RecordWell Data

Planning Commission Worksession — Minutes

City of Beaufort · Beaufort County · Planning Commission · meeting of Jun 1, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from City of Beaufort

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

1 Planning Commission Work Session Minutes – June 1, 2026 CALL TO ORDER 2:40 A worksession of the Planning Commission was called to order by Chairman Tomy and was held in- person in the Planning Conference Room on June 1, 2026 at 1:02 PM. The meeting was broadcast via zoom and live-streamed on YouTube. You can view this meeting at the City’s page; City of Beaufort Government. ATTENDEES Members in attendance: Mike Tomy, Chairman, Bill Bardenwerper, Vice-Chairman, Libby Anderson, Secretary, Clinton Hallman, Kim McFann, and Benjie Morillo. Member absent: Bill Suter Staff in attendance: Curt Freese, Community Development Department Director, Christopher Klement, Planner III, and Nick Navia, Planner I. GENERAL DISCUSSION 2:51 Chairman Tomy stated today the Planning Commission (PC) is going to try and get through all of Chapters 2, 3, and 4 so at the next public session the PC can vote on the approvals of these sections. Mr. Freese said we are going to try and use AI tool to give a summary so it’s easier for the PC to make the final decision for when it goes to Council. He stressed that AI will not write the code, but just provide a summary. Mr. Tomy referred to the Historic District Task Force Meeting he attended and the issue that came up with Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs) and how they relate to the Northwest Quadrant and the Old Commons. He recommend that the PC take another look at the code as it relates to those areas and whether or not the PC needs to single out those areas for ADUs and what the restrictions are on ADUs in those areas. Mr. Tomy will look into this. 2 PUBLIC COMMENT 8:18 Graham Trask, doesn’t have any specific comments. He said some of the suggestions made today are very important to him and he hopes the city’s IT person and the city will be receptive to him raising his hand to interject at various points throughout the meeting. DISCUSSION – CHAPTERS 2, 3, AND 4 REVIEW 10:18 Mr. Freese said the purpose of the worksession today is to finalize changes to Chapters 2, 3, and 4 of the Development Code so they may be formally recommended with a vote at the next regular meeting on June 15, 2026. Staff is working on providing final versions but recommends using the versions sent at the PC meeting for reference, until final changes can be discussed at the worksession. In addition, Staff will work with Ms. McFann, to create side by side versions when such changes are finalized. Mr. Freese went over the items and proposed revisions which included the attorney’s revisions that were listed in his memorandum that was included in PC packets. T5-UC/RMX – Split Zoning Mr. Freese stated there was concern raised at the PC meeting, that it was unfair and contrary to the purpose of the RMX/T5-UC split zoning, to require any split zoned property next to an urban block must be developed in the T-5 UC district. These split zoned areas are all found on major corridors. The proposed revision in Section 3.2.1.G is to remove the sentence, if the PC agrees, “If urban blocks and lots/street sections, as found in Appendix C, exist adjacent to the RMX/T5-UC district being developed, T-5 UC development standards shall be followed”. Public Comment Paul Trask, 610 Bladen Street, referred to the zoning RMX/T5-UC and feels the changed language is constructive and good; it works. Public comment was closed. Inclusion of Bed & Breakfast Revision: Mr. Freese stated this was discussed at the February and March worksessions. The following revisions were agreed on, with the idea that any additional changes might be within the purview of City Council. The proposed revision in Section 3.6.3.C, if the PC agrees, is as follows: Bed and Breakfasts (B&B): a. Definitions. As used in this section: i. "Bed and breakfast" or “B&B” means a residential-type lodging facility having no more than ten guestrooms where transient guests are fed and lodged for pay. ii. "Guestroom" means a sleeping room, or a combination of rooms for sleeping and sitting, which includes, among other amenities: 3 (a) a bed or beds; (b) a private or shared bathroom; (c) clothes hanging and storage amenities; and (d) a selection of furniture and lighting. iii. "Residential-type lodging facility", means a facility that serves as both the innkeeper's residence and a place of lodging for transient guests. iv. "Innkeeper" means the proprietor or residential manager of the bed and breakfast who resides on the premises of the bed and breakfast. b. Number of Guest Rooms: 10 maximum, not including the caretaker's quarters. c. Signs: Total sign area for all signs advertising the B&B shall not exceed 5 square feet. All signs shall be constructed of wood or other durable non-plastic materials. d. Parking: One space per guest room, plus one (1) space for the resident manager shall be provided on-site. Formalized on-street parking spaces meeting the requirements of Section 5.7.4 B. may count towards this requirement. e. Spacing: There shall be no other B&B in a T3 or T4-HN zoning district located within 500 feet of a proposed B&B in either of these districts. Distances shall be measured from the property line. f. Meals: No meals will be served to anyone other than registered guests, except as provided for in Section 3.6.2 C.1.g. below. No variances from this condition shall be permitted. g. Events: Business meetings, receptions, teas, and other events are permitted, provided that the events are hosted for registered guests only. This shall apply to all B&Bs established under the Beaufort Code. h. Operation: B&Bs shall be operated by a resident manager living on the premises. Mr. Bardenwerper referred to the sentences that have been added and then referred to the State Statute Section 45-4-20 and the Bed & Breakfast revision and asked, “why do we have, in the red-lined section of Mr. Freese’s memorandum, a definition of residential-type lodging facility and an innkeeper”, when those aren’t terms that are used as seen in the regulation. The PC agreed by using the word Innkeeper, it implies the owner has to live at the Bed & Breakfast. Mr. Hallman suggested under I.a.iii, capitalizing the letter “i“ in innkeeper because it’s defined. Ms. McFann referred to the definition of the innkeeper in 1.a.iv and commented that it doesn’t refer to the owner, but the proprietor. Mr. Bardenwerper referred to the State Statute Section 45-4-20 regarding the Proprietor. Ms. McFann read the definition of a Proprietor as “the legal owner or holder of a business, property, or exclusive rights. It is commonly used in a business context and does not have to refer to the individual who owns, manages, and holds responsibility for and enterprise.” Public Comment Wallace Scarborough, 1207 Bay Street, commented that when the law was written, people weren’t putting things into LLC’s. It is correct that LLC’s are basically new. Mr. Scarborough understands that LLC’s have a principal who is the main controller of an LLC. He understands that if you are the principal of an LLC and that LLC owns the Bed and Breakfast, that the principal is the person that would need to be the Proprietor and live there. He recommends that the PC take the position of what the State 4 Statute says and not to get into what an LLC does or does not to. The best thing would be to take the State Statute and place it into the City’s Code. Public comment was closed. Ms. McFann asked, if we are just referencing the Statute, does a more restrictive provision need to be added. Mr. Freese clarified that the city attorney will look at all of these recommendations and he will then make comments or suggestions. Council will see his suggestions. Mr. Bardenwerper suggested under item e, Spacing, the word proposed be changed to existing. PC agreed to add the language, “petition City Council for a special event permit”. Public Comment Wallace Scarborough, 1207 Bay Street, said the Events weren’t supposed to be allowed in the State Statute. They didn’t want a Bed & Breakfast to be in the event venue. Bed & Breakfasts were in residential areas and hotels were in the commercial zones. A Bed & Breakfast was supposed to quietly fit into a neighborhood and cater to only the people staying there. For a special event, it is required to petition to the City Council for approval. Graham Trask, feels the code is clear. He said Bed & Breakfast are carved out to go into residential neighborhoods because otherwise renting rooms out is not allowed in a residential neighborhood. Regarding Events, the city code does have requirements for events that you have to get approved by City Council. Those requirements are designed to protect the residents who are in the residential neighborhood. Mr. Trask believes it is a risk to allow staff to approve those differently than are required already in the code. He recommends the PC move forward with aligning with State Code and if there are events that a Bed & Breakfast wants to hold at the Bed & Breakfast they have to be approved by City Council. Wallace Scarborough, 1207 Bay Street, said Bed & Breakfast require special requirements such as ADA approved bathrooms, ADA approved ramps for wheelchairs, and public bathrooms and that is why we really don’t want them. He said State Code 45-10 states the definition of a hotel is defined as an annual public lodging house with more than 10 bedrooms. Public comment was closed. Mr. Freese summarized the PC recommendations were: o Section 3.6.2.3.C.3 - remove the word inn and have the title read, Hotel/Motel. o Section 3.6.2.3.D.a. - remove numeral i. o Section 3.6.2.3.C.a.ii - change the word Inns to Lodging. o Remove all of Section 3.6.2.3.A and add a reference that says, Bed and Breakfast: See section 45-4-20 as amended from time to time of the State Statute. o Section 3.6.2.3.C.1 - remove item a (Number of Rental Rooms). o Section 3.6.2.3.C.1.d - change the word proposed to existing. o Section 3.6.2.3.C.1.d - do not include T4-N. o Section 3.6.2.3.C.1.e – remove the section that refers to Meals. o Section 3.6.2.3.C.1.f - under Events, add the sentence, A special event permit issued by the City is required for all events. Add after the word hosted, limited for registered guests only. 5 Public Comment Graham Trask, commented that the PC is asking things of the attorney in amending the code and is also representing the City in a lawsuit relative to B&B’s. This is a conflict for the city attorney. He encourages the Board to getting council from a nonconflicting attorney. Public comment was closed. Drive thru restriction in the RMX district Mr. Freese said at the PC meeting, there was discussion of drive-thrus in RMX. Staff does feel there are many requests for drive thrus, and both in past practice and per code, there are challenges to developing a drive thru within the City. Staff believes the RMX district is appropriate for drive thrus, and cleaning up the language below, would satisfy the goals of the code, in hiding the stacking of vehicles from the street, while allowing the realistic development of the use within the City. The proposed revision in Section 3.7.2 C, if the PC agrees, is as follows: ii. Specific to RMX: Drive through may be accessed or exited across the front of the building. Vehicle stacking must remain on side or rear of the building. Public Comment Paul Trask, 610 Bladen Street, talked about a few issues regarding the Chick-Fil-A and commented that City Council assumed this was approved under the former UDO, but that is false. The permit was issued under T5-UC. The City facilitated the entire project by selling the adjoining property which was the original Chick-Fil-A site. Without that sale, nothing could be built. He referred to the RMX zoning, RMX and commented that it’s a matter of right and should be able to circulate the building. He referred to the Taco Bell, KFC and Panda Express that all have stacking issues. He referred to the McDonald’s on Boundary Street that was approved under T5-UC and said, doesn’t function well. Mr. Trask referred to T5-UC and his project, Chipotle, and said cars do not stack and have a fence with landscaping for screening. This area is called an “urban district” but it doesn’t have any urban infrastructure or a quiet street. He suggested to have reasonable functional drive-thrus, there needs to be screening. Public comment was closed. Mr. Freese summarized what the PC recommendations were: o Section 3.7.2.B.1.b add sentence after the word frontage that says, except RMX, with the drive- thrus may be allowed at the discretion of the Planning Commission. Height Downtown Mr. Freese said there was discussion if 4 stories, as allowed in T-5 DC, should be lowered to three stories, as there is no four story building in T5-DC and there is considerable concern from the HDRB 6 about approving any four story building. Staff would support moving to a three story only requirement in T5-DC. The proposed revision: Table Chapter 2.4.1 (revise from 4 stories to 3) Public Comment Graham Trask, commented the city has no more than 3 stories downtown except for one 4-story building that has been approved but yet to be built. Mr. Trask said, from his prescriptive, The Anchorage Condominiums would not be approved today. He received a lot of push back on his parking as well as push back for just 3-stories for only a portion of his building. The PC should have a maximum of a three-story limit on buildings downtown. Paul Trask, 610 Bladen Street, commented that the Milner does not support 4-story buildings downtown. He recommends limiting the stories to three. Public comment was closed. Mr. Tomy referred to Section 2.6.A and suggested removing the word habitable in the second sentence. Mr. Morillo referred to Section 2.6.1 and suggested adding a letter “H” titled, Specific to T5-DC: building heights and roof lines must be proportional to the functional interior space of the structure. Expansion of vertical building facades, empty structural shells, or oversized parapets is prohibited. Mr. Tomy referred to Section 2.6.3.A – Two-Story Mass. PC agreed to remove the sentence that says, The second floor does not need to be built out or habitable. Public Comment Paul Trask, 610 Bladen Street, said it would be helpful to include an illustration. He referred to the presentation Adam Biery gave to the PC back in February and passed out a document that included the comments that were made. Mr. Tomy said he would like added to the sketch some landscaping inside of it. Mr. Trask will have this redone and get back to the PC. Mr. Trask said this change is very constructive and it addresses the issues that we’re trying to create a urban streetscape that’s pedestrian accessible. He referred to the option to pull the building back from the street and have a patio in the front. He recommended that the setback be changed to 20-25 foot maximum setback inn Section 2.4.B.1 under T5-UC. Mr. Trask asked for clarification of Section 2.4.A.1 under T5-UC regarding the build-out from 60% to 75% minimum. PC agreed to change the 75% back to 60% minimum. Public comment was closed. Ms. Anderson referred to the Bladen Street Overlay and asked if we still need it and asked if it’s working like we want it to. PC suggested having the review of for the Bladen Street area under the Historic District Review (HDRB) Board. PC Agreed to have the Bladen Street Overly section removed from the Code. PC agreed in Section 2.4.1.D under 2 stories min, leave in the sentence that says, at property line, see 2.6.1.G, so it reads, 3 stories max at property line, see 2.6.1.G. 7 PC also agreed in Section 2.6.1.G, to change 15 feet to 25 feet. Apartments - Housing Module Approach: Mr. Freese said that Mr. Morillo, had questioned whether the housing module approach should remain in the design standards for apartment houses. The standards require, through design, apartments to appear more as townhouses or rowhomes, than monolithic buildings. The proposed revision in Section 4.5.7: Staff would support keeping the standards in the proposed code, with exemption for T-5 UC, wherein such an approach may not make much sense on major arterials. 1. Width: The building width shall not exceed 100 feet along any frontage in all districts except T- 5 UC and T-5 DC. 2. House Module Approach: In all districts with the exception of T5-UC and T5-DC, Apartment home buildings shall reduce the apparent scale of multi-family buildings so they read as a collection of houses rather than a single large block. a. Every building façade visible from a public right-of-way must be expressed as a set of discrete Modules that read like individual houses, separated by varying forms, vertical breaks, offsets, and/or roof changes b. Modules shall be between 18 feet-30 feet in width. c. Buildings shall use varied roof forms such as front gables, cross gables, low-pitch hip roofs and small dormers to break up the overall massing of a building. Large roof forms such as hip roofs that encompass a whole building or uninterrupted flat parapet roofs are prohibited, unless broken into modules that support the house module approach as outlined in this section. The use of excessive hips, gables, shed, or parapet roofs with the singular goal of creating complex roof systems is strongly discouraged – the appropriate roof forms mentioned above should be used to create simple roof forms that do not detract from the appearance of the individual modules. d. Primary roof ridgelines should generally be perpendicular or at shallow angles to the street to emphasize smaller forms. e. No interrupted façade shall exceed 40 feet without a vertical modulation (offset, porch, material change, or recess). f. For facades longer than 60 feet, there shall be at least 2 strong compositional changes (e.g., projecting gable, recessed courtyard, mid-bay break). Mr. Bardenwerper suggested in Section 4.5.7.8 changing the title from Lot Diversity to Building/Unit Diversity. He also suggested to removing Section 4.5.7.11 House Module Approach. Ms. Anderson suggested when referring to large apartment complexes, a provision be added that there will be charging stations for electric cars. Mr. Bardenwerper suggested removing Section 4.5.7.9 and replace it with Location and Pedestrian Activation Section from 4.5.7.13. Mr. Freese referred to Section 4.5.7.9.b and recommending changing the number of employees from 500 to 100. 8 Mr. Tomy referred to the empty property in front of the Hanover Preserve Apartments and commented that it needs to be maintained. Mr. Freese stated their Development Agreement ends on January 1 and right now they don’t have anything vested on the commercial side. 100’ width for Apartment Buildings Mr. Freese said the 100’ width proposal (See above in Section 4.5.7), is one of the critical recommendations to break up monolithic buildings and develop apartments more consistent with Beaufort’s architectural heritage and vernacular form. In T-4, IC, RMX etc. districts, which are often located in rural or transitional areas where tall or large buildings are not existing, such a restriction would create design However, for the T-5 UC transect, the code desires building frontage on the majority of the lot, and such zoning is located along arterial streets where urban form is encouraged. To that end, it may make sense to allow a specific T-5 UC width of 140’-160’ to accommodate the needs of the transect. PC agreed to add the word Frontage to the title in Section 4.5.7.10 so it reads, Frontage Width. Also change the sentence to read, The building width shall be not exceed 100 along any frontage. Also, create a sub-section i. Specific to T5-UC and T5-DC: The building width shall not exceed 160 feet along any frontage. Pedestrian Revisions to Apartments Discussion: Move to within Section 4.5.7, and move from 500 employers to 100 employers to be more consistent with existing Beaufort employers and nodes. Misc. Discussion: PC agreed to talk about the Planned Unit Developments (PUDs) at their next meeting. Mr. Tomy asked once these chapters are approved what do we have left to review. Mr. Freese mentioned Chapter 8 and then maybe the Comprehensive Plan. Mr. Klement passed out the current Comp Plans to the PC. Ms. Anderson asked about the downtown charrette happening on Thursday. Mr. Freese said the Historic District Review Board (HDRB) was invited to a meeting with the Main Street Operations Team and an Architect at the Best Western at 3:00 pm. Mr. Freese said the PC Members are welcome to attend. ADJOURNMENT 3:25:33 Mr. Hallman made a motion to adjourn seconded by Ms. McFann. The meeting ended at 3:25 pm.

Source: City of Beaufort website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.