March 1, 2017 (PDF, 331.68 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of Mar 1, 2017 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Public Works Committee
11:00 A.M., Wednesday, March 1, 2017
The regular meeting of the Public Works Committee was called to order at 11:00 a.m.,
Wednesday, March 1, 2017 in the City Hall conference Room, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of
Palms, South Carolina. Attending the meeting were Councilmembers Harrington and Ward, Chair
Ferencz, City Administrator Tucker, Public Works Director Pitts, Assistant Administrator Fragoso
and City Clerk Copeland; a quorum was present to conduct business.
1. Chair Ferencz called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public
had been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Ward moved to approve the minutes of the regular
meeting of February 1, 2017 as submitted; Coun cilmember Harrington seconded
and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments – None
4. Departmental Reports for February 2017 – Director Pitts
Director Pitts reported that the work focus in February had been painting the green garbage
barrels on Ocean Boulevard, repairing the potholes in the Marina parking lot and clearing the
pampas grass from the sidewalk on Palm Boulevard. A Charleston County crew was on the island
and repaired the RCP pipe at Sand Dollar Drive and Wildwood . Garbage collections were
approximately twenty-four tons (24 T.) greater than the same month last year, and yard d ebris
collections increased approximately seventy-five tons (75 T.) over the same month in 2016. The
older Loadmaster was taken in for preventative maintenance and for other repairs/replacements
as needed; although the work totaled forty-four hundred dollars ($4,400), the Director is confident
that this line in the Public Works budget will end the year at or under budget.
5. Old Business
A. Update on drainage issues
1. Sand Dollar Drive
Administrator Tucker reminded the Committee members that Kevin Klemm, the resident at 3 Sand
Dollar Drive, attended the Council meeting of February 28 th and appealed to the City for
assistance with the flooding issue on his property . The Administrator thought Mr. Klemm had a
misunderstanding when the line was originally videoed; his reaction to the repair that was made
was that more repair was necessary. The City’s reaction, Eadie’s reaction and David Stevens’
reaction was that the repair has been made, is holding and nothing more needs to be done. Mr.
Klemm’s point at the meeting was that the repair is failing and that the pipe should be dug up and
be replaced, and more fill material added to increase the elevation. Since Eadie’s video was not
available, Director Pitts asked that Charleston County camera the line again.
What the City is learning is that users of the video -taping equipment have found it to be
“temperamental,” i.e. once repaired and used again they malfunction and do not produce any
Public Works Committee
March 1, 2017
Page 2 of 7
recorded video. Charleston County has indicated that, when their equipment is used for this pipe,
it will likely not produce a video, leaving the City in the same predicament, but they will come to
the island to look at the pipe again and offer a recommendation on what needs to be done.
If he were at the meeting today, the Administrator would have posed the following questions to
Mr. Klemm:
If the recommendation is to replace that segment of pipe, is he aware of the level of
disruption it will cause on the right-of-way adjacent to his property?
Beyond the fill material, would he have any expectations of other improvements he would
expect the City to make?
If Mr. Klemm wants the City to replace his driveway, he needs to communicate that to the City,
and the City needs to make a decision about what it is or is not willing to do.
Director Pitts has gotten two (2) quotes on what the cost to the City would be if it decided to
replace the pipe, and the work should be around five thousand dollars ($5,000).
Administrator Tucker stated that, from Mr. Klemm’s comments, he is not going to be satisfied until
the pipe is replaced.
Councilmember Kinghorn expressed his understanding of the situation as one where Mr. Klemm
brought an issue to the City’s attention; the City hi red an expert to evaluate it; and the expert
came back with a conclusion that Mr. Klemm hoped would be different, i.e. the system is
functioning as it should and nothing needs to be done.
If Mr. Klemm had attended this meeting, t he Chair planned to tell him that, since the Committee
was not composed of experts, it had to follow the recommendations of its expert. If he has issues
with the expert’s conclusions, he should communicate them to the expert.
Councilmember Kinghorn added that Mr. Klemm could hire his own expert for a second opinion.
If that expert concluded the video was inconclusive, Councilmember Kinghorn asked if the City
had ever cost-shared with a citizen.
Director Pitts cautioned that, before the elevation was raised an inch, members of the Committee
should go to #5 Sand Dollar because it is lower than #3 Sand Dollar; raising the elevation at #3
Sand Dollar would have negative unintended consequences for the property next door.
One (1) area of concern in deciding what the City is willing to do is that many areas of the island
flood more often and worse than what Mr. Klemm is experiencing. The Administrator noted that
her concern is whether there truly is a problem to repair, and, if that is the case, she advocates
for the City to repair it. She indicated that she would prefer for the City to locate a problem and
establish limits to what it would do; anything beyond that would be the property owner’s
responsibility.
Chair Ferencz said that Mr. Klemm’s second point was that the repair tha t was done was done
improperly.
Public Works Committee
March 1, 2017
Page 3 of 7
Referencing the material that was in the pipe when it was originally videoed, Director Pitts stated
that the system was cleaned, according to Eadie’s Construction, before it was vacuumed; Mr.
Klemm was with Director Pitts to see the video that showed the level of sediment in the pipe to
be minimal – material that would normally accumulate as water runoff goes through it.
2. Flapper valve on Tabby Lane
David Stevens went to the area and concluded it would be a good candidate for a flapper valve,
and the City has received an estimate for purchase, installation, sales tax and contingency of less
than ten thousand dollars ($10,000), and money budgeted in Drainage Contingency will fund it if
the Committee chooses to do so. The Administrator added that the valve would have to be main-
tained once installed.
When the island experiences the extreme high tides, the entirety of Tabby Lane is under water;
there is enough water to flood out a car.
Chair Ferencz indicated that the same circumstance occurs on 25th Avenue; Director Pitts added
41st Avenue and Charleston Boulevard at 1st Avenue experience the same.
The matter was brought to the City’s attention by Robert Ryan of 10 Tabb y Lane via an email to
Councilmember Carroll that was forwarded to the Administrator and then Committee Chair Ward.
Since this is an inconvenience that happens in extreme king tides on other streets ,
Councilmember Kinghorn again asked about cost-sharing with the residents on Tabby Lane.
Administrator Tucker said that staff could investigate whether the residents on the street would
be willing to cost-share.
The Chair opined that installing the flapper valve on this street would be setting a precedent for it
to be done on the other streets Director Pitts mentioned.
When Councilmember Kinghorn posed the question of cost-sharing to the Committee, the Chair
said that her response would be “That’s what I pay taxes for.”
The Administrator recalled that the City has paid for the placement of two (2) flapper valves; i.e.
one (1) close to the old Dangerfield property and one (1) in the area of the one hundred (100)
block of Palm Boulevard.
Concluding the discussion, the Chair repeated that staff would look int o cost -sharing by the
residents of Tabby Lane, and the Administrator said that she would contact Mr. Ryan.
3. Handicap parking spaces on 21st Avenue
Administrator Tucker reported that the County would make the necessary improvements through
Transportation Sales Tax (TST) funds, and the City will assume responsibility for on -going
maintenance. The work will be getting underway shortly.
Public Works Committee
March 1, 2017
Page 4 of 7
The Administrator noted that citizens and visitors have advocated for two (2) additional handicap
parking spaces on the opposite side of the road on 21 st Avenue. Having watched the existing
spaces for a long time, Administrator Tucker said that she has seldom seen them both being used
at the same time, and, if the spaces were to be added to the opposite side, there is no good way
for someone who is physically challenged to get to the beach . The Administrator questions that
the need exists for additional spaces at that location; she reported that another handicap parking
space has been added at 42nd Avenue.
Councilmember Kinghorn recalled that handicap access has been requested for 5th Avenue.
According to the Administrator, the C ity has responded to the person wanting access at 5 th
Avenue that the topography will not accommodate handicap accessibility because the City cannot
cut through the dune.
The list of beach accesses that are handicap accessible are noted on the City’s website.
The Administrator told the Committee that, if the beach accessible wheelchair that is housed at
the Lutheran Center is being used, the City will pay for a rental.
When Councilmember Ward asked about mobi-mat at 5th Avenue, the Administrator said it could
be done, but it must be wide enough to accommodate a vehicle since the 5 th Avenue beach
access is also an emergency access.
Director Pitts indicated that the City does not have any wide mobi -mat in stock, but it could be
ordered; he thought that one (1) emergency vehicle mat for the access at 31A was included in
the FY18 budget.
If the Committee supports putting the wide mobi -mat at 5 th Avenue, additional funds must be
included in the FY18 budget or, possibly, find money in the current year’s budget that is not going
to be used.
Certain areas of the beach require an OCRM permit to legally install mobi-mat, and the City has
four (4) applications pending with one (1) for 21st Avenue.
Since Director Pitts has not ordered mobi-mat in this fiscal year, fifteen thousand dollars ($15,000)
is available; the Director thought it was enough money to buy the wide mat for 5th Avenue.
MOTION: Councilmember Ward moved to recommend to Ways and Means the
placement of mobi-mat at 5th Avenue assuming funds are available; Councilmember
Kinghorn seconded.
Councilmember Kinghorn questioned the practicality of placing mobi-mat only part of the way to
the beach, and the Administrator replied that it meant a shorter distance for the impaired person
to be carried.
Director Pitts explained that mobi-mat cannot touch the toe of the ocean-side of the primary dune.
Public Works Committee
March 1, 2017
Page 5 of 7
Director Pitts answered that 42nd Avenue is another beach access, and the mat is already in place.
The resident who has reached out to Councilmember Ward about 5th Avenue has rental property
and has family members who use the house that are physically-challenged. The lack of handicap
parking is not an issue in this situation.
Councilmember Kinghorn then asked about the possibility of creating handicap parking in the
right-of-way, and the Administrator responded that the City could evaluate the area.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
B. Update on NPDES project
Administrator Tucker reported that the construction kickoff meeting was held the previous day,
and construction is to begin next week with a projected completion date of mid -June. The IOP
Water and Sewer Commission has set the meter ; the pre-engineered building to house white
goods is due to arrive on June 8th.
C. Update on Phase II drainage
The Administrator stated that the bid package is being prepared by Civil Site Environmental (CSE)
with the expectation of taking bids in May in anticipation of beginning construction in mid-August.
D. Update on overgrown lots on Wills Way
According to the Administrator, the property owner at #17 has been contacted and has indicated
that the lot will be cleared in a couple of weeks. On #18, the original letter was returned to the
Police Department; they have since obtained a more current address and mailed a second letter.
6. New Business
A. Discussion of stormwater fee cap for non-residential properties
Administrator Tucker recalled that Council recently p assed an ordinance to cap the fees on
residential properties; subsequent to that action, County Council has been discussing an increase
to non-residential properties and inquired about whether the City would take similar action on non-
residential properties. The opinion among staff was not to increase the fee for non -residents as
well; the County has not yet sent out commercial bills after seeing just how high some bills would
be with the proposed increase. In the course of drafting a second ordinance cap ping non -
residential fees, a statement was made by the County that they would expect the City to make up
the shortfall from its stormwater reserves for each year of the cap. The statement suggests that
the County knows how much it is going to cost for the program, and, if the City caps its fees, it
will be going into the red. With this statement, all work on an ordinance was stopped until Council
has an opportunity to hear a presentation from Charleston County stormwater personnel and to
get their questions answered before drafting an ordinance.
Public Works Committee
March 1, 2017
Page 6 of 7
With the agreement of the Committee, Chris Wannamaker and Frank Pandullo from Charleston
County will attend the next Ways and Means Committee to explain the situation.
The Administrator commented that this issue will bring to the forefront earlier discussions about
the City’s assuming responsibility for its stormwater program at some point. The County is doing
a fine job administering the program for IOP, bu t it is a large organization supporting a lot of
people, and a portion of the City’s stormwater fees is going toward support of that.
Answering the Chair’s question about what the City gets through its stormwater agreement with
the County, Administrator Tucker stated that the County insures that the City complies with the
seven (7) compliance standards associated with stormwater regulations, such as housekeeping,
public education, construction improvements and monitoring. The entity directing the progra m
must put the people infrastructure in place to do all seven (7) of the standards and document to
DHEC and EPA that they are getting done. (Councilmember Kinghorn stated that the stormwater
program is referred to as an unfunded mandate.) The fees charge d are the way to fund the
program.
Councilmember Kinghorn asked if any consideration had been given for the Council of
Governments (COG) assuming the stormwater responsibility.
The Administrator said that she did not know about discussion with the COG, but she indicated
that some local governments in the area do their own, like Mount Pleasant. When the City
approached Mount Pleasant about directi ng the program, they were not close -minded; they did
stipulate that they would do a total assessment of the City’s system to determine if they wanted
to take it on.
When the Chair asked what justification the County was presenting for doubling the fee, and the
Administrator responded that new mandates for monitoring contributed, and she speculated that
another was, after operating the program for a couple of years, they now know what the actual
administration expenses of the program are. A good reason to be with the County is that they
have been audited by EPA and gotten a clean audit.
B. Flood issues on Hartnett Boulevard
Director Pitts recalled that half way down the block from 29th to 30th Avenues, a plastic corrugated
pipe that goes between two (2) yards to help the drainage; originally it was a swale ditch. In front
of one (1) house there is a small po rtion of rip-wrap and a small piece of an open ditch; the rest
of the area has become the resident’s yard. In his opinion, the problem is the result of not having
swale ditches.
The Administrator reported that Charleston County had affirmed the Director’s assessment; they
stated that there was very little drainage infrastructure present in the area and a closed line
between 2909 and 2911 Hartnett.
The residents along that stretch of Hartnett are opposed to open ditches because there are many
small children in the area.
Public Works Committee
March 1, 2017
Page 7 of 7
According to Direct or Pitts, the ditch needs to be a depression type ditch. When asked, the
Director said he could open the ditch, but the problem is the residents it would affect; he noted
that, in the area in question, the ditch has been filled in for years.
Although the resident has been informed of the proper resolution verbally, Councilmember Ward
suggested that it be put in writing.
Director Pitts added that Hartnett does not have enough elevation for a closed system.
C. Ditch adjacent to 26 Intracoastal Court
The Administrator explained that, in this situation, the ditch has a pipe in it and the pipe ends and
the remainder is an open ditch to the outfall. The advocacy from the adjacent resident is that they
would prefer for all of the ditch to be piped.
Director Pitts added that the r esident had told him that over time erosion has occurred and the
pipe needs to go back and fill added. The Director stated that the resident could build his bulkhead
where it is now, but it could not extend into OCRM jurisdiction.
Chair Ferencz recommended that a letter of explanation be sent to the homeowner.
7. Miscellaneous Business – None
Next Meeting Date: 11:00 a.m., Wednesday, April 5th in the Conference Room
8. Adjournment
MOTION: Councilmember Kinghorn moved to adjourn the meeting at 12:25
p.m.; Councilmember Ward seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.