTH OF 119.42 FEET, A RADIUS OF 825.00 FEET, A CHORD LENGTH OF 119.32 FEET, AND A CHORD BEARING S 68°27'47" E TO SAID POINT OF BEGINNING, SAID TRACT OR PARCEL OF LAND CONTAINING 39.10 ACRES. PARCEL 4B – EAST ARGENT ALL THOSE CERTAIN PIECES, PARCELS OR LOTS OF LAND, SITUATED, LYING AND BEING IN THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, JASPER COUNTY, SOUTH CAROLINA, SHOWN AS: BEGINNING AT A POINT ON THE SOUTHERN RIGHT OF WAY OF EAST ARGENT PARKWAY; THENCE LEAVING SAID RIGHT OF WAY S 53°04'49" W A D ISTANCE OF 535.84 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE N 30°30'28" W A DISTANCE OF 651.80 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE N 37°07'31" W A DISTANCE OF 72.29 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE N 04°27'13" E A DISTANCE OF 623.40 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE WITH THE ARC OF A CURVE TURNING TO THE RIGHT, HAVING AN ARC LENGTH OF 437.71 FEET, A RADIUS OF 825.00 FEET, A CHORD LENGTH OF 432.60 FEET, AND A CHORD BEARING S 49°07'00" E TO A POINT; THENCE S 33°55'02" E A DISTANCE OF 766.04 FEET TO SAID POINT OF BEGINNING, SAID TRACT OR PARCEL OF LAND CONTAINING 11.45 ACRES PARCEL 6 – EAST ARGENT ALL THOSE CERTAIN PIECES, PARCELS OR LOTS OF LAND, SITUATED, LYING AND BEING IN THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, JASPER COUNTY, SOUTH CAROLINA, SHOWN AS: BEGINNING AT A POINT ON THE SOUTHERN RIGHT OF WAY OF EAST ARGENT PARKWAY; THENCE LEAVING SAID RIGHT OF WAY S 08°13'26" W A DISTANCE OF 2382.25 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE N 82°19'01" W A DISTANCE OF 213.13 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE N 70°23'37" W A DISTANCE OF 293.79 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE N 17° 30'31" E A DISTANCE OF 523.27 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE N 02°05'01" E A DISTANCE OF 329.20 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE N A-2 36°05'07" W A DISTANCE OF 964.75 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE N 22°19'53" W A DISTANCE OF 67.57 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE N 65°54'13" E A DISTANCE OF 1372.88 FEET TO SAID POINT OF BEGINNING, SAID TRACT OR PARCEL OF LAND CONTAINING 32.98 ACRES PARCEL 12B – EAST ARGENT ALL THOSE CERTAIN PIECES, PARCELS OR LOTS OF LAND, SITUATED, LYING AND BEING IN THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, JASPER COUNTY, SOUTH CAROLINA, SHOWN AS: BEGINNING AT A POINT ON THE SOUTHERN RIGHT OF WAY O F JASPER STATION ROAD; THENCE LEAVING SAID RIGHT OF WAY S 23°32'49" W A DISTANCE OF 384.27 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE N 66°26'15" W A DISTANCE OF 1851.72 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE S 49°52'56" W A DISTANCE OF 1162.30 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE N 55°45'35" W A DISTANCE OF 635.07 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE N 58°56'30" W A DISTANCE OF 614.32 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE N 82°31'30" W A DISTANCE OF 183.80 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE S 79°50'40" W A DISTANCE OF 125.03 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE N 12°48'51" W A DISTANCE OF 555.88 FEET T O A POINT; THENCE N 18°50'01" E A DISTANCE OF 671.09 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE N 52°54'34" E A DISTANCE OF 737.20 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE N 74°06'56" W A DISTANCE OF 12.76 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE N 48°55'27" E A DISTANCE OF 31.99 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE S 74°06'56" E A DISTANCE OF 15.54 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE N 52°54'34" E A DISTANCE OF 187.25 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE N 81°37'16" E A DISTANCE OF 181.89 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE N 87°53'16" E A DISTANCE OF 2075.88 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE S 70°23'37" E A DISTANCE OF 293.79 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE S 82°19'01" E A DISTANCE OF 213.13 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE S 08°13'26" W A DISTANCE OF 1656.93 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE S 65°32'06" E A DISTANCE OF 733.87 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE S 23°32'37" W A DISTANCE OF 66.01 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE S 65°32'06" E A DISTANCE OF 100.72 FEET TO SAID POINT OF BEGINNING, SAID TRACT OR PARCEL OF LAND CONTAINING 164.12 ACRES PARCEL 13 – EAST ARGENT ALL THOSE CERTAIN PIECES, PARCELS OR LOTS OF LAND, SITUATED, LYING AND BEING IN THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, JASPER COUNTY, SOUTH CAROLINA, SHOWN AS: BEGINNING AT A POINT AT THE NORTHWEST QUADRANT OF EAST ARGENT PARKWAY AND SC HIGHWAY NO. 170; THENCE NORTHWESTERLY ALONG EAST ARGENT PARKWAY N 66°33'37" W A DISTANCE OF 281.50 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE WITH THE ARC OF A CURVE TURNING TO THE RIGHT, HAVING AN ARC LENGTH OF 475.50 FEET, A RADIUS OF 1708.43 FEET, A CHORD LENGTH OF 473.96 FEET, AND A CHORD BEARING N 58°35'13" W TO A POINT; THENCE N 50°36'49" W A DISTANCE OF 1723.06 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE WITH THE ARC OF A CURVE TURNING TO THE RIGHT, HAVING AN ARC LENGTH OF 269.55 FEET, A RADIUS OF 925.00 FEET, A CHORD LENGTH OF 268.60 FEET, AND A CHORD BEARING N 42°15'55" W TO A POINT; THENCE N 33°55'02" W A DISTANCE OF 176.80 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE S 71°06'57" E A DISTANCE OF 121.80 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE S 87°31'38" E A DISTANCE OF 227.99 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE N 76°35'35" E A DISTANCE OF 113.34 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE N 52°45'33" E A DISTANCE OF 42.03 FE ET TO A POINT; THENCE S 50°13' 07" E A DISTANCE OF 1396.70 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE S 50°47'20" E A DISTANC E OF 1060.13 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE S 24°33'09" W A DISTANCE OF 196.32 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE WITH THE ARC OF A CURVE TURNING TO THE LEFT, HAVING AN ARC LENGTH OF 63.50 FEET, A RA DIUS OF A-3 7271.31 FEET, A CHORD LENGTH OF 63.50 FEET, AND A CHORD BEARING S 2 4°18'09" W TO SAID POINT OF BEGINNING, SAID TRACT OR PARCEL OF LAND CONTAINING 23.15 ACRES PARCEL 14A – EAST ARGENT ALL THOSE CERTAIN PIECES, PARCELS OR LOTS OF LAND, SITUATED, LYING AND BEING IN THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, JASPER COUNTY, SOUTH CAROLINA, SHOWN AS: BEGINNING AT A POINT ON THE NORTHERN RIGHT OF WAY OF EAST ARGENT PARKWAY; THENCE LEAVING SAID RIGHT OF WAY N 22°18'26" E A DISTANCE OF 1956.46 FE ET TO A POINT; THENCE S 66°25'27" E A DISTANCE OF 212.31 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE S 00°18'25" W A DISTANCE OF 1944.42 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE S 04°27'13" W A DISTANCE OF 21.32 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE S 04°27'13" W A DISTANCE OF 167.64 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE WITH THE ARC OF A CURVE TURNING TO THE LEFT, HAVING AN ARC LENGTH OF 83.49 FEET, A RADIUS OF 975.00 FEET, A CHORD LENGTH OF 83.47 FEET, AND A CHORD BEARING N 70°09'24" W TO A POINT; THENCE N 72°36'36" W A DISTANCE OF 206.88 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE WITH THE ARC OF A CURVE TURNING TO THE RIGHT, HAVING AN ARC LENGTH OF 161.81 FEET, A RADIUS OF 900.00 FEET, A CHORD LENGTH OF 161.59 FEET, AND A CHORD BEARING N 67°27'34" W TO A POINT; THENCE N 62°18'32" W A DISTANCE OF 549.91 FEET TO SAID POINT OF BEGINNING, SAID TRACT OR PARCEL OF LAND CONTAINING 27.96 ACRES. PARCEL 14B – EAST ARGENT ALL THOSE CERTAIN PIECES, PARCELS OR LOTS OF LAND, SITUATED, LYING AND BEING IN THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, JASPER COUNTY, SOUTH CAROLINA, SHOWN AS: BEGINNING AT A POINT ON THE NORTHERN RIGHT OF WAY OF EAST ARGENT PARKWAY; THENCE LEAVING SAID RIGHT OF WAY N 04°27'13" E A DISTANCE OF 167.64 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE S 50°13'07" E A DISTANCE OF 1659.77 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE S 52°45'33" W A DISTANCE OF 42.03 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE S 76°35'35" W A DISTANCE OF 113.34 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE N 87 °31'38" W A DISTANCE OF 227.99 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE N 71°06'57" W A DISTANCE OF 121.80 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE N 33°55'02" W A DISTANCE OF 649.86 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE WITH THE ARC OF A CURV E TU RNING TO THE LEFT, HAVING AN ARC LENGTH OF 574.94 FEET, A RADIUS OF 975.00 FEET, A CHORD LENGTH OF 566.65 FEET, AND A CHORD BEARING N 50°48'37" W TO SAID POINT OF BEGINNING, SAID TRACT OR PARCEL OF LAND CONTAINING 6.44 ACRES PARCEL 16 – EAST ARGENT ALL THOSE CERTAIN PIECES, PARCELS OR LOTS OF LAND, SITUATED, LYING AND BEING IN THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, JASPER COUNTY, SOUTH CAROLINA, SHOWN AS: BEGINNING AT A POINT ON THE NORTHERN RIGHT OF WAY OF EAST ARGENT PARKWAY; THENCE LEAVING SAID RIGHT OF WAY N 08°12'54" E A DISTANCE OF 2966.88 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE S 78°28'47" E A DISTANCE OF 2283.96 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE S 11°31'13" W A DISTANCE OF 121.28 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE S 51°08'15" W A DISTANCE OF 777.70 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE N 58°19'01" W A DISTANCE OF 33.09 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE N 63°27'40" W A DISTANCE OF 276.63 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE N 63°05'49" W A DISTANCE OF A-4 96.30 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE N 48°30'37" W A DISTANCE OF 67.21 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE N 51°38'29" W A DISTANCE OF 107.41 FEET TO A PO INT; THENCE N 49°34'26" W A DISTANCE OF 63.14 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE N 66°39'45" W A DISTANCE OF 167.83 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE N 69°08'13" W A DISTANCE OF 88.98 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE N 51°31'56" W A DISTANCE OF 254.55 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE N 26°39'12 " W A D ISTANCE OF 56.48 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE N 36°42'18" W A DISTANCE OF 112.61 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE S 08°17'33" W A DISTANCE OF 2258.75 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE S 57°31'44" W A DISTANCE OF 231.15 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE WITH THE ARC OF A CURVE TURNIN G TO THE RIGHT, HAVING AN ARC LENGTH OF 503.64 FEET, A RADIUS OF 4925.00 FEET, A CHORD LENGTH OF 503.42 FEET, AND A CHORD BEARING S 60°27'30" W TO SAID POINT OF BEGINNING, SAID TRACT OR PARCEL OF LAND CONTAINING 55.01 ACRES. PARCEL 18 – EAST ARGENT ALL THOSE CERTAIN PIECES, PARCELS OR LOTS OF LAND, SITUATED, LYING AND BEING IN THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, JASPER COUNTY, SOUTH CAROLINA, SHOWN AS: BEGINNING AT A POINT ON THE NORTHERN RIGHT OF WAY OF EAST ARGENT PARKWAY; THENCE LEAVING SAID RIGHT OF WAY N 08°17'33" E A DISTANCE OF 2258.75 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE S 36°42'18" E A DISTANCE OF 112.61 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE S 26°39'12" E A DISTANCE OF 56.48 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE S 51°31'56" E A DISTANCE OF 254.55 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE S 69°08'13" E A DISTANCE OF 88.98 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE S 66°39'45" E A DISTANCE OF 167.83 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE S 49°34'26" E A DISTANCE OF 63.14 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE S 51°38'29" E A DISTANCE OF 107.41 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE S 48°30'37" E A DISTANCE OF 67.21 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE S 63°05'49" E A DISTANCE OF 96.30 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE S 63°27'40" E A DISTANCE OF 276.63 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE S 58°19'01" E A DISTANCE OF 33.09 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE S 17°07'01" W A DISTANCE OF 1234.16 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE WITH THE ARC OF A CURVE TURNING TO THE LEFT, HAVING AN ARC LENGTH OF 900.94 FEET, A RADIUS OF 1375.00 FEET, A CHORD LENGTH OF 884.91 FEET, AND A CHORD BEARING S 76°17'59" W TO A POINT; THENCE S 57°31'44" W A DISTANCE OF 208.79 FEET TO SAID POINT OF BEGINNING, SAID TRACT OR PARCEL OF LAND CONTAINING 40.00 ACRES. B-1 EXHIBIT B ENGINEER’S REPORT EAST ARGENT MUNICIPAL IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT Municipal Improvement Districts • A MID is an area within the City designated by Council as an area within which an Improvement Plan is to be accomplished • The Improvement Plan provides for certain public infrastructure to be constructed within the MID and the costs of such infrastructure to be paid from the proceeds of MID Bonds that are repaid from special assessments imposed within the MID • MID Bonds are issued by the City and secured solely by and payable solely from revenues generated from special assessments imposed within the MID • MID Bond proceeds are used to finance public improvements that benefit the properties in the MID • MID Bonds are not a general obligation pledge or pledge of any other revenues of the City other than special assessment revenues • The proposed East Argent MID Bonds will also be secured by Road Development Fees that would otherwise be used to reimburse the developer for the costs of public roads 2 Municipal Improvement District (MID) and MID Bonds Municipal Improvement Districts Step 1: Landowner petitions City to create MID Step 2: Resolution approving Improvement Plan and ordering public hearing Step 3: Public Hearing Step 4: Enactment of ordinances (1) establishing MID and (2) imposing the special assessment by adopting the Assessment Roll and Methodology Step 5: Allow time for objections to the special assessments Step 6: Offer and sale of MID Bonds (final determination of amount of bonds, interest rates, and other terms to determine annual debt service and the amount of annual assessments) Step 7: Final confirmation of Assessment Roll (taking into account actual annual debt service) Step 8: Recording of Assessment Roll placing lien on assessed property 3 Process to Establish a MID and Issue MID Bonds Municipal Improvement Districts Steps 1 – 3 (petition, resolution, and public hearing) have been completed December 10 – First reading of ordinances (1) establishing MID and (2) adopting the Assessment Roll and Methodology January 7 – Second reading of ordinances (1) establishing MID and (2) adopting the Assessment Roll and Methodology February 4 – First reading of Bond Ordinance (authorizing issuance of MID Bonds and approving the Trust Indenture, Offering Memorandum, and other bond documents) February 18 – Second reading of Bond Ordinance February 22 – Posting of Preliminary Offering Memorandum March 8 – Pricing of Bonds March 22 – Bond Closing 4 Proposed Schedule Properties to be Assessed for Improvements East Argent Municipal Improvement District Proposed Development Plan Parcel Designation Land Use Parcel Size (Acres) Number of Units/Square Feet Residential 4A Multi Family 11.55 150 4B Multi Family 11.45 150 6 Single Family 23.01 72 16 Single Family 40.36 160 12B Single Family 134.03 435 18 Multi Family 40.00 240 Total Residential 260.40 1,207 Non-Residential 13 Commercial/Retail 23.15 231,500 14A Commercial/Retail 3.68 36,800 14B Commercial/Retail 4.46 44,600 Total Non-Residential 31.29 312,900 Total 291.69 Description Estimated Cost Phase 4 and 5A Loop Road Plans Paving, Grading and Earthwork $4,542,446 Sanitary Sewer $1,181,081 Water Distribution $665,830 Storm Drainage $955,313 Miscellaneous $1,077,408 Engineering Design, Permit and Construction Monitoring $421,104 Offsite Utilities Plans Paving, Grading and Earthwork $337,600 Sanitary Sewer $2,543,020 Water Distribution $147,672 Storm Drainage $23,493 Miscellaneous $306,829 Engineering Design, Permit and Construction Monitoring $167,931 Entryway and Roadway Hardscape and Landscaping Paving, Grading and Earthwork $723,745 Storm Drainage $354,618 Hardscape Walls and Landscaping $421,637 Highway 170 Signalization and Intersection Improvements $869,000 Total $14,738,725 East Argent Municipal Improvement District Proposed Infrastructure Improvements Sources Bond Proceeds: Par Amount $18,200,000.00 Total Sources $18,200,000.00 Uses Project Fund Deposits: Project Fund $14,738,725.00 Other Fund Deposits: Debt Service Reserve Fund $1,274,000.00 Capitalized Interest Fund $1,274,000.00 Delivery Date Expenses: Costs of Issuance $911,050.00 Rounding $2,225.00 Total Uses $18,200,000.00 East Argent Municipal Improvement District Preliminary Sources and Uses of Funds Parcel Designation Land Use Number of Units/Square Feet Proposed ERU-Based Allocation of Infrastructure Improvements Residential 4A Multi Family 150 $1,351,512.22 4B Multi Family 150 $1,351,512.22 6 Single Family 72 $810,907.33 16 Single Family 160 $1,802,016.29 12B Single Family 435 $4,899,231.78 18 Multi Family 240 $2,162,419.54 Total Residential 1,207 $12,377,599.37 Non-Residential 13 Commercial/Retail 231,500 $1,746,885.85 14A Commercial/Retail 36,800 $277,690.71 14B Commercial/Retail 44,600 $336,549.07 Total Non-Residential 312,900 $2,361,125.63 Total $14,738,725.00 Municipal Improvement District Proposed Allocation of Benefit of Infrastructure Improvements East Argent CITY COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM _________________________________________ SUBJECT: AN ORDINANCE OF TH E CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA, AUTHORIZING THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE EAST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT; PROVIDING FOR THE FI NANCING OF IMPROVEMENTS WITHIN THE IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT BY ASSESSMENTS, THE ISSUANCE OF BONDS, OR OTHER REVENUES AS HEREIN DES CRIBED; AND OTHER MATTERS RELATING THERETO. DEPARTMENT: CMO/City Attorney ATTACHMENTS: Ordinance X _ Resolution ___ Motion _X_ Support Documents ___ Appointment ___ Other ______________________________________________________________________________ SUMMARY: The City and its attorneys and consultant s have been working cooperatively with Argent Land Holdings LLC, the primary owner and master devel oper, of the East Argent tract to establish a municipal improvement district to pay for a portion of the infrastructure within the development. The City held the required public hearin g on October 15 th for the petition to create the district and the proposed improvement plan. The MID would allocate the cost of the proposed improvements (road, sanitary sewer, and water) to approximately 400 acres within the development. The proposed Ord inance adopts a propo sed municipal improvement district and the financing plan for the East Argent improvements. ______________________________________________________________________ RECOMMENDED ACTION: ADOPT Ordinance at second reading which is 2020-12- 10C AN ORDINANCE OF TH E CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA, AUTHORIZING THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE EAST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT; PROVID ING FOR THE FINANCING OF IMPROVEMENTS WITHIN THE IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT BY ASSESSMENTS, THE ISSUANCE OF BONDS, OR OTHE R REVENUES AS HEREIN DES CRIBED; AND OTHER MATTERS RELATING THERETO. _____________________________________________________________________________ DEPARTMENT Submitted: ____M Czymbor__________ Date: 12/10/20 Requested Agenda ___City Council____ Date: 1/7/21 FINANCE DEPARTMENT Budgeted ___Yes ___No ___N/A Date: CITY ATTORNEY Approved as to Form and Correctness Date: CITY MANAGER Approved Agenda Item For: Date: ______________________________________________________________________________ COUNCIL ACTION: Approved as Recommended Disapproved Approved with Modification ___ Tabled to Time Certain ___ Other ______________________________________________________________________________ ORDINANCE NO. 2020-12-10D AN ORDINANCE APPROVING THE ASSESSMENT ROLL AND MASTER ASSESSMENT METHODOLOGY FOR TH E EAST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT AND OTHER MATTERS RELATING THERETO. EAST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT January 7, 2021 2 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA, AS FOLLOWS: Section 1 Findings. The City Council of the City of Hardeeville (the (“ City Council”) the governing body of the City of Hardeeville, South Carolina (the “ City”), hereby makes the following findings of fact in connection with the enactment of this ordinance (this “Ordinance”): (a) Pursuant to Title 5, Chapter 37, Code of Laws of South Carolina 1976, as amended (the “Act”), governing bodies of the municipalities of the State of South Carolina (the “State”) are authorized to establish municipal improvement districts and thereafter to acquire, own, construct, establish, install, enlarge, improve, expand, operate, maintain, and repair, and sell, lease, and otherwise dis pose of any improvements therein and to finance such acquisition, construction, establishment, installation, enlargement, improvement, expansion, operation, maintenance, and repair, in whole or in part, by the imposition of assessments in accordance with t he Act, by special district bonds, by general obligation bonds of the municipality, by revenue bonds of the municipality, or from general revenues from any source not restricted from such use by law, or by any combination of such funding sources. (b) As s et forth in a resolution adopted by the City Council on October 15, 2020 (the “Resolution”), the City has received a petition of Argent Land Holdings, LLC , Argent TH B, LLC, RF Development, LLC, and RF Development II, LLC (collectively, the “Petitioner”) petitioning the City for, and consenting to, the creation of an “improvement district” (within the meaning of Section 5 -37- 20(3) of the Act) pursuant to the provisions of the Act, to be referred to as the East Argent Improvement District (the “ Improvement D istrict”), which shall consist of approximately 291 upland acres (400.21 total acres) of certain real property situated within the City . The Petitioner is the “owner” (within the meaning of Section 5- 37-20(6) of the Act) of the parcels of real property tha t a re the subject of the Petition and included within the Improvement District. Pursuant to the Resolution, the City approved an “improvement plan” (within the meaning of Section 5-37-20(4) of the Act), entitled “Improvement Plan – East Argent Improvement District”, and attached to the Resolution as its Exhibit B (as the same may be amended from time to time, the “Improvement Plan ”), which Improvement Plan contemplates the establishment of the Improvement District. (c) Pursuant to Ordinance No. 2021-__, enacted on January 7, 2021 (the “MID Ordinance”), the City Council established the Improvement District and authorized the f inancing of the cost of certain public improvements within or benefiting the Improvement District ( as are specifically described in the MID Ordinance, the “Improvements”) through the imposition of an “assessment” (within the meaning of Section 5-37-20(1) of the Act) upon real property in the Improvement District (“ Assessments”) and the issuance of assessment revenue bonds of the City (the “Bonds”), secured by and to be serviced from the Assessments (together with any other sources pledged to secure and service such Bonds). (d) In connection with the establishment of the Impr ovement District and the imposition of Assessments upon the parcel s co ntained therein, the City has caused to be prepared t he basis and methodology of the Assessment s, as set forth in the East Arg ent Improvement District - Master Special Assessment Methodology Report, date d December 10, 2020 (the “ Master Assessment Methodology”), which is attached to this Ordin ance a t Exhibit A . The City has further caused to be prepared the assessment roll relating to the Assessments wherein there have been entered the names of the persons whose properties are t o be assessed, the amount assessed against the respective properties, and a brief description of the parcel s of land to be assessed (the “ Assessment Roll”), which is attached as E xhibit C to the Mast er Assessment Methodology. The basis and methodology set forth in the Master Assessment 3 Methodology and the Assessment Roll are based upon each parcel’s expected development use and the estimated benefit of the Improvements to such parcel. The City Council hereby finds that such basis and methodology fairly reflects the advantage derived by each parcel from the Improvements, and that such basis and met hodology for the Assessment s is appropriate and included in the authorized methods set forth in Section 5-37-20(1) of the Act. (e) Pursuant to the Assessment Roll, the total of the A ssessments imposed upon the parcels located within the Improvement Distric ts shall not exceed $47,893,788; provided, however, the total amount of the Assessments imposed upon parcels located within the Improvement Distri ct may be decreased substantially based upon the final par amount and pricing of the Bonds. (f) The Petitioner, as the owner of all property within the Improvement District on which Assessments are to be levied, has given its written consent for the imposition of Assessments upon such property. Section 2 Confirmation of Assessments and of Assessment Roll. The Master Assessment Methodology and Assessment Roll, including the Assessments reflected therein, are hereby approved, and shall be the basis for the actual Assessments on each parcel of real pro perty l isted thereon. The City Council hereby declares that the Assessment Roll is “ complete” within the meaning of Section 5 -37-110 of the Act as of the date of enactment of this Ordinance . Pursuant to Section 5 -37-120 of the Act, t he Petitioner, as the owner of all property within the Improvement District on which Asse ssments are to be levied, has given its written consent for the imposition of Assessments upon such property, and, therefore, the requirement of s uch Section 5-37-120 that the City mail noti ces of the Assessments to the owners of property within the Improvement District is deemed satisfied. Section 3 Publication of Notice of Assessment Roll. The City Manager is hereby directed to cause one copy of the Assessment Roll and the Master Assessment Methodology to be deposited in the offices of the City for inspection by any interested party. The City Manager is further directed to cause to be prepared and published the notice of comp letion of the Assessmen t Roll in a newspaper of general circulation in the City (the “ Notice of Assessment ’). The Notice of Assessmen t shall set forth a description in general terms of the Improvements , state the time and place fixed for the hearing of objections in respect to t he Assessments, and provide that an owner of property within the Improvement District who fails to file with the City Council a written objection to the Assessments against his property before the end of the hearing period shall be deemed to have consented thereto. The Notice of Assessment shall be published in a newspaper of general circulation within the City no t less than ten days prior to the time fixed for the hearing of objections, and the time fixed for the hearing of such obje ctions shall be at least thirty days. Section 4 Confirmation of Assessment Roll; Hearing of Objections. (a) The Assessment Roll, as attached to this Resolution at Exhibit B, has been presented to City Council. The Assessment Roll, including the Assessments reflected therein, is hereby confirmed, and, subject to the rem aining provisions of this Section, shall be the basis for the actu al Assessments on each parcel of real prope rty listed thereon. The City Council hereby declares that the Assessment Roll is “confirmed” within the meaning of Section 5-37-110 of the Act as of the date hereof. (b) The City Council shall hear any objections of all persons who have filed written notice of objection during the time fixed for the hearing of such objections, and such persons may appear and make 4 proof in relation thereto either in pers on or by their attorney. The City Council , at the sessions hel d to make final decisions on objections, ma y thereupon make such corrections in the Assessment Roll as it may deem proper. In the event that City Council makes any such correction to the Ass essment Roll in a meeting held for such purpose, City Council may confirm such corrected Assessment Roll by r esolution at such meeting, and such corrected Assessment Roll shall be “confirmed” within the meaning o f Section 5-37-130 of the Act as of the date hereof. (c) The City Council anticipates that the Petitioner will request certain corrections to the Assessment Roll based upon the final par amount, pricing, and other terms of the Bonds and a proposal of administrative costs of the Im provement District provided by the administrator of the Improvemnet District to be re tained by the City. The City Council may consider such corrections to the Assessment Roll, which corrections may be made and confirmed by resolution of the City Counci l and shall be considered “corrections” within the meaning of Section 5-37-130 of the Act. (d) Upon the expiration of the time fixed for the hearing of objections, the Assessment Roll, as attached here to at Exhibt C to the Mast er Assessment Me thodology or as may b e corrected and later confirmed by City Council, shall be certified by the Clerk of the City Council and filed in the Office of the Clerk of Court for Jasper County and in the Office of the Register of Deeds for Jasper County, and from the time of filing the Assessment Roll, such Assessments shall constitute and are liens on the real property against which they are assessed superior to all other liens and encum brances, except the lien for property taxes, and must be annually assessed and collected with the property taxes on such real property. Section 5 General Repealer; Severability. All rules, regulations, resolutions, and parts thereof, procedural or otherwise, in conflict herewith, to the extent of such conflict, are hereby repealed. The provisions of t his Resolution ar e h ereby declared to be separate and if any section, phrase or provision shall for any reason be declared by a court of competent jurisdiction to be invalid or unenforceable, such declaration shall not affect the validity of the remainder of the se ctions, phrases and provisions hereunder. Section 6 Effective Date. This Ordinance shall be effective upon its enactment. DONE AND ENACTED IN MEETING DULY ASSEMBLED this 7th day of January, 2021. CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA (SEAL) By: Harry Williams, Mayor Attest: Lori Pomarico, City Clerk A-1 EXHIBIT A East Argent Improvement District Master Special Assessment Methodology Report and Assessment Roll East Argent Improvement District Master Methodology Report_v2.2 1 EAST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT Master Special Assessment Methodology Report January 7, 2020 Provided by: Wrathell, Hunt and Associates, LLC 2300 Glades Road, Suite 410W Boca Raton, FL 33431 Phone: 561-571-0010 Fax: 561-571-0013 Website: www.whhassociates.com Table of Contents 1.0 Introduction 1.1 Purpose ......................................................................................... 1 1.2 Scope of the Report ....................................................................... 1 1.3 Special Benefits and General Benefits .......................................... 1 1.4 Organization of the Report ............................................................ 2 2.0 Development Program 2.1 Overview ....................................................................................... 2 2.2 The Development Plan .................................................................. 3 3.0 Improvement Plan 3.1 Overview ...................................................................................... 3 3.2 The Improvement Plan .................................................................. 3 4.0 Financing Program 4.1 Overview ....................................................................................... 4 4.2 Types of Assessment Revenue Bonds Proposed ......................... 4 5.0 Assessment Methodology 5.1 Overview ....................................................................................... 5 5.2 Benefit Allocation ........................................................................... 5 5.3 District Administration and Bond Assessments Collection ............. 8 5.4 Lienability Test: Special Benefit to the Property ............................ 9 5.5 Lienability Test: Reasonable and Fair Apportionment of the Duty to Pay .............................................................................................. 10 5.6 True-Up Mechanism ..................................................................... 10 5.7 Assessment Roll ........................................................................... 11 6.0 Additional Stipulations 6.1 Overview ...................................................................................... 12 7.0 Appendix Table 1 ..................................................................................................... 13 Table 2 ..................................................................................................... 14 Table 3 ................................................................................................... 15 Table 4 ................................................................................................... 16 Table 5 ................................................................................................... 17 Table 6 ................................................................................................... 18 Table 7 ................................................................................................... 19 Table 8 .................................................................................................. 20 1 1.0 Introduction 1.1 Purpose This Master Special Assessment Methodology Report (the “Report”) was developed to provide a master financing plan and a master special assessment methodology for the East Argent Improvement District (the “District”), located in the City of Hardeeville, South Carolina (the “City”), relating to funding the costs of public infrastructure improvement s contemplated to be provided in the District (the “Improvement Plan”) and financed with proceeds of special assessment revenue bonds issued by the City and secured by , among other sources of funds, special assessment s levied by the C ity and collected for the City by Jasper County , South Carolina (the “County”) in accordance with Title 5, Chapter 37 of the Code of Laws of South Carolina 1976, as amended (the “Act”). 1.2 Scope of the Report This Report presents the projections for financing the Improvement Plan described in the Engineer’s Report for East Argent Improvement District Hardeeville, SC dated October, 20 20 (the “Engineer’s Report”) prepared by Thomas & Hutton (the “Project Engineer”), and describes the method for the allocation of special benefits and the apportionment of special assessment s resulting from the provision for and funding of the Improvement Plan. 1.3 Special Benefits and General Benefits Improvements undertaken and funded by the City as part of the Improvement Plan create special benefits, different in kind and degree than general benefits, for properties within the District, as well as general benefits to the areas outside the District an d to the public at large. However, as discussed within this Report, these general benefits are incidental in nature and are readily distinguishable from the special benefits which accrue to particular property within the District as the Improvement Plan enables properties within the boundaries of the District to be developed. There is no doubt that the general public and property owners outside the District will benefit from the provision of the Improvement Plan . However, these benefits are only incident al since the Improvement Plan is designed to provide special benefits particular to property within the District, including but not limited to allowing the development of property therein. The improvements 2 that are part of the Improvement Plan (the “ Improvements”) are likely to encourage development in the District. Properties within the District are directly served by the Improvement Plan and depend upon the Improvement Plan to satisfy the requirements of their development entitlements. This fact alone clearly demonstrates the special benefits which the properties located within the District receive. The Improvement Plan will provide the public infrastructure improvements necessary to make the lands within the District developable and saleable. The Imp rovements would preserve or increase property values within the District. The installation of such improvements will cause the value of the developable and saleable lands within the District to increase by more than the sum of the financed costs of the in dividual components of the Improvement Plan. Even though the exact value of the special benefits provided by the Improvement Plan is hard to estimate at this point, it is nevertheless greater than the costs associated with providing the same. The general welfare and tax base of the City would be maintained or likely improved by creation of the District in the City. 1.4 Organization of the Report Section Two describes the development p lan as proposed by the Developer, as defined in Section 2 below. Section Three provides a summary of the Improvement Plan as set forth in the Engineer’s Report. Section Four discusses the proposed financing program for the District. Section Five sets out the special assessment methodology for the District. 2.0 Development Program 2.1 Overview The District will serve a portion of the East Argent Development (the “Development”), a 7,351-acre mixed-use development located within the municipal boundaries of the City . The District encompasses approximately 291.69 +/- upland and approximately 3 400.21 +/- total acres and is generally located in the northeastern portion of the City, west of S.C. Highway 170. 2.2 The Development Plan The proposed development plan for the District envisions a total of 1,207 single and multi -family residential dwelling units and 312,900 square feet of commercial/retail uses , although the planned land use may change throughout the development period. The development is expected to be conducted by Argent Land Holdings, LLC or one of its affiliated companies (the "Developer") over a multi-year period and may be developed in multiple phases. Table 1 in the Appendix to this Report illustrates the development plan for the District as currently proposed by the Developer . Please note that the proposed development plan is consistent with the Development Agreement for the Development. 3.0 Improvement Plan 3.1 Overview The infrastructure costs to be funded under the Act were determined by the Project Engineer in the Engineer's Report. Only infrastructure that may qualify for bond financing was included in these estimates. 3.2 The Improvement Plan The Improvement Plan needed to serve the planned development within the District is projected to consist of improvements designed to comprise master infrastructure that will serve and benefit all land within the District and will comprise an interrelated system of improvements, which means all of the I mprovements will serve the entire District and will be interre lated such that they will reinforce one another. The Improvements are described in more detail in the Engineer’s Report; however, they generally consist of roadways, storm water management , water and sewer utilities , landscaping, hardscaping, irrigation, entry monuments, signage and signalization. At the time of this writing, the total cost of the Improvement Plan, including the costs of design, engineering, surveying and permitting are estimated at $14,738,725, with some of the Improvements having already been partially constructed. Table 2 in the Appendix 4 to this Report illustrates the specific components of the costs of the Improvement Plan. 4.0 Financing Program 4.1 Overview As noted above, the D eveloper is embarking on a program of capital improvements which will fac ilitate the development of land within the District. Even though the actual financing plan may change and only a portion of the Improvements contained within the Improvement Plan may be fund ed, it is likely that in order to fully fund costs of the Improvement Plan as described in Section 3.2 in one financing transaction using long -term bonds , the City would have to issue approximately $18,200,000 in par amount of special assessment revenue bonds (the "Bonds"). Please note that the purpose of this Report is to allocate the benefit of the Improvements to the various land uses and parcels in the District and based on such allocation of benefit to apportion the maximum debt necessary to fund t he Improvement Plan. The discussion of the structure and size of the indebtedness is based on various estimates and is subject to change. 4.2 Types of Assessment Revenue Bonds Proposed The proposed financing plan for the District provides for the issuance of the Bonds in the total amount of not to exceed $18,200,000 to defray the cost of construction/acquisition of the Improvements of approximately $14,738,725. As projected under this Report, the Bonds would be structured to amortize in 30 annual installments following a 12-month capitalized interest period. Interest payments on the Bonds would be made every May 1 and November 1 and principal payments on the Bonds would be made every November 1 commencing November 1, 2023. In order to finance $14,738,725 in improvement costs, the City would need to issue Bonds in the total amount of not to exceed $18,200,000. The difference is comprised of debt service reserve, capitalized interest and costs of issuance. The preliminary sources and uses of funding are presented in Table 3 in the Appendix to this Report, while the preliminary amortization schedule is presented in Exhibit “A”. 5 Please note that the structure of the Bonds as presented in this Report is preliminary and may change due to changes in the development program, market conditions, timing of infrastructure installation as well as for other reasons. The City maintains complete flexibility as to the structure of the Bonds and reserves the right to modify it as necessary. 5.0 Assessment Methodology 5.1 Overview The issuance of the Bonds provides the City with the funds necessary to construct/acquire the Improvements which are part of the Improvement Plan outlined in Section 3.2 and described in more detail by the Project Engineer in the Engineer's Report. These Improvements lead to special and general benefits, wi th special benefits accruing to the properties within the boundaries of the District and general benefits accruing to areas outside the District and being only incidental in nature. The Bonds will be paid off by assessing properties that derive special an d particular benefits from the Improvement Plan . All properties that receive special benefits from the Improvement Plan will be assessed for their fair share of the debt service on the Bonds, together with the costs of administration of the District and c ollection of special assessments, issued in order to finance the construction/acquisition of the Improvement Plan. It would be fair and equitable to finance all or part of the cost of the Improvements by the Bonds to be paid from special assessments upon the real property within the District. 5.2 Benefit Allocation According to the Project Engineer, the Improvement Plan will serve and provide special benefits to all land in the District , which is currently projected to be developed with a total of approximately 1,207 single and multi -family residential dwelling units and 312,900 square feet of commercial/retail uses, although the planned land use may change throughout the development period. The Improvements that comprise the Improvement Plan will serve and provide benefit to all land uses in the District and will comprise an interrelated system of improvements, which means all of the Improvements will serve the entire District and improvements will be interrelated such that they will reinforce one another and their combined benefit will be greater than the sum of their individual benefits. All of the land uses within the District will benefit from 6 each infrastructure improvement category, as the improvements provide basic infrastructure to all land within the District and benefit all land within the District as an integrated system of improvements. The improvements that are part of the Improvement Plan have a logical connection to the special and particular benefits received by the land within the District, as without such improvements, the development of the properties within the District would not be possible. Based upon the connection between the improvements and the special and particular benefits to the land within the District, the City can assign or allocate a portion of the debt service on the Bonds through the impositi on of non -ad valorem special assessments on the land receiving such special and particular benefits. Even though these special and particular benefits are real and ascertainable, the precise amount of the benefit cannot yet be calculated with mathematical certainty. However, such benefit is more valuable than the cost of, or the actual non -ad valorem assessment amount imposed on the parcels within the District. The benefit associated with the Improvement Plan is proposed to be allocated to the different land uses in proportion to the density of development and intensity of use of the capital improvements that are part of the Improvement Plan as measured by a stan dard unit called an Equivalent Residential Unit ("ERU"). Table 4 in the Appendix to this Report illustrates the numbers of units/numbers of square feet for each land use, ERU weights that are proposed to be assigned to the different land uses contemplated to be developed within the District based on the relative density of development and the intensity of use of infrastructure, and the total ERU counts for each land use category. The rationale behind different ERU weights is supported by the fact that gen erally and on average smaller units or units with a lower intensity of use will use and benefit from the District's improvements less than larger units or units with a higher intensity of use, as for instance, generally and on average smaller units or unit s with lower intensity of use produce less storm water runoff, produce fewer vehicular trips, and need less water/sewer capacity than larger units or units with a higher intensity of use . Additionally, the value of the larger units or units with a higher intensity of use is likely to appreciate by more in terms of dollars than that of the smaller units or units with a lower intensity of use as a result of the implementation of the Improvement Plan. As the exact amount of the benefit and appreciation is no t possible to be calculated at this time, the use of ERU weights serves as a reasonable 7 approximation of the relative amount of benefit received by the different unit types from the improvements within the District. Utilizing the ERU -based benefit allocation method illustrated in Table 4, Table 5 in the Appendix to this Report illustrates the maximum allocation of costs of the improvements that comprise the Improvement Plan and are estimated by the Project Engineer to total $14,738,725 to all land uses projected to be developed in the District. Please note that it is possible that in order to facilitate the marketing of the land in the Development, the Developer may request that the City limits the principal amount of the actual Bonds issued by the City to certain predetermined levels , which in turn w ould limit the amount of costs of the Improvement Plan which would be funded with proceeds of such actual Bonds issued by the City. If that were the case, i n order to accompli sh that goal, the Developer w ould have to agree to contribute to the City or another public entity, for the benefit of land within the District and at no cost , completed infrastructure improvements amounting to the numerical difference between the total cost of the Improvement Plan at $14,738,725 and the cost of that portion of the Improvement Plan financed with proceeds of the actual Bonds issued by the City. As an example, if the Developer wanted to limit the total amount of the actual Bonds issued to fund a portion of the costs of the Improvement Plan in the amount of $8,587,650 and also to limit the allocations of the infrastructure costs to the various parcels as illustrated in Table 6 in the Appendix to this Report, the Developer would have to contribute to City or another public entity, for the benefit of land within the District, at no cost to the City or such other public entity , completed infrastructure improvements valued at $6,151,075. Further, Table 6 illustrates that such contribution of infrastructure improvements would represent a partial “buy down” of infrastructure by the Developer on behalf of a particular parcel and by extension, would also represent a partial “ buy down” of special assessment s associated with repayment of the actual Bonds issued by the City. Assuming that the Developer did not contribute completed infrastructure as contemplated in the preceding paragraph, Table 7 in the Appendix to this Report illustrates the apportionment of the maximum special assessments associated with the Bonds (the “Bond Assessments”) as well as the maximum annual assessments required to pay the principal and interest payments on the Bonds to the parcels and land uses proposed to be developed within the District based on the benefit allocation proposed in Table 4. 8 5.3 District Administration and Bond Assessments Collection Provision of the infrastructure improvements that are part of the Improvement Plan within the District is possible only to the extent that such infrastructure improvements are funded by the City through issuance of the Bonds, and that for the purpose of repaying the Bonds, the City imposes the Bond Assessment s, which are collected by the County on the real estate tax bill and once collected, are remitted to the City, which in turn remits it to the trustee for the Bonds to be used to pay debt service on the Bonds. Consequently, the special benefits of the implementation of the Improvement Plan to the properties within the District would not be possible without the initial establishment and continued existence of the District . The existence of the District, its continued administration and collection of special assessment for repayment of the Bonds , therefore, have a logical connection to the special benefits received by lands within the District. Further, the Bond Assessments are included in the t rust estate for the Bonds from the perspective of the holders of the Bonds, and as long as the Bonds are outstanding, the existence of the District, its administration and c ollection of Bond A ssessments is in the vital interest of the holders of the Bonds. Moreover, the sale of any Bonds will be predicated upon the City’s ability to ensure that the Bond Assessments and any other security for the Bonds are able to be reliably collected over the period the Bonds will remain outstanding, thus requiring a mec hanism to administer the District and collect the Bond Assessments. In connection with the Bonds issued and Bond Assessments levied by the City, it is therefore logical that the costs of the District 's administration and collection of the Bond Assessments are directly related to the costs of infrastructure improvements that are part of the Improvement Plan and consequently also provide special benefits to all land in the District . Therefore, this Report proposes that the annual administrative budget of the District, which is expected to include the costs of collection of the Bond Assessments, is also funded by the properties within the District through the levy of special assessment s in direct proportion to the benefit derived by the various land uses fr om the infrastructure improvements that are part of the Improvement Plan , which in the context of this Report means in accordance with each land use’s ERU weight as illustrated in Table 4 in the Appendix to this Report. If, for instance and for the purpose of illustration, the initial year’s annual costs of the District's administration and c ollection of the 9 Bond A ssessments is $50,000 , then that year’s assessment s for administration and collection of the Bond Assessments (the “Annual Administrative Assessment s”) per ERU would be $38.21. The Annual Administrative Assessment s would change from year -to- year based on the projected costs of the District's administration and collection of special assessment s, and the maximum Annual Administrative Assessments at the time of maturity of the Bonds, as projected under this proposed master financing plan, is illustrated in Table 8 in the Appendix to this Report . Table 8 additionally illustrates the maximum apportionment of the annual payment for the Bond Assessment (the “Annual Bond Assessment s Payment”) when combined with the Annual Administrative Assessment s. Exhibit “B” presents the schedule of maximum annual assessments. 5.4 Lienability Test: Special Benefit to the Property As first discussed in Section 1.3 , Special Benefits and General Benefits, the implementation of the Improvement Plan provides special benefits to properties within the District. The improvements that are part of the Improvement Plan benefit all assessable properties within the District and accrue to all such properties on an ERU basis. The Improvement Plan can be shown to be creating special benefits to the properties within the District. The se special benefits resulting from each improvement are: a. added use of the property; b. added enjoyment of the property; c. decreased insurance premiums; d. increased marketability and value of the property. The improvements that are part of the Improvement Plan make the land in the District developable and saleable and provide spe cial benefits which are greater than the benefits of any single category of improvements. These special benefits are real and ascertainable, but not yet capable of being calculated and assessed in terms of numerical value; however, such benefits are more valuable than either the cost of, or the actual special assessment levied for, the improvement or debt allocated to a parcel of land. 10 5.5 Lienability Test: Reasonable and Fair Apportionment of the Duty to Pay A reasonable estimate of the proportion of special benefits received from the provision of the Improvement Plan is delineated in Table 4. The apportionment of the special assessment is fair and reasonable because it was conducted on the basis of consistent application of the methodology described in Section 5.2 across all assessable property within the District according to reasonable estimates of the special benefits derived from the improvements that are part of the Improvement Plan. Accordingly, no acre or parcel of property within the District will be liened for the payment of any special assessment more than the determined special benefit particular to that property. 5.6 True-Up Mechanism The Assessment Methodology described herein is based on conceptual information obtained from the Developer prior to platting, development and construction of units of the various land uses within the District . As development occurs it is possible that the land uses and the numbers of units of each may change. The mechanism for maintaining the methodology over the changes is referred to as true-up. All changes to the number of units within parcels will be permitted subject to the following true-up mechanism. If a particular parcel of land has been designated for, for instance, 150 multi -family residential dwelling units and the final number of multi -family residential dwelling units at the conclusion of development of such parcel equals 155, that parcel w ill still be subject to the payment of both the Annual Bond Assessment s Payment and Annual Administrative Assessment s based on its original 150 multi -family residential dwelling units; however, that will also automatically reduce that parcel’s allocation o f both assessments on a per unit basis in direct proportion to the increase in the number of units over the projection contained in this Report. The rationale for this adjustment is that the increase in the final number of units and increase in developmen t density did not require any additional infrastructure within the District, and so the property owner should not have to pay any additional cost. Conversely, if a particular parcel of land has been designated for, for instance, 44,600 sq. ft. of commercial/retail uses and the final number of sq. ft. of commercial/retail uses at the conclusion of 11 development of such parcel equals 44,000 sq. ft., that parcel will still be subject to the payment of both the Annual Bond Assessments Payment and Annu al Administrative Assessment s based on its original 44,600 sq. ft. of commercial/retail uses; however, that will also automatically increase that parcel’s allocation of both assessments on a per sq. ft. basis in direct proportion to the decrease in the num ber of sq. ft. over the projection contained in this Report. The rationale for this adjustment is that the decrease in the final number of sq. ft and decrease in development density did not diminish the obligations under the Improvement Plan of providing this parcel of land with infrastructure sufficient to serve the needs of that parcel based on the original and higher density of development and did not decrease the costs of providing same pursuant to the Improvement Plan. The number of units and types of residential land uses as well as the number of sq. ft. of commercial/retails land uses within each parcel will be certified to the City by the Developer. 5.7 Assessment Roll Until platting and development occurs and the Bond Assessments and Annual Administrative Assessment s can be apportioned to specific parcels of land as reflected in Tables 7 and 8, th e Bond Assessments, Annual Bond Assessment s and Annual Administrative Assessments are proposed to be levied on an equal gross acre basis within each parcel shown in Exhibit “C”. Please note that as parcels are subdivided, notwithstanding the true-up provisions outlined in Section 5.6 , the Bond Assessments and Administrative Assessments will be apportioned to each subdivided parcel on a first subdivided -first assigned basis in the manner described in this Report , that is based on the land use and the number of units/square feet for that subdivided parcel as reflected in Tables 7 and 8. The sum of the Bond Assessments and Administrat ive Assessments on the subdivided parcels after such subdivision shall be equal to the total of all lots and parcels after subdivision based upon their land use and individual assessment levels as detailed in this Report. 12 6.0 Additional Stipulations 6.1 Overview Wrathell, Hunt and Associates, LLC was retained by the D eveloper to prepare a methodology to fairly allocate the special assessments related to the Improvement Plan . Certain financing, development and engineering data was provided by the Developer and the Project Engineer . The allocation Methodology described herein was based on information provided by those professionals. Wrathell, Hunt and Associates, LLC makes no representations regarding said information beyond restatement of the fact ual information necessary for compilation of this Report. Wrathell, Hunt and Associates, LLC does not represent the City as a Municipal Advisor or Securities Broker nor is Wrathell, Hunt and Associates, LLC registered to provide such services as described in Section 15B of the Securities and Exchange Act of 1934, as amended. Similarly, Wrathell, Hunt and Associates, LLC does not provide the Developer or the City with financial advisory services or offer investment advice in any form. 13 7.0 Appendix Parcel Designation Land Use Parcel Size (Acres) Number of Units/Square Feet Residential 4A Multi Family 11.55 150 4B Multi Family 11.45 150 6 Single Family 23.01 72 16 Single Family 40.36 160 12B Single Family 134.03 435 18 Multi Family 40.00 240 Total Residential 260.40 1,207 Non-Residential 13 Commercial/Retail 23.15 231,500 14A Commercial/Retail 3.68 36,800 14B Commercial/Retail 4.46 44,600 Total Non-Residential 31.29 312,900 Total 291.69 Table 1 East Argent Municipal Improvement District Proposed Development Plan 14 Description Estimated Cost Phase 4 and 5A Loop Road Plans Paving, Grading and Earthwork $4,542,446 Sanitary Sewer $1,181,081 Water Distribution $665,830 Storm Drainage $955,313 Miscellaneous $1,077,408 Engineering Design, Permit and Construction Monitoring $421,104 Offsite Utilities Plans Paving, Grading and Earthwork $337,600 Sanitary Sewer $2,543,020 Water Distribution $147,672 Storm Drainage $23,493 Miscellaneous $306,829 Engineering Design, Permit and Construction Monitoring $167,931 Entryway and Roadway Hardscape and Landscaping Paving, Grading and Earthwork $723,745 Storm Drainage $354,618 Hardscape Walls and Landscaping $421,637 Highway 170 Signalization and Intersection Improvements $869,000 Total $14,738,725 Municipal Improvement District Proposed Infrastructure Improvements East Argent Table 2 15 Sources Bond Proceeds: Par Amount $18,200,000.00 Total Sources $18,200,000.00 Uses Project Fund Deposits: Project Fund $14,738,725.00 Other Fund Deposits: Debt Service Reserve Fund $1,274,000.00 Capitalized Interest Fund $1,274,000.00 Delivery Date Expenses: Costs of Issuance $911,050.00 Rounding $2,225.00 Total Uses $18,200,000.00 Table 3 East Argent Municipal Improvement District Preliminary Sources and Uses of Funds 16 Parcel Designation Land Use Number of Units/Square Feet ERU per Unit/1,000 Square Feet Total ERU Residential 4A Multi Family 150 0.80 120.00 4B Multi Family 150 0.80 120.00 6 Single Family 72 1.00 72.00 16 Single Family 160 1.00 160.00 12B Single Family 435 1.00 435.00 18 Multi Family 240 0.80 192.00 Total Residential 1,207 1,099.00 Non-Residential 13 Commercial/Retail 231,500 0.67 155.11 14A Commercial/Retail 36,800 0.67 24.66 14B Commercial/Retail 44,600 0.67 29.88 Total Non-Residential 312,900 209.64 Total 1,308.64 Table 4 East Argent Municipal Improvement District Proposed Benefit Allocation 17 Parcel Designation Land Use Number of Units/Square Feet Maximum ERU- Based Allocation of Infrastructure Improvements Residential 4A Multi Family 150 $1,351,512.22 4B Multi Family 150 $1,351,512.22 6 Single Family 72 $810,907.33 16 Single Family 160 $1,802,016.29 12B Single Family 435 $4,899,231.78 18 Multi Family 240 $2,162,419.54 Total Residential 1,207 $12,377,599.37 Non-Residential 13 Commercial/Retail 231,500 $1,746,885.85 14A Commercial/Retail 36,800 $277,690.71 14B Commercial/Retail 44,600 $336,549.07 Total Non-Residential 312,900 $2,361,125.63 Total $14,738,725.00 Municipal Improvement District Maximum Allocation of Benefit of Infrastructure Improvements East Argent Table 5 18 Parcel Designation Land Use Maximum ERU- Based Allocation of Infrastructure Improvements Example of Allocation of Infrastructure Improvements Funded by Bonds Example of Allocation of Infrastructure Improvements Funded by Developer Residential 4A Multi Family $1,351,512.22 $673,556.58 $677,955.64 4B Multi Family $1,351,512.22 $667,724.92 $683,787.30 6 Single Family $810,907.33 $429,396.69 $381,510.64 16 Single Family $1,802,016.29 $1,098,373.47 $703,642.82 12B Single Family $4,899,231.78 $2,501,175.07 $2,398,056.71 18 Multi Family $2,162,419.54 $1,088,576.28 $1,073,843.26 Total Residential $12,377,599.37 $6,458,803.01 $5,918,796.37 Non-Residential 13 Commercial/Retail $1,746,885.85 $1,575,033.81 $171,852.04 14A Commercial/Retail $277,690.71 $250,372.55 $27,318.16 14B Commercial/Retail $336,549.07 $303,440.64 $33,108.43 Total Non-Residential $2,361,125.63 $2,128,846.99 $232,278.63 Total $14,738,725.00 $8,587,650.00 $6,151,075.00 Example of Bond-Funded Infrastructure Improvements Cost Allocation with Developer Funding Table 6 East Argent Municipal Improvement District 19 Parcel Designation Land Use Maximum Bond Assessments Apportionment* Maximum Bond Assessments Apportionment per Unit/1,000 Square Feet Maximum Annual Bond Assessments Payment Apportionment per Unit/1,000 Square Feet Residential 4A Multi Family $1,668,904.35 $11,126.03 $898.12 4B Multi Family $1,668,904.35 $11,126.03 $898.12 6 Single Family $1,001,342.61 $13,907.54 $1,122.65 16 Single Family $2,225,205.80 $13,907.54 $1,122.65 12B Single Family $6,049,778.28 $13,907.54 $1,122.65 18 Multi Family $2,670,246.97 $11,126.03 $898.12 Total Residential $15,284,382.37 Non-Residential 13 Commercial/Retail $2,157,128.41 $9,318.05 $752.18 14A Commercial/Retail $342,904.21 $9,318.05 $752.18 14B Commercial/Retail $415,585.00 $9,318.05 $752.18 Total Non-Residential $2,915,617.63 Total $18,200,000.00 * Bond Assessments Apportionment is based on benefit allocation derived in Table 4 Table 7 East Argent Municipal Improvement District Maximum Bond Assessments Apportionment 20 Parcel Designation Land Use Maximum Annual Bond Assessments Payment Apportionment per Unit/1,000 Square Feet Maximum Annual Administrative Assessments Apportionment per Unit/1,000 Square Feet* Maximum Total Annual Assessments Apportionment per Unit/1,000 Square Feet Residential 4A Multi Family $898.12 $76.42 $974.54 4B Multi Family $898.12 $76.42 $974.54 6 Single Family $1,122.65 $95.52 $1,218.17 16 Single Family $1,122.65 $95.52 $1,218.17 12B Single Family $1,122.65 $95.52 $1,218.17 18 Multi Family $898.12 $76.42 $974.54 Total Residential Non-Residential 13 Commercial/Retail $752.18 $64.00 $816.18 14A Commercial/Retail $752.18 $64.00 $816.18 14B Commercial/Retail $752.18 $64.00 $816.18 Total Non-Residential Municipal Improvement District Maximum Total Assessments Apportionment Including Administration * Please note that the amount of the Annual Administrative Assessments is based on the initial annual administrative expense cost of $50,000 at the time of issuance of the bonds, one-year capitalized interest period, thirty-year bond repayment period and an annual cost increase rate of 3.00% Table 8 East Argent Exhibit “A” Payment Date Principal Coupon Rate Interest Capitalized Interest Net Debt Service Bond Balance 11/01/21 $18,200,000.00 11/01/22 7.000% $1,274,000.00 $1,274,000.00 $0.00 $18,200,000.00 11/01/23 $195,000.00 7.000% $1,274,000.00 $1,469,000.00 $18,005,000.00 11/01/24 $205,000.00 7.000% $1,260,350.00 $1,465,350.00 $17,800,000.00 11/01/25 $220,000.00 7.000% $1,246,000.00 $1,466,000.00 $17,580,000.00 11/01/26 $235,000.00 7.000% $1,230,600.00 $1,465,600.00 $17,345,000.00 11/01/27 $255,000.00 7.000% $1,214,150.00 $1,469,150.00 $17,090,000.00 11/01/28 $270,000.00 7.000% $1,196,300.00 $1,466,300.00 $16,820,000.00 11/01/29 $290,000.00 7.000% $1,177,400.00 $1,467,400.00 $16,530,000.00 11/01/30 $310,000.00 7.000% $1,157,100.00 $1,467,100.00 $16,220,000.00 11/01/31 $330,000.00 7.000% $1,135,400.00 $1,465,400.00 $15,890,000.00 11/01/32 $355,000.00 7.000% $1,112,300.00 $1,467,300.00 $15,535,000.00 11/01/33 $380,000.00 7.000% $1,087,450.00 $1,467,450.00 $15,155,000.00 11/01/34 $405,000.00 7.000% $1,060,850.00 $1,465,850.00 $14,750,000.00 11/01/35 $435,000.00 7.000% $1,032,500.00 $1,467,500.00 $14,315,000.00 11/01/36 $465,000.00 7.000% $1,002,050.00 $1,467,050.00 $13,850,000.00 11/01/37 $495,000.00 7.000% $969,500.00 $1,464,500.00 $13,355,000.00 11/01/38 $530,000.00 7.000% $934,850.00 $1,464,850.00 $12,825,000.00 11/01/39 $570,000.00 7.000% $897,750.00 $1,467,750.00 $12,255,000.00 11/01/40 $610,000.00 7.000% $857,850.00 $1,467,850.00 $11,645,000.00 11/01/41 $650,000.00 7.000% $815,150.00 $1,465,150.00 $10,995,000.00 11/01/42 $695,000.00 7.000% $769,650.00 $1,464,650.00 $10,300,000.00 11/01/43 $745,000.00 7.000% $721,000.00 $1,466,000.00 $9,555,000.00 11/01/44 $800,000.00 7.000% $668,850.00 $1,468,850.00 $8,755,000.00 11/01/45 $855,000.00 7.000% $612,850.00 $1,467,850.00 $7,900,000.00 11/01/46 $915,000.00 7.000% $553,000.00 $1,468,000.00 $6,985,000.00 11/01/47 $975,000.00 7.000% $488,950.00 $1,463,950.00 $6,010,000.00 11/01/48 $1,045,000.00 7.000% $420,700.00 $1,465,700.00 $4,965,000.00 11/01/49 $1,120,000.00 7.000% $347,550.00 $1,467,550.00 $3,845,000.00 11/01/50 $1,195,000.00 7.000% $269,150.00 $1,464,150.00 $2,650,000.00 11/01/51 $1,280,000.00 7.000% $185,500.00 $1,465,500.00 $1,370,000.00 11/01/52 $1,370,000.00 7.000% $95,900.00 $1,465,900.00 $0.00 Total $18,200,000.00 $27,068,650.00 $1,274,000.00 $43,994,650.00 East Argent Municipal Improvement District Preliminary Amortization Schedule Exhibit “B” Assessment Year Principal Portion of Bond Assessments Interest Portion of Bond Assessments Administrative Assessments Total Annual Assessments 2020 - 2021 $0.00 $0.00 $50,000.00 $50,000.00 2021 - 2022 $0.00 $1,274,000.00 $51,500.00 $1,325,500.00 2022 - 2023 $195,000.00 $1,274,000.00 $53,045.00 $1,522,045.00 2023 - 2024 $205,000.00 $1,260,350.00 $54,636.35 $1,519,986.35 2024 - 2025 $220,000.00 $1,246,000.00 $56,275.44 $1,522,275.44 2025 - 2026 $235,000.00 $1,230,600.00 $57,963.70 $1,523,563.70 2026 - 2027 $255,000.00 $1,214,150.00 $59,702.61 $1,528,852.61 2027 - 2028 $270,000.00 $1,196,300.00 $61,493.69 $1,527,793.69 2028 - 2029 $290,000.00 $1,177,400.00 $63,338.50 $1,530,738.50 2029 - 2030 $310,000.00 $1,157,100.00 $65,238.66 $1,532,338.66 2030 - 2031 $330,000.00 $1,135,400.00 $67,195.82 $1,532,595.82 2031 - 2032 $355,000.00 $1,112,300.00 $69,211.69 $1,536,511.69 2032 - 2033 $380,000.00 $1,087,450.00 $71,288.04 $1,538,738.04 2033 - 2034 $405,000.00 $1,060,850.00 $73,426.69 $1,539,276.69 2034 - 2035 $435,000.00 $1,032,500.00 $75,629.49 $1,543,129.49 2035 - 2036 $465,000.00 $1,002,050.00 $77,898.37 $1,544,948.37 2036 - 2037 $495,000.00 $969,500.00 $80,235.32 $1,544,735.32 2037 - 2038 $530,000.00 $934,850.00 $82,642.38 $1,547,492.38 2038 - 2039 $570,000.00 $897,750.00 $85,121.65 $1,552,871.65 2039 - 2040 $610,000.00 $857,850.00 $87,675.30 $1,555,525.30 2040 - 2041 $650,000.00 $815,150.00 $90,305.56 $1,555,455.56 2041 - 2042 $695,000.00 $769,650.00 $93,014.73 $1,557,664.73 2042 - 2043 $745,000.00 $721,000.00 $95,805.17 $1,561,805.17 2043 - 2044 $800,000.00 $668,850.00 $98,679.33 $1,567,529.33 2044 - 2045 $855,000.00 $612,850.00 $101,639.71 $1,569,489.71 2045 - 2046 $915,000.00 $553,000.00 $104,688.90 $1,572,688.90 2046 - 2047 $975,000.00 $488,950.00 $107,829.56 $1,571,779.56 2047 - 2048 $1,045,000.00 $420,700.00 $111,064.45 $1,576,764.45 2048 - 2049 $1,120,000.00 $347,550.00 $114,396.38 $1,581,946.38 2049 - 2050 $1,195,000.00 $269,150.00 $117,828.28 $1,581,978.28 2050 - 2051 $1,280,000.00 $185,500.00 $121,363.12 $1,586,863.12 2051 - 2052 $1,370,000.00 $95,900.00 $125,004.02 $1,590,904.02 Total $18,200,000.00 $27,068,650.00 $2,625,137.93 $47,893,787.93 Maximum Annual Assessments East Argent Municipal Improvement District Exhibit “C” Owner Name Parcel Designation Tax Map No. Land Use Upland Acres Number of Units/Square Feet Principal Portion of Maximum Bond Assessments Apportionment Interest Portion of Maximum Bond Assessments Apportionment Administrative Assessments Apportionment Maximum Total Assessments Maximum Annual Bond Assessments Maximum Annual Administrative Assessments* Maximum Total Annual Assessments Argent Land Holdings, LLC 4A 066-00-00-015 Multi Family 11.55 150 $1,668,904.35 $2,482,142.19 $240,720.01 $4,391,766.55 $134,718.18 $11,462.62 $146,180.80 Argent Land Holdings, LLC 4B 081-00-01-036 Multi Family 11.45 150 $1,668,904.35 $2,482,142.19 $240,720.01 $4,391,766.55 $134,718.18 $11,462.62 $146,180.80 Argent Land Holdings, LLC 13 081-00-01-039 Commercial/Retail 23.15 231,500 $2,157,128.41 $3,208,272.20 $311,140.64 $5,676,541.25 $174,128.86 $14,815.92 $188,944.78 Argent Land Holdings, LLC 14A 066-00-00-013 Commercial/Retail 3.68 36,800 $342,904.21 $509,997.48 $49,459.94 $902,361.63 $27,680.09 $2,355.19 $30,035.28 Argent Land Holdings, LLC 14B 081-00-01-038 Commercial/Retail 4.46 44,600 $415,585.00 $618,094.77 $59,943.29 $1,093,623.07 $33,547.07 $2,854.38 $36,401.46 Argent Land Holdings, LLC 18 066-00-00-003 Multi Family 40 240 $2,670,246.97 $3,971,427.50 $385,152.01 $7,026,826.48 $215,549.08 $18,340.20 $233,889.28 Argent TH B, LLC 6 066-00-00-012 Single Family 23.01 72 $1,001,342.61 $1,489,285.31 $144,432.00 $2,635,059.93 $80,830.91 $6,877.57 $87,708.48 RF Development, LLC 16 066-00-00-017 Single Family 40.36 160 $2,225,205.80 $3,309,522.92 $320,960.01 $5,855,688.73 $179,624.24 $15,283.50 $194,907.73 RF Development II, LLC 12B Portion of 066-00-00-016 Single Family 134.03 435 $6,049,778.28 $8,997,765.43 $872,610.02 $15,920,153.74 $488,353.39 $41,552.01 $529,905.40 Total 291.69 $18,200,000.00 $27,068,650.00 $2,625,137.93 $47,893,787.93 $1,469,150.00 $125,004.02 $1,594,154.02 * Please note that the amount of the Annual AdministrativeAssessments is based on the initial annual administrative expense cost of $50,000 at the time of issuance of the bonds, one-year capitalized interest period, thirty-year bond repayment period and an annual cost increase rate of 3.00%; please note that the actual allocation of the Annual Administrative Assessments may be different from the allocation shown herein as the Developer may voluntarily fund the Annual Administrative Assessments for selected parcel of his choice by accepting higher Annual Administrative Assessments on parcels owned by the Developer Assessment Roll East Argent Municipal Improvement District CITY COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM _________________________________________ SUBJECT: AN ORDINANCE OF TH E CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA, A PPROVING THE ASSESSMENT ROLL AND MASTER ASSESSMENT METHODOLOGY FOR ESTABLISHMENT OF THE EA ST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT AND OTHER MATTERS RELATING THERETO. DEPARTMENT: CMO/City Attorney ATTACHMENTS: Ordinance X _ Resolution ___ Motion _X_ Support Documents ___ Appointment ___ Other ______________________________________________________________________________ SUMMARY: The City and its attorneys and consultant s have been working cooperatively with Argent Land Holdings LLC, the primary owner and master devel oper, of the East Argent tract to establish a municipal improvement district to pay for a portion of the infrastructure within the development. The City held the required public hearin g on October 15 th for the petition to create the district and the proposed improvement plan. The MID would allocate the cost o f the proposed improvements (road, sanitary sewer, and water) to approximately 400 acres within the development. SC law requires the establishment of the improvement district and the apportion of costs to benefitting property ow ners based upon a special assessment methodology report. The proposed Ord inance approves the master assessment metho dology and the assessments for the East Argent improvements. ______________________________________________________________________ RECOMMENDED ACTION: ADOPT Ordinance at second reading which is 2020-12- 10D AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA, APPROVING THE ASSESSMENT ROLL AND MASTER ASSESSMENT METHODOLOGY FOR ESTABLISHMENT OF THE EAST ARGENT IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT AND OTHER MATTERS RELATING THERETO. _____________________________________________________________________________ DEPARTMENT Submitted: ____M Czymbor__________ Date: 12/10/20 Requested Agenda ___City Council____ Date: 1/7/21 FINANCE DEPARTMENT Budgeted ___Yes ___No ___N/A Date: CITY ATTORNEY Approved as to Form and Correctness Date: CITY MANAGER Approved Agenda Item For: Date: ______________________________________________________________________________ COUNCIL ACTION: Approved as Recommended Disapproved Approved with Modification ___ Tabled to Time Certain ___ Other ______________________________________________________________________________ CITY COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM SUBJECT: AN ORDINANCE TO ADOPT A MASTER PLAN SUBMITTAL FOR A TRACT OF LAND CONSISTING OF APPROXIMATELY +/ - 197 ACRES, KNOWN GENERALLY AS THE HUNT CLUB AT EAST ARGENT LOCATED OFF OF EAST ARGENT LOOP ROAD AND JASPER STATION ROAD AND TO AMEND THE OFFICIAL ZONING MAP OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE TO INDICATE THAT PORTION SUBJECT TO THE MASTER PLAN DEPARTMENT: Planning ATTACHMENTS: x Ordinance _ Resolution Motion Support Documents Appointment Other SUMMARY: The applicant is requesting approval of a Master Plan for a 500 unit, single- family development to be known as Hunt Club. The project site is a total of 197 acres located in the East Argent Planned Development District (PDD). The project site is located off of East Argent Parkway and is proposed to be a single-family residential development by Forino Co. LP. The site is currently vacant and undeveloped. The parcels are located in the East Argent PDD near the Retreat at East Argent project site which was previously approved for a Master Plan and recently received Site Development approval. The proposed development has two access points. One access is located off of East Argent Parkway and the other access is located off of Jasper Station Road. The proposed Master Plan consists of approximately 197 acres proposed to be developed as a single-family residential community. The Master Plan illustrates a general lot layout, road layout, utilities, open space and stormwater facilities. The use proposed in this application is consistent with goals of the Land Use Element which aims to increase housing choice as well as encouraging mixed use developments. The East Argent PDD will be a mixed use development consisting of residential and commercial uses. The applicant is proposing a minimum of a 50’ buffer from East Argent Parkway. This buffer is not a requirement and exceeds the requirements of the PDD. Additionally, the applicant is proposing 36% open space within their development. The PDD requires 10% total open space; therefore, the applicant is exceeding the open space requirements of the PDD. A community trail as well as sidewalks have been provided throughout the site. The plan also provides an amenities site which will consist of a clubhouse, pool, fitness facility, and other potential amenities. The City’s MZDO promotes the incorporation of open space into new developments and master plans, which is critical in preserving wetlands and other natural areas. Open space within a development also provides its citizens with the opportunity to enjoy recreation without leaving their community, resulting in decreased roadway congestion. The Land Use Element of the Comprehensive Plan and the Natural Resources Element state that open space should be a component of every development. Based on recommendations from the City’s Comprehensive Plan and the requirements of the East Argent PDD, Staff finds that the applicant has met the requirements for open space and amenities. Staff and Planning Commission recommend the proposed plan be accepted as presented. RECOMMENDED ACTION: Adopt Ordinance 2020-12-10E at second reading DEPARTMENT Submitted: Requested Agenda Planning Date: 12-10-20 City Council Date: 1 -7-21 FINANCE DEPARTMENT Budgeted Yes No _x_N/A Date: CITY ATTORNEY Approved as to Form and Correctness Date: CITY MANAGER Approved Agenda Item For: Date: COUNCIL ACTION: Approved as Recommended Approved With Modification Other Disapproved Tabled To Time Certain This map was created using geothinQ | www.geothinQ.com | Mapping Smart Land Decisions EAST ARGEMT IMP's LOCATION MAP 11/16/2020 - 1 - STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA ) ) ORDINANCE NUMBER: 2020-12-10E CITY OF HARDEEVILLE ) AN ORDINANCE TO ADOPT A MASTER PLAN SUBMITTAL FOR A TRACT OF LAND CONSISTING OF APPROXIMATELY +/- 197 ACRES, KNOWN GENERALLY AS THE HUNT CLUB AT EAST ARGENT LOCATED OFF OF EAST ARGENT LOOP ROAD AND JASPER STATION ROAD AND TO AMEND THE OFFICIAL ZONING MAP OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE TO INDICATE THAT PORTION SUBJECT TO THE MASTER PLAN WHEREAS, the City of Hardeeville has received a request from the owner of a tract of land consisting of approximately 197 acres known generally as the Hunt Club, to amend a Master Plan for the property; and WHEREAS, the above-mentioned property was duly noticed and public meeting held by the Hardeeville Planning Commission which has recommended unanimous approval of the Master Plan; and WHEREAS, the City Council finds the Master Plan and Map Amendment to be consistent with the Comprehensive Plan, Development Agreement and the Conceptual Master Plan previously adopted with the East Argent PDD, and in accordance with the statutory requirements of the State and of the City’s Municipal Zoning and Development Ordinance; NOW THEREFORE, the Hardeeville City Council, in council session meeting duly assembled, does hereby find sufficient reason and cause to approve the applicant’s request for the Master Plan for the property described in the attachment, and to amend the Official Zoning Map of the City to reflect that the East argent Tract PDD contains this Master Plan. Signature Page to Follow - 2 - SO ORDERED AND ORDAINED this _____________ day of __________, 2021 By the Hardeeville City Council being duly and lawfully assembled. ______________________________ Harry Williams, Mayor Attest:_______________________ Approved as to form:______________________ Lori Pomarico, City Clerk Prina Maines, City Attorney (Seal) First Reading:________________________ Public Hearings:______________________ Second Reading:______________________ Planning Commission__________________ This map was created using geothinQ | www.geothinQ.com | Mapping Smart Land Decisions EAST ARGEMT IMP's LOCATION MAP 11/16/2020 - 1 - STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA ) ) ORDINANCE NUMBER: 2020-12-10F CITY OF HARDEEVILLE ) AN ORDINANCE TO ADOPT A MASTER PLAN SUBMITTAL FOR A TRACT OF LAND CONSISTING OF APPROXIMATELY +/ - 50.55 ACRES, KNOWN GENERALLY AS THE POINTE GRAND AT EAST ARGENT LOCATED OFF OF EAST ARGENT LOOP ROAD AND JASPER STATION ROAD AND TO AMEND THE OFFICIAL ZONING MAP OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE TO INDICATE THAT PORTION SUBJECT TO THE MASTER PLAN WHEREAS, the City of Hardeeville has received a request from the owner of a tract of land consisting of approximately 50.55 acres known generally as the Pointe Grand, to amend a Master Plan for the property; and WHEREAS, the above-mentioned property was duly noticed and public meeting held by the Hardeeville Planning Commission which has recommended unanimous approval of the Master Plan; and WHEREAS, the City Council finds the Master Plan and Map Amendment to be consistent with the Comprehensive Plan, Development Agreement and the Conceptual Master Plan previously adopted with the East Argent PDD, and in accordance with the statutory requirements of the State and of the City’s Municipal Zoning and Development Ordinance; NOW THEREFORE, the Hardeeville City Council, in council session meeting duly assembled, does hereby find sufficient reason and cause to approve the applicant’s request for the Master Plan for the property described in the attachment, and to amend the Official Zoning Map of the City to reflect that the East argent Tract PDD contains this Master Plan. Signature Page to Follow - 2 - SO ORDERED AND ORDAINED this _____________ day of __________, 2021 By the Hardeeville City Council being duly and lawfully assembled. ______________________________ Harry Williams, Mayor Attest:_______________________ Approved as to form:______________________ Lori Pomarico, City Clerk Prina Maines, City Attorney (Seal) First Reading:________________________ Public Hearings:______________________ Second Reading:______________________ Planning Commission__________________ CITY COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM SUBJECT: AN ORDINANCE TO ADOPT A MASTER PLAN SUBMITTAL FOR A TRACT OF LAND CONSISTING OF APPROXIMATELY +/ - 50.55 ACRES, KNOWN GENERALLY AS POINTE GRAND AT EAST ARGENT LOCATED OFF OF EAST ARGENT LOOP ROAD AND TO AMEND THE OFFICIAL ZONING MAP OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE TO INDICATE THAT PORTION SUBJECT TO THE MASTER PLAN DEPARTMENT: Planning ATTACHMENTS: x Ordinance _ Resolution Motion Support Documents Appointment Other SUMMARY: The applicant is requesting approval of a Master Plan for a 312 unit, multi- family development to be known as Pointe Grand Apartments. The project site is a total of 50.55 acres located in the East Argent Planned Development District (PDD). The project site is located off of East Argent Parkway and is proposed to be a multi-family residential development by Hillpointe, LLC. The site is currently vacant and undeveloped. The parcels are located in the East Argent PDD just over a half mile from SC170. The site is located near the Mansions Independent Living project which was previously approved for a Master Plan and recently received a Site Development Permit. The proposed development has two access points off of East Argent Parkway. One access is a full access and the second is right in, right out only. The proposed Master Plan consists of approximately 50 acres proposed to be developed as a multi-family residential community. The Master Plan illustrates a general lot layout, road layout, utilities, open space and stormwater facilities. The use proposed in this application is consistent with goals of the Land Use Element which aims to increase housing choice as well as encouraging mixed use developments. The East Argent PDD will be a mixed use development consisting of residential and commercial uses. The applicant is proposing a minimum of a 50’ buffer from East Argent Parkway. This buffer is not a requirement and exceeds the requirements of the PDD. Additionally, the applicant is proposing 53% open space within their development. The PDD requires 10% total open space; therefore, the applicant is exceeding the open space requirements of the PDD. A community trail as well as sidewalks have been provided throughout the site. The plan also provides a park site and a separate amenities site. The City’s MZDO promotes the incorporation of open space into new developments and master plans, which is critical in preserving wetlands and other natural areas. Open space within a development also provides its citizens with the opportunity to enjoy recreation without leaving their community, resulting in decreased roadway congestion. The Land Use Element of the Comprehensive Plan and the Natural Resources Element state that open space should be a component of every development. Based on recommendations from the City’s Comprehensive Plan and the requirements of the East Argent PDD, Staff finds that the applicant has met the requirements for open space and amenities. Staff and Planning Commission recommend the proposed plan be accepted as presented. RECOMMENDED ACTION: Adopt Ordinance 2020-12-10F at second reading DEPARTMENT Submitted: Requested Agenda Planning Date: 12-10-20 City Council Date: 1 -7-21 FINANCE DEPARTMENT Budgeted Yes No _x_N/A Date: CITY ATTORNEY Approved as to Form and Correctness Date: CITY MANAGER Approved Agenda Item For: Date: COUNCIL ACTION: Approved as Recommended Approved With Modification Other Disapproved Tabled To Time Certain Draft Dated October 22, 2020 ORDINANCE NO: 2020-11-5A AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA ESTABLISHING THE EXIT 3 REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA; MAKING CERTAIN FINDINGS OF AN “AGRICULTURAL AREA” AND A “BLIGHTED AREA” WITHIN THE EXIT 3 REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA; DESIGNATING AND DEFINING REDEVELOPMENT PROJECTS CONSISTING OF PUBLIC IMPROVEMENTS WITHIN THE EXIT 3 REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA; DESIGNATING APPROPRIATE REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT COSTS; APPROVING AN OVERALL REDEVELOPMENT PLAN; AND OTHER MATTERS RELATED THERETO. WHEREAS, the City of Hardeeville, South Carolina (the “City”) is a municipality of the State of South Carolina (the “State”), and as such, possesses certain p owers granted by the Constitution and general laws of the State; and WHEREAS, Title 31, Chapter 6 of the Code of Laws of South Carolina 1976, as amended ( the "TIF Act") is intended to promote and protect the health, safety, morals and welfare of the publi c by providing a mechanism to allow municipalities to respond to the challenges posed by an “Agricultural area” and a “Blighted area”(each within the meaning of the TIF Act) within its boundaries to encourage private investment and restore the tax base in areas where agriculture uses and blight are present; and WHEREAS, Section 31-6-30 of the T IF Act describes the qualities present in an area which permit establishment of a “Redevelopment project area” (within the meaning of the TIF Act); and WHEREAS, the r edevelopment project area, described in the Redevelopment Plan Exit 3 Redevelopment Project Area, a copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit A and made a part hereof (the “Redevelopment Plan”) encompasses those cer tain parcels of real property in Jasper County, South Carolina (the “County”), within the corporate limits of the City, comprising approximately 1,608.30 acres of real property (the “ Exit 3 Redevelopment Project Area”). All parcels of real property within the Exit 3 Redevelopment Project Area are vacant and are classified by the Jasper County Property Assessor as Rural Agriculture. The Exit 3 Redevelopment Project Area is an “Agricultural area” and a “Blighted area” (each within the meaning of the TIF Act) having those qualities set forth at Sections 31-6-30(1)(a) and (b) and 31-6- 30(1.5) of the TIF Act; and WHEREAS, the City Council of the City (“City Council”) finds that sound growth of lands located in the Exit 3 Redevelopment Project Area is impaired by obsolete platting, lack of necessary transportation infrastructure, lack of water or wastewater, lack of storm drainage facilities, inadequate electric and natural gas energy services, and lack of modern communications infrastructure; and WHEREAS, the City C ouncil has acknowledged the need to redevelop the Exit 3 Redevelopment Project Area in a manner that will create sound economic development opportunities and improve the quality of life in neighborhoods located in and adjacent to the Exit 3 Redevelopment Project Area , and hereby determines that the re development of the Exit 3 Redevelopment Project Area through public investment in infrastructure improvements is in the best interests of the public health, safety, morals, or welfare of the residents and citizens of the City; and WHEREAS, the City Council has been advised of the opportunity to induce private development of parcels within the Exit 3 Redevelopment Project Area by the undertaking the following improvements all of which will be located in the City (collectively, the “Redevelopment Projects”): (a) a new interchange at Exit 3 2 on I–95, including all related drainage and storm water and infrastructure; (b) an approximately 1.5-mile stretch of RiverPort Parkway north of I –95, including all related drainage and storm water infrastructure; and (c) an approximately 4-mile stretch of RiverPort Parkway south of I –95, including all related drainage and storm water infrastructure, all as more fully set forth in the Redevelopment Plan; and WHEREAS, the total costs of the Redevelopme nt Projects is estimated to be $88,400,000 as more particularly described in the Redevelopment Plan; and WHEREAS, as described at Section 31-6-20(5) of the TIF Act, the use of incremental tax revenues to be derived from the tax rates of the City, the County and Jasper County School District (the “School District”) in the Exit 3 Redevelopment Project Area for the payment of redevelopment project costs to be incurred by the City solely for public improvements is of benefit to the taxing districts inasmuch as such taxing districts would not derive the benefits of an increased assessment base without the benefits of tax increment financing and all such taxing districts benefit from the redevelopment of the Exit 3 Redevelopment Project Area; and WHEREAS, the City Council has determined to avail itself of the authorization contained in the T IF Act in order t o accomplish redevelopment of the Exit 3 Redevelopment Project Area and adjoining areas in accordance with the Redevelopment Plan; and [WHEREAS, pursuant to Section 31-7-120 of the Code of Laws of South Carolina 1976, as amended, the City and the County are adopting the Redevelopment Plan jointly through an the Intergovernmental Agreement to be entered into between the City and the County (the “County Intergovernmental Agreement”) in substantially the form presented to the City Council at this meeting; and] WHEREAS, pursuant to Section 31- 6-80(B) of the TIF Act, (i) at its meeting on November 5, 2020, the City Council conducted a public hearing related to the Exit 3 Redevelopment Project Area after publishing notice thereof in the Jasper County Sun on October 14, 2020, and (ii) such notice was published in the publication above not less than 15 nor more than 30 days prior to the date fixed for the hearing; and WHEREAS, pursuant to Section 31-6-80(C) of the TIF Act, (i) on September 18, 2020 notice of the November 5, 2020 public hearing was given by the City to representatives of the County and the School District, which are all of the other taxing districts which have ta xable property included in the Exit 3 Redevelopment Project Area, and (ii) such notice was given by the City to such taxing districts not less than 45 days prior to the date set for the public hearing; and WHEREAS, as a condition to the School District providing its consent to the Redevelopment Plan, the School District is requiring the City to enter an Intergovernmental Agreement with the School District (the “School District Intergovernmental Agreement”) in substantially the form presented to the City Council at this meeting; and WHEREAS, the Redevelopment Plan will afford maximum opportunity for the redevelopment of the Exit 3 Redevelopment Project Area by private enterprise in a manner consistent with the needs of the City. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT O RDAINED BY THE CITY C OUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA: 3 SECTION 1 . The City Council confirms all the findings of fact contained in the recitals of this Ordinance. SECTION 2. The City Council, based upon evidence presented to it and in the public record, does hereby expressly find that (a) (i) redevelopment and sound growth of real property located in the Exit 3 Redevelopment Project Area is impaired by obsolete platting, lack of necessary transportation infrastructure, lack of water or wastewater, lack of storm drainage facilities, inadequate electric and natural gas energy services, and lack of modern communications infrastructure ; and ( ii) therefore, an “Agricultural area” and a “Blighted area” (each within the meaning of the TIF Act) exist within the Exit Redevelopment Project Area, and (b) the portions of the Redevelopment Projects located outside of the Exit 3 Redevelopment Project Area will benefit the Exit 3 Redevelopment Project Area. SECTION 3. Pursuant to Section 31- 6-80(A)(1) of the T IF Act, the City Council does hereby expressly approve the Redevelopment Plan attached hereto and incorporated herein as Exhibit A, which plan contains a statement of the objectives of the City with regard to the plan. SECTION 4. Pursuant to Section 31- 6-80(A)(2) of the T IF Act, the City Council finds that tax increment financing is needed to help reverse the existing conditions of the property in the Exit 3 Redevelopment Project Area through the funding sources described therein which will be used for the Redevelopment Projects as more particularly described in the Redevelopment Plan. SECTION 5. Pursuant to Section 31-6-80(A)(3) of the TIF Act, the City Council does hereby approve the cost estimates of the Redevelopment Plan and Redevelopment Projects and the projected sources of revenue to be used to meet the cost including estimates of tax increments and estimates of the total amount of indebtedness to be incurred all as set forth in the Redevelopment Plan. SECTION 6. Pursuant to Section 31- 6-80(A)(4) of th e TIF Act, the boundaries of the Exit 3 Redevelopment Project Area and a list of all real property in the Exit 3 Redevelopment Project Area are as follows: ALL that certain piece, parcel and tract of land lying and being in the Hardeeville Tract, City of Hardeeville, County of Jasper, State of South Carolina, being shown and described as PARCEL 1 (1,808.32 Acres), PARCEL 2 (280.70 Acres), PARCEL 4 (179.72 Acres), PARCEL 5 (31.27 Acres), PARCEL 6 (469.07 Acres), PARCEL 7 (163.77 Acres) PARCEL 8 (288.62 Acres), PARCEL 9 (27.57 Acres), PARCEL 10 (247.70 Acres), PARCEL 11 (39.14 Acres), PARCEL 12 (692.89 Acres), PARCEL 13 (461.22 Acres), PARCEL A (202.78 Acres), PARCEL B-1 (140.54 Acres), PARCEL B-2 (35.02 Acres), PARCEL C-1 (66.88 Acres), and parcel referenced as “PARCEL 1.623 AC.” for a total of 5,136.83 acres, more or less; said property having dimensions, metes and bounds as shown on the Plat entitled “ALTA/ACSM LAND TITLE SURVEY OF THE HARDEEVILLE TRACT ((5,136.83 acre) CONTAINING PARCELS A, B -1, B-2, C-1, 1, 2, 4 thru 13, AND THE 1.623 AC. SITE ALONG U.S. HIGHWAY NO. 17,” known as the Hardeeville Tract, City of Hardeeville, Jasper County, South Carolina, said plat being dated 12/10/07, last revised 2/11/08, said plat pre pared by Thomas & Hutton Engineering Co., Savannah, Georgia, Boyce L. Young, S.C.R.L.S. No. 11079, and recorded in the Jasper County Records in Plat Book 30 at Pages 374-382. LESS AND EXCEPT PARCEL 1 (1,808.32 ACRES), EXCEPT FOR THAT 201.03 ACRE PORTION T O BE INCLUDED HAVING A METES AND BOUNDS DESCRIPTION AS FOLLOWS: 4 Beginning at a point at the intersection of CSX railroad 200’ r/w and SC highway s-27-34 (Purrysburg road) and having a state plane coordinate of n 155155.21 e 1966751.73; thence northerly along Purrysburg road n 25°18'00" w a distance of 974.56 feet to a point; thence with the arc of a curve turning to the right, having an arc length of 271.45 feet, a radius of 967.00 feet, a chord length of 270.56 feet, and a chord bearing n 17°15'29" w to a point; thence n 09°12'58" w a distance of 288.94 feet to a point; thence with the arc of a curve turning to the left, having an arc length of 660.75 feet, a radius of 1033.00 feet, a chord length of 649.54 feet, and a chord bearing n 27°32'25" w to a point ; thence n 45°51'53" w a distance of 529.56 feet to a point; thence with the arc of a curve turning to the right, having an arc length of 1037.75 feet, a radius of 1712.00 feet, a chord length of 1021.93 feet, and a chord bearing n 28°29'58" w to a point; thence with a compound curve turning to the right, having an arc length of 20.28 feet, a radius of 1712.00 feet, a chord length of 20.28 feet, and a chord bearing n 10°47'42" w to a point; thence with a compound curve turning to the right, having an arc le ngth of 42.56 feet, a radius of 1712.00 feet, a chord length of 42.56 feet, and a chord bearing n 09°44'37" w to a point; thence n 09°01'53" w a distance of 333.59 feet to a point; thence leaving said road n 89°41'00" e a distance of 567.57 feet to a point; thence s 89°41'07" e a distance of 3163.49 feet to a point; thence s 00°38'38" w a distance of 1986.66 feet to a point; thence with the arc of a curve turning to the right, having an arc length of 571.07 feet, a radius of 11594.15 feet, a chord length of 571.01 feet, and a chord bearing s 48°18'09" w to a point; thence s 49°42'49" w a distance of 1976.75 feet to said point of beginning, said tract or parcel of land containing 201.03 acres LESS AND EXCEPT FROM THAT 201.03 ACRE PORTION, A 0.45 ACRE CEMETERY SITE HAVING A METES AND BOUNDS DESCRIPTION AS FOLLOWS: Beginning at a point having a state plan coordinate of n 158578.00 e 1965350.97; thence n 88°55'55" w a distance of 132.00 feet to a point; thence n 01°04'05" e a distance of 148.50 feet to a point; t hence s 88°55'55" e a distance of 132.00 feet to a point; thence s 01°04'05" w a distance of 148.50 feet to said point of beginning, said tract or parcel of land containing 0.45 acres. ALSO LESS AND EXCEPT PARCEL 2 (280.70 ACRES), PARCEL 11 (39.14 ACRES), PARCEL 12 (692.89 ACRES), PARCEL 13 (461.22 ACRES), PARCEL A (202.78 ACRES), PARCEL B-1 (140.54 ACRES), PARCEL B -2 (35.02 ACRES), PARCEL C -1 (66.88 ACRES), AND PARCEL REFERENCED AS “PARCEL 1.623 AC.” Total acreage to be included in the Exit 3 Redevelopment Project Area is 1,608.30 acres, more or less, being: PORTION OF FORMER PARCEL 1 (200.58 Acres, more or less); PARCEL 4 (179.72 Acres , more or less); PARCEL 5 (31.27 Acres, more or less); PARCEL 6 (469.07 Acres, more or less); PARCEL 7 (163.77 Acres, more or less); PARCEL 8 (288.62 Acres, more or less); PARCEL 9 (27.57 Acres, more or less); & PARCEL 10 (247.70 Acres, more or less). A listing of all real property in the Exit 3 Redevelopment Project Area is set forth in the Redevelopment Plan. SECTION 7. Pursuant to Section 31-6-80(A)(5) of the TIF Act, the City Council hereby determines the duration of the Redevelopment Plan to be 25 years. 5 SECTION 8. Pursuant to Section 31-6-80(A)(6) of the TIF Act, the City Council hereby specifically finds and determines that, inasmuch as the taxing districts in which this Exit 3 Redevelopment Project Area is located will continue to receive tax revenues resulting from the parcels in the Exit 3 Redevelopment Project Area as currently assessed, there will be no adverse impact caused by the tax increment financing plan set forth in the Redevelopment Plan upon the revenues of the City, the County and the School District and that the long term impact will be beneficial to the City, the County and the School District following the inducement by the City of substantial private investment. SECTION 9. P ursuant to Section 31- 6-80(A)(7) of the TIF Act, the City Council hereby expressly finds that (a) the Exit 3 Redevelopment Project Area is an “Agricultural area” and a “Blighted area” and that private initiatives are unlikely to alleviated these conditions without substantial public assistance; (b) property values within the Exit 3 Redevelopment Project Area would remain stati c or decline without public intervention; and (c) redevelopment of the property within the Exit 3 Redevelopment Project Area is in the interest of the health, safety, and general welfare of the citizens of the City. SECTION 10. Pursuant to Section 31- 6-90(1)(a) of the T IF Act, there will be no displacement of persons by the Redevelopment Projects. SECTION 11. In order to finance a portion of the cost of the Redevelopment Projects, it is anticipated that the City will issue “Obligations” (within the meaning of the TIF Act) in the maximum about of $37,500,000 in the form of a loan made by South Carolina Transportation Infrastructure Bank to the City and the County in the original pr incipal amount not to exceed $37,500,000 (the “SCTIB Loan”). The expected details of the SCTIB Loan are set forth in the Redevelopment Plan. The enactment of this Ordinance and the adoption of the Redevelopment Plan does not authorize the City to issue Obligations. The issuance of such Obligations will require each of City Council and County Council of the County to enact an ordinance approving such issuance. In addition, prior the issuance of any Obligations, the City expects to establish an “improvement district” (containing the same property contained within the Exit 3 Redevelopment Project Area and to be known as the “Exit 3 Municipal Improvement District”) pursuant to Title 5, Chapter 37 of the Code of Laws of South Carolina 1976, as amended. SECTION 12. The City Council hereby approves [each of the County Intergovernmental Agreement and] the School District Intergovernmental Agreement, in substantially the form[s] presented to this meeting, with such changes as may be approved by the City Manager . The City Manager shall consult counsel with respect to any changes to [the County Intergovernmental Agreement or] the School District Intergovernmental Agreement. Each of the Mayor of the City and the City Manager are hereby authorized to executed and deliver [the County Intergovernmental Agreement and] the School District Intergovernmental Agreement. SECTION 13. Any subsequent changes to the Redevelopment Plan will not affect any prior procedural approvals or requirements heretofore obtained or complied with in connection with the establishment of the Exit 3 Redevelopment Project Area. SECTION 14. All rules, regulations, and parts thereof, procedural or otherwise, in conflict herewith, to the extent of such conflict, are hereby repealed. If any section, phrase or provision of this Ordinance shall for any reason be declared by a court of competent jurisdiction to be invalid or unenforceable, such declaration shall not affect the validity of the remaining sections, phrases, and provisions hereof. [End of Ordinance; Execution Page Follows] 6 SIGNED, SEALED, AND DELIVERED AS OF THE ___ DAY OF ____________, 2020. CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA By: ____________________________________ Mayor Attest: ___________________________________ Clerk First Reading and Public Hearing: November 5, 2020 Second Reading: _____________, 2020 A-1 EXHIBIT A REDEVELOPMENT PLAN [TO BE INSERTED] CITY COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA ESTABLISHING THE EXIT 3 REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA; MAKING CERTAIN FINDINGS OF AN “AGRICULTURAL AREA” AND A “BLIGHTED AREA” WITHIN THE EXIT 3 REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA; DESIGNATING AND DEFINING REDEVELOPMENT PROJECTS CONSISTING OF PUBLIC IMPROVEMENTS WITHIN THE EXIT 3 REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA; DESIGNATING APPROPRIATE REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT COSTS; APPROVING AN OVERALL REDEVELOPMENT PLAN; AND OTHER MATTERS RELATED THERETO. DEPARTMENT: Administration ATTACHMENTS: Ordinance X Resolution ___ Motion Support Documents Appointment ___ Other ______________________________________________________________________________ SUMMARY: Pursuant to Title 31, Chapter 6 of SC Code of Laws municipalities are authorized to establish redevelopment project area s. It is proposed that the City of Hardeeville create a redevelopment project area ( Exit 3 Redevelopment Project Area) consisting of approximately 1,608.75 acres of real property. Section 31-6-80 of the Tax Increment Financing Act requires that a public hearing be held on the Redevelopment Plan and notice of such public hearing be given to all taxing districts of which taxable property is included in the Exit 3 Redevelopment Plan Area not less than 45 days prior to the date set. A public hearing was held before the City Council on chamber 5, 2020 at 5 p.m. in Council Chambers and the taxing districts shall receive notice of such public hearing. The proposed plan describes the proposed improvements to construct a new exit on I95 in the corporate limits of the City and utilizes the revenue proceeds from a tax increment financing district to repay a loan received from the State Infrastructure Bank Board (STIB) for the project. The second reading will not be presented for consideration until the City and Jasper C ounty successfully negotiate and adopt an Intergovernmental Agreement with the STIB and an IGA with the Jasper County School District for usage of the Schools TIF proceeds to fund the loan repayment. ____________________________________________________________________ RECOMMENDED ACTION: Adopt at First Reading Ordinance 2020-11-5A which establishes the Exit 3 Redevelopment Project Area; makes certain findings of an agricultural area and a blighted area within the Exit 3 Redevelopment Project Area; designates an defines redevelopment projects consisting of public improvements within the Exit 3 Redevelopment Project Area; designates appropriate redevelopment project cots; approves an overall redevelopment plan and other matters related thereto. ____________________________________________________________________________ DEPARTMENT Submitted: Michael J. Czymbor Date: 12/10/20 Requested Agenda Regular Mtg Date: 1/7/21 FINANCE DEPARTMENT Budgeted ___Yes __X_No _N/A Date: CITY ATTORNEY Approved as to Form and Correctness Date: CITY MANAGER Approved Agenda Item For: Date: __________________________________________________________________________ COUNCIL ACTION: Approved as Recommended Disapproved Approved With Modification ___ Tabled To Time Certain ___ Other _____________________________________________________________________________ P.O. Box 1861• Beaufort, S.C. 29901-1861 • Telephone (843) 522-1800 • www.CoastalConservationLeague.org November 5, 2020 Hardeeville City Council Council Chambers 205 Main Street Hardeeville, South Carolina 29927 Re: Agenda Items IX.A. & B. Hardeeville Council Members, Thank you for the opportunity to comment on the City of Hardeeville’s proposed ordinances to establish a Tax Increment Financing (TIF) District and a Municipal Improvement District (MID) in connection with Exit 3 and surrounding development. The following comments are provided on behalf of the Coastal Conservation League. A TIF district is a tool that allows municipalities to revitalize and redevelop blighted, agricultural, or conservation areas. The intent of state law is to encourage redevelopment of areas that are currently blighted or are at risk of becoming blighted. According to the ordinance before council this evening, the Redevelopment Project Area is both “agricultural” and “blighted.” State law defines TIF eligible agricultural areas as: any unimproved or vacant area formerly developed and used primarily for agricultural purposes within the boundaries of a redevelopment project area located within the territorial limits of the municipality where redevelopment and sound growth is impaired by a combination of three or more of the following factors: obsolete platting of the land; diversity of ownership of the land; tax and special assessment delinquencies on the land; deterioration of structures or site improvements in neighboring areas adjacent to the land; overcrowding of structures and community facilities in neighboring areas adjacent to the land; lack of necessary transportation infrastructure; presence of or potential environmental hazards; lack of water or wastewater; lack of storm drainage facilities; inadequate electric, natural gas or other energy services; lack of modern communications infrastructure; lack of community planning; agricultural foreclosures; and static or declining land values.1 Blight is defined as: (1) [A]ny improved or vacant area within the boundaries of a redevelopment project area located within the territorial limits of the municipality where: (a) if improved, industrial, commercial, and residential buildings or improvements, because of a combination of five or more of the following factors: age; dilapidation; obsolescence; deterioration; illegal use of individual structures; presence of structures 1 S.C. Code Ann. §31-6-30(1.5) P.O. Box 1861• Beaufort, S.C. 29901-1861 • Telephone (843) 522-1800 • www.CoastalConservationLeague.org below minimum code standards; excessive vacancies; overcrowding of structures and community facilities; lack of necessary transportation infrastructure; presence of or potential environmental hazards; lack of water or wastewater services; inadequate electric, natural gas or other energy services; lack of modern communications infrastructure; lack of ventilation, light, sanitary or storm drainage facilities; inadequate utilities; excessive land coverage; deleterious land use or layout; depreciation of physical maintenance; lack of community planning; and static or declining land values are detrimental to the public safety, health, morals, or welfare or; (b) if vacant, the sound growth is impaired by: (i) a combination of two or more of the following factors: obsolete platting of the vacant land; diversity of ownership of such land; tax and special assessment delinquencies on such land; deterioration of structures or site improvements in neighboring areas adjacent to the vacant land; overcrowding of structures and community facilities in neighboring areas adjacent to the vacant land; lack of necessary transportation infrastructure; presence of or potential environmental hazard; lack of water, or wastewater; lack of storm drainage facilities; inadequate electric and natural gas energy services; and lack of modern communications infrastructure; or (ii) the area immediately prior to becoming vacant qualified as a blighted area. Any area within a redevelopment plan established by Chapter 10 of Title 31 is deemed to be a blighted area.2 Although the boundaries of the Redevelopment Project Area are unclear3, we understand the area is broadly the planned location for Exit 3 and the affiliated infrastructure projects listed in the ordinance.4 This area does not meet the definition of “agricultural” or “blighted” under South Carolina law.5 The proposed ordinance makes no findings whatsoever as to the factors listed above, only asserting that the Exit Three Redevelopment Area is an ““Agricultural area” and a “Blighted area”(each within the meaning of the TIF Act).” The project area described in the City’s proposed TIF ordinance does not rise to the state standard for creation of a TIF district to finance and repay state loans for construction of Exit 3, a new 2 S.C. Code Ann. §31-6-30(1) 3 The currently posted agenda contains a page that reads “REDEVELOPMENT PLAN [to be inserted]” and does not contain any maps of the site. Plats are simply identified as Parcels 1-13, Parcel A, Parcel B-1, Parcel B-2, Parcel C-1, and Parcel 1.623 AC. 4 (a) a new interchange at Exit 3 on I–95, including all related drainage and storm water and infrastructure; (b) an approximately 1.5-mile stretch of RiverPort Parkway north of I–95, including all related drainage and storm water infrastructure; and (c) an approximately 4-mile stretch of RiverPort Parkway south of I–95, including all related drainage and storm water infrastructure[.] 5 S.C. Code Ann. §31-6-30 P.O. Box 1861• Beaufort, S.C. 29901-1861 • Telephone (843) 522-1800 • www.CoastalConservationLeague.org interchange off Interstate 95, and surrounding proposed mixed-use development, such as RiverPort. It appears the creation of a MID could be appropriate for the Exit 3 project area, but a TIF is inappropriate under these conditions. In addition, there are significant financial risks to municipalities in bonding funds against future potential development, particularly where, as here, the proposed development plans have not been finalized and all necessary state and federal environmental permits have not been obtained. There are extensive wetlands in this area that will need to be avoided and any unavoidable impacts must be minimized or mitigated for, which may change how and whether such future development takes shape. We recently submitted comments to the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers related to the proposed RiverPort development outlining our concerns with the project, specifically impacts to wetlands and sufficiently meaningful mitigation to offset unavoidable impacts. A copy of these comments are attached for reference. In light of these concerns, we encourage the City to table the creation of special financing districts until the development has obtained final authorization from state and federal agencies. Lastly, there are known costs associated with sprawl development and we encourage the City to take time to fully understand such costs before moving forward. In particular, we urge the City to review the 2006 Clemson Fiscal Impact Assessment for Jasper County, Hardeeville, and Ridgeland, and to coordinate with Jasper County in ongoing efforts to update this study. Thank you for your consideration of these important issues. Sincerely, Jessie White South Coast Office Director June 25, 2020 VIA E-MAIL Mr. Richard L. Darden U.S. Army Corps of Engineers ATTN: REGULATORY DIVISION 69A Hagood Avenue Charleston, SC 29403 Richard.L.Darden@usace.army.mil Re: Application P/N SAC 2010-00064 Riverport Development Dear Mr. Darden, The Southern Environmental Law Center (“SELC”), on behalf of the Coastal Conservation League (the “Conservation League”), submits these comments on the above referenced joint public notice (“JPN”) issued by the Charleston District of the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (the “Corps”) and the South Carolina Department of Health and Environmental Control (“DHEC”) on May 27, 2020. The Applicant has applied to the Corps for a Clean Water Act (“CWA”) Section 404 permit to fill wetlands, and to DHEC for a Section 401 Water Quality Certification and a Coastal Zone Consistency Certification for the project. The project proposes to discharge fill material into 35.17 acres of wetlands for road crossings and improvements to existing roads as part of a major mixed-use development in Jasper County, South Carolina. As explained in the JPN, the Applicant proposes to build a master-planned, mixed-use development with industrial, commercial, civic, and residential uses at the 4,368.81-acre Riverport Tract. The project, located north and south of I-95, would include 3,339 new residential units, more than 10.6 million square feet of industrial warehouse space and 2.6 million square feet of commercial space, and a new interchange with I-95 at Mile Marker 3.1 The stated project purpose is to “meet projected future growth associated with the existing Port of Savannah and Jasper Ocean Terminal.” JPN at 2. This project appears largely similar in size, location, and purpose to the formerly proposed “RiverPort Development” (also SAC 2010- 1 We question how a private developer can apply for a permit to make major modifications to an interstate highway without the apparent involvement of either the U.S. Department of Transportation or the South Carolina Department of Transportation. The Corps should consider whether it would be permissible or prudent to issue a permit for that component of the project unless and until those agencies sponsor the Application. 2 00064), for which the Corps began preparing, but later suspended without explanation, an Environmental Impact Statement in 2014.2 In sum, and as described in greater detail below, we have significant concerns regarding this proposal. We offer the following comments on the project and may supplement our comments in the future if we have the opportunity to review additional information about the proposal.3 1. Pursuant to NEPA and Its Implementing Regulations, the Corps Must Prepare an EIS for This Project. The National Environmental Policy Act (“NEPA”) directs federal agencies to prepare an Environmental Impact Statement (“EIS”) for any major federal action that significantly affects the quality of the human environment. 42 U.S.C. § 4332(2)(C). The “significance” of a proposed action is determined by evaluating both the context of the action and the intensity of its impact. 40 C.F.R. § 1508.27. Intensity refers to the severity of the action as revealed through the consideration of ten factors, many of which would apply to this proposal: (1) “Impacts that may be both beneficial and adverse”; (2) The “degree to which the proposed action affects public health or safety”; (3) “Unique characteristics of the geographic area such as proximity to historic or cultural resources, park lands, prime farmlands, wetlands, wild and scenic rivers, or ecologically critical areas”; (4) “The degree to which the effects on the quality of the human environment are likely to be highly controversial”; (5) “The degree to which the possible effects on the human environment are highly unknown or involve unique or unknown risks”; (6) “The degree to which the action may establish a precedent for future actions with significant effects”; (7) The cumulative impacts of the activity on the environment; 2 U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Notice of Intent to Prepare a Draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS) for the RiverPort Development and Proposed New Interchange on I-95 in Jasper County, South Carolina and Notice of Scoping Meeting, SAC-2010-00064 (July 31, 2014). 3 As a general matter, the JPN does not include sufficient information to provide meaningful public notice and opportunity for comment. Public notice for a CWA Section 404 permit “must contain a statement explaining how impacts associated with the proposed activity are to be avoided, minimized, and compensated for,” and the “level of detail provided in the public notice must be commensurate with the scope and scale of the impacts.” 33 C.F.R. 332.4(b)(1). In light of the scope and scale of impacts here, this JPN does not prov ide adequate information. We may submit a FOIA request to allow us to review more detailed information about the project, and we may supplement our comments in the future after we have had the opportunity to review additional information about the proposal, including the mitigation plan. In the meantime, we offer the following initial comments based on the information provided in the JPN. 3 (8) “The degree to which the action . . . may cause loss or destruction of significant scientific, cultural, or historical resources”; (9) “The degree to which the action may adversely affect any endangered or threatened species or its habitat that has been determined to be critical under the Endangered Species Act of 1973”; and (10) “Whether the action threatens a violation of Federal, State, or local law or requirements imposed for the protection of the environment.” Id. § 1508.27(b). “An action may be ‘significant’ if one of these factors is met.” Ctr. for Biological Diversity v. Nat’l Highway Traffic Safety Admin., 538 F.3d 1172, 1220 (9th Cir. 2008). As with the prior iteration of this project, the Corps must prepare an EIS to evaluate the full scope of impacts from, and alternatives to, this “significant” action. At 4,368.81 acres, the proposal is nearly identical in size to its predecessor and contains the same general component parts, with large-scale residential, commercial, and industrial uses and a new interchange with I- 95 planned.4 Notably, this intensive development would border the 31,551-acre Savannah National Wildlife Refuge (“Savannah NWR” or “refuge”), which contains ecologically critical freshwater marshes, tidal rivers and creeks, and bottomland hardwoods. See 40 C.F.R. § 1508.27(b)(3). Along with about 3,000 acres of managed freshwater impoundments, these habitats support a diverse array of plant and animal species, including resident wading birds and federally endangered wood storks, red-cockaded woodpeckers, least terns, shortnose sturgeon, and manatees.5 See 40 C.F.R. § 1508.27(b)(9). The refuge is also an important link in the chain of NWRs along the Atlantic Flyaway, attracting thousands of migratory birds each year.6 Due to the project’s proximity to, and potential impacts on, the Savannah NWF, NEPA demands that the Corps evaluate this proposal in an EIS. In addition to the neighboring Savannah NWR, the project area itself contains valuable ecological and aquatic resources that would be adversely affected by the proposed development. Not only would the project fill 35.17 acres of wetlands, it would surround and fragment nearly 1,400 more acres of wetlands, JPN at 6, and expose them to harmful runoff and likely other sources of pollution. Such impacts reduce the capacity of wetlands to retain and store floodwaters, thereby increasing the risk of flooding to the proposed new homes and businesses. See infra Section 2. Because much of the Riverport Tract—especially the portions slated for 4 U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, supra note 1, at 3. 5 U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, “Savannah National Wildlife Refuge,” https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q= &esrc=s&source=web&cd=&ved=2ahUKEwicusmV053qAhW7oXIEHYoDB2UQFjABegQICBAC&url=https%3 A%2F%2Fwww.fws.gov%2Fsoutheast%2Fpdf%2Ftearsheet%2Fsavannah-national-wildlife- refuge.pdf&usg=AOvVaw147nGf WuoSaspPcCDZWTkX 6 Id. 4 residential development—already lies within the FEMA 100-year floodplain, the Corps must analyze this flood risk and the associated risk to public health and safety. See 40 C.F.R. § 1508.27(b)(2). Beyond wetlands, the project area also contains critical habitat for the frosted flatwoods salamander. Even though the JPN shows no construction within the limits of the critical habitat, the project could still adversely affect that habitat through fragmentation, pollution, and human disturbance. See 40 C.F.R. § 1508.27(b)(9). Finally, the proposed project could unleash or exacerbate a host of cumulative impacts on the environment which merit further study in an EIS. See 40 C.F.R. § 1508.27(b)(7). In 2014, the project sponsors predicted that the commercial and industrial components of the RiverPort Development would support 24,000 permanent jobs by Year 30.7 Assuming a similar degree of economic impact here, all of these new jobs would induce housing and commercial development in and around rural Hardeeville, resulting in more wetlands fill and water pollution, more traffic and air pollution, and other environmental degradation. The proposed new interchange with I-95 and improvements to Purrysburg Road would only reinforce these development forces. The project also has the potential to aggravate past and future threats to the Savannah NWR. As mentioned above, the refuge contains valuable and increasingly rare habitats—for example, tidal freshwater marshes. These marshes are far more biologically diverse than their saltwater counterparts, but have largely disappeared from the Atlantic Coast after decades of development.8 The freshwater marshes in the Savannah NWR face additional threats such as saltwater intrusion from the dredging and deepening of the Savannah River and rising sea levels. The proposed development could further stress this delicate ecosystem. As proposed, this project would introduce intensive development into an otherwise rural, natural place, bordered by an internationally significant, and severely threatened, wildlife refuge. Due to the potential impacts to wetlands, endangered species, and public health and safety— compounded with other past, present, and future actions in the area—the Corps must prepare a full EIS for the project. The Corps already began this process in 2014 for the prior iteration of the RiverPort Development. Though that process apparently ended without an EIS, there can be little doubt that this new, largely identical proposal warrants the same level of NEPA review. 2. Compliance with Clean Water Act Guidelines 2.1 Ensure the Least Damaging Practicable Alternative is Selected. As proposed, the project will have significant wetland impacts; therefore, this project must comply with the Clean Water Act Section 404(b)(1) Guidelines (the “Guidelines”). 33 C.F.R. § 320.4(a)(1). The Guidelines provide significant protection to wetlands, and the 7 U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, supra note 1, at 3. 8 U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, “Tidal Freshwater Marsh,” Savannah National Wildlife Refuge (last updated June 20, 2014), https://www.fws.gov/refuge/Savannah/wildlife_and_habitat/tidal_freshwater_marsh.html. 5 degradation or destruction of wetlands “is considered to be among the most severe environmental impacts covered by these Guidelines.” 40 C.F.R. § 230.1(d). The Guidelines state that the Corps may not permit a discharge of dredged or fill material if there is a less damaging “practicable alternative,” or if the discharge will “cause or contribute to significant degradation” of waters of the United States. Id. § 230.10. In applying the practicable alternative standard, the Corps must consider the project’s “basic purpose.” See id. § 230.10(a)(3). If the project’s basic purpose is not water dependent, the Guidelines apply a presumption that a practicable alternative with less adverse environmental impact on wetlands exists. Id. An alternative “is practicable if it is available and capable of being done after taking into consideration cost, existing technology, and logistics in light of overall project purpose.” Id. § 230.10(a)(2). Where a discharge is proposed for a wetland or other special aquatic site, all practicable alternatives to the proposed discharge that do not involve a discharge to the wetland “are presumed to have less adverse impact on the aquatic ecosystem, unless clearly demonstrated otherwise.” Id. § 230.10(a)(3). The burden is on the Applicant to rebut the presumption by “clearly demonstrat[ing]” that a less damaging practicable alternative is not available. See id. Here, the Applicant has failed to carry that burden. The Applicant is required to take all appropriate and practicable steps to avoid and minimize adverse impacts to waters of the United States. See 40 C.F.R. § 230.91(c)(2). While we understand that the Applicant has taken steps to limit wetland impacts to road crossings, 35 acres of wetlands is still a significant loss to this watershed. In this early project stage, it is crucial that the Applicant evaluate all possible alternatives that would further avoid and minimize impacts to wetlands, including alternative site designs that minimize the number of required road crossings on the project site. Additionally, we urge the Applicant to bridge road crossings to maintain some of the hydrologic connections among the contiguous wetland system on the site and avoid further fragmentation and degradation of the project’s wetlands. Given the significant public benefits wetlands provide, the Applicant must avoid wetland impacts to the greatest extent possible in order to comply with the Corps’ public interest test.9 Coastal wetland systems provide important wave buffering and flood retention services for coastal communities and should be protected to maintain these hazard mitigation services.10 An assessment following Hurricane Sandy found that coastal wetlands helped affected states avoid 9 The Corps must evaluate whether proposals for Section 404 permits comply with the public interest test, which is based on probable impacts, including cumulative impacts, to safety, wetlands, flood hazards, floodplain values, land use, and the needs and welfare of the people, among other considerations. See 33 C.F.R. § 320.4(a)(1). 10 See W.J. Mitsch et al., “Ecosystem services of wetlands,” 11 INT’L J. OF BIODIVERSITY SCI., ECOSYSTEM SERVS. & MGMT., no. 1, at 1–4 (2015), https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/21513732.2015.1006250?scroll=top&needAccess=true; A. Bullock & M. Acreman, “The role of wetlands in the hydrological cycle,” 7 HYDROLOGY AND EARTH SYS. SCI., no. 3, at 358–89 (2003), https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00304786/document; M. Acreman & J. Holden, “How wetlands affect floods,” 33 WETLANDS, no. 5, at 773–86 (2013), https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s13157-013-0473-2. 6 $625 million in direct damages during the storm.11 The Houston area lost 4 billion gallons worth of flood retention after losing 5.5 percent of its freshwater wetlands between 1992 and 2010.12 Charleston’s Church Creek basin lost 24 percent of its wetland area from 1996 to 2010, and the community’s flooding woes became a recurrent problem over that time period. Maintaining existing wetlands so that they continue to provide natural flood storage and storm buffering helps avoid taxpayer-funded flood control projects in the future. In light of the stronger storms and sea level rise the South Carolina coast is already experiencing due to climate change, it is crucial to preserve wetlands and their services to the greatest extent possible.13 2.2 Floodplains, Present and Future Risk. Under the Section 404(b)(1) Guidelines, the Corps is required to consider “the capacity of wetlands to retain and store floodwaters and to serve as a buffer zone shielding upland areas from wave actions, storm damage and erosion.” 40 C.F.R. § 230.41(b). A significant portion of the Riverport property lies within the 1% Annual Chance Flood Hazard, or 100-year floodplain, as defined by Preliminary FEMA National Flood Hazard data, and therefore a significant portion of the wetlands impacted by this project are within the floodplain.14 The JPN does not mention this flood risk, which suggests that the Applicant has not adequately considered this issue. The flood storage capacity of the wetlands on the proposed site coupled with the potential of this proposal to alter stormwater flow in the watershed through its construction must be considered in order to comply with the Guidelines. Floodplains, in addition to wetlands and forested infiltration areas, are natural site resources that should be maintained to assist in water retention on a property.15 Undeveloped floodplains and wetlands provide crucial flood storage benefits. Floodplains of the Waccamaw River and swamplands just north of Conway reduce flooding by up to 1.5 feet for floods up to a 200-year event, and provide an average of $6.14 million in avoided damage annually.16 Following Hurricane Florence, a floodplain area of about 156,000 acres around the Great Pee Dee, Little Pee Dee, and Lynches rivers stored enough water to fill over half a million Olympic-sized swimming pools.17 Because the floodplain absorbed this 11 S. Narayan et al., “The value of coastal wetlands for flood damage reduction in the Northeastern USA ,” SCIENTIFIC REPORTS, at 1 (2017), https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-017-09269-z. 12 J.S. Jacob et al., “Houston area freshwater wetland loss, 1992-2010,” (2015), http://tcwp.tamu.edu/files/2015/06/WetlandLossPub.pdf. 13 U.S. Global Change Research Program, “Precipitation Change in the United States,” CLIMATE SCIENCE SPECIAL REPORT: FOURTH NATIONAL CLIMATE ASSESSMENT (2017). 14 Almost the entire northern half of the project, where the residential development is proposed, lies in the 100 -year floodplain, and a significant portion of the property south of I-95 lies in the 100-year floodplain. 15 City of Charleston, “Stormwater Design Manual,” Section 1.7.4.1 https://www.charleston- sc.gov/DocumentCenter/View/5972. 16 Keil Schmidt, Pilot Report: Measurement of Floodplain Value for Downstream Flood Reduction, TNC. 17 One acre-foot is equal to 1,613.3 cubic yards, so the forest stored approximately 1,936,000,000 c ubic yards. An Olympic swimming pool is 3300 cubic yards. This means the floodplain stored enough water to fill over 586,665 Olympic swimming pools. Williams et al, “Hurricane Florence Flooding in Georgetown County: A Qualitative Exploration of the Interactions of Estuary and Tidal River,” JOURNAL OF SC WATER RESOURCES (2019). 7 extreme flooding and slowly released the water over 10 days, downstream Georgetown County weathered the storm without major flooding. Development and wetland fill within the floodplain exacerbate existing flooding issues and leave the area at risk to increased future flooding from intensifying storms, fueled by a changing climate.18 The public interest review requirement for the issuance of a Section 404 permit further supports the need to consider these critical resilience issues. The decision of whether to issue a Section 404 permit must be based on an evaluation of the probable impacts, including cumulative impacts, of the proposed activity and its intended use on the public interest. 33 C.F.R. § 320.4(a)(1). This public interest review requires the Corps to carefully weigh all factors which may be relevant to the proposal, balancing benefits against reasonably foreseeable detriments. See id. The regulations list flood hazards, floodplain values, and shore erosion and accretion as factors that must be considered as part of a public interest review if relevant to the project. See id. This project is proposing to place over 3,000 new homes in the floodplain. The community exposure and risk this would create is clearly not in the public interest. The potential for flood hazards caused by sea level rise, extreme rainfall, and intensifying storm surge is a relevant factor that must be considered as part of the public interest review for a permit proposing substantial development within the 100-year floodplain. The Riverport Tract is vulnerable to flooding from rainfall and storm surge due to its position near the Savannah River and low lying nature of the land. The Savannah area has experienced flooding from several extreme rain events already this year.19 One storm on June 12, 2020 brought approximately 5 inches of rain in just an hour, equivalent to a 500-year rainfall event.20 The current linear rate of sea level rise at the Fort Pulaski gauge, down the Savannah River from this project, is 3.33 mm per year, or 1.3 inches each decade.21 Accounting for the additional acceleration of sea level rise, Intermediate and Intermediate-High scenarios from the 4th National Climate Assessment project 1 to 2 feet of sea level rise at the Fort Pulaski gauge by the middle of the century, compared to sea levels in the year 2000.22 These same scenarios predict between 3.8 and 6.1 feet of sea level rise by 2100. With any increase in sea level rise, the water of the Savannah River inches closer to 18 U.S. Global Change Research Program, “Southeast,” IMPACTS, RISKS, AND ADAPTATION IN THE UNITED STATES: FOURTH NATIONAL CLIMATE ASSESSMENT, Volume II (2018), https://nca2018.globalchange.gov/chapter/19/. 19 See https://www.wtoc.com/2020/03/06/rain-leads-flooding-coastal-empire/; https://www.wjcl.com/article/streets- flood-in-savannah-after-morning-rain/32131832; https://www.wtoc.com/2020/06/12/street-flooding-reported- savannah/. 20 WTOC, “Heavy Rain Causes Flooding in Savannah, Richmond Hill,” (June 2020), https://www.wtoc.com/2020/06/12/street-flooding-reported-savannah/ 21 National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, “Sea Level Trends,” (2020), https://tidesandcurrents.noaa.gov/sltrends/sltrends.html. 22 National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, “Global and Regional Sea Level Rise Scenarios for the United States,” U.S. Department of Commerce (2017), https://tidesandcurrents.noaa.gov/publications/techrpt83_Global_and_Regional_SLR_Scenarios_for_the_US_final.p df. 8 the development site. Failure to consider these combined flooding risks could have disastrous consequences for the planned development associated with this project. There is a consensus among researchers that climate change will continue to make storms and the floods that follow more intense, as a warmer air can hold more moisture and add more fuel to storm systems.23 Extreme rainfall has already become more frequent and more damaging throughout the Southeast.24 In a climate scenario where today’s emission levels remain constant, the number of extreme rain storms in the Southeast will increase by two to three times the historic average by the end of the 21st century.25 Before the end of the century, throughout the Southeast, extreme summer thunderstorms that typically result in 100-year floods events are expected to drop between 40 percent and 80 percent more rain than today.26 This trend will continue into the future even in a scenario with emissions reductions.27 With all of these factors considered, placing more infrastructure in a floodplain and destroying crucial wetlands make even less sense. We should be maintaining our existing wetlands so that they continue to provide natural flood storage, minimizing the need for costly flood control projects in the future, rather than investing in costly new infrastructure within the floodplain. Planning for impacts now is cheaper and more responsible than placing the burden on residents and the government down the road – for every $1 spent on mitigation, the nation saves $6 in future disaster costs, by the latest estimations.28 2.3 401 Water Quality Certification and Coastal Zone Management Consistency Certification. In addition to a Section 404 permit, the proposed development requires a 401 Water Quality Certification (“401 Certification”) and a Coastal Zone Consistency Certification (“Consistency Certification”) from DHEC to proceed to construction. The regulations implementing these Certification programs set forth similar analytical requirements to the Guidelines. Most notably, DHEC may not issue a 401 Certification or a Consistency Certification to fill or permanently alter wetlands if a feasible alternative exists to the proposal. 23 Global Fluid Dynamics Laboratory, “Global Warming and Hurricanes,” NOAA (2020), https://www.gfdl.noaa.gov/global-warming-and-hurricanes/. 24 U.S. Global Change Research Program, “Precipitation Change in the United States,” Climate Science Special Report: Fourth National Climate Assessment, Volume I at 207-230, https://science2017.globalchange.gov/chapter/7/. 25 U.S. Global Change Research Program, “Precipitation Change in the United States,” CLIMATE SCIENCE SPECIAL REPORT: FOURTH NATIONAL CLIMATE ASSESSMENT, Volume I at 207-230, https://science2017.globalchange.gov/chapter/7/. 26 Andreas F. Prein et al., “Increased Rainfall Volume from Future Convective Storms in the US,” NATURE CLIMATE CHANGE 7, at 880-884 (2017), https://www.nature.com/articles/nclimate3168. 27 U.S. Global Change Research Program, “Southeast,” IMPACTS, RISKS, AND ADAPTATION IN THE UNITED STATES: FOURTH NATIONAL CLIMATE ASSESSMENT, Volume II (2018), https://nca2018.globalchange.gov/chapter/19/. 28 National Institute of Building Sciences, “Natural Hazard Mitigation Saves: 2017 Interim Report,” (2017), https://www.nibs.org/news/381874/National-Institute-of-Building-Sciences-Issues-New-Report-on-the-Value-of- Mitigation.htm. 9 See S.C. Code Regs. 61-101.F.5.a-b.; S.C. Coastal Program29 at III.C.3.XII.E.1 (July 1979). The Consistency Certification regulations are particularly strict with respect to residential and commercial development. A residential development may not fill or permanently alter wetlands “unless no feasible alternatives exist or an overriding public interest can be demonstrated, and any substantial environmental damage can be minimized.” S.C. Coastal Program at III.C.3.I.1.b. A commercial development may not fill or permanently alter wetlands “unless no feasible alternatives exist and the facility is water-dependent.” S.C. Coastal Program at III.C.3.IV.1.b (emphasis added). As discussed above, the Corps—and DHEC—must evaluate all alternatives to the proposed development to ensure that no practicable alternative exists which would result in less wetland fill. But the agency should also consider the various other ways in which the project could permanently alter the functions and values of surrounding wetlands. See S.C. Code Regs. 61-101.F.5.a-b (directing DHEC to deny 401 Certification where the proposed activity would impair the “functions and values” of the aquatic ecosystem). The construction of homes, businesses, warehouses, roads, and parking lots would cover the Riverport Tract in impervious surfaces, generating stormwater runoff and funneling pollution into nearby waterways. Polluted runoff is one of the single largest threats to water quality in the United States, and studies show that waterbodies exposed to urban runoff experience declines in plant and animal diversity and fitness.30 Along with runoff, the waterways around the proposed development may become receiving waters for harmful industrial and municipal discharges. Finally, any wetlands fragmentation due to road crossings or other construction would compound the effects of pollution by further degrading habitat and water quality,31 and would potentially exacerbate the risk of flooding in the area.32 3. The Proposed Mitigation Plan is Insufficient. Mitigation is the third and final step in the 404 process, and should therefore not be considered until avoidance and minimization have been completed and the 404 requirements are satisfied. 40 C.F.R. § 230. Given the large number of planned wetland impacts, the Applicant should be planning to appropriately mitigate for these impacts. However the current mitigation package proposed by the Applicant is deficient and these shortcomings must be addressed.33 29 Available at https://scdhec.gov/sites/default/files/docs/HomeAndEnvironment/Docs/SC_Coastal_%20Program% 20(Pt.%202%20-%20Ch.%20III).pdf. 30 U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, “NPDES Stormwater Program” (last updated Mar. 20, 2020), https://www.epa.gov/npdes/npdes-stormwater-program. 31 Bradley Cosentino et al., “Dispersal and Wetland Fragmentation” (2018), https://experts.illinois.edu/en/publications/dispersal-and-wetland-fragmentation. 32 Susan Laurance et al., “Drivers of Wetland Disturbance and Biodiversity Impacts on a Tropical Oceanic Island ,” Biological Conservation vol. 149, no. 1 (2012). 33 We have not yet obtained the full Mitigation Plan for this project, therefore the assertions made about the Mitigation Plan below are based solely on the limited information on mitigation provided in the JPN. 10 The Applicant has proposed an on-site Permittee Responsible Mitigation (“PRM”) plan after determining that sufficient bank credits do not exist in the watershed. JPN at 2. The Applicant proposes to generate credits for the PRM by preserving and buffering remaining on- site aquatic resources and restoring approximately 150 acres of pine plantation to historic wetland conditions. 3.1 The Preservation Criteria Must be Satisfied. The majority of the credits generated by the proposed PRM come from the preservation of avoided on-site wetlands. While the preservation of the remaining on-site aquatic resources benefits the development, for various reasons this should not directly generate credits for the PRM. First, it is inconsistent with the preservation criteria outlined in federal regulations and listed below: (i) The resources to be preserved provide important physical, chemical, or biological functions for the watershed; (ii) The resources to be preserved contribute significantly to the ecological sustainability of the watershed. In determining the contribution of those resources to the ecological sustainability of the watershed, the district engineer must use appropriate quantitative assessment tools, where available; (iii) Preservation is determined by the district engineer to be appropriate and practicable; (iv) The resources are under threat of destruction or adverse modifications; and (v) The preserved site will be permanently protected through an appropriate real estate or other legal instrument (e.g., easement, title transfer to state resource agency or land trust). 33 CFR 332.2(a)(2). The Applicant’s proposal does not satisfy the criteria in several respects. The remaining wetlands within the project boundary are not under threat of development because the Applicant would be unable to obtain a permit for a larger amount of wetland impacts, as demonstrated by the Corps’ rejection of the Applicant’s original permit application based partly on the massive number of proposed wetland impacts. Many of the wetlands the Applicant proposes to preserve for preservation credits will be encompassed by the development outlined in this permit application, resulting in fragmentation and degradation of these wetland resources. For these reasons, the Applicants’ proposal for wetlands preservation does not qualify for credit generation. Further, the proposal to preserve the remaining aquatic resources on-site “does not offset adverse impacts to other aquatic resources” and therefore does “not meet the preservation criteria 11 identified in the Mitigation Rule.”34 Preservation alone of avoided wetlands does not qualify as adequate mitigation according to the Corps Guidelines for Preparing a Compensatory Mitigation Plan (SOP). Section 5.2.1 of the SOP states: With the possible exception of outstanding aquatic resources that are important on a watershed scale, the preservation of buffer zones, riparian areas, and the remaining aquatic resources on the project site does not [emphasis added] meet the preservation criteria identified in the Mitigation Rule (33 CFR 332.3(h)). Therefore, the preservation of these areas does not generate compensatory mitigation credits to offset adverse impacts to aquatic resources. When removing a wetland and its valuable functions from a watershed, an applicant must proportionately offset that impact to ensure the continued health of the watershed. While the wetlands proposed as preservation provide functional value to the community, their continued presence does not make up for the loss of wetlands elsewhere on the property. 3.2 Preservation, Enhancement, and Restoration. While the Applicant should not take direct credit for the preservation of the remaining on-site wetlands, they should preserve them for flood protection and other ecosystem services wetlands provide. Under the current Charleston District SOP, the Applicants qualify for a 25 percent reduction in the amount of credits needed if they protect the remaining on-site aquatic resources. 35 This reduction is offered by the SOP as an incentive to preserve avoided wetlands, but it is not meant to generate credits outright. The Corps SOP requires that greater than 50 percent of credits in a mitigation plan must come from restoration and enhancement.36 However, the plan outlined in the JPN generates credits primarily through preservation. The Applicant proposes the restoration of 150 acres of pine plantation to its original wetland condition, however the JPN does not detail additional restoration or enhancement measures. As the Mitigation Rule states: “restoration should generally be the first option considered because the likelihood of success is greater…and the potential gains in terms of aquatic resource functions are greater, compared to enhancement and preservation.” 33 CFR 332.2(a)(2). Further restoration of wetlands should be explored to ensure that greater than 50 percent of credits in the Riverport PRM are generated from restoration and enhancement. 34 SOP at 10. 35 SOP at 14. 36 SOP at 1. 12 3.3 Additional Measures to Offset Harm to the Savannah National Wildlife Refuge. Given the project’s proximity to the ecologically valuable Savannah NWR, we urge the Applicant to evaluate and implement measures to protect the refuge from indirect impacts associated with this development. This could involve create a buffer between the proposed development and the Savannah NWR to reduce encroachment upon the wildlife and habitat in the refuge. This would also buffer the proposed residential neighborhoods from smoke impacts from prescribed burning conducted at the Savannah NWR and surrounding conservation properties. We appreciate the opportunity to submit these comments on the proposed Riverport Development. Based on the limited information provided in the JPN, we have significant concerns with the project, including the potential impacts to wetlands and the Savannah NWR and the proposed mitigation plan. Unless and until those concerns are addressed through an EIS, we respectfully request that the Corps deny the permit application for this project. Sincerely, Christopher K. DeScherer Managing Attorney CC (via email only): Jessie White, CCL Chuck Hightower, DHEC Blair Williams, DHEC Pace Wilber, NMFS Kelly Laycock, EPA Region 4 Susan Davis, SCDNR Tom McCoy, FWS P.O. Box 1861• Beaufort, S.C. 29901-1861 • Telephone (843) 522-1800 • www.CoastalConservationLeague.org November 5, 2020 Hardeeville City Council Council Chambers 205 Main Street Hardeeville, South Carolina 29927 Re: Agenda Items IX.A. & B. Hardeeville Council Members, Thank you for the opportunity to comment on the City of Hardeeville’s proposed ordinances to establish a Tax Increment Financing (TIF) District and a Municipal Improvement District (MID) in connection with Exit 3 and surrounding development. The following comments are provided on behalf of the Coastal Conservation League. A TIF district is a tool that allows municipalities to revitalize and redevelop blighted, agricultural, or conservation areas. The intent of state law is to encourage redevelopment of areas that are currently blighted or are at risk of becoming blighted. According to the ordinance before council this evening, the Redevelopment Project Area is both “agricultural” and “blighted.” State law defines TIF eligible agricultural areas as: any unimproved or vacant area formerly developed and used primarily for agricultural purposes within the boundaries of a redevelopment project area located within the territorial limits of the municipality where redevelopment and sound growth is impaired by a combination of three or more of the following factors: obsolete platting of the land; diversity of ownership of the land; tax and special assessment delinquencies on the land; deterioration of structures or site improvements in neighboring areas adjacent to the land; overcrowding of structures and community facilities in neighboring areas adjacent to the land; lack of necessary transportation infrastructure; presence of or potential environmental hazards; lack of water or wastewater; lack of storm drainage facilities; inadequate electric, natural gas or other energy services; lack of modern communications infrastructure; lack of community planning; agricultural foreclosures; and static or declining land values.1 Blight is defined as: (1) [A]ny improved or vacant area within the boundaries of a redevelopment project area located within the territorial limits of the municipality where: (a) if improved, industrial, commercial, and residential buildings or improvements, because of a combination of five or more of the following factors: age; dilapidation; obsolescence; deterioration; illegal use of individual structures; presence of structures 1 S.C. Code Ann. §31-6-30(1.5) P.O. Box 1861• Beaufort, S.C. 29901-1861 • Telephone (843) 522-1800 • www.CoastalConservationLeague.org below minimum code standards; excessive vacancies; overcrowding of structures and community facilities; lack of necessary transportation infrastructure; presence of or potential environmental hazards; lack of water or wastewater services; inadequate electric, natural gas or other energy services; lack of modern communications infrastructure; lack of ventilation, light, sanitary or storm drainage facilities; inadequate utilities; excessive land coverage; deleterious land use or layout; depreciation of physical maintenance; lack of community planning; and static or declining land values are detrimental to the public safety, health, morals, or welfare or; (b) if vacant, the sound growth is impaired by: (i) a combination of two or more of the following factors: obsolete platting of the vacant land; diversity of ownership of such land; tax and special assessment delinquencies on such land; deterioration of structures or site improvements in neighboring areas adjacent to the vacant land; overcrowding of structures and community facilities in neighboring areas adjacent to the vacant land; lack of necessary transportation infrastructure; presence of or potential environmental hazard; lack of water, or wastewater; lack of storm drainage facilities; inadequate electric and natural gas energy services; and lack of modern communications infrastructure; or (ii) the area immediately prior to becoming vacant qualified as a blighted area. Any area within a redevelopment plan established by Chapter 10 of Title 31 is deemed to be a blighted area.2 Although the boundaries of the Redevelopment Project Area are unclear3, we understand the area is broadly the planned location for Exit 3 and the affiliated infrastructure projects listed in the ordinance.4 This area does not meet the definition of “agricultural” or “blighted” under South Carolina law.5 The proposed ordinance makes no findings whatsoever as to the factors listed above, only asserting that the Exit Three Redevelopment Area is an ““Agricultural area” and a “Blighted area”(each within the meaning of the TIF Act).” The project area described in the City’s proposed TIF ordinance does not rise to the state standard for creation of a TIF district to finance and repay state loans for construction of Exit 3, a new 2 S.C. Code Ann. §31-6-30(1) 3 The currently posted agenda contains a page that reads “REDEVELOPMENT PLAN [to be inserted]” and does not contain any maps of the site. Plats are simply identified as Parcels 1-13, Parcel A, Parcel B-1, Parcel B-2, Parcel C-1, and Parcel 1.623 AC. 4 (a) a new interchange at Exit 3 on I–95, including all related drainage and storm water and infrastructure; (b) an approximately 1.5-mile stretch of RiverPort Parkway north of I–95, including all related drainage and storm water infrastructure; and (c) an approximately 4-mile stretch of RiverPort Parkway south of I–95, including all related drainage and storm water infrastructure[.] 5 S.C. Code Ann. §31-6-30 P.O. Box 1861• Beaufort, S.C. 29901-1861 • Telephone (843) 522-1800 • www.CoastalConservationLeague.org interchange off Interstate 95, and surrounding proposed mixed-use development, such as RiverPort. It appears the creation of a MID could be appropriate for the Exit 3 project area, but a TIF is inappropriate under these conditions. In addition, there are significant financial risks to municipalities in bonding funds against future potential development, particularly where, as here, the proposed development plans have not been finalized and all necessary state and federal environmental permits have not been obtained. There are extensive wetlands in this area that will need to be avoided and any unavoidable impacts must be minimized or mitigated for, which may change how and whether such future development takes shape. We recently submitted comments to the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers related to the proposed RiverPort development outlining our concerns with the project, specifically impacts to wetlands and sufficiently meaningful mitigation to offset unavoidable impacts. A copy of these comments are attached for reference. In light of these concerns, we encourage the City to table the creation of special financing districts until the development has obtained final authorization from state and federal agencies. Lastly, there are known costs associated with sprawl development and we encourage the City to take time to fully understand such costs before moving forward. In particular, we urge the City to review the 2006 Clemson Fiscal Impact Assessment for Jasper County, Hardeeville, and Ridgeland, and to coordinate with Jasper County in ongoing efforts to update this study. Thank you for your consideration of these important issues. Sincerely, Jessie White South Coast Office Director June 25, 2020 VIA E-MAIL Mr. Richard L. Darden U.S. Army Corps of Engineers ATTN: REGULATORY DIVISION 69A Hagood Avenue Charleston, SC 29403 Richard.L.Darden@usace.army.mil Re: Application P/N SAC 2010-00064 Riverport Development Dear Mr. Darden, The Southern Environmental Law Center (“SELC”), on behalf of the Coastal Conservation League (the “Conservation League”), submits these comments on the above referenced joint public notice (“JPN”) issued by the Charleston District of the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (the “Corps”) and the South Carolina Department of Health and Environmental Control (“DHEC”) on May 27, 2020. The Applicant has applied to the Corps for a Clean Water Act (“CWA”) Section 404 permit to fill wetlands, and to DHEC for a Section 401 Water Quality Certification and a Coastal Zone Consistency Certification for the project. The project proposes to discharge fill material into 35.17 acres of wetlands for road crossings and improvements to existing roads as part of a major mixed-use development in Jasper County, South Carolina. As explained in the JPN, the Applicant proposes to build a master-planned, mixed-use development with industrial, commercial, civic, and residential uses at the 4,368.81-acre Riverport Tract. The project, located north and south of I-95, would include 3,339 new residential units, more than 10.6 million square feet of industrial warehouse space and 2.6 million square feet of commercial space, and a new interchange with I-95 at Mile Marker 3.1 The stated project purpose is to “meet projected future growth associated with the existing Port of Savannah and Jasper Ocean Terminal.” JPN at 2. This project appears largely similar in size, location, and purpose to the formerly proposed “RiverPort Development” (also SAC 2010- 1 We question how a private developer can apply for a permit to make major modifications to an interstate highway without the apparent involvement of either the U.S. Department of Transportation or the South Carolina Department of Transportation. The Corps should consider whether it would be permissible or prudent to issue a permit for that component of the project unless and until those agencies sponsor the Application. 2 00064), for which the Corps began preparing, but later suspended without explanation, an Environmental Impact Statement in 2014.2 In sum, and as described in greater detail below, we have significant concerns regarding this proposal. We offer the following comments on the project and may supplement our comments in the future if we have the opportunity to review additional information about the proposal.3 1. Pursuant to NEPA and Its Implementing Regulations, the Corps Must Prepare an EIS for This Project. The National Environmental Policy Act (“NEPA”) directs federal agencies to prepare an Environmental Impact Statement (“EIS”) for any major federal action that significantly affects the quality of the human environment. 42 U.S.C. § 4332(2)(C). The “significance” of a proposed action is determined by evaluating both the context of the action and the intensity of its impact. 40 C.F.R. § 1508.27. Intensity refers to the severity of the action as revealed through the consideration of ten factors, many of which would apply to this proposal: (1) “Impacts that may be both beneficial and adverse”; (2) The “degree to which the proposed action affects public health or safety”; (3) “Unique characteristics of the geographic area such as proximity to historic or cultural resources, park lands, prime farmlands, wetlands, wild and scenic rivers, or ecologically critical areas”; (4) “The degree to which the effects on the quality of the human environment are likely to be highly controversial”; (5) “The degree to which the possible effects on the human environment are highly unknown or involve unique or unknown risks”; (6) “The degree to which the action may establish a precedent for future actions with significant effects”; (7) The cumulative impacts of the activity on the environment; 2 U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Notice of Intent to Prepare a Draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS) for the RiverPort Development and Proposed New Interchange on I-95 in Jasper County, South Carolina and Notice of Scoping Meeting, SAC-2010-00064 (July 31, 2014). 3 As a general matter, the JPN does not include sufficient information to provide meaningful public notice and opportunity for comment. Public notice for a CWA Section 404 permit “must contain a statement explaining how impacts associated with the proposed activity are to be avoided, minimized, and compensated for,” and the “level of detail provided in the public notice must be commensurate with the scope and scale of the impacts.” 33 C.F.R. 332.4(b)(1). In light of the scope and scale of impacts here, this JPN does not prov ide adequate information. We may submit a FOIA request to allow us to review more detailed information about the project, and we may supplement our comments in the future after we have had the opportunity to review additional information about the proposal, including the mitigation plan. In the meantime, we offer the following initial comments based on the information provided in the JPN. 3 (8) “The degree to which the action . . . may cause loss or destruction of significant scientific, cultural, or historical resources”; (9) “The degree to which the action may adversely affect any endangered or threatened species or its habitat that has been determined to be critical under the Endangered Species Act of 1973”; and (10) “Whether the action threatens a violation of Federal, State, or local law or requirements imposed for the protection of the environment.” Id. § 1508.27(b). “An action may be ‘significant’ if one of these factors is met.” Ctr. for Biological Diversity v. Nat’l Highway Traffic Safety Admin., 538 F.3d 1172, 1220 (9th Cir. 2008). As with the prior iteration of this project, the Corps must prepare an EIS to evaluate the full scope of impacts from, and alternatives to, this “significant” action. At 4,368.81 acres, the proposal is nearly identical in size to its predecessor and contains the same general component parts, with large-scale residential, commercial, and industrial uses and a new interchange with I- 95 planned.4 Notably, this intensive development would border the 31,551-acre Savannah National Wildlife Refuge (“Savannah NWR” or “refuge”), which contains ecologically critical freshwater marshes, tidal rivers and creeks, and bottomland hardwoods. See 40 C.F.R. § 1508.27(b)(3). Along with about 3,000 acres of managed freshwater impoundments, these habitats support a diverse array of plant and animal species, including resident wading birds and federally endangered wood storks, red-cockaded woodpeckers, least terns, shortnose sturgeon, and manatees.5 See 40 C.F.R. § 1508.27(b)(9). The refuge is also an important link in the chain of NWRs along the Atlantic Flyaway, attracting thousands of migratory birds each year.6 Due to the project’s proximity to, and potential impacts on, the Savannah NWF, NEPA demands that the Corps evaluate this proposal in an EIS. In addition to the neighboring Savannah NWR, the project area itself contains valuable ecological and aquatic resources that would be adversely affected by the proposed development. Not only would the project fill 35.17 acres of wetlands, it would surround and fragment nearly 1,400 more acres of wetlands, JPN at 6, and expose them to harmful runoff and likely other sources of pollution. Such impacts reduce the capacity of wetlands to retain and store floodwaters, thereby increasing the risk of flooding to the proposed new homes and businesses. See infra Section 2. Because much of the Riverport Tract—especially the portions slated for 4 U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, supra note 1, at 3. 5 U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, “Savannah National Wildlife Refuge,” https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q= &esrc=s&source=web&cd=&ved=2ahUKEwicusmV053qAhW7oXIEHYoDB2UQFjABegQICBAC&url=https%3 A%2F%2Fwww.fws.gov%2Fsoutheast%2Fpdf%2Ftearsheet%2Fsavannah-national-wildlife- refuge.pdf&usg=AOvVaw147nGf WuoSaspPcCDZWTkX 6 Id. 4 residential development—already lies within the FEMA 100-year floodplain, the Corps must analyze this flood risk and the associated risk to public health and safety. See 40 C.F.R. § 1508.27(b)(2). Beyond wetlands, the project area also contains critical habitat for the frosted flatwoods salamander. Even though the JPN shows no construction within the limits of the critical habitat, the project could still adversely affect that habitat through fragmentation, pollution, and human disturbance. See 40 C.F.R. § 1508.27(b)(9). Finally, the proposed project could unleash or exacerbate a host of cumulative impacts on the environment which merit further study in an EIS. See 40 C.F.R. § 1508.27(b)(7). In 2014, the project sponsors predicted that the commercial and industrial components of the RiverPort Development would support 24,000 permanent jobs by Year 30.7 Assuming a similar degree of economic impact here, all of these new jobs would induce housing and commercial development in and around rural Hardeeville, resulting in more wetlands fill and water pollution, more traffic and air pollution, and other environmental degradation. The proposed new interchange with I-95 and improvements to Purrysburg Road would only reinforce these development forces. The project also has the potential to aggravate past and future threats to the Savannah NWR. As mentioned above, the refuge contains valuable and increasingly rare habitats—for example, tidal freshwater marshes. These marshes are far more biologically diverse than their saltwater counterparts, but have largely disappeared from the Atlantic Coast after decades of development.8 The freshwater marshes in the Savannah NWR face additional threats such as saltwater intrusion from the dredging and deepening of the Savannah River and rising sea levels. The proposed development could further stress this delicate ecosystem. As proposed, this project would introduce intensive development into an otherwise rural, natural place, bordered by an internationally significant, and severely threatened, wildlife refuge. Due to the potential impacts to wetlands, endangered species, and public health and safety— compounded with other past, present, and future actions in the area—the Corps must prepare a full EIS for the project. The Corps already began this process in 2014 for the prior iteration of the RiverPort Development. Though that process apparently ended without an EIS, there can be little doubt that this new, largely identical proposal warrants the same level of NEPA review. 2. Compliance with Clean Water Act Guidelines 2.1 Ensure the Least Damaging Practicable Alternative is Selected. As proposed, the project will have significant wetland impacts; therefore, this project must comply with the Clean Water Act Section 404(b)(1) Guidelines (the “Guidelines”). 33 C.F.R. § 320.4(a)(1). The Guidelines provide significant protection to wetlands, and the 7 U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, supra note 1, at 3. 8 U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, “Tidal Freshwater Marsh,” Savannah National Wildlife Refuge (last updated June 20, 2014), https://www.fws.gov/refuge/Savannah/wildlife_and_habitat/tidal_freshwater_marsh.html. 5 degradation or destruction of wetlands “is considered to be among the most severe environmental impacts covered by these Guidelines.” 40 C.F.R. § 230.1(d). The Guidelines state that the Corps may not permit a discharge of dredged or fill material if there is a less damaging “practicable alternative,” or if the discharge will “cause or contribute to significant degradation” of waters of the United States. Id. § 230.10. In applying the practicable alternative standard, the Corps must consider the project’s “basic purpose.” See id. § 230.10(a)(3). If the project’s basic purpose is not water dependent, the Guidelines apply a presumption that a practicable alternative with less adverse environmental impact on wetlands exists. Id. An alternative “is practicable if it is available and capable of being done after taking into consideration cost, existing technology, and logistics in light of overall project purpose.” Id. § 230.10(a)(2). Where a discharge is proposed for a wetland or other special aquatic site, all practicable alternatives to the proposed discharge that do not involve a discharge to the wetland “are presumed to have less adverse impact on the aquatic ecosystem, unless clearly demonstrated otherwise.” Id. § 230.10(a)(3). The burden is on the Applicant to rebut the presumption by “clearly demonstrat[ing]” that a less damaging practicable alternative is not available. See id. Here, the Applicant has failed to carry that burden. The Applicant is required to take all appropriate and practicable steps to avoid and minimize adverse impacts to waters of the United States. See 40 C.F.R. § 230.91(c)(2). While we understand that the Applicant has taken steps to limit wetland impacts to road crossings, 35 acres of wetlands is still a significant loss to this watershed. In this early project stage, it is crucial that the Applicant evaluate all possible alternatives that would further avoid and minimize impacts to wetlands, including alternative site designs that minimize the number of required road crossings on the project site. Additionally, we urge the Applicant to bridge road crossings to maintain some of the hydrologic connections among the contiguous wetland system on the site and avoid further fragmentation and degradation of the project’s wetlands. Given the significant public benefits wetlands provide, the Applicant must avoid wetland impacts to the greatest extent possible in order to comply with the Corps’ public interest test.9 Coastal wetland systems provide important wave buffering and flood retention services for coastal communities and should be protected to maintain these hazard mitigation services.10 An assessment following Hurricane Sandy found that coastal wetlands helped affected states avoid 9 The Corps must evaluate whether proposals for Section 404 permits comply with the public interest test, which is based on probable impacts, including cumulative impacts, to safety, wetlands, flood hazards, floodplain values, land use, and the needs and welfare of the people, among other considerations. See 33 C.F.R. § 320.4(a)(1). 10 See W.J. Mitsch et al., “Ecosystem services of wetlands,” 11 INT’L J. OF BIODIVERSITY SCI., ECOSYSTEM SERVS. & MGMT., no. 1, at 1–4 (2015), https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/21513732.2015.1006250?scroll=top&needAccess=true; A. Bullock & M. Acreman, “The role of wetlands in the hydrological cycle,” 7 HYDROLOGY AND EARTH SYS. SCI., no. 3, at 358–89 (2003), https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00304786/document; M. Acreman & J. Holden, “How wetlands affect floods,” 33 WETLANDS, no. 5, at 773–86 (2013), https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s13157-013-0473-2. 6 $625 million in direct damages during the storm.11 The Houston area lost 4 billion gallons worth of flood retention after losing 5.5 percent of its freshwater wetlands between 1992 and 2010.12 Charleston’s Church Creek basin lost 24 percent of its wetland area from 1996 to 2010, and the community’s flooding woes became a recurrent problem over that time period. Maintaining existing wetlands so that they continue to provide natural flood storage and storm buffering helps avoid taxpayer-funded flood control projects in the future. In light of the stronger storms and sea level rise the South Carolina coast is already experiencing due to climate change, it is crucial to preserve wetlands and their services to the greatest extent possible.13 2.2 Floodplains, Present and Future Risk. Under the Section 404(b)(1) Guidelines, the Corps is required to consider “the capacity of wetlands to retain and store floodwaters and to serve as a buffer zone shielding upland areas from wave actions, storm damage and erosion.” 40 C.F.R. § 230.41(b). A significant portion of the Riverport property lies within the 1% Annual Chance Flood Hazard, or 100-year floodplain, as defined by Preliminary FEMA National Flood Hazard data, and therefore a significant portion of the wetlands impacted by this project are within the floodplain.14 The JPN does not mention this flood risk, which suggests that the Applicant has not adequately considered this issue. The flood storage capacity of the wetlands on the proposed site coupled with the potential of this proposal to alter stormwater flow in the watershed through its construction must be considered in order to comply with the Guidelines. Floodplains, in addition to wetlands and forested infiltration areas, are natural site resources that should be maintained to assist in water retention on a property.15 Undeveloped floodplains and wetlands provide crucial flood storage benefits. Floodplains of the Waccamaw River and swamplands just north of Conway reduce flooding by up to 1.5 feet for floods up to a 200-year event, and provide an average of $6.14 million in avoided damage annually.16 Following Hurricane Florence, a floodplain area of about 156,000 acres around the Great Pee Dee, Little Pee Dee, and Lynches rivers stored enough water to fill over half a million Olympic-sized swimming pools.17 Because the floodplain absorbed this 11 S. Narayan et al., “The value of coastal wetlands for flood damage reduction in the Northeastern USA ,” SCIENTIFIC REPORTS, at 1 (2017), https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-017-09269-z. 12 J.S. Jacob et al., “Houston area freshwater wetland loss, 1992-2010,” (2015), http://tcwp.tamu.edu/files/2015/06/WetlandLossPub.pdf. 13 U.S. Global Change Research Program, “Precipitation Change in the United States,” CLIMATE SCIENCE SPECIAL REPORT: FOURTH NATIONAL CLIMATE ASSESSMENT (2017). 14 Almost the entire northern half of the project, where the residential development is proposed, lies in the 100 -year floodplain, and a significant portion of the property south of I-95 lies in the 100-year floodplain. 15 City of Charleston, “Stormwater Design Manual,” Section 1.7.4.1 https://www.charleston- sc.gov/DocumentCenter/View/5972. 16 Keil Schmidt, Pilot Report: Measurement of Floodplain Value for Downstream Flood Reduction, TNC. 17 One acre-foot is equal to 1,613.3 cubic yards, so the forest stored approximately 1,936,000,000 c ubic yards. An Olympic swimming pool is 3300 cubic yards. This means the floodplain stored enough water to fill over 586,665 Olympic swimming pools. Williams et al, “Hurricane Florence Flooding in Georgetown County: A Qualitative Exploration of the Interactions of Estuary and Tidal River,” JOURNAL OF SC WATER RESOURCES (2019). 7 extreme flooding and slowly released the water over 10 days, downstream Georgetown County weathered the storm without major flooding. Development and wetland fill within the floodplain exacerbate existing flooding issues and leave the area at risk to increased future flooding from intensifying storms, fueled by a changing climate.18 The public interest review requirement for the issuance of a Section 404 permit further supports the need to consider these critical resilience issues. The decision of whether to issue a Section 404 permit must be based on an evaluation of the probable impacts, including cumulative impacts, of the proposed activity and its intended use on the public interest. 33 C.F.R. § 320.4(a)(1). This public interest review requires the Corps to carefully weigh all factors which may be relevant to the proposal, balancing benefits against reasonably foreseeable detriments. See id. The regulations list flood hazards, floodplain values, and shore erosion and accretion as factors that must be considered as part of a public interest review if relevant to the project. See id. This project is proposing to place over 3,000 new homes in the floodplain. The community exposure and risk this would create is clearly not in the public interest. The potential for flood hazards caused by sea level rise, extreme rainfall, and intensifying storm surge is a relevant factor that must be considered as part of the public interest review for a permit proposing substantial development within the 100-year floodplain. The Riverport Tract is vulnerable to flooding from rainfall and storm surge due to its position near the Savannah River and low lying nature of the land. The Savannah area has experienced flooding from several extreme rain events already this year.19 One storm on June 12, 2020 brought approximately 5 inches of rain in just an hour, equivalent to a 500-year rainfall event.20 The current linear rate of sea level rise at the Fort Pulaski gauge, down the Savannah River from this project, is 3.33 mm per year, or 1.3 inches each decade.21 Accounting for the additional acceleration of sea level rise, Intermediate and Intermediate-High scenarios from the 4th National Climate Assessment project 1 to 2 feet of sea level rise at the Fort Pulaski gauge by the middle of the century, compared to sea levels in the year 2000.22 These same scenarios predict between 3.8 and 6.1 feet of sea level rise by 2100. With any increase in sea level rise, the water of the Savannah River inches closer to 18 U.S. Global Change Research Program, “Southeast,” IMPACTS, RISKS, AND ADAPTATION IN THE UNITED STATES: FOURTH NATIONAL CLIMATE ASSESSMENT, Volume II (2018), https://nca2018.globalchange.gov/chapter/19/. 19 See https://www.wtoc.com/2020/03/06/rain-leads-flooding-coastal-empire/; https://www.wjcl.com/article/streets- flood-in-savannah-after-morning-rain/32131832; https://www.wtoc.com/2020/06/12/street-flooding-reported- savannah/. 20 WTOC, “Heavy Rain Causes Flooding in Savannah, Richmond Hill,” (June 2020), https://www.wtoc.com/2020/06/12/street-flooding-reported-savannah/ 21 National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, “Sea Level Trends,” (2020), https://tidesandcurrents.noaa.gov/sltrends/sltrends.html. 22 National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, “Global and Regional Sea Level Rise Scenarios for the United States,” U.S. Department of Commerce (2017), https://tidesandcurrents.noaa.gov/publications/techrpt83_Global_and_Regional_SLR_Scenarios_for_the_US_final.p df. 8 the development site. Failure to consider these combined flooding risks could have disastrous consequences for the planned development associated with this project. There is a consensus among researchers that climate change will continue to make storms and the floods that follow more intense, as a warmer air can hold more moisture and add more fuel to storm systems.23 Extreme rainfall has already become more frequent and more damaging throughout the Southeast.24 In a climate scenario where today’s emission levels remain constant, the number of extreme rain storms in the Southeast will increase by two to three times the historic average by the end of the 21st century.25 Before the end of the century, throughout the Southeast, extreme summer thunderstorms that typically result in 100-year floods events are expected to drop between 40 percent and 80 percent more rain than today.26 This trend will continue into the future even in a scenario with emissions reductions.27 With all of these factors considered, placing more infrastructure in a floodplain and destroying crucial wetlands make even less sense. We should be maintaining our existing wetlands so that they continue to provide natural flood storage, minimizing the need for costly flood control projects in the future, rather than investing in costly new infrastructure within the floodplain. Planning for impacts now is cheaper and more responsible than placing the burden on residents and the government down the road – for every $1 spent on mitigation, the nation saves $6 in future disaster costs, by the latest estimations.28 2.3 401 Water Quality Certification and Coastal Zone Management Consistency Certification. In addition to a Section 404 permit, the proposed development requires a 401 Water Quality Certification (“401 Certification”) and a Coastal Zone Consistency Certification (“Consistency Certification”) from DHEC to proceed to construction. The regulations implementing these Certification programs set forth similar analytical requirements to the Guidelines. Most notably, DHEC may not issue a 401 Certification or a Consistency Certification to fill or permanently alter wetlands if a feasible alternative exists to the proposal. 23 Global Fluid Dynamics Laboratory, “Global Warming and Hurricanes,” NOAA (2020), https://www.gfdl.noaa.gov/global-warming-and-hurricanes/. 24 U.S. Global Change Research Program, “Precipitation Change in the United States,” Climate Science Special Report: Fourth National Climate Assessment, Volume I at 207-230, https://science2017.globalchange.gov/chapter/7/. 25 U.S. Global Change Research Program, “Precipitation Change in the United States,” CLIMATE SCIENCE SPECIAL REPORT: FOURTH NATIONAL CLIMATE ASSESSMENT, Volume I at 207-230, https://science2017.globalchange.gov/chapter/7/. 26 Andreas F. Prein et al., “Increased Rainfall Volume from Future Convective Storms in the US,” NATURE CLIMATE CHANGE 7, at 880-884 (2017), https://www.nature.com/articles/nclimate3168. 27 U.S. Global Change Research Program, “Southeast,” IMPACTS, RISKS, AND ADAPTATION IN THE UNITED STATES: FOURTH NATIONAL CLIMATE ASSESSMENT, Volume II (2018), https://nca2018.globalchange.gov/chapter/19/. 28 National Institute of Building Sciences, “Natural Hazard Mitigation Saves: 2017 Interim Report,” (2017), https://www.nibs.org/news/381874/National-Institute-of-Building-Sciences-Issues-New-Report-on-the-Value-of- Mitigation.htm. 9 See S.C. Code Regs. 61-101.F.5.a-b.; S.C. Coastal Program29 at III.C.3.XII.E.1 (July 1979). The Consistency Certification regulations are particularly strict with respect to residential and commercial development. A residential development may not fill or permanently alter wetlands “unless no feasible alternatives exist or an overriding public interest can be demonstrated, and any substantial environmental damage can be minimized.” S.C. Coastal Program at III.C.3.I.1.b. A commercial development may not fill or permanently alter wetlands “unless no feasible alternatives exist and the facility is water-dependent.” S.C. Coastal Program at III.C.3.IV.1.b (emphasis added). As discussed above, the Corps—and DHEC—must evaluate all alternatives to the proposed development to ensure that no practicable alternative exists which would result in less wetland fill. But the agency should also consider the various other ways in which the project could permanently alter the functions and values of surrounding wetlands. See S.C. Code Regs. 61-101.F.5.a-b (directing DHEC to deny 401 Certification where the proposed activity would impair the “functions and values” of the aquatic ecosystem). The construction of homes, businesses, warehouses, roads, and parking lots would cover the Riverport Tract in impervious surfaces, generating stormwater runoff and funneling pollution into nearby waterways. Polluted runoff is one of the single largest threats to water quality in the United States, and studies show that waterbodies exposed to urban runoff experience declines in plant and animal diversity and fitness.30 Along with runoff, the waterways around the proposed development may become receiving waters for harmful industrial and municipal discharges. Finally, any wetlands fragmentation due to road crossings or other construction would compound the effects of pollution by further degrading habitat and water quality,31 and would potentially exacerbate the risk of flooding in the area.32 3. The Proposed Mitigation Plan is Insufficient. Mitigation is the third and final step in the 404 process, and should therefore not be considered until avoidance and minimization have been completed and the 404 requirements are satisfied. 40 C.F.R. § 230. Given the large number of planned wetland impacts, the Applicant should be planning to appropriately mitigate for these impacts. However the current mitigation package proposed by the Applicant is deficient and these shortcomings must be addressed.33 29 Available at https://scdhec.gov/sites/default/files/docs/HomeAndEnvironment/Docs/SC_Coastal_%20Program% 20(Pt.%202%20-%20Ch.%20III).pdf. 30 U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, “NPDES Stormwater Program” (last updated Mar. 20, 2020), https://www.epa.gov/npdes/npdes-stormwater-program. 31 Bradley Cosentino et al., “Dispersal and Wetland Fragmentation” (2018), https://experts.illinois.edu/en/publications/dispersal-and-wetland-fragmentation. 32 Susan Laurance et al., “Drivers of Wetland Disturbance and Biodiversity Impacts on a Tropical Oceanic Island ,” Biological Conservation vol. 149, no. 1 (2012). 33 We have not yet obtained the full Mitigation Plan for this project, therefore the assertions made about the Mitigation Plan below are based solely on the limited information on mitigation provided in the JPN. 10 The Applicant has proposed an on-site Permittee Responsible Mitigation (“PRM”) plan after determining that sufficient bank credits do not exist in the watershed. JPN at 2. The Applicant proposes to generate credits for the PRM by preserving and buffering remaining on- site aquatic resources and restoring approximately 150 acres of pine plantation to historic wetland conditions. 3.1 The Preservation Criteria Must be Satisfied. The majority of the credits generated by the proposed PRM come from the preservation of avoided on-site wetlands. While the preservation of the remaining on-site aquatic resources benefits the development, for various reasons this should not directly generate credits for the PRM. First, it is inconsistent with the preservation criteria outlined in federal regulations and listed below: (i) The resources to be preserved provide important physical, chemical, or biological functions for the watershed; (ii) The resources to be preserved contribute significantly to the ecological sustainability of the watershed. In determining the contribution of those resources to the ecological sustainability of the watershed, the district engineer must use appropriate quantitative assessment tools, where available; (iii) Preservation is determined by the district engineer to be appropriate and practicable; (iv) The resources are under threat of destruction or adverse modifications; and (v) The preserved site will be permanently protected through an appropriate real estate or other legal instrument (e.g., easement, title transfer to state resource agency or land trust). 33 CFR 332.2(a)(2). The Applicant’s proposal does not satisfy the criteria in several respects. The remaining wetlands within the project boundary are not under threat of development because the Applicant would be unable to obtain a permit for a larger amount of wetland impacts, as demonstrated by the Corps’ rejection of the Applicant’s original permit application based partly on the massive number of proposed wetland impacts. Many of the wetlands the Applicant proposes to preserve for preservation credits will be encompassed by the development outlined in this permit application, resulting in fragmentation and degradation of these wetland resources. For these reasons, the Applicants’ proposal for wetlands preservation does not qualify for credit generation. Further, the proposal to preserve the remaining aquatic resources on-site “does not offset adverse impacts to other aquatic resources” and therefore does “not meet the preservation criteria 11 identified in the Mitigation Rule.”34 Preservation alone of avoided wetlands does not qualify as adequate mitigation according to the Corps Guidelines for Preparing a Compensatory Mitigation Plan (SOP). Section 5.2.1 of the SOP states: With the possible exception of outstanding aquatic resources that are important on a watershed scale, the preservation of buffer zones, riparian areas, and the remaining aquatic resources on the project site does not [emphasis added] meet the preservation criteria identified in the Mitigation Rule (33 CFR 332.3(h)). Therefore, the preservation of these areas does not generate compensatory mitigation credits to offset adverse impacts to aquatic resources. When removing a wetland and its valuable functions from a watershed, an applicant must proportionately offset that impact to ensure the continued health of the watershed. While the wetlands proposed as preservation provide functional value to the community, their continued presence does not make up for the loss of wetlands elsewhere on the property. 3.2 Preservation, Enhancement, and Restoration. While the Applicant should not take direct credit for the preservation of the remaining on-site wetlands, they should preserve them for flood protection and other ecosystem services wetlands provide. Under the current Charleston District SOP, the Applicants qualify for a 25 percent reduction in the amount of credits needed if they protect the remaining on-site aquatic resources. 35 This reduction is offered by the SOP as an incentive to preserve avoided wetlands, but it is not meant to generate credits outright. The Corps SOP requires that greater than 50 percent of credits in a mitigation plan must come from restoration and enhancement.36 However, the plan outlined in the JPN generates credits primarily through preservation. The Applicant proposes the restoration of 150 acres of pine plantation to its original wetland condition, however the JPN does not detail additional restoration or enhancement measures. As the Mitigation Rule states: “restoration should generally be the first option considered because the likelihood of success is greater…and the potential gains in terms of aquatic resource functions are greater, compared to enhancement and preservation.” 33 CFR 332.2(a)(2). Further restoration of wetlands should be explored to ensure that greater than 50 percent of credits in the Riverport PRM are generated from restoration and enhancement. 34 SOP at 10. 35 SOP at 14. 36 SOP at 1. 12 3.3 Additional Measures to Offset Harm to the Savannah National Wildlife Refuge. Given the project’s proximity to the ecologically valuable Savannah NWR, we urge the Applicant to evaluate and implement measures to protect the refuge from indirect impacts associated with this development. This could involve create a buffer between the proposed development and the Savannah NWR to reduce encroachment upon the wildlife and habitat in the refuge. This would also buffer the proposed residential neighborhoods from smoke impacts from prescribed burning conducted at the Savannah NWR and surrounding conservation properties. We appreciate the opportunity to submit these comments on the proposed Riverport Development. Based on the limited information provided in the JPN, we have significant concerns with the project, including the potential impacts to wetlands and the Savannah NWR and the proposed mitigation plan. Unless and until those concerns are addressed through an EIS, we respectfully request that the Corps deny the permit application for this project. Sincerely, Christopher K. DeScherer Managing Attorney CC (via email only): Jessie White, CCL Chuck Hightower, DHEC Blair Williams, DHEC Pace Wilber, NMFS Kelly Laycock, EPA Region 4 Susan Davis, SCDNR Tom McCoy, FWS Draft Dated October 22, 2020 ORDINANCE NO: 2020-11-5B AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA, AUTHORIZING AND APPROVING THE EXIT 3 IMPROVEMENT PLAN AND THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE EXIT 3 MUNICIPAL IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT; PROVIDING FOR THE FINANCING OF IMPROVEMENTS WITHIN THE EXIT 3 MUNICIPAL IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT BY ASSESSMENTS, ASSESSMENT DEBT AND OTHER FUNDS AS HEREIN DESCRIBED; AND OTHER MATTERS RELATING THERETO. BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CIT Y COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HARDEEVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA, AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. Findings and Determinations. The City Council (the “City Council”) of the City of Hardeeville, South Carolina (the “City”), hereby finds and determines: (a) The City is a municipality of the State of South Carolina (the “State”), and as such, possesses certain powers granted by the Constitution and general laws of the State. (b) Pursuant to the Municipal Improvements Act of 1999, as codified as Title 5, Chapter 37 of the Code of Laws of South Carolina 1976, as amended (the “Act”), the municipalities of the State are vested with all powers consistent with the Constitution necessary, useful, and desirable to effect improvements within an improvement district, to increase property values, to prevent depreciation of property values, and to preserve and increase their tax bases. (c) As set forth in a resolution adopted by the City Council on October 1, 2020 (the “Resolution”), an “improvement plan” (within the meaning of Section 5- 37-20(4) of the Act), entitled “Improvement Plan Exit 3 Municipal Improvement District City of Hardeeville, South Carolina ,” a copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit A (the “Improvement Plan”), has been presented to the City, which Improvement Plan, among other things, contemplates the creation of an “improvement district” (within the meaning of Section 5-37-20(3) of the Act) to be known as the Exit 3 Municipal Improvement District (the “Improvement District”). A copy of the Improvement Plan, which i s incorporated herein by reference, is available for review at the office of the City Manager of the City, located at 205 East Main Street, Hardeeville, South Carolina. The Improvement Plan contemplates the construction of certain public improvements with in or benefiting the Improvement District as more particularly described herein (collectively, the “Improvements”) which constitute “Improvements” within the meaning of Section 5-37- 20(2) of the Act. None of the Improvements has been completed or is, as o f this date of this Ordinance, under construction (other than those Improvements that (i) consist of approximately a 1- mile stretch of RiverPort Parkway south of I-95, (ii) are not located within the Improvement District, (iii) were constructed by private parties in or about 2013, and (iv) will not be paid for directly or indirectly by “assessments” (within the meaning of Section 5- 37-20(1) of the Act) imposed on the real property in the Improvement District (such Improvements being referred to herein as the “Existing Improvements”)) . (d) The Improvement District will consist of all or a portion of a tract of real property in Jasper County, South Carolina (the “County”), within the corporate limits of the City, comprising approximately 2 1,608.30 acres of real property located within the City, which real property is more fully described in the legal description attached as Exhibit B hereto (the “Property”). The real property comprising the Improvement District is presently owned by SLF III – Hardeeville, LLC, a Texas limited liability company (the “Owner”), which has petitioned the City to create the Improvement District pursuant to Section 5-37- 40(B) of the Act. The City Council has been informed and believes that all of the real property comprising the Improvement District is presently owned by Owner. It is expected that the either the Owner or its successors and assigns (in such capacity, the “Developer”) will develop the Improvement District. (e) A copy of the plat incorporated by reference in Exhibit B hereto is on file in the office of the City Manager and is available for inspection during normal business hours. (f) The City Council has determined after due investigation and study, that to the extent that Improvements will be located outside of the boundaries of the Improvement District , such Improvements will confer a benefit on property inside the Improvement District or are necessary to make improvements within the Improvement District effective for the benefit of property inside the Improvement District. (g) Pursuant to Section 5- 37-50 of the Act and the provisions of the Resolution, a publ ic hearing concerning the Resolution was held on November 5, 2020, which date was neither sooner than 20 days nor more than 40 days following adoption of the Resolution, and neither less than ten days nor more than 120 days before the second reading and passage of this Ordinance. (h) Pursuant to Section 5-37-60 of the Act, the entire text of the Resolution was published once a week for two successive weeks in one or more newspapers of general circulation in the City. The last date of publication was not les s than ten days prior to the date of the public hearing concerning the Resolution. (i) Pursuant to Section 5-37-40 of the Act, the City Council hereby finds that: (1) the Improvements will be beneficial within the Improvement District; (2) the Improvements will preserve or increase property values w ithin the Improvement District; (3) the Improvements are likely to encourage developm ent in the Improvement District; (4) the general welfare and tax base of the City will be maintained or improved by the establishment of the Improvement District; and (5) it would be fair and equitable to finance all or part of the cost of the Improvements by an assessment upon certain real property located within the Improvement District. 3 (j) Pursuant to Title 31, Chapter 6 of the Code of Laws of South Carolina 1976, as amended (the “TIF Act”), the City, prior to the issuance of any Assessment Debt (as defined below) [and jointly with the County], will establish a “Redevelopment project area” (within the meaning of the TIF Act) to be known as the “Exit 3 Redevelopment Project Area” and to include the same real property included within the Improvement District. (k) The City Council hereby finds that the Improvements may be financed by the City through the issuance of bonds in one or more series and other borrowings (collectively, the “ Assessment Debt”) pursuant to the Act and the TIF Act to defray the costs of a portion of the Improvements. The term “Assessment Debt” includes bonds and other borrowings secured by and payable from both TIF Revenues Available for Debt Service (as defined below) and Assessm ent Revenues (as defined below). It is the intention of the City, that the City, the County and the Developer , individually and in conjunction with future owners or other interested parties, to undertake or engage in the financing of the Improvements in conjunction with the City for the benefit of the City and the future owners and users of the real property within the Improvement District. The Owner has petitioned the City to establish the Improvement District, has agreed to the imposition of special assessments on the real property located within the Improvement District pursuant to the Act in amounts, subject to the limitations set forth in Section 3 below, sufficient to pay debt service on the Assessment Debt and, as more particularly described herein and in the Improvement Plan, has agreed to the undertaking of certain of the Improvements. (l) The Improvement Plan sets forth the overall plan by which the City proposes to effect the Improvements within the Improvement District to preserve and enhance property values, prevent deterioration of the City’s urban areas and preserve and enhance the tax base of the City, including an overall plan by which the City proposes to effect such Improvements within the Improvement District in order to encourage and promote private or public development within the Improvement District. The Improvements are more fully described in the Improvement Plan and consist of (a) a new interchange at Exit 3 on I –95, including all related drainage and storm water infrastructure, (b) an approximately 1.5-mile stretch of RiverPort Parkway north of I–95, including all related drainage and storm water infrastructure, and (c) an approximately 4-mile stretch of RiverPort Parkway south of I–95, including all related drainage and storm water infrastructure. The City expects that (a) the Developer will be responsible for the design, permitting and approvals of the Improvements; (b) the Developer will be responsible for the construction of the RiverPort Parkway south of Exit 3 portion of the Improvements; and (c) the South Carolina Department of Transportation will be responsible for monitoring construction of Exit 3 interchange and the RiverPort Parkway north of Exit 3 portions of the Improvements. Upon completion of the construction of the Improvements, the City or other public entity will own the Improvements. Construction of Improvements will proceed in accordance wi

Text truncated. Open the original for the full document.

Source: City of Hardeeville website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.