Regular Meeting - May 24, 2016. (PDF, 434.87 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of May 24, 2016 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
CITY COUNCIL
6:00 p.m., Tuesday, May 24, 2016
The regular meeting of City Council was held at 6:00 p.m., Tuesday, May 24, 2016 in Council
Chambers of City Hall, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South Carolina. Attending the
meeting were Councilmembers Bergwerf, Bettelli, Carroll, Ferencz, Harringt on, Rice and Ward,
Mayor Cronin, Administrator Tucker, Attorney Halversen, Assistant Administrator Fragoso and
Clerk Copeland; a quorum was present to conduct business. The absence of Councilmember
Kinghorn was excused.
1. Mayor Cronin called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public had
been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act. Following
a brief invocation and the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag, Clerk Copeland called the roll.
2. Reading of the Journals of Previous Meetings
MOTION: Councilmember Bettelli moved to approve the minutes of the regular
meeting of April 26, 2016 and the Special Meeting of April 28, 2016 as submitted;
Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Councilmember Ferencz noted that the dollar amounts associated with changes to the budget
should be reported in the minutes of budget workshops in the future.
3. Citizens’ Comments
Joe Petro of Coconut Joe’s urged Council to reconsider the parking fees that are currently being
charged in the municipal lots . He explained that his restaurant does not get the usual beach -
goer, but gets people who want to have dinner, walk on the beach and then go home or to The
Windjammer or The Banana Cabana. They come in at 5:30 p.m. and must pay ten dollars ($10)
for two and a half (2½) hours of parking before they get out of their cars. In his opinion, the
preferred parking would be on the street at a dollar and a half ($1.50) per hour, where parking is
typically not available, so the person must go into secondary parking in the municipal lot and pay
ten dollars ($10). He suggested that either the City revert to the way it was, i.e. parking in the
municipal lots free after 6:00 p.m.; he reported that he gets most of his customers after 5:00 p.m.
His second suggestion was to make all of the kiosks the same; he opined that the City would get
more money if it were to go to an hourly rate. He stated that he thought it wa s “egregious to
charge ten dollars ( $10) at 6:00 p.m. for two (2) hours of parking.” He concluded with asking
Council to consider making a change and the sooner the better.
Gerald Johnson, 3102 Cameron Boulevard, recalled that he had spoken to Council at the Ways
and Means Committee meet ing of May 17 th regarding the loss of his boat slip at the marina; at
that time, he requested a copy of the City’s l ease with the marina manager; it was sent to him,
and he appreciated the gesture. His situation was resolved when he sat down with Manager
Berrigan and the facts were laid out; the result was a win-win situation. He stated that Mr. Berrigan
was doing a great job at the marina and appreciated one (1) comment he made that he would
rather rent to a resident than an off-islander.
Mr. Johnson addressed the parking situation around his house; he acknowledged that the island
has parking issues and that Council is trying to do something about it. He commented that he
has been parking in front of his home for forty-five (45) years, and he has had more troubles since
City Council
May 24, 2016
Page 2 of 14
the houses around him became short term rentals and people want to park in front of his house.
He stated that he has called the police numerous times to see what co uld be done about it, and
been informed that the officer could not write a ticket because it was private property. Now he
has to get a s ticker, and, if friend or his family comes to visit, thery cannot park in front of his
house any more without getting a parking pass. He said that he thought the burden was going to
be put on the day -trippers, but the burden has been placed on the residents to get residential
parking stickers. He noted that he has one (1) sticker on his car allowing him to return to this
home after a hurricane, and he did not understand why that would not suffice. He added that he
must buy a booklet of passes for his family to visit him. He understood that rental property should
have off-street parking for number of cars that can be there. He said that Council shou ld always
ask one (1) question in relation to everything they act upon and that question is “What benefit will
the residents receive from what Council does?” He concluded by reminding Councilmembers
that November was coming soon.
4. Reports from Standing Committees
A. Ways and Means Committee
From the meeting of May 17th, the Mayor reported that Mr. Johnson had addressed the Committee
regarding issues he was having at the marina. Frank Carson from the Charleston County Public
Works Department expla ined the two (2) FEMA Public Assistance projects the County was
proposing for the Isle of Palms if the City will commit to paying the twenty-five percent (25%) local
share. One (1) drainage project would be on Ocean Boulevard from 4th Avenue to Breach Inlet
and the second would involve cleaning and assessing the island’s piped drainage system. The
cost of the first project is two hundred fifty-three thousand seventy-seven dollars ($253,077). The
second project has a cost of six hundred thirty thousand dollars ($630,000); the City’s twenty-five
percent (25%) share totals two hundred twenty thousand eight hundred forty dollars ($220,840).
In the Treasurer’s financial reports, the Committee was told that, with a target of eighty -three
percent (83%), General Fund revenues were at seventy-nine percent (79%) of budget, which was
actually ahead of where the City was last year. Property Taxe s are the same as last year being
one hundred percent (100%) of where the City was last year. The cash balance in the General
Fund remains at thirty percent (30%) of annual General Fund expenditures, and, as stated in prior
meetings, total cash is two million dollars ($2,000,000) ahead of FY15 due to the Beach
Preservation Fee Fund and the tourism funds. Overall expenditures are at eighty -one percent
(81%) of budget through April 2016. The Mayor noted that, in General Government, additional
expense was incurred in the month by paying the accrued interest on the retiring loan when the
City closed on the r e-financing of the bond for Fire Station 2. Although Municipal
Accommodations fee collections were slightly less than the same month in FY15, collections year-
to-date exceed FY15 by five percent (5%). The third quarter’s State Accommodations Tax was
greater than any year since 2010 and is three point two percent (3.2%) greater than FY15 year -
to-date. Hospitality Tax collections were strong for April; collections are running six percent (6%)
greater that FY15 year -to-date. Approximately five hundred nine ty thousand dollars ($590,000)
has been collected year-to-date in Beach Preservation Fee funds.
Revenue from the municipal parking lots was approximately thirty -three thousand dollars
($33,000) through May 16th; total revenue to-date from the parking lot kiosks is fifty-one thousand
City Council
May 24, 2016
Page 3 of 14
one hundred seventy-one dollars ($51,171); by the end of May, the City will have paid for its initial
investment.
In anticipation of Second Reading on the FY17 budget later in this meeting, some of the changes
approved by the Ways and Means Committee were as follows:
Adding back the two (2) police officers and the payroll/human resource person;
Per a notice from PEBA, increasing the retirement by 0.5%;
Increasing parking revenue by $129,000 based on kiosks going to $1.50 on Front Beach;
Adding in the 25% local share of the 2 FEMA projects proposed by the County;
Adding $10,000 to Fire Department Vehicle Maintenance;
Adding 2 surveillance cameras for the municipal parking lots; and
Adding in the salary for taking the Treasurer from three quarters time to full time.
The Committee had an extended discussion of potential, additional parking for marina employees
at the property owned by the IOP Water and Sewer Commission on Waterway Boulevard; at this
time, discussions are continuing.
After an Executive Session where members heard from the Chairman of County Council, the
Committee unanimously approved a motion “to continue the dialogue with PRC (Parks and
Recreation Commission of Charleston County) along the lines of their establishing a lease with
the City for the property for the purposes of building a new restroom facility and, if possible, any
other extension thereto of the use of the facilit y that PRC may wish to entertain .” The Mayor
reminded the Committee that one hundred eight or one hundred nine thousand dollars ($108,000-
109,000) has been included in the FY17 budget for the design and engineering of new public
restrooms. The total cost of new restrooms would be two thirds (⅔) funded by the PRC and one-
third (⅓) by the City.
1. Approval of up to $15,000 to the contract with ATM for additional
meetings and marina concepts
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to approve up to $15,000 to ATM for additional
meetings and marina concepts; Councilmember Bergwerf seconded.
The Mayor stated that this action would give the City more flexibility to work with the tenan ts,
looking at access for golf carts , walking paths as well as vehicular/boat traffic mo ving on and off
the site.
Councilmember Carroll commented that this would be the fourth study.
Councilmember Bergwerf explained that this money would not be used for any additional study;
ATM had completed their contract, therefore, without more money, t he City could not ask any
more questions of them. She said that ATM may have to do another rendering, but there would
be no additional study.
Councilmember Ward asked how much money the City had spent to get Concepts A and B.
City Council
May 24, 2016
Page 4 of 14
Administrator Tucker rec alled that the original ATM proposal was about one hundred sixty -five
thousand dollars ($165,000), but the scope of work was reduced cutting the cost to approximately
ninety-three thousand dollars ($93,000); Concepts A and B were included as part of that contract.
The Planning Commission iteration was funded with an additional five thousand dollars ($5,000).
The marina tenants commented on that version at the last Real Property Committee meeting and
pointed out some serious safety concerns related to it; the recommendation was made to continue
a relationship with ATM to get marina tenants’ input on the Planning Commission’s version.
Councilmember Rice stated that the Real Property Committee was trying to get it right – all of the
puzzle pieces must fit together perfectly. She stated that nothing malicious was happening ; the
Real Property Committee wants to get the plan right so that it works for everyone.
VOTE: The motion PASSED on a vote of 6 to 2 with Councilmembers Ferencz and
Carroll casting dissenting votes.
2. Approval to increase fees at the marina to $20 per day to launch and
$10 per day to park for off-island guests on Friday through Sunday between
May 15 and September 15
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to increase launch and parking fees at the
marina as detailed above; Councilmember Carroll seconded.
Councilmember Ferencz asked where the additional revenue would go; the Mayor answered that
it would go to the marina manager, and, by contract, a portion would come to the City.
According to Councilmember Bergwerf, the goal of the increased fees was to reduce the number
of off-island cars, trailers and boats at the marina. She did not think that the Mar ina Manager
would see a windfall profit from the increase, but keep the revenue stream as it has been.
Since the launch fee includes the parking fee, Councilme mber Ferencz asked why there were
vehicles with trailers parked on 41st Avenue and on Waterway Boulevard and not at the marina.
Councilmember Bergwerf stated the picture Councilmember Ferencz painted was the crux of the
problem, i.e. trying to establish a plan that keeps all of the business es at the marina within the
marina parking lot.
Councilmember Carroll asked why, when the pre-determined launch/parking toggle was reached,
selling of launch tickets continues.
The Mayor reiterated that people with season passes must be allowed to launch no matter what
time of day they arrive or how many hav e gone before ; the Mayor indicated that he wants to
discuss the issue of annual passes with the marina manager. In the Mayor’s opinion, the
elimination of the annual passes would allow for better controls.
Councilmember Bettelli commented that people were coming and going from the marina all during
the day, and the Mayor recognized the island residents who launch their boat and take th eir
vehicle and trailer home to return to the marina by bike or golf cart.
City Council
May 24, 2016
Page 5 of 14
Councilmember Ferencz countered that, if si gnage for “Resident Only Parking” were placed on
41st Avenue and Waterway Boulevard, boaters w ould have to park at the marina; currently the
City has no means of forcing them to park at the marina.
Mayor Cronin commented that these boaters would find a place to park somewhere.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Award of a contract to Ledford’s Termite and Pest Control in the
amount of $12,900 to protect all City buildings, except Public W orks, from
Formosan termites
MOTION: Councilmember Bettelli moved to award a contract to Ledford’s
Termite and Pest Control in the amount of $12,900 to protect City building from For-
mosan termites; C ouncilmember Carroll seconded and the motion PASSED
UNANIMOUSLY.
4. Approval of a Change Order to Thomas and Hutton agreement in an
amount up to $10,500 to allow for bid and construction oversight
MOTION: Councilmember Ward moved to approve a Thomas and Hutton
Change Order in an amount up to $10,500 for bid assistance and construction over-
sight; Councilmember Bergwerf seconded.
Councilmember Ward asked how much was budgeted for the NPDES improvements at the Public
Works site, and Treasur er Suggs responded that it was t hree hundred fourteen thousand five
hundred thirty dollars ($314,530).
The Administrator added that this project had not yet been bid; therefore, the budget numbers
were based on estimate s, but the Administrator has been told that bids currently are coming in
high.
Councilmember Ward asked whether the replacement of the underground fuel tanks was
included, and he was told they we re not and have a cost of two hundred forty -six thousand six
hundred seventy -five dollars ($246,675). Another cost for the Public Works site was the
replacement of the fuel pump canopy at twenty thousand dollars ($20,000). The Councilmember
remarked that a couple of years ago he suggested relocating Public Works off-island; he was told
it would cost in excess of one million dollars ($1,000,000) and the subject was dropped. This year
the costs of the improvements to the site are budgeted at approximately six hundred thousand
dollars ($600,000); he stated that he will be interested in seeing the final costs.
Councilmember Bettelli recalled that the million dollars ($1,000,000) quoted at the time was
primarily for land acquisition.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
City Council
May 24, 2016
Page 6 of 14
The last piece of business was a brief discussion of the 2016 fi reworks, a nd the Committee
unanimously approved additional funds for food and incidentals associated with the event. The
Mayor added that it will be a stressful event since high tide is at about 8:30 p.m. that night; and
the fireworks are scheduled to go off at 9:00 p.m. or 9:15 p.m.
B. Public Safety Committee
Reporting on the meeting of May 3rd, Councilmember Bettelli stated that Ida Havelka spoke to the
Committee on the dangers some enc roachments in the rights -of-way create and voiced her
support for having all encroachments removed from the rights -of-way. When Chief Buckhannon
tried to get a listing of the encroachments approved by SCDOT, he was told that the City would
have to pay bet ween twenty and twenty -two dollars ($20-22) per hour for someone to research
the SCDOT records and that it could take days to weeks to complete the work. Chair Bettelli
asked if it would be simpler to give SCDOT a list of the most egregious encroachments for them
to identify if they were permitted. Administrator Tucker said that she found it hard to believe that
SCDOT would permit any encroachment that would prevent someone from safely pulling off the
road to allow an emergency vehicle to pass; the permitted encroachments would be for low level
vegetation or driveways. The discussion on encroachments will continue in future meetings, but
the Committee was anxious to get input from the full Council.
Mayor Cronin noted that this subject has been discu ssed many times in recent years and has
resulted in no progress toward resolving the problem. The City has been more successful in
preventing new encroachments from going in or in assisting the residents with the encroachment
application form from SCDOT. At one time, Council looked at tackling the issue by zones or
areas, but that would have had residents asking “why us and not them?”
Councilmember Bergwerf noted that she wa s on record for saying many times that she did not
want to tell her neighbors that they must remove their encroachments in the right-of-way to provide
additional parking for day-trippers. Watching the firemen responding to the Citadel Beach House
fire and seeing how much area was needed to deploy all of their resources, she realized that
these encroachments are not a parking issue, but a public safety issue. But she still did not have
a way to solve the problem.
Attorney Halversen confirmed the Mayor’s comments that this was an all or nothing problem.
Since the problem has been around for years, Councilmember Ward asked why it was coming up
now? The City’s plate is full adapting to the new parking plan.
Councilmember Bettelli said that the discussion has come up again for discussion to re-enforce
the issue as a public safety problem.
Responding to Council Ferencz, Administrator Tucker noted that Stantec had done an inventory
of encroachments in the rights-of-way in a low, medium and high priority based on the degree of
difficulty in removing them.
The Administrator opined that part of the problem was a public information problem; she believes
that some citizens do not realize that the right-of-way is not part of their yard, and it is not their
City Council
May 24, 2016
Page 7 of 14
yard to the point that they can landscape it to the point that one could not drive over it. Any kind
of amenity to be placed i n the SCDOT right-of-way, areas beyond the property line, requires an
encroachment permit from SCDOT, and they are very specific about what they allow and will not
allow. The Administrator thought a good idea would be to get the word out because some
residents might comply voluntarily.
With the parking plan limiting parking anywhere except Palm Boulevard and Front Beach,
Councilmember Carroll suggested that, if the Council were so inclined, the removal of encroach-
ments should start on those streets.
Mayor Cronin said that the residents along Palm Boulevard might disagree and claim – in court –
that they are being singled out.
Councilmember Ferencz added that the parking areas are part of a program.
The Mayor called the encroachments issue a Gordian knot, and Councilmember Ferencz stated
that the City cannot continue to ignore the problem.
Councilmember Rice reported seeing a new encroachment on 42 nd Avenue which blocks the
emergency beach access; she said that she had reported it to the Police Department. She said
that It looks like someone has put logs along the road to obstruct access to their new grass. She
thought that those property owners needed to be educated that this is a critical emergency beach
access for the safety of beach-goers.
Councilmember Bettelli commented that the Public Safety Committee reviewed the FY17 budget
and increased the vehicle maintenance for the Fire Department and added back t o two (2)
additional police officers. Chief Buckhannon reported that the City has set out a new coyote trap
in a spot identified by the IOP Water and Sewer Commission close to another hot zone in the
Forest Trail area; an animal was in the trap, but manag ed to escape. Reports of sightings are
diminishing, but some calls are still coming in. He reported that there has been illegal dumping
of yard debris on the 6th Avenue Beach access; it appears to have stopped temporarily, or maybe
permanently.
On April 16th, officers reported to a vehicle on fire in the municipal parking lot on Pavilion Drive;
upon arrival, the crew found a fire in the storage compartment of the commercial shredder
employed for the Hazardous Materials/Shred Day. Wild Dunes reported the sighting of a six-foot
(6 ft.) alligator washed up in the surf; the crew notified DNR, but the alligator later swam back into
the ocean. On April 30 th, personnel launched the jet -ski to investigate something in the water
behind 2800 Palm Boulevard; the object turned out to be a dead leatherback turtle that had been
hit by a boat. During the month, personnel responded to sixty-six (66) calls, and, of that number,
twenty-nine (29) were EMS calls. The Chief noted that having the QRV on the island was reducing
response times. Ten (10) pre -incident surveys were done in April. Chief Graham reported that
she is very close to hiring a new Fire Inspector. Medical in-service training consisted of a quarterly
skills review on the treatment of shock and cardiovascular emergencies. The Disaster Expo was
held on Wednesday, May 18th, and attendance was less than expected.
City Council
May 24, 2016
Page 8 of 14
Chief Buckhannon reported that seven (7) BSOs have been hired and one (1) officer has been
hired who will be going to the academy as soon as a space is available. The parking lots are up,
the signs are in place and the kiosks are operational; he added that people do not understand
why the kiosks on Front Beach are hourly while the kiosks in the parking lots are daily. The Chief
replied that two or three (2 -3) personnel are in the lots during the busiest part of the day, 10:00
a.m. til 3:00 p.m. on weekends and are being paid at their overtime rates. Administrator Tucker
added that staff believes that personnel will only be needed in this inaugural year of the kiosks in
the parking lots and the parking management program. Chief Buckhannon said that the City may
need to add one or two (1 -2) additional kiosks to make them more visible to visitors. On the
Livability front, there were seven (7) noise complaints for which two (2) received citations; one (1)
warning was given to the owner of a barking dog, and one (1) coyote sighting was reported. Island
residents with residential parking stickers can park in the lot at no cost from 6:00 to 8:00 p.m.
The Public Safety Committee will meet on Tuesday, June 14th in the Conference Room.
Before moving on, Mayor Cronin thanked the Fire Department for their response to the Citadel
Beach House fire; thankfully, the tenants that were there managed to get out safely on their own.
What the Mayor saw firsthand was that firefighters knew their role; the training they get kick ed
into gear when confronted with a fire.
Councilmember Bettelli noted that the City had bought some additional equipment last year and
it was put to use in this fire.
The Mayor also thanked the Police Department for their efforts at the first turtle release of the
year; it has been said that between fifteen hundred and two thousand (1,500-2,000) people were
on the beach for the release.
Referring to the QRV that is now on the island, Councilmember Carroll commented that
Charleston County was doing a lot to help the residents of the Isle of Palms with the addition of
traffic cameras on the Mount Pleasant side of the Connector, assistance with the Front Beach
restrooms and the presence of the QRV all the time beginning later in the summer. He expressed
his thanks to Charleston County for it all.
Mayor Cronin stated that, when the City asks, they tend to eventually respond; it may take some
time or some back room maneuvering, but he was pleased with their responsiveness. The Mayor
said that it had only been about eighteen (18) months ago that the City had asked for a QRV
presence on the island, and they just did it.
Councilmember Ward asked if there would be discussi on at this meeting about the problem Mr.
Petro brought to Council.
The Mayor answered that his suggestions would g o before the Public Safety Committee at their
June meeting.
C. Public Works Committee
City Council
May 24, 2016
Page 9 of 14
At the meeting of May 4 th, Director Pitts reported that landscaping/road maintenance picked up,
and Charleston County stormwater crews were on the island cleaning several ditch systems
primarily in the 21 st to 41 st Avenue area and the storm inlet at 57 th Avenue c rossover. The
Hazardous Waste and Shred Day was held Saturday, April 16 th in cooperation with Charleston
County; one hundred seventy-six (176) cars delivered hazardous materials.
Yard debris was down considerably for the same month last year, but the delivery on Friday, April
29th was not included in the Director’s number. Garbage was down in April from the same month
last year.
Vehicle maintenance was quite high because several trucks needed preventative maintenance;
the Director still intends to end the year under or at budget.
As at other meetings, Administrator Tucker reviewed the changes that would be included in the
next version of the budget.
Considerable discussion with Frank Carson and Chris Wannamaker from Charleston County
Public Works was held relative to the two (2) FEMA projects Charleston County is proposing for
the City under the Public Assistance program; they were present to describe the projects and to
get a preliminary commitment from the City to pay the twenty -five percent (25%) l ocal share.
Good news was shared with the Committee about the golf cart path between 20th Avenue and the
Island Center, i.e. the City has received the SCDOT encroachment permit; the project has gone
out for bid and bids will be opened on June 1 st at 10:00 a.m. The Committee briefly discussed
the status of Phase II Drainage and unanimously approved the change order for Thomas and
Hutton that was approved earlier.
The next Public Works Committee meeting will be at 4:30 p.m., Thursday, June 2, 2016 in the
Conference Room.
D. Recreation Committee
Reporting on the meeting of May 4, Councilmember Carroll stated that children’s classes will be
wrapping up for the su mmer, but the fitness classes will continue through the summer. The
Keenagers had forty-five (45) seniors at their last meeting; this will be their last meeting before
the summer break today. The Middle School Dance on April 8 th drew eighty -five (85) young
people. Camp Summershine is completely full and begins the first week of June; there will also
be athletic camps over the summer. The Director said that the annual Yard Sale was another big
success with fifty (50) booths; she reported that the assistance they received from the Police
Department was “awesome.” The Committee also briefly discussed adding booths to the yard
sale and possibly having another one in the fall. Music in the Park was a huge success with
approximately four hundred (400) people attending. Prior to the Music in the Park event, the City
unveiled the marker for the Mayor Carmen R. Bunch Park, and the Bunch family was very
appreciative. Because of her past experience, Director Page is the substitute race chair for the
2016 Connector Run. The Director said that the major complaint in the parking lots has been that
people cannot see the kiosks, so flags are going to be put up, like the ones on a golf course, on
the top of the kiosks to help visitors locate them. The Committee also discussed increasing the
fees for Camp Summershine, keeping in mind families with multiple children attending camp.
City Council
May 24, 2016
Page 10 of 14
When the Committee reviewed the FY17 budget, the Recreation Department’s budget only
increased by three perce nt (3%), and that increase came from items beyond the Committee’s
control. The respondents to the survey about Recreation facilities and programs have come
primarily from residents who are over sixty (60) years of age.
The next meeting will be August 2, 2016 in the Conference Room.
Councilmember Carroll reminded Council that the annual Sand Sculpting Contest will begin at
9:00 a.m., Saturday, June 4, 2016 at Front Beach.
Mayor Cronin noted that Music in the Park was so well attended yet the Disaster Expo drew only
a few in comparison; he questioned what the City could do to draw people to the Disaster Expo
at a time when so man y residents on the island have never experienced a hurricane or an
evacuation.
E. Personnel Committee
From the meeting of May 5th, Councilmember Harrington reported that, like other committees, the
Personnel Committee reviewed the FY17 budget and discussed the need for someone in the
payroll/human resources position. Administrator Tucker explained how eligible employees
accrue and use compensatory time. The Committee also discussed changing the way candidates
file for elected office from petitions to a filing fee; comments made to support the change were
that candid ates are not allowed to go door -to-door in Wild Dunes and that the time to gather
signatures is the hottest part of the summer. Clerk Copeland stated that she had attended a
meeting at the Charleston County Election Commission with clerks from other munic ipalities
holding elections on the s ame day in 2015 and learned that all of the local governments
represented use a candidate filing fee and not petitions. T he Committee unanimously moved to
recommend to Council to replace the petitions for elected office with filing fees.
Mayor Cronin recalled that Council has discussed going to a filing fee in the past, and past
Councilmember Buckhannon has re-introduced the idea since the City is not in an election year.
Councilmember Bettelli stated that he knew of one (1) person who was planning to run for office
in the last election, but became ill and was unable to collect signatures; another person who ran
for the IOP Water and Sewer Commission was fortunate to get his petitions signed when another
candidate carried his with hers. He said that he thought the change to filing fees would encourage
more people to run for elected office.
Mayor Cronin then asked what the fee was to be; he noted that one hundred fifty dollars ($150)
was discussed by the Personnel Committee and questioned whether it was enough or too much.
Councilmember Ward suggested that staff should find out what the fining fees are for other local
governments in the area.
Attorney Halversen indicated that she had researched other municipalities and found that the filing
fees covered a broad range and that she had chosen a middle -ground for the ordinance. She
added that the fee could be whatever Council decided was fair.
City Council
May 24, 2016
Page 11 of 14
The Mayor said that he liked th e idea of the filing fee, but he thought it should be substantial
enough that it was not a frivolous action, but, at the same time, not a burden to a potential
candidate.
Expressing his opinion, Councilmember Ward said that he would support a higher fee for Council
and higher yet for mayor.
Mayor Cronin suggested that Council take no action on the issue at this meeting but consider
what the fees should be for discussion next month.
Councilmember Carroll thought the past two (2) elections were sad i n that the number of
candidates equaled the number of offices to be filled so that no election was needed. He added
that he enjoyed going door -to-door talking to the residents and hearing what kind of issues they
were unhappy about, but he acknowledged that a filing fee would not prevent a candidate from
interacting with the residents in whatever way he/she saw fit.
Councilmember Rice stated that it was bad that the gathering of signatures for petitions fell in
August when t he temperatures hover around one hundred degrees (100º) and many residents
are out of town.
The Mayor indicated that the consensus of Council was to proceed with this change as long as
the fee was properly structured.
The decision was to proceed with First Reading at this meeting wi thout specifying the filing fees
and to direct the Personnel Committee to come back to Council with fee recommendations.
Safety Sweepstakes winners for April were Battalion Chief Hathaway from the Fire Department,
Detective Diane Tarr from the Police Department, Aaron Sweet from the Recreation Department
and Willie Powell from the Public Works Department.
The only vacancy in the City is for one (1) additional BSO; all other Departments are fully staffed.
Pursuant to Councilmember Kinghorn’s recommendation to reduce the number of meeting s, the
Personnel Committee will hold its next meeting at 11:00 a.m., Wednesday, September 7 th in the
Conference Room. Councilmember Harrington suggested that other Committees consider taking
similar action.
He announced that he had been notified by the Surf Rider Foundation that they plan to do a beach
sweep from 9:00 a.m. to 10:30 a.m., Saturday, May 28 th beginning at the pier. Councilmember
Bergwerf indicated that the Turtle Team had also been notified of the sweep.
Mayor Cronin asked Assistant Fragoso to add this information to the City’s website.
F. Real Property Committee
Reporting from the meeting of May 5th, Councilmember Bergwerf related that the marina tenants
were asked to comment on the marina concept unveiled at the marina workshop; the Committee
City Council
May 24, 2016
Page 12 of 14
learned that the marina tenants had no input into this concept and all had comments to make .
The Committee plans to meet with Kirby Marshall of ATM, Scott Parker of DesignWorks and the
marina tenants at the next meeting to review the plan in detail and make suggestions for changes
to be made for another version of the redevelopment plan. The City is discussing with the IOP
Water and Sewer Commission a temporary solution to the overflow parking issues at the marina;
potentially, property owned by the Water and Sewer Commission on Waterway Boulevard could
be used for parking for marina employees, which could open thirty to fifty (30-50) parking spaces
at the marina.
As part of Old Business, the Committee discussed the problem with the bulkhead at the marina;
until an engineering assessment is done, the City will not know the nature of the problem, how
severe it is or have recommendation(s) for corrective ac tion. The Administrator said that her
primary concern was the weight of the structures that are on the area between the new bulkhead
and the old one; she commented that, when the new bulkhead was installed, it was built water -
ward of the old wooden bulkhe ad leaving a space between. The City’s goal is to advertise an
RFP for the engineering assessment in the next two (2) weeks and to allow three (3) weeks for
responses.
Parking and solutions were discussed again and will be an ongoing challenge during t he
discussions on the marina redevelopment. To move forward, the Committee unanimously voted
to seek additional funds to allow the City to continue to work with ATM to tweak the most recent
version of the marina redevelopment through both meetings and additional visual concepts.
Marina Manager Berrigan suggesting increasing the launch fees to twenty dollars ($20) and
parking fees to $10 for off-island guest at the marina from May 15th to September 15th on Fridays,
Saturdays and Sundays; resident fees would remain the same.
The Committee reviewed the changes appearing in the next version of the FY17 budget.
The Real Property Committee will hold its next meeting at 9:00 a.m., Thursday, June 2, 2016 in
the Conference Room.
Councilmember Carroll asked if the City could run a shuttle for marina employees between the
municipal parking lot and the marina, rather than augmenting security at the Water and Sewer
Commission’s property.
Councilmember Bergwerf indicated that the employees or their employers would pay a fee for
parking at the Water and Sewer Commission’s property to defer the City’s investment in the
security of the site.
With Memorial Day the next weekend, Councilmember Ward said that he had been approached
by a couple of the Front Beach businesses who were concerned about the volume of public
parking in the small lot where they have purchased seasonal parking passes for their employees.
Administrator Tucker responded th at the small municipal lot would be reserved for Front Beach
employees on busy weekends like Memorial Day.
City Council
May 24, 2016
Page 13 of 14
6. Reports from City Officers, Boards and Commissions
A. Accommodations Tax Advisory Committee – minutes attached
B. Board of Zoning Appeals – minutes attached
C. Planning Commission – minutes attached
7. Reports from Special of Joint Committees – none
8. Petitions Received, Referred or Disposed of – none
9. Bills Already in Possession of Council
Second Reading of Ordinance 2016-05 – An Ordinance to Raise Revenue and Adopt
a Budget for the City of Isle of Palms, South Carolina , for the fiscal year Beginning
July 1, 2016 and Ending June 30, 2017.
AMENDMENT: Mayor Cronin moved to amend Ordinance 2016-05 as presented at
First Reading to reflect the changes in the newest version of the FY17 budget dated
May 19, 2016; Councilmember Bettelli seconded and the amendment PASSED on a
vote of 5 to 3 with Councilmember Carroll, Ferencz and Ward dissenting.
AMENDED MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to adopt Ordinance 2016 -05 as
amended for Second Reading and to suspend the reading; Councilmember
Bergwerf seconded and the motion PASSED on a vote of 6 to 2 with
Councilmembers Ferencz and Ward dissenting.
Mayor Cronin stated that the amount of money in the FY17 budget assigned to stormwater
improvements is close to ha lf a million dollars ($500,000) to improve the flow of stormwater in
addition to the one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000) that goes annually to Eadie’s to maintain
the island’s ditches. In addition, the undergro und fuel storage tanks must be changed out this
year under EPA requirements. The Mayor reported that, for the critical funds of the City, the
composite year-end total is projected to be in excess of thirteen million dollars ($13,000,000), up
from ten million ($10,000,000) in FY12.
10. Introduction of New Bills, Resolutions and Proclamations
A. First Reading, by title only, of Ordinance 2016-06 – An Ordinance Amending
Title 3, Public Wor ks, Chapter 3, Stormwater Regulations, Article B, Stormwater
Management Utility Fee, Providing for the Classification of Real Property Subject to
Such Fees, Establishing the Amount of Stormwater Management Utility Fees, and
Providing for the Use of Such Fe es by the Stormwater Management Utility of the
City of Isle of Palms.
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to approve Ordinance 2016 -06, by title only, for
First Reading; Councilmember Bettelli seconded
City Council
May 24, 2016
Page 14 of 14
Mayor Cronin commented that, by the passage of this ordinance, the City will go to a stormwater
fee of forty -eight dollars ($48) annually, giving the City time to determine if it will stay with
Charleston County as Utility Manager or go with Mount Pleasant or do on its own.
Councilmember Bettelli thanked those who had lobbied County Council on the C ity’s behalf to
prevent the fee from doubling to seventy-two dollars ($72) annually.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
B. First Reading, by title only, of Ordinance 2016-07 – An Ordinance Amending
Title 1, Government and Administration, Chapter 8, Elections, Section 1 -8-3,
Nonpartisan Elections; Procedure, of the City of Isle of Palms Code of Ordinances
to Change the Procedure for Nominations from Filing of Nominatio n Petitions to
Filing of Statement of Candidacy and Filing Fee.
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to approve Ordinance 2016 -07, by title only, for
First Reading; Councilmember Ward seconded and the motion PASSED
UNANIMOUSLY.
C. A Resolution Authorizing an Appli cation to FEMA Hazard Mitigation Grant
Funds to Elevate the Public Restrooms at Front Beach
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to approve the resolution and to suspend the
reading; Councilmember Ward seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
11. Miscellaneous Business
Affirmation of CTC 2017 Requests
The City’s prioritized 2017 CTC projects are due in a short timeframe that does not allow for the
usual process of establishing the list through the Public Safety Committee and the Public Works
Committee. Projects submitted in recent years have been (1) additional funding for Phase II
Drainage and (2) bike paths for the full length of Palm Boulevard on both sides; staff is requesting
a vote affirming that City Council desires to proceed with these projects as prioritized.
MOTION: Councilmember Ward moved to repeat the most recent CTC projects
requests of additional funding for Phase II Drainage and bike paths on both sides
of the road for the entire length of Palm Boulevard; Mayor Cronin seconded and the
motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
12. Executive Session – not needed
13. Adjournment
MOTION: Councilmember Bettelli moved to adjourn the meeting at 7:33 p.m. ;
Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.