June 7, 2016 (PDF, 121.26 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of Jun 7, 2016 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Board of Zoning Appeals
Minutes
June 7, 2016
I. Call to order
The regular meeting of the Board of Zoning Appeals was called to order on June 7, 2016 at
5:30 p.m. in the City Hall Conference Room, 1207 Palm Boulevard. Members present were
Pete Doherty, Carolyn Holscher, Arnold Karig, Glen Thornburg and Jay Leigh; also Secretary
Douglas Kerr was present.
Mr. Kerr acknowledged that the meeting had been advertised in compliance with State law and
the properties had been posted.
II. Approval of minutes
The next item on the agenda was the review of the minutes of the May 3, 2016 meeting. Ms.
Holscher made a motion to approve the minutes and Mr. Thornburg seconded the motion. The
vote was unanimous in favor of the motion.
III. Home Occupancies
Mr. Karig explained that the Board acted as a quasi-judicial body and all comments made were
treated in the same manner as court testimony; therefore, any person who would like to speak
to the Board should be sworn in. He then swore in all members of the audience that would be
speaking.
2802 Hartnett Boulevard
Mr. Kerr explained that the applicant was requesting a special exception to allow the
establishment of an office for a pet sitting business.
Ms. Holscher asked if the pets would be limited to cats and dogs. The applicant, Rebekah
Boyd, answered yes only cats and dogs. Ms. Boyd explained that her business would involve
checking on and walking client’s pets at their homes.
Mr. Thornburg asked the applicant if there would ever be an occasion that dogs that do not
belong to her would be at her house. Ms. Boyd answered only if she was watching a friends’
dog.
Ms. Christina Carlson, 2805 Cameron Boulevard, explained that her property backed up to
2802 Hartnett and she was concerned about noise and sanitation. She explained that she has
already noticed other people’s dogs at the house and she has seen reviews of the business
online that suggest she is already keeping other people’s dogs at her home and the business
is not limited to office work only at the home.
Board of Zoning Appeals Minutes
June 7, 2016
Page 2
Mr. Doherty asked what constituted watching a “friends” dog, someone that does not pay?
And how many dogs would potentially be at the house at once?
Ms. Boyd answered, yes that a friend’s dog would be someone who is not paying her and
there would never be more than one dog other than her own at the house.
Ms. Carlson explained that she felt that the applicant has already shown an interest in having
clients’ dogs at the house and she does not want to be put in a position of having to be the
watchdog neighbor that has to check to see how many dogs are on the property. She stated
that she thought it would be everybody best interest if the business was not allowed to be
established at this home from the onset.
Ms. Holscher explained that she would like to have an opportunity to look at the website that
has been mentioned and look into the matter further and she made a motion to continue the
case until the next meeting. Mr. Leigh seconded the motion and the vote was unanimous in
favor of continuing the case.
1 Tabby Lane
Mr. Kerr explained that the applicant was requesting a special exception to allow the
establishment of an office for a commercial property maintenance business.
The applicant, Mike Efremov, explained that this was really a paper company and he would
only be using the mailing address of the house, but all work would be done away from the
home.
Ms. Holscher asked if there would be any signs visible at the house. Mr. Efremov answered
no, nothing would be visible from the house.
Mr. Doherty made a motion to approve the request and Mr. Leigh seconded the motion. The
vote was unanimous in favor of the motion.
IV. Appeals
#5- 5th Avenue
Mr. Kerr explained that the next request was an appeal of his decision as the City’s Zoning
Administrator. He explained that this was not like a variance or special exception request in
that there were no criteria that the applicant needed to meet. The Board’s role would be to
determine whether or not the Zoning Administrator was interpreting the code correctly. He
explained that Section 5-4-12(g) included a mathematical equation that involves averaging the
Board of Zoning Appeals Minutes
June 7, 2016
Page 3
setback of the neighboring houses and the applicants believe that it is being incorrectly
interpreted and the code allows for a greater reduction in setbacks than what the Zoning
Administrator is allowing. He stated that the Board should read the Code and review the
request and make a ruling as to what the correct interpretation of the Code is.
Mr. Kerr stated that the Code reads:
“The zoning district front yard setback requirements for dwellings shall not apply to any
lot where the average setback of existing buildings located within on hundred feet (100’)
of each side of the dwelling within the same block and fronting on the same street is
less than the required front yard setback. In such case the average setback on such lot
shall not be less than the average setback of the existing buildings.”
He stated that the disagreement about the code comes down to which of the neighboring
houses are fronting on the same street, 5th Avenue. He stated that it was his interpretation of
the code that the all of the three other houses on the block are fronting on 5th Avenue,
because the code dictates that those lots have front yards and front property lines abutting 5th
Avenue. He stated that the applicants believe that because the houses on the corner lots have
addresses to the other streets, Ocean Boulevard and Carolina Boulevard, they are not fronting
on 5th Avenue and therefore should not be included in determining the average setback.
The applicant’s attorney, Mr. Hamlin O’Kelly, explained that the City’s code does not include a
definition of the term fronting. He stated that it does include a definition for frontage and front
yard, but not for fronting. He distributed pictures of the houses on the corners, 416 Carolina
Boulevard and 415 Ocean Boulevard, and stated that both houses have front doors facing their
respective roads, not 5th Avenue, and both have addresses on their respective roads, not 5th
Avenue, he stated that therefore he believed that the correct interpretation of the code was that
they were not fronting on 5th Avenue and therefore should not be included in the setback
calculation.
Mr. Leigh explained that from looking at the photographs he agreed that 416 Carolina
Boulevard is not fronting 5th Avenue, but he felt like because the stairs, driveway and mailbox
of 415 Ocean Boulevard were on 5th Avenue, he felt like it was fronting 5th Avenue.
Mr. Kerr stated that if the Board was going to provide a new interpretation of the Code, he
would hope that there would be some detail given about what factors should be considered
when making a judgement: front door location, driveway location, mailbox location, or
something else.
Mr. Karig stated that as he saw the Board’s role in the process they were to determine if an
error had been made in interpreting the Code and he could not find anything that suggests an
error was made.
Board of Zoning Appeals Minutes
June 7, 2016
Page 4
Mr. Thornburg stated that on his personal home he was faced with a very challenging setback
situation and he had to include a curved wall in the design of his house to comply with the
ordinance and he felt that things such as this can contribute to the house’s character and
ultimately result in a higher resale.
The owner, Ms. Linda West, explained that she wanted a rectangular design for the house and
would not be interested in having a curved wall in the design.
Mr. Doherty explained that he also had a house on a corner lot and when the City Council
changed the Code to require corner lots to meet the front yard setback on both street sides,
this severely limited owner’s ability to develop those lots.
Mr. Doherty stated that City Council could choose to clarify the ordinance by including a
definition of fronting.
Mr. Kerr stated that Council could change the code to include a definition of fronting. He
stated that in 2002 City Council amended the code to require corner lots to have front yards on
both streets and he had distributed the comments from the public hearing and he felt that the
discussion at the time indicated that it was their intent to have all of the houses on a block to
have the same front yard requirement, which he felt supported the position that they are all
fronting on the same road.
Mr. Doherty stated that he cannot see that any error was made in interpreting the code and
therefore made a motion to affirm the determination made by the Zoning Administrator. Mr.
Thornburg seconded the motion. The vote was unanimous in favor of affirming the Zoning
Administrator’s interpretation.
V. Miscellaneous Business
Mr. Kerr stated the only thing he had to discuss was the date of the next meeting, which was
scheduled for July 5th, the day after a holiday. He asked if members of the Board would be
travelling or if they would rather meet the following week. The Board members agreed that
July 5th would work for their schedules.
VI. Adjournment
With no other business, the meeting was adjourned at 5:45 PM.
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.