April 12, 2017 (PDF, 120.3 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of Apr 12, 2017 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
MINUTES OF THE ISLE OF PALMS
PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING
April 12, 2017
The Isle of Palms’ Planning Commission met in the City Hall conference room, 1207
Palm Boulevard on April 12, 2017 at 4:30 p.m. Members attending included Richard
Ferencz, Lewis Gregory, Vince DiGangi, Ron Denton, Lisa Safford, Noel Scott and Bill
Mills; the Director of Planning Douglas Kerr was present as well. The press had been
notified of the meeting, and the agenda for the meeting was posted in City Hall and the
Building Department to comply with the Freedom of Information Act.
PUBLIC COMMENTS
There were no public comments made.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Mr. Ferencz pointed out a correction to the minutes of the meeting of March 15th; on
page 1 “Ms. Ferencz” should be changed to “Mr. Ferencz.” Mr. Scott moved to approve
the minutes as corrected, and Mr. Denton seconded. The motion passed unanimously.
DISCUSSION OF SEPTIC SYSTEMS ON THE ISLAND
Mr. Kerr reported that, since the Commission’s last meeting, he and Mr. Ferencz met
with the Isle of Palms Water and Sewer Commission (IOPWSC) staff regarding the
strategy for providing sewer to the entire island via tap fees and a “green living charge.”
Mr. Kerr felt that the IOPWSC staff was comfortable with the strategy, but they were
going to discuss the issue at their upcoming Commission meeting. Additionally, he
stated that the City’s attorney would be looking at the legality of imposing such fees.
The City staff and the IOPWSC staff would verify that the numbers included in the
calculations are accurate.
Mr. Kerr stated that he wanted to discuss two points stemming from the meeting with
the IOPWSC. The first point was that, in previous discussions, the IOPWSC supported
the concept used by the Summerville Commissioners of Public Works (CPW) of
expanding sewer to an area when 50% of an area agreed to pay to tie into sewer and
charging those that do not tie in a sewer availability fee. He stated that previously the
IOPWSC had indicated the monthly fee paid by those who chose not to tie in would
cover their pro-rata share of the construction cost spread over 10 years, which, from
using earlier examples, appeared to be about $140 per month. He stated that, in their
most recent meeting, the IOPWSC indicated that this monthly fee could be an average
sewer bill fee, which would probably be about $60 per month.
Planning Commission Minutes
April 12, 2017
Page 2
Mr. Mills stated that this approach did not appear to be sustainable in the long run as it
would require that the IOPWSC have the capital to fund significant portions of the
expansions, which he did not think was viable. Mr. Kerr agreed that only a few small-
scale projects could be accomplished in this way, but it would be easier for those
owners choosing not to tie in.
The second item he wanted to discuss was how the IOPWSC had historically funded
large scale projects and how the new financing scenario would be an aberration of
those methods. He stated that, typically when a large-scale sewer project is
undertaken, all sewer customers share the cost of those improvements equally. The
scenario being analyzed whereby only those owners who do not currently have sewer
service would pay for the expansion of the system would represent a change in
practice. If this change was to occur, the IOPWSC staff believe that it would be
inequitable to make those owners that paid for the expansion of their system then to pay
for the improvements necessary to the Wild Dunes system. He explained that this was
the reason the May 23, 2016 letter from Chairman Stroud separated out the cost of the
relocation of the Wild Dunes treatment facility, which is estimated to cost about $8M.
He stated that the previous funding scenarios for expanding the sewer system included
the full $52M cost, but that this amount should be separated out as $44M to new sewer
customers and $8M to existing Wild Dunes customers.
Mr. Kerr distributed a revised draft assessment for comments.
Mr. Ferencz suggested adding the provision to require owners constructing new houses
within 100 feet of a gravity-operated sewer line to extend the line should be added to
the Executive Summary of the assessment. Mr. Kerr answered that he would do this.
The Commission agreed to restructure the section entitled “Planning Commission
Recommendations” to have two sections entitled “Viable Options” and “Planning
Commission Recommendations”.
The Commission agreed that the items included in the “Planning Commission
Recommendations” section would be to improve dialogue with the Water and Sewer
Commission, monitor grant funding opportunities, monitor water quality data, outreach
to residents to better understand public resistance, reduce the allowable size of new
houses tying into septic systems, support small incremental expansions of the sewer
system, support a new fee charged to owners that have sewer available but choose not
to tie in, require new construction or substantial improvement within 100 feet of a
gravity-operated sewer line to extend the line, require properties that have gravity sewer
available but are not tied in and that sell to tie in, and prohibit new subdivisions of
properties unless gravity-operated sewer is available.
Planning Commission Minutes
April 12, 2017
Page 3
The Commission agreed that the items included in the “Viable Options” sections would
be two scenarios of island-wide expansion of the sewer lines in the near future. The
two scenarios would be to have the bulk of the financing paid by the approximately 1400
owners that currently use septic systems and a second that would spread the cost of
the expansion across all owners on the island.
The group agreed to wait for legal research on the fees, an opinion from the IOPWSC
on the funding scenario discussed, and refinement of the numbers used in the various
funding scenarios. In the meantime, they agreed to work on revising the draft
assessment to include the items discussed.
DISCUSSION OF NEW FLOOD MAPS
Mr. Kerr reported that, since the group last met, he had been given data from Mr. Scott
and a surveyor who worked extensively on the island at the time of Hugo that confirm
that the elevation of the flood waters during Hurricane Hugo were about 12.5 above
mean sea level when using the sea level datum of 1929 as the vertical control datum
(NGVD 1929).
He stated that ocean-front properties had waves that reached higher elevations, and it
was hard to determine exactly where and how high these waves were.
He suggested adding 1.5 feet to 12.5 to come up with a minimum elevation standard
requiring that new construction or substantially improved structures be elevated at least
14 feet above sea level (NGVD 1929). He stated that this minimum standard would be
proposed at the same time as the new FEMA flood maps. Mr. Kerr stated that, because
the new flood maps use a different sea level reference point, NAVD 1988, which
established sea level approximately one foot higher, that the requirement would
probably be converted to 13 feet NAVD 1988, which is equal to 14 feet NGVD 1929.
Mr. Mills asked why the City would impose a higher standard than what FEMA
determines is appropriate. He felt that the owners on the island were capable of
assessing these risks and making informed decisions about what elevation they should
build. Mr. Kerr stated that, in a disaster when homes have been damaged, they
become a strain on the community and the City; therefore, he thought it was in the best
interest of the community not to allow people to build to elevations that Hurricane Hugo
showed would be severely impacted.
Mr. Gregory questioned the wisdom of making houses become compliant with the flood
maps and noncompliant with the City’s higher standard. Mr. Kerr understood that this
Planning Commission Minutes
April 12, 2017
Page 4
would add limitations to those properties with the 50% rule, but these structures are
already bound by those limitations.
Ms. Safford asked when these changes would take place. Mr. Kerr answered that
FEMA is estimating that the new flood maps will become effective in December of 2018,
and he would suggest that this amendment be reviewed at the same time as the new
maps.
ADJOURNMENT
With there being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 6:05 p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Richard Ferencz, Chairman
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.