April 6, 2016 (PDF, 372.34 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of Apr 6, 2016 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
REAL PROPERTY COMMITTEE
2:00 p.m., Wednesday, April 6, 2016
The regular meeting of the Real Property Committee was held at 2:00 p.m., Wednesday, April 6,
2016 in the City Hall Conference Room, 1207 Pam Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South Carolina.
Attending the meeting were Councilmembers Harrington and Rice, Chair Bergwerf, Administrator
Tucker, Assistant Administrator Fragoso and City Clerk Copeland; a quorum was present to
conduct business.
1. Chair Bergwerf called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public
had been duly notified in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Rice moved to approve the minutes of the regular
meeting of March 3, 2016 as submitted; Councilmember Harrington seconded and
the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments
Stuart Colman, 10 Live Oak Drive, read his prepared statement that a dry stack storage facility
should not be a part of the marina redevelopment plan. (A copy of his statement is attached to
the historical record of the meeting.)
Phillip Smith, 8 Intracoastal Court, reported that among the recommendations made last week at
the Planning Commission meeting relative to the marina redevelopment was the relocation of the
watersports business a bit north and away from Mr. Smith’s property line. To do so would lessen
the impact of this business on the surrounding residential neighbors of the marina. He noted that
this is a very lucrative business with as many as twelve (12) jet skis, parasail boats, jet boats, and
maybe twenty to thirty (20-30) people on the dock at once. Mr. Smith noted that he has made
this request several times and that he was hopeful to have the watersports dock moved as part
of the redevelopment plan. He opined that many good ideas were made about parking and traffic
flow at the marina, but the factor that impacts his area is the overflow parking; he described it as
the biggest problem neighbors of the marina have. In all of the meetings he has attended, he has
not heard a resolution to that problem. He commented that there is not room on Waterway
Boulevard to park safely without impacting the bike path; he said that the parking of trailers along
Waterway is a public safety hazard.
Shane Ziegler of Barrier Isle Ecotours stated that he has been running eco-tours out of the IOP
marina since 1998; he said that he provides tours to approximately ten thousand (10,000) school
children from throughout the state per year. He indicated that his business seldom impacts the
parking issues at the marina because the school tours occur on weekdays in the spring and fall,
not on the weekends; the tourists’ tours in the summer months are also during the week.
4. Comments from Marina Tenants
Jay Clarke of Morgan Creek Grill presented the members of the Committee what he had given to
the Planning Commission; a copy is attached to the historical record of the meeting.
Real Property Committee
April 6, 2016
Page 2 of 10
Brian Berrigan, marina manager, initially thanked the Committee for holding their meeting earlier
in the day, making it easier for him to attend. He reported that the kayak business has been
moved off the ramp to a space behind the Intracoastal docks adjacent to Tidal Wave Watersports.
He reported that he has also received complaints about people smoking on the back de ck;
therefore, he will be prohibiting smoking there. He plans to have signs printed, put up and to give
a reasonable notification period, but he expe cts the Cit y will hear some complaints about his
action; a dedicated smoking place will be designated.
Michael Fiem of Tidal Wave Watersports commented that the Eco-tours were great for the marina
and that they are very pleased about the relocation of the kayaks.
5. Old Business
A. Update on FEMA Project Worksheets related to 2 Category G Projects
Assistant Fragoso recalled for the Committee that one (1) FEMA worksheet was submitted for the
damage to the beach from October storm for one and a half million dollars ($1,500,000); the City
has not received any comments or questions about it from FEMA. The City has been notified that
it will receive seventy-five percent (75%) of the fifteen thousand dollars ($15,000) in damages to
the 49th Avenue beach access.
B. Discussion of Marina Redevelopment
Mr. Berrigan re -introduced John Shaffer to the Committee; then he displayed the two (2) ATM
conceptual drawings and a third one developed by John Tarkany for Mr. Berrigan several years
ago.
A sense of arrival has been a concept that Mr. Berrigan has supported for many years; he has
thought such an entrance would serve the marina well. The drystack boat storage was an
important factor early on and has been a source of much debate despite Mr. Berrigan’s decision
for it to serve island residents only.
Councilmember Harrington said that he has heard from residents who support the drystack; he
opined that the City needs data on how many residents would store their boats in a drystack at
the IOP marina.
Councilmember Rice agreed that there were interesting ideas in the Tarkany drawing; she voiced
support for filling in the di tch since a car and trailer have been stuck in the ditch already this
season.
Administrator Tucker explained that a portion of that ditch was considered to be wetlands, so to
fill it in the City must create wetlands on another part of the island. The City would have to get
permission from OCRM and the Corps of Engineers, then identify a location on the island to
duplicate the habitat in the ditch at the marina. Therefore, the ditch can be piped.
Michael Fiem said that he has worked with the EPA in the past, and, based on his experience,
the wetland under discussion is a dying wetland because the stormwater runoff continues to widen
Real Property Committee
April 6, 2016
Page 3 of 10
it so that eventually it will not be a wetland. As the ditch widens and erodes away, it creates
basically a immobile mound of sand between the Tidal Wave dock and Mr. Smith’s dock. In
addition, the area cannot be dredged because of the electrical lines that run through it; pipin g it
could save money in the long run.
Councilmember Rice noted that there is also the issue of sand shifting behind the bulkhead.
Administrator Tucker stated that , shortly after the bulkhead was replaced, some of the tenants
noticed that there was some silting on the landward side of the bulkhead. The engineering firm
that designed the bulkhead was called to determine if there was a problem with the design of the
bulkhead that was installed, and they decided that there was no problem. Weep holes are in the
bulkhead that exist to allow materials to pass through it. It will require an engineer to assess the
bulkhead and to advise the City about what should be done. The Administrator voiced the belief
that the heavy rains in the fall, followed by Joaqui n and the rains in the spring have only
exacerbate the problem.
Councilmember Rice opined that this problem should be corrected before any decisions are made
about the marina.
MOTION: Councilmember Rice moved to reach out to an engineer to learn the
cost of an assessment of the bulkhead; Councilmember Harrington seconded and
the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Chair Bergwerf stated that she was never in favor of the marina study because she thought the
purpose was to present a drystack to Council; for her, the crucial issue was to improve the footprint
for parking and to keep all of the marina businesses within the marina footprint so that it does not
affect the neighborhoods. In her opinion, a drystack storage would be “hugely” successful; her
question is whether the object of marina redevelopment has been for the residents. As presented,
she believes that the drystack would exceed the City’s maximum height allowance of forty feet
(40 ft.), and if one (1) level were to be removed, would it then be economically viable? Without a
drystack, the City has a chance to make the vehicular and trailer parking efficient enough to keep
the business within the footprint. She indicated that the majority of people she has heard from
think a drystack would be too po lluting and too noisy and would detract from the quality of li fe.
The Chair stated that she ”in no way,” thinks the drystack would reduce traffic at the marina.
Councilmember Harrington indicated that he has no feeling one way or the other; therefore, he
was looking for hard data regarding the level of interest among boat owners on the island.
Administrator Tucker informed the Committee that staff could find out how many residents were
paying taxes for boats on the island; however, that would not capture the pros and cons of the
balance of the population that might not be boating people but might have feelings about a
drystack on the island.
Councilmember Rice indicated that she has gotten a lot of feedback on the drystack and most
were not in favor of it. In her opinion, the goal should be the efficient use of space, to beautify it,
etc. She remarked that, at three million dollars ($3,000,000), the City would be a long time
recuperating its investment.
Real Property Committee
April 6, 2016
Page 4 of 10
Chair Bergwerf reiterated that, for her, parking is Number One. Since Wild Dunes does not allow
a property owner to store his boat in his yard, the Chair repeated that the drystack would easily
be filled.
Administrator Tucker stated that, if too many unknowns existed related to a drystack now, but, in
the future, it would make perfect sense, maybe ATM should have come up with a third design that
improves the entire space, but preserves space for a future drystack.
Looking at another aspect of the d rawings, Mr. Berrigan stated that he was opposed to moving
the gas pumps closer to 41 st Avenue; he believes that moving them farther from the store will
reduce business in the store and create a huge backup on 41 st Avenue. He thought that
preserving space for a future drystack was certainly doable. He supported the idea of having two
(2) entrances, i.e. one (1) for bicycles, golf carts and pedestrians and one (1) for vehicles and
boats/trailers.
Mr. Berrigan noted that, of the four (4) underground fuel storage tanks at the marina, two (2) serve
the dock and two (2) serve the land fueling station.
Mr. Berrigan stated that he, too, was opposed to reducing the ramp from three (3) lanes to two
(2) lanes. He indicated that he would only support a two (2) lane ramp if the drystack was
constructed with its own ramp.
In the Administrator’s mind, the motivation behind the two (2) lane ramp was part of planning a
concept that fell within the parking requirements for the site; she could not understand that a two
(2) lane ramp would be an improvement under any other circumstances.
Councilmember Rice asked what could be done to enforce the parking on the footprint when the
lot is full, and her first thought was to send out electronic alerts.
In the Chair’s opinion, the lot is never full because they simply pull out of the marina to park on
Waterway Boulevard. Until trailer parking is not allowed on Waterway, it will continue. Since
traffic into and out of the marina is so varied with vehicles, vehicles with trailers, golf carts and
bicycles, how would anyone know when the lot is full? In the end, it all boils down to a quality of
life issue for the Chair.
Administrator Tucker stated that she had heard questions about why the land side fuel docks
could not be eliminated, but she indicated that have two (2) fueling resources on the island would
be crucial in the event of a disaster.
Chair Bergwerf reminded everyone of the Marina Workshop at 5:30 p.m., Thursday, April 28 th in
Council Chambers.
While the structure of the workshop has not been addressed, the Administrator indicated that the
important element of this meeting was for Councilmembers to talk to one another about the issues
and to decide what they like and do not like in order to proceed.
Real Property Committee
April 6, 2016
Page 5 of 10
Chair Bergwerf agreed that Council knew what the i ssues were because they have heard from
many residents on both sides and they need a time for open dialogue.
C. Discussion of Tri-County Hospitality Center
Looking for tenets to steer his work, he found them in the City seal which are referenced economy,
safety, health and service. He asked what Council was doing for the island economically that is
important; certainly there are safety factors since they are public restrooms and a bathhouse;
there are health issues; and it provides a service to a much larger population than the island.
Councilmember Kinghorn began with the assumption that the public restrooms are an under -
utilized space – it is a million dollar ($1,000,000) piece of property with a twenty-six (26) year old
restroom on it. (The Councilmember’s presentation is attached to the historical record of the
meeting.) The property has undergone two (2) studies in the past three (3) years, and they
concluded that the City has three (3) options for the space and they are:
1) Make minimum improvements to what currently exists at the location;
2) Replace the existing facilities with new and upgraded ones; or
3) Redevelop the property for the highest and best use, considered to be commercial
redevelopment by the Hartnett report.
The justification in the title Tri -County Hospitality Center is to create something that has added
value for all of the communities. It would be “a twelve thousand square foot (12,000 sq. ft.) two
or three (2-3) story, class A multi-use facility that will maximize its value and serve the Charleston
region’s growing population by improving beach access and providing flexible multi-use facilities.”
In his research, he found that there is no public front beach access facility like the one described,
and he imagined a long list of possible uses.
Partners for the venture who would find benefits for their residents were listed as the City of Isle
of Palms, the Town of Mount Pleasant, Charleston County, Berkeley County, Dorchester County,
South Carolina Parks, Recreation and Tourism, and possibly others.
In addition, Councilmember Kinghorn’s suggestion included financials with the estimated cost of
construction, revenue and expense estimates with a small net gain for the City.
Chair Bergwerf noted that the lot is t hirty feet (30 ft.) wide with a six foot (6 ft.) walkway, so the
maximum width of the building would be twenty -four feet (24 ft.). The Chair asked if the twelve
thousand square feet (12,000 sq. ft.) represented three (3) stories, and Councilmember Kinghorn
answered that it could be two or three (2-3) based on the ceiling height.
Director Kerr explained that they arrived at the numbers by assuming that the building would be
thirty-feet (30 ft.) wide with an access under the building with a two hundred foot (200 ft.) buildable
deck totaling six thousand square feet (6,000 sq. ft.) per floor with two floors.
The Chair indicated that she thought it would be a challenge to get Charleston County to assist
with the restrooms at two hundred thousand dollars ($200,000), and now we are also going to
Dorchester and Berkeley. The Chair challenged Councilmember Kinghorn when she asked why
Real Property Committee
April 6, 2016
Page 6 of 10
the Isle of Palms would think that neighboring counties would use their money for this project
when they probably have more worthy things they could do for their citizens.
Councilmember Kinghorn saw the difference as not asking for hundreds of thousands of dollars
for a toilet, but here they would be asked to make an investment on which they can get a return
and they can offer their citizens a place to go to the beach where they have a stake or an
ownership. For a million dollars, they are getting beach front access and an activity with all of the
facilities and trimmings that it represents in addition to a return on investment.
The Chair voiced the opinion that the City was being very optimistic to think it could get someone
from outside to fund the public restrooms. She opined that the City must have the design in hand
when it goes to make a presentation to one (1) of these entities.
Alternatively, Councilmember Kinghorn suggested that the City could sell the p roperty with the
caveat that the buyer must provide twenty -five hundred square feet (2 ,500 sq. ft.) of restrooms
and outdoor showers; then use the money for another project.
Chair Bergwerf and Councilmember Rice both voiced opposition to selling the property under any
circumstances.
Having experience in event planning for Wild Dunes, Councilmember Rice stated that there is not
a huge demand for events on the island. The City would need someone managing the space full-
time to sell it , assist with setup and breakdown; the space would need a kitchen suitable for a
wedding reception, i.e. she does not see the demand for the space as proposed.
Councilmember Kinghorn contended that no matter how difficult it might be, the City could miss
an opportunity if it does not propose this idea to possible stakeholders.
Chair Bergwerf asked the Administrator about the status of funding from Charleston County; the
Administrator replied that there was not a line in their budget for IOP restrooms, but they have not
closed the door.
Councilmember Kinghorn stated that the Public Works Committee had a similar discussion, but
thought it was worthy of further investigation. Having provided a draft concept, financials, steps
to take and a draft letter to stakeholders, C ouncilmember Kinghorn thought it was up to Council
to decide how to proceed.
One issue that came to light during the work with Liollio and the front beach merchants was the
future need for secondary restroom facilities in addition to the existing locati on, possibly in the
large parking lot. The utilization of the public restrooms continues to steadily increase.
Administrator Tucker observed that an obstacle to the idea was that the project was not sellable
to other local governments, but if it is sella ble to IOP on the notion that the goal of replacing the
restrooms is accomplished and, in so doing, also creates a revenue generator for the City, is it
distasteful to think in terms of doing a bigger project than was originally conceived without the
outside investment, allowing the City to keep all of the revenue?
Real Property Committee
April 6, 2016
Page 7 of 10
To get an architectural rendering of the vision, the Administrator recommended contacting Liollio
because of their familiarity with the site. From that the Committee could decide if it was something
the City wanted to pursue.
Having reviewed the handout from Morgan Creek Grill, Administrator Tucker indicated that there
were some interesting points made and she did not want them to get overlooked. (A copy of the
handout is attached to the historical record of the meeting.)
Chair Bergwerf asked Mr. Clarke how he wanted to reconfigure the finger docks, and he
responded that he had submitted plans several years ago to extend the finger docks to the outer
pilings on the IntraCoastal Waterway; he agreed to bring the drawings to the meeting of April 28th.
Mr. Clarke stated that, in the past, he had spoken with Charleston County about filling in the ditch
along the property line, and he reported that Mosquito Control was fully supportive. He would like
to see a vegetative buffer there and he thought it would lessen the flooding at Fire Station 2.
On the subject of employee parking at the space owned by the IOP Water and Sewer
Commission, Mr. Clarke thought that possibly as many as fifty (50) vehicles could be parked there;
he will bring the costs of fencing to the April 28th meeting also.
D. Update on 42nd Avenue Beach Access
The Administrator reported that City Council had authorized the cons truction of a handicap
parking space there and that the City was getting the encroachment permit.
Director Kerr reported that the City has the SCDOT permit, and he is getting pricing on asphalt.
The handicap beach access path planned for this site was submitted for a grant that would have
paid for fifty percent (50%) of the cost, and the City had budgeted ninety -five thousand dollars
($95,000) for it. Director Kerr informed the Committee that OCRM actually has a law against two
(2) access paths on one (1) property; therefore, he questions that the City would get funding if the
it applied for the grant again next year for the same access. OCRM has granted the permit for
the handicap path, but they might not want to participate in funding it since it goes against their
regulations.
After much back and forth, the access at the Front Beach will be handicap accessible also;
Director Kerr said the new path there will be flat and wide – an excellent handicap access.
6. New Business
A. Review of Operating Budgets for the Marina, Front Beach, Beach Renourish-
ment and Monitoring
Administrator Tucker was going to review only those budget lines that were deviations from FY16.
Marina Fund Expenditures
General and Administrative
Real Property Committee
April 6, 2016
Page 8 of 10
The Professional Services line includes the engineering and design for the comprehensive
redevelopment project for Phase I, however Council decides to define it; the figures came from
the ATM document.
Councilmember Rice noted that the line needed to be increased to include the engineering fees
for the assessment of the bulkhead.
Marina Store
In the Insurance line, the only item is the premium for the underground tank; the property, liability
and flood are paid by the City but reimbursed by the tenant.
Marina Fund
The cost of replacing the four (4) underground storage tanks is included in Other Capital
Purchases along with the replacement of the dock fuel dispensers, only with failure. When staff
reached out to a vendor for the replacement storage tanks, the cost had increased and is reflected
in the FY17 budget.
Municipal Accommodations Fee Fund Expenditures
Front Beach/Parking Enforcement/BSOs/Parking Lots
Printing and Office Supplies has nearly doubled at twenty -four thousand three hundred dollars
($24,300) due to having more kiosks and a mixture of new and older kiosks, more supplies will
be needed, as well as the cost of the parking decals and booklets, e nforcement supplies and
parking lot annual passes. Another line item that will increase because of the increased number
of kiosks is the bank service charge for credit card processing. Telephone and Cable expenses
have been increased by forty-two hundred dollars ($4,200) for the service and 3G upgrade to the
three (3) emergency call boxes and the monthly internet communication modem charge on the
kiosks. Maintenance and Service Contracts has been increased primarily for things that need to
be done at Front Beach to f orty thousand three hundred dollars ($40,300); sixty -eight hundred
dollars ($6,800) of the increase will go toward replacing four (4) bollard lights at the County Park
walkway. Twenty -two thousand dollars ($22,000) has been budgeted for Ma chinery and
Equipment Repairs because the City has increased the number of kiosks and the older kiosks are
requiring more extensive repairs; although City staff are making the bulk of the repairs, the parts
are expensive. Professional Services has been increased by eighty-four hundred dollars ($8,400)
to twenty-seven thousand four hundred dollars ($27,400) to include the T2Flex residential parking
permit system subscription along with services related to parking and ticket management and the
armored car se rvice to take the money to the bank. The expense line for Miscellaneous and
Contingency has been increased to seventy-five hundred dollars ($7,500) for unanticipated costs
in the first full year of residential parking permits and automated parking lots.
Public Restrooms/Front Beach/Breach Inlet
As in other departments in the City, the Insurance expense has been increased slightly to thirty-
seven hundred sixty-four dollars ($3,764).
Real Property Committee
April 6, 2016
Page 9 of 10
Beach Restoration Fund Revenue
As discussed before, the City is planning for a renourishment project in the fall of 2016, and the
anticipated sources of revenue are as follows:
Cash donation 8,875,039
$232,610 stakeholder funds on-hand and new ESTIMATED
Contributions of $8,542,429
Grant Income State of South Carolina 2,625,000
FEMA 753,951
Potential Loan Financing for balance of City’s contribution 1,200,000
Transfers in Beach Maintenance Fund 428,596
Beach Preservation Fee Fund 1,224,208
Total Beach Restoration Revenue 15,006,894
Revenue estimated from Year 2 of the Beach Preservation Fee are one million thirty-five thousand
dollars ($1,035,000).
Expenditures proposed to be paid from the Beach Preservation Fee Fund are Debt Service prin-
cipal and interest on a new loan to partially fund the City’s portion of the off-shore dredging project
totally one hundred sixty -eight thousand five hundred dollar s ($168,500). The Professional
Services expenses will include the ongoing monitoring of the island’s shoreline with an extra
monitoring at Breach Inlet if necessary, the re-budget of the comprehensive beach management
plan and a provision for legal fees related to future preservation activities.
Beach Maintenance Fund
Since the money remaining in this fund is expected to be transferred-in to the Beach Restoration
Fund, staff anticipates closing out this fund with the off-shore dredging project.
Administrator Tucker remarked that the biggest question about this initiative is whether or not the
City will have the money and be ready by the fall for it to proceed, and that would create compli-
cations since there are areas that are desperate for sand. The A dministrator recalled that the
City had decided not to do a shoal management project because the City was going to put the
money toward the larger off -shore dredging project, but, if the situation becomes desperate
enough and the City is not going to be able to mobilize soon enough to do the off-shore dredging,
the City may be forced to do the shoal management project, at least for the areas that do not have
wave dissipation devices.
The large spread sheets spread the expenses that have been discussed am ong the funds that
will support them. For the Marina Fund in FY17, forty-one percent (41%) of the expenses will be
covered by tourism funds with the balance coming from the Marina Fund.
For the Front Beach/Public Restrooms/Parking/Breach Inlet/Dune Walkovers/Beach Preservation
and Maintenance, five percent (5%) of the necessary funding will come from tourism funds while
ninety-five percent (95%) will come from the Beach Restoration/Beach Maintenance and Beach
Preservation Fee Fund.
Real Property Committee
April 6, 2016
Page 10 of 10
B. Consideration of Establishing a Property Acquisition Fund
Chair Bergwerf said that there had been dialogue that this should be a line in the budget and
indicated that she was not moved in either direction; if a line were added to the budget, the
possibility existed that citizens would think that the City had some future plans.
Councilmember Rice though t that property acquisitions were not something for Council to be
focused on at this time.
Councilmember Harrington opined that the City should prepare in case an opportunity presents
itself in the future.
The Chair countered that that City has never had a line in the budget for property acquisition
before, but it had acquired property.
In the Administrator’s opinion, the advantage of having it would be that money would be available
if something were to become available.
On the other hand, the Chair c ommented that it would only beco me significant if there is a
considerable sum of money in it. She added that the City is operating very conservatively so
where would this money come from and how would it limit the City to do other things.
Councilmember Rice opined that currently the City was involved in a lot of projects and yet was
not in a position to replace the public restrooms.
7. Miscellaneous Business
All tenants are current with their leases.
Next Meeting Date: 9:00 a.m., Thursday, May 5, 2016 in the Conference Room.
8. Executive Session – not needed
9. Adjournment
MOTION: Councilmember Rice moved to adjourn the meeting at 4:55 p.m.;
Chair Bergwerf seconded, and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.