April 6, 2016 (PDF, 271.55 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of Apr 6, 2016 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
PERSONNEL COMMITTEE
11:00 a.m., Wednesday, April 6, 2016
The regular meeting of the Personnel Committee was held at 11:00 a.m., Wednesday, April 6,
2016 in the City Hall Conference Room, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South Carolina.
Attending the meeting were Councilmembers Bettelli and Ferencz, Chair Harrington ,
Administrator Tucker, Assistant Administrator Fragoso and Clerk Copeland; a quorum was
present to conduct business.
1. Chair Harrington called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public
were duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Ferencz moved to approve the minutes of the regular
meeting of March 2, 2016 as submitted; Councilmember Bettelli seconded and the
motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments – None
4. Old Business – None
5. New Business
A. Review of FY17 Operating Budgets for General Government and the Building
Department
Administrator Tucker noted that later in the meeting the Committee will be discussing the addition
of personnel, but she emphasized that the impact of those new positions were not reflected in the
operating budgets to be reviewed today. If th e Committee approves any one, all or none of the
positions, the financial impact will be in the next version of the budget.
Initiating the budget discussion, Administrator Tucker reported that the following are global to all
Departmental budgets:
A 3% wage increase for employees composed of a 2% merit and 1% COLA;
A 1% increase in health insurance premiums effective January 1, 2017;
Fuel computed on last 2 years average actual cost per gallon and last 12 months actual
usage;
Liability, property, underground fuel tank insurance increase of 5% and flood insurance
increased by 15%.
General Government
Overtime expense has been increased based on the actual amount year -to-do; the principal
amounts to be paid on the Recreation, Public Safety Building, and Fire Station 2 bonds has
increased for FY17 by thirty-two thousand dollars ($32,000). A small increase has been made to
Bank Service Charges, and Memberships and Dues have increased for Desirée to become a
member of the International City Managers Association. The South Carolina Beach Advocates
meeting is being hosted in Wild Dunes in October, and, typically, based on past experience, when
Personnel Committee
April 6, 2016
Page 2 of 11
conferences are hosted here, an outreach is made to the City to donate something or to support
it in some way; therefore, Meetings and Seminars was increased by fifteen hundred dollars
($1,500). The addition of Adobe Acrobat Pro DC subscription for City Hall is behind the increase
in Maintenance and Service Contracts for General Government. The need for additional meeting
notices and the use of boosting with Facebook ha ve precipitated the increase to Advertising
expense. Employee Training expense is the budget for tuition reimbursement for employees who
are in good standing to further their education; requests must be submitted and approved each
year before budget prepa ration. Having moved the provisions for the safety sweepstakes and
employee of the month to salaries, the budget for Miscellaneous and Contingency has been
reduced.
Judicial and Legal
Overtime has been tracking higher than in the past so the expense f or FY17 was increased;
Printing and Office Supplies are also tracking higher in FY16, resulting in a five hundred dollar
($500) increase for FY17. The maintenance for the on -line ticket payment has increased the
Maintenance and Service Contracts line by three thousand dollars ($3,000).
Capital Projects – General Government
The changes to Capital Projects were to reduce the amount budgeted for radio replacements to
ten thousand dollars ($10,000) and only with failure and to increase the cost of the tablets by two
thousand dollars ($2,000) based on a price increase. With a new quote for audio/visuals for
Council Chambers, the price has been reduced from forty thousan d dollars ($40,000) to
seventeen thousand five hundred dollars ($17,500).
Municipal Accommodations Fee – General Government
Sixty thousand dollars ($60,000) has been included in the Municipal Accommodations Fee fund
for costs associated with signs for the beach access parking plan.
Capital Outlay – General Government
In the Capital Projects Fund/Capital Outlay for General Government, half of the cost of the golf
cart path between 20 th Avenue and the island Center has been assigned, a figure of forty -five
thousand eight hundred twenty-three dollars ($45,823). The total for that line has become one
hundred seventy-five thousand three hundred twenty-three dollars ($175,323); the remaining half
will be budgeted to the Municipal Accommodations Fee Fund. Four thousand dollars ($4,000)
has also been assigned to Municipal Accommodations Fee Fund for forty (40) holiday light pole
banners.
Plant a Palm
Ten thousand dollars ($10,000) has been assigned to the Plant -A-Palm Fund for public art for
Front Beach.
Personnel Committee
April 6, 2016
Page 3 of 11
Mayor and Council
Meetings and Seminars has been increased by four thousand dollars ($4,000) to n ine thousand
dollars ($9,000), and Telephone and Cable have been increase by two hundred dollars ($200)
based on actual expenses. Administrator Tucker reminded the Committee that the 201 6
Municipal Association Annual Meeting will be held here in Charleston and the City will be getting
an award.
The large spreadsheet of expenses by fund includes the budgets for Mayor and Council, General
Government and Court; for FY17 eighty -six percent (86%) of the expenses will be funded from
the General and Capital Projects Funds, thirteen percent (13%) from tourism funds and one
percent (1%) from other funds.
Building and Planning Department
Other than salaries and the expenses associated with them, the only change in this operating
budget is in Professional Services for services requested by the Planning Commission and special
projects, like the golf cart path.
Councilmember Bettelli asked whether the City was going to go to the Water and Sewer
Commission to share the costs for an analysis of the septic versus sewer system. The
Administrator indicated that she did not think a professional study was involved, but legal
expenses had already been incurred related to an analysis of the legality of requiring citizens to
tie-in.
For the Building Department, expens es spread by fund ha ve not changed in terms of the
percentages paid from the General and Capital Projects Fund and tourism funds.
B. Discussion of COLA and Merit Increases for FY17 Budgets
The Personnel Committee has always been asked to opine on the am ount put in the operating
budgets for merit increases and cost of living adjustments. Staff did some surveying of
surrounding communities for their projections for budgets, and it was in the Post and Courier that
Mount Pleasant has just completed a wage study and is proposing a large wage increase for its
employees. Administrator Tucker only mentioned the Mount Pleasant proposal because, at times,
such a change can convince City employees that “the grass is greener” elsewhere. The City of
Charleston and Sullivan’s island are initially proposing a two percent (2%) increase while North
Charleston is proposing two and a half percent (2.5%). The Administrator reiterated that the FY17
budget has proposed a one percent (1%) COLA and a two percent (2%) merit increase.
Councilmember Ferencz indicated that she thought the proposal was fair.
MOTION: Councilmember Bettelli moved to recommend to Ways and Means a
1% COLA and a 2% merit increase for employees in FY17; Councilmember Ferencz
seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
C. Consideration of Additional Personnel
Personnel Committee
April 6, 2016
Page 4 of 11
Chair Harrington stated that Council wants the City staff to have the best resources available, but
he questioned the need for all of the Department Managers to be in attendance at committee
meetings and whether this was the best use of their time. He then suggested the possibility that
all committees might not need to meet on a monthly basis; he noted that Council has been working
to streamline expenses, time, energy and effort by being more electronic.
Councilmember Ferencz commented on the number of after -hours meetings the City has and
asked whether staff members who attend were given either overtime or compensatory time.
Before responding, Administrator Tucker commented to the Committee that this topic was not on
the Agenda and suggested that it could be added to today’s agenda or be an it em on a future
agenda. The Administrator stated that the City must adhere to the requirements of the Fair Labor
Standards Act of the wage and hour laws. If an employee is asked to attend an after -hour
meeting, he or she will receive overtime or comp time , whichever applies, but, if an employee
chooses to attend a meeting after hours for his or her personal information, overtime or comp time
would not apply.
Councilmember Ferencz then asked whether department managers were required to attend every
Council meeting.
MOTION: Councilmember Ferencz moved to add a discussion of the attendance
of City personnel at meetings; Councilmember Bettelli seconded and the motion
PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Administrator Tucker reminded the Committee that her personal goal for this year was to develop
a succession plan for department managers and herself and that she believes that one way in
which succession planning is done is to make sure personnel are shadowing and learning from
the individual all of the time. Two (2) managers from the Police Department were present today,
and, if one is incapacitated in some way, the other must step in as seamlessly as possible. In
addition, the Police Department has positions to propose and are present for that reason; the Fire
Department is one (1) of the departments advocating item 5D, explaining their presence; and the
Recreation Director is attending because one (1) of the proposed positions would fall in the
Recreation Department. Department Managers are not required to attend all meetings, but are a
valuable resource when they do ; the only staff member required to attend meeting is the City
Administrator.
On the issue of fewer meetings or meetings during work hours, either would reduce or eliminate
the amount of overtime and comp time.
Councilmember Ferencz noted that, if committees met less frequently, the agendas would include
more action items and would last longer, but she thought it was worth investigating.
Director Page said that she always attends Ways and Means, Council and Personnel meetings
because she thinks it is important that she know what is going on in the City . S he stated that
decisions made in the Personnel Committee meetings affect her staff and she can keep them
informed rather than dealing with rumors.
Personnel Committee
April 6, 2016
Page 5 of 11
Supporting Chair Harrington’s position, Councilmember Ferencz stated that this line of
communication could also be done electronically by sending them a copy of the audio recording;
they would not have to attend, but be allowed to do their jobs.
Chair Harrington also pointed out that there are redundancies between committees, doubling staff
efforts.
Having worked in the private sector, both Chair Harrington and Councilmember Ferencz
expressed reservations about salaried personnel receiving comp time; b y being salaried, these
people were expected to do whatever was necessary to get the job done.
Councilmember Ferencz opined that looking into ways that department managers could more
efficiently use their work day and not attend meetings was worth study.
Councilmember Bettelli agreed that study would be worthwhile, but he appreciated staff’s
presence because they frequently have valuable input on a subject. He also voiced agreement
about duplication of efforts in committees and suggested that the scope of work and
responsibilities for standing committees needed to be more clearly defined.
The Administrator reminded the Committee that the responsibilities of each committee were
defined in the City Code, and, on the subject of duplications between commi ttees, the
Administrator noted that the agendas are set by the Committee chairs. If the chair wants a subject
on his committee’s agenda, the Administrator can only advise him that the item falls under the
purview of another committee, but the chair has the final word on the agenda.
Councilmember Ferencz stated that aspects of a project might fall under two (2) committees, and
the Administrator agreed.
To encourage this discussion in the other committees, Administrator Tucker suggested that Chair
Harrington include the discussion in his report of the meeting at City Council and ask that the
other committees consider whether they could streamline meetings to have fewer of them and
examine their duties as a committee to avoid duplication.
To be considered by the Committee is the addition of four (4) positions in FY17 and the possibility
of others in the future if the City were to decide to handle its NPDES functions.
MOTION: Councilmember Ferencz moved to include the addition of 2 police
officers to the Agenda; Councilmember Bettelli seconded and the motion PASSED
UNANIMOUSLY.
1. Payroll and Human Resource
2. Two Police Officers
3. City Parks and Facilities Specialist
The need for a human resources person was touched on at the March meeting, and staff was
asked to develop a job description with the expenses associated with it. Currently Clerk Copeland
is performing the dual function of management of human resources where she enrolls new
Personnel Committee
April 6, 2016
Page 6 of 11
employees, keeps track of all personnel records, keying in and generating the bi -weekly payroll
and making payroll deposits in addition to the duties of City Clerk. The accounting that is
necessary for meeting the new requir ements of the Affordable Care Act (ACA) and other state
and federal regulations are growing steadily. In an effort to manage the City Clerk’s position and
the human resource function when the duties related to the history of th e City, minutes of
meetings, have increased in volume, the need for a human resources person has become more
evident. The record keeping associated with human resources must be accurate and carefully
handled; on more than one (1) occasion, the City has been asked for the contents of an
employee’s entire record. The person in this role would assume those duties as noted in the
attached job description (a copy of which is attached to the historical record of the meeting.). The
recurring expense is estimated to be approximately sixty -two thousand six hund red fifty dollars
($62,650), with one-time expenses of twenty-four thousand dollars ($24,000). In order to make
space available for this new person in City Hall, twenty thousand dollars ($20,000) of the one-
time costs is to reconfigure the office space.
Councilmember Ferencz asked how much overtime was being accumulated to get all of the tasks
done. Clerk Copeland responded that more overtime is accumulated during the months of budget
preparation because the meetings tend to run mu ch longer; the work week was fifty to fifty -five
hours (50-55 hrs.) in March and April of last year. The human resources side of the position does
not get the attention that it should, and filing is not done on a timely basis.
Administrator Tucker stated that staff had pondered whether the job could be done by a part-time
person, but the consensus was that the position requires a high level of responsibility. She stated
that she has heard that some companies have attorneys in the human resources role. T he
Administrator questioned that a part -time person would have the level of commitment and
responsibility necessary.
Based on Clerk Copeland’s term with the City, Councilmember Ferencz thought it might be better
to put her in the human resources position and to hire a part-time clerk. Clerk Copeland stated
that there was too much work in the clerk’s position to have a part-time person twelve (12) months
a year.
Administrator Tucker stated that this position was to keep the City from finding itself in a situation
where it has failed to do something that it was supposed to do because someone is too tired
because they are performing too many duties.
The goal of this discussion is to decide which position(s), if any, were to be included in the next
version of the budget by approving the job descriptions directing staff to increase salaries and
associated line items.
Chair Harrington reminded the Committee that Council was looking for ways to make staff more
efficient, giving them more time to get their work done.
Councilmember Ferencz said that she would like to see how staff’s work can be made more
efficient before adding more people.
Personnel Committee
April 6, 2016
Page 7 of 11
Councilmember Bettelli indicated that he would like to see these new positions presented to Ways
and Means in the budget.
Administrator Tucker explained that, in order to prepare a full budget and look at how it all
balances out and determine what will be funded by which fund, staff needed to include things, not
exclude them.
If all four (4) of the positions were to be approved, the Committee would be adding two hundred
fifty thousand dollars ($250,000 ) in fixed costs to the budget according to Counci lmember
Ferencz.
Expanding staff is an expense that is ongoing every year, so it is a big decision with a big
budgetary impact. But it would be wrong for Department Managers not to inform the decision -
making body when there is a need to add personnel.
Councilmember Ferencz did not argue that help was needed, but she wanted t o see if fewer
meetings and more efficient use of time could reduce the need for added people.
Chief Buckhannon said that he only attends meetings that he has to attend and then ad dressed
the reasoning behind the request for two (2) additional police officers. The Chief commented that
the area is experiencing tremendous growth, and the Department last added to staffing in 2007
with the hiring of the Livability Officer. The newspaper recently stated that Charleston County is
growing by forty -eight (48) people per day, and the island has been feeling the impact of that
growth as well over the last several years. At this time, the Department is struggling to meet the
demand of some of the calls they are receiving; some take several hours to accomplish; some of
the calls are more aggressive in nature with more guns and hard drugs involved. The City had
its first homicide last year; when that case comes up for trial, the Department cou ld have six or
seven (6-7) officers gone for three to four (3-4) weeks. Shortly after that incident, an attempted
kidnapping occurred in Wild Dunes when someone was held at gunpoint; it could have easily
become another homicide or an officer involved shooting. With the numbers of people coming to
the beach in season, officers are tied up with directing traffic at the expense of other duties. The
increasing numbers year over year is taking its toll on the Department, and the efficiency is starting
to wear on the command staff. Officers are now required to get a certain number of hours in
training every year; while that officer is training, the City is short one (1) man on the road. Chief
Buckhannon said that he needs help in both investigations and livability.
The recurring costs of adding two (2) officers is projected to be one hundred fifteen thousand
eight hundred dollars ($115,800) with one-time costs of approximately ninety-seven thousand one
hundred dollars ($97,100) for a total Year One cost of two hundred twelve thousand nine hundred
dollars ($212,900).
Administrator Tucker informed the Committee that she had expected this request last year, and
the City has received some complaints about lag-time between the initial call for assistance and
the arrival of the officer. And, in January and February, the City will continue to get complaints
that the City has too many officers on the road.
The minimum staffing per shift is two (2) officers, but the City runs three (3) per shift presently.
Personnel Committee
April 6, 2016
Page 8 of 11
If approved, these officers would be assigned where they are needed – one to investigations and
one to livability. They will be sworn officers who will assist with patrol when needed.
When Councilmember Ferencz asked whether the increase in call volume could be attributed to
the tourist season, Chief Buckhannon stated it is no longer true that things happen between May
and September and that the season is now all year. More and more events are being held on the
island and each one puts a strain on the department . In the month just ended, the Department
had forty-eight hundred (4,800) calls for service; in the summer months, the number of calls will
fall between fifty -five hundred and six thousand (5,500 -6,000). The majority of calls originate
outside Wild Dunes.
For the next position, the job title and description were taken from the Recreation Department and
will likely be changed if approved; the new position will be similar to this position but it will be City-
wide. For some time, the City has been lacking a person who is responsible for all of the City’s
buildings and grounds. With a person assigned to care for the building and a person assigned to
care for the grounds, the Recreation Center always looks lovely; that cannot be said for other City
properties. Typically, small problems become big problems b y the time someone realizes that,
for example, a hedge is dying, not just a bush. This person’s role would be to supervise what
contracts the City has, like landscaping, to be responsible for checking and maintaining all of the
City’s buildings, to assist with budgeting and planning to make sure things happen on schedule
and to have an ongoing awareness of the state of City properties.
In assessing this position, staff discussed which department he would be assigned to, and Public
Works was the obvious choice, but Director Pitts has all he can handle with garbage and debris
pickup and removal. Since Director Page is already supervi sing this function for the Recreation
site, an assignment to the Recreation Department was a good fit.
Director Pitts stated that the Public Works function has evol ved with the beach cleaning of
disposable chairs, the tents, the upkeep of the beach barrels, overseei ng the contracts for
garbage and recycle removal, maintaining the compactor and dumpsters.
Director Page stated that she currently has a lot of talent at the Recreation Department and they
can help him get certain things done; Recreation staff has helped with mowing the rights-of-way,
weed-eating and edging, trimming trees, etc.
Councilmember Ferencz asked where the budget was for this person to do all of the things
discussed, and Director Page replied that there are maintenance and repair costs in al l
departmental budgets that should cover what this person is being asked to do.
Treasurer Suggs envisioned this person maintaining a log of his daily activities to be able to
charge the appropriate department’s maintenance budget for what he does.
Chief Graham added that the City could likely save money by consolidating certain contracts,
namely, landscaping, pest control, elevator maintenance, etc.
Personnel Committee
April 6, 2016
Page 9 of 11
MOTION: Councilmember Bettelli moved to recommend the 4 positions
discussed and to incorporate them into the budget for the Ways & Means
Committee; Chair Harrington seconded and the motion PASSED on a vote of 2 to 1
with Councilmember Ferencz casting the dissenting vote.
Councilmember Ferencz explained that, in the time she has been on Council, the City has added
three (3) firemen, communication specialists and six (6) Beach Services Officers, and, in her
opinion, the City cannot just keep adding people.
Councilmember Bettelli said that he agreed in theory with her, but that the personnel were
necessary; the parking plan could not have happened without the additional BSOs. He stated
that Council needs to do what is necessary to keep the City moving forward.
D. Consideration of BenAssist Actuary Fee of $3,000 to Evaluate the OPEB
Liability for GASB 45 and 75 (Retiree Health Insurance)
As a long time City employee who hopes to retire from it, Chief Graham stated that she has been
concerned for years that, when an e mployee leaves the City , they take no thing with them – no
health insurance, no life insurance, etc. If a retired employee wants to retain his health insurance
coverage, he not only pays one hundred perc ent (100%) of the premium but is also charged an
additional thirty percent (30%), which she considers to be a penalty. She wanted to know if the
penalty could be taken away from retiree health insurance coverage.
Responding to Councilmember Ferencz’ question about the additional thirty percent (30%),
Treasurer Suggs explained that, when th e City was with the South Carolina Local Government
Assurance Group (SCLGAG) they had an unblended rate, i.e. a separate rate for retirees and for
active personnel. When the new GASB rule came down, the City had to recognize a very large
liability for the unfunded liability on the retirement system; there is a similar GASB rule for
unfunded liability and retiree health insurance. The City has never paid anything for retiree
coverage, and, while the City was still with SCLGAG, Council decided to allow reti rees to be a
part of the City’s group but responsible for one hundred percent (100%) of the premium.
The GASB rule says that, if retirees pay the same amount as full -time active employees, there
exists what is referred to as an implicit subsidy; this subsidy comes about because both groups
pay the same premium when, in fact, retirees, as a group, have a h igher cost. The government
entity, therefore, was to recognize a liability equal to the actuarily determined present value of
that future liability. When the city moved to the State Health Plan, the rates are blended so the
implicit subsidy exists.
At the time, the City had no retirees interested in coverage, so the Treasurer advised Council to
establish a model, like another municipality had already done, whereby employees can participate
in the City’s group health insurance plan, but they will be charg ed the implicit subsidy, meaning
that the City does not have to recognize the liability on its books. The thirty percent (30%) comes
from the Municipal Association and Public Employee Benefit Authority (PEBA) who were told by
their actuaries that it was the implicit subsidy.
Personnel Committee
April 6, 2016
Page 10 of 11
The Treasurer reported having had this conversation with a couple of retirees who asked where
the thirty percent (30%) goes, and she had to tell them that the City keeps the money to offset the
ongoing health insurance expense.
Today the City has employees who are nearing retirement and are asking questions about what
kind of coverage they can have through the City and the thirty percent (30%) upcharge has come
back around.
The item on the Agenda is to pay an actuary to determine what the City’s implicit liability would
be, so that City Council can make an informed decision about whether or not the City wants to
change its requirements for retiree health insurance coverage.
According to Treasurer Suggs, this actuarial service should be repeated every two or three (2-3)
years.
One important fact is that the implicit subsidy only applies to pre-65 retirees, which should serve
to reduce the City’s liability.
Treasurer Suggs stated that this company was recommended to her by the previous auditor, and
they have a very good reputation.
The Treasurer commented that this cost could be paid from the current budget under Professional
Services.
MOTION: Councilmember Bettelli moved to recommend to Ways and Means to
spend $3,000 for BenAssist to evaluate the OPEB liability for GASB 45 and 75;
Councilmember Ferencz seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
E. Discussion of Permanent Nametag for Councilme mbers and Department
Managers
Councilmember Bettelli asked that this be added to the Agenda; he stated that he would like to
have a permanent nametag to wear to meetings and public events as a bit of added
professionalism.
MOTION: Councilmember Harrington moved to authorize the Administrator to
get permanent nametags for Councilmember and Department Managers;
Councilmember Bettelli seconded and the motion PASSED on a vote of 2 to 1 with
Councilmember Ferencz casting the dissenting vote.
F. Discussion on Non-resident Participation on Standing Committees
Chair Harrington said that people who own property on the island, but do not live on the island
have no voice in the City, and he thought it would be interesting to get their perspective.
Administrator Tucker stated that standing committees are set by City Code as being members of
Council; if there was interest in expanding them, it would mean amending the Code.
Personnel Committee
April 6, 2016
Page 11 of 11
Councilmember Bettelli noted that full-time residents are not allowed to serve on standing
committees, and he added that every meeting has a period for citizens’ comments when anyone
is allowed to come and speak.
The Administrator remarked that the Real Property Committee had originally b een an ad hoc
committee of Council with a local business person as a member, but the Code was amended to
make it a standing committee because it was being given so much work for the City.
The Chair commented that possibly an ad hoc committee was what the friend was referring to.
The Administrator stated that, if another committee was added, it would have to be staffed to give
them guidance on what they could or could not do.
6. Miscellaneous Business
Next Meeting Date: 11:00 a.m., Wednesday, May 4, 2016 in the Conference Room.
7. Executive Session – not needed
8. Adjournment
MOTION: Councilmember Ferencz moved to adjourn the meeting at 1:25 p.m.;
Councilmember Bettelli seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.