PC WS Minutes_20240808
Edgefield County · Edgefield County · meeting of Dec 5, 2024 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Edgefield County
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Edgefield County
PLANNING COMMISSION
Work Session Minutes
County Council Chambers
August 8, 2024
5:00 PM
1
The Edgefield County Planning Commission Work Session was held on Thursday August 8th,
2024, at the Edgefield County Council Chambers at 225 Jeter Street in Edgefield at 5:00
pm. Notice of the time date and agenda of this meeting was provided to The Edgefield
Advertiser, placed on the Message Board outside Council Chambers, and provided to others
when requested. Any questions regarding the Planning Commission should be directed to
the County’s Planner April Morgan Amorgan@edgefieldcounty.sc.gov
Members present:
Fab Burt,
Lisa Whitaker,
Tracy Walsh,
Sharon Hadden,
David Hair,
Dustin Doolittle,
Karlene Butler
Members absent:
No Members Absent
Staff present:
April Morgan,
Hart Clark,
County Council members present:
No County Council Members Present
Guest Speakers:
No Guest Speakers
I. Call to Order
Burt called the meeting to order at 5:00 pm.
II. Old Business
2
Burt begins be explaining they will be discussing the final review prior to the
public hearing and vote on changes to the Comprehensive Plan, the Land Use
map, the zoning map changes for RA zoning district, the expansion of the
Overlay Districts, and the changes to requirements in the Overlay Districts.
Morgan explains that in front of the commissioners is the Zoning Map and
Land Use Map reflecting everything discussed last month as far as areas
wishing to be proposed to County Council if approved. Morgan asks if the
Commissioners have any questions or requests to change anything on the
maps or if they are okay with what is being shown. Clark explains that this
also includes a packet including any other Comprehensive Plan updates
previously discussed and have already been voted on. Clark explains that this
Comprehensive Plan update will be passed along to Council to go through the
three hearings and once approved they will not have to do another update
for another five years. The Zoning Map will also be passed along to County
Council who will decide if they want to split the map into sections to vote on
the zoned areas or if they will do the entire recommended map all at once.
Morgan introduces the idea of a tree preservation ordinance for “Trophy” and
“Grand” trees which are trees over a certain diameter, a certain species, etc.
The change would be not only enforcing this in the Highway Corridor in the
Comprehensive Plan but everywhere in the case of Commercial, Industrial
and Subdivisions. In addition to landscaping in major subdivisions, adding
the Tree Preservation. Clark adds that we could also create a mass grading
ordinance that prevents developers from going to a piece of land and
flattening it. He does explain that he has seen this ordinance unsuccessful in
surrounding areas such as North Augusta, but has also seen it successful in
jurisdictions such as Hilton Head. In that case, it would prevent all mass
grading. He opinionates that if there is a strong tree preservation ordinance
there should be some form of a mass grading ordinance in place in cases
such as if a developer has 20 trees that must be preserved on a property but
mass grading is allowed, they could simply remove those trees and replace
them with the exact number of inches of trees. He continues that over the
course of years, this turns out nice when the trees have grown but if the goal
is to truly preserve existing trees they would need to prevent mass grading.
Doolittle expresses concern that subdivisions are replanting trees that are
different species that do not grow as large. Morgan explains that along with
that there would be a list of native species trees that would be adopted. Hair
explains that he would like to see in subdivisions the trees remain rather
than be removed and replaced. Clark explains that there will have to be
some sort of exceptions for some grading to be allowed for cases like DHEC
delineations, but there should be some ordinance on not allowing mass
grading if they would like to have a tree preservation ordinance as they go
hand and hand.
Walsh agrees that she would like to see both a mass grading ordinance and a
tree preservation ordinance. She explains that in other counties that are
allowing mass grading they are having flooding issues that have never had
flooding issues before. She explains that Edgefield County is hilly and hard to
find a flat lot, but that is the natural topography of the land and if we allow
mass grading that could affect the creeks, streams and tributaries that feed
3
into the larger bodies of water like Steven’s Creek or Savannah River and
could potentially create flooding issues that could have been prevented by
not allowing mass grading.
Clark agrees that it is important to remember that Shaw’s Creek and
Steven’s Creek are our primary water sources to supply Edgefield County
Water and Sewer Authority as well as Aiken County depends on Shaw’s
Creek. He explains that there is environmental protection for both of these
very important watersheds however erosion is always a concern. He
continues that one of the big key things with Tree Preservation is not to
simply save the Pine Trees, however to save the large trees that do not get
commonly replaced such as Magnolia Trees. He agrees that it is important to
state specific trees that are significant trees to our environment, and if they
must be removed than the same tree must be replaced not just any tree.
Also, a percentage should be in place for removal so that not all trees are
removed. For example, if a developer decides that they wish to put a home
in an area of these protected trees, they could not remove all of the trees
however they could remove 10%-20% (whatever percentage is decided) that
are most in the way and they will work around the rest. This would also
make it impossible to mass grade.
Whitaker asks if it is possible to have something like a buffer zone for the
neighborhood itself and that the trees could not be removed.
Clark explains that most of the time on rear property lines in a development
the developer will leave the natural trees, however the front property line
they remove all trees to bring their equipment in. He states that if there is a
tree preservation, you would make sure that all significant trees, buffers, and
green space be left untouched mandatorily. He continues that you could get
a percentile option to remove significate trees that will have to be replaced.
It would be fine if they were allowed to plant those in green spaces and in
buffer yards, but to make a subdivision look really good you have to have
some spaced on in the yards. The only problem is once it turns from being
developer owned to privately owned by an individual, that would take our
control out. This would mean that the required number of trees should be put
in the buffer yards and greenspace areas to prevent homeowners from
cutting down trees and taking the subdivision out of compliance. One thing
that can be done is with the 30% of greenspace requirement already in
place, it can be specified that this 30% cannot be all in one place but rather
spread out in common spaces throughout the subdivision. Clark continues
that his other concern with landscape requirements is that it almost will
necessitate and irrigation requirement which can be complicated. He explains
that you would imagine a developer would know if they plant trees, they will
know to irrigate it to keep it alive, however they do not always take this into
consideration and trees will die. Clark explains that he does check behind and
gives the instance of the new Frito Lay development where they had
temporary irrigation and he made it clear that if the irrigation was removed
and trees had died the tree would have to be replanted or a stop work order
will be placed. He continues that there should be something in place that
states until the trees are established there should be some sort of irrigation
in place. Clark recommends that they gather the preservation and
4
landscaping ordinances from other jurisdictions that are successful and refer
to them while writing and editing them for Edgefield County.
Burt explains that it can take 50-60 years of an Oak Tree to grow and they
cannot be replaced in the same way they were before removed.
Clark explains that he understands that logging is a big revenue in Edgefield
County and that he does not wish to disturb that but at the same time, if
something is not done to protect natural forest it will cease to exist at some
point and that is one of the beautiful things about Edgefield County.
Walsh asks if it was mentioned to put in that ordinance that if they replant,
they must plant trees that native to the Piedmont Region, Clark verifies this.
Walsh agrees with this because of the problems with the Bradford Pears
which are sterilizing some of our natural tree species meaning that we are
losing some of our natural trees.
Clark lets commissioners know that with Bradford Pears, Clemson has begun
a program where they will pay an individual to remove the tree and replace
the tree with a native species.
Clark continues that it would be specified that if a developer cut down 30
inches of Magnolia Trees, 30 inches of Magnolia Trees would need to be
replaced.
Burt explains that with replacing trees they need to be bare rooted instead of
leaving the cloth sack on the tree. Clark agrees that the root rot from
planting trees in the cloth sack will eventually kill a tree from what he has
heard. He continues to agree that this is the sort of things they should look
into while creating these ordinances.
Clark explains that he believes the next thing Morgan will begin to work on
will be the Landscaping, Tree Preservation, and Mass Grading ordinances.
Burt explains in a subdivision they should grade only where they house goes.
Clark states that there are excuses for not doing that such as wanting to
build a slab house, he explains that there are elevated slabs and that those
excuses are unacceptable as you could build a foundation wall and backfill.
Hadden explains that at exit one off of I-20 they have completely flattened
the landscape and there is not a tree left.
Clark explains that is exactly why mass grading and tree preservation should
go hand in hand.
Doolittle asks about what if they wish to develop an old timber tract that has
no significant trees. Clark explains that they would have to meet the
landscaping ordinance that specifies a certain number of trees must be
planted or present.
Hadden asks if this would affect individuals as well as developers. Clark
explains that this could be decided upon by commissioners if it is only for
major subdivisions and commercial or if a land owner has significant Oak
Tree on their property that they do not disturb it. If the commissioners
decide to then they could exclude individual land owners.
Doolittle asks what it would mean for farmers wishing to extend their farm if
it was a County wide ordinance.
Clark explains that agriculture is sort of protected as they are not required to
make land development applications often. It would only affect them if they
had to receive a Land Development Permit, for example Sara’s Farm
5
Adventure. Even then, they could come to the Planning Commission and ask
for a variance. Another option is simply exempting agriculture.
Walsh asks what is considered a major subdivision. Clark explains that five
lots or more is a major subdivision, or creation of a road is a major
subdivision. This is unless it is exempt. The state law states that any lot that
does not create a road that is five acres or more means it is an exempt lot.
Creation of a road would be using an easement for more than two homes.
Clark explains that there have been situations where there is a flag lot that
shares an easement for two homes already and there is another lot that
applies for a building application for a home that will create a named road
however since it is an existing lot and they are not splitting up new lots it
normally does not come to planning commission.
Walsh asks if when a private road is established if there is a private road
maintenance agreement. Clark verifies that they are required to sign a
private road maintenance agreement signed by every property owner on that
land and it will be recorded and filed.
Walsh explains that is good because with real estate she runs into issues with
private roads often.
Clark explains that they must have a 50 foot right of way with a 20 foot
drivable surface to try to prevent any issues.
Morgan explains she will send a list from the National Nursey and
Landscaping Association and it will have the native species and mirror
surrounding Counties and Jurisdiction and if the commissioners wish to
shorten the list they can. She continues that she would like for the
commissioners to look into commercial entry landscaping, not just in an
Overlay District but for all commercial. She shows examples of businesses in
Edgefield County and shows the difference with the landscaping and buffer
and without either. She explains that the businesses without are
grandfathered in and cannot be forced to change their landscaping. She
explains that they can require different buffers for different types of
commercial and gives the example of having a denser buffer for uses such as
open storage. She explains currently for large scale retail in the overlay
district, there is an Evergreen screening hiding the store while that would
look better in commercial businesses like the tanker trucks and having
instead type one or two buffers in front of retail.
Doolittle asks if we could change the tree type from Evergreen for that
screening, Morgan and Clark clarify we could exclude any trees or request
certain trees if they wish.
Walsh asks if this would apply to individual land owners, Morgan clarifies it
would only be extended from the Highway Overlay Districts to cover
commercial throughout the County and will not affect the residential.
Clark explains that with a list of trees and shrubs allowed could also be
applied to the buffer yard requirements.
Morgan shows that in parking lots there could be an ordinance of having so
many tree islands per amount of spots. She continues that the
commissioners could go from one extreme to the next.
Whitaker asks if staff will prepare these ordinances for them to review, and
Morgan explains she will send the list of trees and what she has to
6
commissioners for them to review and edit as they please for buffer
requirements, landscaping, tree preservation, entrance landscaping and mass
grading. She explains she will create a working folder so as it is worked on
they can refer and update it.
Clark explains that these ordinances can be complicated and may take time
to complete and perfect. He continues that he does not see reasoning for
opposing, however we want to have some protection for greenery.
Morgan explains that they heard discussions from a meeting with another
jurisdiction about how they regret not having these sorts of ordinances in
place.
Walsh asks if Morgan has seen where in a parking lot there is so many
square feet before implementing these ordinances. She explains that in the
City of North Augusta a church was going to pave a parking lot and ended up
losing half of the parking spots to greenspace. Morgan explains that is
something the commissioners can decide if they want to have a set size
where if the parking lot is so many square feet or smaller it is not required to
have the greenspace and that she will refer to the North Augusta and Aiken
County ordinances on this.
Clark explains that in the Highway Overlay District for Major Retail there are
10 or more parking spaces you must have a landscaping plan for it.
Morgan refers to the buffer in the Highway Overlay District for Major Retail
and recommends that buffer be lessened.
Clark recommends that commissioners recommend any ideas and that he
does not have a concern about state law with these ordinances and he will
review law as well before being voted upon.
III. New Business
No new business.
IV. Adjourn
Whitaker motion to adjourn, Butler second. All voted in favor (7-0)
Burt put the work Session to Adjourn at 5:53 pm.
7
Respectfully Submitted: Approved: December 12, 2024
April Morgan, Planner
Fab Burt-Chairman
Source: Edgefield County website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.