Historic Review Board Regular Meeting Agenda (PDF)
Town of Fort Mill · York County · meeting of Apr 14, 2026 · Agendas
Open the original document More from Town of Fort Mill
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Historic Review Board
205 N. White Street
April 14, 2026
4:30 p.m.
A
genda
CALL TO ORDER
AP
PROVAL OF MINUTES
1. HRB Meeting: March 10, 2026 [pages 2 - 93 ]
NE
W BUSINESS
1. Request for Certification of Appropriateness [pages 94 - 114 ]
Applicant Name: Cody King
Owner Name: Reaper Properties, LLC
Property Address: 235 and 237 Main Street
Purpose: Certification of Appropriateness request for building façade painting and
development of a rear lot patio area behind the two buildings.
Pro
perty Information: Local Commercial/LC and Historic District
ADJ
OURN
The following press was notified of the meeting by email or fax in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act:
The Herald, CN2, WRHI, WSOC, and WBTV. The agenda was also posted at the entrance to Town Hall the
required length of time and on the Town website. The Town of Fort Mill is committed to assuring accessibility with
reasonable accommodation, of Town services and facilities for all individuals, in compliance with federal law.
contact the Town Manager’s Office at 803-547-2116 if you need assistance.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
HISTORIC REVIEW BOARD
Ap
plicant: Cody King
Subject Property: 235 and 237 Main Street
Property Owner: Reaper Properties, LLC
Tax Map # 020-02-01-015 and 020-02-01-016
Zoning District: Local Commercial, LC/Historic District
Zoning Case: 2026-164
REQUEST
Initially the applicant inquired about the approval process for repainting portions of the building
facades. After additional discussion, the applicant is also requesting approval to move forward with a
phased approach to improving the rear lot area behind 235 and 237 Main Street. Currently the spaces
are occupied by a business – Charter House Cigar and Barrel.
T
he applicant has provided one color number HGSW6244 that corresponds with the color “Naval.”
Staff included a chip sample in the agenda packet. The application states “Repaint the front of the
building where old paint is weathered and in need of a fresh coat.”
As
for the improvements to the rear of the two buildings, a narrative and illustrations of furniture and
screening wall have been attached to the application. All other materials are described within the
text of the narrative . No samples of any materials were provided. The proposed use of the space is
for an outdoor patio and seating area for patrons of Charter House Cigar and Barrel.
94
VICINITY MAP
DISCUSSION
Painting: The only detail provided was the one color “Naval” as mentioned previously. The applicant
makes no mention of making any repairs or painting any other portions of the two buildings. Current
pictures of the front facades of the building have been attached to the staff report.
T
he following section of the Historic District Design Guidelines provides some guidance for repainting:
3.15 P
lan repainting carefully. Always prepare a good substrate. Remove damaged or
deteriorated paint only to the next intact layer, using the gentlest means possible, prior to
painting.
U
se compatible paints. Some latex paints will not bond well to earlier oil-based paints without
a primer coat.
95
P
atio: The applicant has provided a concept sketch plan that appears to show approximately where
the privacy screens, patio furniture, and access path will be located. There is no scale indicated on the
site plan. However, from GIS system measurements, the patio area is approximately 1,040 sq. ft.
C
hapter 6 of the Historic District Design Guidelines provides guidance for new project s such as the
proposed outdoor amenity , site furnishings , and site features. The entirety of Chapter 6 has been
attached to the staff report for the HRB’s reference.
T
he guidelines mention that outdoor amenity areas should not be roofed or fully enclosed and should
be paved or otherwise landscaped. The guidelines also mention that design of a new barrier should
be simple, such as metal work and low brick walls. Temporary planters are also appropriate to provide
a barrier. Site furnishings should compliment the surrounding context and be strategically located to
serve as an accent to a streetscape, plaza, or other public area. Lastly, the guidelines highlight that
new features should be compatible with the historic character of the property . Railroad ties, plastic,
vinyl, and other synthetic materials, and features over 36 inches in height, are generally deemed as
inappropriate.
96
SECRETARY OF INTERIOR ’S STANDARDS
The Secretary of Interior’s Standards typically serve as the basis for determining the approval, approval with
modifications, or denial of certificate of appropriateness by the HRB . While the current proposal involves a
small, contemporary design, these standards will indeed be relevant in weighing this proposal.
1. Every reasonable effort shall be made to provide a compatible use for a property which requires
minimal alteration of the building, structure, or site and its environment, or to use a property for
its original intended purpose.
2. The distinguishing original qualities or character of a building, structure, or site and its environment
shall not be destroyed. The removal or alteration of any historic material or distinctive architectural
features should be avoided when possible.
3. All buildings, structures, and sites shall be recognized as products of their own time. Alterations
that have no historical basis and which seek to create an earlier appearance shall be discouraged.
4. Changes which have taken place in the course of time are evidence of the history development of
a building, structure, or site and its environment. These changes may have acquired significance,
and this significance shall be recognized and respected.
5. Distinctive stylistic features or examples of skilled craftsmanship which characterize a building,
structure or site shall be treated with sensitivity.
6. Deteriorated architectural features shall be repaired rather than replaced wherever possible. In the
event replacement is necessary; the new material should match the material being replaced in
composition, design, color, texture, and other visible qualities. Repair or replacement of missing
architectural features should be based on accurate duplications of features, substantiated by
history, physical, or pictorial evidence rather than on conjectural designs or the availability of
different architectural elements from other buildings.
7. The surface cleaning of structures shall be undertaken with the gentlest means possible.
Sandblasting and other cleaning methods that will damage the historic building material shall not
be undertaken.
8. Every reasonable effort should be made to protect and preserve archaeological resources affected
by, or adjacent to the property.
9. Contemporary design for alterations and additions to existing properties shall not be discouraged
when such alterations and additions do not destroy significant historical, architectural, or cultural
materials, and such design is compatible with the size, scale, color, material, and character of the
property, neighborhood, or environment.
10. Wherever possible, new additions or alterations to structures shall be done in such a manner that
if such additions or alterations were to be removed in the future, the essential form and integrity
of the structure would be unimpaired.
97
STAFF FINDINGS
The greatest level of details about this project are contained within the graphic illustrations and the
text of the narrative attached to the application. The typical COA application reviewed by the HRB
usually contains sample boards of materials, specific colors, samples, site lighting fixture details, etc.,
which are then referred to by staff at the time of permitting and/or civil construction document
review.
S
TAFF RECOMMENDATION
Staff welcomes additional discussion between the applicant and the HRB about this project and will
stand in support of the design which HRB ultimately chooses to approve.
ATTACHMENTS
A. Application
B. Narrative
C. Naval pant chip
D. Site Plan
E. Site features (5 pages)
F. Overhead Aerial Photo
G. Project Area Aerial
H. Plat Map of 235 and Property Card for 237
98
Charterhouse Cigar & Barrel
Project Narrative & Materials Description
Project Information
Property Address: 235 and 237 Main Street, Fort Mill, SC 29715
Parcel Identification Numbers: 020-02-01-015 (235 Main) and 020-02-01-016 (237 Main)
Occupant: Charterhouse Management LLC
Phase: Phase 1 of Multiphase Project — Rear Lot Stabilization and Outdoor Area Improvements
Project Description
This application addresses Phase 1 of a multiphase improvement project for the rear lot area
behind 235 and 237 Main Street. The rear lot is currently unimproved waste ground in a derelict
condition, serving only as informal owner parking. The proposed Phase 1 improvements are
limited to surface stabilization and the placement of moveable site furnishings. No permanent
structures are proposed, no changes to any building exterior are proposed, and no grading beyond
surface leveling is anticipated.
The intent of Phase 1 is to clean up and stabilize the lot in a manner that is consistent with the
historic character of the property and the surrounding district, while providing a functional
outdoor area for the patrons of Charterhouse, a cigar and whiskey establishment operating at 235
and 237 Main Street.
Future phases, which will include more permanent hardscaping and structural improvements,
will be the subject of separate HRB applications submitted at the appropriate time with full
design documentation, as contemplated and required by applicable code and ordinance. This
application does not address or commit to any aspect of future phases.
Scope of Work — Phase 1
1. Surface Material
The lot surface will be cleared of debris and dressed with clean, uniform gravel with sand
under/base layer. The gravel will be a natural, earth-toned crushed stone consistent in character
with the rear lot context and compatible with the historic district setting.
99
2. Surface Edging
The gravel surface will be contained using salvaged historic brick reclaimed from the subject
buildings themselves. The brick edging will be laid at or near grade to contain the gravel surface
and prevent migration onto the adjacent alleyway and neighboring properties. The use of original
building brick ensures material compatibility with the historic character of the structures and the
district.
3. Privacy Screening
Freestanding, moveable privacy panels will be positioned within the lot to define the outdoor
area and provide visual screening. The panels are dark-toned, commercial-grade, and
freestanding — they are not attached to any structure, wall, or the ground. Their placement is
flexible and may be adjusted as needed.
4. Site Furnishings
Moveable, commercial-grade outdoor seating and table furnishings will be placed within the
defined area. All furnishings are dark-toned, weather-resistant, and freestanding. No furnishings
will be affixed to the ground or to any structure.
Design Compatibility with Historic District
The proposed improvements have been specifically designed to complement the historic
character of the property and the Fort Mill Historic District:
• The salvaged brick edging material is reclaimed directly from the subject buildings,
ensuring material authenticity and compatibility.
• The gravel surface is natural and earth-toned, consistent with the informal rear lot
character common to historic Main Street properties.
• All screening and furnishing elements are dark-toned and visually recessive, avoiding
any conflict with the historic building fabric.
• All elements are moveable and non-permanent, preserving the integrity of the site and
ensuring reversibility.
• The improvements transform a derelict, debris-filled lot into a clean, well-maintained
outdoor area, which is consistent with the district’s goals of maintaining and enhancing
the historic character and economic vitality of downtown Fort Mill.
• The improvements enhance rather than impede emergency access and egress. The
defined gravel surface and clear sightlines through the lot improve navigation and access
relative to the current condition, and all freestanding elements are positioned to preserve
unobstructed access to rear building exits and the alleyway.
100
Existing Conditions
Photographs documenting the existing conditions of the rear lot are submitted as an attachment
to this detail. The lot currently contains construction debris, loose materials, discarded
equipment, patchy ground cover, and no defined surface treatment. Access through the lot is
uneven and irregular.
The proposed improvements represent a material upgrade in every respect. The removal of debris
and establishment of a clean, uniform gravel surface will substantially improve both the
appearance and the safety of the lot. Defined ingress and egress paths will be maintained and
improved over existing conditions, providing clearer and more accessible passage through the
rear of the property. The gravel surface and ground-level brick edging present no obstruction to
emergency access or equipment movement — conditions that are meaningfully better than the
current uneven, debris-laden state of the lot.
All proposed elements — gravel, brick edging, freestanding panels, and moveable furnishings —
are non-combustible or low-risk materials appropriate for an open-air environment. The
freestanding panels are not attached to the buildings and do not impede access to rear building
exits. The overall effect of the Phase 1 improvements is a safer, more orderly, and more visually
appropriate rear lot condition than currently exists.
Site Plan
A site plan showing the general layout of the gravel area, edging, screening placement, and
furnishing zones relative to the building rear elevations and the 18-foot alleyway is submitted as
an attachment to this detail.
Charterhouse acknowledges that this application addresses Phase 1 only and that future phases
of improvement to this site will be submitted for separate HRB review at the appropriate time
with full design documentation as required, and as contemplated within the applicable
ordinances and codes.
101
102
103
104
Privacy Screen
© 2025 Microsoft Corporation © 2025 TomTom © 2025 Zenrin
SITE
W
W
M
M
S
M
W
W
M
M
M
NAIL ROBOT
NAIL ROBOT
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
S33° 37' 02"E
79.95'
N54° 16' 09"E22.72'
N34° 21' 23"W
79.96'
N34° 21' 23"W
100.00'
N34° 37' 49"W100.00'
N56° 07' 09"E24.56'
N53° 53' 36"E24.07'
E E
E
E
E
E
N55° 38' 37"E24.40'
1 STORY BUILDING
1 STORY BUILDING
1 STORY BUILDING
1 STORY BUILDING
SET MAG NAIL
SET MAG NAIL
1/2" REBAR BENT
1/2" REBAR BENT
CENTER OF PARTY WALL
SUBMITTED BY:
CHECKED BY:
DRAWN BY:
ZONING:
SCALE:
PLAT DATE:
FIELD DATE:
SIZE:
MARK DESCRIPTION DATE
SHEET ID
GeoNexa, LLC
18 Sunriff Ct.
Greer
FIRM NUMBER 7609
CHRISTOPHER J. BEDFORD
18 SUNRIFF CT.
GREER, SC 29651
1"=10'
8/11/25
ARCH FULL BLEED C (24.00 X 18.00 INCHES)
10/15/2025
SURVEY OF
235 MAIN ST
CITY OF FORT MILL YORK COUNTY
SOUTH CAROLINA
CJB
GMM
GEONEXA, LLC
CJBCODY KING
SURVEY FOR
1 OF 1
P-1
VICINITY MAP (N.T.S.)
LEGEND:
COMM COMM
LPG LPG
INW INW
G G
E E E
C/E C/E
SAN SAN
CP CP CP
SD SD
W W W
FIBER OPTIC
LIQUID GAS
WASTE
GAS LINE
OVERHEAD ECLECTIC
CENTERLINE
EASEMENT
SANITARY SEWER
CULVERT
STORM DRAIN
WATER LINE
SURVEYED PROPERTY LINE
UNSURVEYED PROPERTY LINE
SURVEYED TIE LINE
NGS TIE LINE
38568$17 72 7+( 3529,6,216 2) 7+( 6287+
&$52/,1$ &2'( 2) /$:6 7+,6 3/$1
63(&,),&$7,21 25 3/$7 6+$// 127 %( ),/('
:,7+ 38%/,& $87+25,7,(6 :,7+287 7+( 6($/
6,*1$785($1''$7($)),;(')857+(5025(,)
7+,6 3/$1 63(&,),&$7,21 25 3/$7 '2(6 127
+$9($6($/7+$7,66,*1('$1''$7(',76+$//
127 %( 86(' )25 $1< 385326( 27+(5 7+$1 $
35(/,0,1$5< 678'< '5$:,1* $1' :,// %(
&216,'(5('$:25.,1352*5(66
7+( :25'6 &(57,)< &(57,),(6 25
&(57,),&$7,21 $6 86(' +(5(,1 $5(
81'(56722' 72 %( $1 (;35(66,21 2)
352)(66,21$/ 23,1,21 %< 7+( 6859(<25
%$6(' 8321 +,6 %(67 .12:/('*(
,1)250$7,21 $1' %(/,() $6 68&+ '2 127
&2167,787( $ *8$5$17(( 125 $ :$55$17<
(;35(66('25,03/,('
7+( 352)(66,21$/ 6859(<25 +$6 0$'( 12
,19(67,*$7,21 25 ,1'(3(1'(17 6($5&+ )25
($6(0(176 2) 5(&25' (1&80%5$1&(6
5(675,&7,9( &29(1$176 2:1(56+,3 7,7/(
(9,'(1&( 25 $1< 27+(5 )$&76 7+$7 $1
$&&85$7( $1' &855(17 7,7/( 6($5&+ 0$<
',6&/26(7+,66859(<'2(6127&2167,787($
7,7/(6($5&+%<7+(6859(<25
7+$77+(6859(<,62)$1(;,67,1*3$5&(/25
3$5&(/62)/$1'2521(25025((;,67,1*
($6(0(176$1''2(6127&5($7($1(:
675((725&+$1*($1(;,67,1*675((7)25
7+(385326(62)7+,668%6(&7,21$1
(;,67,1*3$5&(/25(;,67,1*($6(0(17,6$1
$5($2)/$1''(6&5,%(',1$6,1*/(/(*$/
'(6&5,37,2125/(*$//<5(&25'('
68%',9,6,217+$7+$6%((1250$<%(/(*$//<
&219(<('72$1(:2:1(5%<'((',1,76
(;,67,1*&21),*85$7,21
7+,63/$7+$6%((135(3$5(':,7+2877+(
%(1(),72)$7,7/(5(3257$1''2(6127
1(&(66$5,/<,1',&$7($//(1&80%5$1&(621
7+(3523(57<
7+,6 3523(57< ,6 68%-(&7 72 $1< $1' $//
($6(0(176 5,*+762):$< 25',1$1&(6
&29(1$176 $1' 5(675,&7,216 5(&25'(' 25
815(&25'('
3523(57< 6+2:1 +(5(21 ,6 68%-(&7 72 7+(
58/(6 5(*8/$7,216 25',1$1&(6 $1'25
-85,6',&7,216 2) /2&$/ 67$7( $1'25
)('(5$/ $*(1&,(6 ,) $1< 7+( 5(48,5(0(176
2) 6$,' 58/(6 5(*8/$7,216 25',1$1&(6
$1'25 7+( /,0,76 2) 6$,' -85,6',&7,216 $5(
127 6+2:1 +(5(21 81/(66 67$7('
27+(5:,6(
7+( %$6,6 2) %($5,1* ,6 *5,' 1257+ '(5,9('
)520 9,578$/ 5()(5(1&( 67$7,21 0(7+2'6
86,1* 7+(
1257+ $0(5,&$1 '$780 2)
1656 67$7( 3/$1( &225',1$7(6 6287+
&$52/,1$
7+( 9(57,&$/ '$780 ,6 7+( 1257+ $0(5,&$1
9(57,&$/ '$780 2) (/(9$7,216 %$6(' 21
*(2,'7+,6'$780:$6'(5,9(')5207+(
9,578$/ 5()(5(1&( 67$7,21 2) 6287+
&$52/,1$
$//',67$1&(6+2:1$5(*5281'',67$1&(6
81/(6627+(5:,6(127('
',67$1&(66+2:1$5(,1866859(<)227$1'
'(&,0$/67+(5(2)81/(6627+(5:,6(127('
PROPERTY IS ZONED LOCAL COMMERCIAL
11.)PROPERTY IS IN X FLOOD ZONE
PANEL NUMBER: 45091C0214F
PANEL DATE: 5/16/2017
7+(5( ,6 12 9,6,%/( (9,'(1&( 2) &(0(7(5,(6
217+(68%-(&73523(57<
12 $77(037 :$6 0$'( 72 '(7(50,1(
:(7/$1'6 25 27+(5 (19,5210(17$/ ,668(6
81/(6627+(5:,6(127('
CHRISTOPHER J. BEDFORD, PLS
N/F
REAPER PROPERTIES LLC
PIN: 0200201015DB: 20675 PG: 399
PB: 159 PG: 135AREA: ±0.04 ACRES
N/F
MICHAEL W CHASE
PIN:0200201014
DB: 16197 PG: 51
MAIN ST (SC-160)
PUBLIC R/W 50' PB: C249 PG: 3
18' ALLEYWAY
N/F
CRISPINVINTON METCALF
PIN: 0200201017
DB: 20536 PG: 186
PB: C249 PG: 3
N/F
KYTRAMOODY MOODY
PIN: 0200201022
DB: 6597 PG: 141
PB: C249 PG: 3
N/F
MIAXEL LLC
PIN: 0200201016DB: 17284 PG: 76AREA: ±0.04 ACRES
10' 5' 0' 10' 20'
1"=10'
URVEYORLAND S
PROFESS IONAL
ANILORACHTUOS
PB: 159 PG: 135
Privacy Screen
Privacy Screen
Privacy Screen
Privacy Screen
Privacy Screen
Privacy Screen
Privacy Screen
Privacy Screen
Privacy Screen
Privacy Screen
Privacy Screen
Privacy Screen
Privacy Screen
105
106
107
108
109
110
235 & 237 Main Street Aerial
02/14/2026
111
Patio Project Area Behind 235 and 237 Main Street
112
113
BUTH CALOLINA - COUNTY
MA BLOCK LOT AER.
PHOTO
Parcel No.
ACRES/FT. ORIG. ASSESS.
LAND
ORIG. ASSESS.
BLDG.
Disttiet
020-02-01-016
MIAXEL LLC
3567 PLEASANT RD
FORT MILL SC 29708
Kina's m In Ne.OWNER'S NAME & ADDRESS
Transfer To Pen
Koth Merchom
Zoning #237
Hiaten
Location
ain ST.
Subdivision
or Tract
Schooi Tax OtherTax
State Farm
Addres SEP 0-7-2016 0200201016
-AUG 1-9 2016-
10:29.08 NOV 28 2018
DOI. Date Liber Folio Sale
3-3-1966 3-4-1966 347 605
how
AFF
Lillie B.ms Alhanuy0
7-782 7-9-83 668 8212.20
Est of Robept CHill (dled 3-210 the# 2016ES44906474 8-77-16 15864 234 dad
Yichal Cae Hee + Katherme Hull. Strange -2 on Lc- 5Loo
8-22-16 15872 349
9-1-16 5898 68 Correchi
PROPERTY DESCRIPTION19
St. Robent C, Hui RECOMMENDED ASSESSMENT
1981 1982 A74 92019 19
Land 06Ac6100 6100 7500 84,0c0
/ Improvements j7.606 14500 32500 121,000
Total 20700 20600 40,000 205,000
Date of Notice
Expiration Date
Protested
Date of Hearing
Final Notice
App. To State Tax
Date of Hearing
Final Notice
マジ
100
100
244
Date of Apprainal 10-22-1221
App. To Court
REMARES Lecin c lt Blog tg hsnasletWt t l Dee s fo RS'I ID 24'ga
tI Woe Thes as24'" Byashad I arsared on the BRoU2D.
RE-1 ASSESSOR
114
Source: Town of Fort Mill website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.