RecordWell Data

Work Session Minutes January 8 2025

Edgefield County · Edgefield County · meeting of Jan 8, 2025 · Minutes

Open the original document More from Edgefield County

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

, Edgefield County Planning Commission Work Session Minutes County Council Chambers January 8, 2025 5:00 PM Dustin Doolittle, Autumn Becker, Sharron Hadden, and Karlene Butler were absent for the December 11, 2025, Meeting Staff Present: April Morgan, Hart Clark, David Caddell Burt: Good evening. At this time, we're going to call the Edgefield County Planning Commission Work session to order January the 8th, 2026. And we'll call the order. No guest speakers. Old business is staff updates and reports. Morgan: OK, it's in front of you. We had three plat reviews, two exempt subdivisions, and 5 minor subdivisions. Zero major subdivisions and one combine plat. The preferred tree list, you have that in front of you. The edits that were discussed when y'all voted to push this through to council are highlighted. They were generated, the edits were generated via your concerns about the trees that were on there. So those edits were made so it made more sense for our area. And the tree preservation ordinance itself, I could email it to you. I printed it out, but I think I left it on the table over there. I apologize. It had like two edits that the only significant other wording was that we included a top floor buffer for all the way around it, except for if it's facing a road corridor, it would be a type five buffer along the end. Clark: So basically we increased the buffer requirement if it's on a corridor. Morgan: And that's all I have. And this will go before Council in February. Burt: OK, now move on. Walsh: I have a question for David. Didn't I hear you say at the County Council Meeting that you were also looking at the list of trees that should not be brought to the area that may be invasive? Chairman: James Burt – Dist. I Members: Sharron Hadden – Dist. II Vice-Chairman: Lisa Whitaker-Dist. III Karlene Butler– Dist. IV At Large: Autumn Becker Dustin Doolittle- Dist. V At Large: Tracy Walsh Caddell: That's right. Those edits have been made as well. I'm an arborist myself. I went through the list. Roy Kibler, North Augusta arborist, we sat down with him. He struck some trees, added a couple, I believe. And Clemson Extension, Stephen Polman, who's an arborist locally, he took the list and sent it up the chain and back down. And there were a couple of things that Clemson is adding to a do not plant list. We struck those. So it's been vetted pretty well now, this particular version. I'm pretty comfortable with it. We added more natives, took some of the non-natives out. For landscaping purposes, if let's say a shopping center wants to put a tree in an island or something, sometimes it's appropriate for the non-natives. I would anticipate that most of the natives would be put in the buffers. And I would imagine that if I was a developer, it costs a lot of money to buy two and a half inch caliper trees and water them and care for them. I would preserve the existing vegetation to the best of my ability and just infill gaps. With these trees, so I'm pretty comfortable with the list, especially that we have so many native species on there. Walsh: Okay. That's great, because I'd like to see what was naturally growing here preserved and then replanted with the things that are found here naturally, rather than bringing in foreign species that's going to change our look. Caddell: I agree, I agree. We lean heavily into that. You have to give people options, and unfortunately, some of the nurseries grow hybrid stock, and some of the stock's considered non- native. You don't have a lot of nurseries growing two-and-a-half-inch caliper or white oaks and things like that, unfortunately. You just don't. But I think that market's growing, and with counties doing things like this and pushing native trees, I think it will grow more. That's what we should do. Morgan: It does mention that in there. Well, you know, we prefer that you maintain what's there, and then, like you said, fill in the gaps Caddell: That's right, that's right. It's very expensive to buy, for example, to do a buffer and buy a couple of hundred two-and-a-half-inch caliper trees. These involve burlap. That's very expensive. Morgan: So I really... That's one of the first things that they'll ask when they call us. You know, can we use existing for buffer? Absolutely. We want you to use it. Caddell: Now in with that is and I was discussing this with April and Doc, there is a need to increase inspections around this because root preservation of existing trees is very important. They have to warranty these, right? For a year? So I do think developers will lean heavily towards maintaining what's out there and of course we'll have tree surveys we'll have we'll have a plan sheet that tells us what's out there so you know it's not that in the dead of night you can go in and remove something because they'll have to send us a survey this is a very stringent tree preservation ordinance I'll tell you that. CLARK: if they clear cut it before they do the survey then it locks them down for five years and they can't develop it WALSH:Yeah, I think that the intention behind that That was something Jerry Moody had suggested to me Well, because it's an old trick of developers to get the previous owner to clear cut it and then when they buy it Oh, well, it was already clear before I bought it. Clark: It is an old trick of developers to get the previous owner to clear-cut it, so when they buy it, they can say it was already clear-cut before they bought it. Walsh: That’s what that's what it was to stop someone saying oh, I just harvested the timber. Clark: And well, we don't, you know, timber's not a protected tree, but if you go in there and you got, you know, harp wood, pine, and you got oak trees, and you got maple trees, et cetera, et cetera, those are significant trees that you have to keep. Now, if you're just clearing a timber track, well, that's a whole separate issue, and you won't have any choice but to plant trees, because we aren’t going to let you keep the pine trees anyway, unless it's a native, It's a native pine. Caddell: You can maintain that in the buffer. Walsh: But we're not stopping the timber crops. The people who are going for timber crops. We don't want to do that. Clark: Correct, that's the biggest crop in Edgefield County. Walsh: You want toilet paper and paper to write on and print. You need to grow pine trees. Clark: We've got about 28,000 acres of timber pine. Walsh: Right. So, this is not stopping them from harvesting timber? Absolutely not. It's just if they harvest the timber and then the developer comes in and wants to buy it. Morgan: It's specific to that ordinance. The ordinance applies to commercial and major subdivisions. Walsh: Right. Clark: It would behoove a developer to, when he looks at a land, just go ahead and do a tree survey up front before he even makes any determination, because even if the lot doesn't meet that canopy, he's going to have to meet that. So if he buys a field, he's got to know up front that I'm going to have to plant this to get 30% canopy. So it behooves them to do that up front anyway. Caddell: We'll need to have meetings with the developers and get that across. Walsh: Yeah. Caddell: Because it could be a costly mistake. Clark: I think a lot of developers are, I mean, we're not the first people to do it. We might be a little stricter than a lot of them, but we're not the first jurisdiction they've been to that requires a tree survey or has a tree preservation ordinance. Morgan: I think the only thing that they will come up with would be, how can you prove that this was not pasture for the past? Clark: It must be 30% Walsh: It's less like Tavern Hill. It's being built in a former pasture for hay. Clark: And under, once this is passed, 30% it, you're going to have to come back and plant it. Just because it was a field don't mean anything. You're going to have to plant it. Morgan: And that's not in the, that doesn't include the lot trees. Clark: Of course, they are planting trees in there. And I'm going to ask the council to change phase two and three to take street trees out and just put more subdivision trees and green space and stuff like that. Street trees are the devil. We don't want that. I hate that some of that is already in some places, but that turns into a nightmare for the county, and it tears the roads and sidewalks to pieces. It's just bad. But green spaces, no reason you can't just fill green spaces and areas that aren't technically green spaces but are common areas, like around a retention pond and stuff you don't want to see anyway. Plant trees. Walsh: Well, I mean, I would encourage trees, if they want to plant them, don't plant them at the street because it messes up the sidewalks and the asphalt as the tree grows. But there needs to be trees in the yard shade for those homes somewhere. Clark: So we do have a requirement in there for trees in the yards. However, they do not count towards your 30% canopy for your subdivision. And the reason for that is when the private owner comes and buys the lot, they could choose to come in and cut down every tree off their lot and there's nothing we can do about it. But we can only put those regulatory burdens on the developer. So that 30% is going to be your green spaces, your buffer spaces, your retention spaces, wherever you have a common space. That is where you're going to get your 30%. And then the Planning requirements for each lot, I can't remember what it was. Was it two in the backyard, one in the front? Caddell: It was one per 5,000 square feet of lot. Clark: We're going to require them to be planted. But like I said, the homeowner could buy the lot and then come in and chop them down. And well, that's that. Walsh: But I have sold in neighborhoods where the HOA restrictions. You have to go to the HOA board to get permission to cut a tree down in your yard, which I think is ridiculous, but there are some HOA restrictions where you can't cut down a tree in your yard. Clark: Some of those developers may choose to go that route, but I would rather just count my 30% not including those. Caddell: Yeah. Right, because then it's just gravy, right? It's extra. Yeah. So whatever remains is great in that subdivision. Clark: From staff's point of view, we wrote this because we don't want to take a satellite picture and see governors landing. That's what we're trying to avoid. They didn't really mass grade, but they cut everything as far as the eye can see. If you're standing at the road, you can see the houses at the very back of the subdivision. That's what we don't want. Yeah, have some mystery. Morgan: Well, if a developer comes and it's something that they can always do a cluster development, but then preserve everything else around it. And then you've got all the acreage that's not developed, that's permanently just forested area. Walsh: And then you've got all the acreage that's not developed, that's permanently just forested area. It's not permanent. We've already had that discussion. We can't make it permanent. We cannot make green space permanent. I've asked you that in the Meeting. Morgan: If it's a part, they would have to come up with a Planning Commission before they could ever develop a housing. Walsh: Right. That doesn't mean it's permanent. Because that Planning Commission and county council can change their mind saying, yeah, we need more housing. Clark: As permanent as any current regulatory body can make it. I mean, obviously, you can't say 30 years from the future, the council at that time is going to change all the regulations. I mean everything we do they can throw in the trash 30 from now, but you know, without coming back through the whole process it's it is what it is. Burt: Nothing is going to be forever. Now we go onto New Business, Data Centers. Whitaker: And the whole reason that we've I've been talking for quite a while now and emailing back and forth about the different situations as far as data centers and things like that. And I had at first talked to you, I believe, about doing a moratorium. And then after, it seemed like Monday or Tuesday, everything came to a head and everybody's talking about data centers. I have all the paperwork here that we've discussed, but it didn't seem that there were, you know, that possibly we don't need a moratorium. Some facts, we don't have the water, we don't have the electricity. We don't even have electricity in the water to even start one, which is good in one way and not in others. I had done quite a bit of research on zoning considerations regarding the data centers, and we have to include crypto mining, because if you don't, it's just another hole that you're going to step in trying to prevent something else. But the biggest eye-opener that I came across was the legal firm who works for the data centers and the crypto companies. And they find workarounds and walkarounds for zoning. So, I watched a few of their webinars. I watched a few of their sneaky little practices and incorporated those with everything that I'd sent you. So, I mean, everything in the proposed draft was good as far as it has everything in there. The only difference was the upon decommission, they have to have approval either by DES or any other regulatory Commission that's applicable. And it has to be someone who is, and I guess DES would be, they have to be knowledgeable. Clark: Well, so April put together a significant packet of proposals for an ordinance and I went through it and streamlined it and neaten it up and just made a very basic clean line version of it. So I'll go through them real quick. I started off by defining everything. Since this is not a common thing in most ordinances yet, I just went ahead and set definitions in there. And then I went straight from there into permitted locations. The very first thing would be in my mind, if we want to limit it, just say it's industrial zoning only. You don't get to put it in commercial areas. You don't get to put it in residential areas. And if you look at A1, it says data centers shall be permitted in industrial zone areas and shall be specifically forbidden in unzoned portions of the unincorporated areas of the county. Because, as you know, the county has no zoning at all. Which has no use regulations. So this would prevent that from, you know, somebody picking an old farm out in the middle of nowhere deciding to try and put a data center on it. They could still, of course, come before you and request a change of zoning to industrial, but you have no obligation to grant or deny that. You can do that as you see fit. So by making it industrial, it will either require them to be located in the industrial park or require them to ask for you to rezone something, one way or the other. A lot of the data that we picked up said, you know, not permitted within of residential zoning. I changed that and put no data setter shall be permitted within 1,000 feet of a single or multifamily residence. The reason I did that is our non-residential zoning districts allow for residential. So you can build a house in a commercial district in Edgefield County. We don't prevent it. Limited commercial, general commercial, rural agriculture, rural residential, they all allow for residential, single family residential buildings, at least. So, in my mind, you could then have a house next to a piece of property that's zoned commercial but has a house and then, you know, a data center could come in and build next to that house and because it's not a residential zoning, there would be nothing you could do. So, I just changed it to if there is a residence within a thousand feet, it's a no. Walsh: And the research I've done and people I've talked to, because it's not so much the noise, but it's the vibration that people can feel in their homes from those data centers, people have been affected as much as two miles from those data centers. Clark: Yeah, well, we can't set it to two miles. Walsh: But I'm saying I don't know if a thousand is enough or is there something else in the ordinance where they have to put up some type of wall, not just a vegetative buffer, but some type of wall that's going to... Whitaker: There’s screening, fencing, and... Clark: We have some requirements. Walsh: I'm asking, so that's in there where there's like a solid wall that's going to stop that vibration from, if there is a thousand two feet away. Is that going to stop the resident from hearing the noise and feeling the vibration? So, what type of screening are you looking at? Like a good solid wall? Clark: We have landscape buffers, we have transitional buffers, and then for areas of electrical production or generation, we have wall requirements as well. Clark: So now if you are you are any of your electrical mechanical excedra equipment has to be have an eight foot tall wall from the adjoining property or any accessible street. So yeah, it's got to have an eight foot wall around your electrical equipment. Now that's not the whole facility. That's not the whole building, right? Whitaker: It's EMFs and that's why they have such a two mile radius that you have because EMF doesn't go two miles. You know, that's what it's to buffer from that is why I said in here address noise, heat and EMFs. Walsh: I don't think we need to have a wall around the facility or either walls built in such a way where the... Whitaker: I don't think walls stop EMF though. Walsh: Yeah, or what the vibrations from the servers. Whitaker: That's EMFs. Morgan: In that ordinance from DeKalb, I think there was some kind of mission, a section that indicated that they had something to have a buffer or a wall that absorbed. Clark: And I can let you look at that. Yeah, we can look at it. Walsh: Yeah, I think that's, if they've developed something like that, then I think we should look for it. Clark: But we'll go through these. And this is a base. So what I really want you to do is just take this home and scribble on it. And add and subtract and, you know, if you have questions or concerns, highlight those and then bring it back. But I'll continue through some of these other requirements. I already talked about the transitional buffer. Distance has to be measured from buildings, substations, drives, streets, parking lots. Structures are improvements. So anything they build has got to be outside of that transitional buffer. Architectural and landscaping design requirements. Where visible from a publicly accessible road or right away, a medium, major, or campus data center shall have a minimum of 30% of the width of the front facade of any building. At the ground level, consist of fenestrations such as decorated windows, architecturally glazed windows, and painted and applied decorative murals shall be permitted to count towards fenestration requirements. Structures are improvements. So anything they build has got to be outside of that transitional buffer. Architectural and landscaping design requirements. Where visible from a publicly accessible road or right away, a medium, major, or campus data center shall have a minimum of 30% of the width of the front facade of any building. At the ground level, consist of fenestrations such as decorated windows, architecturally glazed windows, and painted and applied decorative murals shall be permitted to count towards fenestration requirements. But only after of actual fenestration has been met. And then I put a little definition in the mural just so it was clear that you can't put a big old advertisement on the side of the building and call that, you know. A minimum of 10% of the width of side and rear facade shall incorporate decorated windows or architecturally glazed windows. And the following materials shall not be utilized on the building facade. Aluminum siding, corrugated steel, vinyl siding, plywood, pressed wood products, synthetic stucco or unfinished concrete block. So don't make a big ugly building. All data centers shall have a unified landscape and architectural elements. Operation requirements, substations, electrical yards, mechanical yards and any other exposed equipment shall not be located between the building and a publicly accessible road or right-of- way and shall be screened from any adjacent publicly accessible street, private street, trail or park. All lighting other than the and street pedestrian scale lighting shall have a dark sky design. There shall be no spillover from fixtures on the surrounding properties, including the streets. All lights and poles shall have a permanent black finish. All cooling and ventilation equipment within property boundaries shall operate on a closed loop system. This is extremely important. We produce two to three million gallons of water a day in total. Without a closed loop system and data centers can use that by themselves in a day. So that's one of the reasons why we're not terribly concerned about data centers right this minute, because we couldn't supply them what they want anyway. But closed loop system prevents a lot of wasted water, a lot of wasted water. Walsh: That and that water picks up toxins. And we don't want that flushed into our environment. Whitaker: So, do you have anything in here about a recycling center for the water that is trashed? It was in here, is it not? Clark: OK, so later on in there, there is some discussion about anything that has to be recycled and what you have to do with it. And there's also a section that I added. Before any approval from Edgefield County, all environmental approvals from the South Carolina Department of Environmental Services will have to be submitted to us. So they will have to have all those plans and all of their other things, like specifically generator requirements. They can't make up power with generators. So they require obscene amounts of electricity. And in some places, they literally run generators all the time to produce extra power. Well, that's not allowed. This will prevent them to only use generators for emergency electrical supply. And the only thing that's allowed is testing, and I'll get into that in a second. Whitaker: On the D, when you said the appropriate approvals, does that include the acoustical study? Clark: So that's a separate thing, but I'll go into that in just a second. Because that's not a DES thing, so I had to write that separately. Cooling, ventilation and other external equipment used and operated by the facility shall not be located between building and public access right-of- ways unless located on rooftop of any data-centered development or building within the property boundaries. Substates associated with the operation of data centers shall be subject to the following requirements. Shall be 50 feet from any public right-of-ways. Screen with a minimum eight-foot-tall wall from any adjoining property or publicly accessible street. Substation shall not involve the storage of any vehicle or service equipment. Generator maintenance requirements. Any generator on the property shall comply with at least Tier 4 EPA emission standards. Testing of these generators shall not exceed 10 hours per month. Testing for these generators shall not occur between the hours of 9 a.m. And 5 p.m. Wait. Shall only occur between the hours of 9 a.m. And 5p.m. Generators shall be enclosed by a sound attenuation for noise reduction and to reduce pollution. Except for generator testing or commissioning activities, generator use is limited to backup and emergency use only. All applicants for a data center, in addition to any other application requirements of this code, must provide the following information. Applicants shall provide a letter of intent from the relevant utility provider confirming that preliminary coordination has occurred service to the proposed facility is technically feasible subject to final engineering review. A noise impact assessment shall be required as part of the permitting process for any proposed data center development and assessed at a distance of 500 feet from the data center development. The noise impact assessment shall define the scope of the assessment, including the geographic area, the noise sources of the study, and the specific objectives of the assessment for the proposed development. Measured pre-operation at noise or the existing background noise before any server equipment is installed and provide acoustic mitigation strategies if noise level is proposed to exceed 60 decibels during any hour of the day or night once equipment for the data center development is in operation. And this has to come before the final approval. So this is part of the application process for the final approval. Water consumption and sustainability plan. A water consumption and sustainability plan shall address conservation and scarcity outlying the total water requirements of the data center including pooling needs and any strategies to reduce or mitigate excessive water usage. The plan shall demonstrate the water usage, shall not significantly strain the county's water supply. Energy consumption and sustainability plan. An energy consumption sustainability plan shall contain the estimated energy load before construction and the daily operation load once constructed. This assessment shall outline estimates of peak electricity demands and strategies for mitigating strain on the local power infrastructure. Proposed improvements are alternatives to minimize the need for addition transmission lines and the designated power provider. The use of sustainable alternatives for on-site water or power generation, such as solar panels, rooftop cisterns, small- scale wind turbines, or other renewable energy sources, which shall offset at least 10% and total power and water usage, a decommissioning plan. Walsh: I just want to make sure. Are you saying they are required to use? Yes. And it has to provide at least 10%? Correct. OK. Because some of the studies I've read are saying that those types of renewable energy sources, it looks like they can't get 1-2% of power. I'm happy with that 10% I think that's what might be unattainable for them, but that's fine with me. Clark: I think it depends on their size. When you say data center, everybody thinks ginormous 250,000 square foot facility running 7.5 megawatts worth of servers, but that's not necessarily the case. Data centers can be 5000 square feet. They can be the size of a county building. And still have huge electrical and water needs, but not seven megawatts. You know what I mean? So I think it addresses large-scale and small-scale. And we can finagle the numbers. And I'm sure county council will want to finagle numbers. I'm sure that they're going to send this to Will Williams right off the get-go. And he's going to make a lot of recommendations to the council. Whitaker: But this covers basically tier 1 through tier 4. Clark: Yes. But this is, like I said, this is where I think is a starting point for something that's basic protections that are not going to get us in trouble with the state, they're not going to get us in trouble with the feds, and they do prevent, you know, some big tract of land out in the middle of nowhere getting bought up and turned into a data center. And I think that's the fear, and I think that's the goal. A decommissioning plan in the event the data infrastructure is not sold or transferred, for recycling of all on-site electronic infrastructure through certified recyclers that follow the responsible recycling R2 standard for electronic recyclers and e-stewards. Transmission line impact assessment. This is the primary reason why we don't really have to be in a hurry. We have two transfer lines in the county. We have a Dominion one that serves our industrial park, which could not power half of a small data center. We have the Santee Cooper Line in the north side of the county, which, what is that one, 5 megawatts at the most? Yeah. So we don't have a whole lot of major power infrastructure in the county. Now, that's not saying a company the size of Amazon can't come in and make new lines or build new power plants or do all sorts of other things if you've got $190 billion I'm pretty sure you can afford to change out some power lines. Morgan: The one you just read prior to that, that's what she was mentioning earlier, that once they do that, and they gain approval for the decommissioning, and they've done it properly, they have to give us some kind of copies of where it's done. All of the electronics. Yes, the standards, or whoever standards that they have. Whitaker: Or any regulatory. Walsh: I mean, if they quit using the facility and they have to clean it up. Morgan: Correct, and that way we have that in our records that they decommissioned it, it was done correctly, and we have a copy of whoever certified that they did it correctly. Clark: But regardless of our current transmission line size, I did put in there, transmission line impact assessment shall identify the need for new or upgraded transmission lines to meet the data center's electricity requirements. The assessment shall include the potential environmental impact on public land, including tree removal from county-owned land, and rights of way. The plan shall also include information on the plan's substation location, shall show the screening mechanisms, which shall include a minimum of eight-foot-tall deck or brick wall that's potentially visible by the public. Before final approval, Edgefield County, all stormwater and environmental approvals from the South Carolina Department of Environmental Services will be submitted to the Planning director. Any additional information required by Edgefield County's Planning Department shall be submitted before the application is deemed completed. The owner and operator is required to submit an annual compliance report that details any changes to and continuation of all assessments submitted with an application demonstrating compliance and monitoring of all application requirements and conditions of zoning to the County Planning Director no later than the 1st of January of each year, and the burden of showing compliance with supplemental regulations and or conditions of zoning is is on the applicant and the owner of the property or use. So this is the start. This is the basic road map. It has... I don't think that the state would consider this to be too restrictive. I think that they would probably consider that everything in there is technically feasible. If we find out differently, then we can address that. If there are things that you want to add, subtract, change, write that out. But I think it gives us a starting point. And I'll be honest with you. I wrote this with some basic knowledge and about 45 minutes of reviewing her research in the data centers. So there's probably a lot more to it than, you know, my understanding, which is why I'm saying, you know, this is a base map. Whitaker: But it falls within all the, I went from Georgia, Virginia, and South Carolina, what is right here right now, and went through quite a few of their ordinances as well. And it covers pretty much everything that you've covered. But I will say, if you don't have crypto mining, set aside. And you've got to do that because that's one of the ways that they do get around. Clark: Do you want me to just add that as a definition? Whitaker: I want it to be proposed data center slash crypto mining because it's going to be the same type operation and have the same requirements. Walsh: So the other problem that I see is that people who already have these data centers in their communities are facing rate increases on electricity, and I know that's a utility company thing. So for us to work out any type of a deal between the data center and the can we on a county level do anything about, you are going to charge it to the data center, you are not going to charge it to our residents, increasing their rates for electricity just because now they are sucking up more electricity. You are not going to increase rates for residents. Or is that a state level? Because I think Georgia's looking, I think they're looking at that right now. Whitaker: However, the completely absurd thing is Georgia is inviting data centers to come. They are putting out advertisements and everything else. One of their Planning persons, I watched him just the other day, he says, if you have a data center and you need it operational, bring it to Georgia. We'll welcome you, which is, I mean, I was floored. Caddell: Well, that's good for us. Whitaker: That's good for us. Whitaker: But it was just, but now on the other hand, Virginia, Loudoun County was one of the first places to get a data center. Clark: I'm sure Georgia would love to move Silicon Valley to Georgia. Whitaker: But Loudoun County is having trouble right now. And people are having a problem with aquifers and things like that. But they were the first ones to jump on board and say bring them here. OK, you got it. Clark: I think all that we can really say is give us a study on the anticipated impact. I don't think we can, on a state level, require the power company or the developer to do anything regarding rates. I mean, we can ask for a study that says hey how big of an impact do you think we will have. Morgan: But is there anything that dominion, there's no guarantee that? Walsh: Yeah. I think the Georgia legislature is stepping in, and they're proposing something. I think Georgia doesn't have a Commission as we do. I think in Georgia, it's the legislators, the hospital, and the utilities. But I think they're looking at something about... Clark: I'm pretty sure Aiken Co-op just raised weights. Morgan: And their plan is supposed to show us where they can mitigate the strain that it causes. So I don't know to what degree we should, you know, require them. Walsh: We probably need to start putting pressure on the Utility Commission to make sure that, you know, get it done statewide. Because I don't know how much power we have as a county to prevent those rate increases for our residents if a data center moves in here. Because it shouldn't be a strain on our citizens because we've allowed a data center in here and now their housing costs have gone up because they're paying higher electrical rates. Clark: Like I said, I'm sure that we can require the study, but I'll talk with Scott and see how the state level Commission functions on that. He's the government rep for Dominion Energy, so he deals with them. So he'll probably be able to tell us what the regulations on the state level are for that. Walsh: And then I got to listen to I think it's Colleton County. They have a proposed data center. I don't know if it was a workshop like this or a public hearing or whatever, but they're complaining because they told their economic development authority that they were bringing so many jobs in, but it was really just construction workers and then once it was built, it wasn't the jobs that they were promised. But the data center company made it sound like the jobs would be permanent. And so now you're going to have people earning higher incomes, building houses. It's going to be a tax benefit for the county. Clark: I'm sure their 10 employees get paid well. Whitaker: The most employees at a data center that was in the records for 24, 25 was 30. And that was on the high side. Walsh: That's the mega size. But I think the one in Bettis Academy is going to be like 10 to 12. Clark: And I would say that's probably pretty typical. You need a security guard, a janitor, and you need a couple of people to take care of the machines. But they run themselves. And the people who manipulate the data in the machines, while they're working from anywhere in the world, they don't need to be there on site to do that. They could be in an office building in California and tell it to do something from there. And it'll do it. So from a revenue standpoint, they're not a bad thing. Those buildings are extremely valuable. It was the Aiken one, $368 million, something like that. So I mean, from a revenue standpoint, they're great. But they use, from my perspective, their power usage is just, it's phenomenal. I mean, if they keep building them even as they are now, we're going to have rolling blackouts. I don't see how you keep building things of that size without building power plants. Whitaker: And not to mention, I mean, you look at 17 trillion gallons of water globally just for the data centers that are online right now. 17 trillion gallons. There are 345 trillion gallons of water on the planet right now. How long is that going to sustain? Clark: Well, I know we don't. Edgefield County will never provide water for a non-closed-loop system. The bigger ones take 3 million gallons a day. Well, that's our whole production. Walsh: So they have to cool all that equipment. Whitaker: And now they make them capture the evaporation and then they turn that back into water. Clark: It reduces it by 70%. So closed loop system, not so bad, but just straight up using water and yeah, that's not, we would never be able to sustain that. We'd have to build five more water plants. We would suck all the water out of the Savannah. Walsh: Well, Georgia might be doing it. They keep adding data centers over there. Clark: They might. Morgan: And this is just for y'all to look at when you go back and pick the ordinance apart. It's just basic information about data centers, the power, how much power they use, and how much water they use. And this is an environmental and energy study institute. It breaks it down as well. So if y'all want to look at any of that while you're picking through that. Walsh: Well, we'll go back to the mass grading. This is from Anderson County. They include language about mass grading in their tree preservation ordinance. So I handed each of y'all a copy. If we could maybe study If we could study this some more. I had more information on the printout, but we lost electricity at my house today, so I couldn't print it off. But I'd like for us to look at this too, some of this language. I know nobody's had a chance to really read it. But if we could read it, study it, and see what language is in there, we could incorporate it for mass grading. This works with their tree preservation. So I was thinking it had language that we could use to work with our tree preservation on mass grading. And I want to make another comment about the terraced grading. I think it was mentioned one time. I think there's one or a few properties in Mount Vintage that have used this terraced grading, but the worst example I've seen was a Stanley Martin neighborhood in Graniteville. They did terraced grading, so it was, if y'all are familiar with North Augusta, and the Pisgah, the roads around North Augusta High School, and the hills, right? So that is a split-level housing neighborhood because of the slopes, because the builders back then with the topography of the land. And so right now we've got developers that, it's more expensive, foundations are more expensive to build like that, rather than just finding a way to flatten it out and pour a slab. Well, there's a road like that in Clairborne in Graniteville, and they did that terraced grading. But you'll have the house's foundation wall right here, and the grading comes all the way up to the wall. There's not three inches from that concrete slab. There's not three inches where it drops down 15 for the next house. And they wouldn't even put up, my buyer asked, would you put up a retaining wall and backfill it so I have more room? Nope, you can do that after you buy the house. But to me, we have a 15-inch deluge like we did before the hurricane. I don't know how you're not going to have erosion when you don't have... Yeah, when you have a concrete pad, and then you can't even walk in the side yards because they are so steep, and I just don't think that's a safe place. A safe, good way for us to allow builders. Clark: But we don't need that. I'm not going to have any significant slope within 10 feet of a building. But I do see what you're saying. When it comes to mass grading, though, I'm going to defer mostly to David on this kind of stuff, simply because I'm not very familiar with things like tree preservation and mass grading. Not exactly my area expertise. Caddell: I think you need to ask yourselves what your issue is with mass grading because everyone has a different issue with it. Walsh: I think my issue is if we allow mass grading and changing of the topography, we create flooding in areas that used to not flood, and maybe you've got existing homes that aren't in a flood zone, but they are now because we have allowed a developer next to that neighborhood to go in and do mass grading and change the topography. Caddell: You're removing the eight horizon soils, you have all subsoils as compacted. Even if it's sodded, it runs off faster. Right, right. Walsh: And so it creates flooding where there wasn't flooding before. And again, as far as preserving the naturalness of, especially Edgefield County, we're hilly, right? We're the foothills of the foothills. So I think what I'm looking for is developers to respect the topography and not just completely flatten it out because it's cheaper to build on it, right? But let's respect our natural topography and not create problems for somebody else, you know, for a neighboring parcel, because they've gone in and they've done mass grading and changed the topography. And I know even my house, my room addition, when we dug down a little bit more so my husband could have his basement, you know, we have water seeping, water seeps out of the ground, and we had to do things to mitigate that, you know, for the room. Caddell: Well, I think that's one of the big objections. The other one is just the aesthetics of it. The uniformity of low-grade terrace with the same home over and over and over again and again and again, and every bit of vegetation is gone. If the tree preservation ordinance goes through, as is, then y'all will have struck a pretty large blow to mass grading because it would be almost cost-prohibitive for a developer to reinstate 30% vegetation to get the density that they would need to. So you will have struck a blow for overall subdivision mass grading, but it is true that within the developed area, there may be areas that are graded for homes on slabs. That is how developers want to build. And I don't think the tree ordinance would stop that. It would prevent large-scale cut-and-fill across an entire property. So if you want to stop that, you do need to add mass-grading language. Whitaker: What constitutes mass grading? Caddell: It's just whole-scale stripping and grading of the land, cut and fill. You cut the high points, you fill the low points. Clark: You pan it until it's flat. Caddell: Right, and not necessarily flat across the whole property, but you have flat areas. And to some extent, That's good. If you have an old eroded ravine, then stormwater runs slower over flat land. So you want to grade that area. It slows it down. It's good for the environment. In terms of storm flow, the steeper the slope, the more velocity is picked up. But the way it's been done a lot in North Augusta is that every inch of topsoil is gone. You've done construction on these lots, you've built the house, you have compacted B Horizon soil with no, not a bit of nutrients in it, no drainage, and then you roll sod on it, and typically, they smooth the sod with an asphalt roller, which, it makes no sense. And you see water seeping out from underneath the sod. So I actually like some of the language in the handout you gave. And there are two points here. It says land- disturbing activity in an area greater than 20 at any given time, mass grading, or the practice of clearing and grading more than 15 lots concurrently. I think language like that could be played with a little bit, and you could add language about a requirement for topsoil preservation, where if there's a section, if you want to grade a spot for six homes, then you strip the topsoil, you preserve it, you grade it, and you build the homes, and you replace the topsoil prior to landscaping. Things of that nature. So I think you could play with language like that. I don't think removing a developer's ability to build homes on slab foundations. I'm an environmental person. I like homes with crawl spaces. I like trees in every yard. But there's also the cost of home ownership for people and being able to build homes at an affordable price, especially for new families. You have to consider that in this. But I can tell you, and again, this is y'all's show here. I'm not on the Planning Commission. But y'all just struck a significant blow to large-scale subdivision mass grading, as you see in areas of North Augusta, if the tree preservation ordinance goes through. Because that buffer doesn't come close to the 30%. There are a lot more trees that have to be present within that subdivision. But you could embed some language to limit the areas of mass grading within the development if you wanted to. That's not a bad idea. I don't think two separate ordinances are needed. I think you could deal with it in one. Really. I think they get in the way of each other. Walsh: Honestly. Yeah, that's what, I mean, what little bit I was able to look through this, I felt like that they had incorporated it in with their tree preservation. Coordinates pretty well. And I tried to hit areas that the tree preservation alone won't cover. Caddell: When I was the stormwater manager in North Augusta, I pushed a mass grading ordinance there that embedded a tree preservation section, sort of the opposite of what you're trying to do here. And the Planning Commission at the time shot me down on that. They're a little less environmentally friendly than y'all are. But I can just tell you, I really got into the weeds and this stuff about 12, 15 years ago. And what you have sent to the council already is far and above what they have in North Augusta. Yeah, they have some strict regulations about which roads you can plant in front of your house. And they have street trees, which are next to worthless environmentally, and they damage infrastructure. Walsh: Yeah, they're having to take down all those cypress trees down. And I'm like, why would anybody put a tree that grows that large next to a sidewalk and buildings? Clark: There is a way to successfully do street trees and parking lot trees, etc. The problem is they don't ever want to give more than four feet or six feet. You need to give, I mean, however big your canopy on that tree is going to be, that's where your roots are going to expand as well. So, you know, you can't just say I'm going to give it a four foot. Caddell: I reviewed the plans when they proposed those cypress trees. I was on staff then, and I said they needed two more feet in the landscape planning median and a tree root barrier. And the city caved on both of those requests. Staff knew it. I tried to listen to the staff. That didn't happen then and there. Yes, it could have been stopped. So they spent tens of thousands of dollars to remove trees that had roots in people's yards. Clark: That's another thing with like North Augusta. They adopt, they basically adopt those trees. They do. They take them. And then now the taxpayer is responsible for it. I don't want that. Caddell: Every tree they have to replace comes from select trees and it costs the taxpayers of North Augusta $600 and then guy waters it twice a week. So we don't want to do that. And we took the best of what they had. And they do have some good language there. We took the best of what Clemson had and the Forestry Commission. And April found some really incredible language in here that's very protective. So I think y'all are moving in the right direction. Yes. And embed some mass grading language in there, that would be okay. We can't kill affordable housing. That wouldn't be fair to home buyers. But I think the objection I get when I get calls, and it may be different than what y'all get, is that I'm driving by the subdivision, it looks horrible, there's not a stick of vegetation out there. It's the same model house over and over again. And in our talks, I know you have a 25-foot buffer around the sides and the back on the main road frontage, you have a 50-foot buffer. So there will be a 50-foot wooded buffer with large trees, medium trees, small trees, and shrubs protecting the view. So yes, you'll see houses. But you won't see what you see in some of our subdivisions now. And that's a big deal. Walsh: I think so. I mean, trees are good for cleaning the air, and shade, and cooling the earth, and noise. I mean, and aesthetically more pleasing. Caddell: And by planting natives, you're putting in mass trees for wildlife. So you've got wildlife corridors and everything else. Burt: See, in my picture, even a backyard needs a buffer. That's my picture of it. I'm just thinking to myself that when I go down to Chapin and all this, I get sick. It's like a killing. Why do you want to buy something that isn't there? And you just see higher and higher and higher. Because, for example, when you're the third and natural, you're never the same anymore. Just like all this steel and stuff you got to put in concrete, back in the day, we didn't have to do that because we didn't disturb nature. Now, for example, how many of you ever go out to the Savannah Lake? See, they left the natural. You build on whatever you've got. And that's the way it should be. Walsh: We need to respect our natural habitat and build within our natural habitat and not change it so much when we're negatively affecting everything around it and other parcels around it. And I'm seeing that too much with these new subdivisions, some of these new subdivisions. I understand housing affordability, but they're also taking a lot away from what it means to own your own house and have your own property. Now you can't modify it really the way you want to. Burt: Thank you. Meeting Adjourned at 6:07 pm The next Planning Commission Meeting is scheduled for February 12, 2026. The Planning Commission is scheduled to meet on the second Thursday of each month at 5:00 p.m. for a work session meeting and at 6:00 p.m. for the regular meeting at the Edgefield County Council Chambers located at 225 Jeter St., Edgefield, SC. These meetings are subject to prior cancellation or change. The public will be notified of any cancellation or change. Individuals requiring special assistance or a sign interpreter to participate in the meeting are asked to notify the Building & Planning Department 48 hours prior to the meeting at (803) 637-4073. Any questions regarding the Planning Commission should be directed to the County’s Planner, April Morgan, at amorgan@edgefieldcounty.sc.gov Respectfully Submitted December 11,2025 Approved April Morgan Fab Burt

Source: Edgefield County website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.