November 2, 2016 (PDF, 218.9 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of Nov 2, 2016 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
PUBLIC WORKS COMMITTEE
11:00 a.m., Wednesday, November 2, 2016
The regular meeting of the Public Works Committee was held at 11:00 a.m., Wednesday,
November 2, 2016 in the City Hall Conference Room, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South
Carolina. Attending the meeting were Councilmembers Ferencz and Kinghorn, Chair Ward,
Administrator Tucker, Public Works Director Pitts, Assistant Administrator Fragoso and City Clerk
Copeland; a quorum was present to conduct business. Also present was Mark Yodice of Thomas
and Hutton.
1. Chair Ward called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public had
been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Kinghorn moved to approve the minutes of the
regular meeting of October 11, 2016 as submitted; Councilmember Ferencz
seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments – None
4. Departmental Reports for October 2016 – Director Pitts
The Director noted that the miscellaneous garbage collections were approximately fifty (50) tons
due primarily to the large amount removed from Beachwood East after Matthew. The City’s three
(3) pumps were deployed to 46 th, 50th and 52nd Avenues following Matthew; they ran for several
days. On October 10th, Charleston County deployed the disaster debris removal contractor, and
they deployed additional resources on October 13th, beginning at 21st Avenue. Due to the volume
of debris generated by Matthew, a debris transfer station was set up in the municipal parking lot
to expedite the debris removal from residential streets. In addition, Charleston County cleaned
the ditches on 26 th and 27th Avenues as well as Forest Trail. During the month, Public Works
personnel also straightened and installed sundry street signs through the island.
Staff held the bid opening for the NPDES wash-down project; the City received two (2) bids; they
are currently under review and were as follows:
Addendum 1 Addendum 2
IPW Construction $793,705.00 ($9,500) $8,600
Hitt Contracting, Inc. $756,000.00 ($1,989) $5,885
As Mr. Yodice had warned staff, pricing on everything related to co nstruction is extremely high,
but, due to the urgency of the project, the City chose to proceed with the bidding process. The
bid went out with two (2) adden da, i.e. construction of a driveway with asphalt rather t han con-
crete and replacement of the wood fence along 13th Avenue.
Administrator Tucker stated that staff was not asking the Committee to make a recommendation
to Ways & Means at this meeting; she reported that staff is pleased with the qualifications of the
low bidder Hitt Construction and Thomas and Hutton has had good experience with them in the
past. Based on those past experiences, Mr. Yodice is going back to Hitt in an effort to negotiate
lower pricing.
Public Works Committee
November 2, 2016
Page 2 of 5
Mr. Yodice reported that he has spoken with Hitt, but they have not yet met across the negotiation
table. They voiced willingness to work with the City to find some alternate ways to reduce costs.
Hitt indicated that they were going to brainstorm within their company and with suppliers; Thomas
and Hutton has a couple of items they have identified that would change the finished product to
some degree. Thomas and Hutton will present the options to the City for consideration after the
meeting.
If that can be done between now and Ways & Means, the project can be discussed further at that
meeting; otherwise it will come back to the Committee for more discussion and an analysis of the
funding. When reviewing the FY17 budget, it wa s clear that the kind of numbers the low bidder
put forth we re not there; therefore , staff and the Committee must carefully examine the
affordability of moving forward in this fiscal year, what the participation would be on the part of
Charleston County NPDES (originally the expected participation was $190,000) and the fact that
some components would not qualify as NPDES qualifying activities. The Administrator noted that
the City has more NPDES funds available that are being held by the County, but the City might
need to exhaust all but twenty percent (20%) of those funds.
When Councilmember Ferencz questioned that the City should give both bidders the opportunity
to lower their bids, the Administrator reported that questions on the qualifications of the other
bidder have come up. Mr. Yod ice commented that the City would be well within the contract
language to negotiate with only one (1) bidder; in addition, he noted that the bid had not drawn a
lot of interest among prospective bidders because they are so busy at this time with routine,
money-making projects.
Chair Ward thanked Mr. Yodice for his work on the City’s behalf.
Returning to the Public Works monthly report, Director Pitts reported that garbage was up a little
bit for the month, but was probably on average for the current five (5) year period. Although yard
debris was up, the report only covers through the 18 th of the month; on that date, the City took
debris to the transfer station in the municipal parking lot. The County’s debris removal contractor
has two (2) large trucks in the parking lot loading at 6:00 a.m. each day; Direct or Pitts estimated
that six or eight (6 or 8) truckloads remain to be removed. Vehicle maintenance for the month
was average despite tire purchases.
Chair Ward congratulated Director Pitts and his personnel on the excellent job they have done to
get the island cleaned up after Matthew; he indicated that he has heard many compliments on
the job done. The Director said that the first pass of the island has been completed, and personnel
have halfway completed the second pass.
MOTION: Chair Ward moved to re -order the Agenda to address Item 6B at this
point in the meeting; Councilmember Kinghorn seconded and the motion PASSED
UNANIMOUSLY.
6. New Business
Public Works Committee
November 2, 2016
Page 3 of 5
B. Discussion of drainage problems at 3 Sand Dollar Court
Chait Ward introduced the owner of the property Kevin Klemm, and he offered pictures of the
problem that occurs as the result of rain. (The pictures are attached to the historical record of the
meeting.) He reported that the problem was discovered shortly after his family moved in July of
2015, and he first tried to figu re out the source of the problem in order to figure out a solution.
From the storms, he learned that most all of the water from Sand Dollar sheet flows down the
street because the street is slanted because there is no storm drain on the street . He said that
an underground pipe was at the end of the street that was intended for the water to run into. He
has concluded that the problem goes back to the original design and the compaction of the street.
In his opinion, what has happened over the years is that a depression has developed; therefore,
when the water runs down the street, it collects and cools in the low spo t rather than continuing
down the street. The result is that his driveway has been undermined and has buckled; the
separation is visible in one (1) of the photos. The weight of the water and the erosion have, over
time, created a large pond, and the palm trees in the parkway are also being pulled over due to
the weight. Mr. Klemm stated that he was open to suggestions on the solution, but, in his opinion,
the viable pipe between the two (2) properties could be extended to his property with an inlet
drain; the depression also must be raised with fill, and, with the installation of an inlet drain, a new
pipe could extend and connect to the pipe next door.
Director Pitts stated that there was stormwater infrastructure in Wildwood and that a drain inlet
exists between #6 and #8 Sand Dollar on the other side of the street. He reported that all of that
water is underground and that is where the upgrade would flow to exit into the 41st Avenue ditch.
Administrator Tucker stated that she sees two (1) options; first, the City could report the problem
to Charleston County, as it has in the past, and wait for them to respond, or second, the City could
contact Dave Stevens of Civil Site Environmental to get a prompt response. She explained that
Charleston County had understood that the City wanted the crown of the road raised, but that
does not appear to solve the problem; she agreed that the solution lay with the addition of some
infrastructure.
Responding to Councilmember Kinghorn’s question about who was ac tually responsible for this
road, the Administrator was clear that it was not the City’s, but she added that the County would
be slow and DOT even slower still.
Councilmember Kinghorn indicated that his preference would be to continue to advocate to the
County on Mr. Klemm’s behalf and simultaneously contact Dave Stevens for his assistance.
Chair Ward asked the Administrator to get pricing from Mr. Stevens for the Ways and Means
Committee meeting.
Councilmember Kinghorn assured Mr. Klemm that the Cit y would investigate and address the
problem.
Chair Ward encouraged him to stay in touch with members of the Committee.
5. Old Business
Public Works Committee
November 2, 2016
Page 4 of 5
A. Update on golf cart path on Palm Boulevard between 18th and 20th Avenues
Director Kerr reported that the only outstanding issue was that a curb is still in place where the
path intersects 20th Avenue blocking access to the path; he was told yesterday that the contractor
plans to remove the curb and pave a connecting section of asphalt today. Assuming the work
gets done today, the project would be substantially complete; Administrator Tucker added that
DOT must inspect the completed project as well.
The Chair noted that not having the path usable presented a safety issue.
Administrator Tucker indicated that the path could be opened before the SCDOT inspection.
The Administrator stated that she believes two (2) oak trees have died in Mayor Carmen R. Bunch
Park and might need to be removed.
B. Update on the status of debris removal operations after Hurricane Matthew
The Chair commented that this item had been covered under Director Pitt’s report.
C. Update on the electronic leak detection system for the underground storage
tank at the Public Safety Building
Administrator Tucker reported that the contract has been awarded, but the system has not yet
been installed. She also noted that this item has been included as a proposed expense in the
mediation of the building.
D. Update on bike path improvements on Palm Boulevard from Breach Inlet to
the IOP Connector
The Administrator said that Councilmember Kinghorn has a video showing the problem as he
perceives it as being both a maintenance problem for the bike path there now and the lack of
regulation bike paths on both sides of the road.
After the video was shown, Councilmember Kinghorn stated that he was in the north side bike
lane heading north and pointed out that the bikers shown were the run -of-the-mill, ordinary
cyclists. He pointed out that the cyclists were riding on the wrong side of the road – driving against
the traffic rather than with it; as a car comes along travelling south, the car cannot move over to
give the required three feet (3 ft.) of clearance between it and the cyclists, creating a safety issue.
He then asked the Committee to envision cyclists riding on the opposite side in that bike path,
they would have to veer out into the street while the other cyclists were going by; compound that
by pedestrians walking in the bike path. He reiterated his advocacy for a bike lane on both sides
of the road and improvements to the quality of the road and existing bike path . He offered to
accompany other Committee members on cycles to travel from Breach Inlet to the Connector,
and he asked for the Committee’s continued efforts to get these things accomplished.
Administrator Tucker reported that she has forwarded the video to SCDOT.
Public Works Committee
November 2, 2016
Page 5 of 5
Assistant Administrator Fragoso stated that she had received a phone call about the COG’s
program for the three (3) counties where three (3) scopes of work were identified for inclusion ;
they explained that the plan was looking at a regional connection between the three (3) counties.
It is more of a global look at how they can connect existing bike paths and trails together; they are
not focusing on local paths; however they will select six (6) local projects, three (3) pedestrian
and three (3) bicycle, for study and analysis. The City will not know until their work product is
complete, so the possibility exists that the City’s paths could be reviewed by the COG. They
noted that the paths they are likely to choose are those that connect to existing trails.
Chair Ward said that he keeps items on the agendas that could be completed successfully in the
foreseeable future, in the next year or eighteen (12 -18) months; therefore, this item will be on
recurring agendas for an update.
6. New Business
A. Report on emergency purchase of a grapple attachment for the skid steer in
the amount of $4,014.50
On the day that the Administrator and Public Works Director realized that the debris collection
was not working and something must be done differently, they isolated two (2) things, i.e. to collect
all of the debris at th e large parking lot and to identify more ways that the City could get debris
into trucks. The attachment for the s kid steer, which was budgeted for purchase, was one (1)
thing the City needed to deploy ; the Administrator decided to purchase the grapple at tachment
under an emergency purchase. The grapple purchase exceeded the amount budgeted because
Director Pitts had intended to purchase a used attachment from the rental fleet of the local vendor,
but, based on the immediate need, a new one (1) was purchased.
The Administrator stated that the City could not have made the progress in debris removal that it
has without the grapple attachment.
7. Miscellaneous Business
Next Meeting Date: 11:00 a.m., Thursday, January 5, 2017 in the Conference Room.
8. Executive Session – Not necessary
9. Adjourn
MOTION: Councilmember Kinghorn moved to adjourn the meeting at noon;
Chair Ward seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.