March 3, 2016 (PDF, 329.12 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of Mar 3, 2016 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE
9:30 a.m., Thursday, March 3, 2016
The regular meeting of the Public Safety Committee was called to order at 9:30 a.m., Thursday,
March 3, 2016 in the City Hall Conference Room, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South
Carolina. Attending the meeting were Councilmembers Bergwerf and Carro ll, Chair Bettelli,
Administrator Tucker, Fire Chief Graham, Police Chief Buckhannon, Assistant Administrator
Fragoso and Clerk Copeland; a quorum was present to conduct business.
1. Chair Bettelli called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public had
been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Bergwerf moved to approve the minutes of the
regular meeting of February 8, 2016 as submitted; Councilmember Carroll seconded
and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments
Elizabeth Campsen, 32 Intracoastal Court, addressed the Committee about the managed beach
access parking plan as it relates to her neighborhood; she explained that Intracoastal Court
intersects with Waterway Boulevard close to 41 st Avenue. Over the past three ( 3) years, the
overflow marina parking has become an issue , and many in the general neighborhood have
become very upset about the parking on Waterway bec ause that is their only way out of their
neighborhood. She stated that she has seen parking as far down on Waterway as 25 th Avenue.
She indicated that she had tried to calm her neighbors with the idea that the Option C parking
plan would be in effect this summer and it would designate their area as residential only parking,
solving their problems. When the sign plan was presented, she saw that the City would not be
placing “Resident Only” parking signs on Waterway Boulevard. Representing her neighborhood,
she asked that the City reconsider “resident only” signs there. She indicated that she had read
the ordinance and the reasons for instituting the plan, and all of them apply to her street. She
quoted from Section 8-2-22 of the Ordinance that states
“City Council has determined after a traffic survey of the residential areas of the City and
after a public hearing, that such areas are severely impacted by nonresident parking along
the rights-of-way of the streets by reason of adjacent beach and commercial uses.”
Mrs. Campsen said that she had closely followed the ATM progress on the marina redevelopment
plan, paid special attention to Section 4, Parking, and found it to be “woefully inadequate .” She
stated that she and her neighbors feel “that the City is turning a blind eye to the needs of residents
to get that area under control.” She added that, according to the City Code, there is not sufficient
parking at the marin a for the tenants that ar e there now. The ATM calculations of the current
spaces is less for vehicles and boat trailers, and their proposal going forward is less than the
Code recommendation. Mrs. Campsen said that they look at the cars and trailers every day in
season; she comm ented that she does not see how less parking in a redevelop ed area would
help. She stated that enforcement of the Code as to her residential area and a sign would help
to limit it; it might encourage/force the tenants there to abide by the zoning laws and parking
regulations for their businesses and keep their patrons on-site.
Public Safety Committee
March 3, 2016
Page 2 of 9
In addition, Mrs. Campsen reported seeing speeding, bad behavior and many intoxicated persons
in the same area where children are skating, riding bikes, playing ball, etc.; the parking is a public
safety issue for these residents.
4. Old Business
A. Discussion of Encroachments on Rights-of-way
Chief Buckhannon stated that, legally, property owners should get encroachment per mits from
SCDOT to put landscaping, trees, sculpture, etc. in the right -of-way; he estimated that ninety to
ninety-five percent (90-95%) of the island’s encroachments are not permitted.
Administrator Tucker stated that the City always advises people tha t an encroachment permit is
necessary; when a member of the City staff sees a new encroachment going in for which there is
no encroachment p ermit on file, the City informs the owner that he must have an SCDOT
encroachment permit. The typical things that SCDOT will permit are ingress and egress and low
vegetation that would not prohibit a car from rolling over it since the rights-of-way are designed
for cars to pull out of the lane of travel if there is a problem. Therefore, anything that inhibits the
ability to do that is not something they typically permit on the side of the road. There are
encroachments on the island that have been in place for years, and they all need to be removed
for safety reasons and fairness.
Chief Buckhannon recalled that several years ago the City took the stance that it would go after
new encroachments, but the old would be left alone. Property owners with new encroachme nts
are warned that they must get a permit or the encroachment must be removed; they are given
thirty (30) days to do so; the City will also assist the owner with the encroachment application. If
the encroachment is not removed after thirty (30) days, the property owner can get a citation. If
the property owner has applied for the encroachment permit, but it does not arrive in the thirty
(30) day window, they can be given a thirty (30) day extension.
Councilmember Carroll asked if there was a cutoff date when the City would not require the
removal of right -of-way encroachments; the Chief recalled that Council had made the decision
about two (2) years ago, and, at that time, pictures were taken of all the encroachments on the
island. In a follow-up question, the Councilmember asked what agency has enforcement authority
on this issue, and the City Administrator stated that both the City and SCDOT have the authority.
Administrator Tucker explained that , in an unincorporated area , SCDOT has the authority to
require the removal of encroachments in the right -of-way; in practice, they send a “Deficiency
Notice” stating that a property owner has encroachments in the right -of-way that are deficient to
their standards and the property owner is required to remove them in a certain space of time. In
tandem with the City, SCDOT has the authority to do it here as well, and, since they are SCDOT
rights-of-way, they should be more vigilant in ensuring that they are left clear. In the road
agreement with the municipalities, the statement is included that the City will help to keep the
rights-of-way free of obstru ctions; the problem is that the road agreements are all different
depending on when the road was constructed.
Public Safety Committee
March 3, 2016
Page 3 of 9
Councilmember Carroll said that he has driven all of the side streets from 3 rd to 9th Avenue and
seen such diversity of what people can and cannot do – some rights-of-way are too narrow to
allow parking and others are landscaped to the edge of the road.
Councilmember Bergwerf reiterated her opinion that it is an unsolvable problem.
Chair Bettelli stated that, over the years, some residents have said that they would sue the city if
it tried to force them to remove the right-of-way obstruction.
According to Councilmember Carroll, from 44 th to 57 th Avenues on the ocean -side, there is
sidewalk and palm trees, and there is not enough room to park between the sidewalk and the
road, and it is illegal to drive across the sidewalk to park. From 41 st to 44 th, the sidewalk is
attached to the road but can be used to pull off the road and to park in the grassy area.
Chair Bettelli said that this would continue to be a topic of discussion at meetings, and he asked
that any time a Committee member sees an encroachment going in to notify the Building
Department.
Administrator Tucker recalled that, in 2007, pictures were taken of all the encroachments on the
island, and they were cat egorized according to safety; they were categorized from completely
unsafe to relatively minor and easily remedied. When Council saw the pictures, they backed off
from requiring that all be removed.
Councilmember Carroll reported that he had received multiple calls in the past week about no
signage for resident only parking on Waterway Boulevard in the area of the marina and 41 st
Avenue.
The Administrator recalled that three (3) areas of the island intentionally were not included in
resident-only parking, i.e. Breach Inlet, the Recreation Center and the area around the marina.
Since Council could not reach a consensus on how to handle these areas and because the
discussions were holding up progress on the parking plan for other areas of the island , Council
chose not to include them in an area of resident-only parking and to address them separately at
a later date.
Councilmember Bergwerf noted that an ordinance change would be required for Council to go
back now and make Waterway Boulevard resident-only parking.
The Administrator urged the Committee not to make any changes to the beach access parking
plan ordinance; she stated that changes need to be made as an “after -action” – to live through
this season and then go through the ordinance thoroughly to ensure that every issue is addressed.
B. Updates Related to Coyotes
Administrator Tucker announced that the City has hired a trapper who has set one (1) trap in the
Breach Inlet area based on the photograph of the four (4) coyotes on the beach, and the City has
received notification that Wild Dunes has also hired a trapper.
Public Safety Committee
March 3, 2016
Page 4 of 9
Councilmember Carroll asked about enforcing the ordinance on overgrown lots, and he was told
that the enforcement process has already started.
In her travels around the island, Councilmember Bergwerf noted that the island not only had some
overgrown lots, but also areas of intended vegetation that could also become habitats for the
coyotes. She added that part of the problem is people feeding their pets outside and allowing
animals to be out overnight. For those who do leave their animals out, the trap is as likely to catch
the pet as a coyote; she asked what could be done to encourage people to follow these simple
steps.
The Administrator said that people have to be willing to listen and get the message about the
facts; she commented that p eople need to do the things that make the coyotes unwelcome
because that is the way to get control them.
According to Chief Buckhannon, if an area is known to be an issue, like at Breach Inlet, a trap is
put in that area; he confirmed that the City will not put traps on private property. The City’s website
has a link to the DNR website where someone can find a list of professional trappers.
C. Status of Rescue Pumper
Chief Graham reported that she had gone to E-1 on Tuesday afternoon to inspect the new rescue
pumper; a coupl e of minor things were found that need to be changed. The City should take
ownership in a two to three (2 -3) of weeks. When other people were around to inspect their
equipment, they made very positive comments about the IOP truck; Chief Graham stated that she
believes the truck will serve the City well for many years.
When the old truck was put out to bid, Awendaw had the highest bid at twenty-eight thousand one
hundred dollars ($28,100). Awendaw has asked to take possession of the truck now rather than
wait until the new truck arrives; if the City were to have a need for it, Awendaw would respond
through mutual aid.
The Administrator indicated that the deal would be consummated in the next couple of days.
D. Status of the Connector Camera
Chief Buckhannon announced that the Connector camera will be live on Monday, March 7 th.
Administrator Tucker reported that, over the course of a year, the City had spent eighteen hundred
dollars ($1,800) more than anticipated to make the camera operational.
Administrator Tucker announced that the mayors of the three (3) East Cooper communities ar e
working in joint advocacy to the County to fund and p ut up cameras on the approaches to the
islands.
Following-up on Councilmember Carroll’s comments on social media, Administrator Tucker
agreed that people pay attention to Twitter, which is very helpful to get information out quickly; in
addition, Mount Pleasant and Charleston re-tweet the City’s Twitter announcements. The feed
from the IOP Connector camera will be added to SCDOT’s SC511 service.
Public Safety Committee
March 3, 2016
Page 5 of 9
E. Discussion of Additional Crosswalks on Palm Boulevard
Chair Bettelli reported that the City has five (5) crosswalks between 21st and 41st Avenues.
Chief Buckhannon stated that SCDOT would not allow the City to have crosswalks at every
corner; when there are too many crosswalks, they become ineffective. If the City wanted to add
a crosswalk between 28th and 34th Avenues, the Chief recommended that it be at 31st Avenue to
follow a theme of a crosswalk about every three (3) blocks.
Administrator Tucker stated that staff needs to know whether it should contact SCDOT to paint a
crosswalks there or the City proceed with painting or a stamped crosswalk on the pavement.
Chief Buckhannon indicated that, if the crosswalk were to be in for this beach season, the City
would have to absorb the expense if it were only to be a painted crosswalk with signs put up; he
was not inclined to think that SCDOT would respond to the City’s request in time. The Chief
opined that the City could get the encroachment permit in thirty (30) days.
Chair Bettelli suggested that the City paint the lines this year and budget for the stamped cross -
walk next year.
MOTION: Councilmember Carroll moved to proceed with an encroachment
permit and painting lines for a crosswalk at 31st Avenue; Councilmember Bergwerf
seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
F. Body-worn Camera Policy
Chief Buckhannon stated that the City has a policy that was re-written in the past thirty (30) days;
the re-write met the requirements of CALEA and the City’s insurance carrier, and it was approved
by the South Carolina Criminal Justice Academy Training Council pursuant to state law. With this
process completed, the City is in-line for any available funding; the next step will be applying for
funding to purchase or be reimbursed for the equipment.
Responding to Councilmember Carroll, the Chief reported that the City has twenty (20) cameras;
five (5) of which are worn out. All officers on the road wear body cameras, and based on the wear
and the environment, the cameras only have a three-year (3 yrs.) lifespan. The cameras must be
manually activated, and an officer is to have the camera on when engaging with the public or on
a call.
Administrator Tucker explained that the handheld ticket devices recently purchased are going to
be exchanged with a model that uses small iPads for capturing information.
5. New Business
A. Review of Ten-year Capital Plan
Since members of this Committee have heard the presentation on the preparation of the Capital
Plan, the Administrator has chosen not to repeat it.
Public Safety Committee
March 3, 2016
Page 6 of 9
B. Review of FY17 Capital Budget
Fire Department
Administrator Tucker recounted that Chief Graham has voiced concerns to her and the City
Treasurer that certain fire apparatus might not last until the year they are scheduled to be
replaced; the entire fleet suffered from being in tents or temporary facilities or outside during the
period that personnel had to be outside the fire stations. The replacement dates were established
before that situation occurred and then, in 2015, there was Joaquin and the Fire Department had
to respond to a fire call in the middle of the storm. Those trucks that had already suffered outside
are no w suffering fr om post -Joaquin effects. The trucks are well -maintained and have had
repairs, but they continue to deteriorate.
The Administrator opined that, in budget discussions, Chief Graham would have moved more
equipment forward to be replaced sooner on the Capital Plan than the City would be able to afford
to do; the Committee was made aware of this because there could be a failure or trucks out of
service or increased maintenance costs to keep them going.
Chief Graham reported that Engine 1, the newest fire apparatus in the fleet, had broken down on
I-26 and was being towed to the shop in North Charleston. She commented that they have been
experiencing a lot of electrical problems on a repeated basis for the past couple of years, and
they attribute them to the trucks being kept outside for an extended period of time.
Responding to Chair Bettelli’s comment, Administrator Tucker reported that the Fire Department
seeks grants every year, but is usually put out of the running by needy communities with fewer
resources than the Isle of Palms.
The Chief stated that she has engaged the mechanic to go over each truck in detail and to predict
the remaining useful life.
The Administrator directed attention to the shaded area at the top of the Fire Department Capital
Plan where she reported that the anticipated purchase price of the replacement pumper truck
purchased in 2003 was increased upward by ninety -nine thousand dollars ($99,000) ; another
change was made to the 2003 ladder truck with an increase to the replacement cost of two
hundred seventy-four thousand dollars ($274,000). The annual set aside for these assets will be
increased accordingly. The 2004 ladder truck has been moved from FY20 to FY19, and the
replacement cost has been increased by one hundred forty-eight thousand dollars ($148,000).
Although they are hard to find, Chief Graham will try to replace these apparatus with
demonstration vehicles to keep the costs down.
Two (2) 2008 Ford pickup trucks are being deferred for the third year and the 2010 pickup is being
deferred for the first time.
Radios for the Fire Department are budgeted for three hundred ninety -nine thousand dollars
($399,000), but the City has been putting funds aside for several years for this purchase.
Public Safety Committee
March 3, 2016
Page 7 of 9
Addition of 1 Ford F-150 $23,000
Both Trainer and Inspector have dedicated vehicles
Normal replacements:
Thermal imaging camera 12,000
Ram extrication device 5,000
To have a set at both stations
Replace 2 Yamaha jet skis 13,000
Stretching useful life to 4 years
Replace small Avon rubber boat & motor deferred to FY18
RAD-57 oxygen & carbon monoxide monitor 5,000
only with failure
2nd set of cutters for vehicle rescue 6,000
new cars made of heavier steel and current cutters do not penetrate
**Estimate for wireless signal boosting for MDTs 23,000
Retainage on PSB construction contract 15,000
**When the City joined the Consolidated Dispatch, the equivalent of laptops were installed in the
vehicles, and, for the Fire Department, what they are hearing is also being keyed in as a visual of
the same information that was spoken . The devices operate on a wireless system, similar to
phones; the laptops in the fire apparatus go to sleep and are disconnected from the system,
requiring them to reconnect to the wireless signal and perform the full security log on.
Chief Graham reported that, in using a demonstrator for the past six (6) months, only once did
the MDT (mobile data terminal) log off. She added that this purchase would be a one -time
expense.
Chief Buckhannon stated that the large apparatus shield the signal, and, when they are in the fire
bay, the building shields the signal even more. Although there are dead spots on the island, the
MDTs for the Police Department are constantly moving.
Under Special Projects are the savings for both equipment and the FY17 allocation for the radios.
Police Department
The Police Department FY17 Capital Budget includes the replacement of one (1) patrol car and
one (1) four -wheel drive patrol vehicle. Being on a three -year (3 yrs.) replacement cycle, the
computer server with backup system has rolled forward at a cost of twelve thousand dollars
($12,000). The purchase of departmental radios will be three hundred fifty thousand dollars
($350,000) including the FY17 savings addition of fifty-eight thousand three hundred thirty-three
dollars ($58,333). The only item under Special Projects is seventeen thousand dollars ($17,000)
for a new body camera system; Chief Buckhannon reported that the new camera system has a
robotics system built into it that will automatically burn one (1) or more DVDs as requested. The
City can also apply for state grants that will reimburse a portion of the expense.
6. Highlights of Departmental Reports
Public Safety Committee
March 3, 2016
Page 8 of 9
Fire Department
Personnel responded to a call on February 8 th on Barnacle Row where a man had fallen
approximately thirty feet (30 ft.) from a ladder; the patient was transported to a local trauma center.
On February 24 th, personnel responded to a call of debris washing ashore at Breach Inlet and
numerous pieces of boat wreckage were found, collected and taken to Fire Station 1; the
Charleston County Sheriff’s Office and the U.S. Coast Guard searched the waters around both
islands and offshore for signs of a boat mishap, but nothing was found. The situation is under
investigation. In the month, personnel responded to a total of forty (40) calls; nineteen (19) were
EMS calls. Twenty-six (26) fire inspections were performed, and ten (10) violations were cited.
All career personnel participated in driver and pump oper ator training, officer exam preparation
and response protocol review. Vehicle maintenance costs were relatively higher this month due
to the replacement of a fuel pump on Engine 1002 at more than sixty-six hundred dollars ($6,600)
and the replacement of the steering gear box assembly on a ladder truck for approximately twenty-
five hundred dollars ($2,500).
Chief Graham reported that Bill Jenkins was retiring after thirty -five years (35 yrs.) of volunteer
service to the IOP Fire Department. Seth Bacon was promoted to Captain, and Jeff Stickney was
promoted to Engineer to fill Captain Bacon’s previous position.
Police Department
In the early hours of February 20th, officers responded to a call of three (3) subjects attempting to
break into a car; with the aid of a Sullivan’s Island police officer and two (2) County Sheriff’s
Deputies, a perimeter was established and the three (3) suspects were arrested. During an
interview with one (1) of the suspects, he stated that they had come to IOP to break int o cars
because “they are always unlocked and have valuables inside.” Command Staff commends Pfc.
Storen for being selected as the Officer of the Quarter for the third quarter of 2015 by the South
Carolina Law Enforcement Network; he conducted a total of t wo hundred fifty (250) traffic stops
that resulted in nine (9) arrests for Driving Under the Influence. The Chief noted that Pfc. Storen
consistently leads the Department in DUI arrests; he made forty-seven (47) such arrests in 2015.
In addition, the Com mand Staff recognizes Tracy Waldron who fulfills multiple roles in the
Department; she is the Administrative Assistant to Chief Buckhannon and also handles records
requests from the public and attorney s, supplies various reports as requested, and assists the
Communication Specialists in the Reception Office. On February 2nd, FTO Maloney went to the
IOP Recreation Department for a “Kids & Cops” session; he talked about safety and participated
in arts and crafts with the children. Sgt. Meekins, ACO Enourato, BSO Skinner and BSO Tyson
attended Doggie Day at the Rec and sold sixty -nine (69) dog licenses. P fc. Amanda Postell
attended a “K ids & Cops” session at the Rec where she talked about bike safety and took the
children outside to instruct them in riding safety.
In the month of February, the Communication Specialists responded to four thousand fifty -three
(4,053) calls, and three thousand two hundred thirty -seven (3,237) calls were for the Police
Department. Officers made two hundred fifty -one (251) traffic stops, and seventy -four (74) of
them received tickets. Twenty-seven (27) arrests were made in February for a variety of offenses;
Animal Control wrote four (4) citations and seven (7) warning tickets. With the rapid onset of the
Public Safety Committee
March 3, 2016
Page 9 of 9
season, training hours are dwindling. Thirty -three (33) coyote sightings were reported in the
month, and they were primarily in Wild Dunes.
When discussing the recruit ment of BSOs for the summer, Elizabeth Campsen suggested that
the City contact Operation Palmetto Employment that helps veterans find jobs.
7. Miscellaneous Business
Next Meeting Date: 9:00 a.m., Wednesday, April 6th in the City Hall Conference Room
8. Executive Session – not needed
9. Adjourn
MOTION: Councilmember Carroll moved to adjourn the meeting at 11:32 a.m.;
Chair Bettelli seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.