March 1, 2016 (PDF, 324.14 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of Mar 1, 2016 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
RECREATION COMMMITTEE
9:00 a.m., Tuesday, March 1, 2016
The regular meeting of the Recreation Committee was held at 9:00 a.m., Tuesday, March 1, 2016
in the City Hall Conference Room, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South Carolina. Attending
the meeting were Councilmembers Kinghorn and Rice, Chair Carroll, Administrator Tucker,
Recreation Director Page, Assistant Administrator Fragoso , Assistant D irector Ferrell and City
Clerk Copeland; a quorum was present to conduct business.
1. Chair Carroll called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public were
duly notified on the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Rice moved to approve the minutes of the regular
meeting of February 11, 2016 as submitted; Councilmember Kinghorn seconded
and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments – None
4. Departmental Report for February 2016 – Director Page
Director Page reported that, on February 18th, eleven (11) Keenagers had gone on a field trip to
the Nathaniel Russell House Museum followed by lunch at Page’s Okra Grill. According to the
Director, Doggie Day at the Rec was “awesome;” seventy (70) dogs participated in the contests
and fifty-three (53) got rabies shots. The Middle School Dance was attended by only twenty (20)
youths; Seacoast Church had an event for young people of the same age on the same night and
drew those that would have normally attended the Middle School Dance. Upcoming events
included the Front Beach Fest planned for Saturday, March 5th featuring the Blackwater Rhythm
and Blues band and The Tams; more than forty (40) local craft vendors, restaurants, businesses
and free entertainment will be present. The annual Isle of Palms Easter Egg Hunt will be at 10:00
a.m., Saturday, March 26; as in the past, jump castles, a ballo on artist, a photo booth, a face
painter and an appearance by the Easter Bunny will be part of the fun. The date for this year’s
Yard Sale is Saturday, April 23 rd from 8:00 a.m. til noon, and the spaces are available for five
dollars ($5).
Councilmember Rice suggested that a food truck featuring breakfast food should be invited to
participate in the Yard Sale.
Chair Carroll asked that the number of participants or the number of teams be added to the
athletics report.
The Director noted t hat Andy Sinwald had attended a SCRPA Programming Summit that she
thought had been very helpful for him since he is new in the field.
Director Page then directed attention to the graphs she has added to the report; the first graph
demonstrated the participation totals for January and February; the second graph illustrated the
number of individuals that have enrolled and/or paid for participation; and the third graph showed
the number of hours the building was open and supervised, the number of classes of fered and
the number of games plan in both adult and youth sports.
Recreation Committee
March 1, 2016
Page 2 of 6
Councilmember Kinghorn asked whether two hundred (200) people maxed out the cardio room,
and Director Page replied that she had never seen it full. Assistant Director Ferrell remarked that
the room is pretty full before 7:00 a.m. with people using it before they head to work and again at
5:00 p.m. on the way home; the room is pretty busy between the hours of noon and 2:00 p.m.
Councilmember Kinghorn stated that the graphs were very helpful and meaningful; he also voiced
approval with the way the Director had shortened the report.
5. Old Business
A. Update on pickle ball
Director Page stated that they had explored several options to avoid a conflict between tennis
and pickle ball, but it was going to be expensive to have the pickle ball anywhere else. The pickle
ball net is to be put up this week, and, like the tennis courts, it will be first come -first served. If
enough people participate, a league could be formed. The Director does not intend, at this point,
to invest much in paddles; she expects that those who play will have their own.
B. Update on Bark Park pumping
The Director reported that she is working on getting that done, but there had been a mix-up in the
equipment. In the meantime, the trenches have been dug, and the pumping can begin as soon
as the equipment arrives. The pumped water will be directed to the same storm drain as runoff
from the building.
Administrator Tucker asked that she get with Director Kerr to insure that the City would not be
breaking any NPDES regulations.
6. New Business
A. Review of FY17 Capital Budget
B. Discussion of 10-Year Capital Plan
In order to produce the Ca pital Budgets, staff begins by checking what was completed in the
current year; unfinished projects are typically rolled into the coming budget year and added to the
projects assigned for purchase or replacement in the comin g budget year. Once that list is
compiled, the items to be replaced are evaluated to determine if they can be deferred for a year
or must be replaced, and items that are in out-years are reviewed to determine if any need to be
moved up to the coming budge t year. For those items included in the FY17 Capital Budget are
also assigned a replacement year in the future.
The “big ticket” item in the Recreation Capital Budget is the replacement of the soccer field lights
at one hundred twenty-five thousand dollars ($125,000); items to be replaced “only with failure”
are the replacement playground equipment or outside scoreboard and HVAC systems. Other
items on the Capital Budget are the golf cart, outdoor water fountains, baseball field fencing, four
(4) outdoor basketball goals and posts and the radios to comply with Phase II. The total
Recreation Committee
March 1, 2016
Page 3 of 6
Recreation Capital Budget is two hundred seventy -four thousand dollars ($274,000); a copy of
the proposed FY17 Capital Budget is attached to the historical record of the meeting.
Councilmember Kinghorn asked how the capital purchases were prioritized, and the Administrator
indicated that it was the wear and condition of the items to be replaced; he stated that some items
on the list are not required to be replaced, but the decision has been made to do certain things.
Director Page reported that both the baseball field fencing and the lights at the soccer fields are
in disrepair; a lot of the soccer lights no longer burn, they c annot be repaired and the wiring has
rotted. She added that they were installed in 1997.
Councilmember Kinghorn then asked whether the estimated cost included the poles and
everything; the Director answered that it did. The lights would be purchased through Musco
Lighting, as were the multi-purpose field lights and tennis and basketball courts, and they come
with a twenty-five year (25 yr.) warrant y. The lights are monitored twenty -four (24) hours a day,
seven (7) days a week and , when there is a problem, they automatically send a technician to
repair. In addition, the new lights would not bleed out, but beam directly on the field.
The poles need to be replaced because they no longer meet code, and, once the lights are
replaced, the poles must meet code.
Director Page stated that she tries not to spend money, but, when something needs to be
replaced, she adds it to the budget to get the necessary things done. She noted that maintenance
at a Rec Center was tough; everything they have must be in good shape to minimize the chances
of someone being hurt.
Responding to Chair Carroll, the Director recalled that the softball fencing was replaced last year.
Councilmember Kinghorn asked how budget purchases were prioritized, i.e. wh at would the
deciding factor be in replacing an asset versus maintaining and using it for another year . He
indicated that he would like some third party validation.
To enlarge or relocate the cardio room would be an expensive venture; the Director believes that
to relocate it, the building would have to be expanded.
The construction of a swimming pool and a gymnasium are both scheduled for FY21, and
Councilmember Kinghorn asked for the rationale of doing that, acknowledging that the two (2)
projects were on a wish list. According to Director Page, they were listed to keep them before the
Committee and City Council.
Chair Carroll opined that a referendum should be held to get residents’ input before the City spent
five million dollars ($5,000,000).
Referring again to the cardio room, Director Page stated that the best time to construct a new one
would be when the gymnasium was built, and , following the discussion, a separate line of two
hundred fifty-thousand dollars ($250,000) in FY21 was added to the budget for the construction
of a fitness facility that did not tie it to a new gym.
Recreation Committee
March 1, 2016
Page 4 of 6
Chair Carroll questioned that a city the size of the Isle of Palms needed a new gymnasium.
Councilmember Rice commented that the gym is old and “in tough shape;” she also stated that ‘it
is packed all the time.”
Administrator Tucker reminded Chair Carroll that the Mayor had asked that the Committee Chairs
make the budget reports at the Ways and Means Committee meeting.
C. Consideration of Implementation of
Changes to the monthly report;
The pursuit of non-traditional funding
Partnering with other local entities
Surveys for input into the facility utilization and future needs of the Recreation
Department
Changes to the monthly report
For the March report, the Director will add the number of participants and teams involved in sports
activities.
The pursuit of non-traditional funding
Director Page reported that she has been looking into grants, but, from past experience, she knew
that it was difficult for the Isle of Palms to get grants because the community is considered to be
too affluent. She recalled that she did get a CDBG grant of forty thousand dollars ($40,000) for
HVAC for the gym based on the degree of use by senior citizens; each year the City receives a
PARD grant distributed by Charleston County based on population, ranging from fifteen hundred
to three thousand dollars ($1,500 -3,000). The PARD grants have been used for buying
playground equipment, resurfacing the tennis courts, replacing the gym ceiling, etc. At one time,
staff sold ads in the activity guide in order to publish it; that happened for a couple of editions, but
then the City’s businesses stated that they thought they were doing enough throug h the sports
sponsorships. In the past, Counci l has not supported the concept of going out for funding or
soliciting for donations; therefore, she thought that to do so she would need a directive from the
Committee.
Councilmember Kinghorn said that it was easier to raise money when the money would go toward
a specific goal; he thought the baseball field fencing was a good example. He noted that funding
could come from state, federal or local grants, corporations and/ or foundations; with the aging
population on the island, he suggested checking with AARP for funding opportunities.
According to the Director, the other issue with grants is that Council must adopt the project before
the funding application could be submitted.
Recreation Committee
March 1, 2016
Page 5 of 6
Councilmember Kinghorn countered that, hypothetically, the City was awarded a grant of one
hundred thousand dollars ($100,000) for a fitness space that has to be matched, he thought that
Council would be more likely to find a way to fund that over something equal cost because the
Rec Department has brought something to the table.
Councilmember Kinghorn reiterated his position that the best way to raise money through
contributions was registration, and, whether paper or electronic registration, a blank could be
inserted encouraging contributions to the Building Fund, for ex ample. A similar space could be
placed on the Recreation Department website, assuming that was the direction Council wanted
to go.
Chair Carroll asked whether a donation to the Rec Department would be tax deductible, and she
confirmed that it would be. The Chair then asked who would be assigned the task of overseeing
a program for donations; he thought the staff at the Recreation Department had full plates every
day. He also suggested that a donation space could be added to the e -newsletter stating that
“the Recreation Department gladly accepts donations for future needs.”
Assistant Fragoso asked the Director if a line needed to be added to the budget for online
registration at the Recreation Department.
Director Page responded that the software module for online registration will cost twenty -five
thousand dollars ($25,000). For those people who come to classes and repeatedly pay by the
class, the ability to register online would mean nothing; she thought the most use for online
registration at the Recreation Department would be sports and summer camps.
Partnering with other local entities
Director Page stated that the Rec Department has partnered many times with groups such as the
Red Cross, the Department of Natural R esources, and the Charleston County Parks and
Recreation Commission. The Director indicated that Charleston was unique in that the local Rec
Directors meet monthly to talk about programs that are happening and how to help one another;
they also try not to duplicate efforts or compete, but complement each other. When needed,
Mount Pleasant allows teams from the island to participate in their leagues; there is the Connector
Walk for the Child; the Exchange Club participates in Middle School Dances and the Front Beach
Fest; and the Windjammer supports every activity at the Rec or on the beach.
The Director’s conclusion was that, when she is approached by an agency that wants to do some-
thing, she will look at it and determine how it could help the residents and the Department. She
stated that, if they were to take on something else at this time, they would have to drop something;
she noted that she did not think she could ask her employees to do more than they already do.
Surveys for input into the facility utilization and future needs of the Recreation
Department
Since the last meeting, the Director has developed two (2) surveys, which she distributed to
Committee members for their input. (Copies are attached to the historical record of the meeting.)
Recreation Committee
March 1, 2016
Page 6 of 6
Administrator Tucker stated that, when a survey pops up on her computer, she wants to know
how long it will take to complete and for it to be as quick as possible. Based on that, she opined
that the surveys offered by the Director were too long; she indicated that she would advocate for
something that is brief and targeted to what the Director is trying to learn. The Administrator
added that the question “Are you an island resident?” must be on any survey the City or
Department generate.
Chair Carroll asked if it would benefit the Recreation Department to have its own Facebook page.
The Administrator noted that every form of social media that the City gets into has to be carefully
monitored, and the more sites that it is on, the more the risk goes up that something would be
posted that is not well thought out and which represents the entire City because people who are
too busy and who are also trying to manage the social media aspect of something.
The Administrator recalled that she has encouraged all Council membe rs to get on Twitter
because it will give them a quicker notice that something has been posted to Facebook.
Councilmember Rice thought it important to ask “What other program would you like to see at the
Recreation Department?”
Councilmember Kinghorn expanded on that saying he liked the idea of space at the end of a
newsletter for open comments or suggestions.
Councilmember Rice thought that the age of the survey participant could be valuable, for instance,
many seniors could indicate that they want a pool for water aerobics.
7. Miscellaneous Business
Next Meeting Date: 9:00 a.m., Tuesday, April 5th in the City Hall Conference Room.
8. Adjournment
MOTION: Councilmember Kinghorn moved to adjourn the meeting at 10:19
a.m.; Councilmember Rice seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.