Special Meeting Visioning Workshop, 12:00 p.m., November 16, 2016. (PDF, 371.09 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of Nov 16, 2016 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL
VISIONING WORKSHOP
12:00 p.m., Wednesday, November 16, 2016
Council Chambers
1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South Carolina
The Special Council meeting was called to order at noon in Council Chambers of City Hall, 1207
Palm Boulevard, I sle of Palms, South Carolina. Attending the meeting were Coun cilmembers
Bergwerf, Bettelli, Carroll, Ferencz, Harrington, Kinghorn, Rice and Ward, Mayor Cronin,
Administrator Tucker, Attorney Halversen, Assistant Administrator Fragoso, and all department
managers of the City. A quorum was present to conduct business.
Mayor Cronin called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public were duly
notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act. The Mayor stated that
the purpose of the meeting was to look at the long-range vision of the City, i.e. where are we know
and where we potentially could go.
Vision
The Vision Statement included in meeting packets is the statement from the City’s
Comprehensive Plan that was revised last year and states how Council has embraced the view
of the island.
Councilmember Ferencz stated that she do es not think the statement captures the island; she
sees the City as more than a variety of housing styles. She asked whether the Vision Statement
wanted to bring attention to “the natural cycle of beach erosion”; she thought it should be more
positive.
Mayor Cronin commented that the Planning Commission had spent a great deal of time studying
the Comprehensive Plan in the process of updating it last year; and, once completed, City Council
approved it.
Councilmember Ferencz wanted the task of drafting a positive vision statement to be assigned to
a Committee, but the Mayor comm ented that the purpos e in giving the job to the Planning
Commission was for them to update it . Councilmember Ferencz stated that the Planning
Commission had not been tasked to re-develop the statement, but “to change words that they did
not feel were cognitive at the time.” She was in favor of a vision statement for the City that could
be used as a marketing tool, projecting the image of family, residential, natural resources, etc.
The Mayor would consider the best way to develop a more positive vision statement, but he
commented that the Vision Statement from the Comprehensive Plan was never meant to be a
marketing tool, but a document based on the City’s land use plan and the zoning maps as a
planning guide. He pointed out that this vision statement was approved through an ordinance
and he was not interested in going back through the ordinance process again.
Administrator Tucker indicated that the Vision Statement was on the Agenda for Council to decide
if it wanted a different one than what is in the Comprehensive Plan.
Fiscal Vision
Visioning Workshop
November 16, 2016
Page 2 of 17
A. Ten Year Capital Plan: Additions, deletions and refinements
Also included in the meeting packet was a list of large scale projects the City anticipates doing in
the next eighteen (18) months; he corrected the Phase II Drainage to be from 45th to 52nd Avenues.
The Mayor noted that the drainage project was awarded a half a million dollar ($500,000) grant
from the South Carolina Rural Infrastructure Authority. He stated that none of the projects are
minor, including two (2) major beach renourishment projects that are under way, the marina
redevelopment plan, the NPDES improvements at the Public Works site, etc. (The project list is
attached to the historical record of the meeting)
Councilmember Rice asked that an improved fitness room for the Recreation Center be added to
the list.
Councilmember Carroll noted that each of the items on the list has a dollar figure associated with
it; therefore, he suggested that they be prioritized. For him the highest priority should be given to
the beach renourishment projects because the City derives so much revenue from tourism.
Recalling the meetings from the previous evening, Mayor Cronin stated that Council had approved
a modification to the permit to include the entire seven miles (7 mi.) of beach, but the question
still remains how to execute a project on the west end of the island. He explained that the estimate
of a four million dollar ($4,000,000) price tag was based on ten dollars ($10.00) per cubic yard
and four hundred thousand cubic yards (400,000 cu. yds.), of sand needed to complete the
project. The estimate is also predicated on the west end project being coincident with the east
end project, resulting in one (1) mobilization/demobilization expense. When the Mayor asked the
City’s coastal engineer about using sand fr om Breach Inlet, he was told that to do that would
mean a new project with a new permit.
Councilmember Bergwerf said that the west end of the island did not need a restoration project,
saving four million dollars ($4,000,000) because the area wa s accreting as of yesterday; she
added that the beach has been accreting since the protective dunes were created. She said that
she is seeing walkways that have been covered by the accreting sand for years; she would prefer
for the City to delay actions and look at the beach on the east end in six (6) months and to have
an expert tell Council at that time if the area is in danger.
The Mayor stated that the focus of any restoration project should be to achieve a dry sand beach.
According to Councilmember Rice, when the permit is modified, the City will have five (5) years
to execute it and doing one (1) project does not necessitate doing two (2).
If the City were to use the same formula for funding a project on the east end, the City would be
a million to a million and a half dollars ($1,000,000 – 1,500,000) short of funding the project.
Councilmember Rice repeated that the use of accommodations funds for this purpose seemed
very valid and that many local governments use all of their ATAX money every year.
Visioning Workshop
November 16, 2016
Page 3 of 17
The funding for the restoration project at the east end of the island is as follows:
FY17 Budget $2,800,000 ($1,200,000 borrowed)
State of South Carolina 6,900,000
Lowe Wild Dunes 1,000,000
Stakeholders 2,100,000
The Mayor reminded Council that the City must have the stakeholder money in -hand before
applying to the state.
In addition to voicing his support for allocating a percentage of ATAX funds annual ly to beach
restoration, Councilmember Kinghorn asked that some of those funds be used for beautification
of the beach access paths, for example, uniform signage, landscaping, benches, etc.
Mayor Cronin asked the Administrator if the City had the resources to manage all of the be ach
accesses as the City would like; the Administrator said that the City does not have those
resources.
Councilmember Bergwerf suggested that the City’s landscape vendor be given the responsibility
for the improvements and maintenance of the beach ac cesses along with the green spaces on
the island.
In the way of guidance to staff, the Mayor stated that, in the future, the City would budget one
percent (1%) of accommodations tax revenue to beach preservation, if affordable.
For clarification, Administrator Tucker asked if Council had an appetite for re-directing more ATAX
money to beach restoration if it meant that ATAX could not make enough transfers -in to pay for
what it pays for now and that result in a tax increase. She got a resounding “no” from Council.
Councilmember Rice commented that she views beach restoration as a constant cycle with the
rising tides, so she thought that the City n eeded to be prepared because erosion was not going
stop.
In Councilmember Harrington’s opinion, the City coul d increase revenue by parking mobile
homes/recreational vehicles in the municipal par king lots in the off -season where currently it is
not allowed.
When the Mayor asked if the parking lot would then need a flush out area; Chief Buckhannon said
that getting utilities to the lot would be very expensive. As for waste, the Chief said t hat the lot
would have public sewer at each site or the lot would be required to have a dump station.
When asked if the revenue generated from recreational vehicles (RVs) w ould make it cost
effective to install the utilities, Councilmember Kinghorn replied that the more amenities the
location offers the higher the per night charge ; he has seen the most basic, small space rented
for fifty dollars ($50) per night. He added that the City has much to offer people who rent space
in the lot, i.e. the ocean across the street and restaurants offering ho t dogs to cuisine close at
hand, and the police department across the street for security.
Visioning Workshop
November 16, 2016
Page 4 of 17
Without any investment from the City, it could store boats in the winter months and save island
residents who take their boats out of the water from going to Mount Pleasant; Councilmember
Carroll said that people could also store RVs there.
The Mayor said that both options warrant further consideration.
Director Kerr commented that, if the City were to decide to establish RV parking, an amendment
to the City Code would be required because it does not allow anyone to sleep overnight.
Attorney Halversen said that she would look at the Code to determine if there is a prohibition for
storage.
Councilmember Bergwerf asked how many Council members would, in principle, consider using
the municipal parking lot as a RV park for maximum two (2) nig ht stays in the winter .
Councilmembers Carroll, Ferencz and Ward indicated that they would not support the activity .
Councilmember Ward said that to use the lot for winter RV storage would be against the
residential character of the island and indicated that he would prefer to see boat storage.
Referring to the list of major projects that are ahead for the City in the next eighteen (18) months,
Administrator Tucker stated that frequently a result of a visioning workshop is more work for staff;
by including the list in the packet, Council can readily see the projects on which staff are working
now.
With that statement in mind, Councilmember Carroll repeated his stance that the City needs to
hold a referendum to learn what the residents want the City to do because of the dollar amount
associated with each. He was of the opinion that the pursuing some of them would lead to a tax
increase for residents.
Considering the marina redevelopment plan, Mayor Cronin distributed a schedule with the
heading “History of Marina Funding;” he pointed out that in a couple of years the debt incurred to
purchase the marina will be paid in full. At that time, all of the lease income generated by marina
tenants and paid to the City will be available for other purposes.
Councilmember Carroll then asked if the City ATAX funds “subsidize the negative income” at the
marina, and the Mayor assured him that was not the case because lease revenue from the tenants
exceeds the amount the City pays toward the debt. The Mayor noted t hat State ATAX and
Hospitality Tax funds have been used in the FY17 budget for engineering of the marina
enhancement plan – City property tax dollars are not used for expenses at the marina. The City
has made it a practice of using accommodations taxes to fund projects like dredging, insurance,
renovation of the watersports dock, etc. The schedule shows that in the ten years (10 yrs.)
following the payoff of the marina debt, the City will receive approximately four million four hundred
fifty thousand doll ars ($4,450,000) in unencumbered revenue; therefore, the City could borrow
four million dollars ($4,000,000) against that revenue stream.
On the issue of the referendum, the Mayor indicated that it s hould be specific as far as how the
marina redevelopment will be financed and that it will not be a t ax burden on the residents. The
discussion was moot since, currently, the City does not yet have the cost estimates.
Visioning Workshop
November 16, 2016
Page 5 of 17
Councilmember Bergwerf remarked that Council has limited parking on Waterway Boulevard and
41st Avenue, but, in doing that, the marina, with its unorganized and limited parking, has been put
into a “tough spot.” In her opinion , the City must pick up its share of responsibility to fix the
parking.
Councilmember Rice asked when the City expected to receive the renderings and cost estimates
from ATM; Administrator Tucker replied that the City has not received an update from ATM related
to that in a while, but they have reached out for a copy of the bulkhead assessment.
According to Assistant Administrator Fragoso, the contract with ATM allows six (6) months to
complete that phase of work.
Mayor Cronin added that the City will not hear if it has been awarded a Boating Infrastructure
Grant until March 2017.
Administrator Tucker stated that, if the City borrows any money for the marina enhancement plan,
a section of the law states that a small number of the City’s electorate could demand a
referendum.
Councilmember Kinghorn asked whether the cash flow and the financing were such that the City
did not have to borrow, knowing that dependent on the timing of the implementation, the current
tenants’ lease payments will be available.
If the City holds a referendum, November is the natural time to hold it.
Administrator Tucker made it clear that, based on the expense of the marina enhancement, with
or without grants, and what is known today, the City could not do the job without borrowing.
The ten-year capital plan included in meeting packets extends to FY26 and on it are some big
ticket items that need discussion, for instance the 41 st Avenue roundabout for seven hundred
thousand dollars ($700,000); the consensus of Council was to remove it from the plan.
Councilmember Kinghorn asked what kind of improvements were planned for the dais for twenty-
five thousand dollars ($25,000). Administrator Tucker said that, presently, councilmembers
cannot see each other, so, at one time, reconfiguration was considered, as well as some
audio/visual improvements. Again the consensus of Council was to remove this item from the
ten-year plan. Mayor Cronin then referred to the Gateway Enhancement Phase II, 14 th Avenue
and Palm Boulevard from City Hall to 21 st Avenue; he explained that this was a beautification
project for the entrance to the island. Administrator Tucker added that also included in the project
was the undergrounding of power lines; Councilmemb er Carroll suggested a change in the
description because he thought people would then support the project. Despite the fact that City
matching funds are required, Councilmember Kinghorn stated that he strongly supported using
the funds available in the Non -standard Service Plan with SCE&G every year; oth erwise, they
just disappear.
Since this was a visioning meeting, Councilmember Ferencz asked when the City was going to
decide to move Public Works away from the entrance to the island and, possibly, off island.
Visioning Workshop
November 16, 2016
Page 6 of 17
Councilmember Kinghorn thought relocating Public Works was ”a nice idea,” but it was
impractical. A brief discussion ensued that also included outsourcing public works services.
With encouragement from the Mayor, Council agreed to leave the Gateway Enhancement for four
hundred thousand dollars ($400,000) on the ten-year plan.
No changes were made to the plan for t he Police and Fire Departments; the Mayor did point out
that the sinking fund for capital assets is projected to pay for a new seventy-five foot (75 ft.) ladder
truck in FY19 and a pumper truck and ninety-five foot (95 ft.) ladder truck in FY20.
As further guidance to staff, Councilmember Kinghorn emphasized that, when possible, capital
purchases should be thoroughly examined to determine if replacement in the fiscal year
designated could be deferred to a point in the future; Councilmember Bettelli assur ed
Councilmember Kinghorn that such examinations are a routine exercise in the budget process.
Mayor Cronin noted that the Fire Department’s trucks suffer from the salt water environment
before they accumulate high mileage; these particular trucks endured the elements 24/7 while the
Public Safety Building was constructed. Councilmember Rice reminded Council that the City
frequently sells its equipment after it is replaced.
The Mayor reported that the replacement of a thirty yard (30 yd.) Mack truck is sc heduled for
FY18 for the Public Works Department; he stated that staff was diligent about keeping equipment
for as long as possible. He also added that these trucks get a lot of use; in the wake of Hurricane
Matthew, the trucks were operating constantly for a minimum of two (2) weeks collecting debris.
When Councilmember Kinghorn asked about the City acquiring the island’s roads, Council agreed
that the City would not do it, and the fund allocation was taken off the capital plan. Mayor Cronin
told Council that, the last time he and the Administrator met with SCDOT, they brought the subject
up to the City.
Since the City is trying to increase the number of handicap accessible beach accesses,
Councilmember Rice asked if the amount allocated for Mobi-mat was sufficient.
Administrator Tucker agreed that the dollar amount should be increased especially since the use
of it on beach paths “has been favorably embraced by the community.” In discussing the
landscaping contract, staff has talked about adding a new duty to the contract for sweeping sand
off the Mobi-mat and wooden mats as part of their normal routine. Currently the Mobi-mat
inventory is used to replace worn out segments as they occur, and new Mobi-mat is put on an
access as the result of a citizen appeal. The Administrator suggested that the amount be
increased to thirty thousand dollars ($30,000) annually. For FY18, Councilmember Kinghorn
agreed to an allocation of thirty thousand dollars ($30,000) with a reassessment in the following
budget cycle.
In the Recreation Department, the largest allocation of funds is two point two -five million dollars
($2,250,000) for a swimming pool in FY21. Again Councilmember Carroll thought that a
Visioning Workshop
November 16, 2016
Page 7 of 17
referendum should be held to determine the will of the residents; Mayor Cronin stated that he did
not think a majority of Council supported the project to move it to a referendum.
Director Page said that it was easier to tell people that a pool was in the master plan than to tell
them it was not planned at all; therefore, she supported it staying on the ten-year plan.
Councilmember Ward recalled that a referendum on a pool was held in 1990 or 1991, and it was
narrowly defeated. He indicated that he supported mov ing the pool project to an out -year,
possibly seven (7) years in the future.
In leaving the pool in the plan, the notation would remind a future City Council that it has been an
topic for discussion and was a worthy consideration at that time.
In Councilmember Kinghorn’s opinion, the answer was to remove the pool from the Recreation
Master Plan.
Since the residents provided input for the development of the Master Plan , Councilmember
Ferencz did not think Council had the authority to make changes to it.
When Councilmembers were polled about the pool, the vote was five to four (5 to 4) to eliminate
it from the ten-year capital plan.
When Councilmember Harrington asked whether the City could consider a two -year (2 -yr.)
budget, he was told that state law requires local governments to have annual budgets.
Another expensive project in FY21 was the construction of another gymnasium for two and a half
million dollars ($2,500,000), also a part of the Master Plan; Council agreed to make no changes.
On the other hand, Councilmember Rice was in favor of moving the construction of a fitness
facility from FY21 to FY18, but she did not think the price tag would be two hundred fifty thousand
dollars ($250,000).
The Mayor suggested making the change to FY18 and to vet the viability of a fitness facility in the
budget process.
In an update to Council, Director Page recalled that the original quote from the architect included
a lot of things that she did not think were necessary, and she has calculated the cost of a 25 X 25
fitness space as one hundred twenty -five thousand dollars ($125,000). If the gym were to be
remodeled, a lot of it would have to be torn out and reconstructed, and it could be done. She
added that she was waiting for architectural (engineering and design) fees.
When asked if architectural and design fees were included in the one hundred twenty -five
thousand dollar ($125,000), the Director said they were not.
Councilmember Ferencz questioned that having a covered walkway at the entrance t o the
Recreation Center was necessary since it has a two hundred fifty thousand dollar ($250,000) cost.
Director Page stated that she thought it was a necessary addition; she recalled moving people
Visioning Workshop
November 16, 2016
Page 8 of 17
into the building at last year’s Easter Egg Hunt due to lightening , but, with a covered walkway,
they would have had shelter from the weather on the covered walkway.
Councilmember Rice suggested moving the walkway to FY21 so that it could be done in conjunct-
tion with the new gymnasium.
Proceeding to the projects planned for the Front Beach area, the Mayor commented that the
resurfacing of the City -owned portion of Ocean Boulevard was scheduled for next year, but he
thought that a cost of one hundred twelve thousand five hundred dollars ($112,500) was too low.
He asked whether the depressions in the road would have to be fixed before it was resurfaced,
and the Administrator responded that the City would have to figure out what was causing them
before that determination could be made.
Councilmember Bergwerf voiced concern over spending sixty thousand dollars ($60,000) on the
Breach Inlet boat ramp that is used by maybe (10) people and is part of the property owned by
Carroll Realty.
Councilmember Carroll stated that he has proposed to the City that the property owners in the
area pool their resources to pay for dredging there; he noted that the ramp is unusable from mid-
tide on. He asked if the City could apply for the permit for dredging to be paid for exclusively by
the property owners.
Councilmember Bergwerf also pointed out that a boater cannot tie up to the dock there because
it is private property.
Mayor Cronin thought that the City could seek the permit on behalf of other property owners with
legal agreements drawn up to protect the City; he added that to do so would put a burden on City
staff to administer the permit.
If the dredging area contains beach compatible sand, the Mayor thought it would be relatively
simple to pump it to front beach, but he did not think there would be a sufficient quantity of sand
for renourishment. Councilmember Carroll stated that he would donate the sand to the City.
The suggestion was made to leave the projects related to the Breach Inlet boat ramp until FY23.
Referencing the annual allocation of one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000) for dune
walkovers, Councilmember Rice confirmed that, in the future, the expense would be paid from
the one percent (1%) accommodation tax for beach preservation.
Councilmember Rice reiterated her opinion that the Front Beach area was no longer attractive
with dead grass, no mulch, broken lights, exposed irrigation pipes, etc. She stated that it was not
being cared for properly, and she asked Councilmembers for input on a solution.
Administrator Tucker said that the previous vendor was taking care of some of those issues and
was responsible to report other problems to the City so they could be fixed. Due to poor
performance, the City is planning to re-bid the landscaping contract.
Visioning Workshop
November 16, 2016
Page 9 of 17
According to the Administrator, the City needs a full assessment of Front Beach related to repairs
and replacements and identifying what needs to be done with some cost projections; in her
opinion, more than seventy-five thousand dollars ($75,000) of work needs to be done and then it
needs to be properly maintained. With the exception of the Recreation Department, none of the
City’s properties are properly maintained; the City is reactive, not proactive.
The question posed to Council was what image it wanted to project to residents and visitors alike,
and Council appeared to be in complete agreement that improvements need to be made.
Currently the City budgets sixty -three thousand e ight hundred dollars ($63,800) annually for
grounds maintenance.
Councilmember Ferencz stated that the City needs an island -wide plan from Breach Inlet to 57 th
Avenue for underground lighting, landscaping, the bike path, etc.
The Mayor suggested that t he City needs to get advice from a landscape architect , and
Councilmember Rice thought that the City should have a staff member who would be responsible
for oversight of the landscape contractor, as well as constantly visiting City -owned properties to
make repairs and handle maintenance needs when possible. With approval from the City
Administrator, when outside assistance was required, he would seek out the appropriate vendor
and oversee their work to insure that the repair/maintenance was done properly and up to City
standards.
Administrator Tucker stated that she would like to see all City -owned properties to project the
well-kept and well-maintained appearance of the Recreation Department, but that would require
getting the work done and having the people to perform the ongoing maintenance.
Responding to Councilmember Ferencz’ inquiry about the cost of the maintenance and upkeep
of the Rec Center, Director Page said that it takes a person who can assess what is going on and
what needs to be done, and them searching for whatever it takes to get that done, i.e. builder,
contractor, landscaper, etc. The City’s staff person would oversee the job.
Councilmember Ferencz expressed her opinion that the City does not have to increase personnel;
that person could be a part of the job for an outsourced maintenance company.
Mayor Cronin agreed that the City does not need someone on staff, but a competent contractor.
One (1) difference between an employee and a contractor is the pride an employee builds in a
job well done, whatever the job, not just what is in his job description or contract.
The Mayor like d the idea of outsourcing; he stated that Wild Dunes does no t have a grounds
maintenance crew, but the grounds are done by one (1) contractor who is inside the gates every
day. In Wild Dunes, Dave Kynoski has the oversight responsibility, but he also has committees ;
in addition, he does not have the level of depar tments to manage that fall to the IOP City
Administrator.
Since Council appeared to be in agreement, Councilmember Kinghorn suggested that, as part of
the budgeting process, staff be tasked with coming back to them with a recommendation to
Visioning Workshop
November 16, 2016
Page 10 of 17
accomplish the goal of having the Recreation Department level of maintenance and upkeep for
all City-owned, outside properties.
Since DOT has confirmed that they will install bike paths on both sides of Palm Boulevard, biking
safety was briefly discussed, particularly in relation to Waterway Boulevard.
Moving on to the ten-year plan for the marina, Mayor Cronin recalled that the replacement items
for the restaurant are being moved forward every year.
Councilmember Rice noted that Morgan Creek Grill has three (3) more years on its current lease,
and the City has postponed extending the lease because of the redevelopment plan. She asked
for input from Council on what they envision for the future of the restaurant.
Councilmember Kinghorn said that the City could go with year -to-year renewals until the
redevelopment project is complete and the City would be forced to do something with the lease.
The Mayor recalled that Mr. Clarke, leaseholder for the restaurant, h as offered to take
responsibility for everything if he were granted an extended lease.
Councilmember Rice thought that the City should consider re-bidding the lease in the near future
to test the marketplace; once the lease expires, the City has the rig ht to re-bid it, and Mr. Clarke
would be welcomed to bid.
Councilmember Ferencz expressed the opinion that, since the City granted the marina manager
a thirty (30) year extension, it should feel obligated to do the same for the restaurant; she pointed
out that Mr. Clarke has done everything the City has asked of him to be a good tenant.
Mayor Cronin wanted to find a way to transfer the responsibility for replacing the items on the
capital plan to the tenant.
Attorney Halversen added that part of the previous discussion was that to assume the
responsibility for these items was not economically feasible for the tenant.
In clarifying her position, Councilmember Rice said that she was trying to look forward; the end of
the lease is a few years out, and Council needs to decide how it plans to handle the issue when
it does come before them in order to get the best possible deal for the City.
Councilmember Carroll said that the tenant needs to be told that the City will be looking at a triple-
net lease with any renewal; he should know in advance what is expected to decide if he is willing
to renew under those terms.
The discussion turned to the multiple businesses operating out of the marina; Attorney Halversen
explained that, if a business has a sub-lease of a portion of the marina property to another entity
that would be a sublease that would come before City Council for approval; a written document
is not required. The lease states that all of the liability, including indemnification and other
insurance requirements, fall to the tenant; the marina tenant could ha ve other contractual
arrangements underneath him, but he is ultimately responsible to the City for everything. If the
Visioning Workshop
November 16, 2016
Page 11 of 17
City chooses not to contract with the businesses, like TidalWave Water Sport or Ecot ours, etc.,
the lease states that the tenant is encouraged to do so.
Agreement was reached to remove the replacement of the generator, walk -in freezer, sprinkler
system, and hood/ventilation system at the marina restaurant from the ten-year capital plan.
When Councilmember Ferencz asked whether the replacement of the underground storage tanks
would happen in FY17, the Administrator answered that to replace them was the goal, but it may
have to be moved to FY18.
Mayor Cronin questioned dred ging the marina again in FY18. Administrator Tucker explained
that dredging typically has a seven year (7 yr.) cycle, and that it was scheduled next year. Since
no one has expressed a need for dredging, the Mayor suggested moving the project to FY20.
Recalling that the City was not going to borrow money in order to do the beach restoration project,
Councilmember Ferencz questioned the newly -added entry for principal and interest for an
offshore project.
Mayor Cronin said that the City did not know at this time if borrowing was going to be necessary;
the budget indicates that the City will borrow for the 2017 restoration project.
Councilmember Ferencz said that she understood from earlier discussions that the City was going
to use ATAX funds, and the Mayor cautioned that the City may have to do this as early as next
month.
The Mayor was please d to report that the City’s total debt is under ten million dollars
($10,000,000); it is dropping at a rate of a millions dollars ($1,000,000) a year.
Another tool included in packets was a prediction of the General Fund in FY18 . (A copy is
attached to the historical record of the meeting.) The revenue is projected to be greater than
eleven million dollars ($11,000,000), an increase of approximately t wo hundred seventy -eight
thousand dollars ($278,000); expenditures are forecast at approximately eleven million two
hundred fifty -eight thousand dollars ($11,258,000), an increase of three hundred eighty -five
thousand dollars ($385,000). Based on these pr ojections, the funding gap is foreseen as one
hundred seven thousand dollars ($107,000).
Treasurer Suggs noted that revenues collected thus far in 2017 are relatively low, resulting in the
relatively small increases in projected revenue; as the year passes, it is very likely that the revenue
projections will increase enough to cover the predicted shortfall.
Based on the construction on the island, Mayor Cronin expects to see an increase in property tax
revenue for the first time in several years.
Councilmember Kinghorn asked what opportunities Councilmembers see for additional revenues.
The City is assured of additional revenue in FY17 coming from permits for the new hotel to be
constructed in Wild Dunes and the re-opening of The Palms hotel on Front Beach.
Visioning Workshop
November 16, 2016
Page 12 of 17
Based on the City’s success with automating the municipal parking lots, Councilmember Kinghorn
questioned the feasibility of adding a kiosk to the Breach Inlet parking lot.
Councilmember Carroll was quick to respond that the City does not own the property; it belongs
to the State.
The Administrator commented that SCDOT would allow the City to install a kiosk there like it did
when they owned Front Beach and the City installed kiosks.
Mr. Carroll had said that he would not support putting kiosks in that lot because he thought it was
a good thing that people could come to the island and fish off the bridge or go crabbing on the
beach. He stated that Breach Inlet was proba bly one (1) of the most dangerous places on the
island and swimming is prohibited , and he thought it senseless to charge people to go into an
area that is dangerous.
Councilmember Kinghorn noted that the lot is used constantly and year -round, and, therefore, a
potential of constant revenue that would reduce the shortfall in the budget.
Attorney Halversen ended the discussion when she stated that state law prohibits the use of
parking fees as a source of additional revenue; if it were an area that needed traffic control or had
safety issues, kiosks would be more favorably looked upon.
Other new revenue sources set forth by Councilmember Kinghorn were to continue pursuing
grants, an alternate use of the municipal parking lot in the off-season, and franchise fees.
Councilmember Ferencz remarked that franchise fees are passed along to consumers and feel
like an additional tax to residents.
Mayor Cronin indicated that he was willing to look at the other franchise agreements the City has,
telephone, cable, SCE&G, etc.
With the discussion of alternative uses for the municipal parking lot, Councilmember Rice asked
how boat storage fees were determined; Administrator Tucker said that the fee is typically per
foot for the length of the boat. The monthly rate charged at the IOP marina is twelve dollars ($12)
per foot. The Councilmember then asked whether the City would need additional insurance in
order to store boats on its property. The Administrator said she would need to discuss it with the
insurance representative, but she reiterated her opinion that additional lighting and security
cameras would be necessary.
Councilmember Ward stated that he has a client who has a boat storage business, and he has
found that it can be “a collection nightmare.”
Service Vision
From re search by staff, the Mayor has learned that forty percent (40%) of the students at
Sullivan’s Island Elementary School are from the Isle of Palms, approximately four hundred
students (400) attend public schools and approximately two hundred (200) attend private schools;
Visioning Workshop
November 16, 2016
Page 13 of 17
therefore, more than eight hundred fifty (850) school -age children live on the island since pre-
school age children were not included in the research . Director Kerr said that the 2010 census
indicated seven hundred sixty-eight (768) children under nineteen (19) years of age live here.
The point the Mayor was seeking to make was that Council needs to be sure that activities on the
island deal with families and children; what the City does must serve that population because it is
a large percentage of the total people on the island.
In addition, Mayor Cronin wanted Council to be aware of the island’s demographics as he sees it
as a large part of who the City is. The Recreation Department is always focused on the young
and the young-at-heart.
Outside of the Recreation Department, Councilmember Ferencz asked what the City did for the
children, and the Mayor answered that the City is looking to enhance the marina, in part, to give
it a children -friendly environment for families, freshening up the Front Beach area to make it
inviting to families, and making parking in the municipal lots free for residents in-season.
B. Establish priorities for the next two years – see above discussions
C. Streamlining initiatives
A. Budget Process
The Mayor stated that, for the past several years, every Committee has gone through the
budget(s) under its purview, and every month the Administrator has reviewed those budgets with
Council focusing on the changes – a lot of redundancy. He would prefer to break the budget into
two (2) cycles and have two (2) separate meeting s for the budget creation, i.e. one (1) meeting
for revenue and the General Fund and a second me eting for Capital Projects; two (2) meetings
dedicated solely to the budget. The Committees would be free to look at the Capital Fund budget
or capital needs for the department(s) they oversee, but the overall City budgets will be discussed
in these two (2) meetings.
Administrator Tucker said that she was hearing from individual members of Council that there has
been too much focus on a line-by-line review and that the attention should be drawn to where
there are changes, but also she would like for the group to embrace that, for the General Fund,
certain things are not going to change year over year thus avoiding the line-by-line explanations.
Staff is always willing to answer questions about what is contained in any line of the budget, but
there is no need to review it unless there is question or an aberration.
Councilmember Kinghorn commented that Council’s obligation is to come prepared, and, i f
members have questions beforehand, they should ask them beforehand. He recommended that,
in preparation of those agendas, the items with variations be identified and reported to Council.
Referencing the fund balance schedules from the meeting packets, Mayor Cronin remarked that
he has been asked how the City’s fund balances measure up to other local governments’ fund
balances and whether the City was saving too much. To learn the answer, he delved into the
financial statements of three (3) other beach communities, i.e. North Myrtle Beach, Hilton Head
Visioning Workshop
November 16, 2016
Page 14 of 17
and the City of Myrtle Beach, and he distributed copies to Councilmembers. (Copies is attached
to the historical record of the meeting.)
The Mayor noted that these communities are different from the Isle of Palms and have a different
format for the presentation of their financial information, but not dramatically so. Looking at fund
balances for North Myrtle Beach in FY15, they had a year -end balance of eleven million dollars
($11,000,000), but their community is significantly larger than the Isle of Palms; their property tax
revenue is fourteen million dollars ($14,000,000). Their fund balance for all events was just under
their property tax revenu e. In their tourism funds, they had zero fund balance in either local
accommodation tax or hospitality tax; it appears to have all be transferred to the General Fund.
Councilmember Carroll recalled that North Myrtle Beach has a very unique beach renourishment
program; the Mayor commented that the Corps of Engineers has a piece of the obligation for the
entire Grand Strand.
The end-of-year fund balance in State Accommodations Taxes for North Myrtle Beach was less
than thirty thousand dollars ($30,000) whereas IOP’s fund balance in its tourism funds is over four
million dollars ($4,000,000).
For the City of Myrtle Beach, the property tax revenue was twenty -one million dollars
($21,000,000) and an end-of-year fund balance in the General Fund was thirteen million dollars
($13,000,000), approximately two -thirds (⅔) of their property tax revenue. In their state
accommodations taxes, the fund balance was zero; it was transferred to the General Fund. In
their local accommodations taxes, the fund balance was one million three hundred thousand
dollars ($1,300,000), and the fund balance in hospitality taxes was half a million dollars
($500,000). The Mayor was surprised to see that the City of M yrtle Beach appears to use its
tourism funds as if they were a General Fund revenue stream.
The Town of Hilton Head had property tax revenue of twenty -four million dollars ($24,000,000)
for FY15; the fund balances from all government funds totaled sixty -four million dollars
($64,000,000) and included the Beach Preserva tion Fee fund balance of sixteen million dollars
($16,000,000). Hilton Head collects a two percent (2%) Beach Preservation Fee whereas the Isle
of Palms collects one percent (1%); their annual revenue to this fund is approximately six million
dollars ($6,000,000). The Mayor noted that Hilton Head has a twenty-million dollar ($20,000,000)
beach renourishment project happening now.
Recalling his opinion stated many times in the past, the Mayor said that he never likes to see the
tourism funds drop below the level of the Disaster Recovery Fund; he added that, if the City could
transfer the tourism funds to the General Fund, the City would have a Disaster Recovery Fund of
five million dollars ($5,000,000).
When the question was asked about what level of funding would the City be satisfied with, the
Mayor responded that, like one’s personal finances, it is never enough, but he pointed out that
the City’s tax rate has been stable for several years. The City has been successful in establishing
and maintaining a sinking fund from which to pay for capital assets as the need arises. As long
as the City can continue to maintain a credible fund balance and a bond rating that allows the City
to be viewed as a premiere community, it should not deviate from its path.
Visioning Workshop
November 16, 2016
Page 15 of 17
Treasurer Suggs wanted Council to understand that the City’s total fund balance of fifteen million
dollars ($15,000,000) includes savings, such as the Beach Preservation Fund, so the City is not
always going to have fifteen million dollars ($15,000,000). When the City buys the big l adder
truck, the total dollars will be reduced by approximately one million dollars ($1,000,000).
Councilmember Ferencz asked how much of the fifteen million dollars ($15,000,000) was not
reserved, and Councilmember Ward answered that the two point six million dollars ($2,600,000)
in the General Fund was unassigned. The Treasurer noted that the sinking fund money was
spread between the Capital Projects Fund, Municipal ATAX and the State ATAX fund.
The Mayor paraphrased Councilmember Kinghorn’s earlier statement that, if the worst happened
and the City had no revenue stream for a year, it could continue to function for a period of eighteen
(18) months on the existing fund balances.
B. Composition of Council
According to Mayor Cronin, the question has been raised about why the City has a nine-member
Council; typically, towns the size of the Isle of Palms have five or se ven (5-7) Council members.
If the Council were to be seven (7), everyone would be much more intent into all facets of the
operations of the City; Councilmembers would serve on more committees. He asked whether
Council would entertain beginning the process to move from nine (9) to seven (7).
Responding to Councilmember Ferencz’ question about how the number nine (9) was chosen,
Administrator Tucker stated that local lore is that, at the time discussions were going on about the
formulation of the City, the key players involved did not want anyone to be left out, so they created
nine (9) positions because these key players were a group of nine (9). The Administrator added
that she has never found any facts to substantiate that story.
Councilmember Carroll stated that the current number of Council members provides for a good
cross section of the community and a cross section of different opinions.
Councilmember Kinghorn indicated that he would support a reduction; he stated that nine (9) was
unnecessary for what Council has to do.
Since the current number has worked for over fifty (50) years, Councilmember Ward was not in
favor of a change; he added that some Councilmembers regularly talk to residents he does not
know. Some of his friends have said tha t Councilmember Ward, and possibly one (1) other, is
the only person on Council they know; therefore, they believe that he will be their voice to Council.
If representation was reduced, he contended that there would be more distance to meet between
the community and government.
Councilmember Ferencz stated that, in her first year on Council, she understood that the form of
government was strong Council/weak Mayor and that the work done by Council was done in
Committees. Presently she sees a consensus that Council needs less Committees and less time,
but, at the Council meeting the previous evening, she had only two (2) sets of minutes. Since
Councilmembers are discouraged from attending Committee meetings on which they do not
serve, and, since she was without minutes, she asked how Council was to get the information on
City Council
November 15, 2016
Page 16 of 17
which to base decisions . She opined that a reduction in the number of meetings has been
proposed to reduce the time staff spends in meetings, but they were the only ones with the
information, and she was of the opinion that, instead of committees, Councilmembers will be
meeting with the Administrator or the Assistant Administrator or the City Treasurer all of the time.
She said that the City is supposed to be a Committee -structured government, and, for her,
lowering the number of Council members was lowering the information and lowering the amou nt
of work to be done by all; she did not understand why this discussion was taking place.
Councilmember Bettelli commented that Council was simply having a discussion, and, on the
subject of the minutes, he pointed out that this meeting was takin g place on the fift eenth of the
month when it is typically later; with staff’s workload, he thought it was an impossible task because
Council does not want overtime to get them completed. He suggested that committee members
take notes on the meetings they attend.
Councilmember Kinghorn acknowledged that he has supported reducing the number of
committee meetings and has provided Council with his reasoning; currently Council has, at least,
two (2) meetings every week year -round. He commented that the number equates to over one
hundred (100) meetings a year that staff must support; he sked that Council consider how staff’s
time could be spent more productively. The Mayor’s statement that a council of seven (7)
members would be more involved was true, but that did not mean more meetings. In his opinion,
the purpose of a meeting was to validate something, to provide supervision and to set policy; the
real work does not take place in a meeting; Council should be studying, doing research and/or
assessing things and come prepared to contribute to an effective meeting. His proposal has not
been to eliminate meetings but to reduce the frequency by half. He remarked that what was
effective when the City was originally formed might not be effective today.
Councilmember Ward pointed out that the form of government was changed in the 1990s from a
strong mayor to strong council.
C. Reform of frequency and content of meetings
Mayor Cronin proposed scheduling committee meeting s on the same day and time each month
like Ways and M eans and City Council meetings; if that were done, everyone could look ahead
twelve (12) months knowing what meetings are happening and when. If a committee had no
reason to meet, it would not meet.
Voicing his support, Councilmember Ward s tated that the public should know that committees
have a set time for each committee to meet.
Administrator Tucker noted that to have the Public Safety Committee meeting on the first Tuesday
of the month would make it difficult to have the departmental reports ready.
The Mayor indicated that he might schedule several combined Ways and Means Committee and
City Council meetings in the coming year. He told Council that he would work with staff to prepare
a meeting calendar for 2017 for Councilmembers to r eview at an upcoming meeting. One (1)
change he wanted to make was to have the November meeting after Thanksgiving rather than
before in 2017. In March, the CALEA conference falls between Ways and Means and Council;
Visioning Workshop
November 16, 2016
Page 17 of 17
therefore, he proposed holding Ways and Means and Council meetings on the fourth Tuesday
along with a budget meeting one hour (1 hr.) before Ways and Means. Brief consideration was
given to permanently holding Ways and Means Committee and C ity Council meeting s on the
same day.
Mayor Cronin summarized the meeting as one when Councilmembers shared a lot of information
and maybe improved the process to be able to start the New Year “with feet on the ground
running.”
3. Adjournment
MOTION: Councilmember Carroll moved to adjourn the meeting at 4:08 p.m.;
Councilmember Bettelli seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.