February 8, 2016 (PDF, 342.31 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of Feb 8, 2016 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
REAL PROPERTY COMMITTEE
3:00 p.m., Monday, February 8, 2016
The regular meeting of the Real Property Committee was held at 3:00 p.m., Monday, February 8,
2016 in the City Hall Conference Room, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South Carolina.
Attending the meeting were Councilmembers Harrington and Rice, Chair Bergwerf, Administrator
Tucker, Assistant Administrator Fragoso and Clerk Copeland; a quorum was present to conduct
business.
1. Chair Bergwerf called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public
were duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Harrington moved to approve the minutes of the
regular meeting of January 6, 2016 as submitted; Councilmember Rice seconded
and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments
Elizabeth Campsen, 32 Intracoastal Court, stated that she was present to address the matter of
a thirty-year (30 yr.) lease for Morgan Creek Grill. She reported that she had attended th e ATM
meeting in the fall to give input related to the marina redevelopment plan; many people were
excited at the prospect ATM r epresented for improvements at the marina. She expressed the
opinion that “the cart might be getting in front of the horse” to go into a thirty -year (30 yr.) lease
before getting the report from ATM; she noted that Morgan Creek Grill currently has four (4) years
remaining on its lease, so they are not unable to operate. Ms. Campsen was aware that Mr.
Clarke was interested in making significant improvements to the restaurant, but ATM might
recommend the relocation of the restaurant on the marina site. When the marina bond is paid off
in 2019, the City might have a different consideration relative to the revenue stream coming from
the marina. Ms. Campsen stated that Phillip and Cathy Smith agreed with her suggestion to delay
action on the lease; the reason that Mr. Smith was not present was that he is out of town. She
urged the Committee not to act on the lease extension since it could interfere with implementation
of ATM’s recommendations for the marina.
4. Comments from Marina Tenants
A. Consideration of Morgan Creek Grill Lease Amendment
Jay Clarke, owner and Carla Pope, Operations Manager, were present to rep resent Morgan
Creek Grill (MCG), and Ms. Pope stated that, as requested at the January meeting, they have
provided for the Committee a list of the capital improvements they have made to the property
since 2002 and a list of the capital improvements planned if they succeed in getting the lease
extension they are seeking. In addition, they have had the opportunity to speak with members of
the Committee, two (2) at the restaurant and one (1) in City Hall, to show them “the good, the bad
and the ugly” of the restaurant. In addition, they provided an updated schedule of rent, licenses
and taxes paid to the City since 2002; the schedule also show ed how the business has grown
over the years to now exceed four million dollars ($4,000,000) per year.
Real Property Committee
February 8, 32016
Page 2 of 9
Ms. Pope recalled that, when lease negotiation s began, MCG presented a lease with multiple
changes; the amendment they are seeking now has only one (1) change, i.e. six (6) extensions
of five (5) years each for a total of thirty (30) years, to be able to get the type of financial support
they need to operate such a seasonal restaurant. She also reported that , at this time , the
restaurant is showing a small, but reasonable, profit, which they have not always done. Per
discussion with Administrator Tucker, they have updated the exhibit that lists the assets originally
belonging to the City that no longer exist and the assets remaining for which the restaurant was
now taking full responsibility; with these changes the lease between the City of Isle of Palms and
Morgan Creek Grill is a true triple-net lease.
Mr. Clarke stated that the restaurant would be unable to operate as it has in the past and maintain
the building and continue improvements without the lease exte nsion; he reiterated that financial
institutions want to see longer term leases. He noted a Councilmember had expressed concerns
similar to those of Ms. Campsen relative to the marina master plan, but he opined that over the
years he has shown his ability to work with the City, and he plans to continue to do so with regard
to the marina mater plan. He stated that his goal at this meeting was to have the amendment for
a lease term extension sent to City Council for approval; Mr. Clarke added that he did no t
understand why they had to struggle to get the lease extension after the City entered into a thirty-
year (30 yr.) lease with the marina manager and the store. He concluded by stressing again the
“absolute necessity” for the restaurant to get the lease term extended.
Councilmember Rice asked if Mr. Clarke was saying that, if the extension were not granted, MCG
would not continue to operate, and he responded that he was uncertain because it would be very
difficult.
Councilmember Rice stated that she could not support a thirty-year (30 yr.) lease; she opined that
it would be too long and “tied things up too long.” The Councilmember stated that there were
things in the lease that she would like to see changed; she noted that the lease did not contain
anything about the dock – Chair Bergwerf interrupted to say that the dock was included in an
amendment. The Councilmember commented that she did not think the restaurant should control
the ingress and egress to the City dock.
Ms. Pope replied that MCG does no t control the dock; the amendment states that MCG must
allow ingress and egress to all of the City docks, and they do it.
Noting the location of the restaurant dumpster, the Councilmember stated that they impair the use
of the area by residents, and the area could have a better use when the master plan is presented,
possibly storage and access for kayakers or paddle boarders.
Ms. Pope remarked that all of the marina tenants have an investment in the master plan, are
excited to make it work and are willing to do the give-and-take to make it work.
Councilmember Harrington indicated that he was impressed with the improvements and the plan
for future improvements, but he had expected to see the list of future improvements to be
prioritized. He stated that he was sensing little support for the thirty -year (30 yr.) lease, and he
understood that the longer term lease was needed to secure financing to make some of the
Real Property Committee
February 8, 2016
Page 3 of 9
improvements. He asked Mr. Clar ke if he was amenable to a compromise that Council could
support.
Mr. Clarke said that he had spoken with his accountant about a lesser term, and they had agreed
that the minimum would be twenty (20) years to continue to improve the property.
Councilmember Harrington asked the City Administrator whether or not the City had options in
the lease to terminate it if an issue arose with the restaurant, and the Administrator explained that
the lease could be terminated by the City if the tenant were in default, but otherwise the lease
could only be terminated by mutual agreement.
The Administrator then sought clarification on a term of twenty (20) years. Would the twenty (20)
years be sixteen (16) in addition to the remaining fou r (4) or twenty (20) years in addition to the
remaining four (4)?
Mr. Clarke responded that it was the latter – sixteen plus four (16 + 4). He then repeated his
question about the difference between his request for thirty (30) years and the marina manager’s
request.
Having taken pictures on a recent visit to the marina, Chair Bergwerf expressed concern about a
“NO PARKING” sign, a large truck and trailer nearly blocking the entrance to the City docks. Mr.
Clarke explained that he had been approached by Mr. Berrigan about installing the sign to prevent
anyone from blocking the entrance to the City docks , and they had jointly agreed and decided
upon the best location.
Mr. Clarke responded to Councilmember Rice that he could relocate the dumpsters now; h e
agreed that they do not belong there at the water. One (1) possible location would be on the pad
behind the restaurant and fenced in, but Carla assured the Councilmember that the dumpster s
would be moved somewhere by the end of March.
Mr. Clarke report ed that he had investigated the possibility of installing an elevator in the
restaurant, and he was told that it was possible and the cost would be in the neighborhood of one
hundred twenty -five thousand dollars ($125,000). He indicated that he would inqu ire about
partnering with the City and/or seeking a grant to help fund it when the time comes.
MOTION: Chair Bergwerf moved to recommend an extension to the term of the
Morgan Creek Grill lease for four (4) options of four (4) years each plus the four (4)
years remaining in the current lease for a total of twenty (20) years; Councilmember
Harrington seconded.
Councilmember Rice stated that she would be comfortable with ten (10) additional years for a
total of fourteen (14), and Mr. Clarke voiced that he t hought twenty (20) ye ars was a good
compromise. Mr. Clarke remarked that a term of fourteen (14) years would make things very
difficult; he much preferred twenty (20) years, like they had in the beginning.
Chair Bergwerf expressed her impression that M r. Clarke would qualify for financial assistance
with a lease of seven to ten (7-10) years.
Real Property Committee
February 8, 2016
Page 4 of 9
Mr. Clarke said that a triple -net lease was typically longer than that; in a shorter term lease, the
tenant was not totally responsible for the structure from roof to foundation. He stated that he
wanted to continue to improve the building, but, with less than twenty (20) years, he questioned
that he could.
Chair Bergwerf and Councilmember Harrington, respectively, withdrew the motion and second.
MOTION: Chair Bergwerf moved to recommend four (4) options of three (3)
years each plus the four (4) years remaining for a total of sixteen (16) years;
Councilmember Harrington seconded.
Responding to the Administrator’s question about whether there was anything the City wanted in
return for the lease extension, Councilmember Harrington said that he wanted to see the list of
future improvements prioritized, at least, by year.
Mr. Clarke indicated that to anticipate the improvements would be difficult and asked if the other
tenant had been asked to do this.
One (1) comment the Administrator has heard is that the docks assigned to MCG are under -
utilized by the restaurant and its tenants and possibly, in retu rn for the longer term lease, MCG
might be willing to give up control of those seven (7) slips; the motoring public that want to come
to the restaurant would then contact the marina manager to make arrangements.
Ms. Pope commented that those docks were not under-utilized in season, and it is cost prohibitive
for people to pay to go to the marina when they want to park the run-about to go to the restaurant
for lunch. Mr. Clarke added that the finger piers are extr emely difficult to navigate with anything
beyond a fourteen or sixteen foot (14-16 ft.) jon-boat. In Mr. Clarke’s opinion, these docks are a
huge asset to MCG and he was not interested in giving them up; they constitute a part of the
public access to the restaurant.
Chair Bergwerf said that she understood the need for the docks, but she thought they should be
marked more clearly.
Councilmember Rice continued that she did not see any reason for MCG to control the inside
docks because she did not think many people used them to go to the restaurant, but Mr. Clarke
disagreed. He reported that a group of about fifteen (15) women have started to come to the
restaurant regularly and they get to the marina on their paddle boards and use the inside docks.
Councilmember Rice thought the restaurant’s dock space could be reduced by forty percent
(40%) to give residents more access to the water. She stated that she sees her role as one to
represent the residents and their access to the water.
Ms. Pope commented that no one from the restaurant patrols the docks to prevent people from
using them; she reported that people come and go from those docks all day.
Real Property Committee
February 8, 2016
Page 5 of 9
Chair Bergwerf remarked that she thought MCG could garner some good will with Council if they
were to come before Council to present a change in the language of the section in the lease on
the docks stating that they welcomed residents with their kayaks and paddle boards.
Councilmember Rice asked that the following language be included in the lease relative to the
dumpsters:
“must contain and consolidate dumpsters and build a tasteful enclosure.”
Mr. Clarke stated that he would put up some type of enclosure for the dumpsters this spring, but
it would be very difficult to do so without a lease extension of sixteen (16) years (20 year total).
Administrator Tucker explained that, if this language were to be sent to Council, the lease would
have to be re-drafted by the City Attorney, the appropriate legal wording added, and that amend-
ment would have to go through two (2) readings of Council. The final product would not be ratified
for at least two to three (2-3) months.
Councilmember Rice wanted the language to be formally added to the lease.
Amendment: Councilmember Rice moved to amend the motion to include “ ”Must
contain and consolidate the dumpsters and build a tasteful enclosure for them” in
the lease for Morgan Creek Grill; Councilmember Harrington seconded and the
amendment PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Amendment: Councilmember Rice moved to amend the motion to state the Morgan
Creek Grill will no longer control the marsh-side dock.
The motion died for lack of a second.
With permission from the Chair, Mrs. Campsen asked if possibly language could be added to the
lease amendment some type of reciprocal agreement between parties that , once the ATM plan
was presented, issues of adequate parking and resident access, etc. would then be negotiated
between the City and its marina tenants.
The Administrator clarified that language could be added to the draft lease that talks about not
doing anything to inhibit public access for passive recreational activities and to agree to behave
cooperatively to make concessions for a future master plan at the marina.
In Mr. Clarke’s opinion, if such an agreement were to be drafted, it should go to all marina tenants
in the form of modified leases.
VOTE on the AMENDED MOTION: The amended motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
MOTION: Councilmember Rice moved to re-order the Agenda to take up Item A
under New Business; Councilmember Harrington seconded and the motion
PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
6. New Business
Real Property Committee
February 8, 2016
Page 6 of 9
A. Consideration of Leasing a 20’x30’ area of City property behind the Dinghy
Malcolm Burgis and Brett Jones w ere present to represent The Dinghy. Administrator Tucker
stated that this piece of land is an underutilized space in the small City parking lot behind The
Dinghy that they would like to use for storage. She stated that the management of The Dinghy
should contact Director Kerr to ensure that the area could be used as described.
Mr. Burgis reported that he spoke with the Director earlier in the day and had been told that the
use as storage would not conflict wit h the property’s zoning regulations ; Director Kerr did note
that the storage building must be on a slab and anchored down.
Chair Bergwerf asked how the rent for the space would be determined, and the Administrat or
indicated that she has not considered the rent since she did not know whether the Committee
would agree to a lease.
Director Pitts suggested that, before any agreement was reached, the City should analyze the
cost to remove the dumpsters for both The Windjammer and The Dinghy , assuming that it was
cost effective for them to use the City compactor. If the results are that using the compactor was
cheaper or the same as the dumpsters, the dumpsters could be removed. The Director noted
that the removal of the dumpsters would provide more space and that possibly the City should
subsidize surrounding businesses to encourage them to use the compactor by subsidizing the
cost to them if it exceeds what they are paying for dumpsters.
Mr. Burgis stated that his cost for the dumpsters was approximately six thousand dollars ($6,000)
per year.
The Director noted that some Front Beach businesses must use the compactor because they
have no space on which to put a dumpster; from the viewpoint of Public Works, th e fewer
dumpsters the better.
Mr. Burgis indicated that more time would be spent dumping at the end of the day if they used the
compactor, and Brett Jones stated that getting the trashcans to the compactor from his business
was not surfaced, but was dirt.
Administrator Tucker asked if the businesses were to commit to use of the compactor, the City
could make it more convenient for them; she indicated that a lease was possible, but this analysis
should be completed before an agreement for the property wa s reached. In addition, the
Administrator said that she would investigate a fair lease cost.
5. Old Business
B. Update on parking lot lease and future management
Mr. Burgis stated that he had reviewed the lease th at has a minimum lease rate of one hundred
fifty-thousand dollars ($150,000) and thirty percent (30%) of everything over one hundred fifty
thousand dollar ($150,000).
Real Property Committee
February 8, 2016
Page 7 of 9
The Administrator reported that the RFP was posted to the City’s website and that she had sent
all Councilmembers the information on what was different in the RFP, i.e. the increase in the base
rent, the increase in the daily rates and the offer to operate in the off -season. Since the bidder
would decide what the off-season use would be, they were to submit to the City a bid for what
percentage of gross revenue they would pay to the City. The bid opening is scheduled for 2:00
p.m., Friday, February 12th.
Since Council must enter into leases via ordinance with two (2) readings, the winning bidder will
actually have less than a full year for the first year of the lease; therefore, the first year’s lease
would be reduced.
C. Discussion of off-season use of the County Park
According to the Administrator, this subject was deliberated upon at the January meeting, and the
consensus of the Committee was that staff has enough on its plate currently and should not take
on more. The topic was left on the Agenda because there was dialogue in another committee
about expanding offerings and for the Recreation Department to do some cooperative activities
with Charleston County PRC and other remote locations on the island.
D. Update on golf cart path between 18th and 20th Avenues
Administrator Tucker reported that the City was waiting for the design to submit to SCDOT for the
encroachment permit. Assuming the receipt of the encroachment permit, the City would then go
out for bid.
E. Discussion of Beach Preservation
The Administrator reported that Coastal Science and Engineering (CSE) was to make a presen-
tation to the Wild Dunes Community Association (WDCA) on March 12th to update them on where
the City was with beach restoration. She reminded the Committee that the City had decided to
focus its efforts on an off -shore dredging project rather than another shoal management project
because the City would be limited with where it could place sand. In the areas with sandbags or
wave dissipation devices, their removal would be required before they could receive sand, and, if
the project did not last very long, they would be back in the same situation of replacing the
sandbags and wave dissipation devices.
The City has filed a claim with FEMA for the damages were caused by Joaquin, but it is only a
small part of the problem; Joaquin exacerbated an existing problem.
The off-shore dredging project is expected to cost in the neighborhood of fifteen million dollars
($15,000,000), and the City will need funding from every possible source. She informed the
Committee that Governor Haley has put forty million dollars ($40,000,000) in her proposed budget
for beach restoration. At the moment, the City’s engineers are working on the design for this next
project.
The Administrator cautioned the Committee that some people will object to the use of federal
money because Joaquin did not cause the erosion problem; it only made it worse. Other
Real Property Committee
February 8, 2016
Page 8 of 9
objections may revolv e around public access, only a small portion of that area qualifies under
OCRM’s guideline definition for public access.
F. Review of FY17 Revenue Budget
Since all Committee members have reviewed the revenue budget at another Committee and no
one had any questions, the Chair moved forward on the Agenda.
G. Discussion of Encroachment on 23rd Avenue Beach Access
Administrator Tucker explained that the people who live next to the 23 rd Avenue beach access
have the right of ingress and egress for their driveway on the beach access, but the City has had
the beach access surveyed and the residents are encroaching on to the access with a French
drain, landscaping, part of the driveway and vehicles. The question is what does the City want
the next step to be? The concern is how much encroachment the City will allow before it is too
much. The options before the Committee were as follows:
Grant the home owner an easement to keep what is in place now, but with no additions;
or
Grant the homeowner some of the actual footage of the beach access, with nothing further
to be added, or
Continue as is
Speaking philosophically, the Administrator commented that she was always reluctant to give
away anything that is public, but she added that it has been done before on 21 st Avenue when
the City gave the adjacent property owner some footage of the access.
Councilmember Rice asked if the house has a new owner; to which the Administrator answered
that this owner has been there several years.
Councilmember Rice recalled a request years back when a resident asked for space at 11 th
Avenue, and the City denied it. The Administrator noted that this resident has not asked for
anything.
Chair Bergwerf opined that the homeowner has abused a privilege given to him.
Administrator Tucker answered that the resident had gone to Director Kerr when the survey was
made, and he informed them that the City had received complaints that they were blocking the
beach access and encroaching on the right-of-way, but the City has not enforced on them in any
way.
Although the house is elevated, the height is not enough to allow them to park a large SUV under
it. In a large fenced-in area behind their home, they park their boat and trailer, but always pull the
vehicle pulling the boat out of the enclosure.
Chair Bergwerf stated that problems would come up when the new parking plan was
implemented; someone will see two (2) cars parked there and feel they will join them.
Real Property Committee
February 8, 2016
Page 9 of 9
Councilmember Rice suggested that they park their cars with their boat.
Relative to a City staffer speaking with the property owner, the Administrator opined that the City
should present the owner with a solution.
Chair Bergwerf suggested that their vehicles must be parallel parked and the number of vehicles
could be limited.
Administrator Tucker suggested that a written agreement be drawn up to be sign by the City and
the owner that w ould limit the number of vehicles and indicate that there would be no further
encroachments into the beach access. She thought this would be a reasonable compromise and
not create a hardship on the owner.
The Administrator indicated that she would get additional legal advice.
6. New Business
B. Recommendation of Award of Contract to IPW Construction in the amount
of $23,085 for City Hall Repairs
Administrator Tucker referred to Director Kerr’s recommendation for IPW Construction, the low
bidder, to do the repair work.
MOTION: Councilmember Harrington moved to recommend the award of a
contract to IPW Construction in the amount of $23,085 for City Hall repairs;
Councilmember Rice seconded.
Councilmember Bergwerf advised the Administrator to have a list of the specific repairs that will
be included.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
7. Miscellaneous Business
All tenants were current with their rent payments.
Next Meeting Date: 2:00 p.m., Thursday, March 3, 2016 in the Conference Room
8. Adjournment
MOTION: Councilmember Rice moved to adjourn the meeting at 5:23 p.m.;
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.