Board of Zoning Appeals Citizen's Guide
City of Fountain Inn · Greenville County · Other
Open the original document More from City of Fountain Inn
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
CITIZEN’S GUIDE
BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS BASICS
2
THIS PAGE LEFT BLANK
3
C I T I Z E N ’ S G U I D E
BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS BASICS
ABOUT THE ZONI NG ORDINANC E
The concept of zoning is relatively simple: Land in a jurisdiction is divided into districts or zones
in order to regulate what kinds of uses may be located within the zone. Each zone has a specific set
of permissible uses and a set of design standards. These standards regulate the location of buildings
by requiring a predetermined distance from the lot line to the building edge, which is called a
“setback” because the building must be set back from the lot lines on the front, sides, and rear of the
lot. Typical standards set maximum limits for building height and amount of lot coverage, and
minimum requirements for the amount of landscaping and parking.
What happens when a lot is unusual and cannot be developed while meeting all of the standards?
Zoning ordinances typically include a means of varying from the required standards, which is called a
“variance.”
The uses that are identified in advance as permissible within a zoning district are often referred
to as uses “by right,” which means that each use is identified as one that may be located within the
district if it conforms to the design standards and other regulations that apply to the district. No
specific permission is required for the use itself, only the conformance of the buildings and site
features with the standards for development. Conversely, other uses may be permissible where
additional standards are met to ensure that each use is compatible with the uses and character of the
district. These other uses are often called “conditional uses” or “special exceptions.” Special
exceptions require specific approval for the use as well as approval for the development of the site.
WHAT I S TH E B OARD OF ZONI NG APPEAL S
In general, a board of zoning appeals is the body established to hear appeals of decisions
rendered by administrators, applications for situations that depart from the zoning regulations,
applications for some matters that require interpretation, and applications for matters that require the
exercise of discretion.
South Carolina law specifically authorizes the zoning ordinance to provide for a board of zoning
appeals as a part of the administrative mechanism designed to enforce the zoning ordinance. The
board of zoning appeals has the authority to make final administrative decisions for the local
government concerning the zoning ordinance, subject to appeal to circuit court.
POWERS OF TH E B OARD OF ZONI NG APPEAL S
South Carolina law lists the powers of the board of appeals. The powers of the board are limited
to three specific subject matter areas:
▪ Determining appeals from administrative decisions of the zoning administrator.
▪ Granting or denying of applications for variances.
▪ Granting or denying of applications for special exceptions.
4
APPEALS FROM ADMINISTRATIVE DECISIONS
When city staff makes a land use decision rather than City Council or the planning commission,
staff’s decision is referred to as an “administrative decision”; a challenge to staff’s decision is called
an “administrative appeal.”
The board has the exclusive power to hear and decide appeals where it is alleged the zoning
administrator, in the enforcement of the zoning ordinance, erred in an order, requirement, decision
or determination. An example of an appeal from an administrative decision would be if someone
disagrees with how the planning staff interprets a provision of the zoning ordinance. In such cases,
the board may reverse or affirm, wholly or in part, or may modify the order, requirements, decision
or determination of the zoning administrator. The board has all the powers of the zoning
administrator in such cases and may issue or direct the issuance of a permit.
In its decision on an administrative appeal from a decision of the zoning administrator, the board
is not bound by the conclusion or reasoning of the zoning administrator and may consider and apply
the appropriate provisions of the zoning ordinance as dictated by the facts before it. However, if
staff’s interpretation is reasonable, it should be upheld. Only when a party has demonstrated that
staff’s interpretation is unreasonable should the board overturn staff’s interpretation.
VARIANCES
Under South Carolina law, the board has the power to hear and decide appeals (requests) for
variances when strict application of the zoning ordinance would result in “unnecessary hardship.” A
variance allows the board to modify an otherwise legitimate zoning restriction when, due to unusual
conditions, the restriction may be more burdensome than was intended. The variance must not
impair the public purpose.
To obtain a variance on the ground of “unnecessary hardship,” there must at least be proof that
a particular property suffers a singular disadvantage through the operation of a zoning regulation.
An owner is not entitled to relief from a self -created or self -inflicted hardship. A claim of
unnecessary hardship cannot be based on conditions created by the owner, nor can one who
purchases property after the enactment of a zoning regulation complain that the nonconforming use
would work a hardship upon him.
Variances can sometimes significantly change the character of an area and should be carefully
considered. Variances can potentially derail implementation of parts of the comprehensive plan.
When deciding whether to grant or deny a variance, the board has some discretion; however, the
board is not free to make whatever determination appeals to its sense of justice. Rather, the board
must apply the standards prescribed by the local zoning ordinance and South Carolina law. Courts
will not uphold a decision of the board to grant or deny a variance based on errors of law, fraud or
lack of supporting evidence, or a board action that is arbitrary, unreasonable, discriminatory or an
abuse of discretion.
5
Per Fountain Inn’s zoning ordinance, t he board may grant a variance in an individual case of
unnecessary hardship if the board makes and explains in writing all of the following findings.
1. There are special conditions and circumstances which are peculiar to the land, structure or building
involved which are not applicable to other lands structures or buildings in the same district . Typically,
extraordinary conditions mean irregularity in the shape of the lot, exceptional
topographical features, or other physical conditions. The idea is that the lot existed with
specific physical conditions prior to the imposition of the zoning requirements. The
provisions of the zoning ordinance may be appropriate for most lots within the district
but limit the development of the affected lot to the point of hardship. These physical
conditions are present in such a location or in such quantity that the property cannot be
developed in compliance with district standards. Furthermore, the features themselves
may have value to the community, and the variation in site design standards is a trade -
off in achieving protection of the features.
2. These conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinit y, particularly those in the same
zoning district.
3. Because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular piece of property would
effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property in a manner consistent with
others in the zoning district . A property owner is not entitled to a variance simply because
he cannot obtain the maximum economic return from his property. Rather, the board
should only grant a variance when a physical feature of the property, coupled with the
local government’s regulations, precludes the property owner from obtaining reasonable
use of his property.
4. The need for the variance is not the result of the applicant’s own actions. The premise here is to
avoid a deliberate bypassing of zoning regulations through a piecemeal approach to
development. Because a variance grants permission to develop land without complying
with all of the zoning regulations, it is important to ensure that the variance is justified
by something other than the applicant’s previous actions.
5. The authorization of a variance does not substantially conflict with the Comprehensive Plan and the
purposes of the Zoning Ordinance. Variances can potentially allow for significant changes to
the character of an area and may derail implementation of parts of the comprehensive
plan and zoning ordinance.
6. The authorization of a variance will not result in a substantial detriment to adjacent property or the
public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by the granting of the variance . This
provision is intended to protect the compatibility of the neighborhood. The use that
receives a variance should fit the neighborhood in terms of scale, site features, intensity
of development, and other design aspects. The principles of compatibility do not
require sameness. The principles of compatibility do require harmony and transition
from one use to another.
7. The reason for the variance is more than simply for convenience or to allow the property to be utilized
more profitably.
8. The variance requested is the minimum variance that will make possible the legal use of the land,
building, or structure. This rule helps ensure that the granting of a variance does not confer
special privileges on the property owner that are not enjoyed by other similarly situated
properties. This rule also eliminates the grant of a variance for social or personal
hardships, which are not a proper basis for hardship in any case.
When reviewing a request for a variance, the board should also consider the following applicable
policies:
6
▪ The fact that the property may be used more profitably, if a variance is granted, may not
be considered as grounds for a variance.
▪ Often, a property owner wishes to achieve a particular design and is unable to do so
because of some physical conditions of the property. Alternate designs are possible but
do not meet the property owner’s preferences or may not yield the best economic
return. It is inappropriate to grant such variances.
▪ In granting a variance, the board may attach conditions to it. These conditions should
be the requirements that ensure compatibility, that the property owner does not receive
special privileges, and that the variance is the minimum modification necessary to
achieve the purpose. The conditions should be consistent with the spirit and intent of
the zoning regulations, and should be designed to minimize any adverse impact that may
arise from the grant of a variance.
▪ The board may not grant a variance that would allow the establishment of a use not
otherwise permitted in a zoning district, physically extend a nonconforming use of land
or change the zoning district boundaries shown on the official zoning map.
▪ The board should take care to review each application on its own merit. Previous
decisions—especially those that were not made in accordance with the rules governing
variances—do not set a precedent. Poorly supported decisions in the past should not
lead to poor decisions now or in the future.
SPECIAL EXCEPTIONS
Additional standards may be needed for some specific uses to ensure that they are compatible
with the character of the neighborhood or district. These “other” uses are typically called “special
exceptions.” The board of appeals has the exclusive power to permit uses by special exception
subject to standards and conditions in the zoning ordinance. The board may assign conditions to the
approval of special exceptions in order to ensure compatibility.
As with considerations of variance requests, the board, in granting or denying a request for a
special exception, must apply the standards and conditions imposed by the zoning ordinance.
According to Fountain Inn’s zoning ordinance, the board may permit a use by special exception if
the board makes and explains in writing all of the following findings.
1. The use is allowed as a Special E xception in the zoning district. Article 3 of the zoning
ordinance indicates what uses require a special exception within the various zoning
districts.
2. The proposed Special Exception use is consistent with the spirit, purpose and intent of the City of
Fountain Inn’s Comprehensive Plan. A special exception can potentially allow for significant
changes to the character of an area and may derail implementation of parts of the
comprehensive plan.
3. The proposed Special Exception use is consistent with the “purpose and intent” statement of the
applicable zoning district. Each zoning district has a statement explaining the purpose of
that specific district. It is important that a special exception continue to maintain that
purpose.
4. The proposed Special Exception use will be constructed, operated and maintained so as to be compatible
with the existing or intended character of the applicable district and so as not to change the essential
character of t he area in which it is proposed. This provision is intended to protect the
compatibility of the neighborhood. A use that receives a special exception should fit the
neighborhood in terms of scale, site features, intensity of development, and other design
aspects. Sameness is not required but the special exception use should maintain
compatibility, harmony, and transition from one use to another.
7
5. The proposed Special Exception use is compatible with the existing uses adjac ent to and near the
property. This provision helps to preserve and maintain the existing character of the
neighborhood.
6. The proposed Special Exception use does not have an adverse effect on any site or feature of historical,
cultural, natural, or scenic importance. It is important to preserve features of significance
within the City; a special exception should not be detrimental to those features.
7. The proposed Special Exception use is consistent with existing and planned pedestrian and vehicular
circulation adjacent to and near the property.
8. The adjacent streets and highways are or will be adequate to carry any additional traffic generated by the
proposed Special Exception use.
9. The proposed Special Exception use will be adequately served by public facilities and services, such as
traffic operations along streets, police and fire protection, drainage structures, water and sewage facilities
and primary and secondary schools.
10. The proposed Special Exception use will not involve uses, activities, processes, materials and equipment
or conditions of operations that, in comparison to by -right permitted uses in the district, will be
hazardous, detrimental or disturbing to the natural environment, or the public health, safety and welfare
by reason of excessive production of traffic, noise, smoke, odors or other such nuisances.
11. The proposed Special Exception use will conform to any specific criteria or conditions specified for that
use in the applicable zoning district. Article 3 of the zoning ordinance lists criteria specific to
the use that must be met in order to qualify for a special exception.
12. The application must be in compliance with other applicable provisions provided in the zoning ordinance.
APPEALS TO THE BOARD
Appeals to the board and appeals from decisions of the board must follow the prescribed
procedures. Appeals from administrative actions and decisions of the zoning administrator are taken
to the board of zoning appeals, then to circuit court and finally to the state appellate courts. An
appeal from an administrative decision of the zoning administrator is never taken to the governing
body. Appeals from decisions of the board on variances or special exceptions are also taken to
circuit court and finally to the state appellate courts.
ORG ANIZ ATI ON AND OPERATION
Fountain Inn City Council has created a board of zoning appeals of seven members. The City
Council appoints members of the board of zoning appeals for staggered three -year terms. The City
Council may remove for cause any member of the board of zoning appeals prior to the expiration of
that member’s term.
It is important for the board of zoning appeals to organize itself and operate in accordance with
South Carolina law and the local zoning ordinance. The essential elements of the organizational
structure of the board include the following:
▪ Chairperson. The board must elect one of its members as chairperson. The chairperson
serves for one year or until a successor is elected and qualified. The chairperson may be
reelected.
▪ Secretary. The board must appoint a secretary. The secretary may be an officer of the
governing authority or of the zoning board. It is customary for the zoning administrator
to be appointed as secretary.
▪ Rules of Procedure. The board must adopt rules of procedure complying with South
Carolina law and the local zoning ordinance. The for these written procedures is to
ensure that board members, the public, staff, and elected and appointed officials of the
8
local government know how various operating matters will be handled. The rules of
procedure should address the following elements as a minimum.
o Election of a chairperson and duties
o Procedure for electing acting chairperson
o Appointment of a secretary and duties
o Procedures for calling meetings
o Time and place for meetings
o Public notice of meetings to comply with the Freedom of Information Act and
with South Carolina law
o Setting agenda
o Quorum and attendance requirements
o Rules of procedure for conducting meetings
o Time for appeal from decision of zoning official
o Time and procedure for hearing appeals, variances and special exceptions
o Time and procedure for rendering and serving decisions
o Procedure for making and keeping records of actions (including minutes of all
meetings)
o Procedure for ordering remands to the zoning administrator and otherwise
granting re-hearings by the board
o The oath administered to witnesses
It is typically the responsibility of city staff to take in applications, and provide an analysis and a
report on whether the requested action is consistent with the plan and complies with the regulations.
A staff member attends meetings of the board of zoning appeals to present the report, make a
recommendation, and answer questions.
MAKING THE M OST OF MEETI NGS
All actions of the board require public hearing. A public hearing is a formal proceeding to
receive public comment on a particular matter, such as a variance. Any party may appear at the
hearing in person, by agent or by attorney. The planning staff and any other persons may appear
before the board at the hearing and present evidence in support of or in opposition to the request.
The agenda should be followed, and discussion should not be focused on extraneous issues.
Comments on each agenda item should be limited to relevant issues. If the board has no authority
over the covenants of a community, the chair should not entertain questions from board members or
the public about the community’s covenants, and any comments about the covenants should be ruled
out of order. Members of the audience frequently want to discuss issues that are not applicable to
the board’s role. If the chair allows this discussion, the audience is misled into believing the board
does have authority in those matters.
ROLE OF THE CHAIRPERSON
It is essential that the chairperson, who chairs the meeting, understands how to make meetings
run smoothly. The chair needs to fully understand the board’s rules and needs to follow them
carefully. The chair should have a gavel and should not be afraid to use it, not only to open and
close meetings, but to keep order. At the start of the hearing, the chairperson should welcome
everyone to the meeting and indicate what is on the agenda. The chairperson should also explain the
procedure to be followed throughout the meeting.
9
ROLE OF THE BOARD MEMBERS
Board members have a responsibility for the smooth running of an effective meeting. Each
member is responsible in the following ways:
▪ Be prepared and on time. Read the material included with the agenda. Visit the site that
is the subject of an application.
▪ Listen to the explanations by staff and ask questions if something is not clear.
▪ Listen to the applicant and citizens as evidence is presented. Ask questions for
clarification but do not argue or voice opinions.
▪ Be polite and patient with others who are not familiar with public hearing procedures,
rules, planning jargon, and legal documents that board members may understand from
practice and training.
▪ Be patient with those who have a different opinion. Citizens have left the comfort of
home to participate and deserve patience and respect for their opinion.
▪ Leave personalities behind.
▪ Be open minded and fair.
▪ Address everyone with titles of respect (Mr., Ms., etc.).
▪ Treat all speakers and participants in a similar fashion.
▪ Have a public discussion—don’t pass notes or whisper.
▪ Explain yourself—state your findings of fact so the public and the staff understand you
correctly.
▪ Do not dominate the discussion. Make the points that need to be made and allow the
discussion to continue.
▪ Be careful about the tone of voice. Meetings and hearings are not the place for sarcasm
and anger. Board members should model the behavior that is expected from the public.
▪ Be willing to make or second a motion.
Above all, remember that this is not a debate. The board is there to hear testimony and make
decisions based on evidence, not engage in a debate. The thoughtful and reasoned participation of
each member is an important contribution to a well-run and effective meeting.
BOARD D ECISIONS
After a public hearing is concluded, the board must arrive at a decision. The issues often are
complicated, and decision -making is likewise difficult. These decisions will be much easier if the
board closely follows the recommended findings contained in the zoning ordinance. It is the board’s
job to sort through evidence and testimony and make reasoned decisions based on findings of fact.
All members, including the chairperson, should vote on each issue.
Members of the public frequently circulate petitions throughout the neighborhood and bring
them to the commission, overflowing with signatures of people supporting their position. These
petitions usually are not useful evidence. The commission has no control over the manner in which
the petition is circulated, no way to know what the signature seeker told those who signed it, and no
way to verify the signatures. In addition, many people will sign anything their neighbors ask them to
sign in an effort to promote neighborhood harmony. The commission should accept such petitions
when they are offered, but the members should not give them a lot of weight.
South Carolina law provides that the board must decide the appeal or matter “within a
reasonable time.” The board has the same powers as the zoning official and may affirm or reverse
10
(wholly or in part) or modify his actions and may issue or direct issuance of a permit. Absentee
ballots are not authorized; a member must be present to vote.
All final decisions of the board must be in writing, delivered to parties in interest by certified mail
and permanently filed in the office of the board as public records. All findings of fact and
conclusions of law must be separately stated in final decisions or orders of the board. This is
a critical requirement because the board’s findings of fact are binding on the circuit court on appeal.
One of the best ways for the board to make findings is to adopt findings as part of the motion
on the case (either prepared by staff in advance to support the staff recommendation or proposed by
a board member with the motion, using a prepared worksheet or petitioner’s written application to
cite the findings).
The board must have a quorum, which is a majority of its membership (not a majority of those
in attendance), in order to authorize any action as official. In the case where a board member has a
direct or indirect financial interest, that member may not participate in the hearing or decision of the
board.
Board members usually are active in the community. They interact with developers, business
people, and neighborhood residents regularly. These interactions occasionally result in efforts to
influence the board member’s opinion or vote on a specific proposal. It is good practice for board
members to refrain from such discussions. They interfere with due process and they are inconsistent
with the goals of the open meeting law. In many communities, these communications are difficult or
impossible to avoid. The best way to deal with these situations is for the board member to explain
that any information given will be shared with the entire board at the public hearing. The board
member must then share the information as promised. If board members fail to report these
conversations, various board members cast their votes based upon different information. Perhaps
the outcome of a vote would be different, if every member had the same information.
SOM E OTH ER DO’ S AND DON’T S
Avoid conflicts of interest or their perception. Board members should not accept gifts, food,
or travel costs from applicants, interested parties or their representatives. Even if it is innocent, it
looks bad to others. The board can use their rules of procedures to restrict these things. In any case,
laws prohibit direct financial gain.
Make decisions promptly. If information is missing or in conflict, it is appropriate to continue
the case until a specified future meeting, so that the board can be adequately informed when making
a decision. The board’s rules of procedure should limit how often and/or how long a continuance
may be granted.
Prepare findings. Decisions themselves are central to the practice of due process. Specific
factual findings in support of a final decision made by the board of zoning appeals are essential.
Findings should always be done for these cases, and are particularly important if the case is
controversial, because it is more likely to end up in court. It is fine to direct staff to prepare the
findings, but don’t make them guess what the board members were thinking. State for the public
record at the hearing the reasoning regarding the applicable criteria.
Be fair to everyone involved in the process . Especially if you don’t like an applicant, it is
important to provide the opportunity for a fair hearing. It is totally inappropriate for a board to
demonstrate its prejudice against even the sleaziest citizen. It is okay to apply strong conditions and
11
use extreme diligence in enforcing them, but don’t call a sleazy citizen “out” before he ever gets to
the plate. Due process is all about being fair to everyone involved in the process—developer, citizen,
etc.
Be consistent. If you have consistently made the same decision on the same type of request,
don’t suddenly change that decision unless you have an excellent reason for doing so, and point out
what is so markedly different about this request. Rely on the applicable criteria and you will make the
appropriate decision. Don’t get lazy though—review the criteria anew for each case.
Base your decision on legal considerations . Your decision must be based on applicable
criteria from state law and local ordinances. There is no room for sentiment when it comes to board
decisions.
Make a good, clear motion . Your motion should reference applicable criteria. The
chairperson should take a strong leadership role in bringing the group to a vote. Upon termination
of the public hearing and any discussion between board members, the chairperson should ca ll for a
motion on the matter.
Avoid emotions. The types of topics brought before the board can be highly charged in many
communities. Emotions can run high from the perspective of the petitioner, remonstrators, and
decision-makers. Typically, the investment an individual, family or business makes in real estate
represents the largest single investment they will ever make. This is especially true of individual
homeowners and their families. Once things become emotionally charged for either or both sides of
a board issue, involved parties, including the board, can get caught up in the emotion of the situation.
These represent some of the most dangerous times for board members in which they may be swayed
by the emotions of the issue rather than the facts presented. Decisions made on the basis of
emotional reactions are most likely to be flawed decisions, which may be challenged in court.
CONFLICT OF I NTEREST
Board members may not participate in a n appeal matter in which they have a direct or indirect
financial interest. Furthermore, board members may not participate in an appeal matter in which
they are a relative of either the applicant or an opponent. Board of zoning appeals rules should
include a definition of a conflict of interest and a means for determining conflict in cases of
uncertainty. Each board member needs to be responsible for declaring any potential conflicts. It is
recommended that in cases of uncertainty, the board should make the determination. The potential
conflict is publicly announced, and the board members deliberate among themselves. The public
should not be permitted to participate in this determination.
The rules should also specify the conduct expected from a member with a declared conflict of
interest. Typically, the member with a conflict cannot take part in the discussion or vote on the item.
The member may also consider leaving the commission table and joining the audience or leaving the
hearing room altogether until the matter is concluded.
Board members also may not represent another person in a hearing on a n appeal matter before
the board. Board members may represent themselves, but they cannot appear on behalf of another
applicant.
12
EDUCATI ONAL REQUI REM ENT S FOR B OARD MEMBERS
South Carolina law requires members of the board of zoning appeals to complete a mandatory
orientation and continuing education. Specifically, these educational requirements consist of a six -
hour orientation to be completed six months to one year after the initial date of appointment and a
three-hour annual training every year after the first year of service. Failure of a commission member
to complete the requisite education requirements may result in removal from office for cause.
The training program must be approved by the State Advisory Committee on Educational
Requirements for Local Government Planning or Zoning Officials and Employees. The
Appalachian Council of Governments located at 30 Century Circle in Greenville is one of the closest
approved instructors for the required orientation and annual training.
Source: City of Fountain Inn website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.