March 3, 2016 (PDF, 240.8 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of Mar 3, 2016 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
REAL PROPERTY COMMITTEE
2:00 p.m., Thursday, March 3, 2016
The regular meeting of the Real Property Committee was called to order at 2:00 p.m. on Thursday,
March 3, 2016 in the City Hall Conference Room, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South
Carolina. Attending the meeting were Councilmembers Harrington and R ice, Chair Bergwerf,
Administrator Tucker, Assistant Administrator Fragoso and Clerk Copeland; a quorum was
present to conduct business.
1. Chair Bergwerf called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public
had been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Rice moved to approve the minutes of the regular
meeting of February 8, 2016 as submitted; Councilmember Harrington seconded
and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments – None
4. Comments from Marina Tenants
Since ATM has made the presentation of their concept for the future of the marina that does not
contemplate the relocation of any structures, Jay Clarke o f Morgan Creek Grill reported to the
Committee that he was in the process of getting pricing for an elevator at the restaurant that would
go from the ground level to the top deck.
The City is in receipt of the draft noise control agreement, and the Administrator gave Mr. Clarke
a copy to review prior to his leaving. The Administrator noted that, when the noise ordinance was
passed, the following phrase was added to Section 9-2-5(a)(3), Loudspeakers, etc:
“. . . provided, however, that any City-owned property subject to a commercial lease and
a noise control agreement or permit is exempt from the requirements of this paragraph.”
Now that the time period has passed for Morgan Creek Grill’s designation as a City -sponsored
event to test their sound mitigation system and to have outdoor music, they must sign this new
agreement with the City.
Mr. Clarke indicated that, once the lease extension has been signed, he will be ready to proceed
with fencing to camouflage the dumpsters; for the time being, they have been relocated.
5. Old Business
Update on FEMA Project Worksheets related to 2 Category G Projects
Administrator Tucker commented that the City has two (2) projects that fall under FEMA’s
Category G for parks and open spaces; the damage related to the beach received from Joaquin
falls into this category. The two (2) projects that qualify are the 49 th Avenue beach access that
needs to be repaired and the portion of the sand loss related to Joaquin that occurred on the
Real Property Committee
March 3, 2016
Page 2 of 8
northeast end of the island; the FEMA reimbursement will be seventy -five percent (75%) of the
eligible costs. Additionally the Administrator explained that a FEMA project worksheet is the
equivalent of getting a grant commitment.
When asked about timing, Administrator Tucker stated that the 49th Avenue project could be done
rather quickly once the City has the guarantee of FEMA’s participation at seve nty-five percent
(75%). The major offshore dredging project is being planned for the fall of 2016, but there is a lot
of work to be done to make that target.
7. New Business
A. Discussion of kayak landing/pocket parks/viewing station of Hammock
Island
Referring to the materials in the meeting packet from the McDowells, t he Administrator thought
this was a nice idea for the island. The residents are advocating for the City to try to get some
viewing destinations for the Hammock Islands on the island; the complication is that all of the sites
identified by these residents are on private property. The City would, therefore, have to get the
cooperation of the property owners to do what they are suggesting.
Chair Bergwerf commented that the City is in the middle of the planning for the marina, but she
indicated that her first reaction was that Dewees residents would not like the idea of a kayak
landing.
Councilmember Rice suggested that the space at the ends of 11 th and 25th Avenues might be
suitable for a kayak landing spot.
Administrator Tucker stated that the more public spaces the City creates, the more public spaces
the City must maintain, and she acknowledged that the more passive areas are lacking in
maintenance.
Councilmember Rice thought that this issue should move to the Personnel Committe e for them
to consider hiring someone to be responsible for such areas in the City.
If that were to happen, the City might want to add language about supervising contracts, because
the City would cont inue to need some contracts, and need someone with mo re global
responsibility to manage those contracts and make regular visits to the City sites and monitor the
care they are getting.
When Chair Bergwerf asked about other possible spaces on the island, the Administrator noted
that there are properties on the island belonging to the Beach Company that they would divest
themselves of because they have approached the City in the past about them. One (1) su ch
space is a small boat launch/landing at the end of 17th Avenue.
Chair Bergwerf stated that , at a sp ace like that, the City would have to provide some kind of
parking.
Real Property Committee
March 3, 2016
Page 3 of 8
Councilmember Rice stated th at her understanding of these po cket parks is that they are
completely passive and that people are more likely to bike or walk to them.
The Chair suggested reaching out to Wild Dunes with the idea.
B. Discussion of Boat Ramp on Palm Boulevard
City staff typically refers to this boat ramp as the Breach Inlet boat ramp; the Administrator opined
that it would be a C-grade ramp in that only boats of a certain size could use it. In order for people
to use it, they must present proof of ownership and insurance and buy a key; the fee for one (1)
calendar year is one hundred dollars ($100) for residents and two hundred dollars ($200) for non-
residents. The ramp gets little public use by the key holders, but it is the primary water entry point
for Fire Department personnel at that end of the island. This ramp comes up on the Capital Plan
for replacement in FY17.
Chair Bergwerf pointed out that the ramp is critical to the well-being of residents and visitors to
the City, but she thought that the City should not encourage the purchase of keys.
C. Review of Ten-year Capital Plan
Indicating that the budgets for this Committee were the most difficult to generate, the
Administrator said that, between the ATM marina work product and the upcoming beach
renourishment, it was important for staff to get something on paper that would enable dialogue
without suggesting that there is only one (1) way to accomplish them.
For the discussion of beach restoration, the Committee has a handout with several funding
scenarios as well as the proposed FY17 Capital Budget. The A dministrator indicated t hat this
subject is one (1) that Councilmembers need to be familiar with for the Wild Dunes Community
Association (WDCA) meeting coming soon; Coastal Science and Engineering (CSE) will be
making a presentation at the WDCA meeting.
The beginning number on the handout is CSE’s estimate of the cost for the off -shore dredging
project; the next number is the a mount the City estimates coming from FEMA; the remaining
balance must be funded by the City and the stakeholders.
The first funding distribution mirrors the percentage shares of the participants for the 2008 project
applied to the cost of the proposed project after the FEMA grant; contributors to that project were
the City, the State of South Carolina, Charleston County and the private stakeholders. In t his
scenario, the City would be responsible for two million eight hundred fifty thousand ten dollars
($2,850,010), which it does not have, and the stakeholders’ share would be nine million four
hundred five thousand thirty-two dollars ($9,405,032) with the balance of one million nine hundred
ninety-five thousand seven dollars ($1,995,007) to come from the State and from Charleston
County – neither of which has yet agreed to participate. Recently, these same stakeholders have
paid for their own sand, sandbags, repeatedly, and wave dissipation devices to try to protect their
properties.
Real Property Committee
March 3, 2016
Page 4 of 8
The issue to be addressed in the FY17 budget is the source(s) of funds for the City’s share of a
project possibly in the fall of 2016; the City budgeted approximately six hundred twenty -one
thousand dollars ($621,000) in the FY16 budget that will not be spent, but will roll over to FY17.
A portion of the remaining funds would include one hundred percent (100%) of the June 30, 2016
ending balances from the Beach Preservation Fee Fund and the Beach Maintenance Fund
totaling one million thirty -two thousand dollars ($1,032,000); the balance of approximately one
million two hundred thousand dollars ($1,200,000) could come from a bank loan. When
contemplating this project in the past, consideration was not given to exhausting the Beach
Preservation Fee Fund or the Beach Maintenance Fund.
Administrator Tucker recounted to the Committee that the City had borrowed the money for its
share of the 2008 project, and the same could be done again. The debt was paid back primarily
with taxes collected from Wild Dunes.
Currently, the City is holding two hundred thirty -two thousand six hundred dollars ($232,600) of
stakeholder funds that were left from the 2008 project, making the amount to be paid by them at
approximately nine million one hundred seventy-two thousand four hundred dollars ($9,172,400).
According to the Administrator, FEMA has four (4) other South Carolina shoreline entit ies who
will have project worksheets; they are City of Edisto, Edisto State Park, Hunting Island and Hilton
Head. The City might be able to justify another project worksheet for mitigating further damages
like these buildings sustained by putting together a hazard mitigation project and increasing the
federal participation which is fifty-fifty (50/50) money. She added that, if the state were to put
together a hazard mitigation project for the state’s shoreline damages, the City could see the
benefit of th at; the problem is that she recalls a stipulation that an entity cannot award any
contracts until it gets the grant award. Any project would have to be fast-tracked and put together
quickly.
When Chair Bergwerf asked how the Governor’s forty million do llars ($40,000,000) would figure
into the picture assuming it survives the budget process, the Administrator noted that again match
money would be required. Although forty million dollars ($40,000,000) is a lot of money, it is a
“drop in the bucket” when it comes to beach restoration for the entire state shoreline. The
Administrator noted that there is more listening and more championing of the state’s beaches now
than she has ever seen before; Senator Campsen has taken a leadership role.
Attention was shifted to the FY17 projected capital budget for Beach Restoration and Monitoring
where the Administrator r eminded the Committee that the C ity must front the money for the
offshore dredging project. The City can get the stakeholders’ money in the bank, but, on the grant
side, the City must front the money and wait to be reimbursed. The full fifteen million dollar
($15,000,000) expense for t he fall 2016 project is shown in the FY17 Capital Budget; the
Administrator anticipates that another project of similar cost will need to occur in about eight (8)
years. Also included in this budget is seventy-five thousand dollars ($75,000) for ongoing
shoreline monitoring and the re-budget of twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000) for updating the
Beach Management Plan . The Administrator noted that the City’s regular monitoring of the
shoreline was definitely beneficial with the City’s progress on the project worksheet for FEMA.
Real Property Committee
March 3, 2016
Page 5 of 8
When Councilmember Rice confirmed that the beach monitoring was continuing through Coastal
Science and Engineering (CSE), Administrator Tucker reported that the City has had a lot of
success with them in assembling money, in getting grants, and in getting permits.
For Breach Inlet, the rehabilitation of the ramp and gate replacement have been deferred until
FY18.
The marina FY17 Capital Budget, i ncludes the mandatory replacement of the four (4) under -
ground fuel tanks with double walled tanks at three hundred thousand dollars ($300,000); this has
been rolled forward in order to meet the deadline and not be competing with the many other
entities who will need to do the same. The question of whether or not they will be relocated has
not yet been answered. Twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000) has been budgeted to replace
the dockside fuel dispensers, only if they fail. Staff has estimated forty thousand dollars ($40,000)
for painting the bulkhead; the Administrator reported that staff has reached out to ATM to get a
more accurate estimate for the job. The following items located at Morgan Creek Grill were
deferred to FY18: the generator, walk-in freezer, hood/ventilation system and sprinkler system.
For marina Special Projects, staff took a risk by showing costs for work on the master
redevelopment plan before Council has decided what it wants to do or when. In the first year
(FY17), the budgeted funds would be for engineering, design and permitting; based on the initial
controversy over the drystack, it does not appear on the budget until FY20.
Based on phone calls he has received, Councilmember Harrington suggested that a drystack
might be acceptable to residents if it were only available to residents; Administrator Tucker stated
that the marina manager had the same recommendation.
Chair Bergwerf questioned what would happen if all of the boat spaces were not fill ed by island
residents; she ]thenh stated that the way ATM proposed the drystack was out of compliance with
the City’s height limit of forty feet (40 ft.) – the drystack with boats on the top would be forty-five
or forty-six feet (45-46 ft.) tall. She considered ATM to be disingenuous to propose a plan that
they knew would not meet the City’s Code.
Administrator Tucker further explained that the FY18 budget was for the water-side of the marina
and FY19 was for the land-side, and she added that she believes that the estimates are too low
because the location is the Isle of Palms with its reputation of being an affluent community and
an uptick in construction has pushed prices higher. She remarked that she is also suspicious of
estimates when someone is trying to do a project and to make something economically feasible.
Since the City is planning a Special Meeting dedicated to the ATM Marina Master Redevelopment
Plan, Administrator Tucker stated that Council members would be asked to submit questions of
subjects they want to discuss about the marina.
The Front Beach FY17 Capital Budget includes the design costs for new public restrooms of one
hundred one thousand thir ty-four dollars ($101,034) based on Liollio’s old estimate, the
repair/replacement/addition of a beach access at one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000), the
replacement of four (4) bollard lights near the County Park at seven thousand dollars ($7,000)
Real Property Committee
March 3, 2016
Page 6 of 8
and a piece of public art to replace the informational kiosk for ten thousand dollars ($10,000). A
new savings fund for a future project is seventy -five thousand dollars ($75,000) to replace the
underground infrastructure in the Front Beach area. According to the Administrator, the City still
needs to replace part of the white fencing at Front Beach, but it has been deferred to FY18.
Chair Bergwerf asked whether money was being budgeted for upkeep and maintenance on the
existing public restrooms.
Director Pitts reported that , in anticipation of the season, the restrooms have been pressure
washed, lights need to be replaced and two (2) toilets are broken. He stated that he plans to use
temporary labor to paint the interior and exterior before the season.
Councilmember Harrington asked why the City as a governmental agency cannot call on eminent
domain to create a variance to really refurbish the existing restrooms and not spend a million
dollars ($1,000,000) to replaced them; he indicated that, as stewards of the taxpayers’ money,
the City should make better use of it.
According to the Administrator, the City cannot do that without jeopardizing everyone’s flood
insurance; everyone must play by the same rules. The City cannot do something that it is not
willing to let all other residents of the City do, and, if the City goes to a lower standard for flood
resiliency, the City would have to be prepared to let everyone go to that same standard.
Councilmember Rice understood that FEMA would punish the entire community with higher flood
insurance rates if the City tried to circumvent its own regulations.
If the restrooms were not in a V zone, the Administrator remarked that the City would have more
flexibility; a V zone is the most risky zone. In an effort to dodge the V zone requirements, the City
hired experts to select the best location. She continued that, at-grade restrooms in other munici-
palities are in violation of the rules, and everything that is above ground is removed and the facility
is sealed off if a major storm is threatening; frequently, it is a temporary kind of facility. There are
other municipalities that have simply decided to take the risk; if FEMA came to the area and found
it, the City would bear the consequences – to tear it down or to have significantly increased
premiums for the community’s property owners.
Chair Bergwerf noted that the City is vig orously trying to get money from the County and the
Mayor has suggested that the additional funds from the parking lots and the increased fees at the
kiosks be set aside for the construction of the restrooms.
Administrator Tucker cautioned the Committee that saving money as described above was the
suggestion of one (1) Council member; no motion was made. If Council would like that to be
formalized, a motion would be necessary.
When Councilmember Harrington asked whether the cost of the handicap parking space at 42nd
Avenue was included in these funds, Administrator Tucker responded that the discussion was
that the City should construct the parking spaces and continue to pursue grant funding for the
handicap access.
Real Property Committee
March 3, 2016
Page 7 of 8
The Administrator reported that she had followed up with the grant funding agency to learn why
the City did not get funding, and she was told that they could not understand why the City needed
two (2) parallel paths. Therefore, in t he next round, the City will need to clarify why two (2) are
necessary or re-design the project for a driving path and a walking path.
Councilmember Rice asked that, if the City were to consider hiring a parks and grounds person,
would he also oversee F ront Beach; she opined that it needs much more attention than it is
getting.
Administrator Tucker agreed that the area takes a beating during the season; the problem is that
the City is relying on the Public Works staff, occasionally some Recreation sta ff and others who
have a heavy work load to notice and do these things, for example, when coming into the building
recently, she noticed that the bushes were dying. Someone who has that responsibility would
have noticed the problem long be fore they were d ying and tended to them; he would also
constantly be notifying the City when it needed to budget for the replacement of things that are
deteriorating. Currently, the City is acting in a reactionary mode and asking people with full time
jobs to do this “between the cracks.”
The public restrooms have a daily attendant who is not a City employee and who is responsible
to ensure that supplies are available, to report problems and to be a presence; the overall
maintenance of the facility is the City’s responsibility.
Councilmember Rice asked whether the Committee should ask the Personnel Committee to
consider a position for parks and grounds for all City property.
Director Pitts stated that staff does not have time for the City’s property and facilities around the
island, and today a landscaper comes to the island every week to maintain the grounds . The
Director thought a person in the capacity described would be an asset.
Administrator Tucker commented that contractors with the City, like the landscapers, need a City
person to be responsible for supervising the contracts.
For Chair Bergwerf, the issue was whether the City was willing to take on another employee.
Councilmember Harrington suggested that the Administrator take to the Personnel Committee the
addition of a position as described, and she stated that a person could be added to the operating
budgets. He indicated that he would also like to see a list of responsibilities and recommended
salary.
8. Miscellaneous Business
Tenant Rents Report
The Administrator stated that she had not gotten that information prior to the meeting, but would
have it for the Ways and Means Committee meeting.
Next Meeting Date: 2:00 p.m., Wednesday, April 6th in the Conference Room
Real Property Committee
March 3, 2016
Page 8 of 8
9. Executive Session – not needed
10. Adjourn
MOTION: Councilmember Harrington moved to adjourn the meeting at 3:00
p.m.; Councilmember Rice seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.