_04142026-575
Town of Fort Mill · York County · meeting of Apr 14, 2026 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Fort Mill
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
TOWN OF FORT MILL
HISTORIC REVIEW BOARD MEETING
April 14, 2026
205 N. White St
4:30 p.m.
Present: Vice Chairman David Booth, Elizabeth Leventis, Scott Couchenour, Hynek
Lettang, Joanne Walker, David Helms, Planning Director Penelope Karagounis,
Deputy Planning Director Joey Adams-Raczkowski, Planner Emily Hawkins.
Absent: Chairwoman Megan Brinton
Guests: See attached sign in sheet
Vice Chairman David Booth called the Historic Review Board meeting to order at 4:30 p.m. on
Tuesday, April 14, 2026.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Vice Chairman David Booth asked for a motion to be made to approve Historic Review Board meeting
minutes from March 10, 2026. Commissioner Couchenour made the motion. Commissioner Leventis
seconded the motion. The motion to approve the minutes from March 10, 2026, was approved by a vote
of 6:0.
NEW BUSINESS
1. Request for Certification of Appropriateness for Charterhouse Cigar and Barrel
Deputy Planning Director Joey Adams-Raczkowski introduced the one order of business, a request for
Certification of Appropriateness for the Charterhouse Cigar and Barrel, located at 235/237 Main Street.
The applicant is requesting approval of paint color for the Main Street frontage facades as well as a rear
patio area consisting of screening and furniture placed on a low brick perimeter wall with a gravel
surface with seating for about twenty customers. Mr. Adams-Raczkowski clarified that the applicant
intends for this to be a multiphase project.
Mr. Adams-Raczkowski presented visuals of the proposed paint color ‘Naval - 6244’ by Sherwin
Williams to be applied only to the Main Street facades of 235 and 237. Mr. Adams-Raczkowski
explained that the second part of the request is an outdoor patio seating area for customers. The area
would be screened and allow for privacy and access in and around the screened enclosed area. Mr.
Adams-Raczkowski also stated that there are pictures submitted by the applicant of the rear area of the
buildings that were not included in the packet, but instead, handed out to the HRB members present and
will be included in the record for this case.
Cody King and Attorney Trey Nantz, representing Charterhouse Cigar and Barrel, provided additional
details about the proposal. Mr. King stated that this is the first step toward a more permanent solution to
provide a patio space for the patrons of the business, and they were available for questions from the
board. Ms. Leventis received clarification from the applicant that the entire façade including window
frames and doors would be painted Naval color. Mr. King also clarified that none of the existing
unpainted brick would be painted. Mr. King noted that he would like to paint the back of the buildings
the same Naval color, but that would be submitted as a separate request later. Planning Director
Penelope Karagounis also clarified that the Towne Tavern signage has been removed.
There was extensive discussion between the board members and the applicants regarding the patio being
labeled as temporary, until the applicants can hire a general contractor to design a permanent patio area.
Staff clarified for the board that the Guidelines do not differentiate between temporary and permanent
structures. Therefore, what is being proposed needs to be treated as if it is a permanent structure and an
addition to the existing buildings.
While addressing the board, Mr. King clarified the Charterhouse is a whiskey and cocktail lounge at 235
Main Street, with a retail cigar shop with a walk-in humidor at 237 Main Street. Eventually the indoor
smoking lounge will operate at 237. Mr. Nantz explained that the long-term vision is for decking to be
constructed in the rear of the structures. However, for now, there will be a sand base surrounded by
stacked reclaimed brick and a six-foot tall privacy screen around the perimeter.
Regarding the privacy screen, the applicant explained that it is a free-standing system of fire rated
stacked panels made of composite wood with a metal frame. Each panel is then attached to the ground
with spikes to prevent the panels from falling over. There will be spacing on the sides to allow for proper
access. Mr. Couchenour asked if there was the possibility of using wood materials instead. Mr. King
stated that he would explore that option during the next phase of the project which will hopefully take
place within the next 2-3 months, but no more than 6 months.
Additional discussion between the board and the applicants included ABC laws, ADA accessibility, the
possibility of using planter boxes connected with rope or chain instead of the proposed six-foot
screening, height of the screening, where will the screening will be stored when not in use, future deck
and railing height, setting precedent for similar requests, the total height of the screening and supports
being reduced to four-feet in height, what is temporary versus permanent, clarifying that the entire
perimeter of the patio area will be screened, existing railroad ties will be removed, location of HVAC
equipment in relation to screening and future decking, and whether or not the screening can be identified
as a temporary moveable element.
Staff verified that multiphase projects are required to submit a new application, but an additional fee
would not be applied. For the second phase of this project, civil plan drawings will need to be submitted
in addition to HRB review and approval. Also, any favorable motion cannot include a timeframe
because the guidelines do not allow for temporary approvals or structures. Therefore, a timeframe will
not be enforceable.
Ms. Leventis cited Section 6.5 of the Fort Mill Historic District Guidelines, page 113, stating “Locate
Dining areas to minimize impact on the streetscape” as well as Section 6.6 regarding the design of
handrails and/or barrier should be simple, and temporary planters are appropriate to provide a barrier for
outdoor dining areas. Ms. Leventis continued discussion about the possibility of utilizing planters
instead, therefore avoiding the noncompliant materials as well as temporary versus permanent issues.
Ms. Walker questioned the applicant further as to why they did not see the planters as a valid option for
the screening given that the planters and plants would offer the same height of screening as the composite
wood panels. Attorney Nantz stated that the planters would be harder to move and have more of an
impact.
Ms. Leventis then highlighted the screening of service equipment on page 118 of the Guidelines. The
proposed screening would offer compliance with that portion of the Guidelines. Mr. Helms then asked
the applicant if he could provide an all-metal four-foot-high screening product instead, which would be
more in compliance with the Guidelines. Attorney Nantz stated that product would be counterproductive
to the applicant’s goals of having something more temporary in nature as he works on the permanent
solution which will incorporate materials more in keeping with the Guidelines.
Staff asked for clarification about the location of the screening near the rear of Luca Studio and Gallery.
Referring to the site plan provided, Mr. King stated that the screening would not interfere with access to
the rear of that building. Staff also confirmed with Mr. King that the railroad ties would be removed.
Mr. Couchenour made a motion to approve the Naval paint color and moveable screening material as
proposed but lower the height to a maximum of 48 inches, installed per the drawings as submitted
including the stone and brick. Ms. Leventis seconded the motion. By a show of hands, the motion
passed 4:2 with Ms. Leventis, Mr. Couchenour, Mr. Helms, and Mr. Lettang in support; Ms. Walker and
Mr. Booth voting against the motion.
Adjournment
Vice Chairman David Booth entertained a motion to adjourn the meeting. Mr. Couchenour made a
motion to adjourn. Ms. Walker seconded the motion. The motion to adjourn was approved by a vote of 6-
0.
The meeting adjourned at 5:41 p.m.
Respectfully submitted by Joey Adams-Raczkowski
Deputy Planning Director
May 4, 2026
Source: Town of Fort Mill website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.