August 4, 2016 (PDF, 351.22 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of Aug 4, 2016 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE
9:00 a.m., Thursday, August 4, 2016
The regular meeting of the Public Safety Committee was held at 9:00 a.m., Thursday, August 4,
2016 in the City Hall Conference Room, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South Carolina,
Attending the meeting were Councilmembers Bergwerf and Carroll, Chair Bettelli, Administrator
Tucker, Fire Chief Graham, Captain Usry, Assistant Administrator Fragoso, and Clerk Copeland;
a quorum was present to conduct business.
1. Chair Bettelli called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public had
been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Carroll moved to approve the minutes of the regular
meeting of June 14, 2016 as submitted; Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the
motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizen’s Comments
Jim Raih, 3904 Cameron B oulevard, stated that property owners should have their properties
surveyed since the City is striving to get encroachments out of the rights -of-way on the island.
Since surveys are no longer necessary in the buying process, many property owners may have
encroachments of some type into a neighbor’s yard that they are totally unaware of.
Elizabeth Campsen, 3205 Intracoastal Court, addressed the Committee about the trailer parking
along Waterway and 41st Avenue; she asked that Council review the ordinance t hat prohibits
parking anything over twenty feet (20 ft.) on any rights-of-way. She stated that she has reviewed
years’ worth of Council, Public Safety and Real Property Committee minutes, and this has been
a continuous discussion. She asked that the City study ways in which the existing ordinance
could be enforced.
Ms. Campsen reported having called the City’s Police Department on the day of the Dallas police
shootings to say thank you for what the island’s officers do every day, and she expressed hope
that other residents of the island feel the same way toward all public safety personnel.
4. Old Business
A. Discussion of Encroachments in the Rights-of-way
Councilmember Carroll confirmed that people no longer get as -built surveys when a property
changes hands, but, with the new flood insurance, property owners are required to have a current
elevation certificate that would show any encroachments in the right-of-way.
Chair Bettelli commented that residents need to be educated to call the Police Department when
they see something being installed that could be an encroachment.
Councilmember Bergwerf asked whether the City was going to get an assessment of the
encroachments by the degree of threat they pose to public safety.
Public Safety Committee
August 4, 2016
Page 2 of 8
Captain Usry confirmed that officers are in the process of assessing the island’s encroachments
with an eye toward new encroachments . She reported that in recent weeks as many as five (5)
new encroachments have occurred, and the Livability Officer has sent letters to them noticing that
they must go through the proper procedures with SCDOT to get an approval for the encroachment
or remove it.
B. Updates Related to Coyotes
Captain Usry announced that four (4) coyote sightings were reported in the month of July; she
noted that the Police Department is getting fewer calls despite various postings on Facebook that
are not being reported.
C. Discussion of Parking Kiosks in City-owned Parking Lots
Based on her frequent visits to City Hall, she indicated that she would like for Amy, Clerk of Court,
to have some assistance next summer.
Administrator Tucker stated that the City is no longer staffing the lots on the weekends and that
an article about the City’s parking will in The Post and Courier over the weekend. The subject
primarily is the tickets being placed incorrectly or placed correctly, but, when the car door is
closed, the ticket blows off the dashboard. She reported that the newspaper has copies of the
documentation sent in response to the FOIA request.
There were a few problems related to free parking in the lots by residents who are properly
credentialed; because the City got some based information about Wild Dunes’ stickers, some
people got tickets who should not have – these tickets were reduced to warnings.
Councilmember Carroll reported having received an email from Joe Petro, owner of the Banana
Cabana, who stated that his business has definitely picked up, and he th anked the City for its
response to his problem.
D. Update on 41st Avenue Enforcement
Captain Usry stated that the Police Department has assisted Mr. Bell with some selective traffic
enforcement on 41st Avenue; the results were a confirmation of speeders in both directions on the
street. She has again deployed the radar speed sign until August 24 th; in addition, the City
Administrator has researched speed signs, and the Police Department has worked with Custom
Signals that also provides the ability for the City to place a speed limit sign that will show drivers
their speed versus the speed limit on the street. The Captain also stated that some of th e items
from Custom Signs will be on state contract , and she anticipates the cost for one (1) sign to be
approximately thirty-two hundred dollars ($3,200). The sign could be either portable or stationary,
and there is a slight increase in price to go solar versus electric.
Councilmember Carroll asked about the effectiveness of speed bumps ; the Captain answered
that speed bumps can be very harmful to fire apparatus and emergency vehicles.
Public Safety Committee
August 4, 2016
Page 3 of 8
Administrator Tucker stated that she thought 41 st Avenue was a great application of this p roduct
since it can be attached to the speed limit sign, drawing attention to their speed versus the limit
for that street or road. The Administrator opined that people do not notice the speed limit signs;
they see that they have a straight way into the marina. She cautioned the Committee that this
was not budgeted and would be an out-of-budget expenditure; the recommendation for Ways and
Means would be for an unbudgeted expense of up to three thousand dollars ($3,000) for a speed
sign on 41st Avenue. Since the speeders are traveling in both directions, the City should purchase
two (2) speed signs.
MOTION: Councilmember Carroll moved to purchase 2 solar speed signs up to
and not to exceed $6,000; Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the motion
PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
5. New Business
A. Consideration of a contract award to L32 Mobile Vision for body cameras at
a cost of $18,314.50 (Pg. 25, Hospitality Tax, line 182 – Police Department Non-capital Tools &
Equipment, $17,000 and pg. 10, General Fund, Police Department, line 82 – Non-capital Tools &
Equipment, $800)
Chair Bettelli stated that seventeen thousand eigh t hundred dollars ($17,800) was in the budget
for body cameras for Police officers; the bid has come in approximately five hundred dollars ($500)
over budget.
Captain Usry stated that on July 19 th, the Police Department received a letter from the South
Carolina Department of Public Safety, stating that the City was awarded a grant for body cameras
in the amount of nine thousand six hundred dollars ($9,600).
MOTION: Councilmember Carroll moved to award a contract for L32 Mobile
Vision for body cameras at a cost of $18,314.50; Councilmember Bergwerf
seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
B. Award of a contract award to Vic Bailey Ford for 1 – 2017 Ford Interceptor
SUV (unmarked) at a cost of $27,341 (Pg. 23 – Municipal Accommodations Fee Fund, line 112 –
Police Capital Outlay, $32,000)
MOTION: Chair Bettelli moved to award a contract to Vic Bailey as detailed
above in the amount of $27,341; Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the motion
PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
C. Consideration of a contract award to Benson Ford for 1 Ford 2017 Police
Interceptor Sedan at a cost of $24,467 (Pg. 26, State ATAX – Police Department, ln. 275 –
Police Capital Outlay, $38,250)
MOTION: Chair Bettelli moved to award a contract to Benson Ford for 1 Ford
2017 Police Interceptor sedan at $24,467; Councilmember Carroll seconded and the
motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Public Safety Committee
August 4, 2016
Page 4 of 8
D. Consideration of a contract award to Jones Ford for 1 – 2016 Ford F150 4x4
Super Crew Cab truck at a cost of $31,375.17 (Pg. 27, State ATAX – Fire Department, ln. 283
– Fire Capital Outlay, $32,000)
MOTION: Chair Bettelli moved to award a contract to Jones Ford as detailed
above; Councilmember Bergwerf seconded.
Chief Graham reported that this truck will replace the 2010 Battalion Chief’s truck; that truck will
become a part of the fleet as a vehicle for training/inspection.
E. Request from Smithsonian video -on-demand, Smithsonian Earth, for City -
sponsored event status to allow them to film a rehabilitated turtle release back to
the ocean
MOTION: Chair Bettelli moved to allow Smithsonia n Earth City -sponsored
event status as stated above; Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the motion
PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
F. Discussion of STOP sign at Intersection of 25 th Avenue and Waterway
Boulevard
Chair Bettelli said that there have been problems at this intersection in the past.
Captain Usry reported that the problem this time is with cyclists who want to remove the STOP
sign; the Captain reported that the Department get s complaints of cyclists not stopping at STOP
signs from all over the island. I f this is something that the City would like to do, it can make a
request of SCDOT to consider the removal of the sign.
Chief Buckhannon told the Captain that this particular STOP sign has been here as long as he
has been associated with the City in the 1980s.
Councilmember Carroll voice d his opinion that keeping the sign on Waterway is “imperative.”
Waterway has been getting more and more traffic as residents try to avoid Palm Boulevard.
In the Chair’s opinion, in addition to the public safety factor, he viewed the STOP sign as a traffic
calming device.
Chair Bettelli stated that the Committee took no action to remove the sign.
G. Review Contractor Parking Guidelines
This is on the Agenda as a result of emails the City has received from residents of the island.
According to Captai n Usry, when a contractor goes to the Building Permit to get the necessary
permits, he is also issued up to four (4) special parking permits that allow the subcontracts to park
in the easement in front of the residence under construction. The complaint came from 44th
Public Safety Committee
August 4, 2016
Page 5 of 8
Avenue where there are two (2) residences being built on the same side at the end of the street;
one (1) issue the Police Department was asked to look into was workers parking in residents’
driveways. The police cannot enforce anything on private property, so it is up to the homeowner
to ask the driver to leave or have the vehicle towed.
H. Discussion of Safety Concerns related to Bike Path South of the Connector
Chair Bettelli recounted that the City had made a TST request for several years running for a bike
path from Breach Inlet to 57th Avenue. He agreed that currently the island is not safe for cyclists
and that he does not know whether the rights-of-way are wide enough to accommodate regulation
bike paths from one end of the island to the other.
The Administrator confirmed that the City has been pressing for re gulation bike paths on both
sides of Palm Boulevard for the island; she noted that cyclists exiting the Connector and heading
south are first greeted by a pothole on Palm. The entire stretch of road is deteriorating in places,
and the debris from the dete rioration is ending up on the one (1) bike lane that exists. The
Administrator acknowledged that this stretch of road needs attention and it would be better if bike
lanes were on both sides. That is the advocacy stated in the Public Works Committee meeting.
The advocacy from the Public Works meeting was that something needs to be done to maintain
what is there now, whether the TST request is ever acted upon or not.
Administrator Tucker reminded the Committee that this was brought to SCDOT’s attention after
Joaquin; she commented that she had reached out to SCDOT after the Public Works meeting,
asking if there was any update and they have not responded.
MOTION: Councilmember Carroll moved to make a bicycle path from the end of
the Connector and around the corner heading south on Palm Boulevard to make it
safer; Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the motion PASSED
UNANIMOUSLY.
6. Highlights of Departmental Reports
Fire Department – Chief Graham
On June 3rd, personnel responded to a call of a boat on fire in the ocean; upon investigation, the
crew determined that the smoke was diesel exhaust from a boat’s engine. Two (2) swimmers
were reported to be caught in a rip current around the 4100 block of Palm on June 7 th; the four
(4) subjects were returned to shore unharmed. Also on June 7th crews responded to a canoe that
had capsized in the ocean; when crews arrived, three (3) individuals were hanging onto the boat
and two (2) others were back in the canoe. All of the individuals were returned to shore unharmed;
the canoe was also retrieved by Fire Department personnel. Responding to a report of a structure
fire on Seagrass Lane, personnel found that the hydraulic pump that operates the elevator was
the source of the smoke. On June 17 th in a thunderstorm, personnel responded to a call of an
overturned boat with people in the water in the Intracoastal Waterway; after find ing the original
caller, the crew found the boat stranded in the marsh. The boat was secured with an anchor, and
the five (5) passengers were transported back to the IOP M arina. Fire personnel responded to
one hundred fifty-three (153) calls in June, the highest number in thirteen (13) years, and forty-
Public Safety Committee
August 4, 2016
Page 6 of 8
seven (47) of the calls were for EMS. Sixteen (16) pre-incident surveys were conducted in the
month. Directing attention to page 25 of the June report, Chief Graham stated that the Fire
Department exceeded its Vehicle Maintenance budget significantly; Tower 1002, the ninety-five
(95) foot ladder truck required new brakes prior to the end of the year for approximately thirty -
eight hundred dollars ($3,800). In addition, truck 1001, the newest of the pumpers needed to
have the diesel particulate filter sensor cleaned at just under one thousand dollars ($1,000). In
June, many station tours were conducted, and firefighters conducted demonstrations of the jet -
ski and water rescue for visitors on Front Beach and at the Recreation Center.
On July 2 nd, personnel responded to a boat tha t had run aground in the Intracoastal Waterway;
passengers of the twenty-one foot (21 ft.) boat were transferred to the Fire Department boat and
took them to the IOP Marina. On July 7 th, personnel responded to a call of people stuck inside
an elevator; up on arrival, the crew secured the power, and assisted the individuals out of the
elevator. Property management was advised to have the elevator serviced before allowing it to
be used again. The total number of calls for the month was one hundred eighty -nine (189), and
seventy-five (75) calls were for EMS. Seven (7) pre -incident surveys were done, and seven (7)
fire inspections were conducted. This year has started as last year ended with large vehicle
maintenance costs; Engine 1002, a 2003 model, required replacement of the coolant hose, engine
1001, the newest truck, needed to have the diesel particulate filter cleaned, and Ladder 1001 had
to have eleven (11) ball valves rebuilt in the fire pump and the replacement of the transducer for
the pressure governor. Again firefighters conducted many station tours and assisted with the IOP
Beach Run.
Police Department – Captain Usry
On June 4th, officers located a suspicious vehicle in Wild Dunes and, in the course of a traffic stop,
an officer observed an ammunition magazine in the open console, located a loaded handgun
under the front passenger seat and a rifle sticking through the trunk into the back seat.
Additionally, the officers found several electronic items, women’s purses and other items; a local
agency confirmed that they had had several break -ins; the subjects were arrested and taken to
the Al Cannon Detention Center. The island experienced six (6) thefts from a motor vehicle in
the month of June; people are leaving their keys and other valuables on the beach with no one to
keep an eye on them. They are being stolen and then taken to the street or parking lot to see
which vehicle reacts to the electronic signals. The Department did a piece with Channel 4 on the
“Beach Bag Bandits.” Ten (10) people were issued citations for alcohol on the beach in June.
Officer Chris Enourato was recognized for his professionalism for his assisting residents with a
recurring raccoon problem. Pfc. Storen was recognized for receiving the silver pin for the 2015
DUI Enforcement Hero Award for the thirty-four (34) DUI arrests he made in 2015. Officer Shena
Crockett was recognized by a citizen for her professionalism an d politeness during the
performance of her duties. Communication Specialist Jane Stewart was recognized as a
dedicated employee who is always eager to take on new tasks; she can be depended upon to
complete any project she is assigned. During the month, dispatchers responded to five thousand
seven hundred forty -five calls (5,745); forty -six hundred one (4,601) were for the Police
Department. Three hundred five (305) traffic stops were made in the month, and eighty-eight (88)
citations were issued. For the month of June, twenty (20) citations were issued in the Animal
Control Report and year-to-date the total is sixty-four (64). Fourteen (14) noise complaints were
Public Safety Committee
August 4, 2016
Page 7 of 8
filed in June; one (1) citation was written and nine (9) warnings; the balance were deemed to be
unfounded.
On Tuesday, July 12 th, a resident reported having received a bill that appeared to be from an
electric company stating that, if the bill was not paid by a certain date, the power to his residence
would be shut down; the resident also received a phone call giving him instructions to send a
money gram. After following the instructions and paying the bill, the victim contacted the power
company only to learn that this was not their normal business practice; the case has been turned
to CID for investigation. On the same day, a victim reported that he had left his beach bag
unattended, and it was stolen along with his car keys; the approximate value of the stolen items
was almost two hundred dollars ($200). On July 19th, officers reported to the scene of a low speed
vehicle striking the residence and the occupants fleeing; damage to the house was about one
thousand dollars ($1,000) and the value of the stolen LSV is ten thousand dollars ( $10,000). A
victim reported that unknown persons had entered an unsecured residence by making a hole in
the wall through the garage area; they stole multiple televisions and other electronic equipment
valued at twenty-seven thousand dollars ($27,000). In July officers wrote seventeen (17) citations
for alcohol on the beach. Pfc. Storen was promoted to the rank of sergeant effective July 1. The
total number of calls in July was six thousand four hundred eighty-eight (6,488), and five thousand
two hundred seventy-nine (5,279) were for the Police Department, representing an eighteen
percent (18%) increase for the same period in 2015. Two hundred eighty-eight (288) traffic stops
were made in July with fifty-four (54) of the drivers getting citations. Fourteen (14) citations were
issued for dog license or dog at large violations. For July, six (6) noise complaints were called in,
but not citations were issued; four (4) calls received warnings and two (2) were unfounded.
In light of the recent attacks on Po lice officers, Captain Usry stated that the residents of the Isle
of Palms have brought in food, snacks, and cards; generally, the officers are being shown a great
deal of support from the community.
Next Meeting Date: 9:00 a.m., Monday, September 12th in the City Hall Conference Room
Chair Bettelli thanked the public safety personnel and members of the Recreation Department for
their fine work on the July 4 th fireworks; he said that he has gotten several emails stating how
wonderful the fireworks display was this year. He also stated that the national Night Out was a
great celebration at the Rec Center that drew a great crowd.
Administrator Tucker thought th e food and the helicopter were “really good” additions this year.
She was grateful to the businesses who donated food for the event.
Councilmember Bergwerf complimented Chief Graham on the “fabulous” fireworks display on July
4th. As the fireworks were beginning, members of the Turtle Team were notified that a turtle had
come ashore to lay her nest, but the Police took care of the crowd , the people were great, some
held up big blankets so the turtle would not be distracted by the fireworks.
8. Executive Session – unnecessary
9. Adjournment
Public Safety Committee
August 4, 016
Page 8 of 8
MOTION: Councilmember Carroll moved to adjourn the meeting at 10:09 a.m.;
Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted,
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.