September 7, 2016 (PDF, 304.25 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of Sep 7, 2016 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
RECREATION COMMITTEE
9:00 a.m., Wednesday, September 7, 2016
The regular meeting of the Recreation Committee was held at 9:00 a.m., Wednesday, September
7, 2016 in Council Chambers of City Hall, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South Carolina.
Attending the meeting were Councilmembers Kinghorn and Rice, Chair Ca rroll, Administrator
Tucker, Recreation Director Page, Assistant Administrator Fragoso and Clerk Copeland; a
quorum was present to conduct business.
1. Chair Carroll called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public had
been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
Councilmember Kinghorn reported that he had asked for a revision to the minutes of the August
meeting to clarify his motion on hiring an ar chitect; he reminded the Committee that he has
contended that space for an enlarged cardio room exists within the current footprint of the building.
He did not feel that the original minutes properly reflected his position and ask ed for some re -
wording; the changes appear on the bottom of page 3 and top of page 4.
MOTION: Councilmember Rice moved to approve the revised minutes of the
regular meeting of August 2, 2016 as submitt ed; Councilmember Ki nghorn
seconded and the motion PASSED on a vote of 2 to 1 with Chair Carroll casting the
dissenting vote.
3. Citizens’ Comments
John McMaster, 2801 Palm Boulevard , was very complimentary of the Recreation Department,
saying that the building is always clean and the staff is wonderful and friendly, but he also stated
that he was “appalled” when reading the August minutes that someone had suggested spending
half a mill ion dollars ($500,000) to expand the cardio room. He questioned that any
Councilmember had ever used it and, with eight (8) users a day, no one has to wait to use a
machine. He noted that the City might not always have all of the money it needs, so it mu st be
spent responsibly. In his opinion, the cardio room is adequate for ninety -nine point nine percent
(99.9%) of the island’s population. He stated that he uses the cardio room several times a week.
Another issue the Mr. McMaster thought was irresponsible spending was spending ten thousand
dollars ($10,000) for a mural on the Front Beach restrooms; he does not think that it will make the
restrooms any less of an embarrassment.
Patsy Hindman, 7 Barnacle Row , stated that she and her husband drive to the Mount Pleasant
Recreation facility three or four (3-4) times a week because it has the equipment they need. She
said that she would love to see more equipment at the IOP Rec Center; in her opinion, the reason
that the cardio room does not have more traffic is that its offerings are so limited.
Ms. Hindman stated that the Keenagers are the reason for her attendance; she said that she
loves it and always looks forward to the monthly lunches and other activities. She described the
Keenagers as an opportuni ty to meet people and to see people whom you have not seen in a
while, and it is always fun – good food and good programs. She recalled that, at one time, they
had various committees to send birthday cards, decorate for the lunches, arrange the programs,
etc.; additionally, attendees paid five dollars ($5) at the beginning of the season to be used by the
Recreation Committee
September 7, 2016
Page 2 of 7
committees throughout the year, but that stopped last year. She thought that they were finding it
harder to get volunteers to serve on the committees, so the Recreation staff gradually took over
many of those responsibilities. Bringing a dish to share at the lunches is not necessary to attend
them; there is always food left over. She commented that Keenagers fall under Andy Sinwald’s
programs, and Ms. Hindman said that ”he is the most amazing young man” and “incredibly
patient.” She concluded by saying that the Recreation Department is “one of the most wonderful
things on the island.”
Laura McMaster, 2801 Palm Boulevard, stated that everything Ms. Hindman had said was true
and that “everyone loves Keenagers.” As changes have come, she asked why the members do
not decorate the tables anymore; unless there is a problem, she would like to see members
decorating the tables once again.
John McMaster stated that the Rec library needs organizing; he remarked that there are book s
that have not been read in ten (10) years. He indicated that many have books they would like to
donate if there was a way to purge some of the old ones.
Jim Raih, 3904 Cameron Boulevard, was interested in knowing what was happening with the Rec
Center’s Master Plan; having heard about hiring a consultant to find a way to expand the cardio
room, he thought it was important to stick with the master plan. If the cardio room is a part of the
master plan, he would support it. He recalled that a swimming pool was in the master plan, but
he questioned that adding one to the site was set to be done in a reasonable time frame. He
stated that, in his opinion, the Rec Department does a great job with what they have.
MOTION: Councilmember Kinghorn moved to re -order the Agenda to address
items D and E under New Business; Councilmember Rice seconded and the motion
PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
6. New Business
D. Discussion of Rec library
Director Page said that staff limits the books they take now due to age and/or condition; she also
recently organized the books by the first letter of the author’s name. She indicated that they will
accept newer novels.
Mrs. McMaster thought that she could get volunteers to come in once a week to assist with
organizing the library.
E. Discussion of Keenagers participation in programs
Referencing Ms. Hindman’s comments on decorating, Director Page confi rmed that years ago
there were various committees within the Keenagers group, but, as they aged, they did not have
the energy to continue and there were not enough volunteers to do it anymore. The Director said
that anyone who wants to volunteer their time to decorating is encouraged to do so.
Recreation Committee
September 7, 2016
Page 3 of 7
Councilmember Kinghorn asked about attendance, and Director Page stated that there is very
little fluctuation in the number of Keenagers who attend the meetings.
Mrs. McMaster commented that, for many Keenagers, the lunches are the only social life they
have.
4. Departmental Reports
Director Page started August’s report by listing the classes/programs that run all year and those
that took the summer off. As a part of the Employee Wellness Program, Wacky Golf was played
at the Links Course in Wild Dunes, and employees attending had a wonderful time. As has been
noted already, the first Keenagers meeting is today at noon; the Community Wellness Fair will be
on Wednesday, September 22 from 7:00 a.m. to 11:00 a.m. East Cooper Medical Center is
donating bloodwork for employees , and Harris Teeter is covering the expense for employee flu ,
tetanus and pneumonia shots. “Ghostly Tide Tales” is scheduled for October 21 st, Pumpkin
Painting will be October 27 th, the Halloween Carnival will be on October 31 st and the Holiday
Street Festival will be December 3 rd. The 18 th Annual Half Rubber Tournament was held on
Saturday, 20th with fifteen (15) teams participating; a local Charleston team “Below Average” won.
In the four (4) age categories for soccer, a total of two hundred eight (208) youths have registered.
5. Old Business
A. Update on Departmental Survey
Since the survey was not offered by a survey company, the results do not represent empirical
data; the survey was more of an advisory survey.
Councilmember Kinghorn stated that the surveys were completed by people who are using the
Rec facilities; he thought it would be equally important to know why other residents were not using
it. He questioned the best way to effectively reach out to those residents.
Councilmember Rice was surprised to learn that there are island residents who do not know about
the Rec Center or the programs offered.
Chair Carroll suggested using the message boards and/or the water bills.
Councilmember Kinghorn noted that a residential mailing could be done at a low cost to the
Department, as well as the City’s social media sites.
Director Page stated that the weak est area on the islan d in marketing was Wild Dunes; she
indicated that she was to have spoken to new residents of Wild Dunes last Friday when the storm
came through, and the meeting was cancelled.
All of the outreach media mentioned would help the Department to know if it is providing the best
services, what could be done in addition to and what the citizens want.
|Recreation Committee
September 7, 2016
Page 4 of 7
In an effort to clarify the discussion, Administrator Tucker said that she thought two (2) different
conversations were happening, i.e. 1) what does the community now want in Recreations
activities and programs? and 2) how much can the participation be increased in programs with
low attendance by getting the word out more? Just by the numbe rs in the monthly reports, the
participation by the island’s youths is excellent, but possibly the word is not getting out to everyone
who would be interested in participating, for example, Keenagers.
Director Page complimented Assistant Administrator F ragoso on her work on Facebook and
Twitter; the Director said that the island’s following has greatly increased and that Assistant
Fragoso was doing an excellent job. Although Assistant Fragoso was doing a very good job at
promoting the Rec and its activities, the Director suggested that they partner more to market the
Rec Center, its activities and programs.
Administrator Tucker thought that the segment of residents that is being missed is those who
move to the island and have no children living at hom e to be involved with Rec activities and
sports, but are mature adults . The Administrator thought that many of them are going to Mount
Pleasant for fitness programs and sports not knowing that they could do the same thing on the
island.
Ms. Hindman suggested that a way to reach a large number of people would be to setup a table
in the lobby with flyers and information about the Recreation Department, maybe surveys, about
the Rec Center on Election Day in early November.
Assistant Fragoso announced that the City now has the capability to put forms on the website and
that, possibly, a survey could be embedded in the Recreation page. Visitors to the website would
have the opportunity to make comments or ask questions and have a staff member respond.
B. Update on shade sails for playground
Director Page reported that she has received a couple of bids. Additionally, she has realized that
a couple of challenges, but they did not hinder the use of them. She stated that a forty by forty
(40 X 40) sail with three (3) poles sell for about twenty thousand dollars ($20,000) a piece;
removing and reinstalling would a sail of that size and sixteen feet (16 ft.) high could not be
managed by staff members. [A sail must be a minimum of seven feet (7 ft.) above the equipment
it is coverin g for safety reasons.] The playground equipment was laid out such that spacing
between each piece of equipment is according to industry standards; therefore, to put a smaller
sail up would require relocating some equipment beca use a pole must be outside the six foot (6
ft.) radius of pieces of equipment. One (1) bid of forty -one thousand dollars ($41,000) included
one (1) 40x40x15 foot sail and one (1) 25x25x10 foot sail.
Another option for shading the equipment would be to plant an additional tree, compliments of
mitigation by a resident for not adhering to the City’s tree ordinance.
Councilmember Kinghorn thought the tree(s) was an excellent option and one (1) that would
require much less maintenance and upkeep and was free.
Recreation Committee
September 7, 2016
Page 5 of 7
6. New Business
A. Discussion of architectural concept drawing related to an expansion of the
Recreation Building
Director Page stated that she had approached this assignment as Councilmember Kinghorn
stated earlier, i.e. new construction versus reconfiguration of the existing building and the best
option of the two (2) to have more space for the cardio room. She rep orted speaking to two (2)
contractors and neither was excited about taking on the job because the work will result in pretty
much what exists today.
According to Councilmember Rice, the goal is to improve and increase participation of the cardio
room.
Councilmember Rice also recalled that, while she was off Council, the decision was made to
replace the lights at the softball field and leave the fields as they were, not reconfigure them.
Director Page said that the decision to replace the lights was one that she would have liked to
postpone, but the lights on the softball and small baseball fields were so compromised that they
had to be replaced before one (1) failed. Although it would have been nice to turn the fields
around, the cost was very high to do that and they work fine as they are; the FY17 budget includes
replacing the lights on the soccer field.
Ms. Hindman agreed that the space was a cardio room because that was primarily the type of
equipment, but she was interested in seeing a fitness room. She has been told that in Wild Dunes
there are two (2) fitness rooms, and she asked if there was a way for the City to partner with Wild
Dunes for residents outside the gate to use one (1).
Councilmember Kinghorn asked about taking instructors from the mat -based programs to the
Exchange Club to find out if they thought it would a better space for their classes.
Director Page responded that scheduling would be difficult as would the registration for and
collection of class fees. She explained that the instructors were not contract employees, but
employees of the City; she also does not have enough staff to provide a supervisor to be at the
Exchange Club. She also commented that the fitness and exercise spaces are adequate as they
are; the only logistics problem is the cardio room.
Chair Carroll asked if off-site storage could be found for the items in the now storage room so that
the storage room could become the cardio room. He thought that the storage spaced was twice
that of the existing cardio room and would save the City a lot of money.
Director Page noted that the swapping of the functionality of the two (2) rooms is what she has
been talking to contractors about and who have been less than enthusiastic; she added that the
storage room is only a couple of square feet larger than the cardio room. She stated that she did
not mind storing the Christmas tree offsite, but she said that the equipment and supplies that they
need on a daily basis need to remain on-site.
Recreation Committee
September 7, 2016
Page 6 of 7
Councilmember Kinghorn asked that the Director also keep in mind the idea of partnering; if it
could be done in as cost effective way, the City should seek out such partnership opportunities.
Administrator Tucker informed the Committee that the swimming pool and new gymnasium in the
Master Plan are included in the City’s ten -year plan in FY21, as well as the construction of a
fitness facility for two hundred fifty thousand dollars ($250,000).
On the subject of off -campus offerings, the Administrator commented that some of these things
could be offered, but, in the past, the City has avoided those because of supervision issues.
Anytime there is an off -site offering, it is not just the instructo r, but a City employee at a
supervisory level must be freed-up; the only offering occurring away from the Rec Center is taking
place at another City facility.
Councilmember Kinghorn asked why a supervisory level employee would be required for an off -
site program or activity, and the Director replied that instructors are not allowed to collect money
and, for the majority of classes, the Rec Department provides equipment. IOP’s yoga classes
use weights and balls; they are not meditational; in addition, someone must be responsible to see
that the room is left clean. Director Page noted that she does not think that off-site programs are
needed at this time.
B. Consideration of a contract with Carolina Fencing in the amount of $11,200
to replace the baseball field fencing
The replacement of the baseball field fencing was included in the FY17 budget at fifteen thousand
dollars ($15,000). The Director received three (3) bids as follows:
AAA Fencing $26,985
Seegars $25,000
Carolina $11,200
Carolina Fencing, the lowest bidder, was awarded the contract for the tennis courts last year, so
the Director has experience with the vendor, and he was much cheaper than the other bidders.
MOTION: Chair Carroll moved to recommend a contract award to C arolina
Fencing at $11,200 to replace the baseball field fencing; Councilmember Kinghorn
seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
C. Consideration of additional programs
Councilmember Rice recalled that the spring history series had been a huge success; therefore,
she asked that other similar series be repeated in the fall/winter. She stated that the island has
residents who were major college coaches, university presidents, etc., and one (1) resident who
has recently completed hiking the Appalachian Trail.
Director Page said that staff wanted to re-start the history series, but the timing is off with Assistant
Director Ferrell being out on maternity leave.
Recreation Committee
September 7, 2016
Page 7 of 7
Councilmember Rice said that she would assist staff in putting the series together and identifying
and contacting interesting speakers.
The Councilmember’s second suggestion was to hold a second “Music in the Park” event in the
fall of the year maybe next year; she thought that it wa s a rather simple event to put on with
booking a band and getting a couple of food trucks lined up. Councilmember Rice added that it
was a good spirited event and great for all ages.
7. Miscellaneous Business
Status of Marina Off-site Parking Experiment
Director Page reported that there have been no issues related to marina employees parking at
the Recreation Center.
The Committee agreed not to meet in October, and the next meeting was scheduled for 9:00
a.m., Wednesday, November 2, 2016 in the Conference Room.
8. Adjourn
MOTION: Councilmember Kinghorn moved to adjourn the meeting at 10:28
a.m.; Councilmember Rice seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.