Special Meeting, March 21, 2017 (PDF, 160.27 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of Mar 21, 2017 · Budget documents
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
WAYS and MEANS COMMITTEE
SPECIAL MEETING
3:00 p.m., Tuesday, March 21, 2017
A Special Meeting of the Ways and Means Committee was held at 3:00 p.m. on Tuesday, March
21, 2017 in Council Chambers of City Hall, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South Carolina.
Attending the meeting were Councilmembers Bergwerf, Bettelli, Carroll, Ferencz, Harrington,
Kinghorn, Rice and Ward, Mayor Cronin, Administrator Tucker, Assistant Administrator Fragoso
and City Clerk Copeland.
1. Mayor Cronin called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public
were duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Consideration of FY18 Budget
Mayor Cronin stated that staff had provided Councilmembers with a draft worksheet and detailed
FY18 budget; he asked that Administrator Tucker review the changes that have been made since
initial discussions of the budget in February.
Administrator Tucker stated that one (1) of the most significant differences was the treatment of
the marina project; originally the budget assumed that a referendum passed and the City was
going forward with a bond issue for the project; therefore, debt service on the bond was included.
Since the first budget discussion, ATM has decided that the project should begin with the land -
side of the project, not the water -side as originally proposed. The current version of the budget
reflects only the architectural/engineering and permitting phases of the land-side improvements
at two hundred thirty -three thousand dollars ($233,000) based on ATM’s estimates. If Council
desires to go forward with the referendum in November of this year, the language must go to the
Election Commission before August 15th to be included on the ballots.
Councilmember Kinghorn note d that beginning with the land -side was ATM’s recommendation;
he asked whether the City had reasons to change from the water-side to the land-side.
The Administrator replied that the thing staff found surprising wa s the fact that the docks are in
such poor condition; but that does not address the problem that led to the redevelopment plan
and was identified several years ago, i.e. the lack of organization on the land-side that does not
represent the standards of a destination that the City wants to portray . At the same time, the
older docks have not had any significant work done to them and have continued to deteriorate.
Saying that he was not sold on the idea, the Mayor indicated that he wanted to hear the reasoning
behind starting the project on the land-side.
Speaking as the Chair of the Real Property Committee, Councilmember Bergwerf stated that one
(1) of the discussion points was that the permitting process for the water -side could take as long
as a year or more and that the time could be spent making the land-side improvements.
Councilmember Ferencz pointed out that grant funds the City has applied for are not for the land-
side improvements.
Special Ways and Means Committee
March 21, 2017
Page 2 of 9
Mayor Cronin reiterated that the budget now includes the limited architectural/engineering and
permitting, but, if Council decided in the coming months through grants and other action, to move
quicker on the marina project, it could be discussed at that time but before August to get the
wording correct for a referendum and for whatever financing might be required.
Since he did not know the components, the Mayor said that he was not comfortable with the six
million four hundred thousand dollars ($6,400,000) price tag ; he added th at his “dream state”
would be that the tenants’ leases supported the future development of the marina.
Councilmember Bergwerf, who was also shocked with the cost, said that some of the items added
to the original estimate included dredging while the docks were pulled away, restrooms, etc.; she
thought the City could phase the project and have referendums as needed along the way.
As Councilmembe r Ward recommended, funds need be set aside in each budget cycle for
ongoing maintenance at the marina, and, for the Mayor, one (1) of those maintenance items would
be dredging.
Councilmember Rice remarked that Councilmembers should be aware that the City will not hear
the results of the Boating Infrastructure Grant (BIG) until May, not March as originally told, and
that the amount requested in the grant is substantially less than anticipated, i.e. four hundred fifty
thousand dollars ($450,000).
The Administrator noted that the City might also apply for a grant to fund the replacement pump-
out station in the amount of forty thousand dollars ($40,000).
During the budget process last year, s taff brought to Council’s attention , that the City does not
employ anyone whose responsibility is to maintain its facilities and buildings unlike the Recreation
Department that has both facilities and grounds supervision. The City has continued to be
reactive, not proactive; a situation which prompted Council to authorize an assessment of all City
buildings to determine their deficiencies and the urgency with which they should be addressed.
From responses to the RFP, Hill Construction Company was selected , and the City is now in
receipt of their work product . Staff has taken the work product and reduced it to a one (1) page
schedule for quick reference. From its initial review, staff looked for items in the report that could
be resolved in the current fiscal year , and then at the things that should be incorp orated into the
FY18 budget which total three hundred twenty-two thousand five hundred dollars ($322,500). For
the remaining items in the report, they have been added to the appropriate year in the ten-year
Capital Plan.
Having looked at the tasks to be done in FY18, Councilmember Carroll asked how the
replacement of the roof of the Public Safety Building , which opened in 2009, would affect the
City’s lawsuit against the building contractor.
Administrator Tucker responded that she has spoken with the attorney of record about the Hill
report and the issues with the leaking roof. She added that the building had significant leaks from
Joaquin that were exacerbated by Hurricane Matthew; the Hill Construction recommendation is
for the rehabilitation of the roof at two hundred fifty thousand dollars ($250,000) or a total replace-
ment of approximately four hundred thousand dollars ($400,000). Both FEMA and an insurance
Special Ways and Means Committee
March 21, 2017
Page 3 of 9
adjuster have looked at the roof and their conclusions were that the leaking problems stem from
construction defects.
In order to prevent more leaking in the future, staff concluded that the roof must be addressed in
FY18 with or without a resolution to the lawsuit.
The Mayor commented that he does not like the idea of spending a qu arter of a million dollars
($250,000) for a repair; he said he would prefer to spend the required amount of money to do the
job right and replace the roof. He also commented that the roof does have some type of warranty,
but it is also tied up in the lawsuit.
The Administrator noted that, whenever anything comes up about the Public Safety Building, legal
counsel is included in the discussions, from the notification of a problem, the decision to wait or
repair to the invoice for a repair.
Councilmember Kinghorn asked the Administrator to voice her opinion on future maintenance and
upkeep of the City’s buildings and to whom the responsibility should go.
Administrator Tucker stated that she has long advocated that the City needs an employee whose
primary responsibility would be the maintenance and upkeep of these properties, and, when items
come forward on the schedule, he would be responsible to see they were done.
Councilmember Kinghorn opined that Council agreed that City properties should get regular and
preventative maintenance and upkeep ; he, therefore, asked that, at the appropriate time, the
Administrator present them with a plan.
Councilmember Harrington commented that the Administrator proposed hiring someone for this
purpose a couple of years ago, and it did not survive the budget process.
Referring to the thirty thousand dollars ($30,000) for the public restrooms included in the Hill
report, the Administrator stated that the ex pense was for guttering but staff was relatively
confident that guttering was included in the Liollio proposal , allowing it to be removed from the
FY18 budget.
Directing attention to the General Government page of the full budget document, the Administrator
referred to line 54 Employee Training that is dramatically higher than FY17, totaling approximately
eighty-four thousand dollars ($84,000). She explained that the City fully supports its employee s
becoming more knowledgeable in their field that should lead to their being better at their jobs for
the City; in addition, some ranks in both the Fire and Police Departments require degrees from a
four-year college or university to qualify for the position , i.e. Detective Sergeant , Captain and
Police Chief and Fire Chief. According to A dministrator Tucker, employees seeking tuition
assistance must pay for the courses upfront to be reimbursed at the end based on the grade
achieved, and the number has been increasing since the upturn in the economy – six (6) more
employees are participating in FY18 than in FY17.
Further possible changes to the budget include re -budgeting the vehicle wash in the NPDES
improvements that will likely be competed in FY18.
Special Ways and Means Committee
March 21, 2017
Page 4 of 9
Councilmember Ward asked whether the four perce nt (4%) employee wage increase had been
vetted through the Personnel Committee, and he was told that it had not.
Administrator Tucker explained that staff is recommending a two percent (2%) merit pool and a
two percent (2%) cost of living adjustment (CO LA). Treasurer Suggs noted that the same
percentages were reflected in the version of the budget seen in February. The Administrator
stated that the City has been forewarned that the retirement rates will increase for both employers
and employees effecti ve July 1 , 2017; the specific amount has not yet been announced.
Depending on the percentage increase, some employees’ take-home pay could be reduced.
Councilmember Ferencz recalled that, when Michael Loftus was on Council, the merit pool was
capped at three percent (3%), and she reported that the CPI is currently at two point seven percent
(2.7%).
For FY17, the Treasurer stated that the COLA was one percent (1%) and the merit pool was two
percent (2%), but, considering the increase to retirement contr ibutions of between one third and
one half percent (0.33% and 0.5%), the two percent (2%) COLA appeared to be more acceptable.
Councilmember Ferencz stated that, in a year when the City has many high -ticket expenditures,
Council must carefully consider wage increases; she commented that Council c ould not always
do what it wanted to do but must settle for what it could afford to do.
Mayor Cronin asked that the Personnel Committee study the issue at its next meeting.
Turning to the Fund Balance sched ules, Administrator Tucker directed attention to the Capital
Projects Fund that shows a n overall decrease in fund balance of one million nine hundred
thousand seventy thousand dollars ($1,970,000). This reduction reflects that this is the year when
many of the projects for which Council has been setting money aside in recent years are coming
to fruition, causing fund balances to go down by significant amounts.
On the next page, nearly all of the tourism fund balances are decreasing by half; again the Ci ty
has been saving money for radios, garbage trucks, fire trucks, etc., for several years, so that the
money would be available now that the purchases are at-hand.
Of the two million two hundred twenty -three thousand dollars ($2,223,000) cumulative reduc tion
to tourism fund balances, eight hundred three thousand dollars ($803,000) is a Transfer-in to the
Marina Fund. Other components of the reductions are as follows:
MUNI ATAX
Transfers-in for personnel $630,000
Drainage Phase II 552,000
Parking management and Front Beach 176,197
Ladder fire truck 103,750
Radio replacements 83,750
Garbage truck 75,000
Public Works underground tanks 61,669
Special Ways and Means Committee
March 21, 2017
Page 5 of 9
Hospitality Tax
Transfer-in for personnel $260.000
Enhanced City-wide landscaping 193,800
Underground tank – marina 178,250
PSB roof rehab – portion 125,000
State ATAX
Tourism promotion – CVB $522,000
Transfer-in for personnel 336,000
Front Beach/public restrooms 578,691
Marina bulkhead rehab 237,000
Restroom rehab 230,000
Events 167,000
Marina up-land redesign 155,143
Ladder fire truck 103,750
Radio replacements 83,750
Garbage truck 75,000
Councilmember Kinghorn asked if any of the state -legislated money was “sunset,” meaning that
the legislation that created them was only for a specific period of time ; if the funding was to be
continued beyond that period, new legislation was required.
Mayor Cronin responded that a local government can only roll forward two years (2 yrs.) of State
ATAX; he added that, to his knowledge, no one has been challenged because most municipalities
spend all of the funds they receive. The Mayor and Administrator said that none of these funds
carry that kind of stipulation.
Referring to the list of projects that will use tourism funds, Councilmember Ferencz asked if any
of them could be delayed or only partially done in FY18.
Mayor Cronin commen ted that the garbage truck and the ladder truck have been funded with
savings accumulated over several years; if the purchases were not made, the City would simply
have more reserved funds in the bank.
Indicating that she was not concerned about the projects using reserved funds, but was interested
in items like special events or items where the City could buy fewer than planned.
The Administrator stated that events represent a small piece of the City’s overall budget; the
additional funding for a more comprehensive landscaping contract is included in the budget based
on discussions at the Visioning Meeting.
Treasurer Suggs agreed with the Administrator and stated that the “lion’s share” the FY18 budget
the major expenditures for the replacement of the underground storage tanks, Phase II drainage,
the replacement of the vehicles and the radios, the restroom rehab, and the bulkhead repairs. If
Council agrees that these things must happen, the City has the money.
Special Ways and Means Committee
March 21, 2017
Page 6 of 9
Councilmember Ward reported having spoken with Treasurer Suggs earlier in the day and noted
that the net change between and three percent and four percent (3% -4%) in payroll and payroll-
associated expenses result in only a thirty-five thousand dollar ($35,000) increase to the overall
budget. He stated that “in the scheme of things that is not a very big number.”
On the fund balance schedules for the beach restoration, prese rvation, maintenance and the
Marina, the Administrator drew attention to the column headed “Assigned for Marina
Enhancement” and stated that, at Councilmember Ward’s suggestion, a sa vings for future
maintenance has been established with a seventy -five thou sand dollar ($75,000) set -aside in
FY18.
The Marina Fund’s ending balance is projected to be nine hundred thirty -three thousand dollars
($933,000); the Administrator reminded Council that included in that number was the Transfer -in
of approximately eight hundred four thousand dollars ($804,000).
The Treasurer commented that the Transfers-in to the marina were for specific purposes, i.e. one-
third (⅓) of the cost of underground storage tank replacements, two-thirds (⅔) of the cost for the
bulkhead rehabilitation, two-thirds (⅔) of the cost for the up -land A&E, and two-thirds (⅔) of the
debt service, a routine Transfer-in.
An i tem of interest that could change in the General Fund FY18 budget was group health
insurance for Mayor and Council; although the number of participants may increase or decrease
based on the results of the N ovember election, the number has been left the same as FY17 for
budgeting purposes.
Recommendation from the Real Property Committee to reinstate the budget for the public
restrooms to the original budgeted amount of $565,000
When the Mayor and Administrator met with County Council Chair Vic Rawls recently about the
public restrooms, he offered for Charleston County Public Works employees to construct the
shower platform and beach walkover at Front Beach in lieu of funding. Based on that discussion,
Council reduced the budget for the project to two hundred thousand dollars ($200,000) at the
February budget meeting. Director Kerr reported conversations he had with the Facilities
Maintenance Director and the Public Works Construction Supervisor at Charleston County about
the project; he was told that they have a small team of skilled workers for building and as many
as one hundred (100) projects ahead of IOP’s boardwalk. On the oth er hand, they were happy
to help with the project administration, for example, inspections and the selection of a contractor.
From the Public Works Supervisor, the Director learned that they could move earth to gain access
to a space, but they do not buil d bridges or boardwalks. As a result of these discussion s, the
Director does not think the County could assist the City and effect any reduction to the cost of the
project.
Councilmember Bergwerf pointed out that the Front Beach walkover does not meet the needs of
the City any longer; in her opinion, the existing boardwalk is no longer viable and is not wide
enough to accommodate people coming and going. She urged the Mayor and staff to find the
money in the budget to ensure that the project was completed in FY18, noting that the budget has
a line of one hundred thousand dollars for the addition or replacement of a dune walkover.
Special Ways and Means Committee
March 21, 2017
Page 7 of 9
Treasurer Suggs noted that the project could be funded by the Beach Preservation Fee Fund.
Mayor Cronin agreed that the boardwalk needed to be replaced, but he commented that he would
prefer for Charleston County to pay for it.
Responding to Councilmember Rice’s question, Director Kerr said that the permit would be good
for five (5) years and that the City has had it for three (3) years.
The Treasurer reminded Council that the City receives four to five hundred thousand dollars
($400,000 - $500,000) a year from Charleston County that represents a piece of their
accommodations tax which they are not obligated to do; she added that originally the City received
twenty percent (20%) of the taxes collected from the Isle of Palms and now it is twenty-five percent
(25%). She expressed the opinion that County Council would consider the extra five percent (5%)
as their contribution to the public restrooms.
The Mayor recommended using funds from the Beach Preservation Fee Fund and ATAX funds
for the boardwalk and that the City continues to pursue additional funds from Charleston County.
Since the Beach Preservation Fee Funds cannot be used toward the public restrooms,
Councilmember Ferencz suggested that the restrooms and the boardwalk and shower platform
be two (2) separate projects. Administrator Tucker stated that the City intends to bid the two (2)
as one (1) project.
To answer Councilmember Ferencz, Treasurer Suggs stated that the cost for the boardwalk is
estimated to be one hundred seventy -five thousand dollars ($175,000), rehabilitation of the
restrooms at one hundred eighty-five thousand dollars ($185,000), the shower platform at one
hundred thirty thousand dollars ($130,000), design and construction oversight at twenty -five
thousand dollars ($25,000) and a contingency of fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) for a total project
cost of five hundred sixty-five thousand dollars ($565,000).
Administrator Tucker remarked that her advocacy for reinstating the entire project cost into the
FY18 budget was a failsafe for the project to be completed if Charleston County ca nnot deliver
on Chair Rawls’ offer.
According to the Treasurer, in this version of the budget is two hundred thirty thousand dollars
($230,000) for the restrooms comprised of the two hundred thousand dollar ($200,000) figure
from the February meeting and thirty thousand dollars ($30,000) for the gutters. The cost of the
boardwalk could be covered by the Beach Preservation Fee Fund, leaving one hundred sixty
thousand dollars ($160,000) yet to be funded.
Mayor Cronin thought that the remainder could come from the Beach Preservation Fee Fund or
one (1) of the tourism funds. He then commented that, at times, OCRM issues Requests for
Proposals (RFP) to help fund accesses to the beach; he asked that Assistant Fragoso look into
the availability of said funds.
Special Ways and Means Committee
March 21, 2017
Page 8 of 9
Treasurer Suggs stated that some money was in the Aisle of Palms Fund which is reserved for
beautification of the Front Beach area; the money is generated through the sale of
commemorative bricks, benches and palm tree s; after looking at the General Ledger, the
Treasurer stated that this fund has eighteen thousand dollars ($18,000) to contribute.
Staff was asked to find one hundred sixty thousand dollars ($160,000) for the next version of the
budget to be used toward the public restrooms and boardwalk.
Councilmember Kinghorn reiterated his opinion that this was the wrong approach, noting that he
has offered options, that he felt had not been vetted , to make the public restroom structure a
revenue source; he indicated that the maintenance costs should be reduced for the restrooms
through bidding a new maintenance contract.
In the Marina Fund, the Administrator said that staff needed to review the revenue generated from
the marina leases to ensure that they had been adjusted by the CPI; additionally, the Administrator
noted that this budget does not contemplate any changes to the marina leases and one (1) tenant
is making overtures to the City regarding changes to a lease at this time.
Councilmember Ferencz commented that, after the February meeting, the news of an eight
hundred thousand dollar ($800,000 ) reduction in the FY18 budget had been publicized, and
tonight the decision has been made to reinstate three hundred sixty -five thousand dollars
($365,000) of that reduction. She indicated that she was exasperated that, i n two (2) hours of
talking, no new budget was produced. She asked Council if they needed to reduce the budget.
Councilmember Kinghorn opined that the “budget was on the mark,” and, if anything, he thought
the amount budgeted for City-wide landscaping was too low to achieve the intended goal.
Councilmember Ferencz stated that the immediate maintenance needs identified in the Hill
Construction report have added another three hundred twenty -two thousand dollars ($322,000)
to the original budget. She indicated that she was not against spending money where it was
needed, but the City could not continue to spend more and more every year.
Councilmember Kinghorn contended that Council had n ot spent the time needed to define new
revenue sources, such as extending the parking season, placing kiosk s in additional parking
areas of the island, etc.
Councilmember Bergwerf agreed that the City was facing some extraordinary expenses in the
FY18 budget which, to her thinking, distort the fund balances; the fact also is that some of these
expenses will not be repeated in FY19, such as the drainage project, the fuel tank replacements,
the public restrooms, the radio replacements and the financial software purchase.
The Mayor pointed out that for nine (9) years Council has balanced and managed a budget an d
done all of the things it should do to improve the City without asking the residents for additional
tax dollars; he added that the City did not derive any additional revenue when property taxes were
adjusted based on the reassessment a couple of years ago. The citizens have received services
and improvements because the City has used other sources of funds; he stated that the amount
of property taxes collected will not pay for the Police Department for a year.
Special Ways and Means Committee
March 21, 2017
Page 9 of 9
Administrator Tucker stated that the reason the CPI increase is included in the law is that
expenses are continually increasing, and, when a local government does not take the CPI on the
millage each year, the result is the need to make a big jump in property taxes to balance the
budget. City Council of the City of Isle of Palms has made a conscious decision every year not
to increase the millage unless absolutely necessary , and the reason the City has been able to
operate in this manner is that tourism funds are available to offset certain City expenses. In some
respects, the Administrator feels that Council is delaying the pain in the future when a tax increase
becomes the only route to balance the City’s budget.
The Mayor informed Council that the business license issue is still in the legislature; at the
moment, it has been kicked back to Committee, but it has not gone away. The City would
experience a major loss if the version before legislators is passed; the City would not only lose
the business license revenue but also the rental license revenue.
3. Adjournment
Mayor Cronin adjourned the Special Meeting at 4:47 p.m.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.