October 10, 2016 (PDF, 312.13 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of Oct 10, 2016 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
REAL PROPERTY COMMITTEE
9:30 a.m., Monday, October 10, 2016
The regular meeting of the Real Property Committee was called to order at 9:40 a.m., Monday,
October 10, 2016 in the City Hall Conference Room, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South
Carolina. Attending the meeting were Councilmembers Harrington and Ri ce, Chair Bergwerf,
Administrator Tucker and City Clerk Copeland; a quorum was present to conduct business.
Steven Traynum of Coastal Science and Engineering was also present for the meeting.
1. Chair Bergwerf called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public
had been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
Since the minutes were given to Committee members when they arrived for the meeting, Chair
Bergwerf recommended delaying the approval of minutes to the next meeting.
3. Citizens’ Comments – None
4. Comments from Marina Tenants
Carla Pope, representing Morgan Creek Grill, reported that, as a result of Hurricane Matthew, the
restaurant fared relatively well despite the wind and rain. A small awning at the back of the
building was blown off the building and into an air conditioning unit, an ice condenser and one (1)
small puncture in the roof system; smaller losses were fans from the upper deck, one (1)
television. Insurance claims will be filed for those losses, and the restaurant plans to re-open on
Tuesday, October 11th. As for the loss of revenue, Ms. Pope told the Committee that MCG does
have business interruption insurance to cover some of that loss, but the restaurant had anticipated
a big week with weddings and the pig roast planned for Saturday.
Councilmember Rice asked whether the problem of water under the building had been corrected
before the storm, and Ms. Pope stated that it had not, but they did not see a major rise in the
water level.
Administrator Tucker said that Mr. Berrigan had reported that the store also had not sustained
any major damage; Mr. Berrigan managed to get the store open very quickly after the controlled-
access began and was pumping gas.
Councilmember Rice commented how nice it was to have a second option on the island for gas,
especially since the station on Palm ran out of gas.
The Administrator reported that Mr. Berrigan had been proactive and gotten a second delivery,
and did not run out of gas; he moved the water-side pumping to the land-side and exhausted his
supply.
Additionally, the tanks at the Public Works facility were backup for Sullivan’s Island, but she does
not think they had to use it.
Real Property Committee
October 10, 2016
Page 2 of 6
One (1) situation that the Administrator thought “worked really well” in the storm was the
management of the crowd at the Kangaroo station and at the marina on 41 st Avenue; she stated
that the Police Department had coordinated very well with the business owners to control a
situation that was getting crazy.
5. Old Business
A. Public Restrooms – Evaluation of amount of possible work to be done based
upon new appraised value
The Administrator informed the Committee that, based on the updated appraisal, the value of the
building has increased, so Director Kerr was getting new estimates for repairs and improvements
identified earlier.
Director Kerr stated that the building had not flooded during the storm.
Responding to Councilmember Harrington’s question about the mural, the Administrator said that
the building was pressure washed in preparation for the painting and she was confident the work
would begin once things “returned to normal.”
B. Status of 49th Avenue Beach Access
Administrator Tucker stated that the City got an OCRM permit to repair the 49 th Avenue beach
access, bid the job and awarded a contract; the contractor was ready to mobilize when Matthew
became a factor. Since the storm, the dynam ics there have changed; it is no longer ‘Lake 49,”
but “River 49.”
According to Director Kerr, the storm washed sand back onto the path and nearly filled it up; now
the water is only a few inches deep.
Steven Traynum agreed that the beach access stil l needs work and recommended that the City
proceed with its plan because the elevation of that area needs to be raised. The project may cost
less since the City will be paying by the cubic yard of sand, and less sand will be needed than
before Matthew. D irector Kerr said that he would call Mr. Petersen of Petersen Grading to find
out when the work will begin.
C. Status of Local Comprehensive Beach Management Plan
Administrator Tucker reported that the Plan had gone out for public comment and that OCRM had
received no public comments. OCRM had comments about some changes they would like to see
made, and staff had begun work toward responding to those comments when Matthew
intervened. Staff will be working with Chris Jon es to respond to those comments. OCRM’s
comments will add to the comprehensive nature of the finished product; referring to the OCRM
comments, the Administrator stated that she did not see anything in their comments th at would
alter the way the City manages the shoreline, for instance, they asked that a certain topic covered
in the Plan be expanded upon.
Real Property Committee
October 10, 2016
Page 3 of 6
On the subject of the major renourishment project and the Stone Fleet, the Administrator reported
that the City has received support from both Senator Lindsay Graham’s office and from Senator
Tim Scott’s office related to the concern that the proposed h istoric district for the Second Stone
Fleet might inhibit the C ity from harvesting sand from within district boundaries. Staff has had
meetings with staff members from both of those offices, and they have been sent information on
the complication. One (1) important point of consideration is more the over-arching circumstance
that, if the City is not allowed to harvest sand at all, future projects might face the situation where
there is no “good” sand anywhere else, except within that district. The City hopes to come to an
agreement that allows the City to harvest in that district under certain circumstances. The City
has asked when the public comments period will be in order to make comments; at this point, no
one has that information.
6. New Business
Post Matthew report concerning City’s real property and shoreline
Concerning the City’s buildings and property, Administrator Tucker reported the following:
leaks were found in several properties that must be addressed,
siding off City Hall, but no evidence of roof leaks,
at least half a dozen leaks were discovered in the Public Safety Building, and
no significant damage at the Recreation Center.
The Administrator added that the City would be filing insurance claims for its losses.
Debris is going to be a problem d espite Public Works personnel reporting back to work to clear
the streets with assistance from the Fire Department personnel with chain saws, which is why the
City is not collecting garbage this week. Staff will work to get the message out to residents vi a
the message boards.
Chair Bergwerf stated that this is a perfect example when an electronic message board could
have been and would be very useful tool for storm updates to this garbage issue.
The off-island EOC was the Homewood Suites just over th e Connector; although the hotel was
closed, the general manager, assistant general manager and meal crew did an excellent job
taking care of the needs of City personnel for a forty-eight (48) hour period. Administrator Tucker
said that she hoped there would be a way to recognize them in the future.
The shoreline took the biggest hit; water did go underneath houses that washed debris onto the
road; when crews first came onto the island for the first assessment, they were unable to get to
Beachwood East because of the volume of debris on the road. Along the entire shoreline, primary
dunes were lost and a need exists to try to restore that protective berm. Especi ally vulnerable
are homes at Beachwood East, Seascape, Grand Pavilion and Ocean Club Building 1. The City
must do another post storm survey to document from a survey standpoint what the alteration to
the sand has been since the last survey was submitted. The Administrator described that, in the
area of the wave dissipation devices on the landward s ide and on the road, the City ha s cleared
the debris and today harvested the vegetative d ebris that was piled up there to prevent it from
ending up on the beach. On Sunday, the Mayor and Administrator met with Major Chapman of
Real Property Committee
October 10, 2016
Page 4 of 6
the South Carolina National Guard; they are the survey team in anticipation of the National Guard.
Although it would be great if the Guard could get on the island and do the work to push the
protective berm back up, the Administrator was concerned that they would be tied up in areas of
the state with needs greater than those of the Isle of Palms and that, anticipating the extreme
tides expected over the coming weekend, she did not think the City had the luxury of time.
Darren Nettles was also in the group since sections of the wave dissipation devices will have to
be taken out to build the protective berm; he was also informed of the need for his presence on
the beach when the devices are removed.
The Administrator explained that the City has two (2) options for contractors who could get to the
island right away and begin to move sand, i.e. take sand that is on the active beach at low tide
and move it back up against the houses to restore the protective dune.
With the higher than normal tides and winds expected at the end of the week, Mr. Traynum stated
that work should be done by Thursday or Friday to protect the residences in jeopardy;
Administrator Tucker commented that she was confident that the N ational Guard would not
mobilized on the island in order to meet that timeline.
To OCRM/DHEC’ s credit, they started issuing emergency orders right away, allowing beach
communities to sandbag and/or move sand; the City could also mobilize under the existing shoal
management permit if necessary. Mr. Traynum indicated that the City had a couple of options at
its disposal or what might be a jumble of the two (2); the OCRM emergency orders will allow the
City to bring sand from upland to build a dune or to scrape sand from the beach to create a berm,
but the sand scraping is to be done within the property lines as if they extended onto the beach.
At Beachwood East, there is little beach to start with, so Mr. Traynum questioned that there was
very little sand to scrape into a dune; these dunes are six feet (6 ft.) high and twenty feet (20 ft.)
long requiring about five cubic yards of sand per foot.
Administrator Tucker commented that the City could provide the equipment and the manpower,
but someone qualified must be on the beach supervising the work to ensure that the ecosystem
is not disturbed. She also acknowledged that the City would be doing this work ahead of the
National Guard and incurring the expense, whereas the National Guard would be free to the City.
Since no disaster order has been issued, meaning that FEMA reimbursement might not be
available and, if it were to be authorized, the reimbursement would be only seventy-five percent
(75%).
Since the Beachwood East homes were not occupied during the hurricane, Administrator Tucker
has been tasked with writing to the property owners telling them of the condition of their homes
and including photographs.
Mr. Traynum commented that the same OCRM emergency order could be used anywhere on the
beach; it would allow for the replacement of the primary dune that was lost from Breach Inlet to
about 9th Avenue. In his opinion, scrapping sand to create a protective dune in that area would
be effective.
Real Property Committee
October 10, 2016
Page 5 of 6
OCRM has to be notified that the work has begun within seventy-two (72) hours, but the City does
not have to contact them for approval to do the work.
Mr. Traynum explained that the other emergency option is the FEMA Emergency Berm which
says that, if the properties were severely threatened, they would allow six cubic yards (6 cu. yd.)
per square foot yielding a block of sand six feet (6 ft.) tall and thirty (30 ft.) feet wide. The caveat
is that the volume of sand is predicated upon the lesser of the amount to reach that shape or the
pre-storm condition. In his opinion, this plan would work well on the south end of the island and
around Grand Pavilion where there was sand that was eroded away; at Beachwood East there
was no sand. He has also been told that the volume of sand could also be an engineer’s
recommendation on what has to be done to protect the property.
Councilmember Rice asked whether the shoal had moved closer or changed in any way that
might be in the City’s favor.
Since the tide has been high even at low tide, he has been unable to see what the sand bar is
doing; Mr. Traynum said that a survey would help the City to know how the storm caused the
sand to shift underwater. He also said that he thou ght the beach lost more sand from Matthew
than it did from Joaquin; the survey would make it possible to calculate how much sand was lost
from the project area to be reimbursed at seventy-five percent (75%) from FEMA.
On the south end of the island, a lot of sand was lost; possibly as much as fifty feet (50 ft.) around
8th and 9th Avenues; Mr. Traynum expects the sand to come back naturally as the beach recovers
from the storm.
When asked about equipment, Administrator Tucker stated that Eadie’s and H DR have large
equipment with buckets attached; she added that companies that are available will quickly
become unavailable.
According to Mr. Traynum, this type of project has an hourly rental rate for the heavy equipment,
not by measuring the sand volum es; he estimated that the work at Grand Pavilion would take a
day, and Beachwood and Dunecrest, two (2) days. The work would qualify under the FEMA
Emergency Berm, therefore, reimbursed at seventy-five percent (75%).
MOTION: Councilmember Harrington move d to award an emergency contract
to Coastal Science and Engineering to survey the beach in an amount not to exceed
$30,000; Councilmember Rice seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Administrator Tucker suggested waiting for the National Guard to do the work on the south end
of the island and to hire a contractor to do the imminent work for those properties most in danger.
MOTION: Councilmember Rice moved to award an emergency contract to a
vendor to move sand at Grand Pavilion, Beachwood East, Seasc ape and Ocean
Club; Councilmember Harrington seconded and the motion PASSED
UNANIMOUSLY.
7. Miscellaneous Business
Real Property Committee
October 10, 2016
Page 6 of 6
Tenant Rents Report
In dealing with the preparation for and aftermath of the hurricane, Administrator Tucker stated
that his issue had totally slipped her mind.
Next Meeting Date: 9:30 a.m., Tuesday, November 8th in the Conference Room
The Administrator explained that Mr. Traynum was going to mark the location of the sand bags
using his GPS system and she will call the Mayor to review the actions taken by the Committee
to ensure that he agreed with them.
8. Executive Session – not needed
9. Adjourn
MOTION: Councilmember Rice moved to adjourn the meeting at 11:04 a.m.;
Councilmember Harrington seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.