May 4, 2016 (PDF, 332.85 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of May 4, 2016 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
PERSONNEL COMMITTEE
11:00 a.m., Wednesday, May 4, 2016
The regular meeting of the Personnel Committee was held at 11:00 a.m., Wednesday, May 4,
2016 in the City Hall Conference Room, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South Carolina.
Attending the meeting were Councilmembers Bettelli and Ferencz, Chair Harri ngton,
Administrator Tucker, Assistant Administrator Fragoso and City Clerk Copeland; a quorum was
present to conduct business.
1. Chair Harrington called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public
had been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Ferencz moved to approve the minutes of the regular
meeting of April 6, 2016 as submitted; Councilmember Bettelli seconded and the
motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments – None
4. Old Business
A. Review of FY17 Budgets
Administrator Tucker stated that she would be happy to answer any questions of concerns anyone
had relative to any of the budgets, and that Draft 2 of the budget included the changes made to it
at the workshop. It is also the budget on which the newspaper ad was based which announced
the Public Hearing for the budget at 5:45 p.m., Tuesday, May 24 th. Staff is proposing several
changes to the budget for the Public Hearing and Second Reading; the changes will not affect
the millage rate or a need for new fees.
Councilmember Ferencz commented that, at the workshop, Council had removed in excess of
two hundred eighty-eight thousand dollars ($288,000) from the budget, but in looking at Draft 2,
the money was not removed from the budget but added to the project ed positive net result to be
added to the Capital Projects Fund at year’s end. Therefore, the budget was not reduced, and
she noted that it was done without the consent of Council.
The Administrator agreed and commented that, in doing so, it was consistent with past years. In
addition, where the positive net result goes falls completely under the purview of City Council.
Councilmember Bettelli stated that, “based on the revenue is coming in, it cannot just hang out in
space somewhere.”
Councilmember Ferencz opined that there were other options available that Council did not
discuss.
Councilmember Bettelli agreed, but said that the place for the discussion was Ways and Means;
in the meantime, it is merely a placeholder. The money was removed from operating expenses
as requested, and the money is still there.
Personnel Committee
May 4, 2016
Page 2 of 9
The Administrator agreed that staff did not clarify with Council at the time the positions were
removed from the budget that, based on prior Council action, staff recommended that the money
should go into the Capital Projects Fund. The Administrator repeated that the only source of
funds for Capital Projects is the positive net result left in the General Fund at year’s end. By
cutting the positions, the positive net result was increased to the point that the money needed to
go somewhere or to cut things. The problem with cutting things would be that staff would have to
make a judgment call on what services to reduce or not do. The Administrator also agreed that
staff had not asked for nor received t hat direction; however, she reiterated that it was consistent
with practice and it seemed to be the prudent thing to do. Administrator Tucker continued that
the fund that is at the greatest risk now and that most needs the cash -in is the Capital Projects
Fund.
Treasurer Suggs explained that if expense is removed but revenue stayed the same, the
additional revenue would become a part of the positive net result ; Council could reduce revenue
by reducing the parking fees, as one (1) example.
Councilmember Ferencz asked whether the millage could be reduced since it had been increased
last year.
Treasurer Suggs recalled that last year had been a reassessment year, because of the
collectability factor, the City was not made whole, and Council voted to take the allowable CPI
which closed the gap to flat a little more. Using the County’s projections, the City will still come
in less because of the rollback millage the City had at the end of last year.
The Administrator stated that there would be risk in taking an action to reduce the millage,
because the City might not meet budget.
Councilmember Ferencz asked why Council went through the budgeting process each year if
Council’s reduction in expenses only means putting more money into the Capital Projects Fund.
She remarked that, as soon as staff is confident in what the revenue will be and what the expenses
will be when the bottom line is going to stay the same.
The Treasurer commented that the new police officers were included in Draft 1 of the budget but
are not in Draft 2 and that the Police Department budget is lower in Draft 2.
Administrator Tucker concluded that the lesson here is that the staff should clarify, when items
are removed from the budget and staff is faced with a situation like t his, what they think is the
prudent thing to do.
Councilmember Ferencz asked whether staff thought that the City has a million dollars
($1,000,000) in Capital Projects that need to come out of that fund on top of a million dollars
($1,000,000) being taken from others so that the Capital Projects budget is in excess of two million
dollars ($2,000,000) for one year.
The Administrator noted that there is a difference between having the money in that fund and
spending it.
Personnel Committee
May 4, 2016
Page 3 of 9
The changes proposed for the next version of the budget include the following:
An increase of $129,000 in parking meter revenue based on the increase of the hourly
rate to $1.50.
Considering the possibility of either assuming responsibility of handling the City’s own
NPDES program or asking Mount Pleasant to do it, the City must have a third party
assessment by an engineering firm to determine the state of the City’s drainage system;
staff has estimated an additional $30,000 in expense.
The NPDES improvements for the Public Works site have become much more complex
since originally conceived; therefore, staff recommends approving a change order of
$10,500 to have bid assistance and construction oversight by Thomas and Hutton.
Since the buildings and grounds person was eliminated from the budget, an idea gained
from Mount Pleasant was to hire a construction company to assess the City’s facilities and
to generate a list of future maintenance issues for the City to address. The amount to be
added to the budget is $12,000, average $2,000 per building.
Based on conversations with the County, staff recommends adding back to the FY17
budget the cost of engineering and design for the public restrooms.
The County has approached the City about two (2) Joaquin-related FEMA projects that
would require the City to commit to paying the 25% match; one (1) is a cleanout and
assessment of all of the City’s drainage pipes costing the City $159,000; the second is the
replacement of the pipes crossing Ocean Boulevard between 4th Avenue and Breach Inlet
for 25 % of $58,000 per crossing with 8 crossings. The County’s representatives for these
programs will attend the Public Works meeting to explain the projects and to provide the
costs.
The Public Safety Committee vot ed to add back to the budget two (2) additional police
officers.
Based on experience this year, the vehicle maintenance for the Fi re Department will be
increased by $10,000.
Four (4) additional surveillance cameras will be added to the budget, the cameras wi ll be
deployed at the municipal lots, at the compactor (may be done in FY16) and at the IOP
Water and Sewer Commission’s property on Waterway that is being considered for marina
employee parking. A camera, installation and technical aspects cost about $1,700 each.
Staff is also proposing a city -wide termite bond that will include coverage for Formosan
termites.
Chair Harrington indicated that he wanted to talk about the human resources position; he recalled
having asked the Administrator what she needed to run the City.
Following the Committee’s directive, Treasurer Suggs has received a quote from ADP for
performing the payroll function for the City, but the quote is based on eighty -eight (88) full-time
positons and does not take into account the many par t-time employees of the City. For
information, the Treasurer reported that the City produced one hundred fifty (150) W-2s for 2015.
The Treasurer took the ADP quote and extrapolated numbers to compute more realistic numbers
based on a more accurate head-count and came to a Year 1 cost of seventeen thousand dollars
($17,000).
Personnel Committee
May 4, 2016
Page 4 of 9
Treasurer Suggs commented that she had asked for a bare bones quote and that she was unsure
about the need or desire for the additional modules although a time and attendance software is a
goal with the new financial software. Without knowledge of how robust the ADP time and
attendance module was, the treasurer was unsure whether it could take the place of the module
in any financial software the City decides upon.
From a conversation with her counterpart at Sullivan’s Island, Treasurer Suggs learned that they
had tried ADP, but their payroll person found that she was doing as much work and time preparing
the data to go to ADP for t hem to process the payroll. On the back end, the information had to
be manually keyed into the General Ledger because there was no interface. They determined
that the service was not worth what they were paying ADP and brought payroll back in-house.
Looking at the other side of the City Clerk’s position, the transcribing of minutes, Councilmember
Ferencz said that she thought staffing agencies would have professional transcriptionists who are
“lighting fast,” leaving the Clerk only to review what has been transcribed.
Administrator Tucker reported that she had only received one (1) set of information in the time
allotted, but she did want to point out the difference between transcription and minutes, i.e. trans-
cription is word for word while minutes are taking people’s words and describing the intent of what
happened.
A transcriptionist that Mount Pleasant uses for Planning Commission minutes said that she would
need the minutes, in addition to the recording, which does not solve the problem. Wh en she
works for Mount Pleasant, the Planning Commission members get the minutes and a copy of the
transcription. The prices she quoted were seven dollars ($7) per page of transcription; if she
attends the meeting, in addition to the seven dollars ($7) per page, she get thirty dollars ($30) for
the first hour and twenty-five dollars ($25) for each subsequent hour of the meeting. This person
reported that an hour of meeting produces about forty (40) pages when transcribed.
Minutes are something that cle rks are trained on – what is necessary to be included, translation
of motions, etc.; Clerk Copeland has had all of that training. Many City meetings last longer than
an hour and she does not generate forty (40) pages of minutes.
Councilmember Ferencz s tated that the position would add sixty -two thousand dollars in fixed
costs and twenty-four thousand dollars additional in the first year for a total in FY17 of eighty -six
thousand six hundred dollars ($86,600).
Administrator Tucker said that the human resources function is becoming more and more complex
as the state and federal government roll new programs and regulations; this person needs to be
well trained and knowledgeable of these rules.
When asked what would happen if the Clerk were hit by a truc k, Treasurer Suggs indicated that
she was the backup on payroll, and the Administrator said that she has had clerks from other
municipalities assist when the City Clerk has been unavailable. The Administrator said that she
would check with staffing agenci es to see if they had anyone qualified to do minutes for local
government.
Personnel Committee
May 4, 2016
Page 5 of 9
Despite wanting to give the City Clerk relief from her workload, Councilmember Ferencz said she
could not add sixty-two thousand dollars ($62,000) to fixed costs.
Councilmember Bettelli stated that he thought the Committee “was doing the residents a
disservice when (we) cannot afford them the type of government and the type of services that
they deserve.” He added that the City staff is an additional service to the residents.
Repeating Councilmember Kinghorn’s position, Councilmember Ferencz said she would rather
see how Council could affect efficiencies before hiring additional personnel by having fewer
meetings and other things to lighten the load. She opined that this position was not for the
residents but for City Council and the Committees.
Councilmember Bettelli countered that everything staff does is for the residents.
Administrator Tucker reported that the last time staff was added to General Government was in
2008 for the Assistant to the Administrator, now the Assistant Administrator.
Chair Harrington agreed that Council and Committees should look at ways to be more efficient;
he added that the Committee has to listen to the Administrator as she answers the question “What
do you need to run the City efficiently?” The Chair indicated that he would support this position
to have it debated in the Ways and Means Committee again. He opined that the reduction in
overtime might make this position more affordable.
The Administrator commented that the overtime would only be reduced if efficiencies were found;
the bulk of the Clerk’s overtime in spent on minutes.
Councilmember Ferencz asked how the tasks included in th e Clerk’s job description would be
accomplished if this position is not approved.
Administrator Tucker explained that was being done already; some members of the Building
Department have assisted with minutes for shorter and less involved Committees. O nce those
minutes are done, Clerk Copeland must review them against her notes to ensure that nothing of
import was overlooked. In addition, employees from other department have also helped out, for
example, someone who is on light duty who has some admini strative skills; this assistance is
usually on special projects because access to personnel files must be closely monitored.
Chair Harrington noted that Chief Graham is currently handling workers’ compensation.
Councilmember Ferencz suggested getting m ore assistance from other employees on an
overtime basis.
Chief Graham stated that workers’ compensation can become quite time consuming. Over the
years, it has become more than submitting a form to the state; the Chief has become a patient
advocate to get employees back to work, to find out why the worker’s compensation has been
delayed, to get disability if necessary or to assist other departments with Family Medical Leave
Act paperwork. The Chief strongly believes that this job should be handled by a human resources
person, who would ensure consistency and protect the City and the employee.
Personnel Committee
May 4, 2016
Page 6 of 9
According to the Administrator, any employee health records must be kept in separate files
following the HIPPA regulations.
MOTION: Councilmember Bettelli moved to include the costs associated with
the human resources position in the next version of the FY17 budget; Chair
Harrington seconded and the motion PASSED on a vote of 2 to 1 with
Councilmember Ferencz dissenting.
B. Discussion of outsourcing payroll, outsourcing transcription and calen -
daring fewer Personnel Committee meetings.
Since outsourcing has been discussed, Councilmember Bettelli suggested that the decision about
the need for a meeting the subsequent month be made at each meeting.
The next duty of the Personnel Committee will be the selection of candidates for boards and
commissions after the advertisement runs in August unless something unforeseen comes up.
Councilmember Ferencz stated that she had looked at the calendar and when the Committee
always has something to do, such as the election of Chair in January. She suggested looking at
the previous agendas to determine how many were necessary to be done at that time; she also
suggested meeting every other month except at budget-time. The Councilmember said that she
would prefer to look at the entire calendar to give time to plan; she wants all meetings to start no
later than 4:00 p.m. She wanted to urge the other Committees to take similar action. She asked
for staff assistance in reviewing a year’s agendas to recommend which months the Committee
would not meet, thereby eliminating three or four (3-4) meetings a year.
Chair Harrington also noted that some committees must meet every month.
C. Discussion of Compensatory Time
Chair Harrington opened the discussion commenting that, if by being more efficient, Council and
Committees could reduce the demand on employees, they would accrue fewer hours of overtime
and compensatory time.
Administrator Tucker distributed the City’s policy on comp time as well as the policy from
Charleston County; everyone she talked to reported that an employee cannot get any kind of
payout on compensatory time. Compensatory time is available to those employees exempt from
overtime to try to aid in giving some relief to the additional time for the job.
The Administrator confirmed that all exempt employees received compensatory time if they earn
it. The federal Wage and Hour Laws govern who is exempt from overtime.
Councilmember Ferencz thought there was a salary or a title level that would eliminate compen -
satory time, but that is not how the City operates. She asked if this was common among the
Administrator’s peers, and the Administrator said that it was and some have contracts that define
the terms of their employment.
Personnel Committee
May 4, 2016
Page 7 of 9
Administrator Tucker’s predecessor took every Friday off if he had earned sufficient comp time
during that week.
Employees of the City earn comp time at different levels based on the demands of their job and
take it for different uses, but it is used in lieu of vacation when so much compensatory time has
built up. The Administrator opined that it is not unusual in state and local government.
Councilmember Bettelli said that he had gotten comp time when he worked with Bell South.
Councilmember Ferencz stated that, if an employee accrues vacation, when that employee leaves
the position, he is paid for that accrued vacation time. If that same person earned comp time, he
would be more likely to take a day of comp time rather than eight (8) hours of vacation time. She
recalled having asked the Mayor about the Administrator’s comp time and it was over two hundred
(200) hours at the time.
The Administrator stated that she had earned twenty -nine (29) hours of comp time in April; she
added that, if she attends a City function voluntarily, she does not accrue comp time, but if she
goes because she has a duty or a concern about the event, she then accrues comp time. She
only earns comp time when she works nights or weekends to meet deadlines or attending
meetings after hours.
Councilmember Ferencz asked if comp time was budgeted, and Treasurer Suggs said that it was
not. Comp time does not have a financial impact on the City.
Councilmember Ferencz then inquired about how comp time was taken – was it a day at a time
or a week? The Administrator said it varies; Treasurer Suggs took her second maternity leave on
comp time. The general understanding is that comp time will be taken within thirty (30) days when
possible; Director Pitts has taken comp time to work at the fair; sometimes, Chief Graham will
take a day to spend out on the water. Of City employees, the ones who would earn the largest
number of hours would the Administrator, the Assistant Administrator, the City Treasurer and,
possibly, Chief Buckhannon, thus allowing them to take out chunks of time without having to take
vacation.
Treasurer Suggs stated that t he City does not budget for vacation because there is no financial
impact on a forty (40) hours a week person; in the calculation for shift people, some extra is added
to account the double time associated with filling the slot.
Chair Harrington indicated that he would work with the Administrator to determine which months
the Committee should meet, and he suggested not holding another meeting until August.
Councilmember Ferencz said that she would not be available in August.
Administrator Tucker recommended a meeting early in September when the Committee will begin
its deliberations over appointees to boards and commissions. The Committee agreed to hold its
next meeting at 11:00 a.m., Wednesday, September 7, 2016.
Personnel Committee
May 4, 2016
Page 8 of 9
Councilmember Ferencz asked if the Personnel Committee could make a recommendation to the
chairs of other committees to consider looking at the calendar to determine if there are months
when they would not need to meet.
Since the topic of fewer meetings was discussed at the last Ways and Means Committee meeting
the other members of the Committee did not think it was necessary, and Councilmember Bettelli
opined that the Personnel Committee should not be telling other committees what they shou ld
discuss.
Administrator Tucker suggested that the Chair include in his report at the Council meeting that, in
an effort to streamline meetings, the Personnel Committee will be re ducing the number of
meetings it holds and encourage other committees to follow suit.
5. New Business
Discussion of a Change in Election Petition Policy
The Administrator reported that this concept came up during an election time with the City once
before, and there was some advocacy that more people might decide to run for Mayor or Council
if they only had to pay a filing fee and did not have to go door -to-door to gather signatures for
petitions. Since it was election time when this subject was broached, it got very little traction.
Since the City is not in an election y ear, it was pointed out that this may be the time to discuss it
again.
Councilmember Ferencz suggested that someone who pays a one hundred fifty dollar ($150)
filing fee would be more likely to carry through the process where, in past years, people have
picked up petitions, giving the appearance of running, but never turned in the petitions. She
added that a candidate who wanted to get out and talk to the residents would do so.
Councilmember Bettelli recalled there have been times when a potential cand idate became ill or
was incapacitated in some way making getting signatures very difficult.
Clerk Copeland recalled a meeting she had attended with clerks from other municipalities and
had learned that the Isle of Palms was the only one (1) using petitions to file for candidacy.
Councilmember Bettelli noted that the time to gather signatures is a very hot time of year.
Councilmember Ferencz commented that one is not allowed to go door-to-door in Wild Dunes.
Councilmember Bettelli stated that a filing fee might encourage more diversity in participation.
MOTION: Councilmember Bettelli moved to recommend to Council that the City
replace Candidate Petitions with a filing fee; Councilmember Ferencz seconded.
When asked whether a filing fee might ac tually dissuade people from running, Administrator
Tucker opined that it would not.
Personnel Committee
May 4, 2016
Page 9 of 9
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
6. Miscellaneous Business
Next Meeting: 11:00 a.m., Wednesday, September 11, 2016 in the Conference Room
7. Executive Session – not needed
8. Adjournment
MOTION: Councilmember Bettelli moved to adjourn the meeting at 12:48 p.m.;
Councilmember Ferencz seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.