April 5, 2016 (PDF, 329.27 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of Apr 5, 2016 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
RECREATION COMMITTEE
9:00 a.m., Tuesday, April 5, 2016
The regular meeting of the Recreation Committee was held at 9:00 a.m., Tuesday, April 5, 2016
in the City Hall Conference Room, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South Carolina. Attending
the meeting were Councilmembers Kinghorn and Rice, Chair Carroll, Administrator Tucker,
Recreation Director Page, Assistant Administrator Fragoso and Clerk Copeland; a quorum was
present to conduct business.
1. Chair Carroll called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public were
duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Rice moved to approve the minutes of the regular
meeting of March 1, 2016 as submitted; Chair Carroll seconded.
Councilmember Kinghorn asked to clarify statements attributed to him in the March 1 minutes; he
stated that he believes that space is available in the existing footprint of the Recreation building
to relocate the Cardio Room. As the budget is built each year, he questioned whether the
Department Managers searched out assistance from professionals to make decisions about the
need to replace or maintain/repair an asset for another year or so; he indicated that he would like
to see a more measured process.
Councilmember Rice and Chair Carroll withdrew the motion and second, respectively.
The Committee agreed that Clerk Copeland should re-listen to the tape of the March meeting, but
state the clarifications in the minutes of this meeting; the Committee will defer approval of the
March minutes until the May meeting.
3. Citizens’ Comments – None
4. Departmental Report for March 2016 – Director Page
The Director stated that the Recreation Department is going to celebrate another Island History
Evening where residents can share their interesting experiences before, during and after
Hurricane Hugo; during the evening, the Rec staff will promote the Disaster Expo to be held from
4:00 p.m. til 6:00 p.m., Wednesday, May 18th in the bay of Fire Station 1.
Like the coyote video, Administrator Tucker voiced concern that some stories from Hugo might
not be appropriate for younger children and would only scare them; Director Page said she would
keep that in mind as they move forward with planning.
In March, fifty-three (53) Keenagers attended the group potluck lunch meeting; the next meeting
will be April 6 th. The Front Beach fest was a huge success with approximately two thousand
(2000) people in attendance; staff will closely duplicate the event again next y ear keeping with
the beach music theme that appeared to be the draw this year. For the Egg-cellent Craft Easter
egg decorating activity, the staff boiled egg s the day before for children who saw no reason for
the tool to remove the eggs from the dye when their hands fit into the dye cups just fine.
Recreation Committee
April 5, 2016
Page 2 of 7
The inclement weather brought the annual Easter Egg Hunt into the gym, but it did not dampen
the fun of the fifteen hundred to two thousand (1,500-2,000) attendees. In hindsight, the Director
said that the number of people should have been limited at the door, but, once the lightning and
thunder began, staff was anxious to give everyone shelter quickly.
Summer camp registration began yesterday and will continue through the week for residents.
According to the Director, a man arrived Sunday night with his sleeping bag and pillow and more
people joined him around 3:00 a.m. to ensure that their children got enrolled; by the time the
Director arrived at 6:00 a.m., parents were lined down the sidewalk.
The last Middle School Dance will be held Friday, April 8 th; the Yard Sale will be Saturday, April
23rd; Music in the Park will be Saturday, May 14th from 1:00 p.m. to 4:00 p.m.; and the Sand Sculp-
ting Competition w ill be Saturday, June 4 th beginning at 9:00 a.m. The IOP Beach Run is
scheduled for Saturday, July 16th.
At the Chair’s request, the number of participants for athletics has been added to the report.
Councilmember Kinghorn asked for feedback on receiving the monthly Recreation reports only
electronically and eliminating the paper copies entirely; Assistant Fragoso noted that the report is
usually on the intranet. Until the City purchases tablets for Council, Councilmember Rice wanted
to continue with the status quo.
5. Old Business
A. Update on Departmental Survey
Enclosed in meeting packets was a new version of a survey for the Recreation Department which
has been condensed from the original version. Councilmember Kinghorn brought Survey Monkey
to the Director’s attention as a means of reaching a large group of the island’s population; she
indicated that she would look i nto it. Responding to the Councilmember’s question about the
Department’s email base, Director Page reported that everyone who has registered for an activity
through the RecTrac program and who has signed up for the Department’s e-newsletter is in the
database.
Councilmember Rice suggested distributing the surveys to people at the dog park, who likely are
not in the Rec Trac program.
Related to further discussions on raising money, the Administrator wondered about adding “Would
you be willing to donate funds to the City to expand programs and facilities, and, if so, ple ase
provide contact information” to the survey.
Councilmember Rice suggested asking if residents are aware the Rec Department’s Building
Fund.
Councilmember Kinghorn indicated that such a question could limit funds and would restrict funds
from being used otherwise.
Recreation Committee
April 5, 2016
Page 3 of 7
Administrator Tucker then suggested adding the words “tax deductible” before contribution to
encourage residents.
Councilmember Kinghorn recommended that the survey be more solicitous, such as
Are there areas that we can improve upon?
What could we do differently? or
How can we serve you better?
B. Further Discussion of Funding Opportunities
Director Page had asked for this to be on the agenda because she did not think she had a clear
directive from the Committee on what she was being asked to do.
Councilmember Kinghorn asked the Director to benchmark some of her peers in what they do to
raise non -tax dollars and n on-program registration dollars, be it grants, private contributions,
foundations, etc., and what success or experience they have had. The goal being to raise more
non-City funds to improve and enhance programs.
C. Discussion of Inclement Weather Policy for Recreation Events
Director Page stated that having a policy that would fit every situation was difficult; for athletics,
the half rubber tournament, the beach run, the Department uses “rain -out hotline,” which is very
beneficial because one only has to sign up for the service to receive a text notification if the event
has been rained out. For the Holiday Street Festival and the Island Beach fest, staff always
makes sure that Windjammer is available to house the band, but getting volunteers and vendors
to come back on a rain date is very difficult; every effort is made to hold the event as scheduled.
Councilmember Kinghorn asked what the Recreation staff had concluded they would do
differently in another weather event like the one that occurred for the Easter Egg Hunt.
Primarily the Director replied that they would have to control the number of people entering the
front door, and, in her opinion, they waited a bit late to do that. When they did try, the lightning
and thunder started and they wanted to get everyone out of harm’s way as quickly as possible.
Responding to Chair Carroll, the maximum number of people allowed in the gym at one time is
six hundred seventy-five (675); so by moving people down the hallway the overcrowding thinned
out. When reviewing the footage from the cameras, the Director could see that people had
congregated near the door, leaving more room at the rear of the gym than people realized. Since
classes were going on in the other rooms, they were unavailable at the time.
Complaints that Councilmember Kinghorn heard were that peop le had not been notified that no
egg hunt would be offered in the building.
Administrator Tucker remarked that notification of that sort could be on the event posters, saying
that “in case of rain, fun and games will be in the gym, but no egg hunt.”
Since it was not raining at 9:30 a.m., Director Page was anticipating a lot of people to attend.
Recreation Committee
April 5, 2016
Page 4 of 7
In the thirty-nine (39) years that Director Page has staged an Easter Egg Hunt, this year was only
the second time that an event has been rained on; Administrator Tucker added that it may be only
the third event that has been dampened by rain.
Councilmember Kinghorn opined that having a Rec staff member outside in the line
communicating with people and giving out candy or water as an act of customer service would
have lessened the anxiety.
6. New Business
A. Review of FY17 Operating Budget, foreshadowing staffing
Administrator Tucker pointed out that column H should read FY16-17, not FY15-16.
An item not included in this version of the budget and that will be presented to the Personnel
Committee is the addition of Parks and Facilities Specialist position who would be responsible for
the maintenance and general upkeep of all of the City’s proper ties and buildings. The evidence
of having a person responsible for the property and not having a person responsible is quite
evident when looking at the Recreation Center versus the Front Beach, for example. In addition,
this person would supervise the City’s contracts like landscaping, elevator maintenance, general
housekeeping, etc. and plan for replacements for future budgets; currently the City takes care of
these matters reactively, and often the repairs/maintenance become more costly because they
have been allowed to go on too long with no one intervening.
The obvious place to put this person would appear to be the Public Works Department, but they
are already overtaxed in the growing season that coincides with the height of garbage and debris
season; since the Recreation Department has success with grounds and buildings, the decision
was to have this position fall under Director Page’s supervision.
When Chair Carroll said that he would like to compare IOP with other comparable local
governments as to staffing, the Administrator replied that she would do so, but that it would be
difficult to find a similar sized municipality that was also a tourist mecca that always wants to
present itself in the best possible light all of the time.
Councilmember Rice stated that the City “desperately needed this position;” she re ported being
on Front Beach recently and had found the condition of the benches to be “embarrassing.”
Director Page agreed that the City needed this position and indicated that she would welcome
this person to her team that often assists the Public Works Department with cutting the rights-of-
way, cleaning beach accesses, etc.
As to City contracts with outside vendors, the right person in this position would maximize those
contracts insuring that the City was getting what it was paying for or finding out why and correcting
the work. This person would know of things to be added, deleted or changed in a contract so that
the end result was the best for the City at the lowest cost.
Recreation Committee
April 5, 2016
Page 4 of 7
Globally for all departments, the following changes are included:
a three percent (3%) wage adjustment is presented that consists of a one percent (1%)
cost of living adjustment and a two percent (2%) merit increase;
a one percent (1%) increase to the group health insurance;
the fuel calculation is based on the last two (2) years average amount paid and the last
twelve (12) months actual usage; and
property and liability insurance have been increased by five percent (5%), and flood
insurance has been increased by fifteen percent (15%).
Administrator Tucker reiterated that the impact of this person would not be added to the budget
until approved by the Perso nnel Committee. They will be presented with a total of four (4)
positions, with job descriptions and potential budgetary impacts upon which to decide; if approved,
some or all will be included in the next version of the budget.
Hypothetically, Councilmember Kinghorn asked what the Recreation Department would do if the
budget were to be frozen.
The Administrator explained that she has dealt with that situation twice at the Isle of Palms; once
with the economic downturn and another time when she was concer ned about tracking over
budget and informed the Department Managers not to send purchase orders to City Hall for
approval until spending leveled off. The downside of freezing salaries is that the City begins to
lose people and filling vacancies is expensive or service delivery suffers because that vacancy is
not filled.
A second scenario presented by Councilmember Kinghorn was to freeze the budget, not to have
Council decide upon each line but rather allow the Administrator and Department Manager to
make those decisions. If that were done, could they find savings in the expenses to still provide
a two percent (2%) merit pool for employees.
Administrator Tucker acknowledged that it would be tough since the City budgets so conserv a-
tively, but a special activity could be cut.
Councilmember Kinghorn thought that a capital project could be delayed and the funds necessary
for employee increases could be transferred in from the Capital Projects fund; he thought that
was the cleanest way to handle the pro blem. He indicated that this was a reason that he
continued to look for alternative sources of money – expenses were only going to continue to rise;
therefore, he was looking for a way to incentivize Department Managers to generate more
revenue outside the norm.
An addition to the Capital Projects Budget for the Recreation Department is a generator and
transfer switch for ninety thousand dollars ($90,000) that would be partially offset by a hazard
mitigation grant of sixty-seven thousand five hundred dollars ($67, 500). The need for alternate
power at the Recreation Center was brought to the City’s attention when it went through the
earthquake exercise; since the building now does not have a generator, its use was limited in the
aftermath of the disaster.
Recreation Committee
April 5, 2016
Page 6 of 6
The remaining budget pages illustrate what funds will be paying for other capital items.
Municipal Accommodations Fee Fund
4 outdoor basketball goals $18,000
Playground or exterior scoreboard equip. 10,000
As needed
50% of replacement soccer field lights 62,300
State Accommodations Tax Fund
Replace outdoor water fountain 5,000
Special activities 51,000
Capital Purchases Fund
Replace golf cart 5,000
Replace outdoor water fountain 5,000
Replace 11 HVAC units in Expansion, 30,000
(only with failure)
50% of replacement soccer field lights 62,500
Replace baseball field fencing 15,000
Replace 4 outdoor basketball goals & posts 18,000
Generator & transfer switch 90,000
The final page shows the full Recreation Department FY17 proposed budget s pread by funding
source; the box at the bottom of the page indicates that eighty-five percent (85%) is expected to
come from the General and Capital Pro jects Fund and the remaining fifteen percent (15%) is to
come from the tourism funds.
B. Award of a contract for an artificial holiday tree for Front Beach
Director Page stated that she had gotten three (3) written quotes, but she had found it difficult to
get like-for-like products due to a difference in the type of lights used; the quotes came from
Display Sales, Barry Minors, Inc. and Downtown Decorations. After talking with the vendors and
comparing the products, she recommended that the contract go to Display Sales at $16,999.76.
The Administrator pointed out that sales tax does not appear to be applied in looking at the quote;
Director Page assured her that the price was all encompassing. Director Page said that she
would contact the vendor and get a new quote.
MOTION: Chair Carroll moved to award a contract to Display Sales for one
holiday tree at $16,999.76 including sales taxes ; Councilmember Kinghorn
seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
7. Miscellaneous Business
Councilmember Kinghorn commented that, on Recreation programs, any time that it does not
generate net revenue, it is deficit spending; therefore, the goal should be, when a program is run,
Recreation Committee
April 5, 2016
Page 7 of 7
to get net revenu e gain which helps to build that program, serve other citizens and stay in the
black.
Councilmember Rice stated that the value of the programs is more than monetary and that
everything could not be measured financially.
Director Page reported that the athletic programs all pay for themselves because there is a
registration fee and sponsorships.
Councilmember Kinghorn notified the Committee that he would be out of the country in May.
The Director stated that her idea of a recreation center was to pro vide opportunities, not neces-
sarily paying for everything that is done.
Next Meeting Date: 9:00 a.m., Wednesday, May 4 in the Conference Room.
8. Adjournment
MOTION: Councilmember Kinghorn moved to adjourn the meeting at 10:34
a.m.; Councilmember Rice seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.