November 8, 2016 (PDF, 346.21 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of Nov 8, 2016 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Real Property Committee
9:30 a.m., Tuesday, November 8, 2016
The regular meeting of the Real Property Committee was held at 9:30 a.m., Tuesday, November
8, 2016 in the City Hall Conference Room, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms South Carolina.
Attending the meeting were Councilmembers Harrington and Rice, Chair Bergwerf, Administrator
Tucker, Assistant Administrator Fragoso and Clerk Copeland; a quorum was present to conduct
business.
1. Chair Bergwerf called the meet ing to order and acknowledged that the press and public
had been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Harrington moved to approve the minutes of the regular
meeting of September 8, 2016 as submitted; Councilmember Rice seconded and the
motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
MOTION; Councilmember Rice moved to approve the minutes of the Special
Meeting of September 16, 2016 as submitted; Councilmember Harrington seconded
and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
MOTION: Councilmember Harrington moved to approve the minutes of the
regular meeting of October 10, 2016 as submitted; Councilmember Rice seconded
and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments
Presentation by Johnson, Mirmiran & Thompson (JMT) on the Results of the Marina
Bulkhead Evaluation
David Osgood, an engineer representing JMT, stated that he had done the field work for the
report; upon visiting the marina, Brian Berrigan, marina manager, voiced concerns about the
amount of soil he was routinely adding on the landward side of the bulkhead. In investigating the
site, the first observation was that the weep holes in the wall were f ailing, allowing the soil to fall
out; the concern was the volume of soil that was being added and that it exceeded the amount
visible from outside the wall. Before recommending that the weep holes be replaced, JMT wanted
to be sure that nothing else was happening to cause the erosion.
JMT was given all of the documents from the construction documents, including the geotechnical
reports and borings from the original design; they were, in turn, given to the geotechnical staff at
JMT. If the marina had a major settlement issue behind the wall, it would risk the buildings and
parking lots adjacent to it. JMT did an analysis of the borings in an effort to investigate more
thoroughly, they had and also cut five (5) cores, or observation holes, through the c oncrete cap
of the bulkhead, to investigate the conditions between the walls and under the concrete cap. The
amount of fill being lost ranges from two feet (2 ft.) in some areas to as much as four feet (4 ft.);
there were a few locations where it was still in place. Most of the wall in front of the marina store
was completely voided underneath the entire run. The chances of the settlement occurring below
are basically impossible; this was substantiated by some of the pictures included in the report that
Real Property Committee
November 8, 2016
Page 2 of 11
show standing sand behind the wall in the areas where it is leeching through. JMT believes that
there is any no extra geotechnical settlement that anyone could have foreseen occurring.
JMT’s coastal specialist analyzed the number of recent storms and the king tides; based on the
analysis, she concluded that most of the fill is washing out into the Intracoastal Waterway.
JMT states that
“Based on our observations, it can be stated to a reasonable degree of engineering
certainty that we are confident the weep drains are faulty, were damaged somehow or
were not installed properly during construction which is negatively impacted by sheetflow
of rainwater running into the wall, therefore, causing the fill between the original wall and
the new sheet pile wall to erode.”
The deficiencies to be remedied are
(1) A large number of the two inch (2 in.) in diameter well -points installed in the wall as
weep drains are faulty;
(2) A large quantity of fill between the walls is missing or has been lost through the seep
holes; and
(3) Another considerable factor in the missing fill is the apparent lack of consideration of
the surface flow during a rainfall event.
Based on those deficiencies, JMT has the following recommendations to the City:
(1) There is always the “do nothing” option.
(2) To provide the most longevity and surety to the City, JMT recommends demolishing
the concrete cap in order to gain access to the back of the steel sheet pile wall to gain access to
the back of the steel sheet pile wall and expose the buried timber wall. Excavate the fill between
the walls along the entire length of the bulkhead and remove the existing weep drains. Each
weep drain location will then be replac ed with a JETfilter®, or engineer approved equivalent
product, the entire excavation lined with fill fabric and backfilled with a combination of SDOT #67
stone, pea gravel and quality fill material. Other activities, described in the report, will also need
to occur to give the City the best results; this solution will take approximately one hundred ten
(110) days and cost an estimated three hundred ten thousand dollars ($310,000).
(3) A less invasive option would be to demolish the current weep drains in place and
refitting with JETfilter®, or other engineer approved equal product, utilizing the same hole. It
would then be recommended to demolish the concrete cap, back fill, as necessary, the void areas
between the two (2) walls, installing the Ffrench drain or curb and gutter system behind the timber
wall and recast the concrete cap . With this option, there is no excavation or installation of 57
stone, the contractor would replace the weep drains from the upside and back fill sand. With all
of the work included, this method would take approximately ninety (90) days and cost
approximately two hundred sixty thousand dollars ($260,000).
(4) The least invasive option would be to demolish the current weep drains in place and
refitting with JETfilter®, or engineer approved equal product, utilizing the same holes and back
filling the voids, without complete demolition of the concrete, by pumping fill material through the
various core hold locations. This method would take an estimated fifty -five (55) da ys and cost
approximately one hundred eighty thousand dollars ($180,000). While the least expensive repair
option, it is very unlikely that this will provide a one hundred percent (100%) fill of the void.
Real Property Committee
November 8, 2016
Page 3 of 11
Administrator Tucker’s first question was about what kind of permitting would be requi red and
whether each option has the same permitting requireme nts. Mr. Osg ood responded that the
project should not require any permitting for the options presented because it would be considered
a minor repair to the existing wall, i.e. maintaining the existing wall.
Councilmember Rice inquired about the availab ility of contractors and was told that they could
potentially have to wait due to the work created by Hurricane Matthew. Mr. Osgood stated that
the only part of the work that would require any type of specialty work is the work on the opposite
side of the wall because it will be over the critical line.
One (1) drawback to option 2 is that the work can only be done at low tide.
In the least expensive option, would there be a risk that the problem would continue over time,
and the City would have to pay the additional money anyway. According to Mr. Osgood, if the
weep drains were replaced, the problems should stop.
Councilmember Rice said that she was not prepared to make a decision because she knew other
people she wanted to consult.
Mr. Berrigan indicated that he agreed with Councilmember Rice in that he would like more time
to study the report prepared by JMT; if the City were to select option 2 that will require one hundred
ten (110) days, it must be coordinated with other projects that might be going on, for example the
replacement of the underground fuel tanks. He also voiced alarm over the statement “Once an
option is selected, more detailed estimates could be provided through further engineering and
analysis.”
The Administrator asked Mr. Osgood if there were any marinas or bulkheads in the area that may
have experienced something similar and had to go back and retrofit. She thought it would be
helpful to reach out to them and learn about their experience. Mr. Osgood agreed to research
and get back to her, and he added that, typically, the problem is that the bulkhead was constructed
without any weep drains.
4. Comments from Marina Tenants – None
5. Old Business
A. Public Restrooms – Evaluation of amount of possible work to be done based
upon new appraised value
Administrator Tucker explained that this work had taken a long time because the City has had a
hard time getting contractors to respond because they are so busy since Matthew.
Director Kerr started with the handout about the fifty percent (50%) rule; he explained that it was
based on the original analysis, but the numbers have been updated, but, generally the pros and
cons still hold true despite being several years old. He reviewed the financial analysis as follows:
Real Property Committee
November 8, 2016
Page 4 of 11
New 2016 appraised value $325,000
50% of appraised value of structure $162,500
Cost of repairs done in prior 5 years <0>
if work begins October 2017
Limit of work that can be done $162,500
Contractor’s estimate to replace fixtures, $173,000
add ventilation, repair rust and paint
In the second page listing the repairs, Director Kerr commented that the estimate of twenty -
thousand dollars ($20,000) for doors and petitions has not be confirmed by the contractor; he also
informed the Committee that the one hundred seventy -three thousand dollars ($173,000) does
not include design, permitting, demolition and the showers, which will not count against the fifty
percent (50%) rule.
In the Director’s opinion, some costs could be refined or something eliminated in order to stay
under the ceiling of one hundred sixty-two thousand five hundred dollars ($162,500). Whether or
not painting would count against the fifty percent (50%) rule would be dependent on how it is
done; if the painting were to be done by City staff, it woulddoes not go against the fifty percent
(50%).
The biggest con at this point is that, if the City spends the full fifty percent (50%) and a storm were
to blow off a section of the roof, the building would have to be demolished and rebuilt. Committee
members remarked that the building has withstood sev ere weather thus far without serious
damage.
To compound issues, the City has received the preliminary, updated flood maps that are a year
to eighteen (18) months from being adopted, and, in these maps, the public restrooms go from a
V zone to a zone id entified as AO. This AO zone would still require elevation, but would allow
flood proofing, which is not allowed in the V zone. Director Kerr stated that he did not know, from
an engineering stand point, whether it was possible to flood proof a building in a V zone, but if it
were possible, the City could arrange to have it flood proofed, making it flood compliant and no
longer subject to the fifty percent (50%) rule. The question to be answered by an engineering
analysis is whether or not the building, as it stands today, could withstand the pressure of the
water if it were flooded up to three feet (3 ft.). The Director reiterated that the new flood maps
and associated requirements were twelve to eighteen (12-18) months away being applicable. He
also explained to the Committee that he did not want to underplay the amount of work necessary
to flood proof the building; to structurally reinforce an existing wall would going to be a major
undertaking.
Councilmember Rice repeated that the present conditions in the public restrooms were deplorable
and some kind of improvement must be done before the coming beach season.
Director Kerr suggested that the Committee go through the proposal and detail it out because the
scope of work is very narrow. Staff felt that priorities should be getting natural light and ventilation
into the building and getting rid of the rust and making it really clean inside. The idea for adding
windows is to have a two (2) bank of windows right under the roof.
Real Property Committee
November 8, 2016
Page 5 of 11
Chair Bergwerf recalled discussions of just knocking out some of the cement blocks at the roof
line.
Director Kerr responded that staff has discussed knocking out the blocks and putting in possibly
the glass-block panes to let light into the building. Many of the plumbing lines have been cut and
patched over the years, so the intention is to re-plumb the portion of the lines that feed the toilets
and sinks. New toilets and sinks would be installed. The plywood ceilings would be replaced by
slats that would allow air to go up into the attic, escape the restrooms with two (2) exhaust fans
above them on each side – one fan would draw air in and the second would blow it out. The
electrical wiring for the lights and all of the lighting would be replaced also. The partitions would
be replaced with a slick plastic material that is made into partition doors and would withstand the
abuse and salt air environment. Included in the accessories were the grab rails for the handicap
accessibility components, toilet paper holders, etc. Once the work has been completed, someone
walking into the building and, other than being clean and with more light and fresh air, it would
still be very much the same building that is there now, but it would be considerably better than it
is now.
When Councilmember Harrington asked for an explanation of the difference between main -
tenance and construction; he did not think the replacement of toilets and sinks should be included
against the fifty percent (50%) rule. The Director said that the key distinguishing factor between
the two (2) was that w hether the work requires a permit; he also noted that the building permit
requirements do not allow costs to be subdivided out if there are multiple components to a pro -
ject. The various components are combined into one (1) contract that counts against the fifty -
percent (50%) rule. If the City were to do the work unrel ated to the contract, it would not count
against the rule, but Director Kerr expressed the opinion that the City would prefer to have all of
the work done by one (1) contractor at the same time.
Administrator Tucker stated that, due to the dollar amount, this work would have to be bid out.
The Administrator also told the Committee that, if in eighteen (18) months the new regulations
stand, to build a new facility would likely be less than the one point three million dollars
($1,300,000) originally thoug ht since it would not have to be ele vated as much. Staff is not
evaluating what it would cost for a new facility, but is waiting until a final decision on the flood map
is made.
If the Committee were to proceed with these improvements, Director Kerr asked if an engineering
analysis of possible flood proofing would be beneficial.
Before the work can go out to bid, the City would need to get bidding documents and guidance
from an architect or engineer.
When the FY17 budget was prepared, consideration wa s given to doing something about the
public restrooms during the year; it includes approximately one hundred ten thousand dollars
($110,000) related to engineering and design for new restrooms in contemplation of constructing
a new building. If the engine ering for these changes were to be less, some funds would be
available in this budget year to accomplish some of the work, and savings in other parts of the
budget might be sufficient to make up the difference.
Real Property Committee
November 8, 2016
Page 6 of 11
Voicing skepticism, Administrator Tucker said that she was reluctant to do the renovations and
the flood proofing; she thought a better approach would be to complete this list of work and to
look at the flood proofing later.
Looking into the future, Director Kerr stated, that, if the City goes through this effort and the quotes
received are all too high, i.e. exceeding the threshold of one hundred sixty -two thousand five
hundred dollars ($162,500), the Committee would need to prioritize the list of work or try to
negotiate a lower price.
The Director also sought guidance from the C[MC1]ommittee about whether to design and bid the
restroom improvements with the showers and boardwalk or to bid them separately; he did note
that, for the efficiency of going through the process as a staff, doing them together as one (1)
project would be optimal.
MOTION: Councilmember Rice moved to proceed with the preparation of
design documents to bid the improvements to the public restrooms, the exterior
showers and the handicap accessible boardwalk ; Councilmember Harrington
seconded.
Director Kerr confirmed that OCRM has issued the permit for the boardwalk.
Councilmember Rice thought that the Committee and staff should take whatever steps possible
to complete the restrooms improvements before the season begins in earnest in May.
The Administrator said that the Committee needed to discuss logistics since, typically few, if any,
Committee meetings occur in December. She, therefore, asked if the Committee wanted to offer
staff parameters relative to the design and someone to produce the design. Up to this point, all
of the work has been done by Liollio Architecture; Administrator Tucker asked whether the
Committee wanted to continue with Liollio or, since this project is smaller, look to a smaller firm.
If staff can engage a company to begin work on the design quickly, it might save a month for the
Committee to select a design firm that would then need a month to do the design and prepare the
bid documents, another month for the bids and the award of a contract. Spring would be looming
and the Committee would again have to decide whether to proceed with the project or wait until
after the season.
Chair Bergwerf voiced the opinion that the restroom improvements was not complicated and
should not require any “fancy” design work.
Director Kerr explained that the boardwalk and shower would need design work, and, since the
work involves cutting into the walls, input from a structural engineer was necessary.
Since Liollio has knowledge and experience with the building, Councilmember Harrington was in
favor of continuing with them; he added that to do so might be more cost efficient.
Administrator Tucker stated that it would be good if the contract award for engineering and design
could be awarded in November so they could be working through December to prepare bid
documents that could be advertised.
Real Property Committee
November 8, 2016
Page 7 of 11
Responding to Councilmember Rice, the Administrator commented that the contract to be
awarded would be for design, bid documents and construction oversight as well.
Director Kerr indicated that he has spoken with Liollio, and they had given him the impression that
they could have a proposal for inclusion in meeting packets for November 15th.
AMENDMENT: Councilmember Rice amended the motion to include “in an
amount not to exceed $50,000; ” Councilmember Harrington seconded and the
amendment PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
AMENDED MOTION: The amended motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
On a related subject, Councilmember Rice recalled a conversation from a previous meeting that
the attendant appears not to report issues on a timely basis so that they can be handled by the
City.
Chair Bergwerf said that, since the attendant apparently spends most of her time in the small
room in the public restrooms, most people are unaware that someone is on duty; she indicated
that one (1) thing that should be included in the new desig n was to have a large window in the
door into the small office area.
Director Kerr reported that the attendant tends to keep the door closed and that someone must
knock if he/she is needed for some reason.
The Administrator reported that the person wit h the contract is a subsidiary of “My Favorite
Things;” years ago, City Council decided that they wanted a person there any time the facility was
open. The attendant restocks supplies as they are needed, clean things and is supposed to notify
the City when something needs to be repaired. Administrator Tucker said that time has come to
re-bid that contract; the contract actually expired several years ago and has been automatically
renewed on an annual basis. She did caution the Commit tee that bids come could come in for
much more than the City is currently paying because it is difficult to find people who will do that
kind of work.
Councilmember Rice supported re-bidding the contract, but, in the interim, she thought it would
be beneficial to meet with the “My Favorite Things” representative to review the contract.
From previous talks with this company, Director Kerr said they understand the Attendant’s job to
include carrying out the trash, minor cleaning, re-stocking the paper supplies and reporting to “My
Favorite Things” who contacts Director Pitts, who is already overwhelmed; therefore, at times,
things “fall through the cracks.”
Director Kerr thought that the City needed two (2) separate contracts, i.e. one (1) who takes
inventory of the facility, lights and plumbing, etc. on a regular daily basis and a second contract
for the attendant. In his opinion, to expect Director Pitts to put his work aside for a morning to
replace a light bulb was cumbersome and inefficient process; the City doe s not have the man --
power to tend to all of those things all of the time.
Real Property Committee
November 8, 2016
Page 8 of 11
B. Status of 49th Avenue beach access
Administrator Tucker reminded the Committee that the City obtained a permit to repai r the 49 th
Avenue beach access and awarded a contract for the work prior to Hurricane Matthew; as a result
of Matthew, changes to the configuration have occurred and might require less work than
originally planned.
Director Kerr reported that, a few days after Matthew, the contractor that was on the beach to
construct the protective dunes actually did eighty percent (80%) of the work needed for the 49 th
Avenue access. With this work done, the scope of the contract with Petersen Grading was
significantly changed; the problem is that what is at that access now does not comply with the
stipulations of the OCRM permit. OCRM defined v ery specific elevation requirement s in the
permit, i.e. that the grade go from seven (7) at the road down to six (6) and have a berm at the
end; that has not yet been done, but getting to that point should be relatively easy now . The
surveyor has set the grades according to OCRM’s permit, and then Petersen Grading will finish
the job in a couple of weeks.
C. Status of Local Comprehensive Beach Management Plan
Administrator Tucker was pleased to report that the City has gotten all of the comments back from
OCRM and has begun to respond to them; that work product is in Chris Jones’ hands to draft
them to send back to OCRM to ensure that the City has satisfied the concerns they had. None
of OCRM’s comments were unsurmountable, but more things they wanted the City to think about
and speak to in the Plan. The Administrator said that she was hopeful that the update would be
complete in about six (6) weeks.
D. Update on beach restoration
The Administrator said that the post-Matthew survey has been done , and the City has received
the updated results from Coastal Science and E ngineering concerning losses associated with
Hurricane Matthew. Following the same model that was used after Joaquin, the FEMA pro-rated
share would be one million two hundred forty-three thousand dollars ($1,243,000) relative to the
quantity of sand lost which was eighty -four thousand eight hundred twelve cubic yards (84,812
cu. yds.). Administrator Tucker remi nded the Committee that FEMA will only allow work to be
done in the area they describe as an engineered beach, a beach created with a beach
renourishment project. If the City should decide to expand the scope to include areas outside the
53rd Avenue to Dewees Inlet area, it could not look for FEMA participation.
In other happenings, the State Historic Preservation Office (SCHPO) has become compliant to
listen to an alternate proposal as a result of excellent advocacy on the City’s behalf from the City’s
contact in the state Emergency Management Division. The City will be requesting the ability to
harvest, if necessary, within the area that is designated as a proposed historic district. The permit
application was sent in showing more areas of harvest than just that area, but the City wants to
maintain the possibility of going there under certain conditions if pumping out of some of the other
areas and encountering bad material. The City needs to be able to go forward with that advocacy
for future renourishment projects.
Real Property Committee
November 8, 2016
Page 9 of 11
The Wild Dunes Community Association (WDCA) has notified the participants in the next beach
restoration project what their share of the expense will be, which is important because the City is
working on the grant application to be submitted to the state for funding a portion of the fifteen
million dollar ($15,000,000) project. The application will be incomplete and will not be accepted
until the City can demonstrate that it has all of the money.
The Administrator then conveyed Jim Smiley’ s message as she understands it, and she does
think it is worthy of consideration. When the City began its beach restoration initiative in 2007, it
was in response to a critical situation, and the project was structured around that critical situation.
The City did look at other beach communities that were doing beach restoration, Hilton Head
being one (1); in the Administrator’s opinion, they have one (1) of the best programs in the state,
they have been doing it a long time, it is very comprehensive and does encompass their entire
shoreline. If it should be the will of Council, the permit could be modified to include other areas
of the island that need beach renourishment with the same dredging company and the same
trucking company; it would require boosters on the pumps, that are an added cost, for a rough
estimate of four million dollars ($4,000,000) added to the project. In Admin istrator Tucker’s
opinion, to consider that option was in keeping with the City’s position that it is responsible for the
entire shore line; that is the premise under which the City has done the survey monitoring and the
additional mon itoring at Breach Inlet when it appeared to be in critical shape. Other than
emergency work that was done a fter Matthew, renourishment projects have not been designed
to include the entire seven miles (7 mi.) of shoreline. Therefore, the question is whether or not
there is appetite for quickly amending the permits and the additional expense, should it be
affordable, to add those areas on the western end of the island, i.e. approximately from 10 th
Avenue to Breach Inlet.
Chair Bergwerf asked if the survey results indicate that work is needed on the western end of the
island, and the Administrator confirmed that there had been sand loss along the western end.
As a resident of that area of the island, the Chair stated that this area often has sand loss, but it
always comes back.
According to the Administrator, the question is that there has been sand loss from Matthew and
does the City want to replace it with an expansion of the project that is proposed to begin in
January 2017.
Based on Mr. Smiley’s comments, Councilmember Rice considered taking a percentage, maybe
two percent (2%), of ATAX money to go to r enourishment as a budgeted item all the time; she
thought there was an excess, and that it was legal to use ATAX funds in this way.
Administrator Tucker thought that the WDCA has scheduled a meeting for November 11th, but an
invitation was not extended to the City to attend, but she thought that attendance by
Councilmembers would be not be a problem. The purpose of the meeting is to brief the property
owners who will have to pay the money, and, although she will not be able to attend, the Mayor
is planning to be there; she noted that she did not know whether Coastal Science and Engineering
(CSE) would be represented.
Real Property Committee
November 8, 2016
Page 10 of 11
Chair Bergwerf commented that sand was still being pushed up around 8th and 9th Avenues; she
wanted to know if the property owners were paying for the work.
Administrator Tucker confirmed that the owners were financing the work; these people have
gotten their own emergency orders from OCRM.
6. New Business – None
7. Miscellaneous Business
Tenant Rents – All tenants are current.
Conscious of timing, Administrator Tucker stated, that, if there is a desire to amend the permit
and to do restoration in areas west of 53 rd Avenue, the decision needs to be made now so a
recommendation would need to be made to the Ways and Means Committee and Council next
week.
Chair Bergwerf said that she did not know enough to make a decision on the permit; the
information was “too new.”
Councilmember Rice said that she needs to make a fi eld trip to the portion of the beach being
considered for inclusion; she indicated that she has walked it and seen the dangling steps, but
four million dollars ($4,000,000) is a lot of money. She would also like to hear the thinking from
CSE; she asked the Administrator if someone could attend the meeting on Tuesday.
Mr. Smiley stated that, regardless of doing a project between 10th and Breach Inlet and regardless
of the additional cost, he wants to have Council consider the island’s public beach as a unit, and
do what is necessary to maintain it as the lovely beach that it is. He also would like to end the
thinking that this is a Wild Dunes project that the City is “acting as front man for;” the City has
done that for years, and thus far, it has worked b ecause there have not been any “hotspots”
outside of Wild Dunes. That has contributed to the island-side mentality of them versus us.
Mr. Smiley opined that the City should submit its OCRM permit application “knowing whatever
needs to be done is going to be done or that [the City] cannot afford to do it .” Since the permit
application was filed on November 2nd, Mr. Smiley was of the opinion that the application should
be amended now to include “restoration of sand deficient areas on the entire beach.”
Councilmember Rice voiced concern about how stakeholders should be approached on the west
end of the island; she thought the idea of using a percentage of ATAX funds annually for beach
restoration was a very sensible one.
Chair Bergwerf contended that the City has always taken care of the entire beach and that, in her
opinion, the public relations had created the “them versus us” attitude on the island.
The Administrator said that the strategy would be to amend the permit and the area for additional
dredging could be bid as an alternate, but the four million dollars ($4,000,000) is a complication
that was not anticipated in the budget. She added that the City did not know how the property
Real Property Committee
November 8, 2016
Page 11 of 11
owners in that area would feel about participating in the funding; Administrator Tucker noted that
CSE had indicated that the modification could be accomplished with little work on their part and
at a small price.
Chair Bergwerf stated that this is an area of the beach that she walks on every day, and she sees
a beach that is in the condition it was fifteen (15) years ago. The beach before Matthew was the
result of “incredible accretion” that now has been lost; based on the rate of accretion, she
questioned the need for a renourishment project on the west end of the island. She indicated that
she needed much more information from the experts to support a project; she repeated that the
beach is where it was years ago.
Mr. Smiley agreed with the Chair, but added that getting the modified permit for the entire island,
the City would be free to address erosion problems as they come up.
MOTION: Councilmember Harrington moved to recommend to the Ways and
Means Committee amending the permit for beach renourishment to include the
entire shoreline; Councilmember Rice seconded and the motion PASSED
UNANIMOUSLY.
Next Meeting: 9:30 a.m., Monday, January 9th in the Conference Room.
8. Executive Session – not necessary
9. Adjournment
MOTION: Chair Bergwerf moved to adjourn the meeting at 11:10 a.m.;
Councilmember Harrington seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.