September 14, 2016 (PDF, 124.05 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of Sep 14, 2016 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
MINUTES OF THE ISLE OF PALMS
PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING
September 14, 2016
The Isle of Palms Planning Commission met in the City Hall Council Chambers, 1207
Palm Boulevard on September 14, 2016 at 4:00 p.m. Members attending included Ron
Denton, Richard Ferencz, Lewis Gregory, Noel Scott, Vince DiGangi, Bill Mills and Lisa
Safford and the Director of Planning Douglas Kerr. The press and public had been
notified of the meeting, and the agenda was posted in City Hall and the Building
Department to comply with the Freedom of Information Act.
Chair Ferencz called the meeting to order.
PUBLIC COMMENTS - None
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
The next item on the agenda was the approval of the August 17th, 2016 minutes. Ms.
Safford noted that the word “meet” should be “meeting” in the first sentence of the third
paragraph on the second page. Mr. Denton made a motion to approve the minutes as
amended and Mr. Mills seconded the motion. The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
DISCUSSION OF NONPOINT SOURCE POLLUTION STUDY
Mr. Kerr explained that, since the last meeting, OCRM has provided data regarding the
water quality in the waterways on the backside of the island. The sources of the sample
collections seem to roughly correspond to the locations sampled in the 2002 study, but
the format of the data requires a conversion to correlate to the samples from 2002. He
indicated that he would continue to work with OCRM and Ross Nelson, if necessary, to
find a correlation between the recent data and the old data to determine if any
conclusions could be drawn about the water quality.
DISCUSS SEPTIC TANKS ON THE ISLAND- KRISTEN CHAMPAGNE AND BILL
JENKINS, ISLE OF PALMS WATER AND SEWER COMMISSION
Mr. Kerr introduced Kristen Champagne and Bill Jenkins of the Isle of Palms Water and
Sewer Commission (IOPWSC) and reported that he and Chair Ferencz had met with
the IOPWSC staff twice regarding various issues, and they thought it would be good for
the entire Commission to meet. He stated that there have been general discussions of
providing public sewer throughout the entire island, but also there is a real-world
example that will show the challenges.
Ms. Champagne thanked the Commission for having her and stated her belief that
providing sewer to the entire island was a possibility and that the IOPWSC was
researching the Whispering Palms area to see what it would take to build a new lift
Planning Commission Minutes
September 14, 2016
Page 2
station to provide sewer to the properties in the area. She explained that the Water
Commission hired an engineer to do a feasibility study and cost analysis; he determined
that it would cost approximately $6,000,000 to provide sewer to approximately 300
homes in the area, or about $20,000 per new property. She stated that this particular
situation has the benefit of the IOPWSC already owning the property that would be
necessary for the lift station, so this example eliminates any land acquisition hurdles,
which could be significant. She added that the cost of the lift station was approximately
$850,000.
Mr. Mills asked how many properties on the island did not have sewer, and Ms.
Champagne answered about 2,450.
Mr. Ferencz asked whether the situation at Whispering Palms was a best case scenario
for providing sewer. Ms. Champagne answered that it was because the IOPWSC
already owned the necessary land.
Mr. Ferencz asked about the cost to build a smaller lift station to serve only the
properties immediately adjacent to the Whispering Palms area. Ms. Champagne
responded that the smallest lift station would cost about $350,000 and serve about 25
properties.
Mr. Denton asked how many properties were currently served by the grinder program
and if those systems were seen more as a band-aide or a permanent solution. Ms.
Champagne answered that approximately 130 properties have grinder pumps and she
would agree they were not a great long term solution since they are very labor intensive.
She explained that each grinder system had to be inspected twice a week by the
IOPWSC staff.
Mr. Mills asked about the mindset of the Water Commission’s Board to expand the
sewer system. Ms. Champagne thought they were willing to participate, but that they
were also aware of the failure of prior efforts to expand. So she was of the opinion that
they were a bit guarded about the residents’ perception of trying to expand the system.
The Commission thanked Ms. Champagne and Mr. Jenkins’ for their time and their
willingness to help.
DISCUSSION OF ZONING ORDINANCE RELATED TO FOOD TRUCKS AND
TRAILERS
Mr. Kerr reported that, since the last Planning Commission meeting, City Council had
met and many of the local restaurant owners came to voice their opposition to food
Planning Commission
September 14, 2016
Page 3
trucks on the island. He stated that the public appeared to misunderstand recent
discussions and thought that Council was considering allowing food trucks and not
restricting them further in the future. Additionally, he stated that he perceived an
urgency among members of Council to enact something quickly before more requests
for Special Exceptions were filed.
The Commission members discussed how an ordinance might be crafted to allow the
Board of Zoning Appeals to hear requests for outdoor sales from restaurants on decks
and porches, but prohibiting trailers, food trucks and other mobile units. Mr. Kerr
suggested that the code be written to allow food trucks and other temporary uses for
City-sponsored events, but prohibit them otherwise; the ordinance could allow
businesses to request a Special Exception from the Board of Zoning Appeals to allow
outdoor sales within the footprint of their permanent building and on decks and porches.
The Commission generally agreed.
Due to City Council’s sense of urgency, Mr. Kerr asked if Commission members would
be willing to hold a special meeting to review an amendment and make a
recommendation. The Planning Commission agreed and scheduled a special meeting
for Tuesday, September 20th at 12:00 p.m.
MISCELLANEOUS BUSINESS
Mr. Kerr stated that the City had recently received the draft of the new flood maps from
FEMA, and they showed a dramatic drop in required flood elevations. He stated that he
felt that this was an issue that would involve the Planning Commission since the flood
regulations were included in the zoning ordinance, over which the Planning Commission
has purview.
Chair Ferencz requested that City Council task the Planning Commission with analyzing
the impact of the new flood maps on the island and making recommendations if
necessary. Mr. Kerr stated that he would make this request.
ADJOURNMENT
With there being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 5:55 p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Richard Ferencz, Chairman
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.