Finance and Administrative Committee — Minutes
Town of Hilton Head Island · Beaufort County · Finance and Administrative Committee · meeting of Sep 14, 2026 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Hilton Head Island
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Town of Hilton Head Island Finance and Administrative Committee
Meeting Minutes
9/14/2026 Page | 1
Town of Hilton Head Island
FINANCE AND ADMINISTRATIVE COMMITTEE
MEETING
Monday, September 14, 2026, 10:00 AM
Minutes
Call to Order
Chair Brown called the meeting to order at 10:00 a.m.
Committee Members Present: Alex Brown, Chair; Patsy Brison, and Melinda Tunner
Other Members of Council Present: Steve Alfred and Tamara Becker
Adoption of the Agenda
Ms. Brison made a motion to adopt. Ms. Tunner seconded. Motion carried 3-0.
Approval of the Minutes
Regular Meeting Minutes of August 10, 2026
Ms. Brison made a motion to adopt. Ms. Tunner seconded. Motion carried 3-0.
Presentations
Town of Hilton Head Island FY2026 End of Year Financial Update - Dave Byrd, Finance
Director
Dave Byrd, Finance Director, presented the Town’s Fiscal Year 2026 End of Year Financial
Update. Mr. Byrd reviewed May sales tax activity and year -end financial results, noting
continued strength in tourism, construction, retail, and other sectors. He discussed several
data anomalies, including a significant one- time retail tax return and an unusually high
telecommunications figure, both of which were being reviewed with the State. Mr. Byrd also
reported that tourism remained strong overall, while short -term rental activity had slowed
somewhat.
Mr. Byrd reviewed the General Fund and reported that actual results were approximately $2.3
million more favorable than projected. Revenue was favorable due in part to property taxes,
local accommodations taxes, business license revenue, insurance broker fees, and investment
income, while EMS revenue was below expectations. General Fund expenditures were
approximately $1.5 million favorable to projection, resulting in an overall General Fund balance
increase of approximately $3.8 million.
Town of Hilton Head Island Finance and Administrative Committee
Meeting Minutes
9/14/2026 Page | 2
Mr. Byrd also reviewed the Capital Improvement Program Debt Service, Stormwater,
Community Development Corporation, Workforce Housing, and Special Revenue Funds. He
highlighted favorable FEMA reimbursements related to beach renourishment, bond premium
revenue, and lower -than-projected CIP expenditures. Finance s taff will continue reviewing
project rollovers and expects to provide updated figures in October. Mr. Byrd noted that the
Town ended FY2026 with a strong overall fund balance position and reviewed historical
revenue trends and treasury/cash management information.
Committee members held discussion and asked questions regarding the General Fund surplus
should be retained in reserves or used to cash-fund the purchase of two ladder fire trucks
rather than financing them through a lease ; the potential $1.1 million in interest savings
associated with purchasing the vehicles and requested that staff provide a clear comparison of
the advantages and disadvantages of purchasing versus leasing ; CIP project rollovers and the
need to better distinguish project authorization from the timing of actual expenditures;
Stormwater fund balance and the need to evaluate future rates; the timing of unused ATAX
grant funds and their availability for future grant cycles; short -term rental permitting data; t he
use of FEMA reimbursements to replenish cash reserves used for beach renourishment ; and
the appreciation for the financial reporting and recognized staff for effective expense
management during FY2026.
Town of Hilton Head Island FY2027 Monthly Financial Update – Dave Byrd, Finance Director
Mr. Byrd provided a high- level update on the Town’s FY2027 financial performance for July.
He explained that the Finance Department is changing the format of its monthly financial
reporting to focus more directly on actual performance compared to the phased monthly and
year-to-date budget rather than emphasizing comparisons to prior -year activity. Mr. Byrd
reported that July revenue was generally in line with expectations and expenses were
favorable, with no significant financial concerns identified. He noted that CIP activity will
continue to require additional explanation because the timing of invoices and project
expenditures can vary significantly. Finance staff will continue updating the CIP snapshot, fund
balance information, and revenue charts as additional information becomes available.
Committee members held discussion and asked questions regarding timing and frequency of
monthly financial reporting and emphasized the importance of receiving timely information
while being mindful of staff workload; support for continuing monthly reporting and noted the
value of phased monthly budgets in evaluating financial performance; and discussed the
potential future use of a more cash- based approach to CIP reporting to better reflect actual
expenditures.
Town of Hilton Head Island Finance and Administrative Committee
Meeting Minutes
9/14/2026 Page | 3
Discussion of Town of Hilton Head Island's Assessment of Public Safety Service Delivery - Bob
Bromage, Director of Public Safety
Bob Bromage, Director of Public Safety, presented the proposed assessment of the Town’s
law enforcement service delivery. Mr. Bromage explained that the assessment is intended to
establish a current service baseline, evaluate the existing service model an d future needs,
examine alternative service- delivery models, and provide findings and recommendations to
Town Council. He emphasized that the assessment is not a recommendation to establish a
Municipal Police Department and does not assume that the existing model should be replaced.
Mr. Bromage explained that the Town’s public safety environment has changed significantly
since the2018 performance audit and the 2000 feasibility study . He noted the growth of the
Town’s public safety responsibilities since the establishment of the Public Safety Department
in 2022 and identified tourism, seasonal activity, traffic, beaches, parks, short -term rentals,
special events, technology, and community expectations as factors affecting service demand.
The proposed assessment would evaluate calls for service, workload, response, staffing and
deployment, proactive activity, traffic demand, seasonal variation, geographic coverage,
specialized resources, community and stakeholder input, facilities, equipment, technology,
legal and governance considerations, transition requirements, recurring costs, and
implementation risks. Three service- delivery alternatives were identified for evaluation: the
current Beaufort County Sheriff’s Office model; a n integrated municipal public safety hybrid
model involving limited specialized services; and a full municipal police department. The
proposed next steps include developing the scope of work and issuing a request for proposals,
selecting a qualified consultant, conducting data collection and stakeholder engagement,
evaluating the alternatives, and presenting findings to Town Council.
Committee members held discussion and asked questions regarding the importance of
conducting an objective, fact -based process without predetermining the outcome; the need for
meaningful community and stakeholder engagement, implementation timelines for each
potential model, performance measures that could be used regardless of the selected service-
delivery model, and providing historical agreements and data to the consultant ; the timing of
the assessment in relation to the upcoming change in Beaufort County Sheriff, the potential
need to address the Town’ s existing law enforcement agreement while the broader
assessment is underway, and the importance of moving quickly enough to address immediate
contractual needs while allowing sufficient time to conduct the assessment properly ; and
members expressed continued support for the Town’s partnership with the Beaufort County
Sheriff’s Office and emphasized that the assessment is intended to provide information needed
for future policy decisions.
Town of Hilton Head Island Finance and Administrative Committee
Meeting Minutes
9/14/2026 Page | 4
Discussion of Town of Hilton Head Island's Public Safety Cost Assessment - Dave Byrd,
Director of Finance
Dave Byrd, Finance Director, presented the financial component of the public safety service
delivery assessment. Mr. Byrd reviewed current Town expenditures related to public safety and
law enforcement and compared those costs with available information regarding Beaufort
County’s police fee and costs associated with peer communities. The presentation included
operating and capital considerations, per -capita comparisons, and information regarding the
County’s police fee structure. Mr. Byrd explained that the Town currently spends approximately
$10.3 million on the identified public safety and law enforcement costs, while the analysis of
comparable communities showed varying levels of spending based on population, service
delivery, and local circumstances. He noted that the peer comparison provides a starting point
for understanding the range of public safety costs but that the eventual assessment will need to
evaluate service levels and costs together.
Committee members held discussion and asked questions regarding the distinction between
the County’s police fee revenue attributable to Hilton Head Island and the Town’s broader
contribution to the County’s G eneral Fund; a request for additional clarification regarding how
the County allocates and spends police fee revenues, whether the fees cover all costs
associated with law enforcement services, and how capital costs, administrative expenses, and
other indirect costs are accounted for ; discussing calculating the per -capita cost of the police
fee and obtaining additional information from Beaufort County regarding historical revenues and
expenditures; any future intergovernmental agreement with Beaufort County should clearly
identify service expectations, revenues, expenditures, and costs rather than operate without
defined financial parameters ; the need to evaluate both operating and capital costs and
expressed the importance of clearly communicating the financial analysis to the public ;
acknowledgment that the cost assessment is an initial step and that future decisions should
consider both the level of service provided and the associated costs; and possibility of pursuing
two parallel efforts: evaluating and potentially revising the Town’s agreement with Beaufort
County while conducting the broader public safety service-delivery assessment.
No action was taken on the discussion item.
At 12:25 p.m., Chair Brown took a brief recess. The meeting resumed at 12:32 p.m.
New Business
Consideration of a Resolution Authorizing the Town of Hilton Head Island to Apply for a Big
Idea Grant to Support a Drone First Responder (DFR) Program, Committing a Local 5% Match
and Confirming Compliance with the Town's Procurement Policy - Michele Bunce, Senior
Grants Administrator
Ms. Bunce presented the request for authorization to apply for a Big Idea Grant to support a
Drone First Responder (DFR) Program, including the required local 5% match and confirmation
of compliance with the Town’s procurement policy.
There was no additional discussion by the Committee.
Town of Hilton Head Island Finance and Administrative Committee
Meeting Minutes
9/14/2026 Page | 5
Ms. Brison made a motion to recommend that Town Council approve the resolution
authorizing the Town to apply for the Big Idea Grant. Ms. Tunner seconded. Motion
carried.
Consideration of a Resolution Authorizing the Town of Hilton Head Island to Apply for a
Problem Solver Grant to Support a Roof Replacement Project for the Fish Haul Beach Park
Restrooms, Committing a Local 5% Match and Confirming Compliance with the Town's
Procurement Policy - Michele Bunce, Senior Grants Administrator
Ms. Bunce presented the request for authorization to apply for a Problem Solver Grant to
support the roof replacement project for the Fish Haul Beach Park restrooms, including the
required local 5% match and confirmation of compliance with the Town’s procurement policy.
There was no additional discussion by the Committee.
Ms. Brison made a motion to recommend approval of the resolution authorizing the Town
to apply for the Problem Solver Grant. Ms. Tunner seconded. Motion carried.
Consideration to Amend a Resolution Adopting and Authorizing the Implementation of the Town
of Hilton Head Island Comprehensive South Carolina Tax (ATAX) Program, Application Process
and Fund Distribution Policy - Dave Byrd, Director of Finance
Mr. Byrd presented proposed amendments to the Town’ s Comprehensive South Carolina
Accommodations Tax (ATAX) Program, Application Process and Fund Distribution Policy. He
explained that the existing policy referenced specific calendar year dates and that the proposed
amendments would remove those date-specific references and make the policy more generally
applicable.
Committee members held discussion and asked questions regarding the proposed
amendments to clarify the responsibilities of the Accommodations Tax Advisory Committee and
to reflect the Town Council’s prior direction regarding the use of unspent ATAX funds ; The
proposed changes included adding language stating that the ATAC proposes ATAX grant
funding recommendations for presentation to the Finance & Administrative Committee and
Town Council; and technical corrections to the ATAX distribution percentages and the treatment
of the initial $25,000 distribution.
Ms. Tunner made a motion to recommend that Town Council amend the resolution
adopting and authorizing implementation of the Town’s Comprehensive South Carolina
ATAX Program, Application Process and Fund Distribution Policy with the proposed
changes. Ms. Brison seconded. Motion carried.
Town of Hilton Head Island Finance and Administrative Committee
Meeting Minutes
9/14/2026 Page | 6
Public Comment - Non Agenda Items
Dave Ferguson addressed the Committee regarding Island Jam and the Town’s financial
support of the event. He raised questions regarding the event’s history, procurement, funding,
attendance, economic impact, and the total cost to the Town. He referenced documents
obtained through a Freedom of Information Act request and expressed concerns regarding the
Town’s use of public funds and the process by which the event has received Town support.
Adjournment
At 12:53 p.m., Chair Brown adjourned the meeting.
Approved: October 12, 2026
The full recording and a transcript of this meeting can be found on the Town’s website
at www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov
Source: Town of Hilton Head Island website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.