Download Minutes File (114.73 KB, PDF)
Town of Edisto Beach · Colleton County · meeting of May 14, 2012 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Edisto Beach
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Page 1 of 3
TOWN OF EDISTO BEACH
ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS
Monday, May 14, 2012
5:00 P.M.
Regularly Scheduled Meeting
THESE MINUTES ARE NOT VERBATIM, BUT DO ACCURATELY REFLECT THE
PROCEEDINGS.
Members attending: Chairman Gerald Jones, Members Reddick Bowman, Polly McIntosh, John
McAlhaney and Joe Dreher
Members absent: Vice Chair Jeanine Rhodes and Member Charles Boozer
Staff attending: Patrick Brown , Building Code Administrator, Rebecca Brown , Code
Enforcement Officer and Sara Simpson, Secretary
Chairman Jones called the meeting to order at 5:00 p.m. He began with an opening statement, “This
Zoning Board of Appeals was established by town ordinance enacted by Town Council of the Town
of Edisto Beach, South Carolina. The ordinance establishing this Board was enacted pursuant to the
South Carolina Local Government Comprehensive Planning Enabling Act of 1994 which has been
codified as Title 6, Chapter 29 in the South Carolina Code of Laws. Being so constituted, this Board
does not have unlimited authority, in fact our powers are limited. For example, this Board may not
grant a variance, the effect of which would be to allow the establishment of a use not otherwise
permitted in a zoning district or to extend a non- conforming use of land or to change the zoning
district boundaries shown on the original zoning map. Moreover, the fact that property may be
utilized more profitably if a variance is granted may not even be considered grounds for a variance.
The standards that this Board must apply are set forth plainly in the governing statute and in Section
86-91 of the Town’s zoning ordinance.” The Board then moved directly into New Business.
New Business:
1307 Point Street – Charles W. and Isabelle S. Mims
Chairman Jones began by stating, “Today we are here to decide if the Zoning Administrator made
an error in his determination that the present structure on lot 1307 Point S treet cannot be used in
the calculation to determine the seaward roof line on new or reconstruction on said property.
Specifically, the appellant requests relief from the from the application of Section 86 -145-1 of the
zoning ordinance.” Building Code Administrator Brown concluded that no error was made in his
interpretation of the ordinance but that the request was a variance from the ordinance. Both parties
agreed to that determination. Chairman Jones then administered the Oath. After administering the
Oath, Chairman Jones asked if anyone standing for the Oath did not say “I do.” No one answered.
Page 2 of 3
The Appellant’s testimony began with Mr. Mim s introducing Lee Frank to speak. Mr. Frank stated he
was tasked to define the developable area of Mr. Mim’s lot. This is the last lot on Point Street and the
next structure upstream is on Palmetto Boulevard. The ordi nance, as Mr. Frank interprets it, required
the incorporation of data derived from the three (3) closest, habitable structures. He realized quickly
that using data from the next structure upstream was inappropriate and would result in a buildable
envelope that was wasn’t even on the lot and would have to be in the right -of-way. As a result, he used
the data from the three closest structures downstream, when typically one structure in one direction and
two structures in the other direction would be used. This would leave a building envelope that was
comparable to the existing structure. Using the strict interpretation of the ordinance would be a
hardship as the building envelope would be moved almost 45 feet landward. This would cause a new
structure to be out of line with existing structures on Point Street and result in all houses on Point Street
to move landward. Mr. Frank recommends that using data from the two houses downstream and Mr.
Mims’ existing house and this would be in keeping with the spiri t of the ordinance. Using this data for
the calculations would require a right hand roofline to move landward about 18 feet and this is
consistent with the Town and the State of South Carolina’s beach retreat strategy.
The Board asked if there was some sort of compromise that could be agreed on by all parties as this is
such a unique situation. Member Bowman stated that in order for the Board to grant a variance, the
landowner had to meet four (4) requirements. If the variance was not granted, this would not prohibit
the building of a new structure, one of the requirements. The Board just doesn’t see where this situation
meets any of the four requirements. Therefore, where one method would move the roofline 18 feet and
another method would move the r oofline 45 feet, there must be some sort of middle gr ound that could
be reached. The Mims’ stated that they were agreeable to a compromise.
Building Code Administrator Brown’s began by giving the Board and the parties a copy of the Town’s
ordinance and t he state’s beachfront management overlay district plan. He stated “the purpose of the
beach management overlay zoning district is to implement and enforce a retreat strategy and storm
hazard mitigation plan adopted by the Town so as to protect life and pr operty located with the close
proximity to the baseline established by the South Carolina Coastal Council.” In Building Code
Administrator Brown’s opinion, using the method of compiling data that Mr. Frank suggested and
granting the variance is still in c onformance with the Town’s ordinance and state law. Any retreat at all
is applicable and in this case, the compromise would be a 20’ retreat. Also, the Town requires one
9’x20’ parking space for each bedroom in the structure and they can be located under the structure.
Mr. Rick Garrick, Mr. Mims’ next door neighbor, stated that he agrees and supports the request for the
variance.
Building Code Administrator Brown’s rebutted and stated that the strict interpretation of the ordinance
in this case would have a domino effect and is unreasonable. Using Mr. Frank’s calculation may be
more in line with the beach management overlay zoning district plan. A recess was taken at this time so
that the parties to come up with a number that everyone could agree on.
Upon reconvening the meeting, Building Code Administrator Brown read a prepared statement, “As the
Building Code Administrator, I do not necessarily agree with a compromise, I think strict application of
the ordinance does create a hardship and does fall under the three sections as outlined in the variance
ordinance. Using the current structure in the calculations does meet the Town’s ordinance and the state
law for retreat. Granting a variance using the current structure in the calculations is warranted.”
Page 3 of 3
Member Bowman moved to grant the request for a variance using the methodology that would move a
new roof line back from the existing corner 20 feet, which is approving the variance with a special
condition. The condition being a new roof line being m oved back 20’ from the existing corner of the
present structure. Mr. Frank explained that this is essentially what the Appellant came in and asked for.
Following a lengthy discussion, Member McAlhaney moved to grant the variance as requested followed
by a second from Member Bowman. A vote was taken, 3 -2 with Member Bowman and Chairman
Jones opposing.
Old Business:
There was no old business to discuss.
Approval of Minutes:
Chairman Jones asked the Board if there was any discussion pertaining to the m inutes of February 17,
2012. There being no discussion, Member McIntosh moved to approve the minutes followed by second
from Member Bowman. The vote was unanimous to approve the minutes.
There being no further business to discuss, Member Reddick made the motion to adjourn the meeting
followed by a second by Member McIntosh, which carried unanimously. The meeting adjourned at 6:45
p.m.
Freedom of Information Act, § 30-4-80(3) was complied with.
APPROVED BY THE ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS
_________________________________________
Submitted by Sara Simpson
Secretary of the Zoning Board of Appeals
A digital recording of this meeting is on file at Town Hall.
Source: Town of Edisto Beach website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.