RecordWell Data

Historic Review Board Regular Meeting Agenda (PDF)

Town of Fort Mill · York County · meeting of Jul 14, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from Town of Fort Mill

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Historic Review Board 205 N. White Street July 14, 2026 4:30 p.m. Agenda CALL TO ORDER APPROVAL O F MINUTES 1. HRB Meeting: June 9, 2026 [pages 2 - 6 ] OLD BUSINESS 1. Request for Modifications to a previous Certificate of Appropriateness [pages 7 - 39 ] Applicant Name: Growing Main, LLC Owner Name: Kevin Higgins Property Address: 233 Main Street Purpose: Modifications to a previous Certificate of Appropriateness Property Information: Local Commercial (LC) and Historic Overlay District NEW BUSINESS 2. Request for Certificate of Appropriateness [pages 40 - 62 ] Applicant Name: Barron B. Mack, Jr. Owner Name: Mack Family Trust, LLC Property Address: 124 Confederate Street Purpose: Certificate of Appropriateness for exterior remodeling Property Information: Local Commercial (LC) and Historic Overlay District INFORMATIO N AND DISCUSSION • August 20, 2026 virtual continuing education opportunity (6:00 pm – 7:30 pm) ADJOURN The following press was notified of the meeting by email or fax in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act: The Herald, CN2, WRHI, WSOC, and WBTV. The agenda was also posted at the entrance to Town Hall the required length of time and on the Town website. The Town of Fort Mill is committed to assuring accessibility with reasonable accommodation, of Town services and facilities for all individuals, in compliance with federal law. contact the Town Manager’s Office at 803-547-2116 if you need assistance. 1 TOWN OF FORT MILL HISTORIC REVIEW BOARD MEETING June 9, 2026 205 N. White St 4:30 p.m. Pres ent: Chairwoman Megan Brinton, Vice Chairman David Booth, Scott Couchenour, Chuck Wright, Planning Director Penelope Karagounis, Deputy Planning Director Joey Adams-Raczkowski, Planner Emily Hawkins. Abse nt: Joanne Walker, Elizabeth Leventis, and David Helms Guests: See attached sign in sheet Chai rwoman Megan Brinton called the Historic Review Board meeting to order at 4:32 p.m. on Tuesday, June 9, 2026. APPRO VAL OF MINUTES Chai rwoman Megan Brinton asked for a motion to be made to approve Historic Review Board meeting minutes from May 12, 2026. Mr. Couchenour made the motion to approve the minutes as presented. Vice Chairman Booth seconded the motion. The motion to approve the minutes from May 12, 2026, was approved by a vote of 4:0. NEW BUSINESS 1. Requ est for Bailey Bill Preliminary Certification Deput y Planning Director Joey Adams-Raczkowski introduced the request for a Bailey Bill Preliminary Certification for the historic Williamson Mill site located at 104 Williamson Street. The application is submitted by Jerry Gronske - 104 Williamson, LLC. Mr. A dams-Raczkowski reminded the board that the Town of Fort Mill Code of Ordinances authorizes a Special Tax Assessment for Rehabilitated Historic Properties that meet the criteria for eligibility This is authorized by Section 5 -21-140 of the SC Code of Laws and is generally referred to as the Baile y Bill. Upon final certification, the Bailey Bill allows the property’s value to be assessed at the pre-rehabilitation value for a period of 20 years. For t his submittal, the applicant has provided an application and a copy of an assessment from York County Tax Assessor, both of which are on file with the Planning Department. The FMV via the appraised value published by the York County Tax Assessor, is $2,010,200. Thus, the minimum expenditure required for this project is $402,040, or 20% of the appraised value. The application indicates that the anticipated project cost of $74M greatly exceeds the minimum, mandatory expenditure amount. The project mus t also meet 2 the work and rehabilitation standards which have already been reviewed by the HRB and subsequent Certificates of Appropriateness were issued by the HRB on January 13, 2026, and March 10, 2026. Duri ng discussion, Mr. Adams -Raczkowski clarified that the Bailey Bill only applied to the historic Williamson Mill site. The new construction of multi-family and commercial, along with the parking deck, are not eligible for the Bailey Bill. Wit h no more discussion, Chairwoman Bri nton called for a motion. Mr. Couchenour made a motion to approve the request as submitted. Mr. Wright seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously 4:0. 2. Requ est for Certificate of Appropriateness – 214 Main Street Deput y Planning Director Adams-Raczkowski introduced the request for a Certificate of Appropriateness at 214 Main Street to address signage issues due to this being a multi-tenant building with two distinct and separate entrances. The building at 214 Main Street is a three -tenant space. However, only Suite 101 occupied by NeedleWorx directly fronts on Main Street and was previously approved for a projecting wall sign. Mr. A dams-Raczkowski explained that the other two suites , entered via a separate entrance at the rear of the building, are occupied by Phoebes and Veritas Construction. These businesses are ineligible for independent signage on the façade of 214 Main Street because the entrance is at the rear of the building. Therefore, the tenants are requesting a muti-tenant directional sign to be placed on the left of the entrance to NeedleWorx, which will list all three tenants. The second part of the request is to consider approving a shared projecting wall sign for Phoebes and Veritas Construction, which would be located to the left of the rear building entrance. Duri ng the board discussion, staff and the applicant clarified that the signs would be wrapped in a vinyl product and/or have metal sign inserts for utilization by future business es who may occupy these three suites. Mr. Adams-Raczkowski also clarified for the board that they do have the ability to provide input about the signage colors and bracketing or mounting method that will be used. Wit h no more discussion, Chairwoman Brinton called for a motion. Commissioner Wright made a motion to approve the request as submitted. Mr. Couchenour seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously 4:0 3. Requ est for Certificate of Appropriateness Modification – 232 Main Street Mr. A dams-Raczkowski stated that the HRB issued a COA on January 14, 2025, for the rear of the Kimbrell’s building for remodeling and conversion of the exterior loading dock area. The project would remove portions of the loading dock, install a new roofing system, and upgrade exterior stairs and entrances to three suites in the rear of the building. Upon a recent site inspection, staff discovered that a majority of 3 the work had been completed. However, the new brick columns are about 70” taller, and all the bricking unde rneath the new roofing system had been painted. Neither of those project elements were previously appr oved by the HRB. Additionally, not all previously approved replacement windows have been replaced. Property owner Kevin Higgins explained that Treadstone occupies one of the lower suites and The Mill 24hr Fitness occupies both a lower and the entire upper suite. Mr. Higgins explained that he arranged for the tenants to upfit the interior and exterior areas of their portions of the building. Mr. Higgins stated that all of the windows will be replaced, however, some may have to be slightly moved due to the building official’s comments. Mr. Higgins also explained that he was aware that there was difficulty attempting to remove layers of tar from the old roofline and some of the bricking began to degrade after pressure washing it 3 times. Mr. Higgins recalls talking with the contractor about painting the brick instead as the best option, which he admits was a terrible mistake. As for the brick columns, Mr. Higgins said that they had the extra brick and thought the taller bricking on the columns looks better. During board discussion, Chairwoman Brinton emphasized that the brick was not approved to be painted and none of the board members know the details of what the brick looked like before it was painted, so it is difficult for the board to decide without that information. Board member Wright made the point tha t there are processes through which brick can be restored and is concerned about setting a precedent of allowing brick to be painted without more information. There was additional discussion among the board members about how to proceed with motions . Staff explained that this was one request and although separating the columns from the paint is an option, one motion could be made with conditions. Board member Couchenour made a motion to approve the column height as-is. With no second, the board entered additional discussion about the application, including deferral of the item so that the applicant can present more information to the HRB. Options were presented to the applicant regarding actions the board could take. If the item is deferred, the applicant can bring back additional details from the contractor and architect to HRB regarding why the brick was painted. With this option, the tenants could not occupy the spaces. If the columns are approved and the paint will be removed, the tenants could move forward with occupancy once they pass inspection. The applicant indicated that he needed time to bring more information back to the HRB for consideration. W ith no more discussion, Board member Wright made a motion to defer so the applicant can bring back details regarding any window changes along with a formal request for the column height and justification for painting the brick. Board member Couchenour seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously 4:0. Mr. Adams-Raczkowski clarified for the applicant that the next deadline to have all materials turned in for the July 14, 2026, meeting is June 23rd. 4 4. Request for Certificate of Appropriateness Modification – 112 Confederate Street Mr. Adams-Raczkowski stated that the HRB issued a COA for this project on May 13, 2025, for exterior remodeling. Upon a recent site visit staff noticed that the materials for the canopy entries, placement of some of the paint colors, and materials for the railings were different than what was originally approved. Also, although exterior to the building and approved separately, the additional parking was not installed. Mr. Adams-Raczkowski clarified that the additional parking was not necessary to meet minimum parking standards. Architect Ver onica Grant and Attorney David Buist represented David Martin Law firm. Mr. Buist acknowledged that there was a discrepancy between the colored renderings that were included in the HRB packet versus the architectural renderings that were part of the building permit package. Mr. Buist confirmed that those two items should have been coordinated more closely at the time of building permit submission. Ms. Grant reviewed the architectural elevations with the board and described the changes as well as the justification for the changes. The wooden materials for the canopies and the railings were replaced with metal materials due to fire retardancy requirements. The same paint colors were used as originally approved, however, applied to different parts of the structure. The board members discussed the changes with Ms. Grant and Mr. Buist. With no further discussion, Chairwoman Brinton asked for a motion. Vice Chairman Booth made a motion to approve the changes as presented . Board member Wright seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously 4:0. INFORMATION / DISCUSSION Planning staff reminded the board members of their continuing education requirements for the upcoming period and that staff would be communicating opportunities for the board to earn those educational credits. ADJOURNMENT Chairwoman Brinton entertained a motion to adjourn the meeting. Vice Chairman Booth made a motion to adjourn. Mr. Couchenour seconded the motion. The motion to adjourn was approved by a vote of 4-0. The meeting adjourned at 5:44 PM Respectfully submitted by Joey Adams-Raczkowski Deputy Planning Director June 18, 2026 5 6 INFORMATION/MATERIALS FROM APPLICANT FOR JULY 14, 2026, MEETING [pages 7 - 20] STAFF REPORT & ATTACHMENTS FROM JUNE 9, 2026, MEETING [pages 21 - 39] OLD BUSINESS Request for Modifications to a previous Certificate of Appropriateness Applicant Name: Growing Main, LLC Owner Name : Kevin Higgins Property Address: 233 Main Street Purpose: Modifications to a previous Certificate of Appropriateness Property Information: Local Commercial (LC) an d Historic Overlay District 7 June 12, 2026 Kevin Higgins Growing Main, LLC sent via email: kevinh@aquatreegarden.com 232 Main Street Fort Mill, SC 29715 RE: 232 Main Street Certificate of Appropriateness – Action to Defer Zoning Case 2026-278 Dear Mr. Higgins, On Tuesday, June 9, 2026, the Town of Fort Mill Historic Review Board (HRB) met to consider modifications to a previously approved Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) issued on January 14, 2025, submitted by Growing Main, LLC at 232 Main Street. During deliberations, the board members reached the consensus that you have not provided enough information for the board to make an informed decision regarding the primary issue of the existing brick being painted without prior approval from the HRB. The board members requested that you provide greater details as to how and why the decision to paint the brick was made; pictures and descriptions of the condition of the brick prior to painting; the cost of restoring the brick prior to painting; and the cost of restoring the brick to an unpainted state. The board also specifically asked that the contractor(s) and architect provide opinions as to the issues mentioned above. The HRB voted unanimously 4:0 to defer this request to the July 14, 2026, meeting. You were informed by staff at the meeting that the deadline for submitting information for inclusion in the agenda packet is June 23, 2026. You were also instructed that no Certificates of Occupancy would be issued for the tenant spaces until these issues are resolved. Please send all information to my attention via email jadamsraczkowski@fortmillsc.gov. If you have any questions, please contact me via email or by calling 803-835-1162. Take care, Joey Adams-Raczkowski, AICP Deputy Planning Director 8 232 Main Street – Rear Exterior Brick Condition Documentation & Supporting Materials Prepared in support of the Certificate of Appropriateness Modification request to the Fort Mill Historic Review Board. Contents of This Document This packet documents the condition of the rear brick wall at 232 Main Street before, during, and after the recent renovation, and includes contractor pricing obtained for alternative approaches to addressing the painted brick. It is organized as follows: 1. Before: Original Loading Dock Condition Photographs of the rear loading dock area prior to renovation. 2. During: Construction and Brick Condition Discovered Photographs taken during construction, including two close-up, annotated views highlighting brick discoloration and mortar inconsistency discovered once the old roofing and tar buildup were removed. 3. After: Completed Renovation Photograph of the same area following completion of the work. 4. Contractor Bids: Alternative Repair Approaches Pricing obtained from two contractors for alternative approaches to the brick: (a) chemical/pressure-wash removal of existing coating, and (b) full demolition and relay of the painted brick veneer. Both bids are included as exhibits. 9 1. Before: Original Loading Dock Condition The following photographs show the rear loading dock area prior to renovation, including the original brick, short columns, corrugated metal awning, and concrete loading ramp. Photo 1 – Rear loading dock, original condition (wide view) Photo 2 – Original brick, columns, and awning structure (close view) 10 2. During: Construction and Brick Condition Discovered The following photographs were taken during construction, documenting site conditions as the old roofing and tar buildup were removed and the brick beneath was prepared and pressure washed. Two close-up views below highlight areas where the brick and mortar showed visible discoloration and inconsistency once exposed. Photo 3 – Construction site overview, secured perimeter Photo 4 – Foundation and structural work in progress 11 Photo 5 – Exposed brick wall section prior to brick work completion Photo 6 – Rear stair wall, brick condition visible after site work 12 Close-Up: Brick Discoloration and Mortar Inconsistency The circled areas below highlight discoloration and surface degradation observed on the brick wall beneath the new stair landing, consistent with the deterioration described following repeated pressure washing. Photo 7 – Streaking and surface degradation on lower brick wall (detail) 13 Photo 8 – Discolored brick patch near stair wall, inconsistent with surrounding brick (detail) 14 3. After: Completed Renovation The following photograph shows the same rear area following completion of the work, including the painted brick, raised column height, new metal roof structure, and new stairs and decking serving the upper and lower suites. Photo 9 – Rear entrance area, completed renovation 15 4. Contractor Bids: Alternative Repair Approaches To evaluate alternatives to the painted brick, pricing was obtained from two contractors for approaches that would remove the paint and restore or replace the brick. Both bids are attached as exhibits immediately following this page. Exhibit A: Paint/Coating Removal Best Under Pressure, Inc. provided a bid of $6,735.00 to chemically strip and pressure wash the existing paint/coating from the brick, including a multi-coat stripper process, prep, clean-up, and boom lift rental. This approach does not address any underlying brick or mortar damage; it would only remove the surface coating. Exhibit B: Demolition and Relay of Brick Veneer Griffin Masonry, Inc. provided a bid of $73,075.00 to demolish and relay approximately 2,500 square feet of painted brick veneer. Notably, this bid’s qualifications state that brick and mortar color/texture would be matched to the existing wall “as close as possible,” but that an exact match is not guaranteed — the same matching risk that contributed to the original decision to paint the brick. 16 Estimate Date 6/15/2026 Bid# 6706 Estimate For: CARMEL CONTRACTORS 114 SPRINGS ST. STE A FORT MILL, SC 29715 BEST UNDER PRESSURE, INC. 704-363-7646 - FAX - 704-948-6274 ckay@carolina.rr.com PO BOX 943 HUNTERSVILLE, NC 28070 Job Site 232 Main St Ft Mill We look forward to working with you! Total Description Qty. Rate Total 232 Main St, Ft Mill - 4 HRS PREP 4 100.00 400.00 - 28 HRS CHEM APPLICALTION & PRESSURE WASH 28 100.00 2,800.00 - 8 HRS CLEAN UP 8 100.00 800.00 - MATERIALS - 20-25 GALLONS STRIPPER, LCS BY ECO CHEM, 3 COAT PROCESS AT SOME AREAS IF NOT ALL ACCORDING TO TEST RESULTS, PLASTIC AND TAPE 1 700.00 700.00 - BOOM LIFT RENTAL 1 WEEK 1 2,035.00 2,035.00 $6,735.00 17 PO Box 23027 P (704) 545-2722 Charlotte, NC F (704) 545-3063 Project Name: Treadstone Project Address: Fort Mill SC Client Name: Carmel Contractor Estimator: Kory Podgaysky Division 4 $73,075 Additional Item Pricing (Not included unless otherwise noted): 1) Water Wagon $250.00 each trip 2) Brick Field Sample Panel - (Sample panels built upon request at 7 courses tall x 3 brick wide = $350/each) Qualifications: 1) This quote is based on field measured quantities 2) Brick to match existing as close as possible. Brick match is not guaranteed 3) Mortar to match existing as close as possible. Mortar match is not guaranteed 4) Lay down area to be provided by GC. Relocation of laydown area will be charged at $100/hr for labor and equipment. 5) This bid is good for 30 days 6) Water to be provided by GC from on site source. Additional costs will be incurred if GMI is required to bring water from offsite. 7) Back charges for corrective work or replacement of material will not be accepted unless authorized by Griffin Masonry, Inc. before such costs are incurred. Exclusions: 1) Bond premium 2) Layout of corners and lines 3) Anchor bolts 4) Bearing plates 5) Caulking and backer rod 6) Testing or special inspections 7) Steel, rebar, welded wire mesh 8) Mechanically fastened, welded, loose lintels (GMI to install loose lintels) 9) Welding 10) Sealants, coatings, paints, hardeners, densifiers, integral colored concrete, polishing, grinding 11) Wall brace footings & engineering 12) Demolition 13) E.I.F.S., GFRC, FRP, and stucco 14) Waterproofing 15) Fireproofing Demo & relay painted brick 6/19/2026 1:41 PM 1 of 1 18 June 27, 2026 Penelope Karagounis MA Planning Director 205 N White Street, Fort Mill, SC, 29715 RE: 232 Main Street – Certificate of Appropriateness Modification – Rear Brick Condition Fort Mill Historic Review Board To the Fort Mill Historical Board, I am writing as the contractor responsible for the exterior renovation work at the rear of 232 Main Street to explain the circumstances that led to our decision to paint the brick in the rear area of the canopy addition. As part of removing the old roo fing system and the former loading dock ramp, we pressure washed the rear brick wall to clear years of tar buildup and black mastic membrane waterproo fing from the original brick surfaces. We tried multiple times to remove this material with no success. After repeated cleaning e fforts, it became clear that the existing brick had deteriorated signi ficantly and repeated e fforts to clean the brick would deteriorate the conditions further. Compounding this situation the mortar in the newer brick and the newer brick itself did not match the older, original brick beside it. The result was a wall surface that was both compromised in places and visually inconsistent. In discussing options with the property owner, we elected to paint the brick to create a uniform appearance across the rear of the building, so that the area would appear as an architectural opening into the suites rather than a mismatched hodge podge of new and old masonry. At the time, this seemed like a practical solution to a real problem with the existing materials. Looking back, our mistake was moving forward with the painting before bringing this to the Historic Review Board and getting their input and approval first. That is on us, and we understand the Board's concerns about precedent and about not having seen the brick's condition firsthand before the work was done. We have provided photos to the owner (Kevin Higgens) taken during the process and we will try our best to answer any questions the Board has so they can fully evaluate the situation. Respectfully, Scott Tuttle Carmel Contractors NC License #54548 PO Box 588 • Fort Mill, SC 29716 SC License #G109706 704.552.2338 • carmelcontractors.com 19 131 EAST GREGG STREET FORT MILL SC 29715 704 . 953 . 5014 SC 10143 A4 H 05/29/26 6 09/04/25 - HRB ELEVATIONS DATE INFO REV SET HISTORY © 2025 COPYRIGHT . THIS DRAWING IS THE PROPERTY of 53:TWELVE PA . REPRODUCTION or REUSE IN PART or WHOLE WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION IS PROHIBITED. THE MILL 24/7 GYM 232 MAIN STREET FORT MILL SC SUITE 120 / 220 / 230 12/09/25 CODE 1 05/29/26 03/09/26 CODE 2 PHASE 2 : NEW ALUMINUM STOREFRONT WINDOW : COLOR = ANODIZED DARK BRONZE PHASE 2 : NEW ALUMINUM STOREFRONT WINDOW : COLOR = ANODIZED DARK BRONZE PHASE 2 : NEW ALUMINUM STOREFRONT WINDOW : COLOR = ANODIZED DARK BRONZE PHASE 2 : NEW ALUMINUM STOREFRONT WINDOW : COLOR = ANODIZED DARK BRONZE EXISTING WINDOW : PAINT DARK BRONZE EXISTING WINDOW : PAINT DARK BRONZE MATCH LINEMATCH LINE 1011 10 9 8 T/FOOTING -10'-6" LOWER -9'-6" FIRST FLOOR ±0" T/TRUSS +11'-4" T/WALL +12'-8" NEW GALVANIZED STEEL ADA COMPLIANT SINGLE RAIL HANDRAIL EACH SIDE OF RAMP AND STAIR NEW MASONRY CANOPY COLUMN BASE : FACE BRICK = MATCH EXISTING POURED CONCRETE CURB WALL NEW STEEL CANOPY FRAME : COLOR = DARK BRONZE / STANDING SEAM METAL ROOF PANELS : COLOR DARK BRONZE NEW GALVANIZED STEEL GAURD RAIL : COLOR = DARK BRONZE / WITH WELDED WIRE INFILL PANELS : COLOR = BLACK NEW ALUMINUM STOREFRONT ENTRY WITH SIDE LIGHT : COLOR = ANODIZED DARK BRONZE NEW FACE BRICK MASONRY WALL AT FACE OF STAIR : COLOR = MATCH EXISTING CONCRETE CAP HOLLOW METAL DOOR AND FRAME : COLOR = DARK BRONZE PREFINISHED METAL GUTTER GALV STEEL DOWNSPOUT PHASE 2 : NEW ALUMINUM STOREFRONT WINDOW : COLOR = ANODIZED DARK BRONZE PHASE 2 : NEW ALUMINUM STOREFRONT WINDOW : COLOR = ANODIZED DARK BRONZE PHASE 2 : NEW ALUMINUM STOREFRONT WINDOW : COLOR = ANODIZED DARK BRONZE EXISTING WINDOW : PAINT DARK BRONZE EXISTING WINDOW : PAINT DARK BRONZE MATCH LINEMATCH LINE 1/4" = 1'-0" 01 EAST ELEVATION 1/4" = 1'-0" 05 EAST ELEVATION ALLEY PERSPECTIVE 20 HISTORIC REVIEW BOARD Applicant: Growing Main, LLC Subject Property: 232 Main Street Property Owner: Growing Main, LLC Tax Map # 020-03-01-008 Zoning District: Local Commercial, LC/Historic iŽôŘīÍƅϙDistrict Zoning Case:ϙ 2026-278 R EQUEST Growing Main, LLC has applied to modify an existing Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) for 232 Main Street, originally approved by HRB on January 14, 2025. VICINITY MAP 21 DISCUSSION This building is located within the downtown historic district. It is not listed on the National Register of Historic Places (NRHP). It was constructed in circa 1956 and was once the Kimbrell’s Furniture Store. Below is a picture of the front of the building from several years ago, when still in operation as a furniture and appliance store. 22 DISCUSSION , CONTINUED Below is a photograph of the existing building prior to renovations. 23 DISCUSSION , CONTINUED The applicant states that the existing loading ramp will be removed. Below is an illustration of the existing and elevation. Full sheets of the below are included as attachments to the COA application. AREAS OF DEMOLITION 24 PROPOSED EXTERIOR WORK – JANUARY 2025 Below is a revised drawing illustrating the proposed exterior improvements to this building. It should be noted that the applicant is also requesting that the exterior windows be approved in addition to the revised canopy design. 25 26 27 EMAIL FROM CONTRACTOR EXPLAINING MODIFICATIONS – MAY 2026 28 AS CONSTRUCTED – May 2026 29 AS CONSTRUCTED – May 2026 30 AS CONSTRUCTED – May 2026 31 SECRETARY OF INTERIOR ’S STANDARDS The Secretary of Interior’s Standards typically serve as the basis for determining the approval, approval with modifications, or denial of certificate of appropriateness by the HRB. Please use the below standards in evaluating the soundness of the COA application. 1. Every reasonable effort shall be made to provide a compatible use for a property which requires minimal alteration of the building, structure, or site and its environment, or to use a property for its original intended purpose. 2. The distinguishing original qualities or character of a building, structure, or site and its environment shall not be destroyed. The removal or alteration of any historic material or distinctive architectural features should be avoided when possible. 3. All buildings, structures, and sites shall be recognized as products of their own time. Alterations that have no historical basis and which seek to create an earlier appearance shall be discouraged. 4. Changes which have taken place in the course of time are evidence of the history development of a building, structure, or site and its environment. These changes may have acquired significance, and this significance shall be recognized and respected. 5. Distinctive stylistic features or examples of skilled craftsmanship which characterize a building, structure or site shall be treated with sensitivity. 6. Deteriorated architectural features shall be repaired rather than replaced wherever possible. In the event replacement is necessary, the new material should match the material being replaced in composition, design, color, texture, and other visible qualities. Repair or replacement of missing architectural features should be based on accurate duplications of features, substantiated by history, physical, or pictorial evidence rather than on conjectural designs or the availability of different architectural elements from other buildings. 7. The surface cleaning of structures shall be undertaken with the gentlest means possible. Sandblasting and other cleaning methods that will damage the historic building material shall not be undertaken. 8. Every reasonable effort should be made to protect and preserve archaeological resources affected by, or adjacent to the property. 9. Contemporary design for alterations and additions to existing properties shall not be discouraged when such alterations and additions do not destroy significant historical, architectural, or cultural materials, and such design is compatible with the size, scale, color, material, and character of the property, neighborhood, or environment. 10. Wherever possible, new additions or alterations to structures shall be done in such a manner that if such additions or alterations were to be removed in the future, the essential form and integrity of the structure would be unimpaired. 32 STAFF FINDINGS Modifications presented: 1. Painting of existing brick 2. Phased approach to installing windows 3. Slight design changes STAFF RECOMMENDATION Staff welcomes additional discussion between the applicant and the HRB about this project and will stand in support of the design which HRB ultimately chooses to approve. ATTACHMENTS 1. Portion of previous COA application with written description of work. 2. HRB Minutes 1.14.2025 meeting 3. COA issued by HRB 1.14.2025 33 MINUTES TOWN OF FORT MILL HISTORIC REVIEW BOARD January 14th, 2025 112 Confederate Street 4:30 PM Present: Chairwoman Megan Brinton, Vice Chairman David Booth, Scott Couchenour, Hynek Lettang, Elizabeth Leventis, Joanne Walker, Jessica Scarlett, Planning Director Penelope Karagounis, Senior Planner Alex Moore, and Planner Grayson Molinari Absent: N/A Guests: Kevin Higgins, Jeffery Hunter, Lisa Zederbaum CALL TO ORDER Chairwoman Megan Brinton called the meeting to order at 4:31 PM. NOMINATION OF CHAIRPERSON AND VICE CHAIRPERSON Elizabeth Leventis nominated Megan Brinton for the roll of Chairwoman. Joanne Walker seconded this motion, with a vote of 7-0 the motion was approved. Scott Couchenour nominated David Booth for the roll of Vice Chairman. Ms. Leventis seconded this motion, with a vote of 7-0 the motion was approved. APPROV AL OF MINUTES Mr. Couchenour made the motion to approve the minutes from the December 10th, 2024, HRB meeting. David Booth seconded the motion with edits. Then, by a vote of 7-0, the minutes for December 10 th, 2024, meeting was approved. NEW BUSINESS Request for Certificate of Appropriateness for 232 Main Street Applicant and Property Owner, Growing Main LLC, requested for a Certificate of Appropriateness following the deferred action of approval on December 10 th, 2024, for a canopy roof. The previous design did not comply with the current historic district standards regarding pitch, orientation, and complexity. The applicant, Kevin Higgins, presented a revised canopy design with a flat roof which is appropriate within the historic district. Additional approvements were presented like using galvanized steel guardrails and panels, entry doors, stairs, and new windows. Staff recommended approval of the revised design, however, input of new additions along with the revised roof was still needed by Historic Review Board members. Mr. Higgins and his architect, Jeffery Hunter, brought materials that would be used for the new windows and door outlines. Mr. Higgins and Mr. Hunter approached the podium and showed the council members the aluminum material they would use for the structure of windows and doors. 34 Ms. Walker motioned to accept the revised concept proposal. Hynek Lettang seconded this motion. The motion to pass 232 Main Street for a Certificate of Appropriateness was approved by a vote of 7-0. Request for Certificate of Appropriateness for 106 Confederate Street Mackey Realty requested a COA for a projecting signage and window signage at 106 Confederate Street. This building is located within the historic district and is registered on the National Register. The proposal is approximately 3.32 square feet in area. The window and door signage complies with minimum coverage area. Staff recommended approval. Representing Mackey Reality was Lisa Zederbaum, Director of Sales, who approached the podium. Ms. Zederbaum explained that the sign was the exact same size as the previous sign. Ms. Leventis motioned to approve the signage and Jessica Scarlett seconded that motion. The certification of approval was passed by a vote of 7-0. There being no further business, Chairwoman Brinton adjourned the meeting at 5:02 PM. Respectfully submitted, Grayson Molinari Planner January 16 th, 2025 35 January 28th, 2025 Mr. Kevin Higgins Growing Main, LLC kevinh@aquatreegarden.com RE: 232 Main Street Certificate of Appropriateness Zoning Case 2024-609 Mr. Higgins, On Tuesday January 14 th, 2025, the Town of Fort Mill Historic Review Board (HRB) met to consider an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) submitted by Growing Main, LLC for proposed exterior improvements at 232 Main Street. The HRB rendered their approval for these exterior improvements based on the attached drawings. This approval by the HRB for this COA does not preclude the requirement for obtaining the necessary zoning and/or building permit(s) from the Town of Fort Mill. The application for commercial review is available at the following link: Town of Fort Mill Commercial Permit Application . You will submit the commercial permit application to developmentcenter@fortmillsc.gov. A Town of Fort Mill business license must be obtained for private contractors performing work on this project. For questions about business licenses, please contact Maria Watts atmwatts@fortmillsc.gov or (803) 835-1167. If you have any questions or comments about the contents of this letter, please contact me at (803) 835-1162, or via email at amoore@fortmillsc.gov. Sincerely, Alex J. Moore, AICP Senior Planner Attachments Ecc: jeff.hunter@53twelve.com gmolinari@fortmillsc.gov developmentcenter@fortmillsc.gov 36 37 38 39 HISTORIC REVIEW BOARD Applicant: Barron B. Mack, Jr. Subject Property: 124 Confederate Street Property Owner: Mack Family Trust, LLC Tax Map # 020-06-08-006 Zoning District: Local Commercial, LC/Historic Overlay District Zoning Case: 2026-328 REQUEST Mr. Mack has applied for a Certification of Appropriateness (COA) for 124 Confederate Street to perform exterior renovations to the existing building. VICINITY MAP 40 DISCUSSION The application on file in the Planning Department indicates that the project will consist of renovation of the existing building at 124 Confederate Street. As a former residential structure, the property was converted into a commercial establishment. The intent is to renovate the building for continued commercial use. Proposed exterior improvements include removal of the existing vinyl siding (yellow in color), repair or replace and damaged wood siding, repair or replace trim, repair boards on the ADA accessible ramp, and remove existing windows on the side porch with screens. The paint color for siding and trim will be ‘Dove White. The screening will be a product called “Screen Tight.” Below are current views of the elevations of the structure. View from Confederate Street 41 Left side of structure as viewed from Confederate Street (top picture) Rear of structure (bottom picture) 42 Rig ht side of structure as viewed from Confederate Street (top picture) Porch on right side of house – windows changing to screens 43 DISCUSSIO N, CONTINUED A contributing property within a historic district is one which adds to the historic integrity or architectural qualities that make the historic district significant. In 1992, the National Register of Historic Places (NRHP) multiple property documentation form for historic properties of Fort Mill, SC was prepared by Mary W. Edmonds of the South Carolina Department of Archives & History. The associated historic contexts of the report prepared by Ms. Edmonds were as follows: • The Growth and Development of Fort Mill, circa 1779 to circa 1940. • The Commercial and Institutional Development of Fort Mill, circa 1860 to circa 1940. • The Residential Development of Fort Mill, circa 1869 to circa 1940. In this report Ms. Edmonds states that NRHP registration requirements require that buildings to be included as a commercial building property type should have a clear relationship to the development of the commercial core of Fort Mill and that they should reflect the significance of circa 1860 to circa 1940. Thus, this structure was built after the period of significance reflected within our historic district and is therefore considered non-contributing. Page 86 of the historic district guidelines indicate that the “Design Guidelines for New Commercial, Mixed Use, and Multifamily Buildings” as enumerated thereafter are to apply to new additions to contributing and non- contributing buildings such as 124 Confederate Street. Additionally, this section states that new commercial infill construction in areas outside of the immediate Main Street context should be compatible with the district. While the proposed remodeling of 124 Confederate Street involves a non-contributing building, and does not involve new infill construction, there are certain aspects of compatibility which do apply: • The applicant’s design does express the true age of the building rather than directly imitating a historic style. This assists in the avoidance of confusing historic interpretation of the context. • The applicant has designed improvements with traditional colors which will allow the building to be appropriately incorporated into the surrounding context. The proposed color palette is similar to what is found along Confederate Avenue. 44 SECRETARY OF INTERIOR ’S STANDARDS The Secretary of Interior’s Standards typically serves as the basis for determining the approval, approval with modifications, or denial of certificate of appropriateness by the HRB. In this instance such points as the building being “recognized as a product of its own time are relevant.” Please use the below standards in evaluating the soundness of the COA application. 1. Every reasonable effort shall be made to provide a compatible use for a property which requires minimal alteration of the building, structure, or site and its environment, or to use a property for its original intended purpose. 2. The distinguishing original qualities or character of a building, structure, or site and its environment shall not be destroyed. The removal or alteration of any historic material or distinctive architectural features should be avoided when possible. 3. All buildings, structures, and sites shall be recognized as products of their own time. Alterations that have no historical basis and which seek to create an earlier appearance shall be discouraged. 4. Changes which have taken place in the course of time are evidence of the history development of a building, structure, or site and its environment. These changes may have acquired significance, and this significance shall be recognized and respected. 5. Distinctive stylistic features or examples of skilled craftsmanship which characterize a building, structure or site shall be treated with sensitivity. 6. Deteriorated architectural features shall be repaired rather than replaced wherever possible. In the event replacement is necessary, the new material should match the material being replaced in composition, design, color, texture, and other visible qualiti es. Repair or replacement of missing architectural features should be based on accurate duplications of features, substantiated by history, physical, or pictorial evidence rather than on conjectural designs or the availability of different architectural elements from other buildings. 7. The surface cleaning of structures shall be undertaken with the gentlest means possible. Sandblasting and other cleaning methods that will damage the historic building material shall not be undertaken. 8. Every reasonable effort should be made to protect and preserve archaeological resources affected by, or adjacent to the property. 9. Contemporary design for alterations and additions to existing properties shall not be discouraged when such alterations and additions do not destroy significant historical, architectural, or cultural materials, and such design is compatible with the size, scale, color, material, and character of the property, neighborhood, or environment. 10. Wherever possible, new additions or alterations to structures shall be done in such a manner that if such additions or alterations were to be removed in the future, the essential form and integrity of the structure would be unimpaired. 45 STAF F FINDINGS Planning staff finds that this application meets the standards as found within the historic district guidelines as well as those put forth by the office of the Secretary of Interior. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Planning staff recommends that the HRB approve the application for the COA as submitted. ATTACHMENTS Attachments include the “Dove White” paint chip as well as a representation of the screening that will be installed on the porch. 46 47 The Industry Leader in Porch Screening Innovation Our six screening systems, all with their unique features and benefits, are the preferred choice of homeowners, designers and building professionals. EXPLORE SYSTEMS MENU  Questions? Try out our AI assistant 7/1/26, 9:16 AM Screen Porch & Patio Systems from Screen Tight https://www.screentight.com/screening-systems/ 1/24 48  Questions? Try out our AI assistant 7/1/26, 9:16 AM Screen Porch & Patio Systems from Screen Tight https://www.screentight.com/screening-systems/ 2/24 49  Questions? Try out our AI assistant 7/1/26, 9:16 AM Screen Porch & Patio Systems from Screen Tight https://www.screentight.com/screening-systems/ 3/24 50  Questions? Try out our AI assistant 7/1/26, 9:16 AM Screen Porch & Patio Systems from Screen Tight https://www.screentight.com/screening-systems/ 6/24 51  Questions? Try out our AI assistant 7/1/26, 9:16 AM Screen Porch & Patio Systems from Screen Tight https://www.screentight.com/screening-systems/ 7/24 52  Questions? Try out our AI assistant 7/1/26, 9:16 AM Screen Porch & Patio Systems from Screen Tight https://www.screentight.com/screening-systems/ 9/24 53  Questions? Try out our AI assistant 7/1/26, 9:16 AM Screen Porch & Patio Systems from Screen Tight https://www.screentight.com/screening-systems/ 10/24 54 MultiTrack The most versatile screening system on the market. Achieve a clean lines and mounting on the interior or surface of a porch structure. Spline optional! Multiple ways to mount, multiple ways to screen. NEW  LEARN MORE Screen Wall A modular screen porch framing system manufactured with Green Eagle T echnology comprised of rigid PVC and composite fiber additiv es to withstand extreme wind and weather. LEARN MORE  Questions? Try out our AI assistant 7/1/26, 9:16 AM Screen Porch & Patio Systems from Screen Tight https://www.screentight.com/screening-systems/ 11/24 55  Questions? Try out our AI assistant 7/1/26, 9:16 AM Screen Porch & Patio Systems from Screen Tight https://www.screentight.com/screening-systems/ 12/24 56  Questions? Try out our AI assistant 7/1/26, 9:16 AM Screen Porch & Patio Systems from Screen Tight https://www.screentight.com/screening-systems/ 13/24 57  Questions? Try out our AI assistant 7/1/26, 9:16 AM Screen Porch & Patio Systems from Screen Tight https://www.screentight.com/screening-systems/ 15/24 58  Questions? Try out our AI assistant 7/1/26, 9:16 AM Screen Porch & Patio Systems from Screen Tight https://www.screentight.com/screening-systems/ 16/24 59 MiniTrack Ultra low profile aluminum tracks at just 3/4-inches to create wide open views. MiniT rack mounts discretely on the interior center of existing porch framing to enable endless trim and design options. LEARN MORE FastTrack The versatile “Lego-like” aluminum framing system for intuitive installation, unlimited screen porch panel configurations and expansive openings. LEARN MORE  Questions? Try out our AI assistant 7/1/26, 9:16 AM Screen Porch & Patio Systems from Screen Tight https://www.screentight.com/screening-systems/ 17/24 60  Questions? Try out our AI assistant 7/1/26, 9:16 AM Screen Porch & Patio Systems from Screen Tight https://www.screentight.com/screening-systems/ 18/24 61  Questions? Try out our AI assistant 7/1/26, 9:16 AM Screen Porch & Patio Systems from Screen Tight https://www.screentight.com/screening-systems/ 19/24 62

Source: Town of Fort Mill website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.