July 6, 2016 (PDF, 318.14 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of Jul 6, 2016 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
PUBLIC WORKS COMMITTEE
4:30 p.m., Wednesday, July 6, 2016
The regular meeting of the Public Works Committee was held at 4:30 p.m., Wednesday, July 6,
2016 in the City Hall Conference Room, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South Carolina.
Attending the meeting were Councilmember Ferencz and Chair Ward, Adminis trator Tucker,
Director Pitts, Assistant Director Fragoso and City Clerk Copeland. Councilmember Kinghorn
was absent.
1. Chair Ward called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public had
been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Minutes of Previous Meeting
MOTION: Councilmember Ferencz moved to approve the minutes of the regular
meeting of June 2, 2016 as submitted; Chair Ward seconded and the motion
PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments – None
MOTION: Councilmember Ferencz moved to re-order the Agenda to address the
one (1) item under New Business; Chair Ward seconded and the motion PASSED
UNANIMOUSLY.
6. New Business
Discussion of Increasing Frequency of Service to Beach Trash Containers
Director Pitts said that Bill Schupp had brought to his attention the increased volume of garbage
coming from the beach barrels; Mr. Schupp indicated that he could pick up containers of garbage
every day that were filled. In the week before and the week of July 4th, Mr. Schupp has picked up
garbage every day.
Mr. Schupp stated that he was picking up two to two and a half (2-2½) dumpsters of garbage; the
dumpsters hold thirty eight cubic yards (38 cu. yds.) of material. Followin g the July 4th activities,
he picked up one hundred fourteen cubic yards (114 cu. yds.) of garbage – the most he has ever
seen.
Noting that Mr. Schupp was willing, Director Pitts wanted the Committee to authorize him to have
beach garbage pickups everyday throughout the summer.
Administrator Tucker said that the contract with Schupp Enterprises would be amended to include
garbage pickup every day.
Chair Ward asked how much money would be added to the budget for the additional services,
and Mr. Schupp responded that the cost would be one thousand eighty -two dollars ($1,082) per
week.
Public Works Committee
July 6, 2016
Page 2 of 8
MOTION: Chair Ward moved to amend the City’s contract with Schupp
Enterprises for beach garbage removal seven days per week; Councilmember
Ferencz seconded.
Councilmember Ferencz inquired about the need to obtain larger barrels to put on the beach, but
Mr. Schupp responded that no one makes a barrel larger than the fifty-five gallons (55 gal.) barrels
currently on the beach.
Director Pitts indicated that increasing the number of barrels on the beach was not the answer;
he opined that, in certain ar eas, there are too many barrels, such as Property Owners Beach
House or Front Beach.
Mr. Schupp commented that his son has agreed to assist him and make the pickups two or three
(2-3) days a week. He added that the City would not be charged for the days he does not make
a run.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
The Administrator noted that this action would not be fin al until after the Council meeting at the
end of the month, but she asked that he consider it to be approved now.
Director Pitts stated that the maximum impact to the budget would be for eleven (11) weeks, the
number of weeks the City has twice a week garbage pickups.
Chair Ward referred back to the minutes of the last meeting that state d “Councilmember
Kinghorn’s absence was excused.” At the last meeting, he asked that the Personnel Committee
look into what constituted an “excused absence,” and he h as since learned that the City has no
specific guidelines relative to that matter. He asked that, in the future, the Clerk simply state that
someone was absent. The Chair opined that meeting attendance was important and was owed
to the community.
Councilmember Ferencz recalled seeing that, if a Committee member was to be absent from a
meeting, he should contact staff or the Committee chair to notify them ahead of the meeting.
Administrator Tucker commented that, the majority of the time, staff has b een alerted that
someone would be absent.
Chair Ward stated that, as Committee Chair, he does not like to make motions because he feels
that the appearance is that the person is dominating the meeting; he added that he was hesitant
to second motions.
Councilmember Ferencz stated that, for her, the problem of one (1) member’s absence from a
three (3) member committee was that only two (2) people end up making a decision to recommend
to all of Council.
4. Department Reports for June 2016 – Director Pitts
Public Works Committee
July 6, 2016
Page 3 of 8
A. Vehicle Maintenance and Trash Collection Tracking Reports
Director Pitts commented that the Public Works Committee has been very busy; the Department
has been so busy that the City Administrator told the Director to get assistance in mowing, that
was being done on a bi -weekly schedule when the time could be “manufactured.” The Director
got two (2) bids, and the low bidder was HDR; since time was of the essence, they were put to
work right away. They will mow on a weekly basis unless the City does not get any rain and the
mowing can be postponed a week.
Administrator Tucker noted that extra funds were included in the FY17 budget for additional
mowing.
An extra shift was run the Saturday after Memorial Day for debris removal in the center part of
the island, and Eadie’s completed the year’s maintenance plan for ditch restructuring on June 30,
2016.
As was foreshadowed, vehicle maintenance ended the fiscal year over budget by approximately
twenty-nine hundred dollars ($2,900).
In June, yard debris was up by thirty tons (30 T.) from the same month last year; for garbage
collection, the island has almost reached pre-single stream recycling levels.
Chair Ward stated that the appearance of the island was very important; the people who come
here have certain expectations that the City should meet.
B. Reports on Investigation of Stormwater Complaint on Charleston Boulevard
The Administrator stated tha t personnel from Charleston County Stormwater camera-ed the
system at 203 Charleston and she had reviewed it. She anticipates the conclusion to be that this
is something that was installed privately and is now failing; the question of whether or not it should
be there remains to be learned, as well as where the water is going. I t could be running into the
waste water system and not the drainage system, but she does not think the current owners are
responsible. Now that it is failing, everyone is trying t o determine who is responsible for the
repairs; with the facts available at this time, the City is not responsible.
Director Pitts reported that there is a stormwater drain running parallel to Charleston Boulevard,
and, at 203 Charleston, there is a pipe that connects into this stormwater system that runs about
five to six feet (5 -6 ft.) from the house at 203 Charleston. The camera did not find where the
underground guttering ends or whether it flushes before it enters the pipe and is in the ground
and covered over; the camera also did not show where the pipe might have been connected.
If the line is private and without a deed, the recommendation from the County would be to put in
a new work order with them and they will block the City’s system thereb y abandoning that pipe
because it appears to go nowhere. If it attaches to Water and Sewer, they will abandon the pipe
very quickly.
Public Works Committee
July 6, 2016
Page 4 of 8
The Administrator speculated that, ultimately, the determination will b e that this problem is one
that the property owner will have to deal with and bear the expense for repairs.
Related to the Director’s report, if there is further development at the Villages in Wild Dunes,
possibly an expansion, the City or Wild Dunes may have to relocate some infrastructure from the
Phase I drainage project to keep it functioning and out of the way of whatever they do.
5. Old Business
A. Update on Phase II Drainage
Assistant Fragoso reported that the City has received one (1) of the easement documents, a
second is still being reviewed by the Water and Sewer Commission’s attorney, and the third
temporary easement for relocating the golf cart path will be forthcoming after contact has finally
been made with the owner who lives out of the country.
B. Update on Public Restrooms
Administrator Tucker stated that there was nothing new to report and the decision has been made
to let the situation cool for a couple of months.
C. Discussion of BIG Application
Acknowledging that the application has been submitted, Chair Ward remarked that he still has
questions. He asked when the redevelopment plan combining input from the Real Property
Committee and the tenants was completed.
Administrator Tucker responded that she did not think the plan has been completed because the
subject is on the agenda for the next Real Property Commi ttee meeting to be held the next
morning.
The Chair then asked why all of the scenarios that have been shown to Council were not included
in the application, as well as the one (1) that was included.
The Administrator stated that the rendering included was the most recent plan that had been
worked on by the Real Property Committee and ATM.
To which Councilmember Ferencz co mmented that Councilmembers had not seen the new one
until they received the application already submitted.
The Administrator explained the newest scenario is what was drawn in the last charrette between
the Real Property Committee, the marina tenants and ATM and, answering the Councilmember’s
question, it has not been formally approved; it is only the most up-to-date plan.
Councilmember Ferencz asked whether the Administrator had compared this most recent version
with Scenario C that Council had said go forward with; in her opinion, the differences were huge.
Public Works Committee
July 6, 2016
Page 5 of 8
She said that she was amazed that the City was able to apply for a federal grant with information
that had not been seen by City Council.
Administrator Tucker opined that the reasoning was that the sce nario represented the last plan
worked on. She recalled that Council had referred the project to the Real Property Committee for
further refining and that was done. Knowing that changes could be made to the grant after it was
submitted, the reasonable thing to do was to submit the most recent redevelopment plan.
Councilmember Ferencz referred to the plan submitted with the grant as “the tenants’ version.”
In her opinion, the new plan appears to include almost all of the items on the list of recom -
mendations from the marina tenants, while she thought Council was looking at the residents’ plan.
She expressed disappointment at presenting this plan to the federal government as if it were the
City’s marina redevelopment plan.
The Administrator stated that she did not recall that all of Council had given staff “the go-ahead;”
the Scenario C plan was referred to the Real Property Committee for additional work. The Real
Property Committee with input from the marina tenants and residents present did additional work.
Quoting from the min utes of the Real Property Committee meeting of June 2, Councilmember
Ferencz said “the City will need the sketch for meeting packets that will be distributed June 17th,”
but there was no drawing included in packets.
Administrator Tucker noted that the work product was completed after the Real Property
Committee meeting, so it was seen by the Committee only in the live working area. They saw the
rendering in the BIG application, but it does include what they instructed ATM to include.
Councilmember Ferencz then said that the Mayor, in a letter of support, has indicated that the
City will provide “the primary financial match” in the amount of four hundred eighty -five thousand
dollars ($485,000) which has not been brought before Council.
When the decision was made to go forward with the application, a known fact was that the City
would have to commit to the local match; the match was discussed at the June Ways and Means
Committee meeting and the June City Council meeting. Council did not have a dollar amount at
that time, because the cost estimates had not been made; therefore, Council decided on the
percentage of costs to which the City would commit.
Councilmember Ferencz asked whether the City could be in legal trouble for not being open with
the residents or Council in terms of moving forward with information that has not been dissemi -
nated or discussed.
The Administrator responded in the negative because City Council authorized sending the project
to the Real Property Committee for additional work; the Committee did the work; and the rendering
included with the application was the product of that work. In addition, Council authorized the
submission of the application with clear advice that the plan going with the application likely would
not be perfect or what would be the ultimate project . In order to meet the deadline, it seemed
logical to include the most recent version of the redevelopment plan with the application.
Public Works Committee
July 6, 2016
Page 6 of 8
Chair Ward stated that this latest version is the one (1) he likes the least, and he commented that
the residents who live near the marina do not like it because all of the changes appear to benefit
the commercial entities and not the residents.
The Chair took note of statements that the marina and Morgan Creek Grill would provide “in kind”
matches and asked why they were not being asked to make financial commitments since they
will see great benefits from the marina redevelopment.
Responding to the Chair, Administrator Tucker noted that the City would receive money to offset
the costs of replacing the docks which otherwise the City would have to fund alone.
Also stated in the application is that the marina will “provide 615 linea r feet of berthing space
dedicated to eligible transient boaters “ and “provide 725 linear feet of berthing space that will be
shared between eligible transient boaters and other uses.” Councilmember Ferencz thought that
this contradicted what she had be en told in that residents would have access to only the seven
hundred twenty-five feet (725 linear ft.) of shared dock space.
The application adds restrooms and replaces the fueling infrastructure none of which have been
approved according to Councilmember Ferencz.
The Administrator thought that new restrooms were always a part of the plan because the
restroom facilities now are inadequate.
The rendition that seemed to please most members of Council had a commercial side and a more
residential side c learly identified; in this iteration, several of the business entities have been
moved off of Morgan Creek and on the Intracoastal Waterway. She indicated that the businesses
want as much water access as possible, but that has never been a function of this marina. It was
purchased to give residents water access, not all water access and dockage to the marina
manager.
Based on his experience in the Coast Guard, Chair Ward said that he was confident that the
Harbor Master at Dewees had problems with the m arina businesses all located on the Morgan
Creek side so near the ramp they use. The Dewees ramp; handles much larger vessels and
needs room to maneuver.
Councilmember Ferencz said that sh e was disappointed that neither the residents nor Council
had been consulted about the most recent iteration of the marina redevelopment plan before it
was submitted with the application. She then asked who had approve d the content of the grant
application.
Administrator Tucker stated that she had read the grant to ensure that there were no
inconsistencies with the discussions at the last Real Property Committee. The Administrator then
offered to make a copy of the recording of the Real Property Committee meeting for the members
of the Public Works Committee.
Chair Ward said that what he had heard from residents attending the Real Property Committee
do not understand why, to sit at the table with the Committee, requires that one do business with
Public Works Committee
July 6, 2016
Page 7 of 8
the City, make a pre sentation and then leave. The Chair continued that his understanding was
that all of the interested parties were sitting around the table and making decision s while the
residents in attendance were not allowed to talk.
The Administrator explained that the discussion was designed to be a design charrette, and
citizens did make comments in the meeting, but it was to be a work session of taking that advice
and making drawings to work through all of the things that were pres ented. The newest version
of the redevelopment plan was the result of that discussion.
The Chair foreshadowed problems in the future if the City is envisioning starting the process in a
year or so.
Councilmember Ferencz concluded that she could tell r esidents that the plan submitted with the
application was not the City’s plan.
Administrator Tucker suggested that she reply that it was the plan submitted with the grant
application for the water side improvements at the marina, but it will be subject to change
throughout the grant pro cess. She also reminded the Committee that this grant process takes
most of a year.
Assistant Fragoso stated that the “hard” deadline to submit the grant application was July 1, 2016;
DNR will submit the final to Fish and Wildlife on September 8 th, but give ATM/the City feedback
on the application the first week of August, leaving ATM/the City a month to make modifications
to the plan.
The Administrator asked that the committee remember that the grant application is cent ered
around the dock replacement and improvements and amenities that go with that; it is not focused
on the entire redevelopment plan.
According to Councilmember Ferencz, the docks are what residents are most interested in – they
want slips and a place to fish and walk along the water, but the City appears to be seeking to
attract more transient boats to the marina that will take slip space away from the residents.
The Administrator pointed to the Real Property Committee minutes where she had made a similar
statement.
Councilmember Ferencz repeated that the residents had purchased the marina to have water
access.
The Administrator recommended that Councilmember Ferencz express her concerns to Council
and noted that the City could withdraw the application.
Before the City moves forward, Councilmember Ferencz said that she wants to hear from the
citizens about what they want and proceed with the referendum.
In the beginning of the process, charrettes were held with different groups of people and a website
was opened specifically to receive input about the marina redevelopment from everyone who was
Public Works Committee
July 6, 2016
Page 8 of 8
interested. The Administrator stated that, based on her experience, people do not make specific
comments until they have something specific about which to comment.
Chair Ward said that the time has come for the City Attorney to develop the referendum question
that may need to be prefaced by a Council work session to find out what the City is trying to say,
but the biggest thing the City is going to learn from the referendum is how much money the City
should spend on the project. In his opinion, the residents need to be heard.
Councilmember Ferencz noted that Council and other stakeholders may be going through these
exercises only to learn that the residents will not support a marina redevelopment plan.
In conclusion, Councilmember Ferencz charged the Administ rator with representing the opinion
of the Public Works Committee that the plan that accompanied the application was not for the
people to the Real Property Committee meeting tomorrow morning; the Councilmember asked
the Real Property Committee to reconsider the fact that “this plan takes away the ability for the
residents to get to the water – it does not enhance it.”
Councilmember Ferencz opined that, if Council is again faced with an imminent deadline, it might
be better to delay until the next round.
D. Discussion of Pooper-scoopers
Chair Ward has been told that people with larger dogs want larger pooper-scoopers.
Administrator Tucker noted that she has been approached by others on this subject before, she
stated that the design in use today is the same as it was when the program began. Now they are
seen everywhere and there are many new designs. She suggested that, at the next meeting,
staff offer some of the alternatives containers and designs that could be used in the future; since
the City has outlawed plastic bags, a different material needs to be found.
E. Update on Golf Cart Path on Palm Boulevard between 18th and 20th Avenues
Assistant Fragoso reported that the contract was awarded and will be executed next week; once
executed, the contractor has forty-five (45) days to complete the job.
7. Miscellaneous Business
Next Meeting Date: 4:30 p.m., Monday, August 1, 2016 in the Conference Room.
8. Adjourn
MOTION: Councilmember Ferencz moved to adjourn the meeting at 5:43 p.m.;
Chair Ward seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland, City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.