March 6, 2017 (PDF, 338.15 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of Mar 6, 2017 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
REAL PROPERTY COMMITTEE
9:30 A.M., Monday, March 6, 2017
The regular meeting of the Real Property Committee was held at 9:30 a.m., Monday, March 6,
2017 in the City Hall Conference Room, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South Carolina.
Attending the meeting were Councilmembers Harrington and Rice, Chair Bergwerf, Administrator
Tucker, Assistant Administrator Fragoso and Clerk Copeland; a quorum was present to conduct
business
1. Chair Bergwerf called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public
had been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Rice moved to approve the minutes of the regular
meeting of February 2, 2017 as submitted; Councilmember Harrington seconded
and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments – None
4. Comments from Marina Tenants
Jay Clarke, owner of Morgan Creek Grill, asked about the progress on the insurance claim that
included claims for damages to the air conditioner on the roof and the condenser for the ice
machine at the restaurant from Hurricane Matthew. He asked that he b e included in any
information the City might receive about the claim.
Administrator Tucker noted that the claims have been filed, but that she has not received any
information since the adjuster was on the island.
Michael Fiem, Tidal Wave Watersports also located at the marina, informed the Committee that
the gate to his business has no power; he reported that the electricity had been sh ut off for the
winter. With the storms and king tides, he has seen the relay box below the lock inundated with
salt water. He was interested in moving the relay box to avoid such situations in the future. The
receptacles on the land side of the hut are tied to the same relay box, so they were not working
when he was at the marina over the weekend.
Administrator Tucker said that she would send William Seabrook, the City’s building inspector, to
ensure that moving the relay box would not be a violation of the code.
5. Old Business
A. Discussion of Morgan Creek Grill lease
Accompanying Mr. Clarke was John Dodd, his attorney, for this discussion. Mr. Clarke stated
that they had intended to have all of their information ready to present at this meeting, but they
have not yet finalized the documents to negotiate “a fair lease and extension.” Mr. Clarke
indicated that they could have the package ready in a few days to send to the City Administrator
and the Committee members, but he was aware of the crunch to get the lease resolved before
Real Property Committee
March 6, 2017
Page 2 of 10
the busy season begins. He expects to have “give and take” in the negotiation process and asked
if a Special Meeting could be scheduled before the April regular meeting.
Mr. Dodd stated that, in the course of discussions with Mr. Clarke over the weekend, it became
apparent that they would not be prepared to present the information at this meeting. He said that
he has advised Mr. Clarke that he should provide to the Committee the information he has
gathered well in advance to the meeting to give the Committee members ample time for study.
Mr. Dodd told the Committee that they have been working with Peter Kent, the restaurant’s
certified public accountant, and Joseph Guerry, a NAIA appraiser, who contributed to the informa-
tion that will be provided.
The consensus of the Commit tee was that they could not calendar another meeting into the
month.
Since Mr. Dodd was not in attendance at the February meeting, Administrator Tucker reiterate d
what Mr. Clarke was told; she indicated that the information included in the minutes of that meeting
would clearly state what the Committee would be expecting to see when negotiations start. She
noted that, if the package was incomplete or something totally unexpected was included,
negotiations would be difficult; she urged Mr. Clarke and Mr. Dodd to be thorough and think about
everything so that nothing was added at the last minute.
On the subject of the walk-in freezer, Mr. Clarke stated that the freezer was at a point of failure,
and he distributed several photographs showing the structural damage the condensation of water
from the freezer has caused. He noted that the dampness and damages would not influence the
termite inspection, and he reported that he was waiting on the contractor to dig the trench to
remove the standing water under th e restaurant. He submitted two (2) scenarios related to the
freezer replacement; the first would involve replacing the walk-in in the current location, and the
second would be to relocate the freezer when it is replaced. In Option One, the work is estimated
to take six (6) weeks and would require closing the first floor dining room during the work period;
new sprinklers are now required that costs approximately sixty -seven hundred dollars ($6,700).
The total cost to replace the walk-in in its current location was approximately sixty-five thousand
dollars ($65,000); the total includes the structural repairs needed. In Option Two, the work would
take twelve (12) weeks but would not require closing the main dining room; this option describes
new construction of a walk-in freezer structure, a storage area, loading dock with fencing and a
gate sprinkler system and alterations to the handicap ramp. The total cost for Option Two has
been estimated at one hundred thirty-one thousand two hundred fifty-eight dollars ($131,258); the
intent with this option is to make the restaurant more aesthetically pleasing.
Administrator Tucker opined that they could likely be running against City building codes to have
the walk -in freezer outside; she also asked if every thing needed to repair the damages was
included in the cost estimates.
On the other hand, Mr. Clarke was confident that the plans would be approved and that everything
was included and code compliant.
Real Property Committee
March 6, 2017
Page 3 of 10
In Mr. Dodd’s opinion, the question was should they to do an upgrade with a new location for the
walk-in freezer and aesthetic changes to make it a more valuable asset for the City and more
functional for the restaurant ; he stated that the City has set aside one hundred ten thousand
dollars ($110,000) and the cost is twenty-one thousand dollars ($21,000) more than that amount.
Mr. Dodd added that they think Option Two would be a substantial improvement that will reduce
truck traffic and increase revenues for the restaurant and the City.
Councilmember Rice pointed out that they do not know if they will be able to relocate the new
walk-in freezer outside, and she commented that she was not aware of one hundred ten thousand
dollars ($110,000) being included in the FY17 budget for a walk-in freezer.
Administrator Tucker directed Councilmember Rice to page 58 in the FY17 budget, which is the
marina’s page in the ten -year (10-yr.) capital plan; the number of one hundred ten thousand
dollars ($110,000) appear s as the total of four (4) specific City assets at the time the original
Morgan Creek lease was signed. She explained that the Ten-year Capital Plan is where all of the
City’s assets on the books are listed with estimates of the year that asset might need to be
replaced and he associated cost ; she said that the walk -in freezer was included because of its
value.
Councilmember Rice informed Mr. Clarke and Mr. Dodd that Council had an intense initial budget
meeting in February where it reduced the FY18 budget by eight hundred thousand dollars
($800,000) of big ticket items that have a significant impact on tourism funds and the City’s
operating funds. The Councilmember suggested that the walk -in freezer should be eliminated
from the City’s ten-year plan.
Mr. Clarke recalled earlier meetings with the Real Property Committee where it was discussed
that all of these items be removed from the City’s books. He stated that one (1) section in the
new lease will propose that Morgan Creek Grill assume full responsibility for everything restaurant
related. He said that he wanted the funds that have been allocated ($110,000) to be used for this
project and he added that he will not come back to the Committee asking for assistance.
Chair Bergwerf stated that, unt il the members see what Morgan Creek Grill is proposing, the
Committee cannot take any action.
The Administrator was clear that just because an item is listed on the Capital Plan does not mean
that item is the City’s res ponsibility; it means that the City put it on the long -range plan as a
planning document. She cautioned Mr. Dodd not to misinterpret what is on the Capital Plan as
“the City feeling some sort of obligation.”
B. Status of renovations to public restrooms and schematic drawings from
Liollio
Referring to the Liollio schematics, Chair Bergwerf asked about the costs associated with them,
and Director Kerr replied that, from the first meeting, Liollio was told that the maximum budget
was one hundred sixty thousand dollars ($160,000). Bringing the Committee up-to-date, Director
Kerr reported that the plumbing and floor painting have been scheduled, and he is trying to
coordinate the removal of the fixtures with the floor painting to begin the next day, after the floor
Real Property Committee
March 6, 2017
Page 4 of 10
cures, the plumber would come back to install the new fixtures. Assuming all of this falls together,
the restrooms will be closed ten to fourteen (10-14) days at the end of April and into the first week
of May.
After a discussion of bringing in port-a-lets when the restrooms are closed, the Committee agreed
upon one (1) of the trailer-style toilets to be placed in the parking lot along with a couple of port-
a-lets to be placed at Front Beach as staff determines.
Continuing his report, Director Kerr stated that the bottoms of the stalls where the rust was
extensive have been removed; some minor signage still needs to be done; the installation of new
doors for the stalls ha s not been scheduled. These actions will b e the extent of the City’s work
until the end of the season when the construction work will begin.
When asked about the progress on the mural, Chair Bergwerf said that the street side and the
side at the boardwalk have been completed. The dolphins for the ocean-side will be done when
the artist returns to town and the weather cooperates.
The Chair reported receiving an email telling her that the new hand dryers have begun to rust,
and the suggestion was to spray them with WD40 once a week and to wipe t hem off ; some
ingredient in the oil prevents rusting.
As the City contemplates a new contract for the restroom attendant, Director Kerr suggested a
list of things to be done daily, weekly and monthly as a guide for the new person.
Councilmember Rice reported that the shelving in the office at the public restrooms also needs to
be replaced.
Director Kerr stated that he had reviewed the schematic drawings with Liollio and was prepared
to discuss them with the Committee. (A set of drawings is attached to the historical record of the
meeting.)
Discussions started with the drawing of “New Elevation West” that is the side of the building facing
Coconut Joe’s where the turtle mural is painted. Chair Bergwerf commented that the mural has
just recently been c ompleted and this conceptual drawing destroys the upper half of the mural;
she suggested putting the louvres on the opposite side of the building to leave the mural intact.
According to Director Kerr, Liollio has strategically placed the vertical boards to create air flow at
that level and to allow natural light to get in; this was the most cost effective method they could
provide to get the desired results.
In the Chair’s opinion, if the louvres are for air flow, she believes they should be on the other side
of the building where the toilets are located.
On the page with “New Reflected Ceiling,” the Director pointed out the four (4) ceiling fans, one
(1) in each quadrant of the building; the ceiling would be sla ts with canned lighting that would
diffuse through the area. The ceiling fans will be flush with the ceiling, and a void in the ceiling
will be around each with a white-washed, treated rim and the fan in the middle. Four (4) exhaust
Real Property Committee
March 6, 2017
Page 5 of 10
fans will also be placed in the attic, similarly to the ceiling fans. The ocean -side of the building
will have louvres as well.
Liollio did have their plumbing engineer look at the infrastructure going into the building to
determine the number of showers it could support; they have decided to have sixteen (16) shower
heads, i.e. four (4) pedestals with four (4) heads on each.
Looking at the drawings, it looks like a bench will be constructed on the ocean-side and the street-
side.
When looking at the materials from which to construct the boardwalk; they were conscious of the
fact that th is boardwalk has been permitted with a width of eleven feet (11 ft.) to serve as an
emergency access carrying a four-wheeler type vehicle. They thought about a material that would
not burn or melt if a vehicle were idling on it for some period of time; Liollio is continuing to work
toward a final boardwalk design. Director Kerr stated that there was a concrete-type product that
could be used up to the OCRM jurisdiction and transition there to the epay wood product, which
is fire resistant. Liollio’s next step would be to go to the final design.
Chair Bergwerf reminded the Director that she wanted to relocate the louvered section to the other
side of the structure.
Administrator Tucker recalled that, based on Charleston County’s offer of assistance with the
construction of the boardwalk, the budget for this project was reduced to two hundred thousand
dollars ($200,000) at the recent budget meeting . The Administrator reported that she had told
the Mayor, after the meeting, that she was concerned about that reduction; although the City
would see some savings if Charleston County does the work, she preferred that the City plan to
cover the necessary costs in the FY18 budget and realize the savings at the end of the year. She
hoped that the budget would be re-instated to its original amount.
Director Kerr reported that he has now spoken with the Facilities Maintenance Division that would
deal with the building and the Public Works Division that would deal with the boardwalk; neither
group was enthusiastic about the project. Both offered to facilit ate construction administration;
the stafffer from the Public Works Division stated that his group has the ability to do emergency
access points, for instance put in a rock roadbed, but nothing permanent. He left the meeting
less confident that they could make a significant impact on the costs.
MOTION: Councilmember Harrington moved to restore the budget for the public
restrooms to its original level of approximately $565,000; Councilmember Rice
seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Administrator Tucker indicated that the City would continue its talks with Charleston County; from
the original meeting with the County, she recalled being told that the County was beginning to
staff up and expanding its capabilities. They do have people with talents beyond the level they
originally did, but that would likely mean that the boardwalk would be their first project to use that
expertise. The Administrator commented that possibly the City and the County staff that made
the assignment and the people who received the assignment should meet to clarify what they can
and cannot do.
Real Property Committee
March 6, 2017
Page 6 of 10
Responding to Councilmember Harrington’s question about a timeline, the Administrator stated
that the work would not begin until after August 22nd.
Director Kerr said that he got the impression from talking wi th the “guys on the ground” that the
County does not have the resources to do it.
Chair Bergwerf suggested small plaques in the restrooms acknowledging AmeriCorp, Island
Realty and Joe Petro for their donations of time and materials to make this renovation a reality;
the Committee agreed to wait until the project was complete and address this subject again.
C. Update on beach restoration
The Administrator again stated t hat the City was in receipt of the stakeholder’s money but is
waiting upon two or three (2 -3) agreements; she does not anticipate any problems with having
them signed. The City has not had an announcement from SC PRT regarding the seven million
dollar ($7,000,000) request from them. As of today, the City has received comments from the
citizens who responded to the Corps of Engineers during the public comment period; in them, the
City had both comments and requests, i.e. request for things to be done by th e Coastal
Conservation League; a very positive and supportive comment from a citizen out of Atlanta urging
that it move forward; comments from Fish and Wildlife regarding some things they would like for
the City to do; the project received a very supportiv e comment from State Archives and History
stating they were very pleased with the new borrow site and with the knowledge that the project
would be out of the area of the Second Stone Fleet; the Catawba Indians requested that, if the
project brought in any native American artifacts or bones that they be notified immediately;
comments from the Natural Marine Fisheries Service requesting an October to March dredging
period, bathymetric surveys, no dredging to occur within four hundred feet (400 ft.) of the hard
bottom habitat, and a beach and borrow area monitoring plan to go to the Natural Marine Fisheries
Service for review before work commences. Based on the comments, the City will work closely
with the project engineer to discuss what is necessary to satisfy the requests; of primary concern
would be how much these tasks would add to the cost.
Responding to the Chair, the Administrator answered that, at this point, the Corps of Engineers
and OCRM would have to make a decision whether or not to permit or not to permit the project
based on the comments or to issue a permit that would be conditional upon meeting the
requirements they specify.
E. Update on Marina Redevelopment Plan – Kirby Marshall, ATM
Mr. Marshall reported that ATM personnel ha ve spent the past month refining the marina plan
based on discussions at the February meeting. The changes made were to modify access to the
upland fuel dock using a model from National Highway Safety Transportation Guidelines; Mr.
Marshall was confident that a recreational vehicle towing a vehicle or a semi-trailer could navigate
the turns. Marina Manager Berrigan had offered a list of comments and questions; among them
was a request to potentially locate the kayak dock to tie-in with the existing restaurant dock; ATM
did not make that change now because they did not want to preempt the existing Morgan Creek
Grill lease; it could be done in the future. Mr. Berrigan also asked to lengthen the fuel dock, and
ATM was able to add about seventeen feet (17 ft.). The dumpster space was enlarged to
Real Property Committee
March 6, 2017
Page 7 of 10
accommodate additional dumpsters. Mr. Marshall explained that ATM had worked to consolidate
and segregate the trailer parking from the regular vehicular traffic. The tie-down area was moved
closer to the boat ramp to achieve one hundred feet (100 ft.) of tie-down space. The way that
ATM interpreted the ADA guidelines from the Department of Justice was that a handicap parking
space was required for every different sectio n of a parking lot. Mr. Berrigan also suggested a
small kids’ play area in the greenspace along the water; it is not shown, but could easily be
integrated into the final plan. Having obtained the historic dredging information from the City
Administrator, ATM has rolled that work into the redevelopment of the water -side of the marina
while the docks are pulled out.
The Administrator voiced Stuart Colman’s concerns about the pedestrian bridge over the boat
ramp after watching a sailboat launch with the mas t up; the Administrator stated that, once the
redevelopment has been completed, a boat’s mast would have to be set after it was in the water.
Mr. Marshall indicated that ATM personnel are having a difficult time in attempts to make the
pedestrian bridge ADA accessible; as it appears in the cost estimates, one (1) chair lift on either
side would be required.
Mr. Berrigan reported that sailboats seldom launch from the IOP Marina because the Intracoastal
Waterway is not really conducive to sailing; in the seventeen years (17 yrs.) he has been at the
marina, he said he could count the number of sailboats on two (2) hands.
Looking at the plan in total, Mr. Berrigan stated that he was “excited” and “cautiously optimistic
about where it is headed.” He also informed the Committee that the 41st Avenue ditch that runs
along the property line to the Waterway was ”eroding at an alarming rate;” in his opinion, the ditch
should be piped.
Michael Fiem reported that, since the last dredging project, the area at the end of the ditch has
become like an alluvial fan and has almost come back to the way it was pre -dredging; he added
that the amount of accretion has not occurred in that amount of time in the past.
Mr. Marshall stated that he received word from US DNR last week that the BIG grant winners will
be announced at the American Boating Conference in Washington, DC in May.
On the subject of the costs of the marina redevelopment plan, Mr. Marshall announced that, with
the construction improvements, the best estimate for the total project is six million four hundred
thousand dollars ($6,400,000). The factors that have increased the costs since the original
estimate are dredging at six hundred fifty thousand dollars ($650,000), way-finding signs that will
be important to pedestrians and vehicular traffic, the platform lifts on either side of the pedestrian
bridge, dumpster screening, restrooms, a cantilevered boardwalk behind Morgan Creek Grill, the
tractor shed, more IT support infrastructure for the parking meter system, the pedestrian bridge
and more fire protection for the marina per current NFPA guidelines. These improvements equal
one and a half million dollars ($1,500,000). Compared to the previous plans, this plan has
increased costs for incr eased qua ntities of asphalt, gravel, more sidewalk, more boardwalk
square footage with a width of ten feet (10 ft.), more gangways, more slips mean more utility
costs, and more floating dock square footage; the costs of the increased quantities is
Real Property Committee
March 6, 2017
Page 8 of 10
approximately eight hundred thousand dollars ($800,000). A total of two million three hundred
thousand dollars ($2,300,000) greater that the original plan without dry stack storage, and total
possible grant funds of five hundred fifty thousand dollars ($550,000).
Councilmember Harrington stated that Council must devise an ad campaign supporting this
project as a strong investment in the future.
Chair Bergwerf noted that in Council the general feeling is that the City must hold a referendum
to support the funding of the project, and that amount will be determined by the grants.
Administrator Tucker told Mr. Marshall that ATM must solidify the numbers and provide them to
the City in more detail; she liked that he explained the difference between the original estimate
and what they have become now and felt it would be important for people to understand. She
also voiced the need for a serious look at the plan by ATM from the standpoint of phasing; if it
must be phased, what would be the recommended phasing so that the City can plan accordingly.
The Administrator opined that having that recommendation along with the associated costs would
be helpful, and, if there is the opportunity to phase it, the referendum qu estion might be only for
that particular phase of work.
Mr. Kirby noted that, if the City were to decide to move ahead today, it would be looking at a one
(1) year permitting process for the marina and close to a year’s obligation process for the BIG
grant. During that year the two (2) processes discussed above could be done concurrently while
the City started with the upland work in the off-season.
The Chair suggested that, if necessary, the upland work could also be phased; she expressed
the need to organize the parking to be more efficient and get the walkways done.
At the mention of the replacement of the underground fuel storage tanks, Administrator Tucker
asked if they have to be relocated to accommodate the plan; Mr. Marshall reported that, in their
current location, the tanks would be about one hundred fifty to two hundred feet (150-200 ft.) away
from the dispensers. He thought they should be moved; to leave them would add more piping
and more costs.
Mr. Marshall said that he would provide a memo illuminating the detail costs and break out their
recommended phasing with the associated cost, which could be massaged to whatever comfort
level the City needed.
The Administrator also told Mr. Kirby that the Committee needs to get an estimate fo r ATM to
secure the permits for the project. Mr. Kirby speculated that those costs would be rolled into the
Phase I costs for the upland improvements.
E. Discussion of landscaping contract
In the meeting packet was a draft of the exhibit that accompa nies the current contract detailing
what the City would expect the vendor to do, and staff was asking for input from the Committee.
The Administrator recalled a lengthy discussion at the Visioning Meeting of using the Recreation
Center grounds as the benchmark for all City properties; when the contract is re-bid in 2017, staff
Real Property Committee
March 6, 2017
Page 9 of 10
wants it to be a very comprehensive and thorough listing of all of the things the City wants to see
the contractor do. At the same time, thought needs to be given to who on staff would supervise
that contractor. Staff has made several changes/additions to the list already, but she asked that
the Committee members, as they ride the island, consider improvements that could to be made.
Administrator Tucker thought that most of the things were already included in the exhibit, but,
someone would be needed on a daily basis to supervise the vendor to ensure that things are
being done to the level the City wants to see them done.
The Administrator thought that staff had increased the FY18 budget for the first version, but she
was concerned that it had been not been increased enough. Assistant Fragoso thought the figure
in the budget was about one hundred thirty thousand dollars ($130,000) that includes an increase
of fifty thousand dollars ($50,000).
The current vendor has been notified that the City will not renew their contract that expires at the
end of May.
F. Consideration of award of a contract to JMT in an amount not to exc eed
$20,070 for construction oversight and monitoring of marina bulkhead repairs
The existing contract with JMT took them through generating the bid package, which they have
done, and the motion would be for an amendment to their contract to bid the project and supervise
the construction that is to begin in October.
Councilmember Rice reminded the Committee that efforts were going to be made to coordinate
the bulkhead repairs and the replacement of the underground storage tanks. She then asked the
Administrator if different terms could be negotiated related to their attendance at meetings; the
proposal quotes a price of one hundred eighty-five dollars per hour ($185).
Administrator Tucker stated that, between now and the Ways and Means Committee meeting,
staff would try to get an amended proposal that includes attendance to at least one (1) meeting.
G. Update on replacement of underground storage tanks
The Administrator has thought that other local governments would need to replace tanks as well;
she, therefore, reached out to them through the Municipal Association in hopes of locating a pro
forma RFP. She got no response.
Assistant Fragoso reported that Charleston County would be hiring a consultant to write the RFP
for them because it is very technical.
The Administrator said that she want to get an RFP advertised to hire a consultant to produce the
RFP for the tank replacement because the City has no one on staff with the expertise to do so.
H. Update on beach access signs
Real Property Committee
March 6, 2017
Page 10 of 10
Assistant Fragoso stated that she had contacted four (4) vendors and has not yet received any
final numbers.
6. New Business – None
7. Miscellaneous Business
The Administrator reported that all tenants are current with their obligations to the City.
Next Meeting Date: 9:30 a.m., Monday, April 3, 2017
8. Executive Session – Not necessary
9. Adjournment
MOTION: Councilmember Rice moved to adjourn the meeting at 11:40 a.m.;
Councilmember Harrington seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.