February 8, 2016 (PDF, 328.84 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of Feb 8, 2016 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE
9:30 a.m., Monday, February 8, 2016
The regular meeting of the Public Safety Committee was called to order at 9:30 a.m., Monday,
February 8, 2016 in the City Hall Conference Room, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South
Carolina. Attending the meeting were Councilmembers Bergwerf and Carr oll, Chair Bettelli,
Administrator Tucker, Fire Chief Graham, Police Chief Buckhannon, Attorney Halversen,
Assistant Administrator Fragoso and City Clerk Copeland; a quorum was present to conduct
business.
1. Chair Bettelli called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public had
duly been notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Carroll moved to approve the minutes of the regular
meeting of January 10, 2016 as submitted; Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and
the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments
Ann Maughon, 7 Wills Way, said that she had been pleased to see that coyotes were on the
Agenda again for discussion, but she was disappointed to find that crosswalks on Palm Boulevard
were not. She reminded the Committee that she had attended the January meeting to report that
many drivers do not stop for pedestrians trying to cross Palm Boulev ard; she again appealed to
add two to three (2-3) traditional crosswalks with lines on the pavement between 28th Avenue and
Forest Trail.
Mike Maughon, 7 Wills Way, distributed a Google Maps image of his neighborhood indicating
where coyotes have been sighted and areas from which cats have di sappeared as well as
photographs of an overgrown, vacant lot. After his cat went missing, he and his wife spoke to
their neighbors to warn them about the coyote problem on the island. One neighbor reported
seeing a coyote enter the vacant lot from Allie Court; Mr. Maughon r eported that a visible path
exists where the coyotes enter the lot from Wills Way. Since he moved to Wills Way in 1989, no
one has done anything to maintain the vacant lot, but the coyotes that live there have solved the
next door neighbor’s rat problem. He questioned whether the City had contacted the owner of
the vacant lot to ask that it be cleared. In talking with people on the island, he has been told that
coyotes have been spotted in the vacant lot at the Baptist Church and on Shady Lane across from
the golf course; the greens keeper at the golf course said that they have had to repair the damage
the coyotes have done digging for moles. He indicated that he would like to see these overgrown,
vacant lots cleared, and he would support efforts to eradicate them like Sullivan’s Island is doing
with the leg traps.
4. Old Business
A. Consideration of the Noise Ordinance Amendment
Administrator Tucker noted that the noise ordinance amendment had First Reading at the January
City Council meeting; it is on this Agenda because staff received additional language to insert in
the ordinance suggested by an island resident.
Public Safety Committee
February 8, 2016
Page 2 of 9
The suggestion is to insert the following language into Section 9.2.5.a.(3):
“provided, however, that any City -owned property subject to a commercial lease and a
noise control agreement with the City is exempt fro m the requirements of this
paragraph.”
Administrator Tucker interprets the language change to refer to some type of permanent noise
control agreement with City tenant s; while the City did have an approved City -sponsored event
with Morgan Cree k Grill for their experimental period with sound mediation , the City has not
typically had any kind of permanent noise control agreement, other than to say in the leases that
the lessee must abide by all City ordinances and state and federal laws. The City Attorney was
asked to attend the meeting to discuss the proposed change and any other aspect of the
amendment that might have generated concerns.
Councilmember Carroll spoke with the resident who made the suggestion and had gotten the
impression that the language of the ordinance allowed City tenants to be exempt from the noise
ordinance; The Councilmember explained that the City’s tenants would definitely be required to
comply with the noise ordinance and not be exempt from it.
The Administrator recalled that one (1) of the arguments involving Morgan Creek Grill was that
the existing code did not allow for amplified music on public property, i.e. City -owned property,
and that is one (1) of several changes included in the amendment.
Attorney Halversen voiced the opinion that the City has the necessary controls in the commercial
leases; any violation to the noise ordinance would be a material part of the leases. Any violation
would trigger the controls in the lease t hat the City has to enforce including termination of the
lease. She questioned that a separate agreement was necessary; since the change points to a
new agreement, she did not know what it would contain that is not already in the lease.
Chair Bettelli suggested that any future leases specifically reference the noise ordinance.
Attorney Halversen reported that another exception was listed in the ordinance stating:
“(4) Construction activities performed by or on behalf of a governmental agency, including,
but not limited to, construction, repair or maintenance of public buildings and drainage
facilities, dredging activities, beach renourishment activities, and other public projects.”
The Attorney said that she tr ied to make the statement broad, so that something else could be
added if necessary.
Administrator Tucker commented that the language came to mind because the City has projects
that must happen at all hours of the day and night, such as dredging at the marina or Intracoastal
Waterway or the harvesting of sand from off-shore.
The Committee agreed that they did not see the need for any changes and would be ready for
Second Reading at the February Council meeting; therefore, Attorney Halversen was allowed to
leave.
Public Safety Committee
February 8, 2016
Page 3 of 9
B. Discussion of Coyotes on the Island
Chair Bettelli thanked the Maughons for their remarks and acknowledged that not all coyote
sightings were being reported; he stated that Sullivan’s Island was having mixed results. The
coyotes were too smart to go into the box traps, and there are drawbacks with the leg traps they
are now using because the leg traps are not without risks. He added that the City must do
something; he recommended taking steps to have someone study the island’s situation and
provide the City with a plan for s ignificantly reducing the number of them on the island or
eradicating them completely.
Councilmember Bergwerf recalled that the City was planning to hold a public meeting; in her
opinion, a key factor in controlling the coyotes was education. She thought that residents do not
understand what the rules are, what the law is, that the City cannot put traps on private property,
etc. According to the Councilmember, historically, for every coyote trapped, four (4) dogs or cats
or hawks are trapped. As for cleaning vacant lots, Councilmember Bergwerf noted that, in addition
to the coyotes, other vermin living in the underbrush would be pushed into the surrounding
neighborhoods; she stated that there will be unintended consequences to whatever the City does.
Councilmember Carroll remarked that, before the meeting, he had distributed an email from Sherri
Musser sharing anecdotal evidence of the coyote problem on the island; she learned of twenty -
three (23) missing cats and one (1) missing dog in only five (5) months. He stated that the City
needs to be proactive and that he supports undercutting the vacant lots on the island and on the
golf course in Wild Dunes.
Administrator Tucker reported that she was putting together a publi c meeting, but each entity
waned to be the center of attention, and the City want ed to put together a panel including DNR
and other people who have dealt with attempts to control coyote populations all over the country,
possibly a wild life veterinarian, trappers, etc.
At the Administrator’s request, Chief Buckhannon explained that any process the City might
choose must go through the Department of Natural Resources (DNR). When he spoke with DNR
representatives last week, he learned that the amount of construction happening on Rifle Range
Road and towards the Francis Marion Forest has forced the coyotes out of their habitat, and,
while it might be a chore for them to get here, they do and will swim. The Chief was told that the
coyotes are becoming a problem state -wide for the same reason – loss of their habitat . The
representative indicated that he would work with the City in any way possible to get whatever
permits might be needed. The Chief cautioned that, when a trapper is brought in to deal with the
coyotes, the animals that are caught must be euthanized; they cannot be relocated. He added
that any “non -target” animals that are caught and that are not pets must meet the same fate.
Since the firing of a gun is illegal on the island, the animals must be taken off island to be killed,
which is contrary to state law, but the DRN representative said he would work with the City.
In addition, Chief Buckhannon contacted some trapping companies, and he got a picture of the
type of leg-old trap they recommend, which he distributed to the Committee members. The Chief
reported that Sullivan’s Island has been using box traps and had no success. If the City were to
hire a trapper, the City has the responsibility of telling him where to set the traps, and he noted
that, unlike Sullivan’s Island, the City has very little public land that it controls other than the
Public Safety Committee
February 8, 2016
Page 4 of 9
marshes. People have reported seeing coyotes when they are on the beach, but up to the high
water mark is private property; therefore the City/trapper would have to get permission from the
property owner and enter into an agreement with him to allow a trapper to s et a trap on his
property. The same process would also be required with Wild Dunes. Clearing the lots is effective
in making the coyotes go away, but many people like the natural look. DNR also told the Chief
that cats are afraid of the coyotes, but typ ically dogs are not. Chief Buckhannon warned that in
addition to the coyotes, the traps would ensnare pets, raccoons, possums and birds of prey. The
trapper indicated that he would put up signs to warn of the traps, but the number of signs would
be limited because coyotes are very smart and they quickly realize something has changed, i.e.
the appearance of the sign.
Administrator Tucker stated that contrary to people’s impressions, coyotes are not nocturnal
creatures. She added that, if the City decides to hire a trapper, the activity must be closely
monitored, and finding a remote location on City -owned property will be a challenge. The
Administrator noted that any private citizen can contract with a trapper for traps to be placed on
his property.
According to Chief Buckhannon, if the City hired a trapper, he would check the traps daily for a
set fee; if he catches a coyote, a different fee is charged, and a lower fee is charged if a “non -
target” animal is trapped. The responsibility of dealing with the “non-target” animals caught rests
with the City. The fee is three hundred dollars ($300) per month with a separate fee for the
animals caught in the traps.
Councilmember Carroll reiterated his stance that the City should move forward with the public
meeting and arrange to undercut overgrown vacant lots on the island.
The Administrator told the Committee that staff wants to hold the public meeting on Wednesday,
February 17th at the Recreation Center.
Back to the subject of the vacant lots, typically once a year the Livability Officer or Animal Control
Officer rides the island and makes a list of the lots on the island that are not maintained, and then
they send out notices to the owners that the lot is overgrown and needs attention. The property
owner is given a specific period of time to clean it up. Complaints from neighbors also prompt
action.
C. Discussion of Managed Beach Parking Signs
Administrator Tucker recalled that, at the January Council meeting, they awarded the contract for
the fabrication and installation of the signs for the parking plan; at this point, the contract has been
signed and the Notice to Proceed has been issued. The Administrator also reminded the
Committee that the City plans to do an “after -action” evaluation at the end of the season to
determine what worked, what did not work and what needs to be tweaked; what is being
implemented now is the parking and sign plan as codified.
Although he was happy to see the parking plan go forward, Councilmember Carroll said that he
was hearing for many residents about the large number of signs to be installed between 20 th
Avenue and Wildwood, and he agreed that it was “overkill.” He thought that a sign at the top and
Public Safety Committee
February 8, 2016
Page 5 of 9
bottom of each street would b e sufficient for that area; if a problem arose in this area, the sign
could be installed.
Councilmember Bergwerf stated that she did not understand why this discussion was taking place
since the decision had been made at City Council; she repeated that the plan could not go forward
without the proper signage for enforcement. She noted that Council could have stayed with Plan
B and avoided all of the discussion about signs.
Chair Bettelli reminded the Committee that the Ci ty had gone to the experts to design the sign
plan, and Council has to give it a chance.
Chair Carroll said that he was only saying what the residents were saying to him.
Administrator Tucker recounted that Council had gone from Plan B to Option C because members
were hearing pleas from residents of “Please do not leave me out.” The residents must not have
realized that to stop parking in the neighborhoods was going to require signage. The
Administrator noted that it was unfortunate that the focus had m oved to the signs rather than
managing the beach parking that was the issue of quality of life Council started out trying to solve.
Councilmember Carroll remembered that the difference between B and C was that B was a pay-
to-park plan that required the Ci ty to buy software for license plate recognition and Option C
ultimately saved the City a lot of money.
Chair Bettelli stopped the discussion because the City has both a parki ng and sign program in
effect and that re-addressing the issue would accomplish nothing.
D. Road and Bike Path Conditions
Administrator Tucker stated that staff has received concerns and complaints about the section of
Palm Boulevard between 3rd and 8th Avenues and the bike path in same section; she has reported
the problem to SCDO T twice. Every time it rains, the road deteriorates further, and the
deteriorating gravel is migrating into the bike path, making it somewhat hazardous as well.
5. New Business
A. Review of FY17 Revenue Budget
Administrator Tucker reported that revenue estimates are based on the past twelve (12) months
actual collections; revenues do not vary much from year -to-year, so the review will cover the
highlights. Where there is a change in the amount budgeted, the numbers are bolded. Looking
at line 22 – Parking Lot Revenue in the General Fund, an increase of forty-two thousand dollars
($42,000) is proposed; the increase is based on the daily rates that were increased at the last
Council meeting and the possibility of off -season revenue. Business Licenses co ntinue to be
discussed in the state legislature; the MASC has been working hard to work out a compromise,
and, if the compromise is agreed upon, the Administrator does not anticipate the City seeing any
adverse effect.
Public Safety Committee
February 8, 2016
Page 6 of 9
Any lines in this round of the budget referring to transfers should be ignored; these numbers
typically are calculated as a function of balancing the budget.
In the Capital Project Fund, the only real income is from interest income; the grant funds are the
anticipated NPDES funds the City will receive for the improvements to the Public Works site.
Both Municipal Accommodations Fees and County Accommodations Taxes are projected to have
small increases in the next fiscal year, as are Hospitality Taxes. In State Accommodations Taxes,
the revenue to the City is expected to increase slightly over FY16.
For the Disaster Recovery Fund, the only revenue shown is interest income.
Administrator Tucker explained that the Victims Assistance Fund is a fund to watch as its fund
balance has gone down steadily for the past several years, and the police officer who performs
that function along with other functions receives a portion of the expense attributed to the officer
from this fund. As the fund balance is reduced, more of these expenses will move to the General
Fund.
The Volunteer 1% Fund gets its revenue from a percentage of the casualty insurance premiums
homeowners pay; the City makes no decisions about the use of these funds; it only perfor ms
fiduciary responsibilities for it. The funds are to be spent for entertainment for Fire Department
personnel; the majority of the funds at the Isle of Palms buys additional life insurance for them.
Plant-a-Palm revenue saw a big uptick at the end of 2015 as people bought commemorative
bricks to go on Front Beach; staff believes that the increase was due to the use of social media.
For the Recreation Building Fund, revenues come from a donation to the Connector Run of five
thousand dollars ($5,000) and registration fees from the Beach Run of about seventy-five hundred
dollars ($7,500). In addition, the State ATAX Fund gives a three thousand dollar ($3,000)
sponsorship for the Beach Run that is returned to the Building Fund; at times there are private
donations.
The final page is the Marina Revenue which consists of rents from the marina tenants and the
additional rent usually collected from the restaurant.
The Administrator directed attention to the large schedule that compares revenues budgeted for
FY16 versus projected budget for FY17 by sources of funds and the small box at the bottom of
the page. She noted that the General Fund and the Capital Projects Fund are listed together
since the only source of money for the Capital Projects Fund is th e General Fund; these funds
comprise sixty-four percent (64%) of the total budget. The tourism funds make up twenty -six
percent (26%) of the total, the marina fund makes up three percent (3%) and all other funds are
one percent (1%). The Administrator st ated that the figures for Beach Restoration and
Maintenance Funds have not been compiled for this version of the schedule.
Currently, staff is working on updating the Capital Plan for Committee meetings in March.
B. Consideration of Citizen Suggestion of Additional Signs at 14th and Palm
Public Safety Committee
February 8, 2016
Page 7 of 9
A citizen sent the Administrator a photo of directional signs in Mount Pleasant that are hung from
the electrical line for the traffic lights to be considered for installation at 14th and Palm. Since the
subject of signs appears to be a delicate one at the moment, she suggested taking no action until
a later date; currently, directional arrows are painted on the pavement at that intersection.
Councilmember Carroll noted that he is currently living in Beachside and, as a result, he has
learned firsthand how difficult it is for pedestr ians to cross Palm Boulevard; h e suggested that
parallel white lines be painted at the end of every block to help residents cross Palm.
Administrator Tucker stated that SCDOT has limits about how close together crosswalks can be,
and she is doubtful that they will allow every block, but she would investigate.
Chair Bettelli related that SCDOT requires a driver to stop if a pedestrian is safely in the crosswalk,
not if someone is waiting in the right-of-way to cross.
C. Consideration of Re -purposing the PSB Dispatch Office into a Conference
Room at a cost of approximately $4,500, using funds budgeted for service
agreements
Chief Buckhannon stated that the old dispatch office is not used, but is just a shell with nothing in
it but desks and old dispatch consoles; currently the City is paying about eleven thousand dollars
($11,000) annually to maintain the old consoles which are not being used. The dispatchers have
been moved to the front and the goal of always having someone to greet people has been
achieved; their tasks have also been re-vamped to be in line with the new title of Communication
Specialists. The old dispatch office, sitting empty as it is, creates two (2) problems for the Chief;
it is a space that holds dispatch equipment that is costly to maintain, but he also needs a more
secure space for the Beach Services Officers to store their equipment that now sits on a table in
the Squad Room unsecured. The Chief wants to move the BSOs and their equipment into a small
office being used as a conference room and use the old dispatch office as a conference room
which would be larger than the conference room presently in use. The floors must be completely
redone, and he has received a quote of about two to three thousand dollars ($2,000 – 3,000) and
the walls need to be repainted and holes repaired , costing less than fifteen hundred dollars
($1,500). He proposes that, rather than maintaining the old consoles, which are no longer in use,
to use the budgeted funds to re-purpose the room; later he will sell the old consoles.
MOTION: Chair Bettelli moved to recommend approval of the $4,500 for the re-
purposing of the old dispatch office in the Public Safety Building; Councilmember
Carroll seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
6. Highlights of Departmental Reports
Fire Department – Chief Graham
Members of the Department responded to forty-three (43) calls in the month of January; twenty-
two (22) of those calls were for EMS. The Chief reported that the QRV is no w stationed on the
island during the day, and they are not to cross the Connector. Forty-seven (47) pre-incident
Public Safety Committee
February 8, 2016
Page 8 of 9
surveys were written during the month, and thirty-nine (39) fire inspections were performed, noting
twenty-three (23) violations. Personnel received a variety of training, such as fire behavior,
personal protective equipment and building con struction. The radiator replacement on Tower
1002 was quite expensive , in excess of six thousand dollars ($6,000). The Chief attended a
Response Provider meeting; this annual meeting is mandated by the Federal government to
review response policies and best practices throughout the industry.
Chief Graham reported that the Fire Department has experienced several situations with
employees that have i ncreased overtime significantly; she noted that , when an employee is
placed on light duty, the position has to be backfilled by overtime. One (1) employee had to resign
to move home to assist with caring for his very ill father; another employee was in an accident off
the job and will be out four to five (4 -5) weeks; a third employee who was injured on the job,
required surgery, has been out since early December and might not be able to return to work.
The Chief noted that she is doing her best to keep the dollar amount of overtime at a minimum,
i.e. bringing in a firefighter rather than an engineer.
On the rescue truck, Chief Graham reported that she was scheduled to go to Florida on February
17th for the final inspection, but one (1) backordered part is preventing the truck from going to the
lettering shop. She anticipates that the truck will be ready for the final inspection at the end of
February or early March; a couple to three weeks (2 -3) later the truck should be on the island.
The bid opening for the sale of the existing truck will be next week.
Police Department – Chief Buckhannon
The Chief reported that the Department has seen an uptick in credit card fraud recently; he urged
citizens to be vigilant in their use of credit cards and do as much as possible to keep the card
numbers from being compromised. The Command Staff recognized the follo wing members of
the Department for perfect attendance in 2015; they are Sgt. Ambas, Sgt. Meekins, Pfc. King,
Pfc. Couche and ACO Enourato. During the month of January, officers issued forty -two (42)
“Property Security Check” notices and eight (8) “You could have been a victim of a crime” notices;
in addition, officers installed several child safety seats since several officers have been certified.
On January 22 nd, Pfc. Hardy and Pfc. Reynolds participated in the Lunch Buddies Program at
Sullivan’s Island Elementary School where they interacted with children from kindergarten to fifth
grade. Telecommunication Specialists responded to a total of four thousand nine hundred thirty-
five (4,935) total calls in the month; four thousand thirty -three (4,033) were f or the Police
Department. During the month, officers made two hundred eighty (280) traffic stops and wrote
one hundred six (106) tickets. Of the eighty -nine (89) reports that officers wrote in the month,
twenty-four (24) were for non -criminal offenses . As a whole, the Department received one
hundred forty -five (145) hours of training; one course was on less lethal weapons, tasers in
particular. He reported that Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals has changed the use of tasers for law
enforcement; officers are encouraged to use other methods, such as batons or physically fighting
with the perpetuator, instead of tasers. The Department received four (4) noise complaints, and
two (2) received warnings becase the complaints were made before midnight. Eleven (11) coyote
sightings were reported, and the calls were primarily from Wild Dunes.
Public Safety Committee
February 8, 2016
Page 9 of 9
7. Miscellaneous Business
Chair Bettelli announced that the 16th Annual HOPE 5K Beach Walk/Run will be held on Saturday,
September 17, 2016; the event is on the City’s list of approved annual events.
The polar plunge for Special Olympics is scheduled for Saturday, February 20 th at The
Windjammer.
Next Meeting Date: 9:30 a.m., Wednesday, March 3rd in the Conference Room.
8. Executive Session – not needed
9. Adjournment
MOTION: Councilmember Carroll moved to adjourn the meeting at 11:08 a.m.;
Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.