Land Management Ordinance Task Force Meeting — Minutes
Town of Hilton Head Island · Beaufort County · Land Management Ordinance Task Force · meeting of Apr 13, 2026 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Hilton Head Island
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Town of Hilton Head Island Land Management Ordinance Task Force
Meeting Minutes
4/13/2026 Page | 1
Town of Hilton Head Island
LAND MANAGEMENT ORDINANCE TASK
FORCE MEETING
Monday, April 13, 2026, 5:00 PM
Minutes
1. Call to Order
The meeting was called to order at 5:00 pm.
In attendance: Chair Councilman Steve DeSimone, Vice Chair Councilwoman Tamara Becker,
and Task Force Members Town Manager Marc Orlando, Lavon Stevens, Louis Johnson,
Gregg Russell, Edwina Dunlap, Ciaran Storan, Lola Campbell, Mike Alsko, James
Wedgeworth, Eric Brehm, Ray Warco, Peter Kristian, Courtney Struna, Cliff McMackin, Judd
Carstens, Barbara Banaszynski, and Thomas Henz.
2. Adoption of the Agenda
Mr. Warco made a motion for the adoption of the agenda. Mr. Kristian seconded. Mr.
Wedgeworth was not present for the motion, which passed unanimously, 17-0.
3. Approval of the Minutes
a. Regular Meeting Minutes of March 26, 2026
Vice Chair Councilwoman Becker motioned to approve the regular meeting minutes of
March 26, 2026. Mr. Alsko seconded. Mr. Wedgeworth was not present for the motion,
which passed unanimously, 17-0.
4. Workshop Discussion
a. Continued Discussion of Land Management Ordinance Amendments
Chair Councilman Steve DeSimone opened the discussion by detailing that the meeting
would cover potential expansion of the Mitchelville Zoning District to include the section of
Mitchelville Road between Baygall and Fish Haul roads, density in the RM-4 (Low to
Moderate Density Residential) Zoning District, and further calibration in the Forest Beach
Neighborhood Character Overlay District.
Marc Orlando, Town Manager, opened the meeting by outlining the evening's agenda,
which focused on continued review of the Land Management Ordinance. Topics included
the Mitchellville Zoning District, the RM-4 density framework, input from the Gullah
Geechee Historic Neighborhood Community Development Corporation (GGHNCDC), and
the Forest Beach Neighborhood Character Overlay District. Trey Lowe, Interim Planning
Director, LMO Official, and Development Services Manager, followed with an overview of
the staff memo, noting that the amendments under review aim to align development
regulations with community priorities, neighborhood character, and long-term resiliency
Town of Hilton Head Island Land Management Ordinance Task Force
Meeting Minutes
4/13/2026 Page | 2
goals. Staff emphasized that no final recommendations were being requested and that
the task force's role was to provide direction and refine concepts.
Regarding the Mitchellville Zoning District, Mr. Lowe presented a proposal to evaluate
extending Mitchellville zoning to parcels on both sides of Mitchellville Road between
Baygall and Fish Hall Roads. Key differences from the existing RM-8 and RM-12 zoning
included increased building height from 45 to 75 feet, maximum impervious coverage
from 35% to 50%, and the addition of uses such as hotels, timeshares, mixed use, and
various commercial categories. The GGHNCDC memo, submitted by Thomas Boxley,
Executive Director, requested that density in historic neighborhoods not fall below six
dwelling units per acre and that Mitchellville development components be extended
uniformly across the road. Task force members raised concerns about infrastructure
capacity, traffic, and the impact of high-intensity commercial uses on a predominantly
residential area. A polling exercise showed 71% of members did not support applying the
Mitchellville District in its entirety, however, the majority were in favor of evaluating
density and uses allowed in the area.
Regarding the RM-4 Zoning District, Shea Farrar, Principal Planner, presented data
showing the district encompasses 2,551 properties and approximately 1,588 acres, with
84% of historic neighborhood acreage zoned RM-4 and 65% of parcels under three
acres. The existing sliding scale density structure has produced inconsistent development
patterns, and the GGHNCDC recommended replacing it with a fixed six dwelling units per
net acre. A polling question on this change returned inconclusive results and was
deferred for further review. Members noted the tension between increasing land value for
property owners and the risk of accelerating land sales away from Native Islander
families, and broadly agreed that equity, community input, and intentional master planning
were essential to moving forward.
Regarding the Forest Beach Neighborhood Character Overlay District, Mr. Lowe
explained that the current 5,000 square foot floor area ratio cap has unintentionally
encouraged subdivision of larger parcels, resulting in larger homes on smaller lots and
changes to neighborhood character. Staff is seeking direction on recalibrating the
standards to better balance building size with lot size. Members noted the importance of
coordinating with existing HOA covenants and raised questions about differentiating
standards between the oceanside and landside portions of the neighborhood. Short-term
rental regulations were briefly raised but confirmed as a topic for a future meeting.
5. Public Comment
Public comment was received from ten speakers. Speakers from the Forest Beach community
expressed strong opposition to any restrictions on short-term rental rights, emphasizing
concerns about property values and equity relative to other island neighborhoods. A Native
Islander spoke in opposition to the proposed zoning changes, citing concerns about
displacement, increased property taxes, building height, and cultural erosion. Councilwoman
Melinda Tunner expressed support for a community meeting prior to any further action on
Mitchellville and noted existing infrastructure concerns along Fish Hall Road. Residents of the
Estuary community raised concerns about traffic safety and the intensity of potential
Town of Hilton Head Island Land Management Ordinance Task Force
Meeting Minutes
4/13/2026 Page | 3
development adjacent to their neighborhood. Additional speakers called for staff to respond to
outstanding written questions submitted by the Gullah Geechee Legal Defense Fund, and
advocated for a density baseline of eight units per acre consistent with prior community
studies.
6. Adjournment
Mr. Orlando closed the meeting by confirming that the April 23 meeting is canceled, and that
the next meetings are scheduled for May 7 and May 21. The May 7 meeting will revisit the
RM-4 discussion and address subdivision regulations. The May 21 meeting will cover
timeshares and short-term rentals. Following those meetings, staff will take approximately 60
days to draft code amendments based on task force direction, which will then proceed through
the Gullah Geechee Task Force, Planning Commission, the Community Development and
Public Services Committee, and Town Council for two readings. Mr. Kristian motioned to
adjourn the meeting. Vice Chair Councilwoman Becker seconded. Mr. Russell was not present
for the motion, which passed unanimously, 17-0. The meeting was adjourned at 7:30 pm.
The full recording and a transcript of this meeting can be found on the Town’s website
at www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov
Source: Town of Hilton Head Island website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.