April 13, 2016 (PDF, 207.9 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of Apr 13, 2016 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
MINUTES OF THE ISLE OF PALMS
PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING
April 13, 2016
The Isle of Palms Planning Commission met in the City Hall Conference Room, 1207
Palm Boulevard on April 13, 2016 at 4:30 p.m. Members attending included Ron
Denton, Lewis Gregory, Noel Scott, Vince DiGangi, Richard Ferencz, Bill Mills and Lisa
Safford; the Director of Planning Douglas Kerr was present as well. The press had
been notified of the meeting and the agenda for the meeting was posted in City Hall and
the Building Department to comply with the Freedom of Information Act.
Chairman Richard Ferencz called the meeting to order.
PUBLIC COMMENTS
Cathy Smith, 8 Intracoastal Court, explained that she was opposed to the drystack
operation proposed in Concept A of the ATM reports.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Mr. Ferencz explained that the next item on the agenda was the approval of the March
9th and March 29th, 2016 minutes. Mr. Mills made a motion to approve the minutes as
submitted and Mr. Denton seconded the motion. The vote was unanimous in favor of
the motion.
SUBDIVISION- 2305 WATERWAY BOULEVARD
Mr. Kerr explained that this was a request for final approval of a subdivision at 2305
Waterway Boulevard. The property is currently configured as one 1.11 acre lot and the
owner is proposing to subdivide the property into two lots, with the lots measuring
30,732 square feet and 17,647 square feet.
Mr. Kerr stated that the property is located in the SR1 zoning district, which requires lots
be at least 17,500 square feet in area, be at least 70 feet wide at the building line, be at
least 110 feet deep, and have at least 60 feet of frontage on the street. He explained
that both properties would be served by public water and on-site septic systems. The
newly created, vacant lot has been tested by the SC Department of Health and
Environmental Control (DHEC) and has been issued a permit for a new septic system.
He stated that the City’s staff has reviewed the plat and believes that request complies
with the requirements of the ordinances and therefore recommends approval.
Mr. Mills asked if there was any issue with the fact that the existing driveway will be
partly on both properties. Mr. Kerr stated that he has suggested that the owners
consider creating an access easement over the driveway to clarify that the owner of Lot
2A has the right to access their property over Lot 2B, but there would not be a
Planning Commission Minutes
April 13, 2016
Page 2
requirement to do this and he understands that the current plan is for both properties to
remain under the same ownership, so it may not cause any issues.
Ms. Safford asked about the driveway for Lot 2B crossing the drainage easement. Mr.
Kerr said that there would be nothing prohibiting this, but if the pipe needed to have
maintenance performed anything placed in the easement could be removed. He also
stated that the owner could pursue moving the drainage easement to the edge of the
property, if they chose expand the buildable area of Lot 2B.
Mr. Ferencz asked about the retaining wall shown of the septic permit on the edge of
the drainage easement. Mr. Kerr stated that he assumed that this was to account for a
change in topography that may be necessary for the septic system.
Ms. Safford asked if the application complied with all of the ordinances of the City and if
so, would there be any basis that would allow for the Commission to deny the request.
Mr. Kerr answered yes, that in his opinion the request complied with all of the codes of
the City and because of this he did not think there would be any basis for the Planning
Commission to deny the request.
Ms. Safford made a motion to approve the request and Mr. Scott seconded the motion.
The vote was unanimous in favor of the motion.
DISCUSS MARINA MASTER PLAN WITH ATM
Mr. Kirby Marshall with ATM addressed the Commission and explained that he had
received comments and read the minutes of the previous minutes and he would like to
respond to some of the concerns that have been raised.
Mr. Ferencz stated that the Commission has dismissed the option including drystack
and is focusing on the issues of traffic circulation, parking, dockage and the gas pump
location on the plan showing no drystack.
Scott Parker with DesignWorks stated that his firm worked on the circulation issues of
the site and currently when people arrive it is very much like showing up to a boatyard
and they wanted to improve the arrival sequence. To do this, the plan includes a
roadway directly to the water’s edge, as this was the most compelling and beautiful part
of the site. He added that currently there was not really any public space at the water’s
edge and he thought it was important to add some greenspace and a boardwalk at the
edge of the water to give the public an opportunity to enjoy the site. He added that the
plan includes a community dock that could accommodate kayaks and paddle boards
and get them away from the busy boat launch and commercial operations.
Planning Commission Minutes
April 13, 2016
Page 3
Mr. Marshall explained that the plan includes reducing the boat ramp from three lanes to
two lanes for two reasons. First, the parking requirements published by SC Department
of Natural Resources (SCDNR) are driven by how many lanes the ramp contains and
the site cannot accommodate enough parking spaces for three lanes, according to their
standards. Secondly, by eliminating one of the lanes and using the area gained to add
ground out docks will greatly improve the efficiency in boat launching and retrieval.
In response to concerns of the location of the gas pumps, Mr. Marshall said that it was
made clear at the stakeholder meeting that these fuel pumps were one of only two
areas on the island where people can get gas and the public and the tenants had an
interest in keeping these facilities. He added that from a traffic flow perspective, it was
important that the fueling be done before boats on trailers got to the ramp, so this was
the reason for their location. He added that if cars stacking up down 41st Avenue was a
concern, the fuel pumps may needed to be moved farther into the lot.
Mr. Mills asked if there was a perceived safety problem with having the pumps so far
away from any oversight. Mr. Marshall answered that he did not think so and that most
fueling takes place without any oversight or cash exchange.
Mr. Mills stated that he perceived a problem with patrons of the restaurant being stuck
in the boat launching traffic. Mr. Marshall responded that the hours of use for the
restaurant and the boat launch should be different enough to not cause much overlap.
Mr. Ferencz asked Mr. Marshall to explain the breakdown of asphalt and gravel in the
pricing that was generated and mentioned that the square footage of the areas of each
surface appear to match what is currently on the site. Mr. Marshall answered that the
plan contemplates all of the drive aisles being asphalt and for all of the parking areas to
be gravel.
Mr. Gregory stated that he felt like the plan needed to be modified to be more
pedestrian, bike and golf cart friendly and have parking for bikes and golf carts added.
He also stated that he questioned the wisdom of putting a kayak launch on the
Intracoastal Waterway (ICW). Mr. Marshall responded that all of the Morgan Creek
docks are commercially used, so there is not much opportunity to put the community
dock anywhere other than on the ICW.
Mr. Marshall explained that one of the ideas investigated internally was to try to
segregate the boat traffic from the rest of the marina site by moving the boat ramps to
the side of the site that borders the Dewees Island property. He explained that the
challenge with this idea was getting enough trailer spaces necessary to accommodate
55 trailers, which is what ATM believes is necessary.
Planning Commission Minutes
April 13, 2016
Page 4
Mr. Parker stated that in his opinion, if the Commission is confident in the idea of not
leaving room for a future opportunity for drystack storage, moving the boat ramp is a
game changer. He stated that it would involve permits and building a new bulkhead to
capture the land that had been used for the ramps, but it would solve a lot of issues with
traffic circulation and add a greenspace between the marina store and the restaurant.
Mr. Kerr asked Mr. Marshall what his opinion was on the cost to move the boat ramp
and Mr. Marshall responded that typically construction cost would be about $60,000 per
lane.
Mr. Kerr stated that one of the reasons given to reduce the number of ramp lanes from
three to two was to comply with a the parking guidelines of SCDNR, but he asked if
there was any thought that reducing the number of lanes would actually reduce usage
and the need for spaces. Mr. Marshall answered that beyond the parking guideline the
improvement of efficiency provided by adding the ground-out docks made the reduction
in lanes desirable.
Mr. Gregory asked how critical the dry boat storage on the site was and asked if this
land could be dedicated to onsite parking. Mr. Marshall answered that this would be a
question for the marina operator and that the lease should be investigated to see if this
storage was critical to maintain.
Mr. Mills asked what the rationale was to show an option that included drystack storage
(option A). Mr. Marshall answered that the scope for the project included the financial
pro forma for drystack storage and Councilman Loftus specifically requested that ATM
provide two concepts, one with drystack and one without.
Mr. Mills asked if ATM could conceive any opportunity to partner with Dewees Island on
parts of the plan. Mr. Marshall answered that ATM has been working on the Dewees
site as well and generally their docks are in the same condition as the Isle of Palms
docks, but the ferry boat dock is brand new and it is closest to the Isle of Palms site, so
this really locks the site into its current configuration and limits the ability to partner on
many uses.
Mr. Ferencz asked if silting would be any more of an issue, if the boat ramps were to be
moved. Mr. Marshall answered that he did not think so.
Mr. Scott stated that he was encouraged to hear the excitement of Mr. Parker about the
idea of a new location for the boat ramp and he would like to pursue this option with a
new conceptual plan.
Planning Commission Minutes
April 13, 2016
Page 5
Mr. Ferencz stated that currently there is infinite capacity because the site spills out into
the roadways and he would like to find a way to keep the marina use confined to the
marina site.
Mr. Kerr stated that several people have expressed an interest in a public restroom on
the site and ask for opinions on this idea. Mr. Parker responded that a stand along
facility on the ground would be expensive and tough to fit on the site and potentially be
a safety concern. He stated that he would suggest adding them onto the marina store
facility, if they are deemed necessary beyond what is currently provided at the
restaurant and the store.
Mr. Kerr stated that he has also heard the idea of adding a gate house to take launch
fees and direct traffic. Mr. Parker responded that he hoped that by providing a better
organized layout to the property, visitors would instinctively know where to go and that
this would not be necessary. Mr. Marshall added that launch fees may be able to be
taken by parking kiosks similar to what is being used in the commercial district.
Mr. Scott made a motion to take the steps necessary to have a new concept developed
that showed the boat ramp being shifted to a location that would improve the traffic flow
within the site. Mr. Gregory seconded the motion and the vote was unanimous in favor
of the motion.
DISCUSSION OF THE MARINA MASTERPLAN’S CONSISTENCY WITH THE CITY’S
COMPREHENSIVE PLAN
Mr. Kerr explained that one of the responsibilities of the Planning Commission was to
give an opinion of any major capital expenses’ consistency with the City’s
Comprehensive Plan. He explained that he had distributed the excerpts from the
Comprehensive Plan that he could find that related to the marina and he did not see
anything that appeared to be in conflict, but at some point in the future the Commission
would need to make a judgement on this issue.
The Commission agreed that they would take this item up at a future meeting after
reviewing the Comprehensive Plan and the new conceptual masterplan for the marina.
DISCUSS SEPTIC TANKS ON THE ISLAND
Mr. Kerr explained that he has been in contact with the scientist who did the previous
nonpoint source study and he was excited about the idea of taking some new samples
and making a comparison. He stated that it sounded as though there would need to be
several samples taken for the data to be meaningful and it would probably need to be
Planning Commission Minutes
April 13, 2016
Page 6
done at the same time of year to be consistent. He stated that a proposal would be
coming forward on this issue.
He stated that he was also still expecting something from the Water and Sewer
Commission on what their plan would be to sewer the island.
Mr. Ferencz stated that earlier in the agenda the Commission heard a subdivision
request for new sites that would be served by septic tanks and he questioned the
wisdom in allowing new lots to be created that would be served by septic systems. Mr.
Kerr stated that he thought this would be a logical trigger for requiring sewer.
ADJOURNMENT
With there being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 6:05 p.m.
Respectfully submitted, Richard Ferencz, Chairman
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.