Special Meeting, 5:00 p.m., December 6, 2016 (PDF, 227.05 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of Dec 6, 2016 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
CITY COUNCIL
Special Meeting
5:00 p.m., Tuesday, December 6, 2016
A Special Meeting of City Council was held at 5:00 p.m., Tuesday, December 6, 2016 in Council
Chambers of City Hall, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South Carolina. Attending the
meeting were Councilmember Bergwerf, Bettelli, Carroll, Harrington, Kinghorn, Rice and Ward,
Mayor Cronin, Administrator Tucker, Attorney Halversen, Assistant Administrator Fragoso and
City Clerk Copeland; a quorum was present to conduct business. Councilmember Ferencz was
absent.
1. Mayor Cronin called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public had
been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Citizens’ Comments
FY16 Audit Presentation by Justin Kiddy and Lindsay Flynn of McCay, Kiddy and
Associates
After distributing a handout containing the highlights of the audit work-product, Mr. Kiddy reported
that the audit team did not mak e any significant journal entries to the financial information
presented by Treasurer Suggs. The first page of data presented was the year-end fund balances
for the governmental funds; the total of which was in excess of fourteen million nine hundred
thousand dollars ($14,900,000). The end ing fund balance in the General Fund was five million
six hundred dollars ($5,600,000), and the ending fund balance for the Capital Projects Fund was
approximately three million five hundred thousand dollars ($3,500,000). Mr. Kiddy stated that the
change to fund balance in FY16 was an increase of approximately two million dollars ($2,000,000)
which he attributed to the Beach Preservation Fee Fund and tourism funds. The operation of the
City has been relatively the same year over year. The primary contributors to revenue presented
as a percentage of total revenue were Intergovernmental Fu nds at twenty -nine point seven
percent (29.7%), Property Taxes at twenty -eight point nine percent (28.9%), and Licenses and
Permits at twenty-two point eight percent (22.8 %). On the expenses side of the General Fund,
Debt Service increased over FY15 as a result of re-financing the Series 2006 Bond for Fire Station
2. The Marina Fund experienced a net increase of three hundred seven thousand dollars
($307,000); the primary expense for the marina in FY16 was Professional Services related to the
Marina Redevelopment Plan . At the end of the year, the City was holding approximately two
hundred thousand dollars ($200,000) in the Volunteer Fire Department Fund. The firm of McCay,
Kiddy and Associates rendered an unmodified opinion, which is the best audit opinion available;
he noted that the auditors noted no findings, significant deficiencies or material weaknesses in
the audit process. (Copies of the audit presentation and th e full audit report are attached to the
historical record of the meeting.)
In response to Councilmember Carroll’s question about the basis of the value of the marina assets
at six point one million dollars ($6,100,000), Treasurer Suggs answered that the value was based
on the historical costs.
Mayor Cronin summarized the presentation as one where McCay, Kiddy and Associates
confirmed the City’s financial statements and that the City’s net position increased by two million
dollars ($2,000,000) in the last fiscal year. He reminded Mr. Kiddy that his firm is also obligated
to perform a controls audit.
Special City Council
December 6, 2016
Page 2 of 5
Mr. Kiddy indicated that work on the controls audit had begun and that the auditors followed up
on some of the recommendations made by the other provider; based on inquiry, the auditors
believe that those things were implemented.
Jim Raih, 3904 Cameron Boulevard, commented that he did not like that the audit presentation
did not include page numbers or footnotes.
3. Old Business
Consideration of a Contract Award to Hitt Contracting, Inc. in the amount of
$756,000 for improvements to the Public Works site to achieve NPDES compliance
Mayor Cronin noted that Hitt Contracting submitted the low bid for the NPDES project at the Public
Works site; although the Public Works Committee discussed the bid, they have not made a
recommendation to Council. It is, therefore, up to Council to decide whether to proceed with the
Hitt quote. Included in meeting packets were staff’s calculations on how the City can derive the
seven hundred fifty-six thousand dollars ($756,000) necessary from the FY17 budget. (A copy of
the calculations is attached to the historical record of the meeting.)
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to award a contract to Hitt Contracting, Inc. in
the amount of $756,000 for the NPDES project at Public Works; Councilmember
Bergwerf seconded.
In the way of background, Administrator Tucker reported that the bid process included a
mandatory pre-bid conference, and only one (1) contractor attended. As a result of that, the City
extended the bid deadline , did a dditional advertising and held a second mandatory pre -bid
conference that was attended by Hitt Contracting. An important point t o that anecdote is that
people in the construction industry are very busy; in this strong market, it is difficult to get bidders
and the pricing is reflective of the market. Hitt Contracting is a reputable contractor who meets
the requirements, and their pricing was very near what Thomas and Hutton anticipated, but the
cost is significantly more than was budgeted unless the project were to span two (2) budget years.
The total projected, estimated cost, including the balance to the contract with Thomas and Hutton
for construction management and the ten percent (10%) construction contingency, is eight
hundred forty-one thousand seven hundred dollars ($841,700). Using eighty percent (80%) of
the NPODES funds being held by Charleston County, the City would have four hundred seventy-
one thousand two hundred dollars ($471,200) to go toward the project, as well as the funds
allocated in the FY16/FY17 budgets of three hundred fourteen thousand five hundred thirty dollars
($314,530). Thus leaving a gap of two hundred forty-five thousand nine hundred seventy dollars
($245,970) to be funded.
The FY17 budget contemplates the twenty-five percent (25%) match of the grant expected from
FEMA relative to Hurricane Joaquin in the amount of two hundred twenty thousand eight hundred
thirty-eight dollars ($220,838); the State has budgeted to pay the FEMA match. Thirty thousand
dollars ($30,000) is also budgeted for a third-party assessment of the feasibility of the City’s
Special City Council
December 6, 20167
Page 3 of 5
assuming responsibility for administering NPDES regulations in-house in the future, which can be
re-budgeted in the next budget year.
The paragraphs at the bottom of the page pose the question to Council about the allocation of
these funds. The Administrator pointed out that Pub lic Works does have a tourism component
because of the increased volume of garbage that necessitates more manpower and more wear
and tear on the vehicles with twice a week garbage collection in the summer months. The
difference of two hundred forty-five thousand dollars ($245,000) could be absorbed in total in the
Capital Projects Fund, or it could be funded in a two -thirds (⅔), one -third (⅓) split with the
Municipal Accommodations Tax Fund.
Councilmember Carroll asked Di rector Pitts to give him background information on the dis-
cussions about moving the Public Works facility off the island.
Director Pitts stated that staff was tasked with investigating the possibility of re-locating the Public
Works Department a couple of years ago; they not only looked for property, but they also visited
the wash-down facilities for Charleston County and Mount Pleasant. Mount Pleasant Waterworks
was supplying their wash station, and they were struggling with over-capacity without expanding
their facility. According to Director Pitts the City would not find property in Mount Pleasant and
the closest space would be found in Cainhoy. In his opinion, trucks would take about two (2)
hours to get on to the island due to heavy traffic on insufficient infrastructure; the Caterpillar would
have to be brought to the island on an eighteen-wheeler (18 wheeler) every day.
When Councilmember Ward asked whether he and Director Kerr had looked for property near
the ports authority, the Dire ctor replied that he thought Director Kerr had found an acre in that
vicinity, but Director Pitts thought there would be a permitting issue for a public works operation.
Councilmember Carroll commented that, if the City were to buy property, it would st ill face the
same expenditure for NPDES compliance.
When the Mayor queried about the use of Municipal Accommodations Taxes for the wash-down
process, Councilmember Rice indicated that she thought it would be a good use for those funds,
and she asked about the possibility of using some State Accommodations Tax (ATAX) funds.
Administrator Tucker said that she did not think the City would need to use ATAX funds.
Councilmember Rice asked for more information about the wash-down facility since she was not
on Council when the project was originally discussed; she asked if other departments in the City
could use it to wash their vehicles as well.
Director Pitts stated that the Fire Department w ould not use this wash -down, although the
particular system to b e constructed would recirculate the majority of the water. He added that,
although the water would be filtered and cleaned, he did not think this washing apparatus should
be used on other City vehicles. As part of the maintenance program, th e equipment h as a
centrifuge to be used before the water is pumped out.
Special City Council
December 6, 2016
Page 4 of 5
VOTE: The motion PASSED on a vote of 7 to 1 with Councilmember Ward not
supporting the motion.
4. New Business
A. Consideration of amendment to sole source contract to Coastal Science and
Engineering (CSE) in the amount of $10,000 for the cultural resource survey to
include all of the proposed borrow site
The Mayor stated that CSE has not formally asked for the amendment, but it is likely that they will
because of the permitting requirement to do a cultural resource survey of the selected site and
the site of the Stone Fleet. He added that this is not a job that CSE would do, but they would hire
a third party, a coastal cultural resource person.
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to award a contract amendment to Coastal
Science and Engineering in the amount of $10,000 for an anticipated cultural
resource survey; Councilmember Bettelli seconded.
Councilmember Ward asked how much the CSE contract was before adding this money, and the
Administrator replied that it was approximately one hundred ninet y-six thousand dollars
($196,000).
Councilmember Ward asked why staff was not waiting until CSE requests the money.
Administrator Tucker stated that, since Council will not have another meeting until late January
2017, she wanted to be prepared with the money so as not to delay the project; she assured
Council that she would not execute the amendment if it was not necessary.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
B. Consideration of FY17 Meeting Schedule and Budget Process
Also in meeting p ackets were monthly calendars for 2017 with the dates and times for Ways &
Means and City Council meetings; in a number of cases, Ways and Means and Council have
been scheduled to meet the same night. In February, Council will hold a Special Ways & Means
meeting exclusively to discuss the FY18 budgets, and the regular Ways and M eans Committee
meeting will be held the next week along with City Council. On March 21st, the evening will begin
with a budget only meeting that will be followed by Ways and Means and City Council; in April,
Council will hold its meetings on the usual schedule, the third and fourth Tuesdays of the month.
In addition, the Mayor was contemplating that Committees meet in the following pattern:
1st Thursday of every month Recreation Committee
Public Works Committee
Personnel Committee
1st Monday of every month Real Property Committee
Public Safety Committee
Special City Council
December 6, 2016
Page 5 of 5
The Mayor stated that these recommendations were open to change by the Committee. Since
meeting dates have already been set for January 2017, it will not follow the model by holding
Public Safety on Thursday, January 5th and Real Property on Monday, January 9th.
In months when the first Tuesday falls in the first few days of the month, Councilmember Ward
asked whether Department Heads would have sufficient time to prepare their reports.
Director Pitts indicated that he had a conflict with Thursdays and would, therefore, like to see
Public Works moved to Wednesdays. Since several Councilmembers commented that
Wednesday was a good meeting day for them, the Thursday meetings were moved to
Wednesdays.
Staff was asked to prepare new calendars with Committee meetings added as discussed.
The large paper in packets represents the format that staff plans to use to display the FY18 budget
estimates; at the bottom are the decisions Council wi ll need to make affecting the budget.
Referring to the large sheet, Administrator Tucker stated that Council would take a global look at
General Fund revenues and expenses and the Capital Plan at the budget meeting of February
21st; for the March 21st budget meeting, staff will provide additional information and ask for some
policy decisions to be made. The Firs t Reading on the budget is tentatively scheduled for April
25th with the Budget Public Hearing on May 23 rd followed by Second Reading. Repeating the
Mayor’s comments, the Administrator said that these dates are flexible and adjustable.
Councilmember Kinghorn asked where the City stood on procurement reform since it would affect
the budget meetings.
For now, the issue has gotten cold, but Attorney Halversen voiced confidence that the ordinance
would be ready for First Reading at the January meeting.
5. Executive Session – not needed
6. Adjourn
MOTION: Councilmember Bettelli moved to adjourn the meeting at 5:58 p.m.;
Councilmember Carroll seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.