_01132026-194
City of Gaffney · Cherokee County · meeting of Jan 13, 2026 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Gaffney
This document is no longer listed on City of Gaffney's website. We kept the copy we read.
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Planning Commission Meeting
Minutes of January 13, 2026
City of Gaffney, SC – City Council Chambers
Planning Commission
An Agenda was posted and sent to the news media in accordance with the State FOI Act.
At about 5:30 pm, the meeting was called to order by Chairwoman Mary Pat Tyndall.
Alison Hall called the roll. All members - Mary Pat Tyndall, Pattie McCraw, Nancy Davis, Amareia Dawkins and
Donald Logan - were present. A quorum was established. Staff members present were Alison Hall, Scott
Keller, and Dale Guffey.
The Chair suggested that the order of items on the agenda be rearranged to permit the request for the
Brooks Park major subdivision preliminary plat approval and the request with public hearing for the
recommendation for zoning districts associated with the ECS Development request to be addressed prior to
the nominations and vote for the 2026 Chair and Vice Chair. The Planning Commission unanimously agreed to
this rearrangement.
Third on the agenda was to consider the approval of minutes of the December 9, 2025, meeting. Donald
made a motion to accept the minutes, which was seconded by Nancy. The motion was carried unanimously.
The fourth item on the agenda was to hear and consider a request from Anthony Vavrick with Anthomy
Rodney Homes for preliminary plat approval for a major subdivision known as Brooks Park (TM #099-01-00-
004.000, 099-01-00-004.001, 099-01-00-002.001, and 099-01-00-006.000) located at Providence Rd, Parker
St., and Martin St. Mr. Vavrick presented the request and Alison Hall emphasized that this is simply the
preliminary plat step, which must be approved prior to the issuance of a land disturbance permit. Staff has
reviewed the plans and will require the typical requirements, SCDOT approval and SC DEH approval, but
some of this will come in the next phase (the Land Disturbance phase), Alison told Mr. Vavrick a letter from
staff would be sent along with the approval notice, if passed by Planning Commission. Nancy made a motion
to approve the preliminary plat, and Donald seconded. The motion was carried unanimously.
The fifth item on the agenda was to hear a request from ECS Development LLC for a recommendation to
establish Zoning Districts for parcels identified as Tax Map #078-00-00-020.000, 078-00-00-023.000, 078-
00-00-021.000, 079-00-00-005.000, 079-00-00-006.000, and 078-00-00-024.000 as well as portions of
parcels #079-00-00-007.000, 080-00-00-139.000, and 080-00-00-041.000. These parcels (totaling
approximately 566 acres) are located off Boiling Springs Hwy, North Gate Rd., and Ferry Rd., and would
be connected to the City limits by means of a 30’ corridor.
Josh Baker (Engineer with Grey Engineering) and Paul Aho (president of ECS) presented their
proposal, which calls for 3.38 acres of Neighborhood Commercial, 382.16 of R-4, and 180.81 acres of R-
8, calling for a total of approximately 2,200 new homes. All stormwater regulations (including runoff
control and reduction) will be followed, and all surrounding roads are SCDOT owned.
The sixth item on the agenda was to conduct a public hearing on Item #5. A large number of people
attended the meeting (the City Council chamber was full, and the chamber doors were open to permit
the overflow crowd in the lobby to better hear the proceedings) and a dozen had signed up prior to the
beginning of this meeting to directly address the Planning Commission. The Chair thanked the public for
attending the meeting to provide comment and reminded the public of the rules regarding public
hearings held by the Planning Commission; namely, that each speaker is limited to 5 minutes, that
comments are to be addressed to the Planning Commission, that this is a public hearing intended to
provide comment to the Planning Commission, who will not be engaging in a back-and-forth with
speakers, and that the public hearing is limited to 30 minutes, although the Chair may extend that time
at her discretion. Further, the Chair reminded the audience that the Planning Commission’s role is to
provide the City Council with a recommendation on Zoning Districts and that the City Council’s role is to
make a decision regarding the actual annexation petition itself.
The public hearing portion of the meeting was extended by an additional 15 minutes by the Chair once
all speakers who had signed up had spoken to allow all who wished to speak to the Planning
Commission to do so. A total of 16 people addressed the Planning Commission.
Concerns expressed by the public can be roughly divided into 5 categories:
• Think about “smart growth” within the current City limits, rather than coming out into the
County. Build in the City first and revitalize downtown first before coming out into the County
• People in the area directly around the proposed development deliberately choose to live in the
country, rather than next to a large development.
• Concern about so many new houses - consider the impact so many new homes on services –
schools, fire, police, road congestion, and so on - the plan for development in this area is just
moving too fast. There was an analogy about “chickens without a coop.”
• Concerns about sustainability of natural resources, especially with such dense development.
• This development involves an alarming loss of vital farmland, without so much as a
park/dedicated green space in the proposed plan.
• A petition opposing the annexation is circulating with over 1,400 signatures, most of which are
from County residents.
At the conclusion of the public hearing, the Chair announced a 3-minute recess to allow those who
wished to leave to do so before the Planning Commission began their discussion, although it was
emphasized that any who wished to stay were welcome to do so.
Item 7 on the agenda was the consideration of Item 5.
The Chair pointed out that, under ECS’s request, 68% of the property would be zoned R-4,
permitting high density development on this farmland. Nancy dislikes R-4 for this project, a feeling that
was widely shared by the other members of the Planning Commission. Donald pointed out that, while
he’s in favor of development in general, he believes R-4 is the wrong designation here. Pattie stated that
2,200 homes would put an unacceptable burden on services (road congestion, schools, etc.). She further
stated that she is not in favor is Neighborhood Commercial (“NC”) for this project, as NC permits too
many options, such as a dollar discount store and is basically opposed to the development entirely.
Alison reminded the members that their role is to make a recommendation as to the Zoning Districts.
Mary Pat is opposed to the R-4 designation for this development and prefers a mix of R-8 and R-12, but
how much of each is the question she’s wrestling with. Nancy wanted to know if the only way to form
the recommendation was by assigning percentages to the Zoning Districts; staff explained that the
answer to that is “no” and that the Planning Commission has wide latitude in what and how they make
the recommendation to City Council. Staff clarified that all existing Zoning Districts – residential,
commercial, and industrial – could be part of the recommendation and that the Planning Commission is
free to make a recommendation to City Council regarding the disposition of the Petition of Annexation,
should they so wish.
The discussion continued. Amareia is in favor of NC designation but is concerned about the
infrastructure impact. Donald doesn’t want R-4 – reminding the Planning Commission that many in the
Grassy Pond community were very much against placing a Dollar General store out there. Mary Pat
suggested a mixture of R-8, R-12, and R-20, with a small amount of NC. Throughout this, members
remained respectful and engaged, taking into consideration both the wishes of the community members
who spoke and the desire for development.
Out of a desire to be clear what the Planning Commission was opposed to, Nancy made a
motion (which Pattie seconded) that the Planning Commission recommend that City Council deny both
Planning Commission Meeting
Minutes of January 13, 2026
City of Gaffney, SC – City Council Chambers
Planning Commission
R-4 and NC districts within this proposed development. This motion passed unanimously on a roll call
vote.
Nancy then made a motion (which was seconded by Donald) that the recommended Zoning
Districts be a mixture of R-8, R-12, and R-20. After further discussion, Nancy amended this motion that
the recommended Zoning Districts be a majority of R-20, a smaller percentage of R-12, and the smallest
percentage of R-8. This motion was seconded by Donald. Following discussion regarding the role of City
Council and the role of Planning Commission in this matter, a roll call vote was held. Donald, Pattie,
Mary Pat, and Nancy voted in favor of the motion, with Amareia voting to oppose. The motion therefore
passed by a vote of 4 – 1.
Nancy then made a motion that the Planning Commission recommend to City Council that the
annexation petition be denied. Pattie seconded this motion and, following discussion, a roll call vote
was held. Donald, Nancy, Pattie, and Amareia voted in favor of the motion, while Mary Pat voted to
oppose. The motion therefore passed by a vote of 4 – 1.
Item 8 on the agenda was to take nominations for the 2026 Chair of the Planning Commission. Nancy
nominated Mary Pat and no other nominations were made.
Item 9 on the agenda was to vote on the nomination for the 2026 Chair. Nancy made a motion that
Mary Pat remain as Chair. This motion was seconded by Pattie and the motion passed unanimously by
roll call vote.
Item 10 on the agenda was to take nominations for the 2026 Vice Chair of the Planning Commission.
Pattie nominated Nancy to serve as Vice Chair. There were no other nominations.
Item 11 on the agenda was to vote on the nomination for the 2026 Vice Chair. Pattie made a motion
that Nancy serve as Vice Chair and Nancy seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously by roll
call vote.
Item 12 on the agenda was to hear the Zoning Administrator’s report. There was nothing to report, beyond
the thanks of the Zoning Administrator to the Planning Commission for their hard work and dedication to the
City of Gaffney as shown through their service.
Being no further business, Chairwoman Tyndall adjourned the meeting at about 7:30 pm.
Respectfully submitted,
Alison Hall
Approved at the March 10, 2026,
meeting.
Source: City of Gaffney website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.