September 6, 2016 (PDF, 330.21 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of Sep 6, 2016 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
PUBLIC WORKS COMMITTEE
11:00 a.m., Tuesday, September 6, 2016
The regular meeting of the Public Works Committee was called to order at 11:00 a.m., Tuesday,
September 6, 2016 in Council Chambers of City Hall, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South
Carolina. Attending the meeting were Councilmembers Ferencz and Kinghorn, Chair Ward,
Administrator Tucker, Public Works Director Pitts, Assistant Administrator Fragoso and City Clerk
Copeland; a quorum was present to conduct business.
1. Chair Ward called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and publi c had
been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Ferencz moved to approve the minutes of the regular
meeting of August 1, 2016 as submitted; Councilmember Kinghorn seconded and
the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments – None
4. Departmental Reports for August 2016 – Director Pitts
Vehicle Maintenance and Trash Collection Tracking Reports
According to the Director, the City’s compactor and pad on Front Beach were thoroughly cleaned
twice in the month of August; the contractor HDR Services was called to the island three (3) times
in the month to mow right s-of-way. Public Works personnel were called upon to remove some
limbs at the Mayor Carmen R. Bunch Park for the construction of the golf cart path between 18 th
and 20th Avenues. Miscellaneous garbage increased for August, but yard debris and household
garbage collections were at a five (5) year high. With no unusual expenses, vehicle maintenance
was relatively low, putting the Department back within budget.
5. Old Business
A. Update on Phase II Drainage
Administrator Tucker reported that the IOP Water and Sewer Commission has not returned the
executed easement documents needed for the project to move forward; Civil Site Environmental
was asked if the drainage could follow another route, but answer was that it must re main as
drawn.
The Administrator noted that Assistant Fragoso is working on a rural infrastructure grant to assist
in funding the project.
B. Discussion of Pooper-scoopers
Director Pitts explained that there are two (2) types of waste bags, therefo re, two (2) types of
dispensers. The header style bags come stacked on a card for individual dispensing, like a tissue
box; the roll style bags come on a large roll, just like the produce bags at the grocery store. The
roll style bags and dispensers are the cheapest, but per bag cost is deceptive. This is true
Public Works Committee
September 6, 2016
Page 2 of 11
because when bags are on a roll, dog owners have a habit of pulling out more than one (1) bag
at a time. Header bags, in contrast, are pulled out of the dispenser one (1) at a time because
each bag is individually secured to the card. Although more expensive on the front end, the
header bags save money in the long run; they are generally preferred by residents because they
are larger, easier to open and have a convenient handle right on the bag.
Since the City is currently using the header bags and dispensers and because the header bags
are the preferred option, the Committee thanked the Director for his r esearch and chose to take
no action.
C. Update on golf cart path on Palm Boulevard between 18th and 20th Avenues
Administrator Tucker reported that the problem is that a water line must be lowere d that was not
anticipated as necessary when the project was designed and bid. Since the City cannot move a
storm drainage box that is part of the design and a requirement by SCDOT, the IOP Water and
Sewer Commission has required that the path be a certain distance from the drainage box. An
additional issue is to have the IOP Wate r and Sewer Commission appr ove Landscape Pavers,
the City’s contractor, as a contractor qualified by the IOP Water and Sewer Commission; Director
Kerr has contacted Eadies for an estimate for the work as well.
Director Kerr reported that Eadies estimates that the work will take one (1) day and they could
begin to work two (2) weeks from receiving the “go ahead;” they will provide the City with pricing
and a written quote by the end of the month. Meanwhile the City’s civil engineer on the project is
trying to convince the IOP Water and Sewer Commission that there is another solution, a conflict
box of some type.
When Councilmember Kinghorn asked about the estimated cost, Director Kerr said that civil
engineer had guessed that it could cost more than the entire project because the IOP Water and
Sewer Commission wants a separation of eighteen inches (18 in.) where the separation today is
two to three inches (2-3 in).
Councilmember Kinghorn asked whether the City could request the IOP Water and Sewer for
some type of exemption and opined that the City should press for the exemption while awaiting
cost estimates. Staff could press the point that the City is doing a small project and that the cost
of the changes requested is excessive.
When the City re -submitted the permit application, DOT said that their biggest concern was the
drainage and the way it had been designed; they would not concede moving the drainage line.
D. Discussion of effect of $10,000 expenditure at public restrooms toward 50%
rule
Chair Ward said that Councilmember Ferencz had asked that this item be on the Agenda.
Administrator Tucker commented that the mural that is to be painted on the building will not count
toward the fifty percent (50%) rule. She reported that staff has ordered a new appraisal of the
Public Works Committee
September 6, 23016
Page 3 of 11
building since values have gone up. Once the City receives the report, she and Director Kerr can
re-evaluate the fifty percent (50% ) rule against that new value to know if add itional work can be
done to the existing building. Staff is also getting pricing to move the showers off the back of the
building and construct free standing showers.
Councilmember Ferencz asked what was included in the word “maintenance” as it applies to the
fifty percent (50%) rule.
Director Kerr explained that the City tracks the cost for everything, from a light b ulb and to
replacing a toilet, but then questioned that the City was holding itself up to a higher standard than,
for example, Coconut Joe’s. In the past when searching for a definitive answer, staff contacted
the State Flood Plain Coordinating Office, a part of the Department of Natural Resources, who
said that the City was doing the right thing in tracking every cost that could be associated with the
maintenance of the public restrooms. When the subject of the mural came forward, the City again
searched for guidance about what items or work must be considered in relation to the fifty percent
(50%) rule and found information contradictory to what th ey had been told by the state two or
three (2-3) years ago. The guidance written in 2015 by FEMA states that, if the work does not
require a permit, it should not be counted, which eliminates tracking light bulbs and repairs to a
leaky faucet and should help the City with its new evaluation of the fifty percent (50%) rule.
After receiving the new appraisal, the Administrator a nd Director Kerr will compare the cost
estimates of the work that needs to be done to where the building now stands with the fifty-percent
(50%) rule.
The Administrator also acknowledged the risk to the City of investing in a building that could be
damaged and have to be torn down and re-built to meet the current standards.
Director Kerr agreed that an advantage with a cinder block building is that it would be tough to
damage it, but a problem with a cinder block building is that is it worth nothing.
The fifty-percent (50%) rule is part of having ordinances in place to encourage the construction of
flood resistant properties, particularly in a V zone where structures should be elevated or flood
proofed.
E. Status of trailers on IOP
Administrator Tucker noted that this issue is, currently, before the Planning Commission who did
not reach a conclusion at their last meeting.
Director Kerr stated that the Planning Committee is specifically looking at outdoor sales activities
and the process that governs the ir approval. The Director explained that any business activity
that occurs outdoors is considered “outdoor sales activities ,” for example, Wild Dunes is asking
to have a concessions stand from a window of a permanent structure. C urrently the code says
the Board of Zoning Appeals must approve it and there are five (5) criteria, that the Director
believes are relatively easy to comply with, that must be met; assuming all five (5) are in place,
BOZA would likely approve the request.
Public Works Committee
September 6, 2016
Page 4 of 11
Responding to Councilmember Kinghorn’s question, Director Kerr said that he had checked other
municipalities to learn how they handles sales from trailers and had learned that in some it is
loosely regulated while others ban them entirely.
Chair Ward commented that the local restauranteurs are “vehemently opposed” to the City’s
allowing food trucks on the island, and he agreed with them. He did indicate that he was find for
food trucks to be allowed for special events like “Music in the Park” or the annual Street festival.
The problem with the trailer at the marina was that they never approached the City about a Special
Exception; they simply found a quick solution to their immediate problem, i.e. mo ving their
operation away from the boat ramp for safety reasons.
F. Update on Palm Boulevard from Breach Inlet to the Connector and bike path
improvements
Administrator Tucker informed the Committee that she and the Mayor were still trying to schedule
a meeting with SCDOT to discuss the City’s long-standing request for bike paths on both sides of
Palm Boulevard from Breach Inlet to 57th Avenue. She and Assistant Administrator Fragoso met
with V onnie Gilreath at the Council of Governments (COG) relative to their initiative for a
comprehensive bike path plan; they were interested in knowing if their scope of work would
include the island-wide study proposed by Councilmember Ferencz at the last meeting. The items
that the City would like to see included in the COG’s work product are as follows:
Feasibility and suitability analysis of the creation of regulations bicycle lanes on both sides
of Palm Boulevard for the entire length of Palm Boulevard from Breach Inle t to 57 th
Avenue.
Construction of a multi -use path to connect the right shoulder of the Isle of Palms
Connector, which is used by bicyclists and pedestrians, to the sidewalk on Palm
Boulevard.
Construction/expansion of regulation bicycle lanes/multi -use pa ths along Waterway
Boulevard and Forest Trail.
The Administrator and Assistant Administrator will be attending a meeting on September 15 th
sponsored by the COG on this subject.
Councilmember Kinghorn asked what the City’s process was for street cleaning and/or cleaning
the bike paths.
The Administrator said that technically the City has no responsibility ; the responsibility falls to
SCDOT, and, if there are problems, the City calls them. As is well known, they do not have an
adequate maintenance budget, and sometimes, when things get in such poor conditions, the City
sends personnel to remove rocks or overgrowth. The City is limited in what it can do because it
does not have the right equipment. She confirmed that the City has a contract for street sweeping,
but the full length of the bike paths is not within their scope; their scope is the Connector, the
central business district, the Front Beach area, the 21 st Avenue and 41st Avenue curves and the
Breach Inlet bridge. Administrator Tucker opined that the state SCDOT has a street sweeping
contract that includes the Connector, but, if the City were to rely on the SCDOT
Public Works Committee
September 6, 2016
Page 5 of 11
contract, the residents would not be happy with the result. Therefore, the City has its own street
sweeping contract.
The City’s contract is structur ed such that street sweeps occur a specific number of times each
month; there is also an amount for the City to request special sweepings, for example, right before
the Connector Run. If City Council were to decide to broaden the scope, that second amount
could fund it.
Administrator Tucker said that she was well satisfied with the contractor’s work, and Director Pitts
remarked that the City was not pleased with the previous contractor’s work and decided to go with
a local company. The work product has improved significantly.
Councilmember Kinghorn asked whether the City had done a cost/benefit analys is of the City
purchasing the necessary equipment and sweeping its own streets versus outsourcing.
The Administrator replied that the City had not done that; she also noted that the City would have
to increase personnel because the street sweeping must be done at night.
Director Pitts said that the City’s contractor sweeps the Connector on the opposite weeks from
SCDOT schedule.
Councilmember Kinghorn’s final question was what approach has the City taken to communicate
to property owners that are having an impact on the bike paths that they have a responsibility to
blow the rocks from their yard/driveway off the bike paths.
The Administrator indicated that she has not routinely communicated with property owners in this
regard.
Councilmember Kinghorn had three (3) propositions for the Committee to consider:
1) The City should do what it can to sweep the bike paths;
2) The City should notify the property owners where clearly their parking lots are putting
debris onto the bike paths and the street that they assist in removing the debris;
3) The Committee should look at the current contract. Does the City need to do more?
If so, what is the recommendation? The City should proceed with a cost/benefit analysis
of doing it in-house versus outsourcing.
Chair Ward said that he has no problem with considering all three (3) sugg estions although he
was less enthusiastic of #3 because street sweeping equipment is very expensive, as well as
adding staff to operate it.
Councilmember Kinghorn also proposed a partnership with Wild Dunes and/or Sullivan’s Island.
6. New Business
A. Consideration of representation at IOP W ater and Sewer Commission
meetings
Public Works Committee
September 6, 2016
Page 6 of 11
Councilmember Kinghorn stated that he had learned that, in the past, the City had representation
at the regular meetings of the Water and Sewer Commission, and Administrator Tucker confirmed
that to be true. He recalled that, in his brief tenure on Council, the City has had a number of
intersections with the Commission, but has not received positive responses to what it believes to
be reasonable requests.
He asked why the situation had changed and whether or not it would be in the City’s best interest
to have a presence at their meetings.
Administrator Tucker recalled that a member of Council had volunteered to be the City’s “eyes
and ears” of the City at Water and Sewer Commission meetings; she opines that it fell off because
it was the same person every time. She thought that, if attendance had been setup on a rotating
basis for Council or Committee members, it would have been less demanding and possib ly
continued.
Councilmember Ferencz asked if this person then reported on the Water and Sewer meeting at
the City Council meeting.
According to the Administrator, if there was something to report or if their meeting had contained
other than routine matters.
Councilmember Kinghorn was concerned about their perception of a Councilmember attending
their meetings. Would it be seen as the City showing more interest?
Administrator Tucker said she thought it would be positively received by the Commission.
Chair Ward suggested that the topic be put forth to the full City Council for discussion.
Councilmember Ferencz suggested having a Commission member attend the Public Works
Committee meeting to report on what was happening on the island from their perspective.
Since the Water and Sewer Commission is under new management, it might be helpful to the City
to be aware of their long-range plans.
Councilmember Kinghorn expressed the opinion that Water and Sewer Commission should be a
strategic partner for the City, but he was sensing a disconnect that needed to be brought back
together.
B. Discussion of Front Beach cleanup
Councilmember Kinghorn said that he had walked from the pier to 10 th Avenue on Monday and
was amazed by the amount of litter on the street. He asked whether the City could do more to
clean up litter and what that something was.
Public Works Committee
September 6, 2016
Page 7 of 11
Director Pitts reported that, on Monday mornings, Mr. Schupp pays members of the Public Works
Department for beach cleanup beginning at 6:45 a.m. to 7:30 a.m.
When Councilmember Kinghorn asked whether the City received many complaints about trash
cleanup, the Administrator responded that there are a few, and, when they do come in, Director
Pitts sends personnel to clean it up.
Councilmember Kinghorn then asked if there was an area of the website that addressed clean
beaches and whether the signage was appropriate; Assistant Fragoso indicated that a portion of
the website spoke to the issues of c lean beaches. He also asked that the educational and
promotional the need for clean beaches in the other forms of social media in which the City
participates.
C. Discussion of validity of resolutions
According to Councilmember Ferencz, this subject c ame up in relation to a resolution the
Administrator found from 1980 that says “there will be no parking in residential areas,” causing
her to ask what was the validity of a resolution.
Administrator Tucker explained that a resolution was a statement of o pinion and has no
enforceability. It is similar to a motion in that it has no legislative or statutory power.
D. Consideration of security lighting for municipal parking lots
Councilmember Ferencz recalled that the Public Works Committee had been instr umental in
getting the decorative lights at Front Beach in collaboration with SCE&G; she questioned whether
the City could use funds from the non -standard service clause to get pretty, security lighting in
the municipal parking lots.
The Administrator voiced the opinion that it could be discussed, but she did not think the same
type of decorative lighting would be appropriate for a big open space, which is what it appears to
be in the off-season.
Councilmember Ferencz commented that the parking lots are considered a part of Front Beach,
and, if the City begins to mow them and improve the look of them, people might get a better
impression of what the City is all about. She added that she does not want the City to bear the
full expense.
The Administrator stated that SCE&G will not pay for security lighting, but will use funds from the
non-standard service clause for decorative lighting. She reminded the Committee that the budget
does contain funds for an expanded video feed for security and remarked that consideration for
those who live around and near the parking lots when lighting is contemplated.
Councilmember Kinghorn suggested volleying this and any other consideration of future
improvements to the parking lots to the Real Property Committee. He also pointed out that the
County Park does not have lights in its parking lot.
Public Works Committee
September 6, 2016
Page 8 of 11
E. Discussion of voting procedures at Committee and Council meetings
MOTION: Councilmember Ferencz moved that an y item sent to Ways and
Means Committee and City Council with less than a unanimous approval at the
committee level and/or at Ways and Means must be voted on individually and not
grouped together; Chair Ward seconded.
Councilmember Ferencz stated that any time there is not a unanimous decis ion, the only time
that the meetings are video recorded is at City Council; when everything is grouped together, the
residents have no opportunity to know what the discussion was.
Councilmember Kinghorn countered that residents have the opportunity to attend all Committee
meetings, the opportunity to attend Ways and Means Committee meetings and the opportunity to
read the minutes of all.
Councilmember Ferencz noted that the minutes do not reflect all of the discuss ion; to which the
Administrator responded that often residents ask for the audio recording that City Hall staff will
provide or, if there are citizen concerns about the dynamics of a meeting, staff offers to make
them a copy of the recording.
Councilmember Ferencz added that many people tell her that they go to the website to watch the
recording of the meeting.
Councilmember Kinghorn indicated that he hears the opposite from residents, and all meetings
have an impact on staff’s time.
Councilmember Kinghorn reviewed the City’s budget process, where each Committee studies
and, ultimately, approves the budget for the department of City government that are under their
purview; the same budget is presented at the Ways and Means Committee where it is all debated
again; until finally the full budget is before City Cou ncil where it again gets approval. He
questioned the usefulness of that months’ long process, when it comes time to purchase a truck
that is included in the approved budget, it must go through the same process again. When items
included in the budget should come up for purchase, that purchase should be made – as long as
it is within budget – without getting three (3) more approvals. On the other hand, when an item is
over budget or not budgeted, it should require action from Ways and Means and City Council.
Chair Ward pointed out that several items on the Council Agenda for approval were not budgeted.
According to Councilmember Kinghorn, the reform in procurement is to approve t he budget and
let the Administrator and Department Heads manage the budget.
Councilmember Ferencz remarked that, between the time the budget is passed and the time a
purchase is to be made, things may have changed. She expressed the opinion that any deviation
from the budget, under or over, should go back to City Council for another approval.
Public Works Committee
September 6, 2016
Page 10 of 11
Chair Ward said that the FY17 budget did not pass unanimously; the Chair voted against the
budget because of certain items that were in it. He wants to have time to discuss the items with
his constituents and let them know what is happening.
Chair Ward w ent on to say that he wants his voice heard on items he is opposed to for those
people who voted him into office.
Councilmember Ferencz asked whether the City Code stipulated that budgeted items must come
to Ways and Means Committee.
The City Administrator said that she was hearing two (2) different things, i.e. Councilmember
Ferencz and Chair Ward would prefer that Council not lump things together for a vote, particularly,
in Council meetings when the votes are recorded and will be watched by citizens because
individually, as things come up, they want to be ensured that they will have an opportunity to make
their position known on the record.
The Administrator heard more about procurement issues from Councilmember Kinghorn, and she
agreed that the procurement code needs to be revised. The toggles included in it for what does
or does not need to be awarded by Council are based on calculations made fifteen (15) years
ago; in addition, developments in law and opinions related to procurement codes need to be
incorporated. She recalled that a review of the procurement code had started just before the
internal controls audit and it was not picked up again. If revised, it would address some of
Councilmember Kinghorn’s concerns that could be approved upon; currently any purchase in
excess of ten thousand dollars ($10,000) must be awarded by Ways and Means and City Council.
In Councilmember Kinghorn’s opinion, the nexus of her motion should be that when the budget
has been thoroughly reviewed and put before the citizenry, a twenty -five thousand dollars
($25,000) purchase of a truck has already been approved on all levels.
Assuming that the motion passes, it will become a recommendation or suggestion to Council, but
as long as the City continues to adhere to its Code and Robert’s Rules of Order; there would be
no violation if, in the future, a Councilmember lumps items together for a vote.
Councilmember Ferencz stated that she feels that, as an elected official, it is her responsibility to
keep her constituents informed about discussions for which they were not present.
Chair Ward called for the vote , and the vote to stop debate was UNANIMOUSLY
APPROVED.
VOTE ON ORIGINAL MOTION: The motion PASSED on a vote of 2 to 1 with
Councilmember Kinghorn casting the nay vote.
F. Clarification of Miscellaneous Business on meeting agendas
Administrator Tucker said that the appearance of “Miscellaneous Business” on an agenda is the
structure of the agenda established in the City Code; if nothing is written under that heading, there
is no “Miscellaneous Business” to go before the Committee or Council. If something needs to be
Public Works Committee
September 6, 2016
Page 11 of 11
discussed that does not fit any other category on the agenda, it should appear under
“Miscellaneous Business” on the printed agenda.
Councilmember Kinghorn thought that the appearance is confusing and that i f there was no
miscellaneous business to discuss, the heading should not appear on the agenda.
Clerk Copeland interrupted to say that the structure of IOP meetings is laid out in the City Code;
therefore, to omit the heading would require an amendment to the Code.
The consensus was to insert the work “None” after the “Miscellaneous Business” heading on an
agenda in the future.
7. Miscellaneous Business
Next Meeting Date: 1:00 p.m., Tuesday, October 11, 2016
8. Adjourn
MOTION: Councilmember Kinghorn moved to adjourn the meeting to 12:42
p.m.; Councilmember Ferencz seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.