RecordWell Data

Community Development and Public Services Committee — Minutes

Town of Hilton Head Island · Beaufort County · Community Development and Public Services Committee · meeting of Aug 10, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from Town of Hilton Head Island

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Town of Hilton Head Island Community Development and Public Services Committee Meeting Minutes 8/10/2026 Page | 1 Town of Hilton Head Island COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT AND PUBLIC SERVICES COMMITTEE MEETING Monday, August 10, 2026, 1:00 PM Minutes Call to Order Chair Becker called the meeting to order at 1:00 p.m. Committee Members present: Tammy Becker, Chair, Ward 4; Steve DeSimone, Ward 3; Steve Alfred, Ward 5 Council Members present: Alan Perry, Mayor; Patsy Brison, Ward 2; Melinda Tunner, Ward 6; Alex Brown, Ward 1, Mayor Pro-Tempore Others Present: Brittany Ward, Town Attorney; Kimberly Gammon, Town Clerk, Sheriff P.J. Tanner, Beaufort County Sheriff Pledge to the Flag Adoption of the Agenda Mr. Alfred moved to approve. Mr. DeSimone seconded. Motion carried 3-0. Approval of the Minutes Regular Meeting Minutes of April 6, 2026 Mr. Alfred moved to approve. Mr. DeSimone seconded. Motion carried 3-0. Special Meeting Minutes of April 28, 2026 Mr. Alfred moved to approve. Mr. DeSimone seconded. Motion carried 3-0. New Business Consideration of an Ordinance to Amend Title 17 of the Municipal Code of the Town of Hilton Head Island to Include a New Section 17-8-111 to Establish the Regulation of a Public Gathering - Brittany Ward, Town Attorney Brittany Ward, Town Attorney, provided the following background regarding the item. On July 9, 2026, during a Town Council Special Meeting, discussions were held in furtherance of the Town Council’s desire to offer a safe environment for all individuals on Hilton Head Town of Hilton Head Island Community Development and Public Services Committee Meeting Minutes 8/10/2026 Page | 2 Island. In discussing options to address concerns of juveniles inciting large group gatherings, the Town Council contemplated the authority to regulate public gatherings and based on the information provided at the July 9, 2026 meeting and the desire to provide citizens and visitors with a safe environment, and in keeping with similar ordinances that have been adopted by other South Carolina communities, the Town Council discussed establishing the regulation of public gatherings as provided for in the ordinance. The Town Attorney explained the ordinance’s intent: to protect public health and safety by defining and restricting crowding or obstructing access on public property, which includes buildings, parks, facilities, and beaches. She noted that other municipalities—such as Greenville, Charleston, and Myrtle Beach—use similar ordinances, typically focused on large gatherings around music venues, performances, or nightlife. The proposed ordinance would amend Title 17 of the Municipal Code of the Town of Hilton Head Island to include a new Section 17-8-111 to establish the regulation of public gatherings and to prohibit and make it unlawful for a person alone or in concert with others to crowd or obstruct Public Property. Committee Members raised multiple concerns: • Vagueness and enforceability: Several members questioned whether the ordinance was too broad and could unintentionally affect legitimate large events such as concerts or political gatherings. • Relevance to July 4th: Some felt the ordinance did not directly address the causes of the July 4th incident. • Law enforcement authority: Sheriff P.J. Tanner addressed the Committee and stated that the Sheriff’s Office did not request this ordinance, believed it to be unconstitutional, and it would not be enforceable by the Beaufort County Sheriff's Office. He clarified that their sole recommendation when he spoke to Town Council on July 9th, had been establishing a curfew, not regulating public gatherings. • Origins of the ordinance: Discussion revealed that the concept had been raised by a council member during the July 9th meeting but had not been formally voted on, and the ordinance was drafted at Council’s direction for consideration only. Additional comments emphasized that any future ordinance must be enforceable, collaboratively developed with law enforcement, and clearly tailored to address the issue Town Council most hopes to mitigate: violent crowd behavior, including fights observed in publicly shared videos from July 4th. Mayor Perry commented that placing the item on the agenda was important to allow transparent public discussion, even if the ordinance ultimately proved unsuitable. Council Member Patsy Brison commented that her intent regarding the proposed public-gatherings ordinance was to address violent crowd behavior seen in recent videos, specifically fights and incitement within large groups. She noted other jurisdictions have tried similar measures and emphasized the need to ensure anything adopted is constitutional. Chair Becker asked if the ordinance only pertained to the beaches. The Town Attorney clarified Town of Hilton Head Island Community Development and Public Services Committee Meeting Minutes 8/10/2026 Page | 3 that the ordinance would apply to all public spaces on the Island, not just beaches. Chair Becker asked if there was public comment. Richard Bisi addressed the Committee to relay that he did not recall Town Council asking for this ordinance and since Sheriff Tanner relayed that the ordinance is unenforceable and likely unconstitutional, it should be scuttled. Skip Hoagland addressed the Committee to ask that they not respond to the criminal actions of a few by restricting thousands of good young people and families who come to Hilton Head Island for summer vacation, and he questioned enforceability of the ordinance and suggested more police presence instead. Mr. Alfred made a motion for the Town Attorney to work with the Beaufort County Sheriff's Office and General Counsel Daniel Gourley of the Beaufort County Sheriff's Office and postpone moving this item forward to Town Council for consideration of approval to an uncertain date, if the Town Attorney, in consultation with the Beaufort County Sheriff's Office and General Counsel Daniel Gourley, should find that the amended Ordinance should be brought to Town Council. Mr. DeSimone seconded. Motion carried 3-0. Consideration of an Ordinance to Amend Title 8 of the Municipal Code of the Town of Hilton Head Island to Include a New Section 8-1-241 to Establish a Juvenile Curfew - Brittany Ward, Town Attorney Brittany Ward, Town Attorney, provided the following background regarding the item. On July 9, 2026, during a Town Council Special Meeting, discussions with Beaufort County Sheriff Tanner were held in furtherance of the Town Council’s desire to offer a safe environment for all individuals on Hilton Head Island. The Beaufort County Sheriff’s Office (“BCSO”) recommended the consideration of a juvenile curfew establishing the authority to hold juveniles and their legal guardian accountable during specific curfew hours. As written, the curfew would apply to individuals under 18 from 9 p.m. to 6 a.m., Thursday through Sunday, during summer months and is specific to Hilton Head Island public beaches. Ms. Ward explained definitions, exemptions, and enforcement considerations, noting the draft was based on prior discussions and input from the Beaufort County Sheriff’s Office. Sheriff Tanner addressed the Committee to say that he strongly supported having a curfew but stated the draft needed changes. He recommended a year-round, daily curfew applying to all public property, not just beaches, to give deputies clear authority to stop and identify juveniles. Without a curfew, deputies cannot legally detain or request ID unless there is reasonable suspicion of a crime. Sheriff Tanner emphasized the curfew would serve mainly as a tool to intervene with unsupervised teens before problems develop. Committee Members raised concerns about age limits, enforcement impacts on well-behaved Town of Hilton Head Island Community Development and Public Services Committee Meeting Minutes 8/10/2026 Page | 4 youth and vacationing families, unintended consequences (such as teens moving to private property instead), and constitutional issues. They also noted that many problematic behaviors seen in recent incidents occurred on private property, where the ordinance would not apply. Overall, the Committee agreed the concept requires significant revision, further collaboration with the Sheriff’s Office, and careful consideration of scope, timing, and impacts before moving forward. Chair Becker asked for public comment. Richard Bisi addressed the Committee regarding public opinion on the curfew, recommendations of the Beaufort County Sheriff's Office to improve safety on public beaches, and expressed the need for more law enforcement and presence. Dave Ferguson addressed the Committee regarding the need to have public safety as an agenda item more often and requested that the community be involved in conversations between Town Council and the Beaufort County Sheriff's Office. Skip Hoagland addressed the Committee to provide them with a draft sample ordinance for public gatherings and juvenile curfews drafted using Artificial Intelligence, which he believes can be used for drafting ordinances as well as other documents, representing a cost savings to free up more funds for law enforcement. Rick Ross addressed the Committee to ask that they not react and enact a juvenile curfew which would unfairly restrict all responsible teens because of the actions of a few and raised concerns about First Amendment assembly rights and pointed out that the curfew would cover only four days a week and only summer months, despite crime occurring year-round, and emphasized that the real issue is criminal behavior—not gatherings—and added that under the ordinance, deputies would have no discretion to leave a well-behaved minor alone after curfew; all must be “returned to sender” and he concluded by thanking the Committee for not advancing the prior version of the ordinance and urged them not to move forward. Steve Robinson addressed the Committee against adopting a juvenile curfew as he believes the curfew would not have prevented the July 4 incident, and he warned that restricting responsible teens and vacationing families would be embarrassing and unnecessary and suggested, instead of a curfew, the Town should focus on issues such as alcohol consumption, marijuana use, and disruptive behavior on the beach and asked the Committee not to pursue the curfew. Mr. Alfred made a motion for the Town Attorney to bring back a revised draft of the ordinance to incorporate comments received from the Beaufort County Sheriff's Office and to include all Town of Hilton Head Island public property and also to include consultation with the incoming Sheriff and postpone moving this item forward to Town Council for consideration of approval to an uncertain date. Mr. DeSimone seconded. Motion carried 3-0. Town of Hilton Head Island Community Development and Public Services Committee Meeting Minutes 8/10/2026 Page | 5 Consideration of an Ordinance of the Town of Hilton Head Island to Amend the Official Land Use Assigned as part of the Port Royal and Surrounds Master Plan as part of the Planned Development Mixed Use (PD-1) Zoning District with Respect to a Portion of Real Property with TMS NO. R510 009 000 1199 0000 Consisting of 4.667 Acres and Located on Union Cemetery Road to Amend the Existing Open Space Use - Shea Farrar, Principal Planner Shea Farrar, Principal Planner, Town of Hilton Head Island, provided a brief summary. The Town of Hilton Head Island is seeking a Master Plan Amendment for a 4.667-acre portion of the Town-owned property, identified on Beaufort County Tax Maps as Parcel R510 009 000 1199 0000. This property is commonly known as the Mid-Island Tract. The amendment is requested to add to the existing open space use designation religious uses meaning: churches, mosques, synagogues, and temples, and the accessory use of a fellowship hall, and related religious activities, including, without limitation, the operation of the St. James soup kitchen, and the hosting of community events in the Cherry Hill School, and public and government uses, as generally defined in the Land Management Ordinance, with an assigned nontransferable, nonresidential density of 14,000 square. This request will allow for the relocation of St. James Baptist Church and Cherry Hill School to the subject property which supports the implementation of Goal #7: Preserve, Protect, and Celebrate Gullah Geechee Culture and Heritage from the Town's 2026-2028 Strategic Plan, which calls for the relocation of the church. Mr. DeSimone moved for approval to forward this item to Town Council for consideration of approval based on the hearing held by the Planning Commission, which unanimously voted to forward this item for consideration to the Community Development and Public Services Committee for a zoning map amendment titled R510 009 000 1199 0000, consisting of 4.667 acres and located on Union Cemetery Road based upon the Committee's review and confirmation that the rezoning meets the criteria pursuant to the standards in Land Management Ordinance Sec. 16-2-103.C.3 (Zoning Map Amendment (Rezoning) Review Standards). Mr. Alfred seconded. Chair Becker asked for public comment. Chester Williams addressed the Committee to request approval of the ordinance for the rezoning needed to relocate St. James Church, and he emphasized that its current location poses safety risks due to proximity to the airport and that the Town, County, and church have long collaborated on the relocation plan. Motion carried 3-0. Public Comment - Non Agenda Items Richard Bisi addressed the Committee to suggest implementation of paid parking at Coligny Beach Park instead of a juvenile curfew; paid parking can be implemented within 30 days and the additional revenue could be used to offset the cost of public safety initiatives. Town of Hilton Head Island Community Development and Public Services Committee Meeting Minutes 8/10/2026 Page | 6 Dave Ferguson addressed the Committee to thank them and all Hilton Head Island departments that deal with public safety for their service to the community and to express his hope that the Committee would seek out opportunities to make Hilton Head Island safer for its residents and visitors. Skip Hoagland addressed the Committee regarding transparency and suggested using Artificial Intelligence in place of attorneys as well as enacting a $5.00 per day tourist impact fee. Adjournment Chair Becker adjourned the meeting at 3:14 p.m. The full recording and a transcript of this meeting can be found on the Town’s website at www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov

Source: Town of Hilton Head Island website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.